According to the court case, which Casey lost, the two Salvadorans were walking across a property on foot, at which point one of the members of the vigilante posse started chasing them, firing numerous gunshots and threatening to kill them. The vigilantes held them at gunpoint, making them kneel on the ground and subjecting them to a lengthy interrogation. They were held for approximately 90 minutes before they let them go, but not before threatening to kill them again.