All Episodes
March 16, 2024 - Timcast IRL - Tim Pool
02:10:39
Fani Willis Wins, Trump Judge Refuses To Remove Leftist DA w/Liam Cosgrove | Timcast IRL
Participants
Main voices
h
hannah claire brimelow
05:16
l
liam cosgrove
32:56
l
libby emmons
09:20
r
rob noerr
18:26
t
tim pool
01:02:04
| Copy link to current segment

Speaker Time Text
tim pool
Ah yes, Nathan Wade in the Georgia case will be stepping down.
Fonny Willis effectively wins.
All that's really happening now with this removal is that the judge said, well, there's an odor of mendacity, but you know, we're just gonna just say stop working together.
So Fannie Willis gets to keep doing whatever she wants.
She's been accused of perjury.
She's facing a potential perjury inquiry.
Nathan Wade, all the same.
There were three individuals, I believe, who have been accused of perjury in that hearing.
And the judge just goes, oh, whatever, I guess.
Now, the funny thing is, this woman is charging many of Trump's lawyers and Trump personalities with lying to law enforcement or obstruction and things of that nature.
Yet she is now being accused of the same thing, and the judge He's a coward.
I can't say I'm surprised we talked a little bit about this morning on the Culture War podcast, but we'll talk about that.
Ooh, I got a good one.
There have been a ton of stories, I don't know if you've seen, of Boeing jets, wheel falling off.
We got a news story right now, side panel falls off.
We've got one leaking fuel or something, emergency landing, turnaround.
I don't know what's going on.
But there's this Boeing whistleblower, who they say in the media died of apparent suicide.
The reporting now, and this is from Jalopnik, this is not a conservative source, is that he told his friend, I am not suicidal and don't believe it if they say I killed myself.
Seems like we have a conspiracy.
But we'll get into that.
We got a bunch of other stories to get into as well.
Before we get started, my friends, head over to castbrew.com and pick up your coffee.
Appalachian Nights is the undisputed champion of the coffee sales because we're already sold out of the coffee pods.
We just reloaded them.
I'm desperately trying to tell you guys, you gotta buy Stand Your Grounds.
It is really good.
Give it a try.
Stand Your Ground is a medium roast.
It tastes very much like Appalachian Nights, but I am honored that we have our one-hit wonder in Appalachian Nights, the coffee being so good.
And Rise of the Birdo Jr.
is also great.
It's light.
It's a breakfast one.
You can also pick up your Alex Stein's Prime Time Grind, two times caffeine.
Shout out to Alex Stein.
But when you support Casper, you're supporting us because we sponsor ourselves.
And you're helping us set up our first live location.
Our coffee shop should be open in a few months.
We already had our first event there on the third floor.
Second floor club is currently being set up and we're hoping to have another event next month.
But also don't forget to become a member at TimCast.com to support our work directly and click join us.
Become a member and you'll get access to our members-only discord server where you can hang out with like-minded individuals and they got pre-shows, they got after shows, tons of content, people working on projects.
The most important thing for a TimCast membership and everything we're doing is building culture
and bringing everyone together.
That means you guys sign up to become members at TimCast.com, support the show, support
all of our endeavors, and then connect to the Discord server so you can be in constant
communication with other people who think and feel similarly or perhaps would want to
debate you, and this is going to help create connections which can help build a parallel
economy.
Maybe you have the next great idea and you don't know how to get it going again.
So what you do is you become a member.
You join the Discord server.
You start talking to people.
Someone pops up and says, you know, I'm a carpenter.
I can actually build that thing right now.
unidentified
Bang!
tim pool
You've invented something new.
We need to build those connections and get that parallel economy going.
And once we get that live space up, the Social Club in Martinsburg, You can actually physically come hang out with people and have those conversations, and it is the communication between people that builds the culture, that invents new products, and that will help us win that culture war.
So, all in all, it also helps support the show and the work we do.
So don't forget to also smash that like button, subscribe to this channel, share this show with your friends.
Joining us tonight to talk about this and everything else, we got a couple people.
We got Liam Cosgrove.
liam cosgrove
Hello, everyone.
Thank you for having me again, Tim.
Good to be here.
And I'm a reporter with The Gray Zone, Max Blumenthal's outlet.
And, yeah, it's good to be here.
tim pool
Right on.
And Rob's back.
He was here this morning.
rob noerr
Thank you so much for having me again.
I'm Rob Knorr.
I am probably the premier right-wing debater on this crazy Twitch YouTube debate sphere.
So, honored to be back again.
Looking forward to it.
tim pool
Right on.
Hannah Clare's hanging out.
hannah claire brimelow
Hey, I'm Hannah-Claire Brameau.
I'm back again.
I'm with SCNR News, or scnr.com, that's Scanner News.
I hope you guys are having a great Friday.
Libby's here.
libby emmons
I'm here.
I'm Libby Emmons.
I'm with the Post Millennial.
Glad to be hanging out, y'all.
unidentified
Uh, and I am not Surge.gov.
Uh, it's Kellen.
I'm filling in for Nate.
tim pool
Is that what I changed it to?
unidentified
No, no, but I like, uh, playing fun with him with that one.
But yeah, let's get, let's get into it.
tim pool
Here we go, ladies and gentlemen.
This is the big news breaking from this morning.
Now, I, we do know, I think, I think we should, we jump to this right here.
Nathan Wade is the, uh, he's, he's stepping down.
He's a special prosecutor who was appointed by Fannie Willis.
And after the judge ruled, basically nothing's going to happen.
She's allowed to keep her work going.
She won't be taken off of this case.
I can't say I'm surprised.
When the judge dismissed six charges against the Trump defendants, three against Trump personally, many people were saying that this is evidence that the judge will not rule against Fannie Willis.
What we're hearing now in the press is that the judge wants to split the baby.
That's what everyone's saying, split the baby.
Uh, as anyone knows, when you split the baby, the baby dies.
libby emmons
That's a problem.
tim pool
And so, if the issue here is that Judge Scott McAfee was trying to prevent, I don't know, um, uh, what's the right word?
Acrimonious conflict or whatever.
How are we doing?
Conflict in general.
He's certainly done the opposite.
And he has, as the coward he is, the spineless, pathetic man that he is, flicked a match into the tinderbox.
Because the appropriate move for this spineless piece of trash would have been to say, If you don't want there to be conflict, you must stop the conflict.
So, which he should have said, what we're going to do is, to avoid the image of partiality and bias, we will politely ask Ms.
Willis to please step aside and we will have someone else come and take up this case.
This is not indicative of wrongdoing on Ms.
Willis, it's indicative of the integrity of the court and our attempt to appear impartial as we bring justice about.
Instead, he's terrified what the left would do if he even tried to be impartial, so he said, burn the whole thing to the ground.
There we are.
hannah claire brimelow
Yeah, it's a rough time for him because he's also in the middle of a real action campaign, so I don't know if that will hurt.
I don't think it will help him in his district, but he said before this wasn't political.
He's staying biased.
You know, a lot of eyes were on him in this decision, and I thought the language of like, well, either Willis and her entire office can go, or Wade can step down.
So you guys make a decision.
Whatever you think was sort of... He was really trying to walk a weird line.
rob noerr
It's another irony in every single legal case, the law fair against Trump, every single time they do exactly what they're accusing Trump of.
So they're charging him with Rico and racketeering and perjury.
I mean, the worst thing she's accused of doing is intimidating witnesses, which is incredibly serious.
And yet she's allowed to stay on this case.
The reason is quite simple.
Just like with Jack Smith, they need to get this case in before the election.
This is all about election interference.
So they're worried, well, if we remove her from the case and bring someone else on, perhaps this won't come about before the election.
Make no mistake, this has nothing to do with justice.
It is completely about interfering in the election and trying to save the American people because they know they're going to get a guilty verdict because the left is nuts and they don't care.
They'll indict Trump for anything.
It doesn't matter if he did it or not.
It's all about impugning him and interfering in the election, which, by the way, is the very thing they say that Trump tried to do, which makes him authoritarian.
tim pool
I suppose the issue, the question is, does this hurt Trump or help him more that he's being targeted, indicted?
Because the one thing it is doing is making sure that Trump can't campaign.
While Trump is locked up in court, going to Florida trying to get dismissals and things like this, you've got Joe Biden, Kamala Harris, and they're going out and they're campaigning.
What, Kamala Harris, you went to like a Planned Parenthood or something?
hannah claire brimelow
Yeah, yeah, yeah, in Minnesota.
tim pool
So they're cheating.
This is cheating.
Democrats are cheating.
And the question is, does it actually hurt Trump, though?
Because many people have made the argument that his polls go up when we see things like this.
libby emmons
Well, his polls do go up when we see this kind of thing.
And I think that a lot of people also see that the way that Trump is being targeted is, in many ways, the way that Americans are being targeted.
We have the DOJ going after We have moms and parents at school board meetings, including a father whose daughter was, you know, allegedly raped in the school bathroom, and the DOJ went after him.
We have the DOJ going after Catholics who prefer Latin mass, all based on just one guy's information, and they extrapolated that.
You have the Biden administration still saying that white supremacy and domestic extremism are the biggest threats facing the United States while the border is collapsing.
You have Haitian immigrants are about to, like, flood the country.
The Biden administration has a program in place where 30,000 refugees can come into the U.S.
from very specific countries, including Venezuela and Haiti, two countries that have definitely been in the news lately.
We've seen a lot of crimes lately in the U.S.
committed by Venezuelan asylum seekers, you know, and we're about to have that kind of stuff going on probably from...
That's what they say, that's how they make it legal, asylum seekers.
And this guy, Jose Ibarra, who is accused of killing Lake and Riley in Georgia, he was an asylum seeker and a story out from the New York Post quoted his wife saying that the reason they got married She had a five-year-old from a previous relationship, and she said the reason they got married was so that they could join up their asylum cases and have a better shot at gaining asylum, and now it turns out that, you know, he's a murderer.
hannah claire brimelow
That's the beginning of a rom-com!
That's such a great reason to get married!
libby emmons
It's a meet-cute!
But the other thing, too, that we see in Michigan and, what is it, Wisconsin, we're also seeing The state's there, the Attorney General's there, going after electors who were on the alternate slate of electors.
So Americans who are locked up in the legal system for these kind of crazy charges, the J6ers, all of that, they can see what's going on.
I think what would be great for Trump is if he got a VP pick, and the VP pick could go out there, someone who's really good at campaigning, that's what we want to see, someone who can draw crowds.
hannah claire brimelow
Well, and this is one of the things Nikki Haley used against Trump.
She gave a speech saying, you know, Trump spends more time in the courtroom than on the campaign trail, right?
Everyone who's against Trump points to his legal issues and says, look, he's not committed to you as voters, when really I think his true supporters are like, you guys are doing everything you can to bind his wrists to the wall and keep him from running.
libby emmons
Right, and she was even one of the people saying we have to tie this up before the election.
We have Trump's attorneys out there every day, like, pushing it back and pushing it back.
And correct me if I'm wrong, you guys, but Alvin Bragg in New York, he said he elevated the, what, 34 counts of falsifying business records?
These are misdemeanors.
He elevated them to a felony, and he still hasn't given any explanation for how they're a felony.
They can only be a felony if they were in commission to a greater crime, and he still hasn't said what that crime is.
tim pool
Well, because they're liars and they're corrupt and they'll just do whatever they want.
libby emmons
That's exactly right.
rob noerr
And remember, that charge that Bragg's charging with has to do with campaign finance non-disclosures, a crime that we know Hillary Clinton committed.
libby emmons
Well, Hillary Clinton paid $8,000 in a fine for that. $8,000!
rob noerr
That's constantly the theme.
libby emmons
And the DNC had to pay a much larger sum of money.
But Hillary Clinton did the same thing.
She got fined $8,000.
And Trump is, you know, what, do you think they're going to fine him $8,000 for the same crime?
rob noerr
Go back to the FAR violation.
libby emmons
$8,000 million!
And her crime, she said that money paid to her attorneys was for legal fees.
And it was actually money paid to her attorneys to create the Steele dossier.
rob noerr
Right.
And you go back to like every single one of these charges, the FAR violations against Trump's campaign manager.
We talked about this this morning a little, right?
That same crime was committed with the Podesta group, which was the campaign manager of Hillary Clinton.
And yet they're allowed to receive retroactively filing paperwork.
You have Hunter Biden who committed FAR.
Every single one of these crimes, the problem isn't that they're charging the crimes.
The problem is the two-tier justice and selective prosecution.
The entire Russia collusion story was as follows.
We had to break some eggs.
We had to break the law because the allegations so serious that Trump may have colluded with Russians.
And how did they seek to prove it?
By Hillary Clinton colluding with a Russian spy and the FBI allowing it to get dirt to illegally spy on Trump.
Every single time what they accused Trump of is exactly what they're doing.
hannah claire brimelow
Well, somebody has to pay for their crimes and it's not going to be them.
rob noerr
It's absolutely true.
And, like, you have to look at, like, with Fannie Willis here.
Again, they say that they're against even the appearance of impropriety.
Go back and look when you had James Comey was fired, and so they have the Mueller report.
Mueller was the, basically, advisor of James Comey, his mentor.
That committee had 17 Democrats on it, including two lawyers that worked for the Hillary campaign.
And I said at the time, I was like, if there's ever a right winger that does a special counsel, they'll lose their mind.
We have the Her Report.
And just because this guy, what, saluted an American flag or something at some point in his life, they're like, he must be Republican.
They're so jaded and they're so entitled that the left wing and the Democrat perception of things is we not only expect special prosecutors and the FBI to let us off the hook, they're not even allowed to say a bad word about us while we do it.
That's the double system that we have, where they literally are let off the hook for obvious crimes.
But if someone like Comey says, but it was bad or her says, yeah, the president's losing his marbles.
They say that's not good enough that he let him off the hook. It's it's the double. This
country cannot survive this sort of double standard. This is the real election interference.
And unless we stand up and do something about it, we're going to be in a really bad place.
unidentified
I mean, I think they hide Scott Pressler. That's.
tim pool
Did they hire Scott Pressler or they're just like working with Scott Pressler?
libby emmons
They announced that he's gonna come.
That's huge.
tim pool
That guy is one of the most effective organizers.
rob noerr
Absolutely.
tim pool
I think that's a good step.
hannah claire brimelow
I think it's a really good step.
I think it's inspirational.
I mean, Scott's young, and he's really boots on the ground.
He's involved, and he's extremely passionate.
This is the kind of thing that I think young conservatives are really looking for in the party.
They want someone who wants to take action, do something, and is sort of relentless.
I mean, that's the thing you can say about him.
He just will not stop, and they need that kind of energy right now.
rob noerr
I think there's a lot of hope that you see people like that, shows like this.
The truth is, you're not going to get from the legacy media or the establishment Republicans like Mitch McConnell.
They don't care.
They don't care that this is happening to Trump because they look at Trump as their enemy.
The people in charge of a losing party then lose their position in a winning party.
They don't want that.
And so it's up to average people, regular people that are empowered by social media and other places, to show the American people how bad this double standard is and how corrupt it is and how it is actual election interference.
And I see hope when you see people like Scott Pressler being put forward, when you see that the mainstream media is losing their legitimacy, when you see that Trump's poll numbers are going up, In large part because people are like, even if I don't care for the man individually, we can't stand for this two tier system.
And I will see what happens.
The corruption is going to be insane.
tim pool
I think we've got cultural problems in this country between these cultish individuals who don't care what's right or wrong.
They just hate Trump.
And so They're gonna march in lockstep no matter what happens.
There's not gonna be a point where someone says, you know what, this two-tiered system is bad, we shouldn't allow it.
No, no, now if Trump ends up winning, and then Trump says, I think we should enforce the law, they're gonna claim it's a two-tiered system and he's targeting us, help, help.
rob noerr
I mean, we talked about it a little this morning.
Just take this one little example.
Ari Melber of, I think, MSNBC, right?
He comes out when Elon was talking about buying X. And he says, can you imagine if Elon Musk bought this?
What if he censored a Democratic candidate?
What if they shadow banned Democratic arguments?
They literally, they're so entitled.
They weren't worried that Elon was going to come along and do to them what they did to us.
They were worried that he would just stop them doing it.
And so they put these hypotheticals out there like, wouldn't it be terrible if Trump did to us what we're doing to him and his supporters?
And I'm sorry, I can't stomach the double standard and hypocrisy from these people anymore.
If any one of us here at this table, if we were on a jury, it wouldn't matter if we liked or dis- Grab the mic.
tim pool
Pull the mic up.
rob noerr
Sorry, sorry.
It wouldn't matter if we liked or disliked the person.
We would try our best to be fair.
These left-wing people believe they are morally superior to us to the point where they don't care.
Show me the person and I'll show you the crime.
And so they, every one of us know in every left-wing area, they will convict Trump of anything.
Facts be damned.
They don't care.
And how can you live in a society where we say, hey, we want to be fair to you.
We might think you're stupid.
We might disagree, but we wouldn't want to lock you up.
28% of people in a YouGov poll in, I think, 2022, 28% of Democrats polled said they wanted to take your children away if you refuse the vaccine.
How do you live side by side with people that want to do the most heinous thing imaginable?
tim pool
Well, Republicans have no counter.
At all.
We talked about this this morning as well, but it's here.
There's no U.S.
attorneys.
There's no district attorneys.
There's no Republicans in any state.
There's no governors.
There's no AGs.
Let me pause.
Obviously, Ken Paxton has some stuff going on.
So, you know, how about that?
But even Ron DeSantis is not really doing that much.
And really what it comes down to is these district attorneys.
Fannie Willis is a Fulton County.
She's a She's a county DA.
She's a prosecutor.
She's a district attorney.
She is not a governor.
She is not a senator.
She is not a high-powered federal official.
She is not even a sheriff.
libby emmons
Like Greg.
tim pool
and leticia james now she's state but then you've got brag where is a single bumpkinville prosecutor to be like well gee i guess i'll charge joe biden with racketeering i don't understand and then he files the charges and they go sir you you represent a county of like three three thousand people well that's the law That's not even happening?
libby emmons
I don't understand that either.
tim pool
File a paper, send it in.
Nope, they won't do it.
libby emmons
Yeah, that's something Charlie Kirk was talking about a while back.
He was like, let's sue Biden.
rob noerr
Sue?
libby emmons
Criminally charge him?
Yeah, I mean, Ken Paxson, you're right, is suing the Biden administration for a lot of stuff, but it's very Texas and border localized, which is super important.
tim pool
How about this?
Joe Biden, where was he when he had the conversation with his ghostwriter?
Do we know?
Was it in Delaware?
rob noerr
I think it was in Delaware.
tim pool
So Delaware, he's protected because ain't no Delaware person gonna go after him.
But hold on, hold on.
Joe Biden lied.
He said at a meeting that he did not tell his ghostwriter that, you know, he did not tell him any classified information.
Okay.
How about we start here?
I'm sure there's a lot of better things you can do, but Joe Biden, the Democrat, they fundraise.
Joe Biden's campaign fundraises.
So if he lies and is fundraising, fraud.
Fraud charge.
Fraudulent.
He is lying to people in exchange for money.
That's fraud in your district.
They're going after Trump on the same documents charges that Hillary, Biden, and Obama, Clinton, everyone should have faced.
None of them should have been charged for this.
And Medicaid says, look, nobody should be charged for these things.
But they're going after him because they're trying to find anything they can.
Why are there no Republicans simply saying, if you accepted any amount of money in my state, and you lied, and he did, and come on, Then, I'm sorry, you're facing criminal charges for fraud.
We're going to investigate you.
How about the solicitation of donations from Kamala Harris for the terrorists during the George Floyd riots?
libby emmons
Yeah, the Minnesota Bail Fund.
tim pool
I mean, there you go.
That's material support for terrorism.
rob noerr
That is a clear example of, quote, engaging in an insurrection, which is what the Section 3 of the 14th Amendment says that they tried to keep.
tim pool
Now here's the best part.
We know for a fact that in all across this country, every single state had some kind of right or another.
So if you're in a conservative state or Republican state, you need to contact the local... Let me put it this way.
If you know that far leftists, BLM, which is an organization, They rioted in your town, or somewhere in your state, you should be calling your D.N.
asking why they are not going after Kamala Harris for providing material support to terrorists.
Kamala Harris directly posted, bail fund, let's raise money for these people.
So she's raising money for a group that engaged in acts of domestic terrorism, and now you may be saying, come on, it's BLM riots, you're calling it domestic terrorism?
That's the point.
Trump didn't engage in insurrection.
How many states went after him for this?
The point is, we talked about it this morning, the Republicans aren't fighting fire with water.
They're not fighting fire with fire.
I'm like, I will take wheat flour.
Unbleached wheat flour!
Throw anything on the flames to make it stop!
They won't do it.
libby emmons
Well, that's one of the great things.
I think it was a really good move putting Laura Trump in the RNC chair.
She came in, right?
She fired a bunch of people, just like her father-in-law would have, which I think is, you know, really, I think that is a little bit fire bringing in Scott Pressler, who has a proven track record of voter registration and getting votes out for the GOP.
So, I think that we might really start to see a different tack from the RNC, and it's really quite about time.
This is an RNC now with Laura Trump in charge that is interested in winning, and I think is going to make that happen.
tim pool
Let's jump to something that affects everyday Americans.
Politics can be a bit esoteric, but we have this story.
Boeing United Airlines flight lands in Oregon after losing a panel midair.
The latest in a lengthy list.
of safety incidents for the embattled plane company.
Here we go, here's another one from Business Insider.
The sudden drop of a Boeing 787 that injured 50 people may have been caused by a flight attendant accidentally hitting a switch in the cockpit, report says.
I just want to ask, how does a flight attendant accidentally hit a switch in the cockpit?
libby emmons
Isn't she not supposed to be in the cockpit?
What is she doing in there?
Right?
Aren't they supposed to lock those doors?
tim pool
I don't want to imply impropriety here.
hannah claire brimelow
Should we just bring them coffee?
libby emmons
I think we should.
hannah claire brimelow
Let's all assume the best thing.
libby emmons
She implied impropriety.
tim pool
You know, she was, she was, she dropped something, was reaching down to pick it up,
and then she went up and she realized she didn't, she missed, and she had to go back down again.
unidentified
Oh.
tim pool
And then on the way up, she hit her head on the...
That's right, and then she hit her head on the controls.
I'm kidding, by the way.
hannah claire brimelow
She's just hanging out.
What are you guys doing?
tim pool
She may have just been bringing in coffee.
liam cosgrove
That's actually very plausible, to be honest.
I mean, I don't see how you accidentally hit a switch.
I mean, there's switches all over on those cockpits that you wonder how they even, like, keep flying.
hannah claire brimelow
Or what if it's, like, the Alaska Airlines guy who was, like... I guess you could fall.
liam cosgrove
Turbulence, you could fall.
Your butt hits a bunch of switches.
hannah claire brimelow
There could be an accident.
But what if it's, like, the Alaska Airlines guy who was, like, riding whatever, the jump seat, and then he all of a sudden was like, I can't do this, ripped his headphones off, and, like, pulled... Do you remember this story from a little while ago?
Yeah, the Alaska Airlines guy... They got out of drugs?
Uh, he said he hadn't taken drugs in several hours.
He was just having a hard time and hadn't been sleeping.
He was the one charged with, um, attempted murder.
unidentified
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
hannah claire brimelow
I thought he was on shrinkage.
He was, uh, three days before.
I don't know how long it lasts.
But, I mean, you know what I think is going to be really trendy this year?
The road trip.
I feel like that's really making a comeback.
Uh, break out all of your memetic architecture and your fun billboards.
We're not getting on planes this year.
libby emmons
I have been, like, I have to travel a lot and I keep being like, how, how far a drive is that?
I do love my car.
hannah claire brimelow
I did that recently, because it's like when you have to go to the airport, and then you're at the airport, and then you have to go away from the airport.
libby emmons
Yeah, you've got to factor in that time.
You've got to factor in the sitting around time.
hannah claire brimelow
Right, right.
Depending on the flight length, you could do a six-hour road trip in the same amount of time it would take you to fly somewhere.
libby emmons
I just drove nine hours the other day.
I was like, it's totally fine.
liam cosgrove
So my questions on this are, one, does anyone here know, because anecdotally this does seem like it's happening a lot more, but does anyone know statistically how much more frequently this is happening, and two, I don't think there's yet to be a death, right?
Like, there was that one where the exit door flew off, but no one flew out with the door.
libby emmons
Yeah, but that was only because the guy was wearing his seatbelt.
unidentified
Yeah.
hannah claire brimelow
And the two people who were supposed to sit there didn't get on the plane.
liam cosgrove
No, it's crazy.
I mean, yeah, I normally don't wear my seatbelt, and when I sit in an exit row now, I do wear it.
libby emmons
Oh, I wear my seatbelt all the time.
tim pool
50 people got hurt when this plane dropped suddenly and they all slammed into the ceiling.
libby emmons
That's messed up.
unidentified
Right.
liam cosgrove
And then, I mean, it comes, like, what do we think of the causes?
I mean, I'm a libertarian, so I think the causes are probably, like, The FAA is outliving its usefulness, and probably things are becoming too calcified.
tim pool
DEI.
liam cosgrove
There's also DEI.
hannah claire brimelow
You know who we should ask?
The Secretary of Transportation, Pete Buttigieg, who definitely knows what's going on.
rob noerr
Can you imagine you're on this flight, right, and Buttigieg is on there, and you're like, oh my goodness, the stewardess hit that switch and we're all falling, and he'd be like, um, flight attendant, please.
We don't use the term stewardess anymore.
I mean, at what point As in general, we don't know specifically what caused each of these, but when we live in a society that no longer rewards competence, and instead we reward sort of victimhood culture, these things are inevitable over time.
You're going to see bridges collapse.
You're going to see public transportation wrecks.
You're going to see airplanes falling apart.
We are being told that those are sacrifices.
You, the average American, we have to sacrifice your safety.
Why?
Because it's important that we virtue signal.
I find it to be one of the most racist, bigoted things imaginable.
I think that we should reward any— I don't think people are inferior based on their sex or their race.
I think we should reward people that are the best for the job, the most competent.
But no, we're instead told that we have to have this racist mentality, that, oh, we have to promote certain categories of people.
And again, I can't point to this incident or others at Boeing, but you see what Boeing's leadership's doing.
You see how invested they are in DEI.
Why don't you take a couple days and make sure your planes are safe before lecturing us about what pronouns we need to use?
liam cosgrove
So I agree that DEI is probably playing a role in this, but also, like, let's think back to when we, in the 90s, when we were all kids and we flew on planes and how the experience was almost identical, except you didn't have a TV in the back of the headset.
To me, I look at it- You don't anymore.
Well, yeah, sometimes you don't even have it.
tim pool
No, no, no, they're all gone.
liam cosgrove
Those don't exist anymore?
tim pool
Yeah, now you have hooks for your phones.
liam cosgrove
Okay.
unidentified
Yeah.
I think they've got both, but the point is like... Depends on your plane.
liam cosgrove
Right, but the point is like this industry has not innovated in like 30 years.
So is it surprising that it's like slowly falling apart?
I mean we're still like...
There's not a free market in airlines, so it's no surprise that the quality is going down.
And part of the quality going down is, sadly, like, the literal integrity and safety of, you know, the planes and the people who run them.
tim pool
Well, yeah, hyper-consolidation.
So, really, it's capitalism's fault.
All the airlines started getting bought out by each other, and now there's, like, three.
liam cosgrove
Right, but the airlines are getting multi-billion dollar bailouts for, you know, when they're not even producing a product, and the barrier to entry is near impossible.
libby emmons
Well, we're in Atlanta.
I actually... We did end up with a new airline a couple years ago, yeah.
liam cosgrove
Thanks to Richard Branson, and then someone else bought them years ago.
libby emmons
That was like, what, 15, 20 years ago, something like that.
tim pool
Yeah, I'm not serious that I think capitalism is the problem, but I do think monopolization and centralization is the problem.
When all these airlines buy each other out, there's no competition.
So now it's like, in the United States, you have two choices.
You have United and American.
Sure, there's budget airlines and, you know.
liam cosgrove
But wouldn't you argue that monopolization is a result of FAA making a huge barrier to entry?
Also, I mean, it's hard to get permitting if you wanted to make a new airport to get a new route going, you know.
tim pool
It's both.
liam cosgrove
And then flooding the industry with cash so they can buy each other out.
tim pool
Nothing made these companies buy each other.
And actually, they deregulated in the mid to late 2000s, I think.
Or when was the deregulation?
Wages used to be way higher for airline workers, and then the government, because it was regulated, the airlines had to pay a certain amount.
And then, I don't know exactly what happened, but I used to work at O'Hare as an acting crew chief.
So a little bit above a ramp agent, but still basically, you know, periodically in charge of the people who are loading planes, sometimes loading planes myself.
Crew chiefs are the ones who are in charge of the room and they tell people to load planes.
If you're acting, it's like halfway there.
You step in when someone's sick.
But they were saying that before the deregulation, which I don't know exactly when that happened, people were getting like the equivalent of, you know, $50,000, $60,000 a year.
And then once the government said, okay, you're now allowed to pay these people whatever you want, we're going to step out of it.
Skill levels dropped dramatically.
Service dropped dramatically.
Wages dropped dramatically.
It used to be that they were going to hire someone to load a plane and they were going to pay them $60,000-$70,000 a year, so you were getting high quality candidates that had to pass scrutiny.
The government then said, Okay, we've been lobbied.
We're going to get rid of this.
Hire whoever you want.
They immediately then said, this is a $7 an hour job and we'll take anyone who can do it.
unidentified
And then you ended up with something that's not better.
liam cosgrove
Fair enough.
I mean, so you're kind of arguing.
I mean, I don't know airline regulation to even make the argument.
I just know from going to the TSA and dealing with planes where you have to put the tray up before you land and take off, which seems ridiculous.
tim pool
That's because of emergency exits and stuff.
liam cosgrove
Right, I know, but the fact that, like, the fact that there's also, I mean, the fact that seats are still, like, you know, straight up, there's not, there's not an airline with, like, beds or couches and things like, there's, there's no diversity in the market.
tim pool
Hold on.
I gotta stop you here.
liam cosgrove
Let me just make the point, though.
So I agree, like, I don't know a bunch about airline regulation.
My point is that I can tell by using it.
And you're wrong.
That it's one of the most heavily regulated industries in the world.
tim pool
But you're wrong about what's going on with the inside of planes and why planes are the way they are.
The airline industry has actually tried and attempted to change the way boarding works, the way seating works, and passengers reject it, and they lose money, so they stop.
liam cosgrove
You're telling me you wouldn't fly- like if you could do a bed in coach, I don't care how- How do you do a bed in coach?
Will you crowd them and you stack them together more closely and you let- They're doing interlaced ones, where the seats are above you- Like that herringbone style?
tim pool
I don't know how you describe it, but instead of having seats just like this, they're like that.
So now you spread out the seats a little bit and put one right in the middle and it's solid.
So you're sitting and you can actually, everyone gets way more leg room.
So if you're in the elevated seat, you have more room and I don't know.
They are certainly trying those innovations.
But having worked for American Airlines, I worked for their regional, American Eagle, for those that are familiar, the smaller jets, CRJs and Embraers.
We always would ask.
And like, we'd directly talk to the people who run the company.
Not like the executives, but like, Ed O'Hare at least, supervisors and the higher ups.
Why is boarding so stupid?
Why does it take so long?
People would ask us, what happens with our bags?
And I'm like, well, like, dude, people need to understand.
You'll get a viral video where it's like a guy outside throwing the bag.
He'll pick it up and just chuck it in.
And they're going, whoa, what's he doing with my bag?
It's like, he's giving you $15 service.
You don't want to pay money for your bags, so that guy gets paid $9 an hour, and when they fire him, they can only get another guy who gets paid $9 an hour, and they don't care about your bag.
And for $9 an hour, they will kick your bag, if you want to pay more.
libby emmons
They might not just not care about your bag, they might hate your bag.
I hate you.
I will tell you.
tim pool
That's how I would feel.
There were a lot of people in the bag room.
So the bag room is where you sit in a chair and there's a conveyor belt.
And all the bags are going across and everyone has a zone.
Behind them they'll have two or three bag carts and it'll say above it something like
No, no, it wouldn't say O.R.D.
because you're at O.R.D., but it would say, um, you know, uh, C.I.T., C.V.G., or whatever.
Those are your cities.
If you see it bad with that city, grab it, load it on the cart.
Those are yours.
This one goes out twice a day, this one goes out twice a day, that one goes out once a day.
liam cosgrove
Right.
tim pool
And there were guys in the bag room who would sit there, and they'd see a big bag that weighs 50 pounds, and so what they would do is, as it's coming on the conveyor belt, they put one arm on it, and then they spin to generate centripetal force, and then, boom, throw it, ka-doom, into the cart, and then sit back down, because they were getting paid $9.75 an hour.
When we'd ask, like, hey, how come they don't pay more, it's like, So, in order to actually be profitable, coach seats aren't actually that profitable.
Business and premium economy are where they make most of their money.
First class is, I think, actually relatively low profitability, and coach is moderate, but business and premium are where the bulk of profit is generated.
So there's a reason why we charge money for For having your bags checked.
We gotta pay the bag checkers, right?
Well, we can afford to pay them this.
And then people make the argument, well, they're making all this profit, they're making billions in profit.
The point is, certainly you can argue they can shave off their profits for their shareholders, but then there's fiduciary responsibility of the company to make sure they get a return to their shareholders where they can, which means they're always looking at ways to cut costs.
Then, here's what ends up happening.
One of the easiest examples of the inefficiency of airlines is it would actually be more efficient if an airline just said, boarding has now begun, have fun, and let everyone just randomly storm in.
That's more efficient than the way all the airlines do it now.
Southwest is a different system where it's like you line up from like a row number or something and you choose whatever seat you get to.
You have like a criteria or something.
The way we board now is based on customer request.
People don't want to board without their family and friends.
So if we set up a more efficient system where it was like all window seats board, then all middle seats board, then all aisle seats board, that would be the fastest way to do it.
But that would mean that husbands and wives would be split up.
Parents and their kids would be split up, and they all reject it outright.
They're unwilling to accept these changes, and that's why everything is the way it is, because this is the highest return for the business over the past 70 years or whatever.
liam cosgrove
Right, so those things are fine.
I didn't mean to, like, start this deep dive into the airline industry.
Like, I'm not talking about the logistics of bags and boarding process.
I just mean, I'm a bit surprised that, like, the interior of planes and the experience is roughly the same as it was in the 1990s.
tim pool
Because people don't want it!
liam cosgrove
I mean, I want it.
The experience in terms of the quality has not changed.
They got rid of the quality of the seats, the quality of the planes, too.
tim pool
People don't want it.
The reason why budget airlines are becoming so prominent and getting so much attention now is because people are like, dude, I will stand up if you give me a flight for 50 bucks.
hannah claire brimelow
That was what the Ryanair guy said.
Remember that?
The budget airline in Europe, he was like, everyone was like, he wants people to stand on the plane.
And he was like, look, if you look at it, some of our flights are like 45 minutes.
You're just literally jumping to the next country.
You could stand for about that long on a bus sometime.
libby emmons
Why not?
On Amtrak too, like I used to take the train from New York City to Philadelphia a lot.
And I would stand the whole time if there were no seats, like whatever.
And even more if you take the, if you take New Jersey Transit to the, Uh, SEPTA in Philly, like you could do like that, and if that's crowded, just stand, but you're paying 15 bucks to get that whole way.
tim pool
But let me just ask you, Liam, uh, just, why don't you fly first class?
liam cosgrove
Well, I mean, because first class is absurdly expensive.
I mean, I don't think that the sorts of things I'm talking about, and again, like a lot of this is just kind of speculation, I don't think the sorts of things I'm talking about would be as expensive as first class.
I think you could pack, layer people into an airplane with beds where couples lay together, very, I'm talking very tight, like it'd be a little claustrophobic, but at least you could lay down so you're not sitting up straight for the whole flight.
I think you could do that for much cheaper than first class.
It might be a little more expensive than coaches now, particularly on like Allegiant and the budget airlines, which I love for short term flights.
tim pool
I'm talking more about business class, premium economy.
liam cosgrove
Yeah, I mean, they are absurdly expensive, I think, for how much... I guess the idea you're presenting is they should create another class... No, there should be just competition in the market, and you're saying there's no competition because it hasn't... people don't want it.
My assumption is, because I just look at how regulated the industry is, where everyone gives you the same spiel before you sit down.
There's these, you know, industry-wide regulations of, like, you know, the trade tables and things like that.
I see, and it makes sense because they're airplanes.
tim pool
Right, but the tray tables thing I don't think is a good example.
liam cosgrove
I know, they're kind of stupid.
libby emmons
I definitely don't want to lay down next to other people on an airplane.
liam cosgrove
No, no, I'm talking, no, no, yeah, you wouldn't lay down next to other people unless you're, you know, a spouse or something.
tim pool
Even then, I don't... But you can't control that because some people fly by themselves.
liam cosgrove
No, I know, and then you'd end up paying a bit more.
unidentified
Then you'd meet people in a really interesting way.
liam cosgrove
To my point, this bed-and-coach idea, this is actually being done right now.
I don't know when it'll come to fruition, but this is the actual thing.
tim pool
They're doing the interlaced seating, so you can actually lay underneath the seat that's in front of you.
liam cosgrove
Okay, so that's a similar kind of thing.
Exactly.
tim pool
But everyone made fun of it, insulted it, and people have basically mocked the concept because... Well, has it come to market yet, though?
I don't know if it's come to market.
liam cosgrove
I think it was... Okay, well, let's see when it does.
I mean, I'm just saying... Here's the main issue.
You would agree it's one of the most heavily regulated industries, right?
libby emmons
It should be.
I mean, you're taking human beings into the sky in a tin can.
liam cosgrove
To start an airline is already such a high capital that you make, you know, it's such a barrier to entry.
I don't think it should be that regulated, actually.
I think, like, You know, I think the regulation is part of the reason we have planes falling apart now because government, you know, bureaucracies.
tim pool
Yeah, but I think it's bureaucracy and DEI.
liam cosgrove
Right, I think it's both too.
No, I agree with you.
tim pool
The issue with the airline industry is, or with any industry, too many people.
You don't matter.
If there were a thousand customers to a business, your say is massive.
As a single customer, they're gonna be like, we can't afford to lose even one.
But with hundreds of millions flying, like every month, all they're gonna do is they're gonna say, hey look, 60% of people will literally sit on a mop bucket if it saves them money.
We are not going to spend $50 million retrofitting our planes with bed seats.
liam cosgrove
It's inelastic demand because people have to travel.
rob noerr
The way I solve this problem is I'm just like a redneck that never leaves rural Pennsylvania and then no problem, you know?
liam cosgrove
Wait, one counterpoint I just thought of, because you mentioned Virgin America.
If everyone remembers when Virgin America first came to market, it actually was a way better experience than the rest of them.
And then I think it's been since been bought out by another company.
tim pool
Now it's, you know... My favorite thing about Virgin was when I first flew on Virgin Airlines, the safety video said, make sure you're wearing your seatbelt when the light comes on.
If you don't know how to put on a seatbelt, something is seriously wrong with you.
And they didn't explain it!
I was like, wow.
unidentified
That's a bold move for your insurance company to accept.
libby emmons
That's like when people stopped saying, leave a message after the beep, you know, on voicemail.
Does anyone have voicemail?
Yeah, no, nobody has.
tim pool
Has voicemail?
libby emmons
No, you know, do you guys remember?
liam cosgrove
Yeah, for sure.
libby emmons
It used to be, yeah, answering machines, leave a message after the beep.
Oh, right, but everyone just knows how to... Now people know how to operate voicemail.
tim pool
Yeah.
libby emmons
They know to leave a message.
tim pool
You know what the worst thing in the world is?
People who have voicemails where they're like, hello?
libby emmons
Oh, I hate that also.
tim pool
I can't hear you.
I'm just kidding!
It's a voicemail!
I'm like, hang up.
libby emmons
Yeah, you're not funny leaving a... I just don't leave a... ever leave a voicemail.
tim pool
Let's get into conspiracy theories.
libby emmons
My mom's the only one who leaves me voicemails.
tim pool
Here we go!
Now, there's a reason why we brought up Boeing.
Because as we're dealing with planes dropping from the sky, it didn't crash, but...
And people getting injured.
And now I think there's been like, well, like five Boeing stories in the past week.
Not to mention, before this, you had the corporate press insulting conservative commentators for warning that DEI and airlines was going to result in plane crashes.
They're like, oh, these people are crazy.
Now you've got a Boeing whistleblower.
They say committed suicide.
Here's from Jalopnik, which is not- this is a leftist obsessed with the culture of cars.
They say, quote, it's not suicide.
Boeing whistleblower warned friend before death.
A family friend of Boeing whistleblower John Barnett says he warned her not to believe reports of suicide.
unidentified
That proves it!
hannah claire brimelow
Well, wasn't he in the middle of giving, like, he went to court, gave testimony, went to his hotel room, yeah, and then was like, nope, can't go any further.
Like, that seems very bizarre to me.
libby emmons
I agree.
And especially since, and he's been on this whistleblower kick since he left Boeing in 2017, and in 2018, 2019.
We had huge plane crashes in like Indonesia and Egypt, you know, it was like hundreds and hundreds of people died.
They said that it was because of faulty, like I forget what it was, but there was like faulty parts and there was like stuff left on board that shouldn't have been there.
And so if he's been on this kick that whole time, like why now in the middle of a deposition would he?
Would he shoot himself?
rob noerr
Well, the question is, is it a Vince Foster suicide where he shoots himself twice in the back of the head?
Or an Epstein one where the cameras malfunction while guards fall asleep?
libby emmons
I used to live in Berridge, Brooklyn, and there was a pharmacy, right?
And the owner of the pharmacy was found dead in his office of apparent suicide, two shots to the head.
And police were like, yeah, it's a suicide.
And I'm like, yeah, okay, for sure.
tim pool
Now hold on, to be fair, it is entirely possible that someone shoots themselves twice in the head.
Immediately.
You're laughing?
So some people often, they'll take the gun and they'll put it under their chin.
And when they pull the trigger, the bullet ejects through their mouth and straight up.
Oh, and so that is a gunshot wound to the head.
And then they'll take it and they'll put it to their temple.
Not fun, not good, not okay.
libby emmons
Terrible.
tim pool
People need serious help.
But I want to make sure people understand context because when the police then put it, like the coroner put in the report, you know, GSW head 2X or something.
People go, what?
That can't be suicide!
And they're like, I think people didn't understand, there are people who have been shot in the head and they survive.
Like, all the time.
liam cosgrove
Like in Fight Club, too, at the end of Fight Club.
tim pool
Well, he put it, he blew it out of his mouth, right, because he was insane.
But yes, that was the premise of the ending plot of Fight Club.
So I just want to say that, not saying that, you know, who is Gary Webb?
Was that his name?
liam cosgrove
In Fight Club?
tim pool
No, no, no.
The journalist who was exposing the CIA and then died of a suicide with two gunshot wounds to the head?
rob noerr
Yeah.
tim pool
You know, I'm still going to lean towards, yeah, he was probably killed.
rob noerr
Well, here's the thing.
I say this about conspiracy theories in general, whether it be suicides, what have.
It's not our fault that we're distrusting.
With the legal system as bad as it is, where, you know, remember we talked this morning about the whistleblower who can't be named, you know, that went after Trump, right?
Remember that?
Remember when whistleblowers were, like, sacrosanct and they were heroes?
And then you had whistleblowers that came out and said, hey, the Biden administration and the FBI under Chris Wray's targeting us because they wanted us to go after- we spoke up about going after parents at school board meetings.
Or the IRS whistleblowers.
We wanted to look into Hunter Biden stuff.
Like, now all of a sudden whistleblowers, ah, we don't believe them.
They're garbage.
They're trash.
So when you have these sort of lies that are constantly told to you in this two-tiered system, you can't help but be skeptical.
For all we know, this gentleman unfortunately did take his own life.
I don't know the specifics of it, but you can't help but be skeptical when powerful corporations that are like cutting corners, all of a sudden when someone's going to try to hold them to account, oh, it just so happened at the zero hour, you know, that he took his own life.
tim pool
I don't believe for a second that he killed himself.
And the funny thing is, journalists are just the stupidest people in the world.
unidentified
Because they're always like, you're about to be a conspiracy theorist.
tim pool
And I'm like, if the argument is a guy was blowing the whistle on Boeing and in the middle of blowing the whistle and providing testimony, and then was found dead after warning a family friend that he would never kill himself.
Yeah, that's called fishy.
And if you lack the cognitive function, To ask questions, it must be very difficult for you to put on your shoes.
liam cosgrove
Did he warn a family friend, or is that him?
Did he go on the news and say that, and then... No, it was a family friend he told him.
Oh, okay, okay.
No, and your point about journalists is great, because, like, conspiracy theorists, if you think about whether they're true or not, are almost always the most interesting stories or potential stories.
So if you are a journalist and you're cocking around, like, poo-pooing, and using the term conspiracy theory as a slander, As a journalist, your job is to basically investigate every conspiracy theory that comes to your desk and determine whether it's true or not.
You don't just, like, throw it out, you know, throw it out in the trash bin because you're afraid of, you know, being called crazy.
That's your job as a journalist is to find out, and those are always the most interesting ones.
tim pool
I remember I was in New York hanging at a bar with a bunch of journalists, and it was, uh, it was like, what, six months after Osama bin Laden had been killed and then dumped from the helicopter or whatever.
And I'm hanging out with these journalists, and they were talking about it, and then I said something like, that whole thing just played out like some stupid action movie, and this one journalist just snapped!
He instantly got super angry, and he went from light conversation to, I'M SO SICK OF YOU CONSPIRACY THEORIES WITH YOUR INSANE ARGUMENTS ABOUT, WE DIDN'T ACTUALLY GET HIM, and I was like, bro, what?
hannah claire brimelow
You said his hypnotism word.
tim pool
I did not say it never happened.
I said the story played out like a bad action movie.
And he's like, what does that mean?
I was like, it means that they did it right in the compound.
He grabbed his wife, then they captured him, killed him, and then dumped him out of a helicopter.
Like the plot of an... I don't know what you want me to say.
I said the thing played out like a bad action movie.
I didn't say it didn't happen!
But these people are so anti-do-not-question-the-official-story-of-the-government-they-get-emotionally-charged.
libby emmons
Yeah, it is like that, although it didn't used to be that way.
I think a lot of that came into being with Obama because everyone had, like, such a huge heart on for him that they just were like, oh, the government must be trustworthy now because our guy is in there.
So now the government is trustworthy.
And then under the Trump, they freaked out.
And then under Biden, they're back to total complicity.
hannah claire brimelow
It is wild to me that Obama was the one that they were like, this guy is trustworthy.
We should definitely trust everything he says.
He doesn't seem like a career politician at all.
libby emmons
It's because he barely was one yet.
hannah claire brimelow
Yeah, his entire career was about politics so far.
liam cosgrove
I think it's an interesting like question of like how did this come about?
How did like the media become?
And for sure that's one, I mean there's a lot of left-wing people in the media and then they thought Obama was their savior so they didn't want to question him as roughly.
Another from just like being in that world and like walking around Capitol Hill and for a brief period, Epoch Times, which is like kind of sort of becoming mainstream conservative media.
You realize that one of the most important things to these DC outlets is, like, getting, you know, quote-unquote, access, where it's like, you want to get the interview with Mitt Romney.
unidentified
Yeah, you want them to hit you with an exclusive, for sure.
liam cosgrove
And Mitt Romney is not going to give you an exclusive if you've just done a story about Epstein and his client list.
So basically, they kind of, like, organically, you know, or they just kind of, over time, morph themselves into these, like, mouthpieces of the state so that they can It's actually much, much simpler than that.
celebrities and things like that. Some of them might actually be like, you know, Operation
Mockingbird, which was a real thing. There were congressional hearings on it. So some of it
actually might be the state using the outlet. But a lot of it is this organic incentive for the
outlet to just cave on its principles so it can get a congressman or a senator to come on the
tim pool
interview. It's actually much, much simpler than that. The people who invest in and run these big
companies, they don't go to journalists and say, I want you to report that Joe Biden is of sound
mind or else.
They don't go to them and say, I need you to report that Joe Biden is of sound mind and we're going to write you a check for 10 grand.
They go outside and they go looking for journalists who want to write about Joe Biden being great.
You, sir, you want to do it?
You're hired.
And that's it.
That's how they do it.
The journalists they bring in, they put out a form saying job opening for a journalist.
Then they interview 10 people, and they sit him down, and they say, what do you think about Joe Biden?
And one guy goes, well, you know, look, I don't like Trump at all.
I wouldn't vote for him, but Biden's not with it.
They go, thank you for coming.
Next, someone comes in and goes, Joe Biden's so smart.
He's the greatest.
Can we write about that?
You're hired.
liam cosgrove
Right.
So you're correct.
I think this is more post-hoc, though.
This is kind of like what has now happened.
I was trying to get at the root of it.
And I will say at Epic Times, where it's actually kind of the opposite, if they want to hear your opinion on Biden being negative.
But what was like, said in many internal conversations at the Epoch Times is specifically like, certain stories would be shut down because it's like, we don't want to jeopardize this interview that we just got with such-and-such senator, or if you're in the press briefing, we don't want to ask this question that's too aggressive because we want to keep getting called on and we want to keep our relationship with the DOD and things like that.
Those conversations absolutely happen.
It's called access journalism.
rob noerr
Right, correct.
liam cosgrove
The irony is- And it gets the- my point is it also gets the right-wing outlets.
rob noerr
The irony of all this is, like, when they say the media holds truth to power, the reality is they bury the truth for the powerful.
That's what our journalism has become.
And when we see sort of people that are trying to be outside the scope of that, they are attacked.
You go to the White House press correspondents, you know, when they're always patting each other on the back saying, we're the fourth estate, we're so important.
The irony is they're right.
That is how important the media is.
It's a shame that our legacy media fails in that.
They are propagandists and not journalists.
tim pool
don't hold truth to power, they hold back truth for power.
rob noerr
Right. That's exactly what they do.
libby emmons
They're also easily manipulated. If you remember the situation with the intelligence community and
the Hunter Biden laptop and the lead up to the 2020 election, you had the Biden camp going out,
soliciting an intel, a former intel guy and saying, hey, do you think this laptop has
the hallmarks of Russian disinformation? And the intelligence guy was like, you know what,
it kind of does have hallmarks of that. And the Biden campaign said, why don't you get more people
who think that they put together this letter, they got the 51 people to sign off on it.
They leaked it to Politico.
Politico ran with a headline that they still haven't corrected that said the Hunter Biden laptop is Russian disinformation.
They, you know, changed it around like that.
But that didn't take much for the Biden campaign to do that.
They just had to reach out to a former intel guy who liked Biden.
It was easy.
Easy to manipulate the guy.
tim pool
You know what I want to do?
I think we should literally do this.
Maybe Rasmussen would be down.
I would like to poll 3,000 people.
I want to do something robust.
I'll do 10,000 people.
I will pay this bill.
I want to know who someone voted for, who they're planning on voting for, and then ask a few other questions.
How old are you?
Where do you work?
What's your income?
And the last one is, do you experience inner monologue?
libby emmons
What about Richard Barris from People's Pundit?
He's pretty good.
tim pool
I think we might need a bigger, maybe, but the general idea is, Correlation between political party and whether or not someone has an inner monologue.
libby emmons
That's sort of interesting.
liam cosgrove
What do you mean by that?
unidentified
I kind of don't even believe that people don't have an inner monologue.
liam cosgrove
How could you not have an inner monologue?
What does that mean?
libby emmons
This is a fascinating conversation.
tim pool
It's estimated that between 50 and 75% of people do not have an inner monologue.
There's nothing happening in their brain.
Well, there's something called aphantasia.
liam cosgrove
That would sound kind of nice, to be honest, to experience for a couple hours.
libby emmons
Sounds like your health.
tim pool
So aphantasia is the inability to visualize in your mind.
There's also, so there's multiple, there's many different ways of thinking.
Just because you have an inner monologue doesn't mean you're inherently smarter.
That's not even necessarily my point.
I'm interested in the correlation.
But I do think that lacking an inner monologue The voice in your head, that's the logical pathway.
So there are some people who think in abstracts.
The studies have been done.
They ask people like, okay, if you do not experience an inner monologue, what's in your mind?
And some people say, I see things.
I see it all.
When you say the dog jumped over the fence, I don't hear words or a voice or anything.
I just see a dog jumping over a fence.
It's like, oh, okay, you visualize.
Some people hear the words.
Some people see the text.
It's a visual, spatial thing.
Some people have what they describe as like an abstract conceptual understanding that they don't even know how to describe.
There's no words.
And they may be very smart, who knows?
I'm interested in the correlation.
But I do think my immediate assumption would be Certainly someone could be very visual.
They could be very... There's also feelings.
There's like four or five principle thought processes that have been defined.
But the inner monologue is quite literally the process of logic.
And so lacking that, you may be able to paint the most beautiful picture, build the best engine, which is intrinsically understanding where parts go, solve math problems, maybe.
But if you can't in your mind say, here are the words, 2 plus 2 equals 4, how do you build those logical pathways?
Consistently and coherently.
It doesn't mean it's not possible, I just think that the depth of someone without inner monologue will be substantially more shallow than someone with.
That is to say, my bias would be, if you have inner monologue, it's probably X times Y, the ability to calculate logic to a certain degree, and if you do not have it, potentially a surface layer thinker.
So what that means is, why is it that Democrats tend to not understand, hey, this guy was blowing the whistle and then died.
If you're in your mind connecting dots, you can see here's the probability.
That this potentially was not a suicide and it is false, but if you do not have the ability to think in your mind words and have these thought patterns, you would just hear, man committed suicide, you'd go, but he committed suicide.
Right.
There's another test that I think Lauren Chen tweeted out and the question is, if you did not eat breakfast yesterday how would you feel?
And I don't think it's a good, I understand the point of the question, but I don't think it's, I don't think that is a good question because I don't eat breakfast.
So my response would be like the same.
I don't eat breakfast.
What do you mean?
But that is the answer to the question.
The question is to determine whether or not you can understand conditional hypotheticals.
People with very low IQs, they typically respond with, but I, but I did eat breakfast.
That's the point.
rob noerr
My buddy Andrew Wilson's been on whatever podcast.
hannah claire brimelow
You gotta pull your mic closer.
rob noerr
Oh, sorry.
My buddy Andrew Wilson's been on whatever podcast and he asked that question.
Rarely do the OnlyFans crowd able to answer that hypothetical.
unidentified
Really?
What do you mean?
tim pool
What do they say stuff like, I did eat breakfast?
rob noerr
That's what they say.
tim pool
Really?
rob noerr
You can check out their scoops.
tim pool
New study.
hannah claire brimelow
OnlyFan girls understand conditional hypotheticals.
tim pool
But this is the issue.
Perhaps I, you know, not to sound like a dick, but maybe the culture war really is a divide between surface level low IQ individuals and multidimensional thought processes and higher intellectual, higher IQ individuals.
hannah claire brimelow
I think that's true on a lot of those.
I think that's one of the reasons that you see people have really intense emotional reactions to things because they actually don't understand them, so they feel threatened.
tim pool
Yeah.
hannah claire brimelow
It's not actually a lot, like, if you understand it logically, you don't feel like it's threatening, but if you can't understand it, you're fearful.
rob noerr
Well, I don't know.
I don't know about this, but what I do know is that it seems, particularly with Democrats, these appeals to authority that they rely on, like the entire bifurcation of us that said during lockdowns of COVID, like, what are you doing?
This is predictably going to harm children, predictably going to harm the economy.
And the other side said, what do you mean you could do your own research?
Trust the science.
Like that is one of the starkest differences, I think, between the population, those that will accept anything that the establishment tells them.
And the irony is, I feel like it was before the biggest vocal most vocal people against like the Iraq war were a lot of left-wingers and I was a Ron Paul guy so I was against the Iraq war as well but somehow one of the most impressive amounts of propaganda I've ever seen
Is that our intelligence agencies, in eight years, were able, through Obama being Mr. War, and then Trump being someone who criticized the intel agencies, we have taken the people that were the most vocal, anti-military-industrial-complex, anti-intel people, and made them their biggest supporters.
The people I used to march with against the Iraq war say to me, how have you changed?
You've changed so much.
I still hate the military-industrial-complex.
I still don't trust the CIA.
Now they trust them implicitly.
liam cosgrove
That's generally true, and obviously, I mean, there's that old saying, when you're young and you have no brain, you're a Democrat, and when you grow up, you have no heart, and you're a Republican, meaning, like, obviously, more logical thinking lends something along those lines.
tim pool
If you're not liberal when you're young, you have no heart, and if you're not conservative when you're old, you have no head.
liam cosgrove
Yeah, okay, yeah, that's it.
And so, and it's true, I mean, like, typically, you know, Republican, as in, like, conservative, you know, actual conservative policies, I think, do have more logic behind their understanding.
In your terms of, like, appeal to authority, I think it's generally true, but I think there are always examples that go the other way.
Like, for example, Israel, the biggest anti, the biggest critics of this war are kind of coming from the left.
I mean, there are some on the right and the libertarian right, But much of the right, even the MAGA right, is vehemently pro-Israel.
tim pool
Like who?
liam cosgrove
Like who what?
tim pool
Who would you describe as a prominent personality?
Ben Shapiro's the obvious one.
You have been Shapiro for sure for sure. I'm not saying you're wrong. I'm saying like give us an example of like this
action bench But he is jewish. So is there is that I was hanging around
liam cosgrove
at c-pak and I mean like basically everyone at c like c-pak was
uh, there there is actually a silent majority I found of like, um,
MAGA conservatives who are um
Sick of israel and and actually big critics of israel I mean, a lot of MAGA conservatives are saying, like, let's not give money to Israel.
tim pool
Trump definitely is.
liam cosgrove
Right.
But I would say most... Okay, here's some examples.
Matt Schlapp, basically every Republican in Congress, even the ones who I like, like Thomas Massie and Rand Paul, really aren't coming out and saying, like, criticizing the way Israel's prosecuting this war in Gaza.
Thomas Massie put up a little meme about Zionism, which was the best relative to the rest of Republican Congress.
unidentified
But Israel's still under attack.
liam cosgrove
Israel is still under attack?
libby emmons
Yeah, they're still under attack.
They're still being attacked.
liam cosgrove
By what?
Well, the missiles that are coming in.
Yeah, there's missiles and stuff.
libby emmons
Because they have a good defense system.
liam cosgrove
You're right.
tim pool
Correct about Trump.
Trump has been like, I'm the most pro-Israel.
But I think most of MAGA is like, we don't care.
We don't want to be involved.
liam cosgrove
No, I guess I agree with that, but there is a hard section.
I mean, there were like, you know, there were Knesset members hanging out at CPAC.
tim pool
Well, I think, like, the traditional Republicans have always been very pro-Israel in our diehard, like, I think Lauren Boebert said, like, something like, we're, it is the holy land and we stand with Israel.
hannah claire brimelow
Yeah, I was going to say, there are some evangelicals who feel a religious or cultural obligation to.
tim pool
But the, like, the run-of-the-mill, working-class MAGA people who are just like, I've not been heard, and Trump's speaking for me, are like, I don't want to spend money on this.
rob noerr
I don't care.
We can talk till we're blue in the face about this religious war that's gone back forever.
I have my opinions.
If it was my family that was attacked on October 7th, I'll guarantee I would say we're not going far enough.
My plan is quite simple, like, I could see Israel's done terrible things, I could see that Hamas has done even worse things, but I'm sorry, we have lost the credibility in the people that prosecute these wars in this country and in our intelligence agencies.
liam cosgrove
Okay, well, Hamas has not killed more than, like, Israel has just killed magnitudes more people than Hamas.
Well, that might be true, but... I don't see how you could say Hamas has done worse things, but... Well, according to Gaza's health ministry.
According to Gaza's health ministry, which has a track record, like, going back the last three wars that they've had of having the exact same numbers, basically, as Israel and the UN.
tim pool
I care as much about the morality of Israel-Palestine as I do about Burma and China.
liam cosgrove
Well, I know.
rob noerr
Exactly.
liam cosgrove
And that is the position of most MAGA Republicans.
The one argument I would make, and I was making this to some congressional staffers last night, of the MAGA wing, who their position is, we don't give any money, but we don't want to be involved, they don't really care about the morality of the war.
My argument to you, Tim, then, would be, You might not care about the war, but Israel's not stopping, and pretty soon Iran or Lebanon might get involved, and when they do, you know for sure that the Pentagon is going to back up Israel, and then you will have just been roped into a war on Israel's behalf that Israel knows we're going to get roped into, and that's why they're so brave.
tim pool
I care as much about the morality of Israel-Palestine as I do about China-Taiwan.
And you know that when China makes their move finally to launch an incursion into Taiwan, the Pentagon's going to rope you in.
liam cosgrove
Yes, correct.
tim pool
Yeah, I get it.
That's why I'm just anti-war generally.
liam cosgrove
Yeah, I know, but and in that case, wouldn't you want to arrest the slide and say, like, you know, Jesus, we have to stop funding Israel right now, but say it more like with more vigor and like, you know, No.
tim pool
We are on the border of... Because my attitude is, how about we stop funding all of it?
rob noerr
Right.
tim pool
I'm not going to moralize Israel and be like, I'm gonna say, yeah, why are we spending money anywhere?
Why aren't we securing our border?
Who came on the show?
They said Trump would win in a landslide.
I think it was Dave Smith.
If the Libertarians would all vote for Donald Trump, if he came out and said every single one of our troops overseas will be brought here to guard our border, you'd lose a bunch of the open border Libertarians, but everybody would be like, Trump, Yeah, for sure.
liam cosgrove
But Israel is intentionally dragging us into this war.
tim pool
Nah, I think you've got Israel Derangement Syndrome.
liam cosgrove
I call it Israel-Palestine Derangement Syndrome, to be fair.
Do you know the story of Israel wiretapping the White House and blackmailing Bill Clinton?
No.
You can see this in the New York Post.
There's been two independently written books on this.
tim pool
Yeah, but do you know the story about the NSA wiretapping Angela Merkel?
liam cosgrove
No, okay, sure, but I'm just saying... Look, look, look.
No, I'm giving you examples.
If Israel doesn't treat us like an ally, Israel ropes us into these things because they know we're going to back them up.
tim pool
And we don't treat Germany like an ally, which is the point.
No, I know, but you... Welcome to international espionage and warfare.
liam cosgrove
But if you're America first, why would you want to get exploited into this war in the Middle East that you care so little about?
tim pool
Why are you trying to make me single on Israel when all of these other countries are doing equally or worse things?
libby emmons
Ethiopia, Afghanistan, Yemen.
liam cosgrove
Because it's not... Hamas doesn't have a lobbying wing in DC that captures all your politicians.
tim pool
I don't want to say her name!
liam cosgrove
No, but Hamas does not have that.
Hamas doesn't have like billions of dollars coming in and capturing your politicians.
tim pool
Who was it who called Ilhan Omar the lobbying wing of Hamas?
libby emmons
Yeah, who did say that?
unidentified
I don't know.
libby emmons
It's true.
hannah claire brimelow
Rashida Tlaib.
liam cosgrove
It's a funny joke, but it's not true.
tim pool
No, I just think there's people who have Israel-Palestine derangement syndrome.
libby emmons
The U.S.
spends a lot of money on Ukraine and the U.S.
liam cosgrove
spends a lot of money on Israel.
libby emmons
Do you guys know the third country that we spend the most money on?
Do you guys know the third country that is third in receiving the most U.S.
aid?
liam cosgrove
Third behind Israel?
What is it?
libby emmons
The third behind Ukraine, which is first, then Israel.
unidentified
Ethiopia.
liam cosgrove
Oh, I thought we were talking all the time.
Are we talking about a current?
libby emmons
I'm talking about right now.
Ethiopia, Afghanistan, Yemen, Egypt, Jordan, Nigeria, Somalia.
tim pool
Do you know who actually, which country still has one of the highest payouts from the, like, investments from the U.S.
government is?
I only learned this recently.
Vietnam.
libby emmons
Yeah.
tim pool
We stopped funding it for sure, but it received like, like significantly more money than like anything else.
Okay.
So, here's what I end up seeing.
NATO has substantially more influence over our military policy.
If you look at Libya, for instance, airstrikes, the United States' interests in Libya turned into a slaver state, destabilized the country.
liam cosgrove
I mean, if you look at the entirety of North Africa... Well, NATO... we just use NATO as our justification to go to war.
I mean, it's not... we're pulling the strings of NATO.
My point is, I would argue, Israel is pulling a lot of our strings in terms of foreign policy.
tim pool
No, I think you're wrong.
I think we're pulling the strings of Israel.
That's the real, that's really what's going on, because Israel is an intelligence and military asset for us in the Middle East.
liam cosgrove
So when we are staging... But how is it an asset if they've gotten us into all the major conflicts that we've been in?
tim pool
No, no, those are our wars.
liam cosgrove
Okay.
tim pool
See, NATO's not getting us involved in things, we're getting NATO involved in things, and Israel's not.
liam cosgrove
I agree on NATO, I don't agree on Israel.
tim pool
There are some Americans... Your position makes no sense.
liam cosgrove
Okay, there are some, but I mean, like, the founding neocons, who, you know, the PNAC group, those guys were Americans, but they basically did all that for Israel.
tim pool
I think Australia's roping us into this war with China.
Why are we sending ships and personnel to Australia in 2002, Tim?
hannah claire brimelow
Did they even send us any kangaroos?
unidentified
What is this?
tim pool
You guys know about what's going on with Australia and China, right?
libby emmons
Yeah, they're having big issues, and that's why we sold Australia a whole bunch of weapons.
tim pool
And there's food issues and dairy issues.
It's been wild.
When I went ten years ago to New Zealand, I started learning about the conflict between Australia and China.
New Zealand is partially involved in, and the things China's been doing in this region of the world is massive.
I mean, they're building these naval bases and air force bases on the atolls.
They're manufacturing islands to establish power.
They're sinking Vietnamese vessels.
I mean, the threat here is tremendous, and Taiwan is roping us into it!
I think the real issue is Taiwan-China.
Why are we involved in this?
Do you know what's going on with China and Taiwan and how much money we spend and how many personnel we have in Taiwan?
I think the Taiwanese are lobbying us so that they can get us involved in their regional conflict.
liam cosgrove
I agree, and there is some of that, but the reality, like you must know this, I mean the reality in terms of dollar value, the reality in terms of espionage leverage like Jeffrey Epstein, who I would imagine you would agree has a lot of links to Mossad.
And is likely a Mossad asset.
tim pool
I'll tell you what I think.
liam cosgrove
Do you think that?
tim pool
I think that the obsession with Israel undermines the foreign policy argument that I and many other libertarians have.
liam cosgrove
It's not an obsession with Israel.
I mean, we just talked about planes for 30 minutes.
tim pool
Israel is number one.
Ukraine is.
liam cosgrove
In terms of all-time funding, it dwarfs Ukraine.
tim pool
The president is coming here and demanding we pay for his war!
liam cosgrove
Yes, and so did the president of Israel in 2000.
tim pool
And guess who's number one?
liam cosgrove
Ukraine!
Ukraine is number one.
libby emmons
Right now it's Ukraine.
liam cosgrove
Right now it's Ukraine.
tim pool
So why are you worried about number two?
liam cosgrove
Because in all because it's been it's been I mean this is a decades long thing and if
you go back decades.
rob noerr
But wait, Liam, I have a question for you, right?
So if my position is we should stop sending money to all of these people and you're like,
I don't understand what your criticism is.
liam cosgrove
It's like, no, I agree with that.
rob noerr
Wait, wait, but you seem to be saying, but it's something more.
We have to take Palestine side.
My point is what you're saying, sort of what we would call non unique in that you're saying,
what if we don't do that, then the shady people in Washington right now will exploit that
situation via Israel and send a war.
tim pool
Ukraine is dragging us into World War III.
Vladimir Putin, over the Donbass, is saying, if the West intervenes directly with troops, we will use nukes.
And Macron is saying, I don't care.
He's doubling down, saying we will go to war over Ukraine.
Ukraine being the largest recipient of U.S.
aid, with their president coming to our country and directly lobbying us to pay their bills, and you're going, but Israel, but Israel!
liam cosgrove
No, I totally agree on Ukraine.
tim pool
I don't care about Israel.
liam cosgrove
Okay, but Ukraine is probably more dangerous because of the nuclear factor.
But the difference is, if you go to the Maidan revolution, that was our coup.
Ukraine is our... There might be some relations back and forth, there's some blackmail back and forth, but that was our coup that started this civil war that now we're dealing with the consequences of.
tim pool
I am as concerned with Israel-Palestine as I am with Ukraine-Russia and China-Taiwan.
liam cosgrove
Even though it could get us dragged into a war with Iran, which might happen War with Russia is worse than war with Iran, and Ukraine is doing that.
They're both, yeah, they're both terrible.
tim pool
So why are you bringing up Israel?
liam cosgrove
Because, because you, because as I just said, Ukraine is our client state where we overthrew
their government and, and started a civil war in the Donbas which led to this conflict
today.
Israel is, is the opposite.
Israel is a situation where they have a lot of influence over our country, whether it be through blackmail or through fanatical, you know, Zionists who are Americans in our country.
But let me give you one anecdote.
After 9-11, which we could also analyze some aspects of 9-11, after 9-11, 2002, before we invade Iraq, Netanyahu testifies on the House floor And just brazenly saying, you can pull up the video, in fact I'll send it to you, he says, there is no doubt Iraq has weapons of mass destruction, and he's schmoozing the congressman, he's like referencing the movie The Great Escape, and he's doing it very charming, and he's blatantly saying he has nuclear facilities hidden underground, and I need regime change, you know.
tim pool
Yeah, kind of like when Zelensky comes here.
No, no, no, no, no!
Zelensky right now is doing these things and you're obsessed with Israel.
I regard them the same.
liam cosgrove
Tim, I was obsessed with Ukraine, too, last year.
I mean, that's what we talked about last time I came on.
tim pool
It's the same thing.
liam cosgrove
I don't like getting dragged into unnecessary wars.
And so you brought up Israel.
Yes, because Israel is about to get us into a war with Iran or Lebanon.
tim pool
And Ukraine is about to get us into a war with Russia.
And Taiwan's about to get us into a war with China.
liam cosgrove
And I'm worried about all those things.
tim pool
And so the position is general anti-war.
But what I see is You've got people who have Israel-Palestine Derangement Syndrome, where, no matter what's going on, this, for some reason, trumps literally everything else.
Quite literally, when Ukraine is the largest recipient of foreign aid right now, and we are facing the direct threat from a world leader with nuclear weapons, you're saying, but maybe Iran?
And I'm like, Russia literally said he'll nuke us if he has to!
liam cosgrove
Well, no, I agree.
The Russia thing is terrifying.
tim pool
So let's focus on what matters.
liam cosgrove
But in terms of the magnitude of death, Israel-Gaza war far surpassed Russia-Ukraine war, and... I don't care about... If you're paying attention, though, to the winds of change, it does... But what does that mean to me?
Hold on, hold on, Tim.
tim pool
Why are you bringing up a moral point that has nothing to do with this country?
liam cosgrove
No, no, Tim, I'm saying...
I was about to get to the point of the country, which is that you can kind of see the national security state shifting its attention to Israel as well.
tim pool
How many children have died in Yemen?
liam cosgrove
It looks like we're moving focus away from Ukraine, thankfully, but sadly it's to support another war.
tim pool
How many children have died in Yemen?
liam cosgrove
I think like over half a million.
tim pool
Do you not know the reporting, the actual number?
liam cosgrove
No, I believe it's over 500,000, is it not?
tim pool
Well, define those deaths.
liam cosgrove
Some of those might be from hunger, but that's for the Saudi Arabia's war in Yemen.
tim pool
So it's like 120,000.
liam cosgrove
Oh, okay.
Well, I heard over 500,000.
That might have been from starvation, things like that.
You're talking about Saudi Arabia's war in Yemen.
tim pool
Right, with U.S.
support and weapons.
liam cosgrove
Correct.
Also, a horrible thing, which the Saudis actually finally backed off of, and now we're again bombing Yemen because of the Houthis thing, because of Israel, again.
So we finally ended that war, and now it's started again because of Israel's war.
tim pool
Wait, wait, wait.
We were involved in helping Saudi Arabia.
We were launching airstrikes and commando raids in Yemen well before October 7th.
liam cosgrove
I know, I know.
tim pool
And then when the Houthis, who we've been in conflict with the whole time, start attacking us again, and we attack them, you're like, but now it's Israel.
liam cosgrove
No, no, no, the Saudi, the Saudis had briefly paused their war in Yemen.
tim pool
Yes, the conflict between us and the Houthi rebels and the Iranian militias and all that stuff has been going on well before October 7th.
liam cosgrove
No, I know, but before October 7th... But you're saying now Israel's done it?
Saudi and Yemen's had a peace deal.
They had a ceasefire.
My point is, it reignited.
Now we are the ones bombing Yemen directly.
tim pool
Maybe it's Iran supplying weapons to Gaza, which resulted in the October 7th attacks, which triggered the war, and it's their fault.
liam cosgrove
I just don't... For me, I don't... Yeah, but that's just pure speculation.
tim pool
If October 7th didn't happen, we would not be here.
So you're saying it's Israel's fault?
I'm like, but Israel got attacked and retaliated.
You can argue the retaliation is over the top, but they didn't start the war.
liam cosgrove
Okay, but we both agree we shouldn't be involved, but if you want to go and assess the entire Israel-Palestine conflict, I mean, you go back to, like, pre-1940s, and it's obvious, like, who the aggressor was in that situation, who took the land.
unidentified
Well, Hamas didn't start planning this until Biden came into office.
tim pool
No, no, no, I'm attacking your position where I believe you're obsessed with Israel for some reason.
liam cosgrove
It's just one of many conversations.
tim pool
Tell me about Burma.
liam cosgrove
I don't know about Burma.
tim pool
Why not?
liam cosgrove
Because we're- are we involved in Burma?
Is it- is it- is there a potential nuclear escalation path with the conflict in Burma?
I only- There is.
I only care if my country's getting involved.
tim pool
Tell me about Kashmir.
liam cosgrove
And especially if my country is backing the side.
tim pool
Tell me about Kashmir.
liam cosgrove
That's, you know.
rob noerr
This is all I don't get.
This is what confused me about this.
If I'm on your side of this, and let's say I'm guessing you think morally Palestine is more justified than Israel.
That's fine.
Tim and I are basically saying we don't care.
There's bad shit that occurs all throughout the world.
We should not be involved.
liam cosgrove
You somehow seem to be saying... Well, before the show started, you were all on board.
You should help me out, because you had some good facts.
rob noerr
Right, but this is what I'm saying.
I'm on your side, and I even told you this.
I said, you should be happy with me, because my position is, as some redneck that's concerned about what's happening in my neck of the woods, I don't give a shit to go through a 2,000 year history of religions fighting.
All I'm saying is, don't get involved.
liam cosgrove
That's why I was trying to make the case that the Israeli government is dragging us into war.
Tim is correct, the Ukrainian government is also dragging us into war.
So is the Taiwanese.
Israel has by far the most robust lobbying apparatus, and as we know from the whole Epstein saga, in addition to lobbying, they have this espionage apparatus that blackmails our politicians and forces us into war.
So my point is, I don't like any of these countries that are dragging us into war, and especially Israel's, which is far more powerful and has far more influence.
So my view is... That's proven from basically all our Middle East interventions, which are all centered around protecting Israel.
tim pool
I think this is a bias and obsession.
I think that if you analyze what's going on with Israel, one could equally make the argument that the US Manipulates Israel as a puppet state in the Middle East for control, military, weapons development, computer chips particularly, so that when it comes to the conflict in the Middle East we have a massive base of operations.
The US, and I think the evidence for this is, the Iraq and Afghanistan wars, we can pull up the map here, For people who don't know geography, and I'm not trying to be mean, people don't realize that we decide, hey, we gotta invade Iraq, and we gotta invade Afghanistan, and we gotta build a bunch of military bases here.
And what is in the middle of these two countries?
Iran.
It has been explicitly stated for a long time that our goal is to go after Iran.
And we have an ally in the region.
They scream it to the high heavens.
Israel's our ally in the region.
It's our ally in the region.
It is a weapons manufacturer.
It's one of the best in security and weapons technology.
And we utilize this as a staging base of operations.
Then people come out like you and say, but Israel's controlling us!
And I'm like, dude, the U.S.
military-industrial complex is not just the United States, it's also NATO.
The massive empire that is the military-industrial complex is not a puppet of Israel.
liam cosgrove
No, Tim, you missed part of my point, which is that there are guys like PNAC, there are these hardcore American Zionists who push it, we push it intentionally, and I'm sure there's some back and forth where we have leverage on them and pull the strings, but to deny Israel's influence over US politics compared to Ukraine's influence or Taiwan's influence, I think is a bit silly.
tim pool
So, the point I'm making is, it is an assumption that people in the US are like, oh no, Israel's telling us what to do, and not, we agree with them.
liam cosgrove
We want our military presence there. There's some of that, but like you had like
I mean, do you agree that Epstein was likely a Mossad asset?
unidentified
I mean, I don't I have no idea But I agree. Well, you should look into that because he was
liam cosgrove
blackmailing. He was blackmailing politicians for the benefit of Israel
He worked for Leslie Wexner who Leslie Wexner is openly a massive Zionist
Very powerful.
tim pool
But what I'm saying is it is bias to say Israel controls us instead of we are aligned with Israel.
liam cosgrove
I said both.
That's why I brought up PNAC.
There are people in the US government who are very powerful.
They were much more powerful during the Bush administration, but they were, I see no distinction between NATO and Israel.
like okay but but well but NATO clearly is just is just the US arm that clearly
define that how they can start unconstitutional because we always use it
to start unconstitutional wars like in Iraq and stuff and NATO I mean we're
obviously the biggest you know country in NATO it's it's I don't disagree with you
rob noerr
I think AIPAC is lobbying unto influence.
I agree with all that.
The only thing that, the tension I'm getting, you tell me if I'm reading this situation wrong.
Let's say Tim and I get our way and we're like, we stopped sending money to all these places.
Heck, I'd pull out of NATO.
I'd want NATO disbanded.
Let's say that happens.
And I just say, I don't care.
Israel, Palestine, I'm both, we can sit two people here and argue till they're blue in the face.
liam cosgrove
I'm also forgetting out of NATO, so.
rob noerr
But here's my question to you.
Are you saying beyond stop sending money all these places, you would also want the U.S.
to proactively work against Israel for the abuses you think they're committing in Palestine?
liam cosgrove
No, I mean, no, of course, what I would, I would, first of all, I agree with all of you that I would take all foreign aid off the table.
But I mean, as the U.S., as like the big superpower, I would negotiate a ceasefire or work out some deal for a lasting peace.
I mean, and Trump tried to do that.
And there's a great clip of Trump After he was out of office, he's being interviewed for his book, and he's talking about meeting Netanyahu and Abbas, the head of the PLO in the West Bank.
And he says, very candidly, he says, you know, I got a really good feeling about Abbas.
He was kind of like a father figure, and I really got the sense he wanted to work out a deal.
Within five minutes of talking to Netanyahu, I realized he had no intention of ever making a deal.
So Trump just very candidly kind of said, you know, who's really the ones who don't want to make a peace deal?
And we pay the price for this, both economically and with our, you know, and potentially the US militarily has wanted to control the Middle East for a very, very long time.
I agree, but I'm saying Trump actually tried to make peace and the one he said was the problem was Netanyahu.
I get it.
He asked me what my position would be and it would be to sue for peace and don't send money to anyone.
tim pool
The point I'm making is one could equally argue that Netanyahu defying Trump, much like the deep state defied Trump.
And Netanyahu aligned with establishment forces in this country.
liam cosgrove
You oppose the deep state?
tim pool
When people come out and they go, it's Israel making us do these things, I'm like, no, Israel's a puppet state of the United States.
liam cosgrove
I think, I think you're, you're kind of, I mean I agree with you, I think it goes both ways, but I think you're very under, um, appreciating Israel's influence.
tim pool
I don't think, I think, but I disagree with that in that it goes both ways in that what I actually think is there is no both ways, it's one entity.
liam cosgrove
I mean, obviously, there's, but even within the military industrial complex, there's people who agree and disagree.
tim pool
Sure, sure.
But what I'm saying is, NATO, Israel, the US, Australia, the Five Eyes spy club, there's no one way about it or the other.
There's no, they're controlling us, no, we're controlling them.
They're two brothers sitting there smoking joints together, in total agreement on everything, and to argue that one brother made the other brother smoke pot is ridiculous!
They're sharing the joint they bought together!
liam cosgrove
Well, I mean, but, okay, you're kind of just asserting this, but even, you know, if that's the case, there are, and you just acknowledged there are disagreements, but, you know, I'm just asserting this is a funny thing for you to say when you're literally arguing that's what you're doing.
But you're asserting, I'm trying to give you some points here, but you're just kind of asserting it's all kumbaya when it gets up there.
tim pool
I think there's different factions.
liam cosgrove
There's like Bush, there's the Bushes who are very Zionist, there's Biden who He's clearly Zionist.
tim pool
I'm done.
You guys are obsessed with this stuff.
liam cosgrove
Dude, I'm not obsessed with Israel.
tim pool
You have an affliction.
liam cosgrove
What are you talking about?
tim pool
You have an Israel affliction.
liam cosgrove
Because there's a massive war that I'm paying for and that we might get involved in a bigger war.
tim pool
And there's so much more stuff going on in the world you can't tell me about because you are so obsessed.
I can't take Israel-Palestine.
I am a foreign policy guy, but I don't... Okay, tell me about the history of China and Taiwan.
Let's start talking about that.
How many people are at risk?
How many people live on the island?
How many troops are there?
How much have we spent so far?
liam cosgrove
Okay, I know more about Ukraine, but I think in Taiwan, I think we have like 120 troops stationed there. 120?
That's the last time I checked.
Have we increased?
Is it over 200 now?
It might be over 200.
And it's a bad thing.
We should not have US troops there as a trigger point to go to World War 3 with a direct nuclear power.
Oh, that one says only 30 troops.
Okay.
Well, maybe they swap them out, but I know at one point they put in like a surge of 100.
tim pool
What lobbying groups exist for Taiwan?
liam cosgrove
Well, I mean, there are think tanks that are super hawkish against China.
tim pool
Like who?
liam cosgrove
Well, like the CSIS and like the Council on Foreign Relations.
These guys are kind of just inherently... Oh, come on.
tim pool
Those are generic terms.
Everybody knows those guys.
liam cosgrove
No, I know.
tim pool
Like we know AIPAC.
Everyone can bring up AIPAC.
What's Taiwan's?
liam cosgrove
Uh, I actually don't know the name of Taiwan's, but I would say there are groups like that and there are groups like the Epoch Times where I used to work, which is, you know, claims to be a media outlet, but it is basically not a Taiwan lobbying group, but it's an anti-CCP lobbying group.
Um, so I, you know, I don't exactly know what your, what your, the point of your line of questioning is.
tim pool
My point is, to a hammer, everything looks like a nail.
You live in Israel world.
I think there's tons of other military conflicts in the world that are deeply pressing.
liam cosgrove
And last year, all I could talk about was Ukraine.
This one's a little more pressing now.
I don't, I'm not, like, I just don't really understand your point.
You keep just saying, like, you're obsessed.
We should stop talking about it.
tim pool
But yeah, yeah.
liam cosgrove
Israel today, right now, is not- But you're obsessed with America, so don't you not want U.S.
tim pool
to be- I live in America.
liam cosgrove
Yeah, and don't you want the U.S.
not to be dragged into another unnecessary war in the Middle East?
tim pool
Which is why my position is, if we could stop the hyper-focus and obsession on one tiny-ass country, and focus on the full-scale problem that is the military-industrial complex... The people who you're bashing as obsessed with Israel are the only ones right now pushing back against... Bro, you've already made a bunch of moral arguments over the deaths in Gaza.
liam cosgrove
Because it is a moral atrocity, I don't really... Obsession.
tim pool
No, but... How many children have died in Ukraine?
liam cosgrove
How many?
You don't even know the number of the most pressing conflict right now!
tim pool
What's the number?
How many in Gaza?
Less in conflict right now.
liam cosgrove
Fewer children have died in Ukraine than in Gaza.
tim pool
How many in Gaza?
liam cosgrove
I don't know, I could look it up.
I would have known it last- How many in Gaza?
A couple months ago when I was more focused on this.
tim pool
How many in Gaza?
liam cosgrove
In Gaza, okay, it's like 30K are the official numbers.
It's probably higher than that.
tim pool
Official from who?
liam cosgrove
From the Gaza Health Ministry, which, yes, is run by Hamas, but they do have a track record of being in line with Israel's numbers.
And the children are something like 12,000.
tim pool
Now, considering we spend substantially more money right now on Ukraine, and we're being directly threatened by probably the most powerful nuclear nation on the planet, I'd like to know how many children have died in Ukraine.
Why don't you know the answer?
Have you asked yourself that?
liam cosgrove
I used to know, well I don't know if I ever bifurcated between children and adults, but I used to know, yes, the Ukraine civilian death count, which is I think below, I think it's below 10,000, I could be wrong on that.
tim pool
I think it's about 11,400.
I don't care one way or the other.
I don't know why it is that you have made a moral argument to me over the atrocities of Gaza, and you don't know about Ukraine.
To me, that signifies you don't actually care about international conflict.
liam cosgrove
Yes, I do, Tim.
tim pool
No, you're obsessed with Israel.
liam cosgrove
But the people making the moral arguments, if you want to get something, if you want to convince a politician to stop supporting a certain policy, sometimes you have to make the moral argument, which is like, That's what the left is doing right now, and I'm not a leftist, but I do actually appreciate that the left is out there protesting because it's putting pressure on Biden.
Every time Blinken walks out of his house, Code Pink and all those, you know, left-wing feminist protesters are pouring red paint on his sidewalk and they're screaming at him, and that's adding pressure.
No, I disagree.
hannah claire brimelow
UNICEF says 545 children have been killed.
That's not correct.
In Ukraine.
tim pool
That's children.
hannah claire brimelow
I'm just saying, if you wanted a number.
tim pool
You said 11,000 civilians I thought you were talking about.
hannah claire brimelow
I'm just saying, if you wanted a number...
liam cosgrove
You said 11,000 civilians, I thought you were talking about.
Yeah.
Yeah, so that's...
tim pool
But I asked children in Gaza.
rob noerr
But listen, it's...
liam cosgrove
That's not Gaza, that's Ukraine.
hannah claire brimelow
No, that's Ukraine.
tim pool
I know, I'm asking how many children... How many children in Gaza?
liam cosgrove
I think it's like, I think it's about 12,000 or more.
tim pool
Because you made a moral argument to me about the atrocities of Gaza, and when I ask you about the atrocities of Ukraine, you don't know.
liam cosgrove
No, Tim, I mean, you put me on the spot, like, what's the exact number?
Yeah, dude, I tracked Ukraine very closely, I can tell you all about them.
tim pool
Now listen, now listen, now calm down, here's the point, here's the point.
liam cosgrove
Okay.
tim pool
The most pressing conflict on Earth right now is Ukraine.
Emmanuel Macron, now let me finish.
Emmanuel Macron just came out, doubled down again, following the third or fourth threat of nuclear force against NATO, and Macron said, we don't care, we will not lose, and he has called for, in the event we need to, NATO troops deployed into Ukraine.
Putin again responded, we are ready and willing to use nukes against you.
This is the most money we're spending.
Zelensky is coming directly to our country.
We're spending hundreds of billions of dollars on this war.
It is the most, most pressing thing.
And you're going, but the children of Gaza, the moral atrocities.
liam cosgrove
Well, because Israel has a potential path to escalation as well.
I mean, like... Okay, now here's my point.
Iran might have some nuclear capabilities, like a dirty bomb or something.
I mean, things could get very ugly with Iran, too.
tim pool
And maybe, maybe, what if, what if, maybe Iran might get involved?
liam cosgrove
It's not what if, dude.
I mean, if this keeps... But I know, but if this keeps going, you know that if they get... Now, here's the point.
tim pool
Vladimir Putin, the President, and Desmond— I agree with you.
So, the leader of a nation which has more nuclear weapons than anybody else has threatened to use them against us.
But why- have you not asked yourself why it is you know more about Israel when Iran has not directly- doesn't even have a- No, I actually- if you actually quizzed me on it, I probably know more about Ukraine.
liam cosgrove
Like, like I was saying, the last two years, I have been all focused on Ukraine.
It's literally one of the reasons that motivated me into journalism, and then Epoch Times hired me, and then I would go to the State Department and the Pentagon and ask- Every single day, I was the only journalist in the Pentagon and State Department criticizing the Ukraine war.
Not many people follow me, but you can ask them.
I was obsessed with Ukraine.
I had Ukraine obsession syndrome.
If I can- Last year, man.
I did.
If I can get in here real quick- And this one seems more pressing because it seems hotter, and also the national security state seems to be pivoting to this one.
tim pool
It's not.
rob noerr
You don't think- Listen, can I get in for a second?
Let me say this.
liam cosgrove
Ukraine is having trouble for the first time getting funding because the focus is on Israel.
Listen, I think the fundamental problem... So, Ukraine is hopefully winding down because of the Israel war.
rob noerr
One second, please.
I think the problem is you are overselling this.
You are talking past the sale.
And I can tell you exactly when you've done it.
You know from the conversation we had before this, we're literally like, yeah, we hear you on Israel, we shouldn't be sending money to them, right?
But you keep going.
And here's where you make a mistake, right?
You're like, well, it's like these Code Pink people and they're doing a lot.
No, that's the exact opposite.
Real quick, average people that are sick and tired of financing these foreign wars buy that argument.
When you say, and these people that you see blocking roads and cutting paintings and acting like spoiled brats, they're helping the cause.
They're not.
Take the win when you got it.
We're saying don't send the money to Israel.
That's what we're saying.
liam cosgrove
Okay, I'll calm down.
I actually agree with the first point you made, that I'm overselling it to you guys, and it's actually probably making you more annoyed with my campaign.
tim pool
That was what I said in the very beginning.
liam cosgrove
If I could just add to the Code Pink people, I disagree when you come to the Code Pink people.
Sure, if you're blocking a road and you're pissing off guys driving in traffic, what are you really helping?
But if you're going outside Blinken's house, which they are doing, that does add pressure to Blinken, and they do see that they're losing the progressive left.
Like in states like Michigan, where there's a huge Muslim population.
Those things, I think, actually do add pressure.
I agree with you.
Like, you know, since we already agree, I probably didn't need to... Yeah, which was your point about me making the moral case for no reason.
That could have an effect.
I mean, I think a lot of people argue it better than me.
I'm not much of a public speaker, to be completely honest.
So I hear you.
I mean, I'm working on it.
But anyway, sorry.
tim pool
This is a conversation we've had with Ian a lot.
Because the first thing I try to do whenever someone comes up to me and talks to me about Israel is I immediately just say, like, how many people have died in Ukraine?
And they can't answer.
And I say, how many people have, what's the current amount of dead in Burma?
I don't know.
Okay, well, let's talk about Sudan.
Well, I don't know about Sudan, but the United States has been funding the conflict in Sudan.
Let's talk about Somalia.
I don't know.
Okay, now ask yourself the simple question, why don't you know?
And I'm not telling you you're absolutely allowed to focus on Israel.
When Ben Shapiro comes out and says, Israel this, Israel that, I'm like, he's an orthodox Jewish man.
I absolutely understand why he's deeply concerned about literally the only Jewish state on the planet.
I can understand his sentiment.
As for an American who's talking about foreign policy, I have to ask you why it is.
There's a video of a woman.
She goes into the camera screaming.
unidentified
She's like, why don't you care about Gaza?
tim pool
It's like she's got some kind of derangement over this.
liam cosgrove
And the issue is... But in terms of magnitude of death, it is the highest of those examples you just mentioned.
tim pool
I'm just saying, but some people... More children have died in Yemen because of the US-funded Saudi conflict.
liam cosgrove
And I did know about the Yemen War.
Who cares?
And part of the Yemen thing is just that, like, the media, for whatever reason, didn't cover it.
So that's, you know, you're right.
That's why.
But in terms of those conflicts you just mentioned, besides Yemen, which ended at least Saudi Arabia's persecution of it, you might not care, but there are people who do care about innocent life, and, you know, it's the greatest magnitude, and therefore it's the greatest urgency to be upset about.
rob noerr
I think take, like, I understand what you're saying that there might other be people that need, you know, convinced in other ways.
For me, this is the simplest argument.
When we take these moral stances, these are the sort of things that our intelligence agencies end up doing.
We're in a military alliance of NATO, right?
And in that alliance, we are honor bound and treaty bound to defend any NATO country, correct?
So we've stationed nuclear weapons in the country of Turkey.
Meanwhile, we're in Syria bombing Assad, and we're told that we can't leave Syria to the point where the generals committed treason, as far as I'm concerned, and lied to Donald Trump when he tried to pull out.
Because the argument is, if we leave Syria, our ally, the Kurds, will have genocide committed on them by our ally, the Turks, who we've given nuclear weapons.
Now, how does that apply to what we're saying?
I don't care about who's right or wrong in these conflicts.
You might be 100% right.
And I do have sympathy that I think Israel's gone too far.
I also think Hamas sucks.
We talked about it.
They could be trying to target the leadership of Hamas.
Instead, they seem to be more interested in bombing.
But the The point is, I'm so sorry I've lost my compassion for having to pretend to care about this stuff.
It's not that I don't have a big heart, I do.
It's that I know that that's used to take advantage of me and other Americans to get us involved in these quagmires.
And so the stance I've taken, until we can trust... That's my point, though.
liam cosgrove
The side that's dragging us into the quagmire is Israel.
It's not Hamas.
There's no Hamas in the lobbying sector.
No one's saying we should start sending weapons to Hamas.
rob noerr
It doesn't matter who's dragging us in, to me.
And I understand you might, to you and to other people.
liam cosgrove
Why does it matter?
You have to know who to oppose because it should depend on who you're dragging you in.
unidentified
Let me finish.
rob noerr
It doesn't matter to me because my answer is stop giving them all money.
And you could be like, yeah, but Israel's really bad.
liam cosgrove
Right.
rob noerr
We're not giving them money anymore.
liam cosgrove
So I agree.
And I think different arguments work on different people.
A fiscal argument might work more for certain conservatives, but a moral argument might work more for someone in the Biden administration.
So I don't see why you can't attack it on both sides.
tim pool
So how many people died in Sudan in the last year?
liam cosgrove
I don't know.
I don't know.
tim pool
know and I get you know how much money on this one how much has the US
government given to the government of Sudan in this con pre this conflict and
liam cosgrove
now moving into 2020 24 I don't know I don't see an escalation path for nuclear
war in Sudan so it doesn't you know shock me that much but so here's what
here's I agree like you got me there man I but I don't but I also don't support
sending money to the Sudanese government I don't support the war there 800
tim pool
$850 million obligated in 2022 to Sudan.
The war in Sudan, the current war in Sudan, is 2023 to the present, though there is ongoing Sudanese conflict that we've been involved in.
And the casualty, the dead, up to $13,000 to $15,000, with $33,000 additional injured.
15,000 with 33,000 additional injured.
And I don't know why we gave them a billion, near a billion dollars.
And in 2023, we don't have the final numbers from foreignassistance.gov, but Sudan, I believe
it's at what, 400 million?
Let me see if this thing loads.
$642 million amidst this civil war.
Why is the U.S.
involved?
It must be the Sudanese lobby coming to the United States and insisting that we give them money, isn't it?
liam cosgrove
It's not that I'm hypothesizing that there is an Israeli lobby.
There is one, and it's AIPAC, and it has billions of dollars that it funds to all these different politicians, and you won't have a hard time getting people like Ron Johnson or Rand Paul or Thomas Massey to criticize the war in Sudan.
You will actually get the hard time, even with those guys who have high integrity, in my opinion, to come out vehemently and criticize Um, the Israeli government, but also it's fewer deaths and it's less money.
So you have your answer right there.
There's a, there's a reason Israel is more pressing and it's because we're sending them more money and more innocent people are dying.
rob noerr
I mean, for me, it just feels like we have such a problem with corruption and getting involved in these wars in this country.
It seems like this entire 30 minute conversation is sort of irrelevant in that we should be focusing on the agreement that we're all agreeing to stop sending the money.
And what happens is when we get drug into the, but Israel's more immoral, I could easily push back and say, but here are certain things, and then we get involved in this, what I see as an unnecessary conversation for the people that we're trying to reach at this moment.
Granted, if we're sitting at the table with a bunch of lefties, or we're sitting at the table with a bunch of, like, evangelicals that think we need to defend Israel because, you know, the resurrection's coming, then yes, your arguments don't...
Your argument changes when it comes to land, but I think that we're spending a lot of time disagreeing on something that we're basically all agreeing on 95% of what we're talking about.
tim pool
The frustrating thing to me is that there are people who live in this world where Israel is the cause of literally everything.
That's true.
And, you know, I've talked about during Occupy Wall Street, that story I tell quite a bit, where the guy stands up and yells, what's wrong with you people?
unidentified
It is fracking!
liam cosgrove
I've heard that story.
And just to be clear, that is not me.
I am not one of these people that thinks like Israel and especially like the people who are literally anti-semitic and they think the Jews are doing it.
I am not one of these people that think the Jews get us into every con.
rob noerr
Yeah, you said that before the show you were talking about this.
liam cosgrove
Yeah, and those people are stupid and wrong because you...
You create a barrier for Jewish people who might be critics of Israel to come on board and join your cause.
So I just want to be clear, I'm not one of those people.
We're going to go to superchats!
tim pool
We're going to read the superchats from the audience, so get your superchats in now, because I guarantee you disagree with at least someone here so far, because no one's going to agree with everything.
Smash the like button, subscribe to this channel, share the show with your friends.
It is such an amazing night out.
The weather was so awesome.
libby emmons
It was a beautiful day.
tim pool
Yeah, amazing.
It was 80 degrees yesterday out here in good ol' West Virginia.
hannah claire brimelow
It's spring for sure.
I'm really excited about it.
libby emmons
Spring comes really a lot sooner.
tim pool
Our cherry tree has begun to flower.
liam cosgrove
Gorgeous.
tim pool
So, cherry blossoms.
It's beautiful.
But become a member at TimCast.com and buy Casper Brew Coffee at Casper.com.
Let's read your Super Chats.
Clint Torres says, Howdy people!
Right on.
Raymond G. Stanley Jr.
says, Tim, today's culture war was good.
Never heard the guys, but I liked their words.
Rob nailed it.
White people love Trump.
First person to acknowledge rural folk even exist and are important to our nation.
I'm not surprised.
Raymond G. Stanley Jr.
is a PA guy like you.
rob noerr
Awesome.
unidentified
Peace.
hannah claire brimelow
He's biased is what you're saying.
This isn't even real.
He's just into Pennsylvania.
You guys all have this club.
rob noerr
I'll take it, yeah.
tim pool
Collisionikoff says, Tim, please look into the story of the 8th graders in Connecticut being criminally charged over edgy speech.
Truly despicable.
Have you guys seen that story?
libby emmons
I haven't seen it.
I'm gonna check it out.
tim pool
Fray Cain says, took fluoxetine, is that it?
As a kid, gave me some severe side effects.
Suicidal thoughts and extreme antisocial behavior.
Misdiagnosed with bipolar and stopped after 10 years.
unidentified
Wow.
tim pool
Brandon Norton says, I hope you guys are going to talk about the guy from Boeing who unalived himself and after was on his way back for a third day.
unidentified
Yep.
tim pool
Yep.
Kendall Bird says, sorry for loss of Mr. Bocas.
Is there a plan for the successor to the mascot of Timcast?
Well, my idea was that we get another cat and we name him Snowball 2.
libby emmons
Oh, that's cute.
tim pool
Yeah, and because, uh, do you guys understand that reference?
rob noerr
Simpsons.
unidentified
That's right.
libby emmons
You mean the Simpsons, yeah.
tim pool
So, uh, we've never had a Snowball 1, and I was like, we can't name another cat Bocas, so we'll get a cat called Snowball 2 as the joke, which is also a Simpsons reference.
libby emmons
I think it's cute.
tim pool
Snowball 2.
Um, and it seems like most people are now asking for another cat, because everyone loved Mr. Bocas.
The funny thing is he destroyed everything and he pissed literally everywhere.
He hated using a litter box.
And it's like how he just had so much love.
It's just I'm sure I'm pretty sure this we're going to find piss from him somewhere and go, how did he get in here?
hannah claire brimelow
I was a fan.
He was an honorable cat, you know, a true statesman, if you will.
But he had some flaws, I will say.
And it was really unpleasant to walk up to your desk and realize that he had peed either on it or near it.
Or I think he got trapped in Carter Rinks' studio one time and he like pooped everywhere.
Look, look, look, he was extreme terrorist in some circumstances.
tim pool
We don't know how he got in Carter's studio.
hannah claire brimelow
No, it doesn't make any sense.
And also, you know, praise be to Bogus, but they were gods.
tim pool
Before he was sick, he found a way to get into the walls.
hannah claire brimelow
Yeah, I mean he did all kinds of crazy stuff.
tim pool
Yeah, he was a crafty fella.
unidentified
I like when he would come onto the show and like prevent me from camera switching because his tails just hit me in the face.
tim pool
I'm pretty sure that in the walls he's probably pissed and we'll never find it and no one ever will and it'll be like 40 years later someone will be like remodeling and they'll go, what the?
It's like a stain.
And I'm pretty sure within the next few weeks or months, we're going to go into like an unused closet or something and just realize there's, you know, piss somewhere and that's what he did.
Shamus, the new cat, Shamus 1, not Shamus 2.
unidentified
Shamus 1 does not- I think the cat is called Shamus 1.
tim pool
Yes.
So Seamus One is a good dude, and he's our new cat.
He was living in our garage.
He was less than a year old when we found him.
Libby really is loving this!
libby emmons
That's just so funny!
tim pool
Well yeah, Seamus Two is the cartoonist.
hannah claire brimelow
Seamus Two's gonna hate-tweet at you after this.
libby emmons
Sorry, Seamus is just really- You mean Seamus Two.
hannah claire brimelow
Or you're apologizing to the cat.
I'm now confused.
tim pool
Well, the issue is Seamus 2 is never here.
libby emmons
Right, yeah.
tim pool
So we're not gonna call him Seamus 2.
libby emmons
How could he be Seamus 1 if he's never around?
tim pool
Yeah, exactly.
The cat is Seamus 1.
He's a good dude.
He doesn't pee everywhere and, uh...
hannah claire brimelow
Which one?
I'm now confused again.
unidentified
Seamus one.
Oh yeah, Seamus two.
tim pool
It was funny because we were hanging out and I mentioned passively, we had a guest over, they were getting ready for the show and I was like, oh, we gotta bring in Seamus to get his balls chopped off.
And then the guest started laughing.
And then I was just like, yeah.
And he was like, really, Seamus?
And I was like, yeah, we have him sleeping in the garage, but he's gotta go get his balls chopped off before he can come in the house.
And then he laughed and I was like, I'm not joking.
And he was like, what?
And I was like, I'm talking about the cat.
So we have removed his ability to reproduce.
I'm pretty sure Seamus One has siblings all over the area though.
So he was living in a garage, and then we trapped him, caged him, Stockholm Syndrome'd him, and then removed his testicles, and now he is a house cat who very much enjoys his new existence, though it is the end of his bloodline, but in the middle of the night you can hear a female cat in heat screaming, and I'm like, The mama cat didn't have one baby.
She probably had a bunch of babies and then they grew up and they're all over somewhere.
libby emmons
Yeah, the female cat screaming in heat is really, that'll keep you up nights.
liam cosgrove
They scream.
libby emmons
It sounds like a person too.
It freaks you out.
Someone's being murdered.
Also, nevermind.
hannah claire brimelow
Are you still thinking about, which names are you thinking about?
One or two?
libby emmons
No, no.
It was, it was, it was, um, be testicle cats.
tim pool
Uh, yes, let's- oh, the spritzing.
Uh, here we go.
Juan Castle says, uh, first, any tips, fellas, for working in high-stress work?
What is- what is hi- it depends on the work, I guess.
Uh, stress ball.
You just squeeze it, argh, you get angry.
You know, I gotta be honest, people always said, drums are so great because you get all your stress out, and I was like, I have never felt relief from physically striking something.
Punching a pillow or squeezing a ball.
That doesn't do anything for me.
unidentified
I don't know.
rob noerr
For me, my advice on work is as follows.
Either get a job that you hate and pays you tons of money so you can live the exact life you want when you're not at work, or get a job that you love that makes enough so you can eat.
So if you're in a high-stress job and it's not paying you enough... Why are those the only options?
Well...
What do you want to do?
hannah claire brimelow
Look Libby, you're not a man.
You don't understand.
libby emmons
It's not easy to get a job that you hate that pays you a lot because to get a job that pays you a lot you have to do well at it.
To do well at something you have to like it at least a little.
rob noerr
Yeah, it's true.
But I think a lot of people get stuck in jobs that they hate, and it doesn't pay much.
libby emmons
Yeah, probably it doesn't pay much because you're working a job you hate.
Like, how are you ever going to advance if you're just like, God damn, I gotta get out of here.
liam cosgrove
Yeah, I think, if you want to de-stress, to Libby's point, you actually, you do have to advance.
So if you are in a job that you hate, and it pays poorly, what I would do, and it's not going to be an immediate fix, but like, go, like, get a side hustle, but like, not like a stupid, you know, I don't know, that phrase sounds stupid, but I mean like, go, Like, I didn't have a journalism background, but I kind of DM'd my way and worked my way into journalism by writing op-eds and things.
Do something like that where you're building something you are passionate about, and results will ease that stress for you when you actually get another job with something you like or something like that.
But hone your skills, become smarter, and, you know, that's really probably the only way to get out of it.
tim pool
The Cryogenic Drummer says, try a workout, Tim.
I've recently hired a personal trainer, and we're also doing work personal training sessions once a week.
And, uh, cause I skate all the time, so I got great legs, but I have zero upper body.
And so I was like, I've literally never done it.
And, you know, I was talking to the most trusted health professional in, in, uh, media, Joe Rogan, of course.
And he told me I had to lift.
He's like, you gotta start lifting, bro.
I was like, you gotta do it.
Keeps you young and all this other stuff.
And I was like, okay, so now I'm doing, uh, lifting and stuff.
And that makes you feel so good.
It's indescribable.
You know, I think the thing that never really got me when people were saying stuff like, do exercise and lift, is they always just be like, oh yeah, it's so good for you.
I'm like, it makes you feel euphoric.
Like, for like the hour or two after, you're floating.
It's remarkable.
And then the next day you wake up just feeling really good.
hannah claire brimelow
Well, in the words of Elle Woods, you know, exercise gives you endorphins, and endorphins make you happy, and happy people don't kill their husbands.
tim pool
That's true.
rob noerr
That's great.
tim pool
That's right.
Let's go!
Richard Cranium says, Tim, can I get a shoutout for my son Clayton?
Almost shared your birthday, born March 8th!
Wow, at 214!
Your talks on creating culture and shade trees made me realize children are how we make lasting change.
That is correct.
And then I always recommend...
Do not underestimate your children.
Children are not stupid, they have just not been programmed.
So, when you buy a brand new computer and it's got, you know, 10 terabytes or however many terabytes you put in it, the computer is no less good of a computer because you've never installed video games on it.
You guys just gotta do the work to install all the programs in the video games.
So, the mistake a lot of parents I see make is, I remember I was asking someone about their kid and if they were teaching him math or anything, like, ah, he's not ready for that, he's not smart enough.
And I was like, He won't be smart enough if you don't start teaching him.
hannah claire brimelow
He's definitely not now!
tim pool
Here's what happens.
People always have this incorrect statement.
The incorrect statement that it is easier for children to learn language.
That's just ridiculously not true.
They're like, oh it's easier for kids to learn how to speak a language and I'm like...
The child is surrounded by people speaking, and it takes them a couple of years to learn to speak, and they're still not articulate.
A human being, an adult human, can become fluent in a Rom- if you have a European-based language, Romance or Germanic, it takes an estimate, I believe it's 44 weeks.
of training to become fluent, conversational in everything.
And if you are a European and trying to learn an Asian language, Japanese, Chinese, Korean, Thai, etc.
It takes up to 80 or 90 weeks. It's more difficult because it's a different language structure.
But think about that.
In less than one year, an adult human can become totally fluent in another language.
So if you speak English, you want to learn Russian, if you are doing standard lessons, it takes you less than a year to do.
How long does it take a human to become fluent in a language?
Certainly a seven-year-old child can talk to you, But are they going to be able to articulate their thoughts about the intricacies of the politics in Lichtenstein or something like that?
Now, I'm not saying they have to know about the politics, but those words themselves.
So people are always like, kids learn language easier.
No, adults can learn language easier because they've been programmed, like we've developed those minds.
My ultimate point.
Get your kid on a skateboard, give your kid a baseball, give your kid a football, any kind of sport, and get them doing physical activity, mental activity, music, reading, all of it, and many parents will find, but my kid doesn't understand it.
Well, of course they don't.
They've never touched it before.
So, I think the first time I was ever shown a chess set, I was three years old.
I guarantee you, three-year-old Tim had no idea what was going on.
He was probably banging on the board and flipping pieces over.
But you just keep saying it.
This is the pawn.
This is what it does.
This is the rook.
This is what it does.
And then you build those neural pathways, so by the time the kid is old enough, they're really good.
This is why, you know, ask yourself, the professional baseball players, how old were they when they started playing baseball?
unidentified
Super young.
tim pool
Two or three?
And were they really even playing baseball?
unidentified
No.
tim pool
But, you know, they were being exposed to it.
So there you go.
All right, Christopher Back says, the only sol- or is it Backe?
The only solution is term limits.
Either commit to it or vote them out, all of them.
Yeah, I wish it were that easy, but there are challenges.
I think you- I think- check out the culture war episode we did with the former congressional staffers to understand the issue of term limits.
Because Congress is non-existent.
Don't- there's no Congress.
It's just pay-to-play.
rob noerr
I ran for Congress and it was a special election in 2019.
There was one county that split in half in Pennsylvania, so half of our election was.
And the other half that I wasn't running for, a man by the name of Glenn Thompson, he's the longest serving Republican in Pennsylvania.
When you went to that county, it was the only county that they told you, don't talk about term limits because they love Glenn and he would be out.
Every other county, they wanted to hear term limits, term limits.
And it was amazing to me because as some just, you know, novice Rube, I'm just saying off the cuff what I really believe.
And everyone else is thinking... Oh, that's your first mistake.
unidentified
Right!
libby emmons
Never say what you believe.
rob noerr
Whoopsie!
You know, everyone else knew.
Don't talk about term limits here.
tim pool
J. Joan Clark says, Whitney Webb tells all.
Tim should really have her on with Dr. Steven Greer, at least culture war.
unidentified
Agreed!
tim pool
Sounds good.
Alright, Cornelius says, if McAfee isn't going to dismiss the charges, the best thing he could do for Trump is leave Fannie on the case instead of allowing a different, possibly more competent DA to take over the case.
rob noerr
But it would delay.
That's why they're not doing it because they want to get it in as soon as possible.
They don't care if they win or not.
They just want to delay and interfere with the election.
tim pool
Max Reddick says, I remember Rob had a conversation with Destiny about Biden's business dealings.
He laid out the argument pretty well, but Destiny didn't buy it.
See, that's the issue with the left and the right.
We were talking about this earlier, the left will tell you things didn't happen, the right will agree on what happened, but disagree on what they mean.
I was thinking about this, and it's not absolute, but talking to Dave Smith, for instance, we're like, we agree X happened, and I'm like, yeah, but that will start to do Y, and he goes, no, Y's not gonna happen, it's gonna be Z!
And so it's like, we agree on reality, but what the probabilities are, are where we argue, and so we get along.
And then you see that clip with Destiny where he's like, they never said that vaccines were going to stop transmission.
And it's like, yes, yes, they did.
No, they didn't.
Yes, they did.
unidentified
No.
liam cosgrove
And then after the debate... Right, and then they play the montage of everybody saying it.
Yeah, exactly.
tim pool
But you can't play the montage when you're live on Piers Morgan, so when the Democrats lie...
rob noerr
Well, the mistake people make is when I'm arguing with Destiny, I'm not arguing for Trump against Biden.
I'm arguing against these bureaucratic institutions.
My argument is the FBI treated Biden differently when he was doing a quid pro quo with your tax dollars to fire a prosecutor looking into his son's company.
Once that prosecutor was fired, his son's company benefits immensely.
And Destiny and the left's argument is, but you don't have proof that he did it for that reason.
It's just coincidence that by firing that prosecutor, it ended up massively benefiting Hunter Biden's company.
And my argument is, why didn't the FBI look into this and have a commiserate investigation until they did the Donald Trump with Russia collusion?
tim pool
Well, what they're saying now is, look, we know that they called DC asking for help dealing with the prosecutor who was investigating this company.
And we know, several months later, Joe Biden flew there and said, if you don't fire the prosecutor, you're not getting the billion dollars.
rob noerr
Five days later.
tim pool
Five days later?
I thought it was like five months.
rob noerr
They said, according to Devin Archer, literally when he says, I heard them say, call DC, which Archer assumes was Joe Biden.
tim pool
It was five days later?
rob noerr
It was five days later he was on a plane.
And Biden's assistant has said on tape.
tim pool
Right, right, right.
But it wasn't, I'm pretty sure the, if you don't fire the prosecutors, you're not getting a billion dollars, was several months after.
rob noerr
Oh, no, no.
That was, he flew to Ukraine.
It was scheduled.
It was five days later.
Now he announced it in his famous Council on Foreign Relations speech months, like years ago.
tim pool
Right, right, right.
So then they go, and that may have all happened, but you can't prove that Biden was told to do it.
He did it for that reason.
And it's like, that's not how we handle adjudication here.
It's something called beyond a reasonable doubt.
rob noerr
I hate to wax on about this, but think about this.
They say that, well, just because it could have personally benefited Hunter Biden, that doesn't mean that's the reason that Joe Biden did it.
Therefore, no need for a special counsel.
And yet, if you remember, the special counsel under Trump of Mueller was appointed because every Democrat, every Republican said, fire James Comey.
Then they fired him and people said, yeah, but Trump did it for personal reasons, possibly.
So why doesn't that apply to Biden as well?
tim pool
Let's read some more.
We got Remi.
He says, Hi, Tim.
I'm getting married tomorrow.
I want to give a shout out to my beautiful wife, soon-to-be wife, Valencia.
I love you, baby.
Congratulations.
unidentified
Good sir.
libby emmons
That's so great.
hannah claire brimelow
That's so cute.
What a good use of a super chat.
I really like that.
libby emmons
That is really good.
tim pool
X Tin Man says, 30 plus years air traffic controller, retired.
These kinds of incidents have been happening forever.
The internet magnifies things.
rob noerr
Agreed.
hannah claire brimelow
Yeah, people definitely turn their attention and look.
Like when we had all the train wrecks.
unidentified
Yeah.
liam cosgrove
That's reassuring.
libby emmons
Muddy... Muddy... Yeah, there were a lot of train wrecks there for a minute.
hannah claire brimelow
But apparently there are thousands, like over a thousand every year.
tim pool
Muddy Drip says, Boeing employee here.
These issues coming up lately are maintenance issues by the airlines.
Check warranties on airplanes.
Interesting.
libby emmons
That's interesting too.
tim pool
I saw a viral video where someone- What did he say?
libby emmons
That the planes are getting- Warranties.
tim pool
It's the maintenance.
It's not the manufacturer.
It's the airlines aren't maintaining them properly.
liam cosgrove
Oh, okay.
libby emmons
There was a story- I did just say, yeah, I had to get my whole brakes fixed.
tim pool
There was a story at O'Hare when I worked there where a guy crashed a tug into a plane.
libby emmons
A tugboat?
tim pool
No, a tug.
libby emmons
What's a tug?
tim pool
Those are the things that they drive around in airports to pull bags and move things.
They're called tugs.
And if you've ever played GTA, you can drive a tug.
Anyway, I think what happened was he was not paying attention and he crashed into the back of a plane.
It basically destroys the plane.
You can't fly it anymore.
And so he just pretended to black out.
Yeah, so he just falls on the steering wheel and just sits there and waits.
And then someone comes out and they're like, what happened?
unidentified
And he's like, oh man, I must have blacked out.
tim pool
And so they can't do anything because it's a medical emergency.
If he said I wasn't paying attention, then they'd... Yeah, that was quick thinking by that guy.
liam cosgrove
It's actually pretty smart.
tim pool
I just blacked out.
Where we at?
Duty Ron says, Tim, I remember seeing you at the Occupy Wall Street movement in 2012.
I was an active NYPD detective.
Here, here, remember Hipster Cop?
He retired.
Do you guys know Hipster Cop?
libby emmons
No.
tim pool
He was a community affairs... community... I think it's community affairs?
I think he was a detective, but he wore these like...
Like, very fashionable outfits.
You know, I don't know how to describe it.
He had glasses and he was reported in the press as the hipster cop.
libby emmons
Was he wearing like, he wasn't wearing cop uniform, he was like a detective or something?
tim pool
Yeah.
libby emmons
Street clothes.
Wearing Versace out there.
tim pool
Hipster cop.
liam cosgrove
Like undercover at Occupy?
unidentified
See, I thought of Radio 911 when he said hipster cop.
I thought like kind of a crazy outfit, but I've never heard of him.
tim pool
Rick Lee.
Hipster cop.
Yeah, look him up.
You'll see the clothes he's wearing.
He was a celebrity.
He would walk around and like, the community of relations, the community affairs, NYPD, they're like supposed to try and talk and negotiate with protests and stuff like that.
And locals.
unidentified
Let's grab some more super chats while we're here.
tim pool
Beef Nasty says, Guys, Israel, Ukraine, Taiwan, Afghanistan, NATO, all of them.
Our dollar is backed by war, control of goods, it's simple yet complex.
Yup.
liam cosgrove
So he's in favor?
tim pool
I don't think he's saying he's in favor.
liam cosgrove
Okay.
I mean, I agree with him.
I would just let the dollar fall and also end the wars.
tim pool
Katie Maria says, Zion cast Tim getting so defensive of Israel as usual.
See, that's what I'm talking about.
When I'm like, I don't understand why we're funding Israel or any one of these other countries, and I don't care for any one of these singular countries.
I think we should stop funding all of it.
People go, you're defending Israel!
And I'm like, that's what I'm talking about.
liam cosgrove
Because, like... Well, Tim, to his point, I will say, I don't think you're Zio-cast, but I do think... Zion-cast.
Zion-cast.
tim pool
But, um... No, that's Don Shapiro.
liam cosgrove
So I remember when I was on here last time, you were ready, and we went in together on Zelensky and on Victoria Nuland and on the people who perpetrated the war in Ukraine.
I don't hear you going in on Israel in the same way.
I get that you're not against the funding, but you're a vehement critic of Zelensky.
Why not Netanyahu?
tim pool
Right now, what is, like, the principal war where we have a world leader with nuclear weapons threatening to nuke us right now?
liam cosgrove
But do you think Iran has any nuclear capabilities?
And I actually don't know.
I know that we've lied about it a lot.
tim pool
I know that we launched Stuxnet with Israel to blow up their nuclear capabilities.
And I know that while we are effectively in proxy war with Iran and have been trying to invade Iran, it's a huge, huge mistake.
I think we shouldn't be funding any of these foreign wars.
I think I'm tired of the moralizing on Israel-Palestine, and too many people are deeply obsessed with this one country.
liam cosgrove
Okay.
Fair enough.
I agree.
I mean, from nuclear weapons, from our standpoint, obviously... The moralizing is what bothers me the most.
Okay.
Let me ask you on the moralizing, why does that bother you?
tim pool
It's an obsession.
liam cosgrove
But if it's true that it's a moral atrocity, why are you angry at the people trying to make that case?
tim pool
How many people have been killed in China?
We are Muslims.
liam cosgrove
People make that case too.
tim pool
List to me the atrocities of the world.
Tell me why I should care about one over the other.
liam cosgrove
Well, because one, we're funding, and that's the one that Israel's perpetrating.
tim pool
Sudan.
liam cosgrove
We're also funding that one.
It's smaller and less people know about it, but it's the same sort of thing.
The issue with Sudan is that people should be angrier about the atrocities that they're being forced to fund.
tim pool
And that's why it's like, I don't care for any one of them.
Stop spending the money.
The Sudan thing is not like we're funding war, although I think it's fair to say you can look in the budget and see that we are, but a billion dollars in quote-unquote developmental assistance?
I'm like, is that what they call War funding?
You know what I mean?
liam cosgrove
Right.
And so then, in Israel's case, 14 times that just in the last year.
But if you go back decades, it's probably way more.
So, wouldn't that therefore anger you more?
tim pool
No.
My point is, someone goes, hey, should we be funding Israel?
unidentified
No.
tim pool
And they go, okay.
And then they go, should we be funding Ukraine?
I go, no.
I say, should we be funding Taiwan?
No.
Sudan?
No.
And then they go, do you know how many kids are being killed every single day in Israel and I'm like, do you know how
many kids are being killed in Sudan?
They go, no. And I'm like, why are you coming to me every day with this one place and knowing
liam cosgrove
nothing about anything else? Well, then in that case, I would say look more, you should have
Whitney Webb on like that guy said, it's a great idea. And look more into the Epstein-Massad
theory. And, you know, like, for example, Alex Acosta said he belonged to intelligence when he
Dershowitz got that deal.
Dershowitz also got the dancing Israelis off.
People know about that.
Dershowitz said on Kim Iverson's show, oh, I've been working for the state of Israel long before you were born.
libby emmons
Well, he's a defense attorney.
tim pool
Dude, I just got to tell you.
liam cosgrove
There's more than what I just said.
I mean, there's the Robert Maxwell, who was literally Mossad and was like an arms trafficker for Israel.
tim pool
Here's what I think.
liam cosgrove
He's Ghislaine's dad.
So my point is, you should look into things like that and realize they do have a lot of influence over this country, and that would anger you more to be exploited, presumably.
tim pool
I think Israel hires all of the anti-Israel people on purpose to create this faction of incessant annoying people on Twitter to push as many people as possible away from the issue.
liam cosgrove
There's a difference between Sudan and Israel.
I'm sorry that my arguments aren't working on you.
tim pool
I would equate the Ron DeSantis supporters with the anti-Israel faction on X. It's like this weird, vicious, pitbull-biting, snarling intensity.
liam cosgrove
I'm not trying to do that with you.
Have I done that tonight?
tim pool
I'm not trying to.
The point I'm bringing up with you is that Like right now, if we're objectively analyzing global conflict, Ukraine receives the most money.
It's a direct conflict between NATO and a nuclear power.
liam cosgrove
I agree with you on all this.
tim pool
And it is the most pressing military threat.
And you made an atrocity moral argument about Israel without knowing the same details about Ukraine.
I'm not saying you're not allowed to make that argument, I'm saying... I didn't know the exact number of civilians killed.
liam cosgrove
And my point is... But last year I could have... I mean, like, that doesn't debunk, like, you know, the whole argument.
tim pool
Debunk?
I didn't say debunk.
I said, what I see is, for some reason, a hyper-fixation from too many people on one country, when the United States is spending combined untold billions all over this planet on things we should not, And when you go to someone... Alex Jones, I saw him on C-SPAN a long time ago.
And this was probably like in 2008 or something.
And I can't remember what it was, but the camera guy, the guy reporting was like, oh we've got Alex Jones.
And he goes to the camera and starts screaming, PEOPLE YOU AREN'T LISTENING TO ME!
rob noerr
THEY'RE COMING HERE TO TAKE YOUR MONEY!
tim pool
THEY'RE TAKING YOUR INCOME!
And I was like, well, he just lost every single person he could have convinced.
liam cosgrove
No, I totally agree with that.
That's a great point.
rob noerr
Can I give you two other examples of things that are different?
One, example one could be, and you tell me what you think of this, if the U.S.
wasn't funding Israel, they would still be bombing Gaza.
Whereas in Ukraine, if we weren't funding, they would have to come to the negotiating table.
liam cosgrove
No, I actually disagree.
I think if we didn't, I mean, Ron Paul, also a courageous man when he was in the Congress, was actually willing to criticize Israel.
He made the argument that actually if we cut off all funding to Israel, they might start playing nice with their neighbors because right now they know that the U.S., even more so than Ukraine, they know that the U.S.
is going to back them in a big regional war.
So no, I think if we actually cut them off, they would perhaps stop bombing.
rob noerr
I don't think it's as clear as Ukraine.
The other thing I'll say real quick is there are people in positions of power and certainly in certain cultural institutions that are on both sides of the Israel-Palestine debate.
That's not the case with Ukraine.
When we talk about Ukraine, it's because there is near uniformity from the left, from the right, from every institution, from students to entertainers.
It's all, we gotta back Ukraine, we gotta back Ukraine.
Whereas Israel-Palestine, you get lost in the shuffle.
liam cosgrove
Like Chuck Schumer's out there.
rob noerr
Chuck Schumer's out there today saying, we need to get rid of Bibi.
Like, so it's not as if they're all in lockstep.
In Ukraine, it's like everyone's in lockstep, so you need a countervailing force.
liam cosgrove
There are, like, lefties in the media that, you know, still have influence.
We give money to 179 foreign countries.
unidentified
Oh, it's wild.
liam cosgrove
But Tim, what I would ask you is, do you not see the shift from Ukraine to Israel in kind of the U.S.
foreign policy circles?
That there is, and it's been harder for Ukraine to get the funding now because Israel's also on the tip.
Do you not see that shift?
And does that not kind of make you go, oh, Ukraine might be winding down?
tim pool
Did you know that the U.S.
reduced its orders for ordinance?
Is this like an executive order from the Biden administration?
ordinance for desert conflict and switched it to Pacific conflict.
liam cosgrove
Is this like an executive order from the Biden administration?
tim pool
There was a military budget.
liam cosgrove
I can see in the zeitgeist that there is a shift to the Indo-Pacific for sure.
tim pool
So it's not Israel.
It may shift now because...
How about I finish?
liam cosgrove
I agree.
tim pool
It may shift to Israel because of what's going on, but in the mid to end of last year, the reporting that we covered was the U.S.
had been ordering large amounts of missiles specifically for the weaponry that we have in the Middle East, and they reduced dramatically those purchases and shifted towards naval weaponry and ordnance.
leading many analysts to indicate the US is gearing up for conflict with China over Taiwan,
especially with the treaty that we have with the treaty we had with Australia,
the deployment of US personnel and as well to the to the Indo-Pacific. So that seems to be their
main play. Plus, with the concern over Thucydides trap and the likelihood of conflict with China,
that seems to make a lot more sense, especially considering China is a nuclear power,
has been working with Russia.
We now have this two-pronged front where Israel is a regional conflict, which may rope in another one of the BRICS allies, Iran.
That is still secondary.
In fact, it may be a third step.
From Ukraine and Russia, then China, Taiwan, and then Israel.
So based on purchasing, based on scale, and based on historical precedent, it seems the bigger conflict is going to be China-Taiwan.
liam cosgrove
I agree.
China-Taiwan is by far the scariest.
The bright side is it hasn't started yet.
I mean, your point of Israel is more underway, like a potential conflict with Iran is more underway than China-Taiwan, but I agree with you.
If you listen to like Uh, bipartisan foreign policy staff.
They are, like, the focus is on 100% China, and that would be by far the worst.
I mean, the U.S.
in a direct hot war with China, um, would be terrible, and we would all agree on that, so that's scary, and I hope we avoid it, but I really want to avoid all three, because all three can go nuclear, potentially.
Um, Iran's perhaps in the form of, like, a dirty nuke or something like that, but... Agreed.
It's terrifying, and we should avoid all of these things.
Um, so, you know, I can't disagree with what you just said.
tim pool
My final point on this is that there are a lot of people, if you go on X, Where it's just like, holy shit, dude, calm down.
unidentified
What the fuck?
liam cosgrove
Well, there is literal, like, anti-semitism, too, where it's like, you know, they take the charts of the Jews and, you know, and media and all that stuff.
tim pool
There are people who, like, their emotions go from zero to eleven when the issue comes up, and they start bashing their faces figuratively against the table when it's like no other issue causes that.
But, I want to read one last super chat.
This was interesting.
TRD says, New York Post, Don Lemon demanded Cybertruck $5 million advance, equity in X, before Elon Musk canned him.
Fact check confirmed!
New York Post reports, Don Lemon demanded Tesla Cybertruck $5 million advance, equity in X, before Elon Musk canned him.
So it's no wonder why Don Lemon was told to screw off.
Uh, wow.
My friends, if you haven't already, would you kindly smash that like button, subscribe to this channel, share the show with your friends, become a member by going to TimCast.com and clicking join us to support our work directly.
It's been a great week.
We're really excited for all the new stuff.
The skate park is officially done.
The main move will be, um, I believe the week of April 8th may be the official launch at the new studio, so we're really excited for that.
And you can follow the show at TimCastIRL.
You can follow me personally at TimCast.
Liam, you want to shout anything out?
liam cosgrove
You can follow me at at Cosgrove underscore IV on Twitter.
I wish we'd talked about the TikTok bill.
I think it would have been more fun and less, you know, high stakes.
If you go to my Twitter right now, you will see Tucker Carlson just tweeted a video of me giving Dan Crenshaw a hard time on the Hill.
That's kind of what I do is, you know, go to the Hill and interview congressmen and then go to press briefings in DC and stuff.
Um, you can find me there, and sadly we didn't get to argue about TikTok, but off-air, Tim and I were going at it on that too, so... Well, Tucker said Biden would have the power to ban any news site that challenges him, and that's factually false.
tim pool
I think that's... Fact check false.
liam cosgrove
I don't know if we have time to do this, maybe we can do it in the... I'll keep it simple for you.
tim pool
He can't ban any website.
liam cosgrove
Well he can actually, so if they have a million monthly users and only one user has to post stuff and be able to contribute, so that could be a new site.
I mean if you have a million monthly users, which isn't that hard.
tim pool
So first, not any, that's factually false.
Secondly, it doesn't ban the site, it requires a forced divestment.
I've estimate within six months and it has judicial is a judicial review
process as authoritarian and it's it's to say outright the bill allows Biden to
do this my argument is it would be like going Donald Trump is a nationalist and
he is also a white man therefore he's a white nationalist and it's like okay
well that's like technically semantically true that's not real but
liam cosgrove
it okay so any not any a month a million monthly users but that like if you add
the a million monthly users caveat it is a true statement.
tim pool
And it has to be connected to one of four countries.
liam cosgrove
There's... Yeah, but that's up to their, that's up to their claim to make.
It just says controlled or at the direction of some other countries.
And you have, and... They said that about zero hedge in 2022 when the war broke out.
tim pool
And then you have to look at legal jurisprudences to whether someone can functionally just claim and it becomes legal.
It doesn't.
We know that with Trump and the insurrection clause in the 14th amendment.
So, none of that even matters.
liam cosgrove
You have a chance to petition it, but the president can claim that you're at the direction of Iran and can ban your thing.
Here's my point.
tim pool
Two-state.
The bill would give Biden the power to ban any news website that challenges him is factually incorrect.
liam cosgrove
With a million plus viewers?
tim pool
No, it's factually incorrect.
liam cosgrove
If you add the a million plus, how is it incorrect?
tim pool
And I could be a millionaire tomorrow if I buy a lottery ticket.
liam cosgrove
A million monthly users is not that much.
tim pool
A million monthly users, I mean like... Yeah, I'm not even arguing the subparagraphs.
liam cosgrove
What else do you need in addition to a million monthly users for that statement to be correct?
tim pool
He cannot ban any website that challenges him.
liam cosgrove
Okay, he can force them to divest.
tim pool
He can try to force certain websites to divest from resources and assets pertaining to one of four countries that have already been codified by Congress.
liam cosgrove
If he claims that the news organization is at the direction or control of one of those countries.
tim pool
Which doesn't change anything I said.
It is factually incorrect to say that Biden could ban any, any, any.
We're done.
rob noerr
Hey!
Yeah, that was round two.
We got to hear that earlier tonight, too.
So yeah, my name's Rob Noor.
N-O-E-R-R.
I am a conservative debater.
I stream on Rumble, Twitch, YouTube.
You can find me if you look up my name, Rob Noor, in any of those places.
I love taking and wrecking these left-wing streamers that think that they're somehow impressive debaters.
They're not.
I focus on corruption and sort of the two-tier justice system to me more than any individual politician, Biden, Trump, Hillary, whoever.
These institutions that exist in perpetuity that put their thumbs on the scale are more of a threat to our country than any individual politician.
And so that's what I like to focus on.
I was honored to come on here.
I enjoyed this thoroughly.
Thank you so much for having me.
Hope to do it again.
tim pool
Absolutely.
liam cosgrove
I should say that as well.
I really do appreciate, and I know I've been argumentative and all that, but I really appreciate the invite.
Thank you, Cassandra, for inviting me on.
unidentified
No, I agree.
liam cosgrove
Come back anytime.
I've had a lot of fun.
I'm not trying to lie in terms of this TikTok bill.
But anyways, I really appreciate it.
tim pool
I'll make one last point on the TikTok bill.
liam cosgrove
And great to meet you three also in person for the first time.
I'm sorry I've monopolized here.
I'm an argumentative guy.
tim pool
My last point on the TikTok bill.
Yuri Bezmenov warned that communists are going to try to indoctrinate our youth and manipulate them.
TikTok is the clearest example of them doing that.
For some reason, people are against Yuri Bezmenov's warning at this point, which doesn't quite make sense.
And I see the likes of Tucker Carlson and many other personalities coming out without actually breaking down the full context of the bill.
And saying things that I believe are gross misrepresentations or extreme exaggerations of what is likely going to happen.
Where the argument turns into, but the government is corrupt and does corrupt things.
To which my response is, LavaBit was an email service provider that was providing secure services.
The NSA approached them with a national security letter in 2013 and they were forced to shut down or comply with the government.
This bill does not give more power to the already near-absolute powers the government has, including the Obama NDAA indefinite detention provision, which allows them to hold secret military tribunals to rendition you in the middle of the night to an offshore location where you could disappear forever, and they claim that's been codified by Congress.
This bill is stamp collecting relative to what the deep state and the security intelligence agencies already have.
And that being said, Hannah Clare, you want to shout anything out?
hannah claire brimelow
Hey, I'm Hannah-Claire Brimlow.
I'm so happy I got to be here so much this week.
It's been fun to see everyone.
Of course, you should absolutely follow at TimCastNews on Twitter and Instagram because that's where Scanner's news work goes out.
I posted a, you know, it's Women's History Month.
None of the men in this room acknowledge that tonight, but I have a profile up about Melissa Mayer, the former CEO of Yahoo and the controversies she caused among working moms.
So please go check that out.
I don't know if it's up yet, but it should be up soon.
If you want to follow me personally, I'm on Twitter, I'm on Instagram at HannahClare.B.
Libby, so fun to see you!
libby emmons
It's great to see you guys.
Great to be here tonight.
You can find me at LibbyEmmons on Twitter, and you can check out all the great work we're doing at thepostmillennial.com and humanevents.com.
liam cosgrove
Tim, real question on the communism thing, to fight communism.
I will ask this question, then I won't argue.
Sir, I have a life, I have to go home.
Tim, don't you think it is kind of a communist tactic to be banning, you know, a platform that millions of people are using to, you know, post things and interact?
tim pool
No.
liam cosgrove
That's not a communist tactic, banning a speech platform.
tim pool
If China was selling designer drugs to our children, I'd say we should ban that product.
And then if they came out and said, yeah, but it's not illegal in the United States, I'd be like, then we should make it illegal.
You're selling drugs to our kids.
I don't understand the issue of, like, this country is our enemy who has, like, tried to destroy us, and is super corrupt, and is undermining our trade policy, our foreign policy, they're buying up our farmland, they're gutting us from the inside out.
We desperately need to take action against them, and the only reason action can be taken now is because Democrats love Israel so much they agreed to finally sign onto a bill that would do something about it.
I'm also seeing tons of personalities sharing the Restrict Act, trying to claim that's the actual bill, and that's just like, why are so many people posting false things about this?
I can only conclude that some people genuinely don't like the bill, I can respect that.
Some people don't understand they're being misled and they're sharing provisions from the restrict deck, which is wrong, or they're sharing only snippets.
But I also do believe it is a fact.
It is a fact that TikTok has been sending push notifications and telling people to go out and advocate and defend their platform.
That is an example of an exertion of authority of a foreign power against us, which I think is horrifying.
unidentified
But That being said, I think diplomacy can work with China.
liam cosgrove
China the solution to Tim's point.
I think diplomacy can work, but I won't argue any further.
unidentified
We don't have an after show on Fridays, but what you guys should do as soon as we wrap is go over to Tenet Media and watch the Culture War, which we had with Rob this morning.
Great conversation.
You guys can follow me at kellenpdl and happy Friday.
liam cosgrove
All right.
tim pool
That wraps it up then, right?
All right, everybody.
We'll see you all on Monday.
Thanks for hanging out.
unidentified
Done.
Export Selection