All Episodes
Sept. 30, 2020 - The Joe Rogan Experience
02:34:25
Joe Rogan Experience #1543 - Brian Muraresku & Graham Hancock
Participants
Main voices
b
brian muraresku
01:14:20
g
graham hancock
38:11
j
joe rogan
39:05
Appearances
Clips
a
andy stumpf
00:01
| Copy link to current segment

Speaker Time Text
joe rogan
Joe Rogan Podcast, check it out The Joe Rogan Experience Training by day, Joe Rogan Podcast by night, all day Joining us by Skype is the great and powerful Graham Hancock, my friend How are you, sir?
graham hancock
Hi, Joe.
It's really good to be back with you.
I wish I could be there in person.
It feels very strange to be on this technology, but these are the times we live in.
joe rogan
Yeah, well, I'm just happy we could talk at all in this day and age.
Me too.
It's the little things, like little victories.
And Brian, I'm going to try it.
I'm going to try it.
Murarescu.
brian muraresku
You nailed it, bro.
joe rogan
Thank you.
This is the first time we've ever done one of these as well in the studio where one, maybe ever, visual.
We've never done one.
We did one with you guys.
Remember we did Randall Carlson?
graham hancock
Yeah, and Mark Defant came in by telephone, I think.
unidentified
Yes.
joe rogan
Which was very strange It was like a sound coming from nowhere At least I could see you But we've never done one of these like this But this book Tell me This is the immortality key The secret history of religion Of the religion with no name I'll say it again The secret history of the religion with no name Now this is Obviously when I found out the subject matter Graham this is right up your alley And it made total complete sense Why you and Brian worked together on this
So, who wants to start and explain?
Graham, why don't we have you start, since you're over there in the UK? Yeah, absolutely.
graham hancock
Well, I mean, for me, in fact, Joe, I think you and I originally got in touch because of my interest in psychedelics in human culture and a book that I published in 2006 called Supernatural, which looks at the huge role that psychedelics have played in cultures and in religions all around the world.
And I touched in that book on the role of psychedelics in the origins of Christianity.
Which of course is a dynamite subject.
And what Brian has done in the Immortality Key has been to present hard and fast evidence that the first Christians were using psychedelics and that their religious experiences were mediated by psychedelic experiences.
joe rogan
And Brian, how did you get involved in this?
brian muraresku
It's a long story.
joe rogan
You look like a stoner, by the way.
I'll just tell you right now.
You look like a guy who's done a few mushrooms in his day.
brian muraresku
Oddly enough, I don't do drugs, and I've never done psychedelics.
graham hancock
Wow!
brian muraresku
Yeah.
joe rogan
That's crazy.
unidentified
Yeah.
joe rogan
You want to start?
brian muraresku
Today?
joe rogan
Well, I wish we were in LA. I could hook you up.
But in Texas, the laws are sketchier here.
What led you to this, then?
brian muraresku
I was fascinated by Graham's work, which I only came across about 12 years ago.
I was a Latin, Greek, and Sanskrit undergrad major.
And instead of getting the PhD or becoming a priest, which are the two options when you study Latin and Greek, I went to law school instead.
For no reason whatsoever.
And then wound up at a law firm and a couple years into it started reading about these psilocybin studies coming out of Hopkins and NYU. And that amazing statistic that two-thirds of the participants were describing it as one of the most amazing experiences of their lives.
And it hit me that there was something there because the testimony coming out of Hopkins and NYU in a very clinical setting immediately reminded me of what I heard about Eleusis.
And for those who don't know what Eleusis is, it's essentially the spiritual capital of the ancient world.
It was where the best and brightest of Athens and Rome went to essentially meet a goddess in the flesh and have this mind-blowing visionary experience.
So before Jerusalem, before Rome, before Mecca, there was Eleusis, and for some reason we're not taught about this in our high school mythology or Western Civ classes, but it was there that Plato Cicero, Marcus Aurelius all went to drink a magical potion and, in their words, have this vision, what Plato calls a blessed sight and vision, the holiest of mysteries, in which they claim to have a direct encounter with the goddess and completely eradicate their fear of death.
It was very similar to what the volunteers are saying with their single experience of psilocybin.
joe rogan
Now, with Eleusis, how much history do we have?
How much recorded history that documents these rituals?
And is there any that describes the actual contents of this mixture?
brian muraresku
No, there isn't much.
I mean, I say Eleusis is like the fight club of the ancient world.
The first rule about Eleusis is you don't talk about Eleusis.
You know, all we have is this fragmentary testimony, again, from Plato, Pindar, Sophocles, and others.
They do talk about a vision that's almost universal, and they almost universally talk about this once-in-a-lifetime transformative event where they become initiates, and only they properly have life after death.
Because at the time, the Greeks didn't really look forward to the afterlife.
In fact, there was no afterlife.
You just disappear into Hades to do God knows what.
But people walk away from Eleusis saying that they'd found salvation.
And we don't know why or how.
We know this potion is involved.
We know they make this pilgrimage 13 miles from Athens to Eleusis to drink this potion.
We know they prepare for months, if not years, before it, and they're forever changed afterwards.
But we have very little hard data to actually look into it.
And so in 1978, this trio of renegades, Gordon Wasson, Albert Hoffman, who discovered LSD, and Karl Ruck, who was then the chair of the classics department at Boston University, they put out this book, The Road to Eleusis, claiming they'd found the secret after 2,000 years.
And what they claimed is that this potion was actually spiked with ergot.
Which is that naturally occurring fungus from which you can synthesize LSD. And in fact, it's where Albert, it's how he synthesized LSD by accident in 1938 with cultures of ergot.
joe rogan
We've talked about ergot before in this podcast, connecting it to the Salem witch trials, which is very speculative, but they think there's real evidence that shows that there was a late frost during the time of the Salem witch trials that probably led to mold growth on their wheat, which probably led to ergot infestation of their food.
And so these poor people were, you know, unintentionally eating acid.
brian muraresku
Unintentionally.
It happened a lot.
There were ergot outbreaks across time, especially in the Middle Ages.
They would call it St. Anthony's Fire, the Ignis Saker, because it's so, so common.
In fact, if you talk to any brewer today, at least the brewers that I was talking to, I went to...
See this beer scientist in Munich, Germany, Martin Zarnkow.
And he says, you can't avoid it.
Now, it's more common on things like rye, but it also pops up on barley and wheat, too.
And again, it's unavoidable, and it's highly, highly toxic.
The question is, does it really produce the kind of vision, the visionary experiences that people have on psilocybin, LSD, mescaline, and others?
According to Albert Hoffman, absolutely.
So as a matter of fact, I went into the Harvard archives, where Wasson's papers are kept to this day in the botany libraries.
And I found a letter that Albert wrote Gordon, his co-author, in 1976, saying that Albert had self-experimented with Ergonavine, which is one of these alkaloids in ergot.
And he claimed, in 1976, it was five to ten times more potent than psilocybin.
joe rogan
It's fascinating to me that these cultures seem to have hid some of these rituals, and this goes back to really as far back as we have recorded psychedelic use, like Soma.
We still to this day don't know what that is, and it's described in these incredible ways in ancient Hindu texts, but we don't know what it is.
brian muraresku
We have an idea.
I actually brought some Sanskrit to show you.
You want to see some Sanskrit?
joe rogan
Hell yeah.
Can you put it up on the screen?
brian muraresku
It's under the Soma tab.
joe rogan
Oh, look at how beautiful that is.
brian muraresku
There it is.
joe rogan
Their language, writing it in Sanskrit, God, it's so pretty.
brian muraresku
Do you want me to read it for you?
joe rogan
Please, you can read that?
brian muraresku
Yeah.
So this was my major in college.
So in the very middle there, you can see, Imam Mindra Gavashira Yavashira Channa Pisha Akkatyavarshabihi Sutama.
And what he's saying there is this is from the Rig Veda, right?
And it's the oldest literature in Western civilization.
We think it's among the Indo-European languages, it's the oldest recorded literature that we have.
It could be 1500 BC, 1700, perhaps much earlier, like the Iliad and the Odyssey in Greek.
This is the mother tongue of all the Indo-European languages.
And what they write about a lot is Soma, which is both a god and the juice that is pressed from this god.
And what they're talking about there is making this ritual potion, very much like the kukion that we find among the ancient Greeks.
And here, Soma is described as a mixed potion.
Yavashira means mixed with barley.
Gavashira, from Sanskrit go, gava is milk, mixed with milk.
And so I've read all the theories that you have about what Soma was, whether it was the Amanita muscaria mushroom or some psilocybin-containing species or DMT. The way that they describe Soma here is always a mixed potion.
So in this case, mixed with barley and milk.
joe rogan
So that would be an ergot, some sort of...
brian muraresku
Already they're mentioned, I mean, and so that's what Rock Hoffman and Wasson were saying in 1978. We have literature from the 7th century BC, it's called the hymn to Demeter, where they record these ingredients of what the kukion was.
You ask, like, where's the actual evidence?
So in the 70s, we didn't have much.
It starts with the literature, which is what classicists do.
And so there's this hymn to Demeter that was discovered in 1777, a year after we declare our independence from Graham's people.
And what they found in there in line...
Sorry, Graham.
unidentified
We're in Texas, man.
graham hancock
Absolutely.
Well done.
I'm all for independence.
I'd like to be independent of my own country, if possible, as well.
brian muraresku
Well, Texas is taking refugees at the moment, is it not?
joe rogan
Well, that's what's happening here.
That's why we're here.
We're refugees from the country of California.
brian muraresku
Exactly.
joe rogan
The nation-state of California.
So, why do we know why they combined it with milk?
Was it just so that it was easier to consume?
brian muraresku
That's what we don't know.
We don't know why the kukion was this mixed thing either.
But so in the hymn to Demeter, they record these ingredients.
It's alfi, which is barley, hudor, which is water, and blechon, which means mint.
And that's all we had.
joe rogan
So it doesn't say milk?
You didn't say milk?
brian muraresku
That was in soma.
joe rogan
In soma.
brian muraresku
Yeah.
joe rogan
Oh, I'm sorry.
brian muraresku
Which they mix with all kinds of things.
And not just barley and milk, but also honey.
As a matter of fact, soma is often identified with madhu, which is honey in Sanskrit.
joe rogan
McKenna speculated that there was a transfer in culture of psychedelic-based culture to an alcohol-based culture.
Based on climate change and also based on preserving things in honey, and that honey would create mead, and mead, which if people don't know, is an alcohol beverage that's actually made with honey.
Do you think that this was the case with the use of honey as well, that it's used as a preservative, or was it used to make it taste better, more palatable?
brian muraresku
We don't know.
That's the problem.
When we're talking about ancient plants and fungi, plants especially, we don't know what plants they're talking about.
So the ancient literature records all kinds of plants across the language.
graham hancock
If I could jump in, Joe, you're absolutely right.
There was secrecy that surrounded the use of these potions in the ancient world.
There's a case from Athens of the potion from Eleusis being used for recreational purposes, and this is roundly condemned.
By all concerned, that it should only be used for the sacred and spiritual purposes of which it was intended.
So there was a great deal of secrecy that surrounded the use of these potions, and the potions were a doorway or a gateway into another level of reality.
And what's fascinating from Eleusis and many other ancient accounts is the way that people come back having lost their fear of death, that they don't regard death as the end anymore.
It's just another stage on the journey, just the beginning of the next great adventure.
And Brian is absolutely right to draw attention to the modern work with psilocybin.
And again, we find people who are terminal cases, who are imminently facing death, losing their fear of death as a result of using psilocybin.
So we can begin to see connections between what we understand about these extraordinary substances in the modern world and how the ancient world used them.
joe rogan
That does seem to be a universal theme, this theme of alleviating the fear of death.
And this comes up constantly with people that I know personally that have had these psychedelic experiences.
They say, well, I feel like I went to heaven, or I feel like now I understand why people believe there's this perfect afterlife, that I've actually experienced it.
graham hancock
A lot of the critics will say that it's some kind of natural human tendency that we don't want to die and that we're afraid of death and that religions provide us with some sort of solace, some sort of feeling of security.
But I don't think that washes at all.
I think what's striking about the psychedelic It's a direct experience that the person has.
They have an experience.
It's not a teaching.
It's not something that they're told about.
It's not a scripture that they read.
It's an experience that they have.
And that experience eliminates the fear of death.
I think Brian, by the way, having written The Immortality Key, for which I've only provided the foreword, I think Brian is absolutely right to be a psychedelic virgin.
In my case, because I have used psychedelics and many other substances, a lot of my critics just try to write off all my work, whether it's on lost civilizations or on psychedelics, they try to write it all off as the rantings of a sort of drug-fueled maniac.
And I think it's very smart of Brian not to put himself in that situation.
I hope he will work with psychedelics in the future, but I think he was right not to work with psychedelics before writing this book and to concentrate on the evidence.
joe rogan
Well, Michael Pollan, who later in life experienced psychedelics and wrote pretty brilliantly about them, for me, he's one of the more interesting people to discuss it because Michael's an investigative journalist.
He takes deep dives into these subjects and his deep dive into psychedelics was incredibly illuminating.
And so for him, I really enjoyed talking to him about it and I really enjoyed his book as well.
His perceptions of it were really unique because you're talking about a guy who lived his whole life without them, you know, and then really dove head first for his book.
graham hancock
It's kind of what happened to me when I wrote Supernatural.
Apart from one experience with LSD in 1974, I hadn't used any psychedelics until I began to research Supernatural back in the early 2000s.
And because I'm a kind of boots on the ground researcher, I felt it was essential that I have these experiences.
What I couldn't guess was the way that the experiences would utterly change and transform my life.
And I can understand from a level of personal experience why psychedelics do lie at the root, I think, of all the world's religions.
And those religions are now busily at work trying to deny that connection.
joe rogan
Well, they're not just trying to do it.
There's many people in science that are trying to deny these connections, too.
And it's so unfortunate that the people that are trying to deny these connections or the significance of these experiences haven't had them.
I don't think anybody who has a dimethyltryptamine experience can just dismiss it as being no big deal.
It's too crazy.
You need to do it, sir.
unidentified
Yeah.
joe rogan
This guy.
Just the fact that it's one of those things where everyone who does it comes out of it saying, I can't believe that's real.
I can't believe you can just get there that quickly.
Three puffs and all of a sudden you're in Narnia.
We're way more intense than Narnia.
graham hancock
You're in Narnia and you're in a place where entities are actually communicating with you and speaking to you and teaching to you.
This is another aspect of psychedelics is the moral aspect of psychedelics.
Critics and enemies of psychedelics want to associate them with some kind of immorality, but actually anybody who's worked extensively with psychedelics will know that they contain moral teachings.
Whether it's the mushrooms or whether it's LSD, they cause us to examine our own behavior, our own impact upon others, to question our unkindness to others, and to give us at least the push To begin to be better people and more nurturing and more caring people for others.
So this strong moral element in psychedelics again is totally ignored by the critics who just want to demonize these substances for reasons that I think are rather sinister actually.
joe rogan
I think our current culture lacks a map of the territory and if we had like some sort of legitimate psychedelic counseling where we could go somewhere and experts both in pharmacology and in medical science can talk people through these experiences And help them, achieve them, and get people to realize that, you know, much like the ancients, these experiences are not, it's not wise to use them recreationally.
I mean, you can if you want.
I mean, many people have and then inadvertently benefited from them greatly.
But I think they're very profound.
And I think they should be treated like, almost like you've got a Willy Wonka golden ticket to go meet God.
Because that's what it seems like.
It's It seems like it's happening.
brian muraresku
It was for the ancients.
graham hancock
It should be treated with respect.
joe rogan
Yeah.
graham hancock
It should be treated with respect and with reverence because of this sense that we're passing through a doorway into a seamlessly convincing parallel reality and the possibility that that isn't just a concoction of our brains, that the brains are simply acting as an interface or a transceiver between us and that other I think
it should be obligatory.
That they have at least a dozen sessions with a powerful psychedelic.
It can be DMT, it can be ayahuasca, it can be LSD. But they've got to go through those dozen sessions.
They should be guided by experienced practitioners.
And at the end of those dozen sessions, I very much doubt if those individuals would be the same individuals who went into the application for the job in the first place.
joe rogan
No, I don't think you could be the same.
When you write about all this, how curious are you personally of the experience and do you plan on having it?
brian muraresku
I do, under the conditions that you set.
I mean, I think that we're in a period now where everything is about to change.
Mm-hmm.
And what I look forward to is maybe in 10 years' time or less, these retreat centers, which are licensed and regulated with professional staff and medical supervised staff who essentially guide people through what would be a novel initiation experience, not unlike what may have happened 2,700 years ago.
joe rogan
I'm hoping they're going to be backdoored in as therapy for people with pre-existing conditions that we have right now, like opioid addiction, Iboga, like Ibogaine being introduced, and MDMA for people with post-traumatic stress disorder, for soldiers, because there's been so much real solid evidence that it's incredibly beneficial to these people.
Particularly the opioid crisis.
I mean, we have a real problem in this country with people being addicted to these pills and then wind up dying from them.
That can be nipped in the bud like really effectively with Ibogaine.
And the fact that you have to leave the country to have these Ibogaine experiences is really, it's a terrible statement on the rational thinking of our culture today.
Because it's not like these are unknown things.
We're talking about it right now on a podcast that millions of people are listening to.
And we've talked about it dozens of times in the past.
And it's something that scientists are aware of, researchers are aware of, and particularly people who have come back from there and have had these experiences and have been cured of their addictions.
It literally rewires the way the brain interfaces with these opioids.
And the fact that it's not available to people and they have to go through traditional counseling and benefit from their willpower and somehow or another try not to relapse, it's terrible.
brian muraresku
Or even just mitigating some of that, even cannabis, for example, which can mitigate.
Some of those addictive potentials.
Yes.
I worked with athletes, for example, which might interest you.
So I represented a guy named Mike James, who was an NFL player, who we believe is the first professional athlete in the U.S. to seek a therapeutic use exemption from the NFL to get off his opioids and use cannabis instead.
And we were there at 51st and Park Avenue at NFL headquarters, arbitrating with the NFL to try and get him a cannabis supply.
And he lost.
And he was fined six figures in the process, and he left the league because of it.
joe rogan
he's not the first one right wasn't there was a who's the other Jamie, you're a football fan.
Who's the other famous football player who couldn't kick the weed?
Ricky Williams.
That's right, Ricky Williams.
brian muraresku
He never sought a TUE, though.
It was unthinkable to get a TUE at the time.
joe rogan
But it's amazing that the NFL would have a problem with marijuana when so many of those guys are on pills.
I mean, some of those guys are so severely injured.
I mean, it is one of the most brutal, if not the most brutal sport in the world.
And the fact that these guys can't seek marijuana for relief when they allow them to take opioids is just bananas.
It doesn't make any sense.
graham hancock
Because we live in an insane society which has got all its priorities upside down and is completely screwing up this beautiful world that human beings have been gifted by the universe.
And I think it boils down to a relatively few people.
We just have incredibly bad governments, lousy leaders, totally irresponsible, lacking any initiative or imagination in it entirely for themselves.
It's a messed up world and it's a kind of litmus test for how messed up that world is, that sovereign adults cannot take the responsible decision to use psychedelics without risking jail.
It's very, very insane that that should be the case, and yet alcohol is glorified in our society.
As you say, the opioids are prescribed hand over fist by Big Pharma.
We're very mixed up, and I have a feeling that the sooner we get our politicians onto major psychedelics, the better things are going to be.
joe rogan
Well, I think we've got to get the whole world involved as well.
We don't want to be the only ones that are tripping.
No problem, though.
If the Chinese and the Russians are not tripping and we are, we're like, everything's going to be fine, man.
graham hancock
Yeah.
And also, the other...
The other point to make, again, the critics try to trivialize this, but actually working with psychedelics, it can be really hard work.
It can be really grueling.
It can be really demanding.
It can put you through the psychological ringer as you confront your own dark side and learn how to deal with it.
Yes, there is a recreational role for these substances, and I honor the right of sovereign adults to use them for recreational purposes if they wish to do so.
But it's the deep work that these psychedelics require us to do, which is really fascinating and which is not easy.
It's very, very, very difficult.
I personally find it difficult.
I don't rush to my next psychedelic adventure.
I prepare myself very, very carefully and with some experiences.
And those are experiences, whether they're real or not, they're experiences that impact you as an experience does.
joe rogan
Yeah, you were breaking up a little bit there, but yeah, I completely agree with you about that.
I mean, I get terrified when I take an edible.
A marijuana edible is the introspective nature of those things and the way it breaks down your thoughts and your behavior and finds the skeletons in your closet.
graham hancock
You're in there for six hours!
joe rogan
Yeah!
Searching around with a flashlight.
I tell people, though, but that's one of the things that I like about it.
I learn things.
I know it's scary.
I know I feel terrifying while it's happening.
But when I come out of it on the other end, I genuinely feel like I'm a better person.
At that moment, I will be nicer to you.
I'm better at being me.
You know, it's very effective.
It really works.
There's something to it.
And it's available.
It's not something that you have to, you know, go to counseling for years and years.
No, it's right there.
You can get it real quick.
brian muraresku
This was the whole point of the mysteries, by the way, in the ancient world.
I mean, so there was a whole apparatus dedicated to curating these experiences for people.
And sometimes it was once in a lifetime, like Atalusis, at some later point in your life, And then you have the Dionysian mysteries, which are a bit weirder and a bit crazier, but they were also curated by professionals, by technicians, women in this case, who were thought to be spiking wine with all kinds of magical plants, herbs, and fungi.
But the mysteries existed to create this experience of death and rebirth, and they're supposed to be terrifying.
You were supposed to enter the underworld to meet the goddess.
It doesn't happen in the daylight.
It doesn't happen prancing around.
And the Greeks are known for lots of great things that we've inherited, like democracy and the arts and the sciences.
And what we're doing right now, this tria logos, through these microfonos, these are all Greek things and Greek technology that we've accepted as part and parcel of Western civilization.
But there was another part to them.
And it's a part, again, that is not taught in high school mythology or Western Civ.
And there's this deeply mystical aspect in the mysteries, for example, which the Greeks really looked to as something that wasn't just like a special part of civilization, but the central part of it.
So there is this, I'll tell you a story about this, this 4th century historian Zosimus.
He records the testimony of a Roman guy named Praetekstatus who was initiated at Eleusis.
Because remember, it wasn't just people from Greece.
It was around the Greek Empire, including at that time were people who'd been influenced by the Greeks.
And Eleusis has survived up until the 4th century AD, at which point it is, it's destroyed.
It's eliminated by the Christianized...
graham hancock
By Christians, yeah.
brian muraresku
By the Christianized Roman Empire in the late 4th century.
And so there were different attempts to wipe it off the map.
And in 364, the Emperor Valentinian, he essentially outlaws all nocturnal celebrations because these things are always at night.
Eleusis was at night, which speaks to part of the experience.
And this guy, Pratextatus, is recorded as saying, Valentinian, please don't shut this down.
I'm an initiate.
I've been to Eleusis.
I've drunk the potion.
I've seen the goddess.
Please do not eliminate this.
Eleusis is the one thing that holds the entire human race together, he said.
He said, if you get rid of Eleusis, life for us will become a-biotos, which in Greek means unlivable.
It wasn't just about Greek existence, it was about human existence.
There was something happening at Eleusis with that potion, with this beatific vision that literally held civilization together like glue for the ancient Greeks.
And democracy, the arts, the sciences, everything else It was an offshoot of that experience.
Eleusis was the foundation.
joe rogan
One of the things you talked about was that there was this transference, like the Eucharist eventually became a placebo.
What do you think it was initially?
Do you think it was a psychedelic mushroom?
brian muraresku
Allegro certainly thought that, right?
Right.
joe rogan
John Marco Allegro, author of The Sacred Mushroom and the Scroll.
brian muraresku
So he releases that book in 1970, and he claims that Christianity is the guise for a Near Eastern fertility cult.
And it's, I mean, I think it's very interesting, but there aren't many linguists who support the proposition.
joe rogan
Right.
There's a lot of people that disagree with him pretty heavily, right?
brian muraresku
I mean, from a purely linguistic perspective, to explain it briefly, so he says that...
joe rogan
Did you read The Sacred Mushroom and the Cross?
Did you read it?
brian muraresku
Several times.
joe rogan
Did you read the Dead Sea Scrolls and the Christian Myth as well?
brian muraresku
From Allegro.
joe rogan
Yeah, that's the one that was...
So the Catholic Church bought out the original one, right?
And it was very difficult to get a hold of for the longest time.
You had to buy copies of it.
brian muraresku
I've heard rumors to that effect, yes.
joe rogan
So he comes out with the second book, The Dead Sea Scrolls and the Christian Myth.
Knowing as much as you know about language, did you feel like he made leaps?
Did you feel like he made these connections that maybe were based on speculation?
brian muraresku
So he writes, it's pure philology, right?
So it's word games and things that only linguists, I mean, I think it's incredible that people who aren't linguists can actually read that.
It's really, really difficult to read Sacred Mushroom on the Cross.
But the basic premise is that the New Testament, written in Greek, has this Semitic substratum.
So underneath the Greek, the gospel writers and Paul are actually referring to different terms in Hebrew or Aramaic.
And that these terms have, in turn, come from the Sumerian, which any linguist would say is a language isolate, that there is no real relationship between Sumerian and the Indo-European languages, like Greek, and the Semitic.
So the premise of the argument is something that most linguists don't accept.
However, and Karl Ruck has written the afterword to one of the editions you probably have of Sacred Mushroom and the Cross.
And he gets into some complex theories about psycholinguistics and this interesting idea that just because they aren't related, there are certain words, certain names, certain vocabulary, like plant definitions, which would carry across the different languages.
And I find that somewhat interesting.
But when you dig into the words that Allegro was recreating, he places an asterisk, actually, next to these words, because they can't be corroborated by the ancient texts.
So some of these Sumerian words, he straight up hypothesizes as existing, but they can't really be found in the existing tablets.
So it's hard to correlate some of those meanings he draws down from the Sumerian.
But that said, he makes very interesting claims.
For example, like in 1 Corinthians 22, there's this interesting line where he says about that we preach Christ crucified is a skandalon for the Jews and a folly for the Greeks.
And skandalon in Greek means like a bolt or a snare, like a trap.
And Allegro ties it to like a tikla in Aramaic, which is like what he calls the bolt mushroom.
And in Sumerian, ukustigila.
And so he's saying that Paul's actually telling the Jews that, you know, the Christ crucified is a mushroom instead of a skandalon.
It's like a code word, like the skandalon is a mushroom.
And then for the Greeks, he says it's a fali, which is moira in Greek, which actually means mandrake, which is another psychedelic plant.
So there's all this different wordplay going on, but it's really hard to tease out any physical forensic evidence for this stuff, which was what I went after.
graham hancock
Was Allegro's position, if I recall correctly, that the sacred mushroom was Amanita muscaria?
joe rogan
Yeah, that was even the cover of his book.
It was a photo of Amanita Muscaria.
graham hancock
And that's where I have a...
I think Allegro did amazing work, but that's one area where I have a problem with Amanita Muscaria as the As the psychedelic of choice in early Christianity, because in shamanic cultures where Amanita muscaria is used, it's recognized that the mushroom is much more effective after it's been passed through a human body, or indeed through the body of a reindeer, and emerged in urine.
And so those shamanistic Cultures of Siberia use Amanita Muscaria by drinking it in the urine of a shaman who has previously consumed the mushroom.
And I don't see a lot of evidence for that in early Christianity, and it's why I like the work that Brian has done looking at the really hard evidence for psychedelics in early Christianity, which are not in this case Amanita Muscaria, if I'm correct, Brian.
joe rogan
Isn't the speculation about Amanita Muscaria that it's seasonal, it's also genetically variable, like there's different species, much like different fruits taste differently, there's different versions of the Amanita Muscaria that have more psychedelic compounds in them, and that there's all sorts of ways of preparing them that we've completely lost.
Am I getting this wrong?
I've only had one Amanita Muscaria experience and it wasn't very convincing.
graham hancock
Yeah, and this is often the case, but I'm told, I've not had the experience myself, but I'm told that if you can bear the idea of drinking the shaman's urine after he or she has consumed the Amanita Muscaria, you will have a really powerful journey.
joe rogan
Yeah, but you don't want a shaman just laughing hysterically after you drink his urine.
graham hancock
Absolutely.
joe rogan
The joke's on you, stupid.
There's also so many correlations between the Amanita Muscaria and Santa Claus, and Santa Claus to shamans.
graham hancock
The colors, the red and white, yeah.
joe rogan
Yeah, also the bag, the toys, the fact that they would dry them on these coniferous trees, the fact that these mushrooms have this mycorrhizal relationship with coniferous trees where they tend to grow under pine trees, which is the tree that we use for Christmas trees.
The fact that they're bright red like a toy that is in a package waiting for a child to open it up.
There's so many of these weird connections.
The colors, the fact that reindeer are with Santa Claus, the fact that these reindeer fly.
They fly through the heavens.
Yeah, I mean, that caribou are notoriously attracted to Amanita muscaria mushrooms.
In fact, people that have had psychedelic rituals and gone outside to urinate have talked about caribou knocking them over to try to get to their urine.
And caribou are reindeer.
And they have been observed eating these things.
So they have this weird relationship.
All those things are together, connected in some sort of a strange way.
And there's also a history of shamanic rituals being outlawed in Siberia.
And the way they got around it was they would come through the chimney, which is just crazy.
They would climb onto people's roofs and slide down the chimney to deliver the mushrooms.
graham hancock
It's just another example of the way that our culture takes an ancient historical truth and completely castrates it and turns it into Santa Claus, you know, whereas what we're actually dealing with are profound experiences in deeply altered states of consciousness.
joe rogan
Well, it's also this information seems to have been lost fairly recently because if you go back to the early 1950s and 40s and look at Christmas cards, the Christmas cards and depictions of Christmas almost always contained elves and Amanita muscaria mushrooms.
The Amanita muscaria mushroom was synonymous with Christmas for some strange reason.
Have you seen those old?
unidentified
Yeah.
joe rogan
Yeah, it's crazy, right?
Like, what is that?
brian muraresku
It's all over the fairy tale books, too.
You can't avoid the Amanita everywhere you look, which is why I think Allegro was also interested, writing in 1970 and studying it in the 50s and 60s.
I think that's why he glommed on to the Amanita.
joe rogan
But it's such an unconvincing mushroom.
The people that I know that have experienced it in terms of a psychedelic ritual, I don't know anybody who's really blown their brains out with it.
brian muraresku
And Gordon Watson also thought it was the ingredient behind Soma as well.
He writes a book about this in 1968, Soma, Divine Mushroom of Immortality.
That was his guess too for Soma.
joe rogan
But Wasson was experienced with psilocybin, which is so universally regarded as being effective.
That's why it's so confusing.
brian muraresku
I always found that strange too, to be honest.
So Wasson, I mean, to explain where this comes from, Wasson has this incredible experience with Maria Sabina in 1955 in Oaxaca, Mexico.
And when he consumes the, we think, psilocybin mexicana.
And he is catapulted to the heavens and he has this vision that he describes as the realest thing he's ever experienced under the influence of the psilocybin.
And the thought occurs to him, he writes later in 1957 in Life magazine, he says that could it be the case that the divine mushrooms are in fact the answer behind the ancient mysteries?
Which is why he then went and started looking at the Amanita, perhaps, or eventually Ergot, which is where I pick up the scent.
At some point in his correspondence with Albert Hoffmann, they together began focusing on Ergot, like we said, because it's so common and so natural, but so highly toxic, too.
And Albert claimed to have this experience with it, and so for years and years, after teaming up with Karl Ruck, they were convinced that Ergot had to somehow be involved.
joe rogan
So, what is the speculation of what the Eucharist originally was?
brian muraresku
According to the early Gnostics?
joe rogan
Yeah, I mean, is there any text that explains what the initial food was?
brian muraresku
Well, I mean, we have the canonical explanation from the Gospels, and we have St. Paul's letter.
I mean, the honest answer, and I think any priest would say this too, is the honest answer is we don't know.
You know, the Gospels are written anytime between 65 and 100 A.D. Paul's letters are some of the earliest writings that we have, like the letter to the Corinthians, for example.
He writes that in about 53 A.D., And the way he describes what's happening there is very, very interesting.
Maybe we can pull it up, actually.
I brought some of the Greek from the New Corinthians.
It's under Christian Pharmacon and the 4 Corinthians 11.30.
So, at some point, I was looking for what that original Eucharist was, and where it was taken.
So you have to think about the Greek world at this time.
You know, Jesus is born in the Holy Land, but Christianity really takes root in the Greek-speaking parts of the Empire, which is why Paul's letters are written to Greek-speaking people, right?
And why it's interesting to follow this theory, because you have the ancient Greek-speaking Greek in the pagan world, But you also have ancient Greeks speaking Greek in this Christianizing world.
And so the people in Corinth is this church not far from Eleusis, by the way.
In fact, today it's only an hour west of Eleusis.
And one of the earliest churches is there.
And Paul is addressing this early church in Greek.
And at the bottom, you can read the English, but he's essentially yelling at them for consuming the wrong kind of Eucharist.
joe rogan
Mmm.
brian muraresku
And earlier in this chapter, he calls it a cup of demons.
And at the end, he says, that's why so many of you are weak and sick, and a number of you have fallen asleep.
And I highlighted the word koimontai there.
So koimao in Greek, I can tell you for certain, does not mean to fall asleep.
Koima'o means to die because it's the exact word that John's Gospel uses about Lazarus.
Remember the famous miracle where Lazarus dies and he's resurrected?
That'd be a pretty shitty miracle if Lazarus was just taking a nap and Jesus went to wake him up from a nap.
And he uses the same verb there.
What Paul is saying here is that he's concerned that so many Corinthians are drinking a wine that is causing them to die.
Why would wine cause you to die in a Greek world that had no distilled liquor?
There was no hard alcohol in ancient Greece.
Distilled liquor doesn't enter Europe until much, much later, 8th, 9th, 10th centuries AD, right?
At this time, there's no word for alcohol either.
Alcohol is Arabic.
If you listen to the word, like alchemy or algebra or alcove, all these A-L words all come from the Arabic.
A-L is like the article in Arabic, like El in Spanish or Il in Italian.
So at this point, wine is not known For its alcoholic content.
Wine is a potion that is routinely mixed with all kinds of stuff.
Toxins, spices, perfumes, and plants, herbs, and fungi.
And here, we don't know what to make of it, but the Corinthians are drinking something that's causing them to die.
joe rogan
But the word is die.
brian muraresku
Koimao absolutely means to die because it's the word that, in fact, you can go to the next slide, Jamie.
If you look it up right there, it means, just like we would say, the sleep of death, but it means death.
And elsewhere in the Gospels, it's the exact word used for what happened to Lazarus before his miraculous resurrection.
It's the whole point of the miracle.
He is koimao.
He has fallen asleep to the death of sleep.
joe rogan
So the speculation is that there's some sort of a psychedelic or a fungi or something that's in the wine that's causing them to die and they're using it recreationally and they're trying to discourage this.
brian muraresku
That's how I read it.
And it's not just based on a random read of this one line in Corinthians.
It's based on an understanding of what Greek wine actually was, how far back it goes, which is centuries and centuries before this.
How it was mixed, what it was mixed with.
Even in the first century, there's a guy called Dioscorides, a Greek pharmacologist.
In fact, he's called the father of drugs.
And at the same time that these Gospels and Paul's letters are being written, he writes something called the Materia Medica.
It's these five books in Greek, and every drug prescription you've ever had in your life exists because Dioscorides wrote that manuscript.
And in that manuscript, in Book 5, he lists out, in Book 5 alone, 56 different recipes for spiked wine.
And in the Greek, he shows you how to spike wine with everything from salvia to hellebore to henbane, which he says is good for swollen genitals.
So if you have swollen genitals, you dissolve henbane into wine.
He says if you drink mandrake wine, like Allegro was talking about mandrake, it'll kill you in one cup full.
And then he says this about black nightshade in book 474. He says if you dissolve nightshade into wine, it will produce fantasias ou aedais, which in Greek means not unpleasant visions.
So just from the literature, we can tell that the Greeks absolutely knew how to spike wine with very powerful substances.
joe rogan
Graham, I gotta tell you, your microphone is really sensitive.
So anytime you do anything, any movement or breathing, it bangs around for whatever reason.
I'm sorry.
I just have to make you aware of it.
graham hancock
So I have to say...
Be still.
joe rogan
No, everything's fine, but anytime you bat, it overpowers everything, unfortunately.
unidentified
Oh dear.
joe rogan
Sorry.
graham hancock
Can I be turned down at the switchboard or something?
joe rogan
I don't know.
I don't think that's what it is.
I'll clean it up in the recording.
Jamie will clean it up.
brian muraresku
I'm writing them down.
joe rogan
Okay, he's writing down all the noises.
That's how good Jamie is.
I wanted to bring up sage to you because one of the things that you talked about was salvia.
Salvia is sage, right?
They are basically in the same species at least.
When those priests would be walking down the aisle and they would be blowing sage, they're burning sage, was that for some sort of a psychedelic effect?
Is that the reason why they were doing that?
brian muraresku
So when it comes to incense, we actually have an answer now.
I'm not sure if you know this, but earlier this year in May, there were some researchers in Israel who released one of the first archaeochemical studies of ancient incense.
Have you heard about this?
No.
So just in May, at a place called Tel Arad in Israel, south of Jerusalem, west of the Dead Sea, There was the organic remains of some kind of incense that was burned on these two altars that is described by the researchers as kind of a scaled-down version of Solomon's temple.
It's dated to the 8th century BC, so in the Judahite period.
So we could feasibly say the beginnings of the Judeo-Christian period.
Oh yeah, there it is.
joe rogan
Frankincense.
I love that word.
brian muraresku
So under archaeochemical analysis, and this sample had actually been excavated years ago in the 1960s and was deposited in the museum.
But the thing with this science, which is amazing, is that they can resurrect this stuff no matter when it was excavated.
So fortunately, it wasn't contaminated.
And after analysis, they found it contained THC, CBD, and CBN. So tetrahydrocannabinol, cannabidiol, And cannabinol.
And so they say it's the first example of psychoactive drug use in the ancient Holy Land, essentially.
joe rogan
So when they were walking down the aisle, would they use only—we know that was cannabis, but sage was used as well, right?
And sage is salvia divinorum, which is a more potent psychedelic than cannabis.
brian muraresku
Yeah, but I think that's a new world plant, though.
joe rogan
Is it?
brian muraresku
If I'm not mistaken.
joe rogan
Oh, okay.
brian muraresku
I mean, at least the one you're thinking of.
joe rogan
So when you say New World, are you talking about European world?
brian muraresku
In the Americas.
joe rogan
Oh, Americas, really?
So sage use when they would have it in that...
graham hancock
What is that...
joe rogan
Graham, you would know this.
What is that thing that they walk down the aisle with when they blow the smoke?
graham hancock
A sensor.
joe rogan
A sensor?
That's really what it's called?
A sensor?
graham hancock
C-E-N-S-O-R, yeah.
Yeah, a sensor.
It's an interesting double entendre there.
joe rogan
Yeah.
graham hancock
Sensorship, yeah.
joe rogan
So they were most certainly using cannabis or something else that they were burning, and they were getting everybody high.
brian muraresku
And frankincense.
joe rogan
Yeah, and what is frankincense?
brian muraresku
It's an aromatic spice.
joe rogan
Ah, so it just smells nice.
brian muraresku
We don't think it's psychoactive, but maybe at the right dose it could be.
joe rogan
But the cannabis certainly was.
So they would give everybody marijuana smoke.
Just walk down the aisle and blow marijuana smoke on everybody.
graham hancock
If I may add, whether or not the smoke is...
is psychedelic.
It is adding to the experience.
It's adding to the setting.
And again, anybody who's worked with psychedelics will know that the setting is at least as important as the substance itself.
So they're masters of creating this mysterious and powerful and energizing setting in which the psychedelic experience can then unfold.
joe rogan
It's such a bummer that we know so little about what exactly was going on, but so nice that someone like you has done these deep dives into it, where at least we could pull out whatever we can.
And it just makes me think, where would we be if people like you weren't doing this?
It's so rare.
brian muraresku
This is why I'm not doing DMT, man.
unidentified
I would...
joe rogan
Because you wouldn't be doing it.
I don't know.
You might be doing it with more feverish need.
I mean, you might be really obsessed with it.
It's just, it's so strange.
And Graham, I always go back to your statement, which I think is such a great quote, that we're a species with amnesia in regard to our archaeology, our history, but also in regard to our use of psychedelics.
graham hancock
Yeah, well we've just not been given the straight scoop about our past.
Sometimes it's just purely the way that scholars work.
That academics work and sometimes I think in the case of Christianity it is actually a kind of conspiracy.
I think there was a deliberate effort to cover up the role of psychedelics and you could see why priests in the developing Roman Catholic faith who've already pulled on the jackboot of the Roman Empire, you could see why they wouldn't like Their congregations using psychedelics because when you use psychedelics you have a direct experience of the divine and hey you don't need that priest anymore.
The priest as an intermediary between you and the divine becomes redundant and I think that there was a concerted effort to cover up the role of psychedelics in early Christianity and to present a different narrative which it was purely was the bread and the wine, the blood and the And the body of Christ in a symbolic sense and not in an actual sense of a substance that connects us to the divine.
joe rogan
So the literature that connects the banning of these psychedelic rituals in the 4th century, you're saying, how does it describe it and what was the reaction by the people?
brian muraresku
I mean, at the time, so you have to remember that the Greek mysteries existed for a long, long time.
We don't know exactly how long, but the excavators, and this began in Eleusis, for example, in 1887. They date it back to at least 1500 BC. So if it survives until the 4th century AD, you're talking almost 2,000 years, as long as Christianity itself has been around.
And the mysteries themselves...
And there are serious scholars who came along in the 70s to say this, could have prehistoric roots, which is how I started the investigation, by asking how this actually got to the Greeks.
Because what's interesting about this kukion potion, for example, is that it's not wine-based.
In that hymn to Demeter that came down to us, she's actually offered wine in this mythical story that takes place.
She's out looking for her daughter Persephone, who's been abducted and kidnapped to the underworld.
And she looks for her for nine days and nights and can't find her.
And she rests her bones exhausted at Eleusis.
And they try to offer her wine.
And she says, no, she wants that water, barley, and mint.
And again, Hoffman, Wasson, and Ruck thought it was kind of like a primitive version of beer, if you think about it.
It reads like a very simple beer recipe.
Now, for the Greeks, all the way through the classical period, through Plato and afterwards, For them to be drinking beer instead of wine is very, very weird.
For them to have a secret mystery religion that's not written down, remember, the civilization that birthed literature and the concept of the university as we know it, is also very weird.
So it's like they are retaining this very prehistoric ritual and this very prehistoric beverage, which is beer.
And as I trace it back further and further, you can see clues of beer being used in funerary and mortuary rituals As far back as 13,000 years.
And there are some who think that beer actually precedes bread at that moment we call the Agricultural Revolution, where the Upper Petolithic becomes the Neolithic.
And Graham writes a lot about this, and very beautifully, at Gobekli Tepe, for example.
So I was able to trace back the potential brewing of religious beer all the way back to Gobekli Tepe.
joe rogan
And the speculation is that this religious beer had some ergot in it.
Possibly.
brian muraresku
It's possible.
It's possible.
We haven't done much testing for ergot that far back.
That's why I wanted to write this book, is because the science is relatively new.
Archaeochemistry, for example, is relatively new.
Some of the better findings have been coming out over the past 20 years, which is like a baby in the sciences.
In fact, Pat McGovern at the University of Pennsylvania, who I interviewed for the book, described archaeochemistry at the time, in the late 90s, when he was Producing some incredible finds as like an infant, which would make it like a toddler today.
And so we're just beginning to put these pieces together.
So we can't say there was psychedelic beer 13,000 years ago.
The question right now is was there beer at all?
And there's very early indications at Gobekli Tepe itself that they were brewing beer.
And at another site to the southwest in Israel, at Mount Carmel outside Haifa, there's this really interesting place called the Rockefet Cave.
And it was a burial site with about 30 individuals.
This is between 11,700 BC and 9,700 BC. A team from Stanford went in there, and they found these boulder mortars.
In which they found traces of the malting and mashing of grains which they think was for beer.
This is 13,000 years ago.
graham hancock
Which brings us to the Upper Paleolithic, and then we have the whole mystery of rock and cave art all around the world.
So Brian is right, we haven't got the analysis that proves that a psychedelic was in that 13,000-year-old beer.
But what we do have 13,000 years ago, and going back much further, 27, 40, 50,000 years ago, is art.
And that art really only makes sense as psychedelic art.
I mean, where else but in a visionary state do you see an entity that is part human and part animal in form, that is part a lion and part a human being?
It's not something you see every day.
It's not something that you see when you're out hunting game.
But seeing these therianthropes, as they're called, is a very common experience in deeply altered states of consciousness.
So the art itself speaks to us of artists Who had powerful experiences in deeply altered states.
joe rogan
What is the conventional speculation about those images, the half-man, half-animal images?
graham hancock
Increasingly, it is that they document psychedelic states.
There's a professor at the University of Witwatersrand in South Africa, David Lewis Williams, written a book called The Mind in the Cave, who's documented this in great detail, that the only possible Another explanation for this art, which is found all over the world, is not just found in one region or one place,
is that the artists were shamans, that they were experiencing altered states of consciousness, and when they returned to a normal everyday state of consciousness, they remembered their visions and painted them on cave walls.
And those visions might well be a lion man or a bison man And that entity had communicated with them just in the way that entities communicate with us today under the influence of DMT or psilocybin.
joe rogan
Did you have a sense of urgency while you were writing this?
Did you understand that this is something that very few people who are legitimate scholars are going to really tackle?
brian muraresku
Well, it hadn't been done, and I don't know why nobody was doing this and combining the humanities and the linguistics with the sciences.
I've been waiting for this book to come along, and no one wrote it.
joe rogan
So you had to write it yourself.
unidentified
Since I wasn't doing DMT, I had plenty of free time.
joe rogan
How long did it take?
brian muraresku
12 years.
unidentified
Wow.
joe rogan
Was there any point in time where you were like, what the fuck am I doing?
brian muraresku
If you ask my wife, yeah, especially.
You're supposed to be a lawyer, man.
No one's paying you for this.
You went to the Vatican?
joe rogan
Was there a real issue?
brian muraresku
Yeah, absolutely.
It's a good point.
This is really, really hard, and it brings up something.
I've been talking with the researchers about this, too.
So when I talk about archaeochemistry, I mentioned Pat McGovern at UPenn.
There's another guy, Andrew Coe at MIT. And every time I have a question, these guys are there to answer it.
Andrew's awesome.
He's a younger guy in his mid-40s.
He's been doing this stuff his whole life.
He has a background in classics like I do.
And so he's the only person I've talked to who sees the legitimacy of this kind of pursuit because he's one of those guys who can think about the humanities and the sciences at the same time.
But it's tough.
There is no discipline for this.
You can't get a PhD in the hunt for ancient intoxicants.
No one's out there studying for it.
It just doesn't exist.
And those who do study it find it very, very hard to get gainful employment.
You can't get paid to do this stuff.
And so a little bit later we'll talk about two archaeochemists I've been in touch with who have remarkable findings.
That I want to share here.
But they've each since left the discipline.
So they were doing incredible work 20 years ago, in the late 90s and early 2000s, were finding incredible things.
But, I mean, life being what it is, they had to leave the profession.
joe rogan
Well, let's get to that now.
Who are they and what are they?
brian muraresku
So there's a couple different guys.
So there are two finds that I really went out of my way to put into this book.
One is trying to find hard evidence of this ergotized beer, and the other is trying to find actual hard evidence of wine that's been spiked.
And ideally, that would be spiked wine in the context of some kind of Christian ceremony.
Or some syncretic Greek Christian ceremony in the first century AD. And so I spent years and years trying to get in contact with these folks and reading through the archaeobotany journals.
And I'll start with the ergot first, since I was really kind of fascinated with ergot.
And this hypothesis from 1978, because it sits there for now 40 years, and there's no hard data to come by.
And people often argue about ergot the same way we argue about Amanita and the other candidates, because it doesn't make sense.
We know it's there, we know it's common, but it doesn't make the most sense as the thing that would have spiked this beer.
So I spent a long time looking for ergotized beer or any beer that was spiked.
Now if you go to the top archaeochemists or archaeobotanists in the US, the UK, or Europe, and I did for many years, and I asked them the very simple question, is there any botanical or chemical data of beer having been spiked with psychedelics?
And the universal answer that would always come back is no.
And so I'd ask them again, and the answer would be no.
And so I started to think about the ancient world and what that meant and what ancient Greece meant.
And so first I went to the site Atalusis to ask the archaeologist there if we could test her vessels.
And I couldn't believe that nobody had ever asked her if they could submit the vessels to chemical testing.
And so I flew there, and I talked to her about it, and she said, unfortunately, they've all been treated for conservation purposes.
You know, they put them in museums.
And they exhibit them to the public.
And when you do that, you contaminate the artifact and it's no longer testable.
So that was my dead end.
And that's where things stopped for a while.
And that's where my wife starts asking, you know...
joe rogan
Brian!
brian muraresku
You flew to Greece by yourself and left your two daughters at home for no reason.
So you could ask a lady if you could test her chalices.
And she told you no.
And now what are you going to do?
And so I said, well, I'm going to get creative, man.
And so I thought about the ancient Greek world.
Here's the thing about the ancient Greek world.
In the wake of Alexander the Great, who was called the Great for a reason, the Greek influence after the fourth, third centuries BC stretched all the way from Iberia, Spain and Portugal to Afghanistan in the East.
I'm not sure if many folks realize that, but the Greek speaking or the Greek influence part of the world was enormous.
And so if you're looking for evidence of this kukion, why would you restrict yourself to Athens and Eleusis?
So I took a step back and I started thinking, where else would there be a Greek presence?
And I didn't expect to find one, but I landed on Iberia eventually because I started researching Urgot in different languages.
That was my first clue.
You know, in English we have this one weird word for it, ergot.
And actually in German there's lots of words for it, bizarrely enough.
Maybe it's because of the history of brewing.
But in German there's aftakorn, mutakorn, tolkorn, which means crazy corn, crazy grain.
Or totenkorn, which means death corn.
And so it's weird that, you know, as you look elsewhere, it seems to be more common to the German mind.
And then in Spanish I just started...
Random Googling for what that is.
It's called Cornezuela de Centeno in Spanish.
And a couple things started popping up.
And these notions of spiked beer started popping up, where they weren't supposed to.
I never expected to find them.
So the first hit that came in was from an archaeological site kind of in the middle, Midwest of Spain, called the Vallo Dolid.
And there, in 2003, they found a Greek vessel, a Greek chalice, called a Kernos.
And it's the same kind of vessel that's used in the Eleusinian Mysteries.
It's like this little cup with a tiny cup on the outside.
I brought a picture for you if you want to see it.
Sure.
Jamie, in Mas Castellar, if you scroll to the bottom, and copy of P29. So, this came from a site called the Necropolis of Las Ruedas.
And the Necropolis of Las Ruedas is this archaeological site that was dated to about the 2nd century BC. Now, these aren't Greek people.
This is a pre-Roman population called the vacai, or the Vaxians.
But for some reason, in this carnos, it tested positive for beer spiked with hyoscyamine.
If you go to the next tab, Jamie, you'll see that they wrote it up.
It's in Spanish.
But there you'll see that at the numbers 76 and 77, when they tested the kernos, which is a very Greek word, by the way, when they tested the kernos, it tested positive for traces of hyouskyamine.
And hyouskyamine can only occur...
In these solanaceous plants, these nightshade plants.
So it's the family of plants that includes very boring things like the tomato or the potato or tobacco, but it has these nightshades like mandrake, again, or henbane.
And so it's one of those tropane alkaloids that could have been in henbane, for example.
So here you're talking about a henbane beer, which is really weird.
The even weirder part is that this is found in a funeral complex.
Just like you'd find at Gobekli Tepe or the Rockefet Cave in Israel 13,000 years ago, here, after thousands and thousands of years, you're seeing this pre-Roman population using beer spiked with henbane in a death cult.
And where the researchers say that it was used to either facilitate the deceased's travel to the other world, or maybe the people who were there ushering the deceased into the other world.
They actually use that phrase.
joe rogan
Holy shit.
Go back to that image of the cup again, please.
So why does it have the cup on the outside of it again?
There's the large vessel and there's a small vessel to the side of it?
brian muraresku
We don't know.
That's just what a kernos is.
joe rogan
It could have possibly been portion control?
brian muraresku
Exactly.
If you scroll to the top, Jamie, you'll see two other kernoi on the top right there.
And so this is the next part of the clue.
So these came from a colony on the east coast of Iberia called Emporion.
Which was a bustling Greek colony.
And these are other Kernos vessels, just like you would see at Eleusis.
These are the kinds of things that they think the initiates were drinking from.
Now, they don't make for very good drinking vessels, but maybe they make for good mixing vessels, like for dosage control.
Something is going on there.
That's what they thought the Kernos was at Eleusis, for example, and that's what I wanted to test.
With the archaeologist there who said no.
And so now we're finding these vessels in Spain where they're not supposed to be.
And I can say, as a classicist or a one-time wannabe classicist, that the first thing you think of when you think about the ancient Greeks is not Spain.
And all of a sudden, I'm coming across this idea of spiked beer in Spain.
And it's just not supposed to be there.
joe rogan
That's so fascinating.
Can you go back to that original image, Jamie?
Yeah, of the cup with the small cup next to it.
What's the conventional description of what this is and why it's shaped this way?
brian muraresku
I mean, the Spanish archaeologists, they also call this a kernos.
I mean, it's the extent of the Greek influence at that particular site.
This is the Pintia archaeological site.
The extent of the relationship and the network is a little unclear, at least to me.
It's unclear how strong the Greek presence was there.
But at the time, by the second century BC, Because the Greeks were already in these other port cities basically, it's not inconceivable that some kind of trade was happening and these vessels would have made their way inland.
joe rogan
Do they have a description as to why there's a small cup connected to the larger cup though?
brian muraresku
It would be the same as any Greek archaeologist has, too.
We don't know why this was associated with the mysteries.
No one knows why.
joe rogan
It really does logically make sense that it would be some sort of a portion, because it's very small.
Obviously, you don't want to have too much of that shit.
graham hancock
It really does make complete sense, actually, that that's what it is, that you take one portion of this and mix it with ten portions of that, and then you're going to have an interesting journey.
joe rogan
I can't think of another explanation off the top of my head.
Obviously, I'm not qualified to speculate, but when I'm looking at this, I'm thinking, oh, that completely fits.
brian muraresku
But you're on the right track, because that's where it led me to, was portion control.
And that's what I found next.
joe rogan
What'd you find next?
brian muraresku
I found...
I found some things, man.
joe rogan
What'd you find, man?
brian muraresku
So, Cernos, right?
I'm thinking Cernos vessels.
And so the vessel doesn't just show up in the middle of Spain there.
It shows up on the coast.
And so this town's called Emporion.
And today it's called Ampurias.
And it's in Catalonia, in northeast Spain, close to the border of With France.
And to be totally honest, I'd never heard of Emporion, and I'm not sure if many classicists have, but it was a bustling import-export business of the ancient Greeks, founded by the Phocaeans, who came from Ionia, which is today modern-day Turkey.
And they found this place in 575...
And we think that the religion comes with them, or some kind of religion.
Jamie, if you go back to Mas Castellar, you can see just an exterior shot of what this colonial town looks like.
And when you look at it, again, there, I mean, that could be southern Greece.
That could be an island in Greece.
That's on the northeast coast of Spain.
That's a statue of Asclepius, the Greek god of healing, standing in a courtyard in Spain.
joe rogan
And the statue dates to?
brian muraresku
At least 5th century BC. Wow.
on the left the Greek goddess Persephone the goddess of the underworld the same goddess who the initiates would find when they made their pilgrimage to a Lucis and drank the potion they went there to meet Persephone yeah and there she is on their coins Wow and then it gets more interesting How?
So these people don't stick to the coast.
They go inland at some point.
And they go inland for a reason.
And there's a site that they found called Mas Castellar de Pontos.
It's a tiny town called Pontos.
And there's this farm that the archaeologists describe as a Greek farm a bit further inland.
Jamie, if we go back to the same file there, we can just click through a bunch of the images and the kinds of things that they found there, which are indicative of the Greek mysteries.
So starting with her, for example, that was unearthed at this archaeological site in Pontos, and the archaeologist responsible for this dig, who's been the same woman since 1990, her name is Enriqueta Pons, she found this and other...
and other objects, she calls this the head of Persephone.
unidentified
Wow.
brian muraresku
Or it could be the head of Demeter, but either way, she thinks it's a Greek goddess.
And this is third century BC.
joe rogan
So obviously there's some intense influence.
brian muraresku
These are Greco-Italian amphorae, also dated to the 3rd century BC. And the next one, that's also some kind of Demeter Persephone.
That's an incense burner, by the way.
You stick incense in the top of it, light it up, depending on what your incense is, and it's used in cult rituals.
That's 3rd century BC. And then it gets weirder.
They find this, 5th century BC, that belongs in a dining room in Athens, not on a farm in Spain.
That's the origin of comedy right there, believe it or not.
That's called a komos.
Komos in ancient Greek is one of these drunken parades in honor of the god Dionysus.
These are the first paid regulars at the comedy store.
joe rogan
And he's got his dick out like Ari Shaffir.
There you go.
Wow.
That's crazy.
brian muraresku
So then it gets weirder.
Just south of the site, they find this.
And this is Tryptolomus.
Tryptolomus is kind of the missionary of the mysteries.
So after Demeter establishes her temple in Eleusis, they send this guy to go scouring the earth to carry the knowledge of the grain and farming across Europe.
and if you go to the next one, Jamie you'll see that it's very similar to the kind of tryptolomous things that show up in Greece this is from the Eleusis Museum on site in Eleusis, if you compare the two you see a dude on a flying dragon cart on the left and a dude on a flying dragon cart on the right, they're both tryptolomous the last place I ever expected to find tryptolomous was a farm in Spain, and there it is wow
So if Tryptolemus tells you anything, it tells you that the mysteries went west, when they're not supposed to, by the way.
Graham alluded earlier to this incident that happened in Athens in 414 BC. To celebrate the mysteries outside of Eleusis is a sacrilege, a total sacrilege.
It was called the profanation of the mysteries.
And one of Socrates' star disciples, this guy Alcibiades, was caught indulging in the mystery ceremony at home instead of at the temple, and he became the Ed Snowden of the ancient world.
He was ostracized.
They would have killed him if he didn't run from Athens.
So this was serious stuff and sacred stuff.
So for them to be celebrating the mysteries, Think about it, it kind of makes sense because no one's looking over their shoulder in Spain.
If it's going to happen anywhere, maybe it'd be in the hinterlands of the empire.
joe rogan
So this is people that realized that they wanted to continue these rituals and couldn't do it in Greece anymore.
They had to get out.
brian muraresku
Right.
Or these were folks who either couldn't afford or didn't want to go all the way to Eleusis.
I mean, you're in Spain.
Imagine getting to...
You can't get to Eleusis today.
Imagine getting to Eleusis 2,000 years ago, 2,500 years ago.
It's really, really difficult.
graham hancock
If I may give a parallel, it's rather like somebody...
seeking an ayahuasca experience today.
And perhaps they can't afford to go all the way to the Amazon rainforest, or it just seems too big a journey.
So they're going to look for somewhere nearer to home where they can have that experience.
And indeed, ayahuasca is available all over the world now.
joe rogan
Yeah, and that's pretty recently, right?
Like, within the last couple of decades, it's available all over the world.
graham hancock
Spread rapidly within the last couple of decades, and I think Brian is suggesting that a similar sort of thing was happening in the ancient world with a different substance.
joe rogan
The guy's name's so right on the nose, too.
graham hancock
Triptolemus.
brian muraresku
I never thought about that until right now.
unidentified
How could you not think of that?
brian muraresku
Because I don't do DMT. But, I mean, Tripp...
joe rogan
People tripping.
I mean, it's just ridiculous that his name is Trip.
brian muraresku
It's interesting.
joe rogan
I mean, look at him.
He's riding a dragon.
His name is Triptolemus.
brian muraresku
And on the next one, too, Jamie, you'll see there's another Triptolemus from Capua.
This is in Italy.
So he did go west.
unidentified
Wow.
brian muraresku
We know he went to Italy.
And if he went to Italy, why wouldn't he go to Spain?
joe rogan
And look at the style of art.
It's completely Greek.
Wow.
unidentified
Wow.
graham hancock
Pretty psychedelic at the same time.
joe rogan
Yeah.
graham hancock
Flying on that dragon.
joe rogan
Yes, it is.
But it's so uniform that in the three different locations you have the same imagery.
Wow.
brian muraresku
And so the question that Wasson, Hoffman, and Ruck would immediately ask is, what is Triptalamus doing there?
Was he really sent as a missionary to teach people how to farm?
That's a traditional signal.
joe rogan
Isn't that wheat in his hands?
brian muraresku
That's exactly right.
joe rogan
Okay, so Urgot.
brian muraresku
He was dispatched to teach people how to grow cereals.
However, across the Neolithic period, people know how to farm.
People are already farming.
So it starts in the breadbasket at Gobekli Tepe in Anatolia.
We have farming across Europe.
In Greece, as early as 6500 BC, it's by 4000 or so BC. It's all over...
Europe.
Why would Tryptolemus need to be sent on a mission to teach people to do something they already knew how to do, which is farm?
And so what they would say is, he was teaching not about growing the grain, but about what grows on the grain, which is ergo.
joe rogan
Of course.
And look, someone's pouring something, too.
brian muraresku
Yeah, that's one of those ritual ablutions.
unidentified
Wow.
brian muraresku
So then it gets more interesting.
unidentified
Okay.
graham hancock
We're waiting, Jamie.
We're waiting, Brian.
brian muraresku
In addition to Triptolemus and the heads of Demeter and Persephone, Enrique Tapons finds this gem, which is a 250-square-foot ritual sanctuary that she calls, in Spanish, a capilla domestica, which is a household shrine.
And she believes it's a household shrine that is specifically dedicated to reenacting the mysteries of Demeter and Persephone, Wow.
you still need some greek influence so in the next slide you'll see the altar where the activity was happening does that look greek very so that's a column that was proven by petrographic analysis to have originated at the mount pentelicus quarry northeast of athens it came from greece and it's sitting in spain And what they're doing on that, aside from burning incense all around, is they're sacrificing dogs.
They found the remains of three female dogs.
There's only one goddess in Greece associated with that, and that's Hecate, who is the mother of the witch Circe and the patroness of all witches.
And they're sacrificing dogs to her because she's known as the kunos fages in Greek, which is the dog eater.
unidentified
What?
graham hancock
God.
brian muraresku
The other things you find in that room, aside from the Greek altar and the Greek goddess to whom dogs are being sacrificed in an underworld journey where the living and dead are communing, is a Greek hearth.
And Enriqueta uses the Greek word eschara for that.
You can go to the next one, Jamie.
So in addition to the Greek altar and the Greek hearth, she finds these, which are very Greek-shaped cups.
These are called Kantharos.
The Kantharos is the ritual vessel that was only used by the god Dionysus to drink his magic potion.
She finds about 10 of these in and around the area.
And when I heard all this, after the Greek influences swimming on this place, I called up Karl Ruck, who at the time was 84 years old.
He's now 85 years old.
And his career was severely impacted after the release of the 1978 book The Road to Eleusis.
His career essentially tanks.
It was the classic case of the wrong book at the wrong time.
He was not supposed to write this because he did.
He was deposed as the chair of the classics department.
He was cut off from grad students.
He was discouraged from interdisciplinary scholarship with his colleagues.
He became the drug guy.
You know, classicists don't write about drugs, but the book really, really impacted his life.
And he became kind of the black sheep of the classics estate.
And there's no evidence to prove that this ergotized beer actually exists.
And so, you know, his career kind of went into a nosedive.
And so I've been keeping him up to speed on all this work.
And so I called him up and invited him to come see...
I'm going to go.
at the incense burner and the cup.
And there he's in an ancient staring contest with Demeter looking at this cup.
And I didn't take him all the way to Spain just so he could look at a cup.
It's because of what was in the cup.
And so in the mid 1990s, after it was excavated, this woman, Enriqueta, the archeologist, for some reason, we don't know why, she got in touch with a young archeobotanist who I mentioned before, Jordi.
And they subjected this chalice to analysis.
And what they found was beer.
unidentified
Wow.
brian muraresku
So this thing was filled at some point with some kind of ritual beer that was used in some kind of ceremony dedicated to Demeter and Persephone.
But that's not all they found.
They also found the remains of ergot.
unidentified
Mm-hmm.
Thank you.
brian muraresku
And it is the first and most compelling data to support this scorned hypothesis from 1978 that's ever emerged.
joe rogan
What was that like for him to experience that?
I mean, it had to be just completely mind-blowing, but also frustrating that he was right all along.
brian muraresku
And I expected that too.
And I asked him, I have a video of me talking to him at the chapel.
I asked him what this all means.
And he's not salty about it.
joe rogan
42 years later?
brian muraresku
42 years, yeah.
joe rogan
Not at all?
brian muraresku
No.
unidentified
LAUGHTER He's got a good life.
brian muraresku
He's happy.
I think he feels vindicated.
Yes.
And I know he's excited to talk about this in public.
And this is the first time we're talking about it in public.
And I know he wants to dive deep on this.
But this is something he's dedicated his entire professional life to.
joe rogan
And you said he's 83 now?
He's 85 now.
How is he holding up physically?
brian muraresku
He's okay now.
He's in quarantine.
He lives in this beautiful pre-revolutionary war home that I went to visit a couple years ago.
I describe it as something like the British Museum having been ransacked by a group of mischievous elves.
He's surrounded by mushrooms and busts of Demeter.
And he's got some artifacts that belong to Gordon Wasson, who was his mentor in many ways, you know, father figure.
joe rogan
So from 78 on, he was just balls deep in this stuff.
He dove head in.
brian muraresku
Instead of turning around after he was yelled at for being the drug guy, if you look him up and his CV, it's all he does is write about the potential use of drugs in the ancient world.
joe rogan
Did he have personal experiences?
brian muraresku
Many.
joe rogan
Yeah, so that's probably why he started writing about it.
brian muraresku
As a matter of...
joe rogan
There's really no reason to not...
brian muraresku
As a matter of fact, when I mentioned that letter from Albert Hoffman to Gordon Wasson in 1976, when he self-dosed on the Ergonavine, he sent some, in the letter it says, he sent some in the mail to Gordon Wasson, who politely declined and made Ruck do it instead.
unidentified
LAUGHTER Wow.
joe rogan
So for Ruck, what was it like for you to be able to show this to Ruck, to give him hard evidence, to show him these cups, to tell him about the tests that were done, the fact that they discovered ergot, the fact that they know these vessels were holding beer.
I mean, this vindication to be there physically while this vindication emerges.
brian muraresku
Psychedelic, man.
joe rogan
It had to be.
brian muraresku
It was really emotional.
I mean, it's still emotional for me.
And I mean, to be clear, there's more testing and more analysis that needs to be done.
This was 20 years ago.
And the breaking news is that that original sample may be stashed away somewhere at the University of Barcelona.
And Jordi was going to go look for it.
COVID intervened.
So we very much want to retest this stuff.
Andrew Koh at MIT very much wants to get a chemical sample.
So I want to be a little careful.
But the way it exists...
Today is extraordinarily compelling, and odds are there's probably even more evidence, some of which hasn't even been excavated.
And for Ruck, or for the field in general, I think it's extraordinary.
joe rogan
Well, the dots all connect themselves.
I mean, that's what's really amazing about it.
If you look at...
What you've discovered and if you look at the history of these people getting together and having these rituals and what we know about psychedelics in particular, LSD, and what Albert Hoffman has shown and any people who've experienced LSD know.
I mean, it all fits right in.
It all makes sense.
It's crazy.
And where would we be if you didn't write this book?
That's what's really interesting.
You know, there's seven plus billion people on this planet, and it just takes one person to not listen to their wife.
The next thing you know...
brian muraresku
Do you hear that, PJ? Do you hear that?
unidentified
PJ, he was right.
brian muraresku
Thank God.
joe rogan
Is she cool?
brian muraresku
I think you just saved my marriage.
I swear to Christ.
I think you just saved my marriage.
joe rogan
Is she cool with it now?
brian muraresku
No.
Still no?
No, she wants to see how this goes and then she'll be cool.
joe rogan
Oh, it'll go great, man.
This book's going to sell like crazy.
Are you going to do an audio version of it?
brian muraresku
I read it myself.
joe rogan
Oh, nice.
When is that going to be out?
brian muraresku
It's out.
joe rogan
Is it out right now?
brian muraresku
Or today or tomorrow, yeah.
joe rogan
Oh, okay, because I tried to look for it yesterday on Amazon.
Really?
Or on, no, Apple.
It wasn't available.
brian muraresku
Okay, the 29th, I think.
unidentified
Oh, okay.
graham hancock
The publication date is the 29th of September, and that's also the same publication date as the paperback of my lost civilization book, America Before.
I want to be clear that...
The Immortality Key is Brian's book.
joe rogan
Yes, you wrote the foreword.
graham hancock
My contribution to it is the foreword, and I'm grateful to Brian for asking me to do that.
I think Brian has done really important work, and I think the next step now is to demystify this field and get more science at work on this subject instead of just closing our eyes and closing our minds to these extraordinary possibilities that we've been radically misled about our own past.
joe rogan
Yeah, and I think thanks to the great work of Rick Doblin and Dr. Rick Strassman and yourself and so many other people that have contributed to this, it's now something that people are allowed to speculate about.
It's now something that people are allowed to...
brian muraresku
Well, it's a test.
joe rogan
Yes.
People are having real legitimate conversations about these things now.
Yeah.
brian muraresku
Yeah, this was the attempt to use 21st century science to test an ancient hypothesis.
And part of the issue is the ancient Greeks, and the other part is the Christians.
I mean, all we had for a long time was Allegro.
So I spent some time...
If Ruck was right about this, was Ruck right about what he writes about the Christians?
And he does write about psychedelic sacraments and the Christians.
joe rogan
And what was his speculation about the psychedelic sacraments and the Christians?
brian muraresku
He also likes the Amanita Muscaria.
unidentified
Really?
brian muraresku
Yeah.
joe rogan
Why does everybody like that one?
Do you think it...
Well, this is also...
I'm asking you as a person who hasn't experienced psychedelics.
I do not know very many people that have had successful experiences with it.
It's very confusing.
But I do recognize that it's entirely...
McKenna speculated very much that we've lost our ability to understand how to prepare it, when to prepare it, when to pick it, and that it's seasonal.
There's so many variables.
Yeah.
graham hancock
We're ignorant about how to use these things.
Our society, I speak of a species with amnesia.
We've forgotten the old techniques and the old ways of doing things.
There's been a concerted effort in the modern world to demonize these substances and to cut them out of our lives and to associate them with irrational behavior and craziness and so on and so forth.
And to move forward in this field I hate to use the word, but it needs to be made more respectable because it's the key to understanding so much about ourselves that has been obscure and mysterious until now.
joe rogan
It's just, for a person who's experienced it, it's so strange, the contrast between the experience itself and the public's perception of it.
Particularly the average person who has not experienced psychedelics, who looks at it like this frivolous, ridiculous thing.
Like, why would you engage in such a thing?
Why would you?
I mean, I remember I had a conversation with Michio Kaku about it once, talking to him about psychedelic mushrooms.
And he was basically telling me, like, scientists want to strengthen their mind.
They don't want to ruin their mind, in that sense.
Like, you don't want to waste your mind on drugs.
And I was like, oh, there's a guy who needs to do some drugs.
graham hancock
Yeah, exactly.
People make these kind of statements as though they're facts.
Yet those people have had no experiences of the substance's concern.
joe rogan
For his own career, you almost have to say things like that.
Or at least then.
We're talking when I had this conversation with him more than a decade ago, probably 15 years ago.
So when you have these experiences and you run into the conventional perception of these, you understand that these people, almost like what happened with Ruck and what happened with many other scholars, that took chances and discussed these things, you wound up being this crazy person.
You wound up being this easily dismissed person.
And it's very – in many ways, it's discouraged in a very powerful way.
And it can be devastating.
graham hancock
Because there has been a hugely well-organized and well-funded propaganda war.
Against these substances.
Our society prides itself on the alert problem-solving state of consciousness.
And the alert problem-solving state of consciousness does have an important role to play.
But part of the madness of our society, why it's become so suicidally dangerous, is because the alert problem-solving state of We're good to go.
I think we're good to go.
They don't want people thinking for themselves.
They don't want the propaganda to be unpicked by a mushroom.
And that's why we face this propaganda war.
And what we're dealing with is the legacy of that propaganda war.
And the majority of people, unfortunately, don't realize that they've been subjected to 50 or 60 years of lying propaganda.
They think it's actually all facts.
And this is what needs to be unpicked.
joe rogan
We're in the middle of a crisis in this country in regards to police violence and police brutality, and a big part of that is the war on drugs.
andy stumpf
It's a giant part of it.
joe rogan
It's responsible for the Breonna Taylor murder, which is being discussed right now, and people are protesting.
That was a war on drugs.
Absolutely.
No-knock raid.
I mean, that's what that's about.
And most of these...
graham hancock
It's not a war on drugs at all.
This is the thing.
It's a completely maniacal idea because ultimately it's not a war on drugs.
And I've used this phrase before.
It's a war on consciousness.
Our society does not want certain kinds of consciousness to be experienced.
It wants to shut them down.
And it treats us like children.
If adults are not free to make sovereign decisions about their own health, their own consciousness, and their own bodies while doing no harm to others, then freedom is a meaningless word.
Unfortunately, freedom is a meaningless word in the societies we live in today.
We do live in a heavily mind-controlled society where facts are – where propaganda is disguised as fact.
joe rogan
I agree with you, but I think this battleship is slowly turning.
It is.
These kind of conversations that we're having right now, it's responsible in a big way for shifting the way people perceive these things.
For the longest time, the only way we've been explained to, the only way these subjects have been explained to us has been In demeaning terms.
And that these are bad experiences and you're going to wreck your life.
You're going to ruin your life.
And when we're here saying, well, maybe it'll make you a better person.
These are revolutionary thoughts in the 21st century.
And the fact that there's so many people that are echoing these statements.
And so many really intelligent, well-educated people who haven't ruined their lives.
Who have families and jobs.
And they're saying, no, this is actually good for you.
graham hancock
I think it needs to be recast in the issue of individual freedom and individual sovereignty.
Of course there must be limits on individual freedom.
We must not do harm to others.
In exercising our freedom.
But really, taking a psychedelic is the least harmful thing it's possible to do to anybody.
It's an entirely inward experience.
And it should not be controlled by the state and by government.
What's happening here is that we're literally being treated like children as adults.
And it's a most unfortunate aspect of our society.
And the way I I see government seeking to use the current crisis to add to its power, to dominate people's lives, to even enter into their homes, to encourage neighbors to snoop on one another.
It's a very insidious trend that we're in, and the war on drugs has been a big part of that trend for a long time.
But you're right, Joe, the battleship is turning around, and it's turning around because people are waking up and they're saying we're just not going to put up with this shit any longer.
We're not going to be told what to do.
We're not going to be treated as infants by our government.
joe rogan
And the thing about the psychedelic argument, too, it falls apart, the idea of criminalizing it, because it lacks all of the rationalizations that you can get with crystal meth and cocaine and death and We're good to go.
graham hancock
and they harm somebody else.
We have a law governing that harm that they've done to somebody else.
We don't need to have a law that enters the sanctum of the individual's consciousness and tells that person what he or she may think and what he or she may experience.
It's a really Huxley-esque or Orwell-esque world that we're messing with here.
joe rogan
Now, when you talk to Ruck about Christianity and about the use of the Amanita muscaria mushroom, does he echo the statements of John Marco Does he buy into that, or does he have a parallel perspective on it?
brian muraresku
It's kind of a hybrid.
In some of his writings, he's a fan of the Amanita.
In others, he takes a broader approach.
And I think that was my approach looking at this too, because the one thing that pops out at you from the ancient Christian world is wine.
And the one thing that pops out at you from the ancient Greek world is this spiked wine.
And Ruck does write quite a bit about that in The Road to Eleusis.
The same book in 1978 where he talks about this ergotized beer.
He is also talking about spiked wine.
But again, there wasn't much data to go on for the longest time.
So same as I was kind of scouring...
The ancient world for evidence of this ergotized beer.
I took it upon myself to put his other crazy thesis to the test.
And I started looking at wine in the ancient world.
Not just for the Amanita.
And I did look for it, by the way.
I looked for evidence.
I didn't find any.
But I found other evidence.
And it starts at the Louvre.
If I can show you a couple pictures.
Jamie, can you go to the Louvre?
joe rogan
That's the first time anybody's ever said that to you, Jamie.
Jamie, can you go to the Louvre?
brian muraresku
So in an obscure footnote from 1978, Ruck talks about a Greek priestess's spiking wine.
And he makes a reference to an old book from the early 20th century by a German scholar called Friedkenhaus.
And Friedkenhaus talked about this vase that was apparently in the Louvre that nobody had ever seen.
And I took it upon myself to try and find that vase.
And so at the very top, Jamie, if you click on the drawing...
This is a line drawing by Frickenhaus himself of what he apparently saw in the Louvre at some point in the early 20th century and not many people have seen since.
joe rogan
So this is his illustration of what he recalls being on the...
brian muraresku
Exactly.
Exactly.
And if you take a look at it or zoom into the woman on the right, you can see her preparing additives for the wine.
And we can't really make out what they are.
But the way Frickenhaus drew it, it kind of looks like a mushroom in her left hand.
You can't really tell.
Ruck says the other one is a sprig of some herb.
And again, you can't really tell.
So I sent an email to the curator at the Louvre, Alexandra Cartiano, and I said, I'd like to take a look at this and I'd like to bring my friend along.
And my friend is Father Francis Tissot, Roman Catholic priest, who happens to be an expert botanist and herbalist.
So I called up Father Francis from his laboratory in the rustic parts of Italy, and I said, Father Francis, since you're trained at Columbia and Cornell and Harvard Divinity School, and you know everything about plants, will you come help identify this for me?
And so he said, sure.
So we met at the Louvre, and we meet Alexandra, and Alexandra says, you know, this vase, I can find it for you, but it's not on exhibition.
This is not in the public catalog.
This is in our storage room.
And if you want, I can take you to the storage room and show you this vase you've been looking for.
And I said, great.
And she takes us up to the second floor, past the statue of the Winged Victory of Samothrace, and she ushers us into this completely empty stock room filled with thousands and thousands of Greek wine vessels.
And there, sitting on a table, on the next picture, Jamie, are what she calls G408 and G409, And I believe this is one of the first color photographs taken of them.
joe rogan
There it is.
brian muraresku
And so we don't know what's happening here, but we've moved from those mysteries of Eleusis to the mysteries of Dionysus.
And there's Father Francis with the magnifying glass trying to figure out what they're adding to the wine.
And again, it's just a painting, right?
We don't know if this is recording an actual event, but we're speculating that maybe the artist tried to record something for posterity.
joe rogan
And this vase is from?
brian muraresku
5th century BC. It's called Red Figure Pottery.
So pretty old.
And we take a look, and as we lean in further, I have a mini heart attack because the pottery's been chipped.
Just where she's holding the other ingredient.
joe rogan
Oh no.
brian muraresku
We have no idea what's in the right hand, but I'll let you try and guess what you think is in the left hand on the next close-up.
So that's completely missing there, and this is all we have left.
joe rogan
Boy, what is that?
It certainly could be a mushroom.
But it could be a lot of things, right?
brian muraresku
It could be a lot of things.
So it was a little disappointing.
unidentified
Yeah.
joe rogan
Wow, so when he originally saw it, it hadn't been chipped, so it happened...
brian muraresku
So maybe, I mean, this is how this stuff goes missing.
This is how this stuff stays secret.
We don't know how or why it was chipped.
Maybe he saw it chipped.
It was probably chipped at some point in its long 2,500-year history, and he just invented something to put there.
joe rogan
Could be.
brian muraresku
What I was hoping to find was what you'll see in the next few slides.
And this is from a separate Hudrya, 5th century BC, at a museum in Turkey.
And this is something Ruck has turned up over recent years.
These are women, very similar Dionysian tradition, adding plants and herbs to their wine.
Ruck identifies that as ivy.
If you lean in, if you go to the next one, Jamie.
Ivy is often associated with Dionysus.
Some of the ancient writers refer to wine spiked with ivy as drunkenness.
joe rogan
Look at their eyes.
Those ladies are tripping balls.
Look at their eyes.
They're like, woo!
Don't you think?
Look at their eyes.
That's not normal.
unidentified
Yeah.
joe rogan
They are wide-eyed.
brian muraresku
The next ingredient's more interesting.
So there's the second ingredient, and the next slide.
joe rogan
Mmm.
Yeah, very much the same mushroom.
graham hancock
Very mushroom, yeah.
joe rogan
I mean, that would be hard to describe that as anything else.
unidentified
Mm-hmm.
joe rogan
Yeah.
Wow.
brian muraresku
So this is where the pottery takes us, which is not very far.
I mean, maybe the artist meant to leave a clue.
Maybe it represents an actual ritual.
Maybe it doesn't.
We do know that the ancient authors are talking about this stuff a lot.
You can go to the next slide, Jamie.
And after that...
Whatever the wine was doing to people, this is what it was doing.
So when you drank the wine of Dionysus, this is like that Comos I showed you, that vase from Spain.
This is not quite a Comos, but it's another kind of ritual parade.
This is also in the Louvre.
If you head downstairs to the Sal de Cajiatid, you'll see the Borghese vase from 40 BC. And before that, this is...
This is typically how an initiate of the Dionysian Mysteries would be pictured.
And the next one, Jamie.
Right.
Before that.
So when they drank the wine of Dionysus, it wasn't to get drunk.
joe rogan
Which one are you?
brian muraresku
Number 15. Borghese, yeah.
So, I've never seen anyone walk up the middle aisle in a Catholic Mass and walk away looking like that.
joe rogan
Yeah, that dude looks smashed, though.
It doesn't look like he's on mushrooms.
He looks drunk.
What is that thing above his shoulder, though?
That looks like a mushroom.
brian muraresku
So that's called a thersos, and the top part's called the narthex, cognate with narcotics.
And Ruck thinks it's where they stuffed all the additives.
It's where they stuffed all the toxins for the wine.
And you often see the initiates of Dionysus carrying these, and you often see them over the head of the initiate.
They didn't go anywhere without their thyrsos wands.
joe rogan
And this wand, what was the top of it made out of?
brian muraresku
Like bundled leaves.
It was a hollow stalk with bundled leaves in there, ruckba leaves, that they would put their stash in.
unidentified
Wow.
joe rogan
So their whole thing was just adding things to alcohol, adding things to wine, adding things to beer.
brian muraresku
In fact, it would be abnormal not to add something to wine.
So wine is routinely described in the ancient Greek as unusually intoxicating, seriously mind-altering, occasionally hallucinogenic, and potentially lethal.
And for that reason, one of the words used to describe wine for like a thousand years from Homer to the fall of the Roman Empire was farmacon, which is drug.
That's the word they used ritually, formulaically to describe wine because it was routinely spiked with toxins and herbs and plants.
joe rogan
Now, was this just when they were having these rituals?
But when they were eating, they would just drink wine normally, right?
brian muraresku
There was everyday table wine, like we have today.
joe rogan
Right.
brian muraresku
But it was more, you know, they wouldn't take two pills with a glass of water.
They would dissolve their medicine into wine.
Wine is described by Pat McGovern at UPenn, for example, as the universal palliative.
That's how you would self-administer medicine.
It's why Dioschorides, when I mentioned in the Materia Medica from the first century AD, it's why he has all these recipes.
A lot of them are just medicinal.
You know, not all of them resulted in these fantastic visions.
When he talked about your swollen genitals, it's because he was trying to offer a recipe for that.
And that goes back hundreds and hundreds of years into the Greek tradition.
But the interesting part of it is that if you go all the way back to Homer, 8th, 7th century BC, you do find this other kind of wine being mixed.
Wine for a ritualistic purpose, like Circe, the famous witch, the daughter of Hecate, who we found in Spain.
So Circe is routinely, again, mixing, Homer calls it farmaca lugra, evil drugs, into the wine.
You could also mix healing drugs into the wine, but there was essentially a whole pharmacopoeia available to them.
unidentified
Wow.
joe rogan
Thank God you wrote this book, man!
unidentified
PJ! There's more.
joe rogan
Keep going, man.
brian muraresku
There's more, PJ. Okay, so for a long, long time, it's been the literature.
It's been vase and pottery.
It's been statuary like the Borghese vase.
The whole point I wrote this book is, again, to apply 21st century science to it.
So in my conversations with Pat McGovern and Andrew Coe at MIT, I started to find the initial clues for actual wine that was actually spiked, not just in the abstract.
So Jamie, if you open this up real quick to graveyard wine, which is how I refer to it.
So if you look at graveyard wine, go to the number scorpion wine right there.
So I was looking for evidence of wine actually being spiked in antiquity.
This comes from Egypt.
This is at Abydos, 3150 BC. It's so old, it's pre-dynastic.
This is Scorpion I. They found 700 wine jars that were subjected to chemical analysis.
Pat McGovern did the testing.
And they found it to be spiked with savory, wormwood, blue tansy, balm, senna, coriander, germander, mint, sage, and thyme.
joe rogan
Whoa.
brian muraresku
And you can find that he published that in 2009, I believe, Ancient Egyptian Herbal Wines.
joe rogan
And Wyrmwood is some type of psychedelic, right?
brian muraresku
I thought that too.
It's not?
It is.
Artemisia absinthium is psychoactive.
McGovern thinks this was Artemisia seberi, which is a slightly different species.
But when you look at it from afar, there's something more than just table wine there.
These were intentionally spiking the wine for a reason.
And they're deposited as grave goods for a reason.
And the reason would seem to be for ushering the pre-Pharaoh into the afterlife.
They were there with him to aid the journey, and we're not going to talk about the underworld journey in Egypt with Graham Hancock without asking Graham Hancock what he thinks about ancient Egyptian funerary practice.
graham hancock
Well, there's no doubt that the ancient Egyptians were very focused on death, not in a negative way.
They saw this life as our opportunity to prepare For the adventure and the challenge of death, that we had whatever years we got, 70, 90, 20, however many years we got, that was our opportunity to prepare for that great challenge of the journey that follows death.
And there's no doubt in my mind that the ancient Egyptians did make use of psychedelic substances.
The blue water lily from ancient Egypt being an example, jars of that Again, diluted in wine were found in the tomb of Tutankhamun.
This is a psychedelic brew.
And when you look at ancient Egyptian art, the entities which are very often part animal, part human in form, and which are teachers of mankind, you find yourself again in that same realm that People using psychedelics today find themselves in, DMT in particular, encountering entities that speak to us, that teach us, and that often take the form of part animal, part human, berianthropes.
joe rogan
It's so interesting to see the actual evidence of this use.
Do Egyptologists dismiss this?
Do they embrace this?
Is this something that is not controversial?
graham hancock
I think Egyptologists will say that the ancient Egyptians were neurotically focused on death.
I would say the opposite.
I would say they had a very balanced approach to death.
I mean, one thing is clear.
We're all gonna die.
Nobody doubts that.
Sooner or later, that moment in our life is gonna come where life ends.
And to me, that is an incredibly important moment.
And the ancient Egyptians, by devoting their culture to figuring out how we live best in order to cross that bridge, to transit into that other realm, were being very practical and very profound in their inquiries.
It wasn't that they were afraid of death.
They wanted to ready themselves for the journey that follows death and they made it very clear that everything we do in this life, everything counts.
Nothing is We're not separated away.
There's nothing that we can deny.
There's complete clarity in the afterlife realm.
Nothing can be hidden.
We're confronted with absolute truth.
And in a way, psychedelics are a preparation for that because psychedelics also confront us with absolute truth.
And that's why psychedelics can often be very uncomfortable because we see the truth about ourselves, but we're being given an opportunity To change ourselves for the better and to be more nurturing and more positive and more useful people.
And as a result, the ancient Egyptians would say to confront a better death.
joe rogan
What I was getting at was what is their reaction to the psychedelically spiked wine?
unidentified
Because I know you in particular… Egyptologists don't want anything to do with psychedelics.
graham hancock
They don't want anything to do with psychedelics.
They would prefer not to go there.
And just as there are many other aspects of ancient Egyptian culture that the Egyptologists don't want to go into, it often seems to me that they're in the process of trying to carve or shape ancient Egypt to fit into modern ideology.
And that's a great pity.
joe rogan
Well, it's also a great pity that, I mean, particularly with your work and the work that you've done with Dr. Robert Schock, describing some indications on some of the ancient structures that there was heavy erosion that was due to rainfall,
thousands of years of rainfall, which would have predated The conventional idea of when these things are constructed, the way that they resisted that, instead of looking at it like this fascinating new evidence that will illuminate this field and now we have some new perspective on this, they rejected it so horrifically and they were mocking.
I remember that.
Who was that one Egyptologist that openly mocked the concept of it?
graham hancock
But not just one.
joe rogan
There's a film in the one that there was the documentary.
Yes, the Charlton Heston narrated the documentary.
graham hancock
Yes, I think you may be speaking about Ken Fetter, but really I could cite a dozen Egyptologists who feel this way.
The notion that the Great Sphinx is 12,500 years old, which is a notion based on the erosion patterns on the body of the Sphinx, is utterly unacceptable to Egyptologists.
They just don't want to go there.
They don't want to consider that possibility because they feel that they've got ancient Egyptian history taped.
That it begins about 5,000 years ago.
There's a bit of a precursor in the pre-dynastic period, a thousand or so years building up to ancient Egypt.
And then you have ancient Egyptian civilization and gradually it merges with the Greeks and with other cultures and spreads out around the world.
The notion that there is a background to ancient Egyptian civilization that goes back into the Ice Age is a notion that no Egyptologist is prepared to accept.
The moment they start accepting that notion, they cease to be Egyptologists in the view of their colleagues.
It's a very dangerous idea to contemplate.
And that's why I spent the last quarter of a century trying to argue the case for a lost civilization that, you know, maybe I'm not right about everything, but we shouldn't neglect the hints and the clues, whether it comes from astronomy, whether it comes from geometry, whether it comes from geology, whether it comes whether it comes from geometry, whether it comes from geology, whether it comes from the statements of the ancient Egyptians themselves about their origins We shouldn't be ignoring this.
We should consider it.
And you're right.
Rather than reacting with fury to the notion of a much more ancient Sphinx, it would have been nice to have seen the Egyptological profession react with interest to it and begin to explore it and consider what it might mean because the geology is irrefutable.
But largely ignored.
joe rogan
The erosion, was it on the body of the Sphinx or was it on the walls of the temple where the Sphinx was carved out of?
graham hancock
Well, where you can see it today is...
So the Sphinx is carved out of solid bedrock.
It's carved out of the bedrock of the Giza Plateau.
And in order to do that, an enormous trench was created around the body of the Sphinx.
And in fact, the blocks that were excavated from that trench were then moved over and used to build what are called the Valley Temple and the Sphinx Temple, where in some cases you find blocks of limestone that weigh close to 200 tons.
And what has happened since then is that the body of the Sphinx has been subjected to multiple restorations.
In fact, one of the arguments that Egyptologists just ignore is that already in the Old Kingdom, at the time when the Sphinx is supposed to have been made according to conventional Egyptology, already in the Old Kingdom they were restoring it.
And there are restoration blocks on the body of the Sphinx that date back four and a half thousand years.
And that process of restoring and renovating the Sphinx has gone on down the ages.
It's still happening today.
The pores of the Sphinx as we see them today are covered entirely with modern restoration blocks.
We don't see the bedrock underneath it, but where we do see the original bedrock is in the walls of that trench that was carved out to create the The body of the Sphinx in the first place, because nobody's been restoring those.
And it's in those that you see this characteristic undulating pattern that speaks of exposure to a very long period of heavy, heavy rainfall.
And the last time you have that heavy rainfall in Egypt is the period that geologists call the Younger Dryas, roughly between 12,800 and 11,600 years ago.
So the body of the Sphinx The trench out of which it is carved is saying, I am 12,000 years old.
And the only argument against that really is the head of the Sphinx being the typical head of an ancient Egyptian pharaoh with the Nemes headdress.
But of course, the head of the Sphinx was originally a lion, just as the body of the Sphinx is a lion.
And the head of the Sphinx was re-carved in dynastic times to give it this human form.
joe rogan
The reaction to that notion and this hard geological data that Robert Schock provided was just the most disturbing part of it.
graham hancock
Let's pay tribute to John Anthony West.
Because it was John Anthony West who originally had that brilliant insight.
That what we're looking at in the case of the Sphinx is water weathering.
And he rightly pays tributes to Schwaller de Lubix, an earlier scholar who was the first to notice this.
And John then brought Robert Schock to Egypt as a professional geologist.
Robert is professor of geology at the University of Boston and brought him there.
And Robert Schock indeed concluded that we are looking at water weathering on the body of the Sphinx.
And gradually, Robert...
7,000 or 8,000 years old, but much more recently he's also settled on the date of roughly 12,000 years old as the last time that you would get that sort of heavy rainfall in Egypt that could have created that characteristic weathering.
joe rogan
And I would encourage anybody who's interested in this to please check out John Anthony West's Magical Egypt series because it's amazing.
I've probably seen it 15 times.
graham hancock
I'm so glad that you had John on your show.
I know it's very rare that you do things by Skype.
joe rogan
We did it in person as well.
I had him on twice.
I had him on in person before he died and I had him on Skype before that.
graham hancock
What an amazing man he was.
Such a radical, such an incendiary...
You know, just planting intellectual bombs in the accepted wisdom of the modern world and making us all think again.
So I think when it comes to the age of the Sphinx, it's really important to realize the role that John Anthony West played, and I'm so glad that you had him on your show.
joe rogan
Yeah, I am as well.
It was a real honor.
graham hancock
He was a dear friend of mine, and I was with him just a month before his death, and he went into that journey of death with enormous courage and absolute certainty.
joe rogan
Now, when these vessels were tested and these psychedelic compounds were detected, what was the reaction?
Was there resistance to this?
How was it received?
brian muraresku
We don't think they're properly psychedelic just yet.
I mean, all the ingredients that that...
joe rogan
Psychoactive?
brian muraresku
Psychoactive, medicinal for sure.
It gets...
There wasn't much backlash that I know of after McGovern's study.
It was a gold standard study.
And then it continued, by the way.
So after those 700 jars at Abydos, after further analysis, they determined that the plants and herbs actually originated in the Holy Land.
In the Southern Levin, they weren't native to Egypt.
They had been brought there or they were shipped there by the folks in the Holy Land, which gets more interesting because the next big find was the world's oldest wine cellar, which was published in 2014. It came from Tel Cabri, which is also in Galilee.
Remember, this is going to be the same Galilee that Jesus comes on the scene and Christianity bursts across the planet.
So at Tel Cabri in 2014, they found another stash of wine, dubbed the world's oldest wine cellar, also subjected to archaeochemical analysis.
And what Andrew Coe and the team there found was wine spiked with honey, storax, terebinth, cypress, cedar, juniper, mint, myrtle, and cinnamon, or at least cinnamaldehyde.
Another very strange mixture.
graham hancock
Doesn't sound very psychedelic, though.
joe rogan
No.
brian muraresku
No.
joe rogan
Not at all.
So they just were into spiking wine.
brian muraresku
They love spiking wine.
But what Andrew Koh says about it is interesting, though.
And that's why I reached out to him originally.
Because he says that spiking wine with this many ingredients is indicative of a very sophisticated understanding of the botanical landscape.
And he says, quote, it demonstrates the pharmacopeic skills necessary to balance preservation, palatability, and psychoactivity.
He uses that word.
Preservation, like in the terebinth, for example, you know, resonating the wine so it doesn't spoil to vinegar.
And then palatability, if there is cinnamon or honey that you mentioned before, too, it would improve the flavor profile.
But then psychoactivity, who knows?
We don't know which juniper it was, but there is juniper used in other psychoactive ceremonies.
There's a species of juniper, Juniperus recurva, which occurs near the Himalayas, actually.
And I've seen videos, really cool videos, if you want to pull it up, Jamie.
You can look up, if you Google, anybody can do this, GB shaman.
If you look up GB space shaman, you'll see a ritual of someone inhaling the juniper, the incense from juniper, and going into trance.
joe rogan
How much is written about wine and the additives and all the different things they put to wine?
Well, let's watch this first.
brian muraresku
There's not much written about it.
You might have to skip forward, but this is them essentially preparing...
joe rogan
What are we looking at here?
brian muraresku
So that's what they call the betayo.
The betayo are the traditional healer prophets and shamans of this tribe in the Hindu Kush.
And what they do is they inhale the incense from burning juniper and then suck the blood from a goat head.
graham hancock
Wow.
joe rogan
Jesus Christ.
graham hancock
The things people get up to.
joe rogan
That's what happens when you outlaw psychedelics.
People try anything.
Can I get mushrooms?
Yeah, suck a goat head.
Wow.
brian muraresku
This is the Hunza people, and it says it puts him into a trance whereby he's able to communicate with the fairies.
joe rogan
Look at that guy, skeptical.
He's like, I'm not buying it.
This guy's always been annoying.
It's like, oh, he just wants to put on a robe and dance.
And he kind of looks like a guy who would do that, too.
And there's the headless goat.
brian muraresku
The headless goat, exactly.
joe rogan
Oh, boy.
Hey, boy.
And what, is there a, do they explain?
Oh, here he goes.
He's sucking on the goat head.
Okay, this guy's annoying.
Look at him.
Look at how he's dancing.
And he's putting on a show.
Everybody's like, look at him.
And he's like, look at me.
I'm sucking on a goat head.
I'm so crazy.
I bet the goat head doesn't really do anything.
I bet the goat head is just so he gets extra attention.
Look at the kids.
Like, wow, this guy's crazy.
Look at him.
Yeah, a little bit of Borat in there, too.
Wow.
Okay.
Now, is it usually more than one person?
This is what's odd, is that this one guy is tripping balls, and then he collapses, and then everybody else is just going, oh, it's Marty.
Look at Marty.
Marty's getting crazy.
And then he's going to rinse his hands off.
Hmm.
And is this something that other people...
This is what's weird about this video.
It seems like one person is having a psychedelic ritual and the rest of them are just watching this guy.
brian muraresku
He was the spiritual technician, the way you find in other traditional societies.
He was the one who trained to navigate that other world and learn the fairy language, apparently.
joe rogan
Fairy language?
brian muraresku
The fairy language.
joe rogan
Hmm.
Yeah, it is weird that those fairies and elves and all these different things exist in so many different cultures.
And they are what you do see if you do take enough psychedelics or the right kind in the right setting.
brian muraresku
Is that true?
joe rogan
Yeah.
I've met gestures.
graham hancock
It's true.
My take on this when I wrote Supernatural is that we have three supposedly different domains of experience.
We have the spirits who shamans encounter in altered states of consciousness.
We have fairies and elves from the Middle Ages.
Very often in illustrations you'll see that the mushrooms are present in the illustrations.
And then today we have aliens.
And at the level of phenomena, there are extremely close similarities between the entities that we call aliens today.
The entities that were called fairies or elves in the Middle Ages, and the entities that shamans refer to as spirits.
And I would say actually what we're dealing with is the same experience in all three cases, but viewed through different cultural lenses and construed in different ways.
And the only thing that really explains these kinds of experiences, where any one of us can actually share that experience and have that experience, It's psychedelics.
Powerful psychedelics like DMT will plunge us into that realm of experience and we will meet entities and many people today do construe those entities as aliens because that's how our culture is dealing with the other today.
joe rogan
Have you ever experienced anything that looked like what the classic iconic alien is?
graham hancock
Yeah, I have.
joe rogan
You have?
Really?
graham hancock
Absolutely.
In one of my early ayahuasca experiences in the Amazon, I saw flying, my eyes were closed, but I saw flying saucers.
And then I saw this classic sort of quote-unquote grey with that high domed forehead and narrow pointed chin and these really grim eyes looking down on me.
I think I may have mentioned this on your show before, but what I really regret doing, I felt I was going to be taken.
I felt I was going to be abducted.
And I opened my eyes and I shouted, no!
Of course!
joe rogan
Of course!
graham hancock
I should have kept my eyes closed and said, yes!
Take me!
But I didn't do that and I've never encountered them in that quite alien form again.
joe rogan
That's a bummer.
graham hancock
Yes, it is a bummer.
And we have to consider the possibility that these are not simply concoctions of our brains, that the brain is a much more complicated mechanism than we think it is, and that In certain circumstances, when brain chemistry is altered in the right way, we gain access to other levels of reality that are normally closed off to our senses.
That is personally my view that what's happening with psychedelics.
I can't prove that that's the case.
But the sense that we are entering a seamlessly convincing parallel world, that it is inhabited by intelligent beings, and that they have things to say to us.
First of all, this is universal.
People who've worked with psychedelics all around the world have had those experiences.
And secondly, I just don't see this.
I don't see why we've all got a brain module for this.
I think we are actually peering through the doorway into another level of reality.
But it's going to take a whole lot more research to prove that.
That's just my own personal opinion.
joe rogan
My personal opinion mirrors yours.
My feelings have always been when I do psychedelics that I've tuned into a frequency that's unavailable to me during regular states of consciousness.
It doesn't seem like a hallucination.
It seems like I entered into a doorway and I'm in a new place and there's an urgency to it because I know that I'm not going to be able to stay here for very long.
And they seem to know that and they seem to communicate with you in a very urgent way.
And one of the things that I've talked about, I've talked about this experience before, one of the most profound ones, I met jesters who were giving me the finger.
And they seem to be explaining to me that I take myself too seriously.
It felt like, and then when I went, oh, okay, they went, yes.
graham hancock
Yeah, you got it.
joe rogan
You got it.
I was like, oh, yeah, you're right.
unidentified
Yeah.
joe rogan
It was a feeling like, oh yeah, okay.
You think of yourself too highly.
graham hancock
That's why the subtitle of my book, Supernatural, back in 2006 was Meetings with the Ancient Teachers of Mankind.
And I think that's what's going on here.
I think that the psychedelics allow us to enter a realm where we encounter teachers who can help us to be better people and perhaps to be a better civilization.
joe rogan
Well, that was one of the more interesting things about, I believe it was University of Jerusalem, their take on what Moses in the burning bush was, that very likely the burning bush was the acacia tree, which is very rich in dimethyltryptamine.
graham hancock
DMT.
joe rogan
Yeah, and that this was what, I mean, when you say it that way, like, oh, of course, Moses, the burning bush, was God talking to him.
And you think about the translation between ancient Hebrew and then to Latin and to Greek and all these, and then the English eventually, like, of course there's going to be a lot lost in the translation.
But if you just looked at it that way, you'd be like, oh, so that's a psychedelic drug.
Oh, of course, you've done that.
Oh, if you do, you kind of do meet something that seems like you would describe as God, and it's very moral.
graham hancock
Yeah, you meet – in what other state of consciousness do you meet intelligent plants that communicate with you?
joe rogan
Right.
graham hancock
You know, that's – It's very hard to imagine any other state of consciousness apart from the psychedelic state.
And what you're citing is the work of Benny Shannon, who is a professor at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem, and he has drunk ayahuasca himself at least 700 times.
joe rogan
Well, he's suspect then.
I don't know if we should listen to him anymore.
graham hancock
Exactly.
Any scholar who goes into this area and really does it properly faces skepticism and being shoved off to the side by his or her colleagues.
It takes courage to do this work.
work.
But what we need is more scientists doing this work, girding up their courage and getting on with it, because we need to learn about this aspect of ourselves.
We've just got such an incomplete picture at the moment.
joe rogan
But it all falls into place if you look at it under that description.
And I'm glad he has the courage to step up and actually put this description out there.
I remember someone sent it to me in an email, and I was like, aha!
Like, there it is.
Of course.
graham hancock
Benny Shannon's book is called Ayahuasca, the Antipodes of the Mind.
It's a really important piece of work, but not widely enough read in my view.
joe rogan
Is there a cultural version of ayahuasca where there is an MAO inhibitor and a plant with dimethyltryptamine outside of the Amazon?
Is there an equivalent?
Sure.
graham hancock
Well, sure.
That was also part of Benny Shannon's argument in ancient Israel, that you have mimosas, certain mimosas, which contain the DMT, and then you have harmoline in other plants that contain the monoamine oxidase inhibitors.
So you can have these What are called ayahuasca analogues, which are doing essentially the same thing.
I've consumed ayahuasca analogues myself, and they are very like ayahuasca, but not quite.
There is a difference.
Again, I'm going to sound very mystical and kind of woo-woo here, but there is a spirit in ayahuasca.
It's a female spirit.
unidentified
spirit.
graham hancock
It's a goddess.
And I've not encountered her with the analogs, only with ayahuasca from the Amazon.
joe rogan
And what have the analogs been like?
The experience is still psychedelic?
graham hancock
Yes, very much so.
The visions, the encounters with entities, the amazing geometric patterns, and the self-reflection.
What the fuck have I been doing with my life up till now?
Why did I make that mistake?
Why did I hurt that person in that way?
But that feeling of a direct intimate encounter with a, I call her a goddess.
I mean, sometimes she appears in, and I can hear my critics out there laughing at me now.
Hancock has completely lost it.
But sometimes she appears in the form of a human woman, sometimes in the form of a serpent.
And then, you know, we get into the whole issue of the Garden of Eden and the story of the Garden of Eden and the role that the serpent plays in that story.
And the role that the serpent plays in that story is pointing out to Adam and Eve that God has basically lied to them.
And he offers Adam and Eve the forbidden fruit.
Alex Gray, my friend, the visionary artist Alex Gray, calls it the first psychedelic slapdown.
That's what the Garden of Eden is.
So, you know, there are these intriguing experiences that are unleashed with these substances.
But to my mind, there is something very special about ayahuasca.
It's a living ancient technology.
You can trace it back thousands of years in the Amazon world.
And it's now coming out of the Amazon and finding its way around the world.
joe rogan
And that ancient fresco that shows Adam and Eve standing by mushrooms is very bizarre as well, right?
graham hancock
Yeah, absolutely.
Again, our psychedelic heritage has been hidden from us.
And that is why I value Brian's book, The Immortality Key, so much because it's done the solid scientific groundwork to begin to give academic scientists permission To investigate this field.
And that's what we need.
We need much more work done in this field than has been done already.
joe rogan
Man, how good does it feel to have put this down to paper and just set it?
Or do you feel like now that it's out there, you have a lot of explaining to do?
brian muraresku
I think there's lots of explaining to do.
It's funny though, and we haven't gotten into too much of the Christian material yet, but I went through the Vatican quite a bit when I was writing this, with different departments at the Vatican.
The Vatican Secret Archives and the Archive of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and the Vatican Museums and all the catacombs in Rome.
And I went through there spelunking with Father Francis.
And to be totally honest, the Vatican couldn't have been nicer or more accommodating to me.
And while some of this is controversial, they've been very supportive to date.
And I say that as someone who went to 13 years of Catholic school.
including four years with the Jesuits, they always encouraged me to ask questions about the origins of the faith.
And there's lots and lots of questions there.
There's a reason that today you can look around and find 33,000 denominations of Christianity.
I think that was the case from the very beginning.
There was never one monolithic form of the faith.
And people didn't go to bed in 33 AD as pagans and wake up in 34 AD as Christians.
It was a process, an intercultural process, that took hundreds of years, which I call Paleo-Christianity, which I think for anyone interested in the faith is kind of the most interesting part.
These are the earliest and most authentic Christians, but they were living in a world where the blood of goats and all this spiked wine was the norm.
And as a matter of fact, Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. wrote about this, of all people.
Yeah, this is called the Pagan Continuity Hypothesis.
The idea that Christianity wasn't born in a vacuum.
In 1950, Dr. King wrote a paper called The Influence of the Mystery Religions on Christianity.
You can Google it.
You can Google it and you can Google it and you can read it.
This was not controversial woo-woo stuff, at least in 1950. When I went to the Vatican, I was really fortunate.
joe rogan
We hired a professional guide who was a professor.
brian muraresku
There it is.
joe rogan
The Influence of the Mystery of Religions and Christianity.
Dr. Martin Luther King.
unidentified
Wow.
brian muraresku
It's impressive.
joe rogan
It's amazing.
We got really fortunate.
We have this amazing guide and we were in the middle of this one area of the Vatican and there was a giant pine cone.
brian muraresku
Oh, yeah.
The Cortile della Pina.
joe rogan
Yeah, and so he brought it up.
Like, what do you think that stands for?
And I said, probably the pineal gland.
And his eyes lit up and we had this conversation.
And then we started talking about drugs.
brian muraresku
You know too much, Joe Rogan.
joe rogan
And so he just loved the fact that I knew that and that I was into this.
And then we had a fantastic time.
But there's a lot of...
Mushroom imagery and iconic mushroom shapes and this connection between mushrooms and Christianity, you can find it.
There's a lot of...
One of the weirder ones, when Jack Harrow was alive, he was working on...
Jack Harrow was a guy who was a Goldwater Republican and became a cannabis advocate when he...
He got divorced and met a girlfriend, and he thought pot was for losers, but he just wanted to get high with this cute girl, and smoked a little pot.
He's like, where has this been all my life?
unidentified
Holy shit!
joe rogan
And then he became a cannabis advocate, and I was very fortunate to meet him before he died, and he was showing me some stuff that he was working on.
But one of the things that he was working on after he wrote that book, The Emperor Wears No Clothes, but...
Then he was writing a book about mushrooms in Christianity and there was these ancient images of these naked people dancing in ecstasy and they were surrounded by this translucent mushroom image.
It was really fascinating and there was a lot of these images and images that were the shape of doors that were carved out in the form of a mushroom.
It only makes sense if you know what psychedelic mushrooms do when you take them.
You have these incredible experiences, and the idea that a religion would emerge out of these experiences is not unusual at all.
brian muraresku
No, especially if it was common in ancient Greece.
That's why I try to focus on that continuity from the ancient Greeks to the Christians, because again, these are the same people.
The earliest Christians were all Greek speaking.
When Paul is writing his letters, which is the majority of the New Testament, the 21 of the 27 books of the New Testament, he's writing in Greek to Greek people.
He's writing to the Corinthians who speak Greek, the Thessalonians and Thessaloniki, now the second largest city in Greece, the Philippians, and then in modern day Turkey to the Ephesians and Colossians and Galatians.
You know, Christianity is born in Galilee, or at least grows up in Galilee, but it doesn't take root there.
It goes to the Greek speakers, and it goes across all the Greek-influenced areas, including Magna Graecia, which is Great Greece, which is southern Italy, which happens to be the same place where the Catholic Church put down its roots 2,000 years ago.
The reason for that was because the early church was all Greek, and these were people who were steeped in the traditions of their ancestors.
I mean, imagine abandoning the religion of your grandparents for this new wine god from one day to the next.
It doesn't make that much sense.
The thesis of the book is that the Eucharist for some communities, at some point in time, at some area in this Greek-speaking part of the world, would have availed themselves of the kind of sacraments that were available to the Greeks for generations and generations.
And so we're still looking for the smoking gun of that ancient Greek spiked wine.
It's not there.
We talked about the Abydos wine in Egypt.
The herbal wine from Tel Kabri in Galilee.
So we've been looking in Greece and Turkey and Italy and elsewhere for that, you know, Greek spiked wine and haven't quite found it yet.
But Andrew Ko is very interested in continuing to test and find more things.
But in the meantime, we did find spiked wine.
joe rogan
Yeah, so you have evidence of spiked wine.
Now it's just finding it in Greece.
brian muraresku
I think you want to find it in Greece to tie it to Dionysus.
You want to find it in Italy to tie it to the Christians, because that's really the area where the church, again, puts down roots and begins to grow up in that period of paleo-Christianity.
And so, just like I was looking for that ergotized beer, I was looking for evidence of where you could properly call it psychedelic wine may have popped up.
And there is one article in one archaeobotany journal from 20 years ago that talks about spiked wine.
Which was news to me, too, because every single time I go to the Pat McGoverns and Andrew Coes and all the top archaeobotanists in Europe, the answer you get back, just like the answer to the question, where is the spiked beer?
The answer is, there isn't any.
And it's another case of this evidence just either being ignored or underreported.
But there was a young, at the time, archaeobotanist, Marina Ceraldi, Who's from Naples and got her PhD in archaeology in the UK and she's on site in Pompeii testing these vessels.
We have a lot of evidence from Pompeii, by the way.
In fact, a lot of what we know about the ancient world comes from Pompeii and Herculaneum because of Mount Vesuvius in 79 AD. It explodes and destroys everything, but it also preserves everything.
Under like 17 feet of volcanic ash we have all these clues about the Dionysian mysteries and in addition to that there was this farmhouse in Scafati just to the east of Pompeii where there were seven dolia which is like a giant storage vessel And these dolia are found in a chela vinaria, like a wine cellar, in a farm that also came complete with a torcularium, like a wine press, and a threshing floor.
So something about wine was happening in this place.
We don't know what.
The sample was extraordinarily well-preserved.
When Marina went in there, it wasn't a chemical analysis.
That's obviously more finely graded.
The sample was in such good shape because it had been waterlogged.
So the botanical samples were in pristine condition, and she could tell by the seeds and stems and other plant material what was there.
And there were over 50 species of plants and herbs and trees in this one sample, which is really weird.
Even more than we found at Abydos or Telkavri.
It was, you know, like just a melange of plant material that shouldn't be there.
And what she found, in addition to many other medicinal plants, was opium, cannabis, henbane, and black nightshade.
joe rogan
What is henbane?
brian muraresku
Henbane is Hyoscyumus.
Hyoscyumine is one of those tropane alkaloids, that nightshade plant, that very witchy kind of plant that we found in the Cernos in Spain.
It was beer potentially spiked with henbane.
So we're finding wine spiked potentially with henbane.
We find four seeds at least.
There were two seeds of opium, nine seeds of cannabis, four seeds of henbane, and then two seeds of this black nightshade.
And in the article that describes it, Marina herself, the archaeobotanist, says this is some kind of spiced wine.
In fact, she calls it a Mithridatium.
Now, to understand that, there was this guy Mithridates.
Mithridates VI was the ruler of the Pontus region, in between the Black and Caspian Seas.
His father was poisoned to death.
And so, to prevent that, he would microdose his whole life.
He was poisoning himself.
Day in and day out.
And so this potion of many different toxic herbs and plants becomes known eventually in the Roman Empire as a Mithridatium, after Mithridates.
Now, when the Romans finally get to him and try and kill him, he tries to poison himself, and it doesn't work because he's immune.
So one of his soldiers has to stab him to death.
joe rogan
So he's micro dosing himself in preparation for someone else poisoning him.
brian muraresku
Exactly.
joe rogan
But then when he tries to commit suicide, he's unable to.
brian muraresku
Exactly.
joe rogan
Oh my God.
How strange.
And so outside of Pompeii, was there any other evidence and how would you go about finding it?
Like, say if you want to continue the search, where would you look?
brian muraresku
I mean, it opens up a whole world of possibilities now that people...
I mean, I wrote this as kind of...
I call them the initial archaeobotanical blips on the radar.
So between this ergotized beer and this potentially psychedelic wine, there's lots of different places to look.
If you're trying to prove this psychedelic hypothesis within paleo-Christianity...
You're looking for a place where the Dionysian mysteries bumped up against the Christian mysteries.
And that's all over the place.
So back in Galilee, for example, Dionysus, there's a whole myth around Dionysus and his birth.
And different authors place his birth in different places.
One of the places they place his birth is a city called Schythopolis.
Scythopolis was like the capital of the Decaiopolis, this 10-city part of the eastern Mediterranean.
From Nazareth to Scythopolis today is 40 minutes door-to-door, Nazareth where Jesus grows up.
So Scythopolis has this northern cemetery where you do find artifacts.
That relate both to the pagan Dionysian mysteries and some Christian artifacts.
So a place like that would be ripe for further investigation.
Or in Ephesus, you have like the Grotto of the Seven Sleepers.
Another place where the pagan mysteries bumped up against the Christian mysteries.
One of the best places is Rome.
And the catacombs, which is why I spent so much time going through the catacombs looking for evidence of these essentially funerary rituals where people were celebrating with the dead using the sacramental wine in the very earliest versions of the Mass.
joe rogan
And is there any scripture, any texts that are describing what they were doing when they were going through these rituals, these funeral rituals?
brian muraresku
I mean, there's a few things.
For the Christians, it's called the refrigerium.
The refrigerium in Latin means like a chill-out.
And there's a very respectable scholar, Ramsey McMullen.
He's considered one of the premier authorities of the ancient Roman world.
He describes the refrigerium as a place where the dead themselves participate.
And it's where the dead basically come back to life.
In the Roman world, you would never leave the dead alone.
Think of it like a funerary ritual in Mexico, for example, when the family goes to visit the graves of the ancestors.
There was a very similar principle in the ancient Roman world that carried over And so we know the refrigerium existed.
The big question is if the wine drunk at the refrigerium was similar to the wine of the early Christian Eucharist.
And when you look through these catacombs, you find really crazy stuff to suggest that, in fact, the two could coexist.
joe rogan
Wow, here we go.
Look at these images.
Now, the book's out.
The book's done.
Your thing now is obviously promoting this and getting the word out.
But do you have in your mind of following up on this research?
Now that the door's opened and now that people are aware of this, it seems like, first of all, I believe you're going to get help.
People are going to be interested in continuing this research and contributing to this research.
Where do you go from here?
brian muraresku
I want to dedicate my life to this for the next 10 years.
unidentified
Really?
brian muraresku
Yes.
Wow.
unidentified
How's PJ feel about that?
brian muraresku
I don't think PJ's too happy.
joe rogan
No?
unidentified
What if this sounds like gangbusters?
graham hancock
I think we need to take you down to the Amazon, Brian.
And you need to have an encounter with Mother Ayahuasca.
joe rogan
Or you could just go to Santa Cruz.
graham hancock
There's something about that rainforest, though.
joe rogan
Yeah, I'm sure.
graham hancock
It really is a special setting for this experience.
But I think it would be interesting, Brian.
Having written this as a scientific and an academic and a research exercise to then go on to see what your personal experience is and how that resonates with what you've learned as a scientific investigator.
joe rogan
Yeah, I mean, even if you wanted to do it in a clinical setting, like Rick Strassman did when he had these FDA-approved studies for DMT, the spirit molecule, just anything.
Just anything where you could tap into that world, because I guarantee you, you're going to come back eyes wide like those ladies in that drawing.
And you're going to be like, oh, okay.
It's fascinating to me when you talk to someone who is a psychedelic virgin, because you almost feel jealous.
Like, I almost...
Do you feel the same way, Graham?
graham hancock
Yeah, absolutely.
It would be nice to know that that experience lay ahead of us.
And we haven't had it yet.
But at the same time, you can learn to work with these substances.
They can be overwhelming at first.
And with more careful use of these substances, you begin to manage them better.
Not always, but usually.
joe rogan
So when you say you want to do this and dedicate your life for the next 10 years, do you have multiple books in mind?
What is your thought?
brian muraresku
So with this, my dream is to see this on the screen.
I think there's so many visual elements here.
joe rogan
What's up, Jamie?
Oh, sorry.
unidentified
Sorry.
brian muraresku
My dream is to see this on the screen.
I've been talking to a couple of development teams, a couple of production companies.
One is Anonymous Content in LA and Six West Media in New York.
Together we're developing a documentary series.
That adapts this, everything we've talked about for like a first season, but there's really multiple seasons here because there's so much evidence that's never been looked at.
And so it's taking the very best of the archaeochemistry and the very best of the on-in-the-field archaeology, combining all the linguistic evidence and the symbology and iconography and putting it together to find, once and for all, the smoking gun for the use of a psychedelic Eucharist in antiquity.
joe rogan
So do you have a place where you're bringing this?
brian muraresku
We are just about to pitch this, as a matter of fact.
joe rogan
Oh, Netflix.
Where you at?
Yeah.
Listen, I would watch that all day long.
I'm really excited.
I'm really excited about the whole thing, the whole prospect of it.
And I think that it's...
I'm just so happy that you became obsessed with it and ignored all the people telling you to not.
unidentified
Yeah.
brian muraresku
Me too, man.
I mean, it's been a long road.
I never thought about psychedelics until I read Supernatural.
A lot of weird stuff was happening in my life in 2007, 2008. After I read those initial studies that came out of Hopkins and NYU, of course I wanted to try psilocybin.
And then the mystery just got deeper and deeper and I realized there was a story to be told here that hadn't been told before and I think it needed a serious and sober look at this stuff.
So I really did spend nights and weekends doing nothing else but this kind of stuff and reading hundreds of books and thousands of journal articles and 12 years of Googling to try and put all these pieces together.
And I will say that, you know, it covers a lot of ground, but you don't need to know anything about history or archaeology, let alone archaeobotany or archaeochemistry or psychopharmacology or biblical studies or paleoanthropology to appreciate this, because I kind of take it one step at a time from the very beginning and show you every piece of evidence that, I mean, as a virgin, did convince me that this is at least worth a sober look from the scientific community.
joe rogan
Well, I hope two things.
Next time I talk to you, we're promoting this television show, and you can tell me about your psychedelic experience that you had with Graham.
brian muraresku
Did I agree to this already?
joe rogan
Yes, you agreed to it.
You agreed to it.
unidentified
You signed up.
graham hancock
You signed up, bro.
joe rogan
And Graham, hopefully next time we communicate, it'll actually be in the flesh when somebody works out this COVID nonsense.
graham hancock
I hope so.
Can I just mention, we've not talked about my book, but this is the hardback of America Before, which we talked about the last time I was on your show.
And America Before has been in hardback for the past 18 months, but it's coming out in paperback 29th of September 2020 at a much reduced price.
And I hope that people who've not been able to access the hardback will be able to have a look at it in the...
In the paperback.
I mean, we had an amazing conversation the last time I was on your show.
And before that, we had the drama with Michael Shermer.
Yes.
And Randall Carson was present and that guy, Mark Defant, came in by telephone.
And I want to pay tribute to Michael Shermer.
You may have noticed this, Joe, that Michael put out a tweet saying that he was going to have to reconsider his – essentially, I'm paraphrasing – he was going to have to reconsider his prior attitude to my work in the light of new evidence about the Younger Dryas impact catastrophe that, in my view, 12,000 years ago or so lost us a whole civilization.
It takes a lot to admit that one may have been wrong and I'm glad that Michael had the courage to put that tweet out there.
joe rogan
Yeah, I am as well.
Kudos to him and kudos to you and to Randall Carlson as well because those two conversations that we had about that are absolutely some of my favorite conversations of all time.
It's obvious that something happened and all the pieces much like this in this conversation about spiked wine and drugs.
It all makes sense.
It all fits into place.
graham hancock
And that we are a species with amnesia and that we need to rediscover our past.
And there's a curious resonance with the way that things are in the modern world, just as I have come to mistrust history, to mistrust the history that is taught to us in schools and universities, no longer to accept at face value the opinions of so-called experts in the field. no longer to accept at face value the opinions of So in the modern world today, many people are learning to mistrust institutions that have long gone unquestioned, whether it's government or whether it's science.
People are beginning to think for themselves.
And I think there's an intriguing resonance between recovering our lost past and regaining sovereignty over ourselves in a modern world that is struggling very hard to turn us all into children and rest all responsibility in government a huge part.
A huge mistake.
Governments are there to serve us.
They are not there to rule us.
They are not there to tell us what to do.
And I'm glad that people are waking up to this.
joe rogan
Hear, hear!
That's an excellent way to end this.
Thank you, Graham.
I love you.
I appreciate you very much.
I wish you were here right now.
I'd give you a big hug.
And thank you, Brian.
I'd give you a hug back.
Thank you.
Alright, thank you guys and thank you everybody listening.
Bye-bye.
Export Selection