All Episodes
May 13, 2024 - Knowledge Fight
01:11:40
Doing Dune: Dune (1984)

Due to public demand, the time has come for Jordan to walk Dan through one of his big fandoms and one of Dan's great blindspots: Dune.  In this installment, they discuss the somewhat confusing David Lynch film.

Participants
Main voices
d
dan friesen
32:32
j
jordan holmes
36:36
Appearances
Clips
a
alex jones
00:12
s
steve quayle
00:02
Callers
andy in kansas
00:01
| Copy link to current segment

Speaker Time Text
unidentified
Dune.
dan friesen
Dune.
Remix.
unidentified
Knowledge fight.
Dan and Jordan, I am sweating.
Knowledgefight.com.
It's time to pray.
I have great respect for Knowledge Fight.
Knowledge Fight.
alex jones
I'm sick of them posing as if they're the good guys, saying we are the bad guys.
unidentified
Knowledge Fight.
Dan and George.
Knowledge Fight.
dan friesen
Need money.
unidentified
Andy in Kansas.
Andy in Kansas.
jordan holmes
Stop it.
unidentified
Andy in Kansas.
alex jones
Andy in Kansas.
unidentified
It's time to pray.
dan friesen
Andy in Kansas, you're on the air.
jordan holmes
Thanks for holding me.
andy in kansas
I'm a huge fan.
dan friesen
I love your world.
unidentified
Knowledge Fight.
alex jones
KnowledgeFight.com I love you.
jordan holmes
Everyone, welcome to a brand new show that we're doing.
dan friesen
Mini-series.
jordan holmes
As you can tell from the remix up top.
dan friesen
I realized as soon as the music started that we should have prepared in some way to have a special theme or something, but we just didn't plan ahead at all.
jordan holmes
You know, I think improv is a loose form of art.
dan friesen
Sure.
jordan holmes
To some.
dan friesen
Just yell Dune.
jordan holmes
So, that is what we're doing.
We're doing Dune with Dan!
dan friesen
Doing Dune.
jordan holmes
That's the plan.
I'm going to try not to rhyme any further.
dan friesen
No, I encourage it.
jordan holmes
So, I don't know why, but people have, for quite a while, kind of insisted that we talk about Dune.
dan friesen
Yes.
jordan holmes
Beyond, I suppose, you know, Alex's...
I think it's almost like a connection that Alex and I have on like an evil...
Hero-villain kind of scale, you know?
dan friesen
It's just a passion for Frank Herbert.
jordan holmes
Right, right, right, right.
It's like a spectrum, you know?
Like, I'm on the chaotic good.
He's a chaotic evil, I guess.
I don't know.
dan friesen
Sure, sure.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
It is definitely something that the U2 share and I have an entire blind spot for.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
I know that I read Dune when I was young, but I didn't get it, and I don't remember it.
I didn't retain any of it.
Yeah.
I've never seen the movies.
Just kind of, as I mentioned to you, I just picture desert and I just check out.
And my brain's like, fuck no.
jordan holmes
You don't do Ben-Hur?
dan friesen
No, I don't want a desert.
It's too dry.
I don't like it.
jordan holmes
Yes.
Yeah, I think that's one of the interesting things about this is that...
There's almost a conversation that happens over your head sometimes whenever it's like, I think I know Alex is referencing Dune.
unidentified
Yeah, yeah.
jordan holmes
And you don't.
dan friesen
Definitely.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
There's a lot of sci-fi context that I end up missing and just sort of taking it as like, this guy's being a weirdo.
unidentified
Right.
dan friesen
Like, oh no, he just thinks he's living inside some sci-fi book that he read as a kid.
jordan holmes
Yeah, yeah.
So, we're going to rectify that.
dan friesen
It's a problem that needs something.
jordan holmes
Something.
At the very least, what we wound up doing right now is we watched David Lynch's Dune.
dan friesen
Right.
jordan holmes
Thus, we are doing David's Dune with Dan.
I almost got donuts.
I wish you had.
dan friesen
Honestly.
jordan holmes
I think the best place to start, because we can't really take it as a whole, right?
As you kind of pointed out, you had a first half of a movie where you kind of knew what was going on.
dan friesen
Well, you're getting ahead of yourself a little bit.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
So, we watched Dune.
jordan holmes
We watched Dune.
dan friesen
Okay, maybe we caught up.
jordan holmes
Exactly.
I mean, there's really no way to kind of give a synopsis of Dune, especially with David Lynch's version, because, you know, it's like half of the movie.
So I was kind of thinking, what is your reaction to the first half of the movie, just overall?
dan friesen
Not the second half?
jordan holmes
Not the second half.
Leave the second half into the...
Let's not get ahead of ourselves.
dan friesen
Okay.
Nonsense.
Yep.
If I'm looking at it just from the standpoint of a movie, I would leave that not knowing what the fuck I'd just seen.
I think there's the bare bones of a story that are being told, but poorly.
jordan holmes
Sure.
dan friesen
Leaving out clearly a lot of connective tissue in detail.
There's the demand that the audience do a lot of work.
Oh, yeah.
So I found that to be unpleasant.
But...
I do think that if I was a teen and I was smoking a lot of weed or something like that, it might blow my mind.
Okay.
Especially, it looked like shit, but it's from 1984.
jordan holmes
Right, right, right.
If you were in the 80s, it'd probably look great.
dan friesen
It'd look amazing.
That scene where Kyle MacLachlan and Patrick Stewart are fighting at the beginning with the shields looked like trash.
jordan holmes
Absolutely.
dan friesen
But back then, I'd be like, holy shit, I can't believe they were able to do this.
unidentified
Totally.
jordan holmes
I can't believe they put Patrick Stewart in squares.
dan friesen
Right, right.
I don't know.
The first half of the movie, I'm assuming, is like, you're making the cutoff point when Paul gets to Arrakis.
Or when he crash lands.
jordan holmes
Yes, after his dad dies.
So that's the point where we've got our first half of the movie, where we begin by establishing that shit's up.
Because, and this is a weird part that, again, David Lynch kind of makes this, as we talked about while we were watching it, he kind of rearranges the book and rearranges the story, and then if you don't understand what's going on, he tries to explain it.
dan friesen
I don't know about that.
jordan holmes
Through voiceover.
dan friesen
Sort of.
jordan holmes
As if they're in their heads, right?
Now that, of course, makes it even more confusing.
But it opens with the Emperor Shaddam.
Right?
Meeting one of the tube guys.
dan friesen
I don't know if that name is ever said.
jordan holmes
Exactly.
dan friesen
In the movie.
I just knew.
Ah, powerful guy.
jordan holmes
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
dan friesen
Super excited power guy.
I guess they did say that he was the emperor, so that is fine.
But to me, he didn't have a name.
And then he's meeting with some dude who's a worm thing, but he's not a worm.
jordan holmes
No.
dan friesen
He's just some kind of a weird alien thing in a case that you don't explain.
Yes.
And he's very powerful.
unidentified
Yes.
dan friesen
This worm, but not worm, has power over the emperor.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
And he's surrounded by a bunch of weirdos in goth outfits.
Yes.
One of whom I noticed when the tube guy leaves, one of the guys starts vacuuming up behind him.
Just one of the guys, one of the goth people who are surrounding this alien in a tank has a vacuum.
jordan holmes
Yeah, the picture is this giant aquarium, right?
A giant aquarium.
dan friesen
I would say so.
jordan holmes
Filled with, you know, later on we find out it's spice gas.
dan friesen
We don't.
You know that.
jordan holmes
I do know that.
dan friesen
You know that from context.
We don't know that from the movie.
jordan holmes
You'll never know that.
dan friesen
No.
jordan holmes
Nope, not even close.
But it's gigantic.
It's like at least eight people across standing.
You know, arm to arm, like that.
And then 20 people long.
And as they're moving out, the entire part is like leaking juice.
dan friesen
Sure.
jordan holmes
And there's one guy on the edge who's kind of like vacuuming it up.
But then there's seven guys worth of juice that they're just letting go.
dan friesen
Yeah, and only one vacuum.
It's absolutely not doing anything.
jordan holmes
No!
dan friesen
It's almost like...
In the moment, my thought was it was an actor's choice.
And it was a background extra who was trying to stand out.
Or second, it's passive-aggressive in terms of the story.
They're like, we're going to leave a mess, but we're going to pretend we're trying to do something.
jordan holmes
That's how much of a flex it is.
dan friesen
That's a power move on the Emperor.
jordan holmes
I can see that.
dan friesen
None of this has anything to do with the story, but these were the thoughts that were going through my head because I don't know who this fucking tank dude is.
I don't know what's going on.
So he's like, oh no, you gotta kill...
Paul Atreides.
unidentified
Yes!
jordan holmes
There we go.
dan friesen
Yeah.
jordan holmes
The movie begins.
dan friesen
Yes.
So the weirdo in the tank is like, kill Paul.
jordan holmes
Right.
The reason that this whole scene is happening, alright, is the Emperor is explaining the plot of the movie.
dan friesen
There's a conspiracy afoot.
jordan holmes
Straight up, he just...
Out and out says it.
They were like, let's dispense with any kind of, you know, we'll just go out and say it.
I am planning on sending this guy here to betray this guy.
Then that guy's going to die.
Now we're going.
dan friesen
Right.
Now, to spoil a little bit.
jordan holmes
I mean, he spoils the movie.
dan friesen
Well, but about how things play out.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
My sense of it from the beginning was, aha.
I will.
So there's this Arrakis planet, Spice on there.
There's a big market for Spice.
jordan holmes
Doing the thing.
dan friesen
A lot of money.
Everybody wants it.
Cool.
Whatever.
unidentified
Yeah.
dan friesen
I don't understand it.
I tried to explain it.
Doesn't make sense.
jordan holmes
Gotcha.
dan friesen
So, anyway, he, Baron Harkonnen, this family, they have control of Arrakis.
jordan holmes
Currently.
dan friesen
Right?
jordan holmes
Yes.
dan friesen
So, the Emperor is going to put the Atreides family in charge of it, but then betray them and have Baron Harkonnen come in and take back over.
jordan holmes
Yes.
dan friesen
I get that.
unidentified
Right.
dan friesen
But my perception of it was...
20 years from now, Baron Harkonnen will take back over.
It'll be some kind of a long con.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
That is the way that the movie made it feel.
Not like I'm setting a trap for this person.
jordan holmes
Right, right, right.
It does feel like they are building a much more subterfuge-based plan as opposed to just being like, hey, he's going to land.
Boom.
Dead.
unidentified
We're gonna fuck him up.
jordan holmes
Right.
Yeah.
That's the trick.
He's gonna take a shit someday and then we get him.
dan friesen
Yeah.
It did.
It did.
It seemed like if this was the whole plan.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
You could have just killed the guy, right?
I mean, like, you didn't need to go through all of this nonsense in order to, like, kill this family.
jordan holmes
Right!
unidentified
Right, right, right.
jordan holmes
So that's where the book comes in.
dan friesen
I imagine.
jordan holmes
You have to go through all this nonsense to kill a family.
And he spends a lot of time explaining it.
dan friesen
So I'm guessing something that's missing from this is that it would set off some kind of allegiances and alliances and all kinds of things if the Emperor were to.
To kill the Atreides.
So you have to put it there to make it look like maybe something had gone wrong with the Fremen or something like that.
jordan holmes
Something like that.
dan friesen
Yeah.
You have to false flag it somehow.
jordan holmes
I love that it took you about five seconds and a little bit of thought to get basically the idea.
dan friesen
Well, I mean, I'm forced to.
jordan holmes
Right, right, because you couldn't have gotten it from the movie.
dan friesen
No.
jordan holmes
No, but that was a good guess.
dan friesen
Thanks.
jordan holmes
Yeah, so to flesh out the...
dan friesen
That actually brings me to my first note.
jordan holmes
Excellent.
dan friesen
I was taking notes.
jordan holmes
Don't film this movie.
dan friesen
Well, that's just sort of behind all of it.
That is that spice is one letter away from space.
And then I wrote coincidence?
jordan holmes
That is, I think, are you referencing Dan Brown?
Never mind.
dan friesen
I think it's interesting that the name of the thing is so close to space.
jordan holmes
I feel like we need to keep that somewhere, wait 40 years, and then there'll be a National Treasure movie with that as a clue in it.
You know, space and spice.
There's only one letter away.
Which one do you choose?
dan friesen
Right.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
Well, I mean, I had a feeling I wrote that note.
And then a little bit after that, There was the voiceover of Paul's thoughts, and he's like...
Is the worm and spice connected?
I feel like he and I are working on the same level, putting connections together.
unidentified
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
jordan holmes
You're just putting things together.
That's, again, basically the place.
dan friesen
Spice is in space.
jordan holmes
So, yeah.
So the political thing, to flesh this out, right?
The emperor has a nominal power, and then there are the great houses, which are, you know, all of this is essentially based on the Greek Iliad kind of family structure thing, you know?
And then you have the guild, which are the humans who are mutated into...
unidentified
The vacuum guy.
jordan holmes
Yeah, the vacuum guy.
They are what allows people to travel through space.
And because they exist within a spice gas, it turns them into that, and it gives them the ability to travel through space.
dan friesen
How does that help any...
Like, if I were hanging out with one of these tank people, they could help me travel through space?
jordan holmes
With a spaceship, you know.
dan friesen
So if they were in my spaceship, they could travel my spaceship through space.
They could fold time and space.
jordan holmes
As long as it has a Holzman generator.
dan friesen
Oh, God.
jordan holmes
Yeah, I know.
But, you know, they can see the future.
That's the idea.
dan friesen
There's a lot of powers going on.
jordan holmes
A lot of powers.
dan friesen
That don't really make sense and aren't delineated at all.
jordan holmes
Well...
The basic idea is you have to be able to see the future in order to travel through space when you're not going at the speed of light, right?
Because if you're traveling through space and folding space, you don't know what's going to be there unless you know what's going to be there.
dan friesen
Right.
That makes sense.
jordan holmes
Does it?
dan friesen
Sort of.
jordan holmes
Yeah, close enough.
dan friesen
At least in terms of an idea, it makes sense.
jordan holmes
Right.
So you've got the great houses, you've got the guild, you've got the emperor, and then you've got the Lonsrod, which is like the...
Yeah, they're the economic council, essentially.
unidentified
Who?
jordan holmes
Yeah, the Chamber of Commerce.
dan friesen
Are they in the movie?
jordan holmes
No.
dan friesen
Okay.
jordan holmes
But all of these things put together mean that if you do stuff in a direct way, everybody has to attack the Emperor.
That's the check on their power.
So in order for the Emperor to check the Atreides, he has to go through the Atreides' mortal enemy, the Harkonnens.
And that makes it look like it's just a regular-ass feud and not the Emperor murdering and ending the house.
dan friesen
Right.
jordan holmes
Because if he just went out and killed everybody, then the rest of the houses would have to be like, hey, fuck you!
You know, like that.
dan friesen
Okay.
unidentified
Yeah.
jordan holmes
So there's the politics.
unidentified
Cool.
jordan holmes
That happened in the first scene that is not explained anywhere.
dan friesen
Right.
And I was distracted by the guy with the vacuum.
unidentified
Yeah.
dan friesen
So yeah.
I mean, it started off with a plot.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
So then we get to Paul.
dan friesen
Yeah.
jordan holmes
How do you feel about the McLaughlin group?
dan friesen
The person?
jordan holmes
Kyle McClellan, yeah.
dan friesen
I'm warm to him generally, I guess.
jordan holmes
You're a Twin Peaks fan.
dan friesen
I like the first season of Twin Peaks.
jordan holmes
Sure.
dan friesen
Second season's all right.
But I never watched the new one, the reboot or whatever.
unidentified
Sure.
dan friesen
I think people have mentioned that.
Yeah, I don't know.
Here's the problem.
jordan holmes
Okay.
dan friesen
I've probably seen him in a number of things.
Sure.
I don't remember.
But I don't know.
I don't have a negative feeling about him.
I will say he was sweaty as hell.
Not like metaphorically in terms of like trying too hard.
He was just sweaty.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
And I noticed.
I noticed this.
I know he's going to a desert planet later.
jordan holmes
Sure, sure.
dan friesen
He's already sweaty as shit.
jordan holmes
He's sweaty in advance.
unidentified
Yes.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
dan friesen
I'm worried for his like internal body temperature regulation.
Like he is just like laying inside in House Atreides sweating his ass off.
This doesn't bode well.
jordan holmes
Yeah, every time he has a vision, he gets real sweaty.
unidentified
So sweaty.
jordan holmes
Yeah, that's David Lynch's way of letting you know.
This is a stressful vision.
This isn't like a regular-ass dream.
dan friesen
He's a young man.
I wouldn't say his delivery of lines is good.
jordan holmes
It's his first movie.
dan friesen
Sure.
jordan holmes
Can you believe that?
dan friesen
Yeah.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
It's not terrible.
I mean, I couldn't do better.
I'm not a good actor.
Yeah, no, I thought he was fine.
I get it.
Put upon heir to a family house, and then there's these weird witches who have been trying to breed him and prophesy him.
It's a lot of stress.
jordan holmes
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
dan friesen
A lot of stress.
jordan holmes
Yeah, yeah.
So the bald lady, that's the Bene Gesserit mother.
dan friesen
Right.
jordan holmes
All right?
She's the head Bene Gesserit.
dan friesen
And there's sort of an implication that there's a lot of them, but you only see one.
jordan holmes
Right.
They're everywhere.
dan friesen
Right.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
But you only see one.
They are, in essence, the secret society that runs everything.
dan friesen
Well, here's my problem with that.
They stick out.
jordan holmes
A little bit!
dan friesen
If you're a secret society, I could pick that Bene Gesserit out of a crowd.
jordan holmes
It does feel a little opulent for a secret society.
dan friesen
If you're trying to be a secret society and everybody is keenly aware of who you are based on...
You being bald and wearing ridiculous outfits.
I think you're fucking up the secrecy part.
jordan holmes
Yeah, yeah.
Not only that, but it's widely known.
That their abilities are to tell you what to do and you have to do it.
dan friesen
They have like a...
The voice.
Okay.
jordan holmes
Yeah, so the voice...
dan friesen
I did notice that happened a couple times.
jordan holmes
Yeah, like that.
So the voice is the way they can control people.
dan friesen
So let me just...
So I'm keeping this in line.
We've got the tank people who can fold space and also can see the future.
jordan holmes
Yeah, spice.
That allows them to do that.
dan friesen
Okay.
But, I mean, spice allows everybody to do everything.
jordan holmes
Exactly.
dan friesen
Right, which is the problem.
jordan holmes
That is the problem.
dan friesen
So you've got the Bene Gesserit ladies who can tell you what to do.
jordan holmes
Yep.
Need spice.
dan friesen
Right.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
So these are the powers we have so far.
jordan holmes
You got it.
dan friesen
Right.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
But the worm, not worm, tank people, can't tell you what to do.
jordan holmes
No.
dan friesen
And the Bene Gesserit can't fold space.
jordan holmes
Right.
unidentified
Cool.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
unidentified
But...
jordan holmes
If you piss off any one of them, then say you piss off the worm people, right?
dan friesen
Not worms.
jordan holmes
Exactly.
They can just be like, well, we're never flying anybody to your planet again.
So they effectively can isolate you and end your connection to the entire universe, right?
dan friesen
So no inner space travel is possible except them?
jordan holmes
Exactly.
And them?
Not without the spice, and so on and so on and so on.
So again, the spice is everything.
dan friesen
Well, this makes more sense now.
This makes sense that this is why the spice is important, because it mutates people into being able to travel between planets.
jordan holmes
Yeah, that's pretty important, right?
dan friesen
Yeah.
unidentified
Yeah.
dan friesen
Okay.
All right.
jordan holmes
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Like, imagine only one, you know, one country has planes.
You know, it's like, well, they're gonna have the ability to tell everybody what to do if you want to fly.
dan friesen
Right.
I mean, it gets sort of like gasoline.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
Right.
Except it also gives superpowers and hallucinations.
But I guess, I mean, if you sniff enough gas...
Put your head in a big tank of ice, you'll probably see some stuff.
jordan holmes
I had not considered that he had not only based this on oil, but also sniffed a lot of oil as a way of...
That's entirely possible.
dan friesen
It was a different time.
Back then, you had to get your kicks.
jordan holmes
Oh, the 60s.
dan friesen
Yeah.
A lot of people experimenting with new ways to catch a buzz.
jordan holmes
I want to say that that's silly, but I also want to say I remember a lot of books from the 60s that were like, we huffed everything.
dan friesen
So, yeah.
jordan holmes
Fair enough.
dan friesen
Yeah.
jordan holmes
Speaking of huffing, the spice is a drug.
dan friesen
Yeah.
jordan holmes
All right.
dan friesen
Except it looked like the only time I saw anybody take it was when Paul took it and it was just like in a little pellet.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
Right?
jordan holmes
Like a little chew.
Yeah, yeah.
It was in the space food.
dan friesen
Uh-huh.
jordan holmes
Always great to see space food in a little pellet form.
dan friesen
Made me very excited for the future.
jordan holmes
Nobody really eats.
dan friesen
I'm fine with that.
jordan holmes
Yeah, that's fair.
dan friesen
Those days will be great once we have food pellets.
jordan holmes
I'm not against it.
But yeah, so the spice.
Because Paul is genetically bred, essentially, when he takes the spice, He becomes able to see the future.
dan friesen
But he seemed to have already been doing that.
jordan holmes
Kinda.
dan friesen
Yeah.
jordan holmes
Because if you can see the future, you can also see the past.
Don't worry about it.
dan friesen
Right.
But he didn't need the spice to do that.
He just seemed to do a bit more of it once he took it.
jordan holmes
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
dan friesen
Yeah.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
The spice, I mean...
dan friesen
Sort of an amplifier.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
So that leads me to think that these people who turn into the tank people could probably travel through space without the spice.
They don't need that shit.
It's just amplifying this.
Or maybe they could make it halfway.
jordan holmes
That's kind of more the idea.
I mean, honestly, it is more like they have, you know, when they're kids, they show the signs of the force.
But then you gotta still cram them full of spice.
dan friesen
Yeah.
jordan holmes
You know, and turn them into weird monsters.
dan friesen
Right.
jordan holmes
So...
dan friesen
There's something else that we haven't even brought up in the beginning of this.
And that is, when you got Paul in the room at the beginning, before the Weird Shield fight, comes in to the room.
We got a trio of people.
We got Patrick Stewart.
Crazy.
We got Dean Stockwell.
jordan holmes
We got the Stockwell of Deans.
dan friesen
Crazy.
And then you got Weirdo Computer Guy, which you had to explain to me.
What was it called?
jordan holmes
Mentat.
dan friesen
Okay.
All I see is a crazy looking dude with grape juice lips.
What is going on?
And they don't explain it.
It's just, what is happening?
Fine.
Eventually we find out, sort of, that they need to drink this juice in order to give them brain powers or something.
jordan holmes
Safu juice.
dan friesen
Right.
And again, you were telling me this is something that they have to do from birth or something like that.
jordan holmes
It's like an amplifier.
dan friesen
They're created as supercomputers because there's no computers or anything.
Fine.
jordan holmes
Yep.
That's a good way of treating that.
dan friesen
Here's my problem.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
The eyebrows.
jordan holmes
Yeah!
dan friesen
They don't need that.
jordan holmes
Why not?
dan friesen
Is this in the book?
The eyebrows?
jordan holmes
I mean...
dan friesen
Does the juice make your eyebrows go crazy?
jordan holmes
No, but...
dan friesen
Because all of the people who drank the juice had crazy eyebrows.
They did.
And everybody else didn't.
Eyebrow trimming does exist in this universe.
jordan holmes
No, as far as I'm aware, in the books...
Thoroughly capable of trimming your own eyebrows.
dan friesen
So there's something, a side product of drinking the juice and becoming one of these human computers that you see through the bullshit that everyone else doesn't.
Everyone else wants short eyebrows, but you want long ones.
jordan holmes
Yeah, because of the...
dan friesen
There's some kind of advantage to it.
jordan holmes
Well, I mean, if you are that much of a supercomputer, then...
You must know that there's an aerodynamic quality to having giant eyebrows.
dan friesen
I would argue it's the exact opposite.
If you try and swim, it's going to give you some drag.
It's going to hold you back.
So it's more of a falling thing.
jordan holmes
So then it's like a feather.
They just kind of...
dan friesen
I mean, I don't know if it would have that effect, but they're working towards it.
It seems like they're working.
jordan holmes
If they get a little spice, boom!
Amplify that up now that everybody floats.
dan friesen
Spice brows.
So anyway, I was very distracted by a number of these aesthetic choices that I figured must have some reason.
Like, the lips one makes sense with the context of this juice staining your lips or whatever.
unidentified
Right, right, right.
dan friesen
I don't fully understand why that has anything to do with them being a brain computer, but whatever.
Eyebrows, apparently not.
There's nothing in the book?
unidentified
Nope.
jordan holmes
Don't need eyebrows.
unidentified
Cool.
jordan holmes
No eyebrow powers are involved in the making of Mentats.
dan friesen
Good, good, good stuff.
jordan holmes
You can look like anything.
There's guys who are, later on, this guy's a warrior.
Looks just like a regular guy.
dan friesen
I would say trim that shit then, if I were there.
You'd look crazy.
jordan holmes
Yeah, I think David Lynch is, one of the ways that he was trying to deal with, I guess, not being able to explain half of what he's trying to.
Is just like, give everybody a specific look.
You know, like when Patrick Stewart walks in, you can tell that Gurney Halleck is a balladeer because he just walks in carrying his gigantic guitar.
dan friesen
I didn't know that.
I thought, because it doesn't come back up.
jordan holmes
Because it could have been anything.
dan friesen
It doesn't come back up.
unidentified
Nope.
dan friesen
And he just said, I'm packing this.
jordan holmes
Yep.
dan friesen
So, I did not know that he was a balladeer.
jordan holmes
Yep, he's a balladeer, my man.
dan friesen
I don't even know what that means.
jordan holmes
It means he sings songs, but also, he's a warrior.
dan friesen
Right.
I did get that.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
Because he does fight.
jordan holmes
Fights later on.
dan friesen
Yeah.
jordan holmes
So he was raised on Geedy Prime.
Tortured.
No good!
unidentified
Yep.
jordan holmes
Now he joins the Atreides.
dan friesen
Because he hates the Harkonnens.
jordan holmes
You got it.
dan friesen
Right.
jordan holmes
In the middle, we have Dr. Yue.
dan friesen
Dean Stockwell.
jordan holmes
Dean Stockwell.
unidentified
From...
jordan holmes
Quantum Leap.
Yeah.
Absolutely.
He is a...
Doctor trained by the Imperium, given Imperial conditioning so that he will never break his word.
dan friesen
Hence the red diamond on his forehead.
jordan holmes
Yes, exactly.
He will never betray whomever he works for, because if you're a doctor, that's like a huge point of weakness for your inner circle.
You know?
Great place to assassinate you.
dan friesen
Hippo laws, you know what I'm saying?
jordan holmes
Totally, totally.
So naturally, it is both impossible and it is the plot.
dan friesen
Yes.
He is the traitor.
Not a lot of tension around that.
Subplot of who's the traitor?
unidentified
Nope.
dan friesen
Because pretty early on, Baron Harkonnen says, like, we got a traitor.
jordan holmes
We got a traitor.
dan friesen
And then there's not a lot of, like, who could it be?
There's not a lot of intrigue.
I guess you don't have time, maybe.
A lot of story to tell.
But yeah, then it turns out to be Dr. Yui.
And when it was, I was not...
I didn't...
Feel like a...
unidentified
I didn't feel a betrayal.
It was him!
jordan holmes
No, none of that.
dan friesen
No, it wasn't like a big reveal to me.
It was like, ah, that was him.
jordan holmes
It was almost even in the movie, like Baron going, we have a traitor!
And then it cuts to him, like, stabbing you.
And you're like, yeah, he's the traitor.
It's Dr. Ewer.
dan friesen
I feel like there were only a few options in terms of characters that had been introduced.
jordan holmes
Could have been.
Who was your second choice for who the traitor could have been?
dan friesen
Well, my thought was Duncan Idaho, but that's just because it's a name that I know.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
And he didn't play any factor in the movie at all.
jordan holmes
Nope.
dan friesen
So I thought, like, well, that would be a way to make him relevant in a name I'm aware of.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
But no, it's not.
jordan holmes
Yeah, and he's the coolest character that Paul...
Idle hero worships who will eventually later on turn out to be recreated over and over and over again for thousands upon thousands of years.
Reborn as a clone and then killed and then reborn as a clone over and over and over again.
unidentified
Wow.
jordan holmes
What a life.
Because he's so cool.
dan friesen
He's too cool not to exist.
jordan holmes
In the movie, he's just not in it.
dan friesen
He doesn't seem to play a big role.
jordan holmes
Nah, he shows up and then he dies.
Just almost immediately.
dan friesen
Lost him.
jordan holmes
Yep.
It's a bummer.
dan friesen
So then, yeah, other than him, I didn't really have a thought of who...
You know what?
jordan holmes
What?
dan friesen
My brain didn't even, like, try and solve the mystery.
Like, it was just like, eh, there's a traitor.
jordan holmes
Oh, next.
dan friesen
Yeah.
jordan holmes
All right.
dan friesen
I know that the housekeeper lady warned about the traitor, too, and I was like, ah, yes, I'm reminded of this plot thread.
unidentified
Right.
jordan holmes
The shout-out mapes.
unidentified
Mm-hmm.
jordan holmes
What?
That's her name.
The housekeeper.
She was the Shoutout Mapes.
That was her name.
unidentified
Cool.
jordan holmes
They called her the Shoutout Mapes.
dan friesen
Stop saying that.
jordan holmes
I don't know why.
I can't not say it.
It's such an...
I don't know.
It's a unique combination of syllables.
dan friesen
So wait, we may be ahead of ourselves.
Where are we in the plot?
We have just started.
jordan holmes
Right.
Okay, so...
After we get the Paul Atreides dream scene, then we go to the Harkonnen scene where he's going like, I'm evil!
I'm gross!
And then you see the first real, this is the most evil man possible thing.
The Harkonnen.
dan friesen
Oh, I thought it was because he was hanging out with Sting.
jordan holmes
Wow, there's definitely that.
How did you like the reveal of Sting as in this movie?
dan friesen
I think I knew it.
unidentified
Yeah.
dan friesen
I think, you know, there are certain things that you're aware of, but then you forget you're aware of.
jordan holmes
Sure.
dan friesen
And then they happen, and you're like, ah.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
And I think that's kind of how I felt with Sting, because I think I knew he was in this.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
And then it didn't really surprise me that much, and I thought, look at that guy.
He's young.
That was, when, so 84. In Sting's discography.
jordan holmes
In Sting years.
dan friesen
What had he just done?
jordan holmes
Oh, boy.
dan friesen
I mean, the police existed.
jordan holmes
I think he had just left the police.
dan friesen
Whoa.
jordan holmes
Just quit the force.
I want to say it was either that or I'm making that up.
But I feel like that was...
dan friesen
Fuck y 'all, I'm going solo.
jordan holmes
Man, I want to say that was...
Fuck me.
dan friesen
I thought he was fine.
Didn't factor all that much into the story, I guess, until he has a duel with Paul at the end.
jordan holmes
I will kill him!
Right.
dan friesen
Also doesn't deliver...
jordan holmes
But the way he walks out in the introduction...
dan friesen
Cocky.
jordan holmes
I mean, the man is wearing nothing but a codpiece emerging from a steam bath.
dan friesen
True.
jordan holmes
You've got no opinion on Sting just being like, that's how I'm doing this.
He looks good.
dan friesen
He looks young.
Yes.
I'm used to him as kind of a more old man.
So it was interesting.
I don't care.
I don't know anything about this character.
Just a guy coming out of a steam bath.
jordan holmes
All right.
dan friesen
But to your point about the heart plugs.
jordan holmes
Yes.
dan friesen
Great idea for a dictator.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
If you have a somewhat limited population.
I don't know if that works at scale.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
But since there are only about ten people that we see around him, it makes sense to have heart plugs on all of them.
jordan holmes
Yeah, I mean, it is based upon the number of people whose heart plugs he just rips out all the time.
Probably wise to limit the number of people around him at any given point in time.
The more there are around him, the more heart plugs he's going to pull out.
dan friesen
Right, and the less chance you have of being successful when you attempt to pull out someone's heart plug.
jordan holmes
Yeah, absolutely.
dan friesen
So I've pulled up Sting's discography.
Yes.
So we had...
1984...
What the fuck?
Okay, hold on.
Hold on.
unidentified
Mm-hmm.
dan friesen
I think this is only his solo discography.
unidentified
Yeah.
dan friesen
It's a bit limited.
Oh, Dream of the Blue Turtles.
That album comes out in 1985.
unidentified
Oh, yeah.
dan friesen
That was his first solo album.
So, yeah, it looks like it was just when he had gone solo.
jordan holmes
Yeah, I think that was right around the time.
dan friesen
Yeah, every breath you take with the police was 83. Wow.
He's on top of the world.
jordan holmes
He is literally on top of the world.
He's about to star in a blockbuster movie, one of the biggest sci-fi movies.
To date, the biggest budget that you can have.
dan friesen
In the few years leading up to this, he has had number one hits with the police, with Don't Stand So Close To Me, Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic, and Every Breath You Take.
Huge.
unidentified
Huge.
jordan holmes
Worldwide global superstar.
dan friesen
Big git to be in this movie at this point.
unidentified
Yep.
dan friesen
Crazy.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
unidentified
Crazy.
jordan holmes
Emerges with a codpiece from his team.
dan friesen
Sure.
jordan holmes
Absolutely.
I think the Baron is great.
I really, really like the portrayal of him as this screaming weirdo.
dan friesen
Disgusting Grosso.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
I think in the new movies, the Denis Villanueva movies, it's a Skarsgård.
dan friesen
Which I haven't seen.
jordan holmes
No.
We might do those.
dan friesen
Right.
jordan holmes
It's a Skarsgård.
He's great.
He's very menacing, and he's terrifying, and he does the Skarsgård thing, right?
But this guy...
Is more nuts.
He's more like pure, absolute, insane nuts.
Just bouncing off the walls.
dan friesen
It's a little over the top.
But I mean, I guess that's kind of what you gotta do when you're this kind of a character, and you're grotesque, and you're evil, and you float for some reason.
Yep.
Do you think that might be tough to play down the middle?
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
Might be a little tough to be understated in that kind of a role.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
He's fine.
You're supposed to not like him, so I didn't like him.
jordan holmes
We're going to put you in the blueberry suit from Willy Wonka and expect you to be the heavy of this movie.
It's tough.
It's tough to do.
dan friesen
I did not take many notes.
I'm looking over my notes here.
You want to hear some of my notes?
jordan holmes
Yeah, let's do it.
dan friesen
This movie killed Toto.
jordan holmes
That is true.
We haven't even talked about Toto.
dan friesen
Toto doing the soundtrack.
jordan holmes
Toto and Sting, both at the top of their game at this exact moment.
dan friesen
Some of the stuff we've already covered.
A lot of crazy eyebrows.
jordan holmes
Yep.
dan friesen
Paul's so sweaty.
jordan holmes
Paul's very sweaty.
dan friesen
I noted that in Atreides' house, it's still hardwood.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
Hardwood still in style.
I like that.
jordan holmes
Do you know what's crazy?
dan friesen
What's that?
jordan holmes
That's a water planet.
So they have treated this wood so well that it survives a water planet.
dan friesen
That seems like the wrong choice.
jordan holmes
Yeah, totally.
Caladan?
Yeah, crazy.
dan friesen
The last note I took before I stopped taking notes.
So this should give you an indication of how early I stopped taking notes.
Paul's mom's hair looks like dove chocolate.
jordan holmes
That's a good way of describing it.
dan friesen
It's like a heart made of dove chocolate.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
Until it didn't.
jordan holmes
So yeah, Paul's mom.
dan friesen
Yeah.
jordan holmes
She's a Bene Gesserit.
unidentified
Mm-hmm.
jordan holmes
Did you get that?
dan friesen
But she's not bald.
jordan holmes
But she's not bald.
dan friesen
Because her hair looks like Dove Chocolate.
jordan holmes
Right.
She is not yet a reverend mother whenever we meet her and Duke Leto.
Duke Leto, a great not Chris Christosopherson character.
dan friesen
Someone who plagued me.
I swore that I knew who this guy was.
I did not know who he was.
Juergen something or other.
unidentified
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
jordan holmes
I appreciated that you brought it up and you were like, oh, he's in Das Boot.
unidentified
Right.
jordan holmes
Like, yep, I don't think I've seen him.
dan friesen
Oh, he's in Twin Peaks Firewalk with me.
That's where I know him from.
Oh, wait, he played a woodsman.
Nope, don't know him from that.
jordan holmes
No, I don't think so.
dan friesen
But, yeah, he was intense.
He had a quiet intensity to himself, made an impact with his role.
jordan holmes
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
dan friesen
Good on you.
jordan holmes
Yep.
Dies almost immediately.
dan friesen
Sure, pretty early.
jordan holmes
Yep.
So that's the...
dan friesen
So wait, but before he dies, there's an attempt on Paul's life.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
Which I thought...
But they've already gotten to Arrakis by this point.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
So they arrive at Arrakis.
They're taking over for the Harkonnens.
jordan holmes
Yes.
dan friesen
And there's obviously the traitor.
So someone is trying to kill him.
unidentified
Right.
dan friesen
There's sabotage devices that are too easily found, apparently, to quote the guy with the crazy eyebrows.
jordan holmes
Yep.
dan friesen
And so they have a fucking device that they use to try and kill Paul.
Right.
A flying syringe that makes a lot of noise.
jordan holmes
Tons of noise.
dan friesen
And can only respond to movement.
jordan holmes
It's too dark.
dan friesen
But it's not.
jordan holmes
Nope.
Not even a little bit.
dan friesen
It's a well-lit room.
unidentified
Yep.
dan friesen
I thought this was a...
Bad assassination strategy.
jordan holmes
Oh, yeah.
Terrible.
dan friesen
I would have gone with a different one.
jordan holmes
It is huge.
dan friesen
Yeah.
jordan holmes
It's so big.
The hunter-seeker is supposed to be this super terrifying...
It's like a drone that murders people, but it's a needle.
dan friesen
Right.
jordan holmes
And in the movie, it is, I mean, a massive dildo-sized thing.
dan friesen
And seems to...
Moves slowly until it doesn't.
jordan holmes
Yep.
dan friesen
Makes a lot of noise, so you're alerted of its presence.
And is like the T-Rex in Jurassic Park.
If you don't move, it can't see you.
jordan holmes
Stay perfectly still.
dan friesen
All right.
jordan holmes
And then the shout-out mapes open the door.
unidentified
Who?
jordan holmes
Yep, exactly.
unidentified
Who?
jordan holmes
The shout-out mapes.
Paul grabs it.
Super speed.
dan friesen
Yes.
jordan holmes
Does that whole thing.
But we haven't even talked.
About the most important aspect of this movie for David Lynch, which is the weirding way.
dan friesen
This comes into play more later, I think.
Right.
So, it's weird.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
I don't...
I mean, it's just yelling, right?
Okay.
Why don't you lay this out?
jordan holmes
Right.
So in the books, the weirding way is basically just how the Bene Gesserit fight.
dan friesen
Those words do exist.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
Okay.
jordan holmes
The Bene Gesserit are not just super powerful mental secret condition people.
They also are space ninjas.
So they can super fight on top of everything.
dan friesen
The Bene Gesserit are.
jordan holmes
Yes.
dan friesen
The bald ladies.
jordan holmes
You got it.
But they don't teach other people how to do this.
Jessica has not only given birth to a son when she was supposed to give birth to a daughter, but she's trained Leto's troops in the weirding way.
So now they're the strongest, best fighters in the world.
In the universe, etc.
dan friesen
Which she wasn't supposed to do.
jordan holmes
She wasn't supposed to do.
Because the Emperor has the strongest super troops.
The Sardaukar.
Oh, the Sardaukar.
So that is why the Emperor wants to kill Atreides in the first place.
Yeah.
dan friesen
Okay.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
I didn't get that from the movie.
Nope.
jordan holmes
So...
dan friesen
The Harkonnens take them out pretty easily for that.
jordan holmes
Right.
Which is the next part.
The Harkonnens...
Get Sardaukar from the Emperor to help kill the Atreides.
dan friesen
Right.
But the Atreides should be stronger.
jordan holmes
They just totally wiped him out because it was a sneak attack.
You don't need to have super...
dan friesen
I guess.
jordan holmes
You stab people.
dan friesen
So, okay.
unidentified
Yeah.
dan friesen
So that makes sense.
jordan holmes
Right.
Okay.
So then we get to finally Arrakis.
Then we get to Leto taking people out, looking at the spice, and we finally get to see our giant sandworms.
dan friesen
Right.
Max von Sydow, as one of the locals, takes people out.
Takes them out in a little tiny space hovercraft thing.
jordan holmes
It's an ornithopter.
It's basically, in the book, it's a dragonfly-looking ship, but because that would be kind of silly, instead it's a weird square that floats.
dan friesen
I don't think that they were too worried about things looking silly in the movie.
I think they were warm to that.
So they're flying around.
They're going to see the spice production.
jordan holmes
Yes.
dan friesen
And they go and they see this one place.
jordan holmes
Yep.
dan friesen
And oh no, worms coming.
jordan holmes
Yep.
dan friesen
Oh no.
jordan holmes
How do we know which guy is the good guy and which guy is the bad guy?
The Harkonnen, they go, ah, we just want the spice!
You can sacrifice your lives if must be.
dan friesen
Yeah.
unidentified
The good guy, Leto, goes, we must save the people!
dan friesen
And then they proceed to save two?
Yeah, not that.
They say there's 26 people in the spice mining facility.
They have no room for all of those people.
They end up bringing two people on board and the rest of them must have gotten eaten by the big worm.
jordan holmes
Yeah, you can fit as many as you can fit.
dan friesen
The worm is big.
jordan holmes
It's very big.
dan friesen
Right.
jordan holmes
It eats the whole thing.
dan friesen
Yep.
jordan holmes
Yep.
I mean, how do you feel about the worm?
It's kind of iconic.
dan friesen
Yeah.
I guess.
I mean, like...
Here's the thing.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
Tell me about your worm thoughts.
dan friesen
This planet sucks.
unidentified
Sure.
jordan holmes
You don't like deserts.
dan friesen
Period.
jordan holmes
No deserts for Dan.
dan friesen
And then we're adding a giant worm.
A bunch of giant worms, apparently, that are going to eat you.
unidentified
Yep.
dan friesen
And wreck shit.
I don't want to be a part of this planet.
I don't care about spice.
Fuck this planet.
You say the Atreides are on a water planet?
unidentified
Yep.
dan friesen
Get me over there.
jordan holmes
Yeah, they're doing great on the water planet, too.
dan friesen
And you know what?
I don't need spice because I don't want to leave the planet.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
This is fine.
unidentified
Yeah.
dan friesen
So, shut it down.
I don't give a fuck.
jordan holmes
It would be nice.
dan friesen
I think that they showed the worm a little early.
I had a pretty clear visual on the worm.
It wasn't really all that scary.
I thought that the ability of the worm to get stuck by rocks.
Made it a little bit less scary as a presence.
jordan holmes
Sure.
dan friesen
People are able to evade them at some points.
So I don't know, but it was big.
I don't give a shit.
jordan holmes
Yeah, I get it.
dan friesen
I'm more scared of a shark, probably.
jordan holmes
Really?
dan friesen
Yeah.
jordan holmes
And that's interesting.
The worm has captured the imagination of generations, including Alex goddamn Jones.
And for you, it's like, eh.
It's a shit worm.
dan friesen
So I understand that the worm is spice.
unidentified
Sure.
dan friesen
What does that mean?
jordan holmes
The worm is...
Okay, so...
The life cycle of the worm, we find out in the later books, is a sand trout.
They're exactly what they look like.
dan friesen
Sandfish?
jordan holmes
Yeah, they're sandfish.
Alright?
They find the spice.
Then they eat the spice because they have to kill the spice.
Then they turn into little worms.
Alright?
Then the worms grow up, come big, etc.
Then they die, melt into spice, and the cycle continues.
dan friesen
So the spice is dead worms.
jordan holmes
Yeah, about that.
dan friesen
What's the water of life?
jordan holmes
That is a dead baby worm.
So to get the water of life, they get the baby worm, and then they drown it.
dan friesen
So this is all about the worms.
jordan holmes
All about the worms.
dan friesen
This whole fucking society is based on worms.
jordan holmes
Yep.
dan friesen
They don't know it.
jordan holmes
They don't know it's just worms.
dan friesen
It's just worms.
unidentified
Right?
jordan holmes
And here's the craziest part.
It's been like that for like thousands of years.
And nobody has ever been like, hey, what's up with these worms?
I mean, they're big.
dan friesen
Yeah, sure.
And here's the other problem.
jordan holmes
Yeah, what's your other problem?
dan friesen
They're so uncontrollable.
Except they're easily controlled.
jordan holmes
Totally easily controlled.
Very easy to control.
dan friesen
Seems like over thousands of years, someone would have put the pieces together.
And been like, wait, the spice is dead worms.
Let's farm these worms.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
No one does that.
jordan holmes
No.
Because they can't.
And that is because of the Fremen.
That is the people who live in the deep desert.
dan friesen
Right.
The blue eyes.
jordan holmes
Yes, with the blue eyes.
They are spice-addicted people.
They are of the desert.
And they kill anybody who tries to get close and study the worms.
dan friesen
Okay.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
I guess that makes sense.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
You've solved this one.
jordan holmes
Except you've got an entire civilization that spans a galaxy, but you're like, man, these desert people.
Can't fuck with them.
dan friesen
Well, they know the deserts.
They know the topography.
jordan holmes
And they got giant worms, I guess.
dan friesen
But they don't.
jordan holmes
Ah, but they do.
dan friesen
But they don't.
jordan holmes
They can ride the worms.
dan friesen
It seemed like a big deal later when Paul rides the worm, though.
jordan holmes
Yeah, no, they ride worms all the time.
dan friesen
Okay.
jordan holmes
It's just a regular thing they do.
They just love riding worms.
dan friesen
Okay.
That didn't come through.
jordan holmes
Yeah, yeah.
It's not hard.
The reason that it's exciting is because they taught an outsider, Paul, how to ride the worms.
dan friesen
Right.
jordan holmes
You don't teach an outsider how to ride a worm.
dan friesen
Okay.
jordan holmes
Because the worm is God.
dan friesen
See, to me, experiencing it in the context of the movie, I thought these worms are revered by the Fremen and shit.
And it was a big deal that Paul was like, I'm going to ride one.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
But like, because no one ever had.
unidentified
Right.
dan friesen
Or something like that.
jordan holmes
Right, right, right.
dan friesen
You know, like in Avatar, you know, I'm going to ride this beast that no one's ridden.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
To know that they all just casually ride worms is a little bit disappointing.
jordan holmes
It is a little bit like if God was also a Greyhound bus.
You know, like, you worship it, but also you take it to the south every, you know, every six months.
unidentified
Yeah.
You get on the worm and you ride south.
dan friesen
So...
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
That's a bummer.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
The worms are fine.
jordan holmes
The worms are fine.
But, the Fremen, alright?
They are the people who are living in the deep desert.
They are the people who have been given the religion from Bene Gesserit, if that makes sense.
They don't really talk about the whole thing as far as the cosmology behind it.
We hear in the movie, like, oh, he's the chosen one, etc.
dan friesen
Is he?
jordan holmes
Prophesied.
Is he the one?
The whole thing, yeah.
dan friesen
Oh, they ask that a lot.
jordan holmes
Right.
Now, the Bene Gesserit...
Have been doing this thing called the Missionaria Protectiva, where they send people out into any place they want to go.
Before they send to Bene Gesserit.
And those people kind of go throughout the population and they give them a religion.
They give them the same kind of constant religion that says, you should really be nice to the Bene Gesserit.
They're super awesome.
Take care of them, worship them, and give them everything.
And then someday there will be the Messiah.
Right?
So the religion is what they use to kind of protect themselves throughout the universe.
They can go wherever they want.
dan friesen
The Bene Gesserit.
jordan holmes
Right.
But also, they are creating what we would kind of call a super being, if you will.
dan friesen
Because they're trying to breed the Letos.
jordan holmes
Yes.
They're breeding these great houses.
Because, again, it's very important to know that aristocrats are the only human beings that count.
dan friesen
But in this case, they do have superpowers.
jordan holmes
Exactly.
dan friesen
So it's not all just like a societal construct or whatever.
There is superpowers going on.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
So, I mean, they're wrong, but they're not as wrong.
jordan holmes
No.
No.
I mean, yeah.
Yeah, you got it.
So they breed this whole thing, and their breeding program is coming down to this very last two people, the people that can't ever interbreed, the Harkonnen and the Atreides.
Jessica is the daughter of Baron Harkonnen, secretly.
They don't know about that.
She has a kid.
dan friesen
Why do these people have names like Jessica and Paul?
jordan holmes
You are asking me.
dan friesen
It's ridiculous.
jordan holmes
I know.
dan friesen
Anyway, sorry.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
There's Vladimir and then...
Yeah, yeah.
So, Jessica is then going to have a kid with Leto.
Leto is supposed to have a daughter, and then the daughter is supposed to have a kid with Fade Ratha, who is Baron Harkonnen's...
unidentified
Yeah.
jordan holmes
Stay.
Right?
And then that kid will be the man who becomes the Kwisatz Haderach and who can see into the past and the future, etc.
Right?
He can cross space and time.
But...
Jessica falls in love with Leto.
dan friesen
Right.
jordan holmes
Right.
And Leto really wants a son.
Because Leto's that kind of dude.
dan friesen
But that's how they were back then!
jordan holmes
That's how they were back then!
dan friesen
Give me a mail air!
jordan holmes
In the year 11,000.
That's exactly how they were!
dan friesen
Oh, this is in the future.
jordan holmes
Yeah, way in the future.
dan friesen
I should have known.
Oh, I guess I did kind of know because you told me that they had computers and then they took over and then they had to destroy all the computers and that's why everything is sort of faux...
Old.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
Sort of steampunk-esque.
jordan holmes
Yeah, a little bit like that.
Where was I?
Yeah, so instead of giving them the daughter, Paul is born, and he is not supposed to be the guy, right?
But, turns out, he is the guy.
Or he's one of the guys.
dan friesen
He's a guy.
jordan holmes
He's just a guy.
dan friesen
Yeah.
He has visions where he gets sweaty.
unidentified
Mm-hmm.
dan friesen
Then he eats some food.
unidentified
Yep.
dan friesen
And has more visions.
And then decides that he's going to be called Muad'Dib.
Which apparently means the mouse on the sunset or some fucking shit.
unidentified
Yeah.
Okay.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
unidentified
Yeah.
jordan holmes
All right.
So.
So after this happens, all right, Lito, Paul, meet the Fremen.
We find out Lito's the good guy.
Immediately after that, we murder Lito.
dan friesen
Dr. Yu.
jordan holmes
Gotta get him out of here.
We know that the good guy is dead, so we can move on.
dan friesen
But Dean Stockwell is only doing this partially in order to give him a tooth in order to try and kill Baron Harkonnen.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
But that doesn't work.
jordan holmes
Remember the tooth.
dan friesen
He remembered the tooth, but then he accidentally killed Brad Dourif instead.
jordan holmes
Yes, he kills Piter DeVries, who is a twisted Mentat.
dan friesen
Right.
Crazy eyebrows!
jordan holmes
It's a regular Mentat, but evil.
dan friesen
Right.
jordan holmes
I mean, which is weird.
dan friesen
Yeah.
I would have...
Nah, everyone cares.
Fucking eyebrows.
jordan holmes
Right?
dan friesen
Yeah.
It's hard to tell.
Like, giant eyebrows and all that would have been a marker of him being a twisted mentat.
jordan holmes
Right, but they both have...
dan friesen
Yeah.
jordan holmes
Yeah, they all have the eyebrows.
dan friesen
Yeah, so it's not a signifier.
jordan holmes
No!
dan friesen
Yeah.
Anyway...
So yeah, the tooth, he remembers the tooth.
jordan holmes
Yep, remembers the tooth.
dan friesen
Lito dies.
jordan holmes
Kills Piter.
dan friesen
And then Harkonnen sends off the supposedly dead bodies of Jessica and Paul to die in the desert by a worm.
Yes.
Fun.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
And that's about where the first movie ends.
jordan holmes
And that's about where the first movie ends.
Yes, yeah, essentially.
So then we rush through.
dan friesen
A bit of political intrigue, a bit of bullshit.
Whatever.
It made sense as a story being broadly told.
And that, yeah.
Yeah.
jordan holmes
Yeah, and as far as like a condensing political intrigue that takes, you know, 80 pages to get through, you don't really need that in a movie so much.
And you kind of get some of the exposition, and then at the end you get Dead Leto.
So you've got like a movie.
dan friesen
All of that stuff is fine.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
The rest of it is confusing.
jordan holmes
Now we get to the rest of it.
dan friesen
Well, but even the stuff that is the rest of it that was in the beginning of the movie is not well explained.
Even just on a very basic level, a guy in the tank, that's at the beginning of the movie.
jordan holmes
Right, right, right.
dan friesen
It's not well explained.
jordan holmes
No, he's just a guy in a tank.
dan friesen
He seems to hold a lot of sway.
jordan holmes
Yep.
He can tell the Emperor what to do like a dick, too.
He's even like, hey, shut up, asshole!
dan friesen
And they use exposition just...
jordan holmes
Liberally.
dan friesen
But it doesn't help.
jordan holmes
Nope.
Inexplicably.
dan friesen
Yeah.
jordan holmes
Now we've got Paul and Jessica in the desert.
They are...
Paul is officially overloaded with Spice.
He gets too much spice, has his vision, realizes this whole thing, and can see the future.
dan friesen
Well, he took spice, had more of a vision, but that was earlier.
And now they have gone on this ship, they commandeered the ship, took back over it, it crash-landed, they ran away from the worm.
Because they, ooh, he can't come onto rocks!
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
So they went over there, and then because he's out in the environment, he's getting overloaded with Spice, right?
unidentified
Yes.
dan friesen
Because Spice is everywhere.
jordan holmes
Spice is everywhere.
dan friesen
Dead worms are everywhere.
jordan holmes
Everywhere.
I mean, it's the desert, and it's the dead worms.
dan friesen
Sure.
So that's what's happening.
He's having these visions.
unidentified
Right.
jordan holmes
So now that he's having the Spice visions, he is actually seeing the future.
And he gets the cloudy picture of what's going to happen, finds out that he's going to be Muad'Dib.
The Mahdi.
The Lisan Al-Gaib.
Et cetera, et cetera.
dan friesen
A lot of names.
jordan holmes
Yeah, all the names for whatever.
All based on a religion that the Bene Gesserit planted in advance to make it so when Paul shows up, they're all super nice to him.
And they treat him all cool.
dan friesen
But it seemed like they were super nice to him because his mom can kick some ass.
jordan holmes
There's definitely that.
dan friesen
That seemed to be why they ended up being nice to him, the Fremen at first.
jordan holmes
Right.
When they first meet the Fremen, Paul runs and hides, and then Jessica shows off that the Bene Gesserit are space ninjas, and then Stilgar, who's the leader of Siege Tabor, he's like, holy shit, teach us all how to do this fighting.
dan friesen
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
And that seems to be why they're nice to him, not the religious stuff.
jordan holmes
No, not really.
But later on, when Paul becomes the guy...
dan friesen
Because here's the point that I would make on that front.
jordan holmes
Sure.
dan friesen
So when they meet the Fremen folk, and then they're like, your mom kicks ass, teach us, and you're all cool.
He's like, what is your name?
What will your name be?
And Paul is like, what is the name for a mouse in the sun?
Whatever the fuck.
And he's like, we call that Muad'Dib.
And he's like, then I will be Muad'Dib.
And there isn't a feeling of, like, holy shit.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
That's his name.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
There isn't, like, a feeling of this is what a prophecy has been fulfilled or anything.
It's just like, that shall be your name.
jordan holmes
Hey, that's your name.
And everybody's like, oh, okay, we're moving on.
dan friesen
Yeah.
jordan holmes
Yeah, so the prophecy is, oh boy.
Essentially, Paul is going to be the, you know, guy who leads the way, essentially.
unidentified
Right?
jordan holmes
That's the translation.
And then the Muad'Dib thing, it's kind of a joke to, you know, he's a little mouse.
He's a little, he's not a real Fremen.
He's not a big guy.
He's the Muad'Dib, but...
The constellation is known as the one who lights the way kind of thing.
So it's like, oh, it's actually the sign that this is the guy.
Not everybody believes yet, but it's like, oh, that's another sign and so on and so on.
dan friesen
Didn't feel that way.
jordan holmes
No, it doesn't come across.
dan friesen
No.
jordan holmes
This is the part of the movie where you don't know what's going on ever.
dan friesen
Quite a bit.
unidentified
Yeah.
dan friesen
Seems to take them over real fast.
unidentified
Yep.
jordan holmes
Takes about five minutes.
Yep.
Because then they have the you can yell at the obelisk scene, which is always great.
dan friesen
This is where you were making a point of it being a departure from the books.
unidentified
Right.
dan friesen
This sort of yell fighting.
jordan holmes
Right, right, right, right.
dan friesen
Yeah.
jordan holmes
In the books, because you have to have hand-to-hand fighting, and this is another underpinning of all of the interactions, is that because the shields...
Protect you from being shot by lasers.
Not because they protect you from being shot, but because it will turn into a nuclear explosion, killing everybody everywhere.
It only makes sense to no longer shoot people, and only wear the shields.
You either have, we only use lasers and cut everybody in half with lasers all the time, or we have shields and then we fight hand to hand.
dan friesen
Yeah.
Or we yell.
jordan holmes
Or we yell from a distance with weird little neck things going...
And then there's the whole...
unidentified
It's weird.
jordan holmes
Yeah, and then there's the whole he just says his name and he's like, oh, my name is a killing word.
Yeah, it's absolutely...
dan friesen
Can only certain words kill?
jordan holmes
It's not established?
No.
But, yeah, apparently.
Now it is.
dan friesen
Okay.
jordan holmes
Yep.
dan friesen
So he takes over an insurgency.
Basically to kill the Harkonnens.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
And that works.
jordan holmes
Yeah, so this is the part that takes a while in the books.
It lasts about two scenes in the movie.
dan friesen
He has an underwritten love interest.
jordan holmes
Yep, yep.
That just shows up and then disappears.
She's really important.
dan friesen
Not in the movie.
jordan holmes
Nope, not even close.
All of their buddies, the Fadekin, super important.
Not in the movie.
dan friesen
He runs back into Patrick Stewart.
jordan holmes
Yeah, and then it's over.
Then we move on.
So then we get to the final climax.
And again, that is a huge chunk of the book that is all just ripped out.
dan friesen
It has a feeling of a lot of yada yada.
jordan holmes
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
And then we get to the climax, right?
Where Paul Atreides, because he is able to end Spice.
He has got the atomics.
Each great house has ancient family atomics that are nuclear bombs, essentially.
And because he has them from being a duke, he points them at the spice fields or whatever and says to the universe, if you don't fucking deal with me, I'm going to end spice forever.
Because, and this is the big point of the whole fucking thing, this is the whole point of Frank Herbert's book, is if you can destroy something, then you are the one who is in control of it.
Right.
dan friesen
That is said in the movie.
A lot.
jordan holmes
It's an exploration of hydraulic despotism.
So if you are the only person who can destroy something, then you're the only person who really has control of it.
And if that's the thing that the entire universe depends on, then you are the center of the universe.
dan friesen
Right.
You're holding everyone hostage.
unidentified
Right.
jordan holmes
So Paul is both figuratively the center of the universe.
Metaphorically, religiously, and then actually physically, literally the center of the universe.
All of this boils down to one person.
dan friesen
Right.
jordan holmes
Right.
dan friesen
And then he succeeds.
jordan holmes
Yep.
dan friesen
That's kind of it.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
Yep.
unidentified
So...
jordan holmes
There you go.
End of movie.
dan friesen
I found it a little anticlimactic.
And then it rains.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
It rains on Arrakis.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
So all of that is really established in a completely different way.
It has nothing to do with him being...
The reason it rains is because the Fremen, for hundreds of years, have been collecting water in these little areas in the hopes of turning the planet back into a green place.
dan friesen
Right, the water of life, which is dead baby worms.
jordan holmes
Exactly.
dan friesen
And you can't drink that?
jordan holmes
No.
dan friesen
Well, you can.
jordan holmes
No, no, no.
The water of life is different from the water in the sieges.
unidentified
Oh, boy.
jordan holmes
The water there is...
Yeah, don't even worry about it.
Honestly, let's just bail on that part.
Let's not even worry about the sieges, because they're not in the movie.
dan friesen
Okay.
So, I don't know.
There's not a good message, I don't think.
If you just watch the movie, and not little else, I don't know what the overarching message is, other than like, hey, the Lido's got their revenge.
jordan holmes
Yeah!
Yeah!
dan friesen
Which is kind of, like, that's the problem.
The arc of the story is essentially very normal.
It's a very normal story of, like, there's two competing houses, one is the good, one's bad, the good ones get set up by the bad, the bad kill the people, there's a betrayal, all this, da-da-da, there's the rightful heir to the good side lives, comes back, kills the bad people.
jordan holmes
Yep.
dan friesen
But everything else around it is nonsense.
jordan holmes
Yes.
dan friesen
Like, so you have unconventional shit, like being married with...
A very conventional story, and it just doesn't meld well.
jordan holmes
No, no.
Because the unconventional shit, as you put it, is what keeps the actual story in the book that Frank Herbert is telling.
Is very unconventional.
It's not that.
dan friesen
See, that's the sense that I have from many things that you've talked about and my sort of cultural osmosis of Dune.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
And so, to me, it didn't feel like this was the story that is being told.
It felt like a...
I felt like I didn't get something.
And it must just be what isn't...
In the movie, it is in the book.
unidentified
Yeah, yeah.
jordan holmes
They shoehorned the opposite of what's in the book into the movie to make it more like a movie.
dan friesen
Because probably it couldn't be told the other way.
jordan holmes
Well, it changes the meaning quite a bit.
If you think about it this way, right?
You have the conventional story of the wronged...
Everybody is against me.
I go into the desert.
I have my 40 days, 40 nights tribulations.
I return and I destroy the infidels.
I do that whole thing.
I actually ride on top of God, the worm, to defeat my enemies.
Now, that's a conventional story.
But, what if instead...
You have a shadowy group of people who have orchestrated all of this political shit into one moment.
Fucked up.
And then, because they fucked up in such a very specific way, it's led to a guy who creates what seems like a righteous war.
But, because he's too good at it, he winds up killing more people than anyone anywhere.
Ever.
So the Harkonnens, you say, oh, these are evil people.
They're torturous.
They're awful.
They kill one one millionth of the death and murder and everything that Paul Atreides is responsible for.
Because, and this is the thing that is kind of the message that's very, very difficult if you don't have a larger, you know, like five book.
Yeah, sure.
It is agency.
It is responsibility.
Because Paul is the only person who can make a choice, any choice he makes is what the future will be, and he knows what it will be, right?
So in the book, when he's going south, when he's going to the siege to lead the Fremen, he doesn't want to do it, because he knows that if he chooses that future, then he kills the world.
He kills the universe.
There's nothing he can do to stop that.
He can only choose to kill himself.
dan friesen
Right.
jordan holmes
Those are the only two options, right?
So in the book, he chooses, in the first book, to kill the universe.
dan friesen
Yeah.
jordan holmes
Right.
So in what way is that the good guy?
dan friesen
Well, I mean, like, there is that moment where he's having a nightmare with his underwritten love interest, and he's like...
The genocide of the planet or whatever.
I have to take the water or whatever.
But it didn't seem like he was wrestling with this too much.
It didn't seem like it was resolved.
Right.
I mean, obviously, I think as he becomes this guy who's basically carrying out an insurgency against the spice trade.
unidentified
Right.
dan friesen
He does become less of a...
Like, sympathetic character, but not to the point where it ever really fully changes in terms of presentation of the movie.
jordan holmes
No.
No, and I mean, it is interesting insofar as you see the justification for the insurgency.
You don't just see the insurgency.
You are there, you are thinking, hey, if I got fucked over like this, I would do what Paul did.
I would be an insurgent.
That kind of thing.
There is a justified thing for me to be doing.
So, Frank Herbert gives you the justification that you want for the Messiah, right?
You want him to be wronged to then go on.
But then, if you say that he's justified, are you then saying that...
The murder of everybody is justified?
When does that stop?
Is he justified in killing the Harkonnens and then stopping?
Or is he justified in protecting himself the only way that he can, which is running the world?
dan friesen
Well, none of it's ethically justified, but it's justified as storytelling.
You know what I mean?
It's justified plot-wise.
jordan holmes
So you have to look at this.
People oftentimes give you that, like, oh, I'm sick of this messiah shit.
You know, this white dude is coming to save the world kind of thing.
This is the opposite.
This is white dude is coming to kill us all.
dan friesen
Right, but at the same time, that's not in the movie.
jordan holmes
No.
unidentified
No.
jordan holmes
Not at all.
So that's why when you get such a combination of, like, this is not supposed to be the story.
dan friesen
Yeah.
jordan holmes
And then he's trying to put, like, fucking tank dudes in there.
dan friesen
I think when I finish the movie and I sit with it for a minute, I'm left with the feeling that I don't think I know more about Dune than I did before.
I think I already knew there were worms.
jordan holmes
Yes.
dan friesen
I think everything that is added to my awareness is stuff that you've explained to me.
Was not in the movie or was kind of in the movie.
unidentified
Right.
dan friesen
So I don't feel more informed.
I don't feel better off.
jordan holmes
Good.
Because, Dan, I'm going to tell you this.
There are more options for learning more about Dune.
Maybe this won't be the last episode of Dune Dune with Dan.
dan friesen
Do more Dune.
jordan holmes
Maybe we'll be doing Dennis' Dune with Dan next time.
dan friesen
I don't know.
There's a part of me that thinks, Like, this could be okay...
Oh, hold on.
jordan holmes
Let's not go crazy.
dan friesen
If there was an intention for this David Lynch dude to be part of a series or something, then I could kind of see it being like, ah, it leaves you in this place where you think that you've seen this story, and then the next one subverts it entirely.
I could see something along those lines.
But I know that there isn't a second one.
jordan holmes
There's books, you know.
dan friesen
Right.
But there isn't a second David Lynch movie.
jordan holmes
Not a second David Lynch movie.
dan friesen
Yeah.
And it also didn't feel like it was setting you up for another one.
It felt like a told story.
And that...
I don't know.
I found myself underwhelmed.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
I mean, you know, everybody likes a good Jesus brought the rain, now everybody's happy forever story.
dan friesen
Yeah.
I felt bad for Toto.
jordan holmes
Yep.
They didn't recover?
dan friesen
No.
jordan holmes
No?
dan friesen
No.
I guess it's debatable.
Is Sting's solo career better than his time with the police?
jordan holmes
Absolutely not.
dan friesen
I think some people would disagree with you.
jordan holmes
I understand those people, and I respect them, and I appreciate them, and that's fine.
They can be wrong about something, and they can still be respected.
dan friesen
Was that song, I dream around, yeah, yeah, that song that sings still, was that about Dune?
Years later, he's still processing being in Dune.
jordan holmes
I think, I don't, I don't think that Dune broke up the police.
But I don't think that Dune helped the police stay together.
dan friesen
We don't have any evidence either way at this point.
jordan holmes
Because Sting was in that I'm trying to be a movie star headspace, which is very difficult to be like, let's be a collaborative band headspace, you know?
dan friesen
That's true.
So there's a possibility that Dune destroyed Toto and the police.
jordan holmes
Yes.
dan friesen
Two giant bands.
jordan holmes
Two huge bands.
Yep.
And somehow David Lynch made it out okay.
dan friesen
Okay.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
In quotes.
unidentified
Eh.
jordan holmes
He's had a pretty important career.
dan friesen
Yeah.
Yeah, he's had things that have worked after that.
jordan holmes
He's told people about Transcendental Meditation.
dan friesen
That is true.
He has talked about that a lot.
Been on Infowars.
jordan holmes
Yes, he has.
dan friesen
So here's the thing.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
One of the reasons to watch Dune is obviously the parallels with Alex's vision of himself.
Right.
unidentified
There is a sense that he may think he is Muad'Dib.
jordan holmes
He's had a vision that God gave him when he was a child about what the future is and his place in it.
Yeah.
unidentified
Kind of quiz that's Hidaraqi.
dan friesen
Yeah.
I didn't feel like, based on the presentation of the movie, that I got a ton of those things.
jordan holmes
That's interesting.
dan friesen
You know what I mean?
jordan holmes
Yeah.
dan friesen
Like, there were little glimpses here and there, but, like, not a ton.
Of new stuff, at least.
Were there things that you were thinking of that you wanted to point out?
jordan holmes
Well, that was actually the question that I was going to have for you, is were there any things that you didn't know Alex had cribbed from, dude?
You know what I mean?
dan friesen
I mean, I'm sure there is, but I don't know about from the movie.
jordan holmes
Right.
No, well, see, that's why I think it's a good idea to watch the Dennis movies, because they're a lot better.
It's two movies, it's spread out, and it does a much better job.
So, I think that might be the way to go.
dan friesen
I think we might have to.
jordan holmes
I think.
dan friesen
Now, here's a question I'm going to ask you in advance.
jordan holmes
Sure.
dan friesen
Are there crazy eyebrows in the new ones?
jordan holmes
I'm going to tell you this.
There are not.
dan friesen
I'm in.
jordan holmes
But, in the most not way.
dan friesen
Oh.
jordan holmes
There are the most not crazy eyebrows.
dan friesen
No one has eyebrows.
jordan holmes
No eyebrows anywhere!
Shit.
Yeah, they removed him CGI.
dan friesen
Okay.
jordan holmes
No.
dan friesen
Yeah, I'm in.
unidentified
All right.
dan friesen
We can watch some more Dune.
jordan holmes
All right.
Well, then, I don't know how we would end doing Dune with Dan.
I think we've done David's Dune with Dan.
dan friesen
We've done David's Dune.
jordan holmes
Yeah.
unidentified
Done.
jordan holmes
I suppose we've got a website?
dan friesen
Dune done.
Yeah, we're on knowledgefight.com.
unidentified
And we are not on any social media.
jordan holmes
But I'm not Neo, nor Leo, nor DZXClark.
I'm just a regular-ass professor.
dan friesen
You are, uh, what's another fun, who is that housekeeper?
jordan holmes
The shutout vapes.
dan friesen
That's who you are.
jordan holmes
Woo, yeah, woo, yeah, woo!
steve quayle
And now here comes the sex robots.
alex jones
Andy in Kansas, you're on the air.
unidentified
Thanks for holding.
Hello, Alex.
I'm a first-time caller.
I'm a huge fan.
I love your work.
Export Selection