| Time | Text |
|---|---|
|
Why London Isn't English
00:05:43
|
|
| Well, well, well. | |
| Looks like John Cleese is in trouble for saying something that is demonstrably true by the numbers. | |
| Because this is a world we live in, dominated by political correctness, in which speaking the truth makes you the enemy of the establishment. | |
| I guess we'd better pour a tea and then get into it really, hadn't we? | |
| On the 28th of May, John Cleese tweeted this. | |
| Some years ago, I opined that London was not really an English city anymore. | |
| Since then, virtually all my friends from abroad have confirmed my observation, so there must be some truth in it. | |
| I also note that London was the UK city that voted most strongly to remain in the EU. | |
| 10,000 retweets and so much screeching. | |
| This caused outrage for some reason. | |
| Now, I'm not sure what that reason is, and nobody really explained themselves. | |
| They just said, I'm angry. | |
| Gregor Findlay, who describes himself as firmly pro-EU, anti-Brexit and worried about climate change. | |
| What the hell is an English city? | |
| Is Edinburgh a Scottish city anymore, considering how many English live there? | |
| English city! | |
| The arrogance from a nation that for centuries invaded other countries, took their resources and made them British colonies and before that, English. | |
| Gregor, an English city would be one that is majority English, that just has mostly English people living in it. | |
| Edinburgh, as far as I'm aware, still has mostly Scottish people living in it. | |
| So yes, Edinburgh is still a Scottish city. | |
| I hope that clears that up. | |
| But Gregor, to your second point, which I think is more important, are you saying that because English people did things you disapproved of in the past, that the English have no right to exist? | |
| That the English as an ethnicity, an identity, a series of values and a people, have no place in the world because of past historical grievances. | |
| Because I have got some bad news for the Mongols if that's the case. | |
| The idea that England has no right to exist because in the past some people from England did things you disapprove of is insane. | |
| You would not say that to any other ethnic group in the world. | |
| So why would you say it about the English? | |
| Someone called James Felton, who tells us that he is a TV and radio comedy writer, and if he didn't tell us, how would we know, says, John, I love your work, which is why I was quite disappointed to hear of you speak of London like that. | |
| It's as English as it's ever been. | |
| Maybe you could define a bit better what you mean by it no longer being English and clear this up. | |
| In an effort to help James with the old Google machine, I did a bit of digging and I found this Evening Standard article. | |
| Census reveals white Britons as minority in capital for first time. | |
| Statistics from last year's census show that 45% of the capital's 8.2 million population class themselves as white Britons. | |
| That compares with a figure of 58% when the census was last compiled in 2001. | |
| One of the key reasons for the change is a sharp increase in the number of foreign-born people living in London. | |
| They now account for 37% of the nation's population compared with only a quarter a decade earlier. | |
| And since that cleared that up, as in John Cleese was demonstrably right when he says that London is no longer an English city, as in a city that is majority English, the anglophobia began. | |
| Victoria W, whose profile is an EU flag, replied with, well thank goodness for that. | |
| I personally can't stand Englishness and I take zero pride of having been born in Little England. | |
| I love being a part of a London that's proudly British, European and open. | |
| You might be wondering why I happen to have a copy of George Orwell's notes on nationalism with me on holiday when I go to Pompeii, but I somehow do. | |
| And this is what he said about negative nationalism. | |
| The first kind, anglophobia. | |
| Anglophobia, within the intelligentsia, a derisive and mildly hostile attitude towards Britain is more or less compulsory, but it is an unfaked emotion in many cases. | |
| During the war, it was manifested in the defeatism of the intelligentsia, which persisted long after it had become clear that the Axis powers could not win. | |
| Many people were undisguisedly pleased when Singapore fell or when the British were driven out of Greece, and there was a remarkable unwillingness to believe in good news, e.g., El Alamein or the number of German planes shot down in the Battle of Britain. | |
| English left-wing intellectuals did not, of course, actually want the Germans or Japanese to win the war, but many of them could not help getting a certain kick out of seeing their own country humiliated. | |
| Really makes you think, doesn't it, Victoria W? | |
| You seem to be one of George Orwell's anglophobes, one of those people who, by your own admission, hates Englishness. | |
| Presumably, England itself, as you derisively call it, little England, and any of the good things born thereof. | |
| I presume they're all foreign inventions. | |
| Democracy, freedom, individual rights, free speech, liberty, you know, all the things that we consider good about modern democracies. | |
| Yeah, that's the English. | |
| And then the proud European decided to get involved. | |
| I'm a proud European, Sadiq Khan said. | |
| These comments make John Cleese sound like he's in character as Basil Faulty. | |
| Londoners know that our diversity is our greatest strength. | |
|
Sadiq Khan's Proud Fact
00:04:11
|
|
| We are proudly the English capital, a European city, and a global hub. | |
| That's not a rebuke of what John Cleese has said. | |
| That in fact completely conforms with what John Cleese is saying. | |
| It might be the capital of England, but it's not an English city as Sadiq Khan says. | |
| It's a European city and a global hub. | |
| And Sadiq Khan's activism over, well, let's just say the last three years completely confirms that what John Cleese is saying is correct. | |
| And Sadiq Khan is in fact proud of the fact that London is no longer an English city. | |
| Just two days before John Cleese had tweeted about London, Sadiq Khan had posted this video to his Twitter feed. | |
| And on the 16th of January, he had tweeted out this video. | |
| I've been here for almost 23 years now. | |
| Five years? | |
| 35 years. | |
| Since 1999. | |
| I was born in Amsterdam. | |
| Portugal? | |
| Sicily. | |
| I'm Romanian. | |
| When you're here, the first thing you are is a Londoner, and then the rest comes second. | |
| London made me feel very, very welcome from day one. | |
| And from day one, I felt like a Londoner. | |
| I have seen firsthand how the people of London are open to foreign cultures. | |
| They don't just if I'm black, if I'm fat, if I'm short, what your accent is, what your religion is. | |
| I feel free. | |
| I feel like anything I think about, anything I dream about, I can do easily. | |
| You can own your own destiny. | |
| set out to become a CFO like I did and you become one and you're just from a small town in Hungary. | |
| I think people understand that and then that's why they want to come here because they want to work and they know they're going to be rewarded for what I do here in London. | |
| And in September 2017, he tweeted out this video. | |
| One of our greatest strengths in London and across the UK is our world-class pool of hard-working and inspiring people from across the globe. | |
| There are nearly a million EU citizens living in London. | |
| They are all Londoners and they make a massive contribution to our city, not only to our economy, but to our culture and our society too. | |
| It would seem that Sadiq Khan is in complete agreement with John Cleese about London no longer being an English city. | |
| And it's down to his activism. | |
| He's proud of this. | |
| He's been working towards this. | |
| Which is presumably why he called it the English capital and not an English city. | |
| Yes, London is the capital of England, but the English are a minority in this capital. | |
| And they're a minority in their capital because of Sadiq Khan's preferred open door policy. | |
| Why isn't Sadiq Khan proud of this achievement? | |
| Why isn't Sadiq Khan tweeting out, London is no longer an English city, it is a world city, is an open city, is a European city? | |
| Why isn't he proud of that? | |
| Why in fact is he recoiling as if some mask has been pulled off and now all the world can see what he's been doing behind closed doors? | |
|
Is It Racist?
00:04:08
|
|
| After all, his supporters are very proud of this. | |
| Some self-confessed Ramona posted this. | |
| London isn't an English city, it's a world city. | |
| It's a home for people who wanted to better themselves, regardless of their circumstantial place of birth, yet still struggle. | |
| Most migrants help other people, like any decent person, and what do they get in return? | |
| John Clees. | |
| So John Cleese was right. | |
| And yes, London is not an English city. | |
| If you're all in agreement with John Cleese, why are you outraged? | |
| Is it just that John Cleese, an Englishman, wasn't supposed to say it? | |
| Of course, then the allegations of racism came in. | |
| Someone called Don Jolly, who The Guardian reliably informs me is a British comedian, said, he is clearly a very smart, funny man, but it is basically a very racist tweet. | |
| Secondly, it's a racist tweet by a man who lives on a Caribbean island. | |
| The irony of that is insane. | |
| Even the language is insane. | |
| Who uses the word opine? | |
| Is it racist or is it an observation backed up by census data supported by Sadiq Khan and his followers? | |
| Just a question, Don. | |
| Also, what's wrong with him living on a Caribbean island? | |
| Are you saying there's something wrong with Caribbean people? | |
| Someone called Space Angel hashtag stop Brexit said, When I saw John Cleese trending, I assume he'd thrown his hat into the ring for the Tory leadership contest. | |
| Having seen his tweet, he'd be the perfect candidate. | |
| Xenophobic, self-interested, soundbite speaker, and a nasty human being. | |
| Shut the door on your way out, John. | |
| Hashtag good riddance. | |
| It's not very inclusive, is it? | |
| Munro Bergdorf, one-time labor advisor and a black trans woman who's currently vying with Nick Griffin for the most racist person in the country. | |
| The uncomfortable truth is that the white race is the most violent and oppressive force of nature on earth. | |
| Said this. | |
| Wonder what John Cleese thinks about America, Australia, South Africa, and parts of the Caribbean not being indigenous, Aboriginal or black-owned anymore because of his colonial ancestors. | |
| let alone that he literally lives in the Caribbean, but that's okay because Nevis was a Brit colony, shake my head. | |
| Okay, to start with, Monroe, black people are not indigenous to the Caribbean either, you damn colonizer, but are you saying colonialism's okay when you do it? | |
| She also followed it up with this gem. | |
| When you move to the Caribbean because of your white fragility but end up living on an island inhabited by the descendants of the people your ancestors enslaved, wild. | |
| If John Cleese is willing to move to a Caribbean island that is majority black, then can we assume that he's not a racist? | |
| Unless you think that he's there to oppress the natives with his whiteness or some other nonsense that, let's be fair, you probably do believe. | |
| Thankfully, Clees did not back down to these anglophobic bullies on Twitter at all. | |
| He followed it up with this. | |
| It might interest those people who seem to think my remarks about London are racist as opposed to culturalist to consider what I like about spending time in Nevis. | |
| Nevis has excellent race relations, a very well-educated population, no sign of political correctness, and the icing on the cake is that Nevis is not the world center for Russian dirty money laundering. | |
| I think it's legitimate to prefer one culture to another. | |
| For example, I prefer cultures that do not tolerate female genital mutilation. | |
| Will this be considered racist by all those who hover, eagerly hoping that someone will offend them on someone else's behalf, naturally? | |
| Good show, Mr. Clees. | |
| And I have to let you know that yes, that's Islamophobia, and yes, apparently, that's a form of racism. | |
| The question is though, why are they so upset when an Englishman points out that their plan to turn London, the capital of the United Kingdom, into a non-English city, an open global world European city, has been a success? | |