All Episodes
Dec. 26, 2003 - Art Bell
02:50:53
Coast to Coast AM with Art Bell - The Importance of Mars - Richard C. Hoagland
Participants
Main voices
a
art bell
46:21
r
richard c hoagland
01:33:50
| Copy link to current segment

Speaker Time Text
art bell
From the high desert and the great American Southwest Wall.
Good evening, good morning, good afternoon, wherever you may be in the cosmos and all the time zones covered in the entire world, which is what we cover with this radio program Coast Code Bam.
I'm Art Bell, filling in for George Norrie, who, I'm not sure, may be time traveling.
Actually, I contacted the doctor in question who's supposed to be taking George back, and I said, look, instead of the 50s or whatever it is George wanted, take it back to zero.
All the way back to the time of Christ.
See, that's what I really want to know about, so.
Maybe we'll be seeing George again?
Maybe not.
Just kidding, folks?
Alright.
Uh, the sponsor last weekend.
The sponsor, remember that?
Too good to be true, I said so at the time.
Well, sure enough.
Uh, the good news is, it's there.
It really is exactly where the photograph said it was.
The bad news?
It seems to be an elaborate construction by a member of the Church of the Sub-Genius, a gag mail-order quasi-religion that worships a cliff artface named J.R. Bob Dobbs, for lack of a better explanation.
The old abandoned saucer home, also known as a pleasure saucer, where many a sub-genius dividal has no doubt been held, can be seen in detail, and it gives a fine, you know, URL, but it's the same photograph we have.
So it really is there.
I knew it.
Now, this story broke just a little before airtime tonight.
The headline is, it's a Reuters story.
Officials feared Las Vegas a target.
That's right.
U.S. government officials, of course, were concerned.
Some passengers boarding one of the Air France flights from Paris to L.A. that were canceled earlier in the week for security reasons, remember that?
Might have intended to crash-land it in, where else, Las Vegas.
On Tuesday, a day after Air France canceled six flights between Paris and L.A. at U.S. urging, officials said terrorists may be seeking a repeat of the September 11, 2001 attacks that killed about 3,000 people.
The Post said that U.S. officials noted a flight from Paris to L.A. would cross Hudson Bay and then eastern Canada before entering U.S. airspace about, we'll say over Minnesota, then swing southwest towards Southern California.
Since the routes flown by commercial airliners are closely monitored and deviations quickly checked, a hijacked flight from Paris to Los Angeles would have relatively few large populated centers to attack except the only big city on the route, which would be Las Vegas, which they would certainly consider a nice, attractive target.
So there you have it.
In World News, entire blocks of buildings lay crushed and survivors lined up blanket-wrapped bodies in the street after a really devastating earthquake leveled nearly three-quarters of the Iranian city of Bam as BAM on Friday, killing at least 5,000 people, injuring 30,000 others.
The quake also destroyed much of Bam's historic landmark, a giant medieval fortress complex of towers, domes, and walls.
San Bernardino searchers slogging through waist-high muck found six people dead Friday and looked for at least ten others.
Unfortunately, no doubt, mostly children missing after mudslides engulfed two camps in the San Bernardino Mountains in a terrifying torrent of soil, boulders, and tree trunks, all from the rains.
It has been raining, of course, in California and in Nevada.
We've had a lot of rain here.
A U.S. agricultural official said Friday, they have now quarantined the offspring of the slaughtered Holstein cow that tested positive for mad cow disease amid an intensifying search for the stricken cow's origins.
Government was trying to reassure the public about safety of the U.S. food supply.
Even as it confronts a wide ban now, get this, 90% of those who had taken beef from the U.S. now no longer do.
The Democrat candidate, Dean, is calling for aid to the beef industry.
The Democratic president candidate assailed the Bush administration for failing to set up a livestock tracking system that he said could have averted the whole current mad cow scare.
Said sports federal aid to help the American beef industry weather the storm.
Michael Jackson told 60 Minutes that he still thinks it's acceptable to sleep with children and that he would, quote, slit my wrist, end quote, before he would hurt a child.
And then, of course, a third attempt to confirm the survival of the European Mars lander failed Friday.
It occurs, folks, when a NASA spacecraft swept over the planned touchdown site on the Red Planet without picking up any signal whatsoever.
The Tiny Beagle 2, designed to search for any signs of life on Mars, was to have landed shortly before 10 p.m.
Eastern.
It was supposed to open its, that would have been on Wednesday, was supposed to have opened spread its solar wings and should have called home within just a few hours.
It, of course, did not do so.
Now, in a moment, the whole question Of the Little Beagle, the continuing U.S. mission, and the entire Mars Curse.
my phrase, Mars curse, we will review with Richard C. Hoagland, my guest, coming up in just a moment.
unidentified
Chao!
art bell
The End Well, if it's Mars, it's got to be Richard C. Hoagland over the years.
He has, I guess, attached himself to Mars in a way.
He has.
That's a fair assessment.
He's an author.
He's winner of the Angstrom Medal for Science.
He's just on and on and on.
Richard C. An author, of course.
I think he may be involved in a TV or movie production of some kind right now.
I'm sure he'll tell us.
Here from the mountains of New Mexico is a somewhat revived, because he had the flu, Richard C. Hoagland.
Hey, Richard.
richard c hoagland
Hi there.
art bell
Hello.
richard c hoagland
Somewhat revived, yes.
art bell
Are you better?
richard c hoagland
Well, what happened is after the flu, I got hit by a cold.
art bell
Oh, my.
richard c hoagland
Which is ridiculous, you know, but it's nothing compared to the weeks I spent literally in bed.
I have not been so sick for like 10 years.
I mean, I feel really for the people who come down with this, especially the kids, you know, and their parents, because it is awful.
In fact, it's so awful it makes you wonder if there's something not quite copacetic going on with this flu season.
art bell
Oh, I've thought that for some time.
richard c hoagland
It's really, it almost harkens back to 1918, 1920, when a lot of people all over the world died, and they were talking a few days ago about a pandemic.
Well, I can seriously empathize with that conversation because you really feel like you want to die when you have this stuff.
art bell
Well, here's one of the things that I don't understand.
They have the shot you can have, the flu shot you can take.
But if you look closely, they say, well, the flu shot does not affect this year's flu.
richard c hoagland
Does that make sense?
art bell
And yet they're still trying desperately to point where they got some bogus stuff by mistake to import or do whatever they can to get more flu vaccine, which I guess, you know, so it's puzzling to me.
If it doesn't affect this year's flu, then what are we doing?
richard c hoagland
The world is making less and less sense, Art.
art bell
All the time, yeah.
richard c hoagland
All you have to do is to watch television, you know, watch the cable shows and whatever.
My favorite, which I think perfectly encapsulates where we are with news and the world, is Keith Olwardman's Countdown.
Have you seen it?
unidentified
No.
richard c hoagland
Okay, it's on MSNBC.
It's every night.
It's a rapid-fire, five-point counting down to the top story.
art bell
Oh.
richard c hoagland
And it's basically like a living cartoon.
I mean, they mix, quote, serious news with other stuff.
art bell
Infotainment, I think.
richard c hoagland
Exactly.
But you can't tell the difference.
art bell
Well, even on the network news shows, it's hard to tell the difference anymore, Richard.
Really?
richard c hoagland
This is not the network of my friend Walter anymore.
art bell
No, it isn't.
All right, let's dig in.
Now, Beagle, I mean, you know, I'm calling this a curse, Richard.
Two-thirds or better of the stuff that we or anybody else sends to Mars gets, I don't know, doesn't work, crashes into something, blows up, hits an extraterrestrial craft, or see, that's a flu hanging on, folks.
Or something happens.
I mean, it's a curse.
richard c hoagland
Well, I would generally agree with you that something bizarre is going on.
In fact, in our last conversation, we talked about that two-thirds of all the missions that have gone to Mars have gone kaput.
Many, many years ago, when I was a fledgling reporter, you know, just a neophyte with CBS working for Walter, they sent me out to JPL for, oh, the first time.
And I remember wandering into an office one afternoon, and I saw this blackboard.
And it had a whole bunch of equations scribbled on it.
And it had to do with the Mariner 6 and 7 at that time that were about to arrive at Mars.
This was a couple of days after the Apollo 11 landing.
And we'd all moved, all of us that had covered Apollo 11, which was incredible, up the street from Downey, where North American Rockwell had their headquarters, where I had literally built a solar system in an abandoned aircraft hangar that we could wander through.
They moved us all up the street to JPL, to Pasadena, to cover the flybys of Mars, which were literally only the second flyby that the United States had ever sent.
The first one was Mariner 4 in 1965, and this was now Mariner 6 and 7 in 1969.
So we get there, and no sooner had we arrived than there's a bulletin that they had lost contact with one of the spacecraft.
There were two spacecraft en route.
And we all rushed back to JPL because the guys had their pagers, and there were no cell phones in those days.
It was literal little beeps, and then you went and found a phone somewhere.
So we dashed back from La Canada, which is right next door to Pasadena, maybe a mile away.
We were having lunch.
We rush into the press room and we see that one of our spacecraft is missing.
Well, that afternoon I wandered up on the hill to go and do some interviews with somebody, and I happened to go by this office, and there was this blackboard.
And there was this whole list of things that might have gone wrong as to why they were no longer listening to one of the two spacecraft.
And at the top of the list, in chalk on the blackboard, was big letters G, G, G. So, of course, being young, I bit, and I said brightly, what's a G G G?
And the engineer standing at the blackboard turned and looked at me and he says, well, that's the Great Galactic Ghoul.
Even then, they had a name for this curse.
art bell
The Great Galactic Ghoul.
richard c hoagland
The Great Galactic Ghoul.
And what they described to me was that they had noticed That a lot of the spacecraft that we and the Russians at that time, the Soviet Union, had tried to send to Mars even as early as 1969 never made it.
And they, some wag, some clown had basically put down the idea that there was this big, you know, galactic monster out there eating spacecraft headed for Mars.
Well, it was tongue-in-cheek, of course, but over the years, as more and more missions have gone from more and more countries, the Japanese are the latest to fall prey a couple, three weeks ago, it's not much of a joke.
art bell
No.
richard c hoagland
Because when two-thirds of the very expensive hardware you send to one place goes poof, you've got to wonder what's going on.
Now, in our last conversation, you said you were voting for aliens.
art bell
Yeah, given a choice between that and what else?
richard c hoagland
Well, what else is sabotage?
What else is humans here on Earth who are desperately trying to keep as long as possible the delay of the day?
art bell
Yes, let us be clear.
The great secret cabal.
richard c hoagland
Yeah, but it's not a great cabal.
It only has to be some guy with a screwdriver.
art bell
It's not very great.
I mean, there is NASA, there's the United States government, there is, you know, I mean, it's got to be pretty big, Richard, to control what happens to U.S. and Russian and Japanese spacecraft on the way to Mars.
richard c hoagland
All it has to be is the right guy at the right place at the right time with a screwdriver.
Because if you're dealing with civilian programs, let's take the U.S. and the British on this latest mission, for example, where scientists would be loath to even begin, prior to the concept of terrorism, to think that civilian spacecraft headed out there where there's nothing of monetary value and nothing of social value, pure science, no one would even think of the idea of sabotage.
Therefore, there's no security.
art bell
Well, I think you and I both know there's more there than that.
That's why we're sitting there talking tonight.
Anyway, well, you know, that's an exaggeration.
I mean, what does one guy with a screwdriver do?
Come on, there are layers of security.
richard c hoagland
That's what you would think, wouldn't you?
art bell
Yes.
richard c hoagland
Except I know for a fact, reported to me from a very good source at Cape Canaveral, that during the launch of Mars Observer in 1992, just before the launch, remember Hurricane Andrew?
art bell
Yes.
richard c hoagland
How it barreled down on Florida?
art bell
I do.
richard c hoagland
Well, they thought it would sweep across Cape Canaveral, and they had this fragile spacecraft standing out there on the pad.
So they brought it back to its hangar.
art bell
I remember that, yes.
richard c hoagland
And they put alternate power on and air conditioning and all that.
Well, when the hurricane went south and missed Canaveral, they then unbuttoned all those precautions for the storm.
And they found that, lo and behold, somehow someone had dumped a kitchen sink full of garbage on the spacecraft sitting in the nose cone on the top of the rocket.
art bell
Pretty incredible.
richard c hoagland
There were iron filings, newspapers, bits of glass, all kinds of bizarre junk, garbage.
And there was no way that this stuff could get through the filters because the filters are micron-sized screens on the air hoses.
art bell
All right, horrid as that is.
richard c hoagland
So it's obvious that somebody tried to sabotage our first mission back to Mars since Viking.
art bell
Granted.
richard c hoagland
Ah, but I'm not done.
When they took the spacecraft back to the clean rooms there at the Cape to frantically clean it, and they had to dissemble parts of it to make sure that nothing got inside, they then found that someone somewhere, probably at JPL, had smeared Vaseline over the lens of the camera art.
art bell
What?
richard c hoagland
So these were two hits by two groups determined that we would never get any pictures of what's on Mars from that mission.
But then, as you know, when it was en route, three days before it got to Mars in 1993, it disappeared.
art bell
Yes, I recall that.
Yes.
richard c hoagland
And no one ever heard from it again.
art bell
Okay, but that's bad news on one mission.
I mean, my God, Richard, we're talking about Russia.
richard c hoagland
Where was the security guard?
art bell
From Russia.
richard c hoagland
Where was the security?
art bell
Beats the hell out of me.
richard c hoagland
JPL, it was sabotaged with Vaseline at the Cape during the hurricane.
art bell
The garbage.
richard c hoagland
Thing was sabotaged with garbage.
And then it up and went poof out at Mars.
So where was the security?
The answer is, as we now know from this piddly-ass bunch of nitwits called Al-Qaeda, if you have a small but determined group that really have long-range plans and will carefully wait for years, if necessary, to put a key man in a key position as a janitor with security clearances, I mean, how many airlines now have reported, you know, stunning examples of people, employees, who are places in airports where they shouldn't be?
Remember that kid who put the box cutters on the airplane months ago?
art bell
Yes, of course.
richard c hoagland
And then had to call the FBI and say, hey, by the way, there they are?
So even in an era of incredible paranoia about security, there is no real security if you're determined.
So the space program has stood naked because it was a civilian space program to begin with.
art bell
But the very theory that would embody the final screwdriver action, essentially, you're trying to tell us occurred, would have to be gigantic in the sense of very high-level people having made a decision that, ooh, there's secret stuff on Mars and we can't let the people see it.
And so we're going to have to stop all these basecraft going up from all these different places.
And by nature, that would be a very high-level operation.
At least you'd have to agree with that.
richard c hoagland
I don't agree.
art bell
I don't agree.
richard c hoagland
That's like saying Al-Qaeda has to take over the U.S. government to do what it's doing.
All it takes is a determined small group.
And the smaller the group, by the way, the better because your security is higher.
You know, the old crack about, you know.
art bell
I think this would be a high-level decision.
unidentified
I mean, the assumption is...
richard c hoagland
You're talking about a competing group within the system that doesn't agree that we should now be made aware of this.
unidentified
Yes, and do their damn good.
art bell
For them to be aware of what is there and by nature, or by necessity, rather, they would have had to have kept that secret from us.
For them to be aware of it in the first place means they're pretty highly placed because they had inside information about what's really on Mars.
richard c hoagland
Yeah, but why do you say they have to be highly placed in the NASA system?
art bell
Because that information would only go to highly placed people, i.e.
richard c hoagland
what's on Mars.
You are assuming that all the information that we're currently getting from space is the first time we've ever had this information.
If in fact it's not, if in fact there are ancient documents held in secret by secret societies passed down from generation to generation to generation.
art bell
That would be at a high level.
richard c hoagland
When you say high level, remember what Ed Mitchell said.
He said there are two governments.
There's the elected government, the constitutional government, then there's the other guys who have taken control.
art bell
Exactly, Richard.
richard c hoagland
But the first group doesn't know the second group exists, or if they do, they don't know who they are.
art bell
Okay, fine.
Hold on.
We're at the bottom of the hour.
What I'm trying to drive through here is that if there is a second group, it can't be a bunch of janitors.
It's got to be people at a pretty high level.
A, to know what's in the secret archives about what's actually on Mars, and B, to cobble together a plan to destroy so many spacecraft.
That's where Richard and I differ.
From the high desert, in the middle of the night, which is where we belong.
This is Coase.
unidentified
Coase.
Coase.
Another day of love, you take the city.
I, I live among the creatures of the night I haven't got the will to try and fight Against someone tomorrow So I guess I'll just believe it Tomorrow will never come I said night I'm living in the forest of the dreams I know the night is not as it would seem I'm living in the forest of the dreams
I'm doing something to make myself believe this night and never go from coast to coast and worldwide on the internet.
This is Coast to Coast AM with guest host Art Bell.
To talk with Art Bell, call the wildcard line at area code 775-727-1295.
The first-time caller line is area code 775-727-1222.
To talk with Art Bell from east of the Rockies, call toll-free at 800-825-5033.
From west of the Rockies, call 800-618-8255.
International callers may reach Art by calling your in-country sprint access number, pressing option 5, and dialing toll-free 800-893-0903.
And now, sitting in for George Norrie, here is Art Bell.
art bell
Here I am indeed.
Richard C. Hoagland is my guest, and actually, we're at the very core of a very important part of this entire discussion, and that is why our spacecraft are disappearing and who or what might be doing it.
We'll get back to that in a moment.
unidentified
We'll get back to that in a moment.
art bell
Richard, I remember you telling me that NASA actually would do different things, including launch on certain dates because they had information from the same old texts and Egyptian secret manuscripts that we talked about before, that NASA itself was arranging launches based on this ancient information.
That is correct, isn't it?
richard c hoagland
Well, some people in the agency.
art bell
Yes.
richard c hoagland
But the question is, how many of them are there of the 20,000, and how high does it go?
art bell
How high does it go?
Well, I'm maintaining pretty high.
richard c hoagland
It's got to go pretty high to make such a have such information, A, and then act on it, B. Well, but it doesn't have to be, in other words, the sabotage that we're talking about, the deliberate screwing up of missions, doesn't have to be from within NASA.
In fact, most likely it's not.
It's from an external source, either another agency or a foreign power or a group of people, you know, like al-Qaeda that just don't want us anywhere near Mars.
Remember back during Pathfinder in 97 when there was an amazing story coming out of Yemen?
The Yemeni family, the men who had taken NASA to court because they claimed that their documents proved that they owned Mars.
art bell
I remember that.
richard c hoagland
And NASA was infringing.
art bell
Yes, I recall.
richard c hoagland
And I mean, the story just dropped into a black hole, and no one has followed up on it.
art bell
So now you're suggesting it could even be Al-Qaeda or something else.
richard c hoagland
Well, when I say Al-Qaeda, I'm talking about a small group that are not governmental, that are simply very patient and know how to infiltrate.
When I said the janitor, who better during Andrew, when that hurricane was bearing down on the Cape, than a guy sweeping the floor to climb up that flight of stairs and dump a whole bunch of filings and shavings from his pocket, from the floor, onto that pristine spacecraft through that port?
art bell
Well, this little group you're talking about would have to have a worldwide reach.
richard c hoagland
That's what we're now worried about, isn't it?
A group with a worldwide reach that's privately funded, aren't we?
It's called terrorism.
It didn't have a name then.
Now, to something more germane, not to beat a dead horse or a mad cow here, remember Ken Johnston, the NASA astronaut that you had on, who, by the way, has now been appointed a JPL Solar System Ambassador.
This is going to be very interesting to see what happens when he actually begins to ask some hard questions.
But anyway, Ken, a few years ago, was on your show, and he talked about his sojourn at Houston, at the Manned Spacecraft Center, when the Apollo data was coming back from the moon.
Remember how he told the story that he and Thornton Page, who was a prestigious astronomer out of Wesleyan, friend of mine, I knew Thornton, I worked with him.
Thornton and he one night were previewing film for the next day's review by various mission specialists.
And on the backside of the moon from Apollo 14, he saw on this film that he had loaded up on the projector a stunning, shining city of lights on the dark side of a crater in the shadow on the far side of the moon.
And they both were stunned.
He took the film back and put it back in the vault where you had to go through multiple security to sign it in and sign it out.
The next day when he went to sign it out to show the whole team, when they got to that part of the film, the city wasn't there.
And Thornton Page, when he met him in the hall afterwards, just smiled and said, I never saw anything.
Now, Dr. Thornton Page, I found out years later, was a member of the Robertson panel, which was the high-level CIA panel convened for several days in the 1950s, in 1953, I believe, to review all UFO cases in the United States back when UFOs were considered a major security problem because they were clogging up the communications channels and preventing NORAD and other agencies from seeing real threats from the Soviet Union.
So we have a member of the agency, the CIA, who sees something with a colleague of mine and a friend of yours, and then the next day it's missing.
And Ken said he took the film out of the projector, looked at it with a microscope, and there wasn't a break, there wasn't a splice.
They had literally duplicated overnight the whole film and taken out the offending, stunning stuff.
Now that could have been agency, it could have been NASA, it could have been a combination of people in both.
The point is it happened, and someone of unimpeachable integrity who was there, who held high-level positions, vouches for that happening, and it's not the first time that he saw something weird that he later began remembering and putting in context that that should not have taken place.
art bell
Well, you and I both agree that something anomalous.
richard c hoagland
Politically incorrect?
art bell
Yes, all of that is going on.
That something is being tampered with and something is woefully wrong.
Let's go back to basics.
richard c hoagland
beagle to it just has not I think Beagle 2, if in fact it is lost, and we don't know that yet.
In fact, about half an hour ago when you were just coming on the air, there was an overflight by Mars Odyssey, the U.S. spacecraft, over the landing site of Beagle 2 there in Ascetus, Planitia.
And by 3.30 this morning Eastern Time, which is 1.30 our time, they are supposed to tell us if Odyssey heard Beagle 2's call sign.
art bell
Okay, so we don't know yet.
richard c hoagland
So we don't know yet.
But we know they've had three previous attempts.
art bell
All silent.
richard c hoagland
All silent.
Including with this huge radio telescope at Jogrell Bank in England.
art bell
So the Beagle's not barking.
richard c hoagland
The Beagle is not barking.
So why do I not think that it's fallen prey to sabotage?
For one thing, look what it was trying to do.
It was trying to land and for the first time find evidence of microbes on Mars.
Not big stuff, not artifacts, not cities, not the really cool stuff that you and I think is there.
art bell
I think, what wasn't it, Arthur C. who said large life?
richard c hoagland
Well, he was talking biology.
He's thinking bushes.
Remember trees and stuff?
Oh, yes.
At the South Pole, where we now know there's a heck of a lot of water.
art bell
Well, that's large life.
richard c hoagland
Now, the odds of dropping a little tiny thing the size of a barbecue pit down on a planet with a surface area equivalent to all of Earth, Mars has the same surface area as all the continents of Earth.
And the little place it was going to land, which is this plane east of Sirius Major, was almost picked at random because of the vagaries of celestial mechanics.
Remember, Beagle 2 was a hitchhiker on Mars Express.
So it had to kind of wind up on Mars where Mars Express was going, not where it really wanted to go itself.
So what Colin Pillinger, who was the scientist in charge, said a few days ago, he said, my bet is if we land anywhere on Mars, we have a better than 50-50 chance of finding life.
Now, he didn't mean big guys.
He didn't mean, you know, Martian elephants or, you know, the ruined, abandoned cities that we're talking about.
art bell
Even microbial life.
Well, that'd be fine.
It'd be big news, wouldn't it?
richard c hoagland
It would be huge news, and it would move the whole story further up the curve.
art bell
Yes, sir.
richard c hoagland
Remember, this is what the two MER missions, the two NASA rovers, the first of which is going to land again on your watch on the night of January 3rd, and the second one on January 24th, are designed to do, to find evidence of fossil life or the conditions for fossil life on Mars.
Now, what Tillinger's Beagle 2 could have done, if it survived, with its little robot arm, which they elegantly called a paw for positional adjustable workbench, somebody had to work really hard for that acronym.
Anyway, it was going to extend its paw on which There were two stereo cameras and a drill and some instrumentation designed to measure composition and really neat gadgets in an incredibly tiny space on this little arm that the beagle clamshell would extend once it landed and survived on the surface.
But it couldn't look any farther around itself physically with something called a mole, by the way, that would burrow into the soil.
art bell
Well, actually, though.
richard c hoagland
And maybe a couple of feet.
art bell
It might not matter.
I mean, if there's microbial life on Mars, then probably it's common.
If it's common, then you're going to find some bit of it just about anywhere.
richard c hoagland
Well, that's the theory, and that's a very good idea.
In other words, once you find life there, presuming it's not contamination and brought it with you, then everything is wide open because microbes...
art bell
If there's microbial life confirmed on Mars, then Pandora's box begins.
The lid starts to come open.
richard c hoagland
So why am I voting against conspiracy and sabotage for Beagle?
art bell
I don't know, because it's so unlike you.
richard c hoagland
Well, let me tell you why.
art bell
Why?
richard c hoagland
I mean, most of what I try to do and talk about has a reason.
I'm trying to be logical here and consistent.
The U.S. missions that are going to land, $800 million.
Close to a billion.
art bell
A lot of money.
richard c hoagland
A gigabuck.
The Mars Express orbiter mission, which successfully went into orbit on Christmas morning, $345 million.
Close to half a gig.
Beagle 2, $35 million.
Pocket change.
And the problem is that landing is the hardest thing.
You've got to get down to the atmosphere.
Things have to happen in sequence.
If you land wrong, if the airbag hits a rock, a sharp-edged razor blade-type rock, bang, there goes your spacecraft splat all over the surface.
So for a little amount of money, they were trying to pull off a miracle.
And I got to hand it to Colin Pillinger.
He put together an incredible team.
There's an incredible team spirit.
I feel so for these people tonight because they're sitting there desperately hoping against hope that it's merely a communications problem or a computer problem and it isn't that the spacecraft no longer exists.
But the odds are, given how many spacecraft have failed with mucho bucks, that this trying to do it on a shoestring, something went wrong somewhere in that sequence of events in the seven minutes from entering the atmosphere to landing, and through no one's fault, it simply didn't work.
Well, that's the odds.
art bell
But that is not consistent with the other things you've said.
richard c hoagland
Because the money's not equal art.
art bell
Well, even so, Richard, the reporting back of microbial life existing on Mars would be, I mean, gigantic news and would lead to the rest of it.
So why aren't you consistently saying this was sabotage?
richard c hoagland
Because we're comparing apples and oranges.
If we had an $800 million mission and it went splat, then I'd say, aha.
But the fact is that these things are incredibly difficult.
I mean, look how Close Pathfinder came to disaster and it was in a $150 million range.
That was, you know, gold is faster, better, cheaper.
Now, I will totally admit that there is some logic to what you're saying.
And if there is a cabal that wants to keep us from ever knowing that there's even a microbe alive on Mars, maybe they did something.
art bell
There you have it.
richard c hoagland
But that's a maybe.
I'm betting on this particular instance that it was just the fates because of the small amount of money, relatively speaking.
Now, one of the reasons I'm saying that is because the real threat here, the threat politically and scientifically, is not Beagle 2.
It's Mars Express itself.
Because as I've said, Mars Express carries a double whammy.
art bell
Mars Express is ours, and it's in order.
richard c hoagland
No, no, no, it's the European.
art bell
I'm sorry, and it's in orbit, right?
richard c hoagland
It's in orbit.
It's not in safely.
It literally got there safely.
It's in perfect health.
It carries among its instrument array two instruments which can blow the doors off artifacts and former intelligence on Mars.
Not microbes, but the big guys.
One is the high-resolution stereo camera that we discussed last time, headed by Dr. Gerhard Newcomb, who has said in print to the BBC, in response to mainly this audience art, he is going to reimage Sidonia.
And we're going to make sure, right gang, that he does it the right way.
We're going to send him more emails and lay out exactly when and how to take pictures that will stand up in court.
The other surprise, the other amazing double whammy on the Mars Express mission is the Marsis instrument, M-A-R-S-I-S, which is an acronym that stands basically for Mars Radar.
For the first time in the history of the space program, ARC, mankind, the Europeans this time, have sent a real radar to Mars.
And what it's going to do is to probe up to three miles beneath the surface, looking at the whole globe over the next couple of years.
art bell
So as then one would presume they would find very quickly the Martian cities.
richard c hoagland
You got it.
Now, what I find stunning about this is that our previous U.S. spacecraft were supposed to carry this kind of radar, and at the last minute, after George Schultz went to the Soviet Union and had a little meeting with Chevronazi, who was the foreign minister of the Soviet Union at that time, they pulled off the radar unit and they substituted the laser unit, which only bounced signals off the surface.
art bell
Now, wait a minute.
You said George Schultz.
Yes, yes, I recall.
well recall meeting with her nazi you said and well okay that's a barn secretary so In a change of the instrument.
Okay, Richard, that's what I call a high level.
richard c hoagland
Yeah, but that's not sabotage.
That's a change of instrument.
art bell
And for what reason?
unidentified
Well, all right.
richard c hoagland
If you have radar, you probe beneath the surface.
art bell
See, I'm trapping you, Richard.
Yes, I am.
I'm going back to it.
That's a high level.
That's a high level.
If they had it removed, it was because they would have seen the Martian cities.
richard c hoagland
That's right.
art bell
Well, okay, that's too soon.
Too soon.
richard c hoagland
Soon.
art bell
Too soon.
Okay, well, back to that.
richard c hoagland
Remember, we have always said there seems to be a timetable, a clock.
art bell
But by what you're saying, that puts Schultz and Chevron in the cabal, in a sense.
richard c hoagland
Yeah, but it doesn't account for sabotage.
Sabotage is different than planned time-release assets.
art bell
Well, there's all kinds of sabotage.
richard c hoagland
I mean, if you remove the instrument that would prove Right.
All you're doing is delaying the inevitable.
art bell
Right, but you might as well say it's the proverbial screwdriver.
I mean, it's apples and oranges.
unidentified
Come on.
art bell
It's policy.
Yes, Richard, but same end effect.
richard c hoagland
Yeah, but there's two different ways of doing things.
One is from the inside, sophisticated, smooth, without seams.
And the other is the monkey wrench.
The monkey wrench is used when you don't have access to the levers of power.
I know, but it's until the appropriate time.
We're not going to call this act here.
What I'm simply saying is now, in 2003, 2004, Europeans have got a real radar on that spacecraft which is functioning perfectly in orbit tonight and which will, if I can call up a very important email I got here, give us some pretty astonishing data.
Okay?
Now.
art bell
Well, if we suddenly get pictures of Martian cities just under the surface, don't you think that's going to shake everything up a little?
richard c hoagland
More than a little.
art bell
More than a little.
richard c hoagland
That's why I'm saying I'm betting on Mars Express.
And if we were dealing with sabotage that had taken out Beagle, it would have been a much more important target to take out Mars Express.
Now, I don't know whether the Mars Express people have better security.
I mean, Europeans tend to be a little more security conscious than we are.
It's not finished yet.
Absolutely right.
So when we come back from the break, I'm going to read you an email that came to me by way of a source out of JPL from a high-level engineer speaking to what this Marsis radar might do.
art bell
An unimpeachable source?
richard c hoagland
An unimpeachable source.
art bell
Okay.
All right, Richard, hold tight.
We are at the top of the hour.
I don't know.
I just don't know.
Low-level, small group, worldwide reach, Schultz, Shevard Nazi, these are pretty high-level guys.
I don't know.
I think this whole thing is, if that's what it is, has to be, by its very nature, very high-level.
But that's just me.
From the high desert in the middle of the night, trucking along like a freight train in the dark, this is Coastal.
unidentified
I think it's time to get ready To realize just what I have found I have to get on the care of what I am It's all clear to me now My heart is on fire My soul's like a wheel that's turning My
love is on fire Be it sight, sand, smell, or touch, the something inside that we need so much.
The sight of a touch, or the scent of the sand, or the strength of an oak when it moves deep in the ground.
The wonder of flowers to be covered and then to burst up through tarmac to the sun again.
Or to fly to the sun without burning a wing, to lie in a meadow and hear the grass sing, to have all these things in our memory's heart, and they use them to help us to fight.
Yeah!
Ride, ride, that's your soul.
Take this place, on this trip, just call me.
Ride, take a pillow.
Ride, ride, that's my seat, it's my dream.
From Coast to Coast and worldwide on the internet, this is Coast to Coast AM with guest host Art Bell.
To talk with Art Bell, call the wildcard line at Area Code 775-727-1295.
The first-time caller line is Area Code 775-727-1222.
To talk with Art Bell, from east of the Rockies, call toll-free at 800-825-5033.
From west of the Rockies, call 800-618-8255.
International callers may reach Art by calling your in-country Sprint Access Number, pressing option 5, and dialing toll-free, 800-893-0903.
And now, sitting in for George Norrie, here is Art Bell.
art bell
Yes, indeed, here I am.
And this is, I want you to listen very closely to me right now, all right?
Beginning tomorrow night, and then Wednesday night as well, I'm going to be here.
And during that time period, we're going to do what we traditionally do in the time period between Christmas and the new year, and that is make predictions.
It's your opportunity to make a prediction about something you think a major event that will occur in the year 2004.
Now, listen to me, doggonnet, listen to me.
I want a good hit rate this year.
And what that means is that you just can't pull this prediction from any old orifice.
I want you to sit down, spend a little quiet time, let your mind go as blank as you can get it, and then reach way out into that area from which such things come, I guess.
And really try and give me a good prediction.
I want the hit rate way up this year, and so it requires your cooperation.
We'll begin taking the predictions, which are duly assigned and numbered and recorded and kept for a year in the Bell Family Ball.
So this year, I want your cooperation.
That means that you really take the time before you make your call, whether it's on Sunday or next Wednesday as the year and calendar flips, to make your prediction a good one.
A thoughtful one.
One that you've plucked from that special area that predictions, such predictions come from.
And if you really spend a little time on it, we'll get some good predictions.
And I want a great hit rate.
It's going to be the best year we've ever had.
but it all depends on you.
unidentified
*Dramatic Music*
art bell
Once again, Richard C. Hoagland, and we were about to be available the contents of this email.
Richard?
richard c hoagland
Well, before we get to that, I got a call during the break.
unidentified
Oh, good.
art bell
Well, I got a fast blast I want to talk to you about then.
richard c hoagland
Okay.
art bell
All right.
You know, in case anybody thinks these arguments are trivial and not meaningful, you have to mind.
Demetris from Queens, New York says, in case building rubbles or Martian civilization exist on Mars, how is this going to affect our lives, our beliefs here on Earth?
Is it better they sabotage and hide the truth from us?
So, you know, that's really a good question, Richard.
This great argument we're having about whether it's a cabal, whether it's an accident, whether it's just bad luck with regard to Mars and what you and I think is on Mars, buried Martian cities.
I mean, it's not a small matter for humanity.
If there are buried cities on Mars, that's a really big matter for humanity, isn't it?
richard c hoagland
Well, it's not only a big matter, but it's something that I really wanted to get into tonight and do it with enough time because we've got plenty of time tonight.
I want to talk in a few minutes exactly to that question because where the rubber meets the road is these are not decisions being made in a vacuum.
These are not people who are pulling strings and keeping us from knowing things or knowing it until a certain time because they have nothing better to do.
There's a strategy here.
There's a political agenda.
And there has been, apparently, since the dawn of the space program.
And it goes back to your favorite document, Art, the Brookings Report.
And, you know, when I say that the Beagle 2 may just have fallen prey to not enough money, it's not that I don't believe it could have been sabotaged.
I'm looking at the one that they should have aimed for, which is the one that is going to give us some extraordinary information if the system is honest and if the Europeans are as independent as they appear to be these days.
Now, while I was on the break, while we were in news, I had a call from one of our very important sources in Washington who has given us some very important information over the years, and I won't bore you with all the hits that he has been right about, but this is one of the guys.
And he gave me two pieces of information.
He says, use with art, he says, the metaphor of the vice.
He said, this is work from both ends, the policy end and the terrorist end.
And what they can't achieve with legitimate policy decisions, a la the Schultz Chevronazi meeting, where the instrument was quietly changed out and nobody who was not supposed to know knew anything.
It was seamless.
What they can't achieve with that, they then hire a bunch of thugs to do the hard way with plausible deniability.
The end result is that we don't know what's out there.
NASA, most of NASA doesn't know what's out there.
The people working on these missions, most of them, don't know what's out there until someone decides it's the appropriate time.
Now, let me tell you item number two that he told me.
Remember, this is a guy who's very well connected.
art bell
Yes.
richard c hoagland
He says that Mars Odyssey did not hear anything tonight, an hour ago.
And that's about an hour and 15 minutes before the rest of the country is going to hear anything.
art bell
So that probably means then that Beagle's forepaws to this.
richard c hoagland
It's forepaws to the sky.
It is not there.
Something in that very complex chain of events from entry to landing over those seven minutes, all it would take is one little relay, one little computer glitch, one little latch that doesn't open on time.
You know, these things are infernally complicated.
And again, if you have a lot of money to throw, you know, at these things, you increase your odds of success because you hire more people, you do more testing, you think of more unthinkable things.
I mean, there were so many parts of this they didn't even have an opportunity to test, that they've admitted they didn't have the money or the time to test.
So, you know, now it's conceivable, it's certainly more than conceivable, that someone doesn't want us to know there are microbes on Mars.
But when we look at the trend curve, the official trend curve, we have gone since 1997, inexorably, mission by mission by mission, closer to the admission that there is some kind of life currently on Mars.
art bell
Well, I certainly admit there's been movement.
richard c hoagland
And would you like to plop the data points, or do you want me to do it?
art bell
Well, no, go ahead.
richard c hoagland
Okay, well, for instance, we start out with a totally sterile Mars, and then we suddenly say, well, maybe there could have been water.
Maybe there could have been a lot of water.
Then we get Odyssey in orbit.
We get the GRS instrument, and my God, pole to pole.
It's dripping with water.
Of course, it's frozen.
Then, of course, remember, we published a paper a couple of years ago claiming that at the equator.
art bell
By the way, Richard, is all the reported water on Mars, and I went through the maps with you, as did many in the audience, is all of that holding up?
Because the water on the moon story kind of collapsed.
richard c hoagland
It comes and goes, doesn't it?
art bell
Yes, it does.
And so I'm wondering, is it...
richard c hoagland
I mean, this is like drip, drip, drip.
Unintended.
art bell
Well, drip, some omni.
richard c hoagland
Okay, well, we had said in our Mars paper, our title paper, which is on the Enterprise Mission website for those who want to read it, that when Odyssey got there, it would find water not merely at the poles and down at some latitude, but it would find two clusters of hydrogen or ice at the equator, 180 degrees apart.
And we based that prediction on these weird dark stains.
art bell
Yeah, and you hit it on the mark.
I mean, you did.
I give you that.
richard c hoagland
Totally, exactly.
That's called science.
art bell
You did it.
richard c hoagland
No Ouija board here.
That's science.
art bell
I predicted they would find the water and they found it.
richard c hoagland
I want to credit Efren Palermo and Jill England for doing the Yeoman service and doing all those maps and helping us make that very specific prediction.
Now, the three of us have said, the four of us actually, because Mike Berry is in the mix here too, have said that those dark stains are water.
In fact, I published on Enterprise in the summer of 2000 the first claim, and we sent press releases all over the world, every major news agency on the planet, that we had seen evidence of liquid water stains, stunning silence from everybody, including NASA.
Well, a year or so ago, papers started appearing at these various conferences saying, well, these things might not be avalanches after all.
They could be water.
art bell
No, you hit it.
richard c hoagland
Well, with that trend curve, remember, if you don't have water, you can't have life.
art bell
That's right.
richard c hoagland
So the next data point...
Let's just look at the life angle for a second here.
Without water, you ain't got life.
We now know that Mars is a planet awash in water.
Most of it is frozen, but near the equator, if these two places, these poles apart places, it appears to be wet.
The data shows that during the summer, when the temperatures are above the freezing point, you get these dark stains.
And when the temperature goes down, the stains disappear.
They behave like liquid water.
Well, there's so much water now available in these niches that the next data point that we would predict for either the NASA missions arriving in a few days or the Beagle 2 mission, which was supposed to have arrived Christmas morning, is that they would find microbes.
In fact, Pillinger was so confident that he was going to find evidence of living microbes, it's almost like he already had a heads up from somewhere that it was a foregone conclusion if he just got his spacecraft down there safely.
So I see officially the tidal wave here, mixing our metaphors, Natalie, is that the next data point has got to be we either confirm fossil evidence of former microbes, that's with the MER missions, or current microbes, which would have been Beagle 2.
Now, the huge leap, of course, is what we're expecting, which is at some point we've got to get pregnant with ruins, artifacts.
Which brings me to this remarkable memo coming out of JPL.
Let me give you a little background.
This came to me from a source, and I don't have permission to use this source's name.
It's not the same source that just called me, by the way.
It's another source.
You can't do this without sources, folks.
Anyway, and I don't have permission to quote the guy's name from JPL, but I can give you where he works.
art bell
Inside JPL.
richard c hoagland
Inside JPL, he is working for the MRO project.
He is a senior engineer on the MRO project, which is the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter, which is the next NASA mission, unmanned mission, going into orbit around Mars in 2005, and it will be able to photograph in color and in stereo art objects five inches across.
art bell
And what say your source?
richard c hoagland
This source says, and I'm quoting now this email directly, since, and this was sent on the 21st of December, since Mars Express with Marsus is going to be arriving in four days, I suggest you follow the progress of Marsus more intently than any of the other experiments, including MER.
That's the two NASA rover missions.
This is a NASA guy saying basically ignore the rover missions.
Focus on the Europeans.
Focus on the Marsus radar.
He says, he goes on to say, Beagle 2, if it works, won't tell us nearly as much as a good ground-penetrating radar.
Remember how the Sears-C, that's S-I-R-C, L-band radar that was on the shuttle, Earth orbit, found ancient buried Roman question mark roads that have been covered with thick sand in the Sahara?
art bell
That's right, yes.
richard c hoagland
Marses can possibly reveal subsurface features equally as exciting.
He says, to be honest, I am over my head with work right now preparing for a hardware delivery to the MRO project.
This consumes too much of my time to get involved in extended outreach efforts.
In that respect, I'm glad I have nothing to do with the MER project.
I regret I can't help you at this time.
Best of luck.
Sign, so-and-so.
art bell
All right.
Well, so that would seem to be a follow this particular photo.
richard c hoagland
Follow the radar.
art bell
Okay, fine.
If this mission should succeed and should get such photographs of underground cities that you and I both believe are there, then presumably somebody at some, I would say, high level has made a decision that it's time for the world to find out that there was a civilization on Mars, or it wouldn't be happening.
richard c hoagland
That's one excellent model, and that's the model I would have gone for up until the last year, year and a half.
art bell
Really?
richard c hoagland
So now the model that I'm looking at now, the equally attractive idea, theory, is that because of what this administration has done in Iraq and other places, and the resultant reaction from Europe, which has been so scathing, and how this administration has thumbed its nose, you know, and the latest thing, of course, is these contracts, you know, to rebuild Iraq.
unidentified
Yes.
richard c hoagland
Basically, we've told those guys, you know, sorry you're out of luck.
You weren't with us when we went in.
You're not going to be with us on the Gravy train.
The wild card here is, are the Europeans really pissed off enough to get off the plan and simply throw their own monkey wrench politically into the works and make public, regardless of what the plan is, what they find on Mars?
And that's the possibility that I think is at least 50-50.
art bell
All right.
So they would be angry and angry enough so that they could blow the lid off this entire thing.
richard c hoagland
Well, we have data.
Remember, I try not art.
And, you know, keep holding my feet to the fire because it's very important you do.
I try to back up things I say.
It's sometimes very hard in the political realm.
I mean, scientifically, this is duck soup.
You know, the title model, I have no doubt in my mind now that we're 99% right with the title model.
The politics are so much more difficult because in politics, they can always change their mind.
Tomorrow something else can happen, so they decide, oh, no, we're going to do this as opposed to that.
And you're not privy to 99.99% of what's going on in the back rooms.
Like what happened when Baker really went to Germany, to France, and to Russia about the reparation of the forgiveness of debts to Iraq?
art bell
We don't know.
richard c hoagland
We have no idea what the quid pro quo is and whether it's changed these politics.
But let me tell you why I think maybe the Europeans have the bit in their teeth and they want to break cover and come out with some real, honest to God data.
It goes back to Professor Newcomb.
When he gave his quote to the BBC and said that he had received emails from all over the world, that means this audience, guys and gals, it means you, and that these people had told him NASA is lying about Mars.
art bell
And he actually repeated that.
richard c hoagland
And he repeated that.
He did not have to say that, as you and I agreed the other night.
And I take that as a signal, both to us and to the administration, that there are surprises coming down the road when this spacecraft goes into operation in a couple of weeks.
art bell
Okay.
Let's imagine for a moment that it does turn up the cities.
unidentified
Yes.
richard c hoagland
Oh, and a delicious idea.
art bell
What sort of societal reaction would you expect to that?
richard c hoagland
It depends on how it is handled.
It depends on how it is put out there.
It depends who comes on board officially as authority figures and what they say.
art bell
Well, you can't be too gentle about it.
I mean, if the high European Space Authority says, look, cities, underground, ruins.
richard c hoagland
No, no, no, no, no.
They're not going to say it that way.
What I would do if I were in their shoes, and this is what this memo from JPL basically is saying.
art bell
Items of great geologic interest.
richard c hoagland
Well, no, they'll call them anomalies.
art bell
Anomalies, yes.
richard c hoagland
And they'll let us discuss it.
They'll let us come on Coast and on MSNBC where I've been invited and who knows where.
They'll let the internet crowd have a field day with it.
There will be long, careful deliberation.
There will be a year or two of analysis of these anomalies.
And we will have basically broken the ground and gotten people used to the idea of the grassroots that we're looking at maybe what we think we're looking at.
art bell
So you think it'll be a gentleman?
richard c hoagland
It has to be.
All this has to be handled gently because Brookings was right.
If you don't do this properly, you can come across.
unidentified
All right.
art bell
Hold it right there.
It's a totally non-trivial argument.
The whole Brookings report is non-trivial, and I think society would go berserk.
But you know, that's just me.
unidentified
from the high desert this is coast to coast You got the beam bad.
Give up the booze and the one night stand and then he'll settle down.
It's a quiet little town and forget about everything.
But you know he'll always keep moving.
You know he's never gonna stop moving.
Cause he's rolling, he's the rolling stone.
When you wake up it's a new morning.
The sun is shining, it's a new morning.
You're going, you're going home.
From coast to coast, Africa.
And worldwide on the internet.
This is Coast to Coast AM with guest host Art Bell.
To talk with Art Bell, call the wildcard line at area code 775-727-1295.
The first-time caller line is area code 775-727-1222.
To talk with Art Bell, from east of the Rockies, call toll-free at 800-825-5033.
From west of the Rockies, call 800-6188255.
International callers may reach ARC by calling your in-country spread access number, pressing option 5, and dialing poll 3 808930903.
And now, sitting in for George North.
Here is our fellow.
art bell
Larry from Akron, Ohio says, you know, it makes no difference what's on Mars.
I still have to go to work tomorrow.
I still have to pay my bills.
And Larry, right before it, but you may not be thinking this all the way through.
And that's really where we need to get to in this discussion about why this is not just important.
unidentified
But it's incredibly important for all of us.
art bell
All of us who are curious about our own origins and why we're here and how we got here and what we're supposed to be doing and, you know, the big unanswered questions.
The End So, Richard, there's Larry over there in Akron who's saying, look, makes no difference.
Don't care what's on Mars.
Have to go to work tomorrow.
Have to pay my bills.
Don't care what's on Mars.
Why should he care?
Why should Larry care?
Why is it important?
That's really the center question amidst all this that we've got to answer, I think.
richard c hoagland
Well, all right, let me give him a trivial answer.
We'll get to the big stuff in a few minutes.
art bell
Sure.
richard c hoagland
The trivial answer is, how did he communicate with you?
art bell
He sent me a computer message.
richard c hoagland
Ah, I wonder where his computer came from.
Without the space program, he wouldn't have a computer.
He would have a dial-up telephone.
He would be charged probably $50 to call Europe.
He'd be paying $12, $18, $20 to call California, if he ever calls California.
In other words, the space program has made the society so much richer.
And everybody out there who bought their loved ones and relatives and brothers and sisters and grandmothers and grandfathers, all these high-tech toys for Christmas, you wouldn't have had all that stuff if it weren't for John Kennedy saying, we're going to the moon.
art bell
What are you talking about?
Everybody knows Al Gore invented the internet.
Anyway, okay, fine.
So that's why we need a space program.
richard c hoagland
It's one of the reasons.
art bell
But that's not the answer to that.
richard c hoagland
It's not the core reason.
And we will get to that.
What I want to do is I want to get to some data.
I sent you some images earlier.
art bell
Oh, yes.
richard c hoagland
All right.
And I think it's probably time to go and look at a few of them.
art bell
All right, sure, fine.
richard c hoagland
Because we have remarkable information now that is waiting to be verified.
art bell
All right.
Picture number one is sunrise.
And these are all at coastcoastam.com, right on the website there.
Can't miss them.
Picture number one, and they're numbered sunrise color image confirms high reflectivity and original geometry of eastern surface of the face.
The face on Mars.
Now remember, this is a picture revisited.
We had this on before, and it is remarkable in that the sun is not at an angle to be illuminating what you're seeing on the one side of the face on Mars.
I mean, it is glowing.
There's no question about it.
There it is, folks.
Go take a look for yourself.
richard c hoagland
And look at the geometry of the face.
art bell
Yes.
richard c hoagland
That geometry is not the way maces work.
Not the way rocks, you know, sedimentary rocks pile up.
Not the way geology splits things.
This is anomalous in two ways.
It's incredibly reflective before the sun is up, and it's incredibly geometric.
In other words, it's look, to me, this is the smoking gun image art.
I have been working toward for 20 seconds.
art bell
Why is it a smoking gun?
What is it about the reflectivity of this?
Certainly odd, I'll give you without the sun being appropriately high to be doing this.
And even if it was, it wouldn't reflect like this.
So what accounts for this amount of reflectivity?
richard c hoagland
Well, unless the thing was solid obsidian, which is of course a volcanic extrusion, and there's no evidence of volcanic activity in the Sidonia region, you can talk to our geologists if you don't believe that.
This thing looks like it's burnished metal.
Now, what things that look statue-like also glow like burnished metal?
Artificial burnished metal statues.
In other words, this is an extraordinary piece of evidence.
But as with all good science, we need confirmation.
So what we have asked, Dr. Newcomb, who is running that camera now in orbit around Mars, as I speak right now, there's this amazing color stereo camera capable of giving us a color image 10 times better, 10 times closer, and in stereo than this picture that you're seeing on the website.
And that's what's so important.
Now, if you go to picture number two, this is a larger chunk of the whole image art.
At the top, you see the face there.
And you see on the lower right, there's something that's very bright and glowing.
art bell
What the heck is that?
What is it?
richard c hoagland
Well, we don't know.
We've been calling it a mesa all these years, but in fact, maybe it's not a mesa.
art bell
Do we know, Richard, a couple of things.
What angle was the sun at in this?
richard c hoagland
90.3 degrees.
art bell
Which would mean it's not over the horizon yet?
richard c hoagland
90 degrees would be on the horizon.
Okay.
90.3 is below the horizon.
art bell
It's below the horizon.
Okay.
Do we know the relative altitude of that side of the face and this other glowing object, reference the other objects in the frame?
richard c hoagland
Yeah, they're all roughly the same height.
Things that sit only are very shallow.
art bell
So there's no way in hell we should be getting this additional reflectivity unless there was a greater altitude involved in those objects.
richard c hoagland
Well, it's not greater altitude, it's greater reflectivity.
art bell
I understand.
no, I meant altitude in terms of actually seeing over the horizon.
richard c hoagland
That's right.
Now, the object in the bottom left is the one that we're going to focus on in the next couple of minutes.
That is this famed DNM pyramid that I named after Pietro Molinar many years ago.
art bell
Oh, yes, uh-huh.
richard c hoagland
The five-sided pyramid.
art bell
Yes.
richard c hoagland
Look at how incredibly bright that side is.
art bell
Just shining like crazy.
unidentified
Yeah.
richard c hoagland
Now, if you go to the next picture, number three, this is a wide shot prepared by Dr. Malin, oddly enough, from one of his surveyor wide-angle camera shots.
And it shows the basic interesting stuff we've identified at Sidonia.
The face, you can see it there, the cliff, the pholis, the city with the pyramids.
And then down below the face, you see this DNN pyramid.
Notice how regular it looks.
Notice how geometric it looks.
art bell
It does, yes.
richard c hoagland
So, then we go to the next picture.
This is now an image from Mars Odyssey that was taken a couple of years ago, maybe a year and a half ago.
And it demonstrated that there was all kinds of symmetries in this DNM pyramid.
By the way, the scale, the short sides are about a mile long, and the long side is almost two miles long, not counting the red extension up above, which shows now there's a platform this thing is sitting on.
And the inset in the lower left corner is from the Viking data back in 1976, transformed into a three-dimensional image by Dr. Mark Carlado with his shape-from-shading technology, which is the same technology which NASA uses and the DOD uses and all that.
So you can see this thing is a pyramid-looking thing, but it's enormous.
And I've noted with a couple of arrows there the corresponding features, that weird hole on the southeast edge that appears to go inside.
And, you know, anyway, if you go to the next picture, this is now a sequence of three images that was given to us a few weeks ago by Dr. Malin with the Mars Surveyor camera.
The image resolution here is about one and a half meters per pixel.
And the three strips were put together by Keith Laney.
Remember Keith Laney?
unidentified
Sure.
richard c hoagland
Who is the guy who does a lot of the Mars work for NASA Ames?
art bell
Yes, the center strip looks like it's in some different relief than the other two.
richard c hoagland
Well, they're different exposures.
That's why you're getting slightly different values.
art bell
All right, well, you can clearly see the size of the center strip.
richard c hoagland
Oh, yeah.
And what's important about the center strip, in fact, you actually honed in on it, this thing has five or six buttresses, depending upon how you count them.
And they look very, very geometric.
The one on the bottom right, the one in the center photo strip, we're going to show you an enlargement now that was made by Steve Troy and some graphics that were done over the last couple of days, drawings, that basically just take that center strip and expand it so you can see the detail around this buttress.
art bell
Gotcha.
richard c hoagland
And if you see the yellow overlays, those correspond to the graphics that he has done on the left and the right.
And at the very top image is just the photo enlarged.
Then what he's done is to overlay a drawing of the detail in the photo.
And as you go down progressively each frame, he fades the under photo deeper and deeper so that you're seeing more and more of his artistic graphic representations.
Now what's astonishing to me is how damn artificial this looks.
It has a rectilinear pattern, it's got coherent structures, and it's got what look for all the world like freeways going into that buttress.
And there appears to be a bridge over whatever.
art bell
Actually they do look that way.
unidentified
Yeah.
richard c hoagland
Now Malin said that his two criteria, I mean this was years ago in the Washington Post after we held our first press conference in 1988.
He told the Washington Post that he would only accept the idea of artificiality on Mars if he, one, could see repeating rectilinear geometry, and two, he could see the roads.
art bell
You're selling me what's already sold, Richard.
I firmly believe there are artificial things on Mars.
I believe I've seen the cities beneath Mars.
The water is there.
I believe all this, Richard.
You don't need to show me the geometry.
richard c hoagland
Well, but there are people in the audience maybe who have not had a chance to see this.
art bell
Perhaps so.
richard c hoagland
And what I need to tell people is that in the next few days, we're going to put up a very detailed analysis by Keith Laney and myself and Steve on the Enterprise Mission website.
And you'll have a lot of opportunity to peruse at your leisure, comparing these images, comparing terrestrial analogs.
For instance, the structure around this buttress, I've been groping in my mind for what it reminds me of.
It reminds me of a lot of the rectilinearities around the Great Pyramid on the satellite imagery looking down on Egypt.
art bell
Well, as interesting as this is, Richard, it's nowhere near the level of the picture of the cities.
You might as well put that up tonight if you really wanted to convince people.
richard c hoagland
You mean the infrared visual comparison?
unidentified
Sure.
richard c hoagland
Well, I didn't for a very specific reason, because there's such contention about that image.
That's one of the reasons why we have gone to Dr. Newcomb, because according to Jim Garvin, remember the Mars guy at NASA headquarters?
art bell
Yes.
richard c hoagland
He said a year and a half ago that Newcomb's camera will be able to take new infrared imagery of Sidonia to compare with the visual imagery and will be able to tell us if what we saw, what was leaked to us on that famous image, Is in fact real.
So let's keep that in our gray box for the time being until we get confirmation.
Science is always about confirmation, which is why it's so politically important that this audience keep emailing Dr. Newcomb and reminding him that this is a mystery whose time has come.
art bell
Okay.
All right.
The next photograph.
richard c hoagland
Well, the next photograph is one that I asked Steve to do specifically for tonight.
This is the apex of the DNM.
This is the highest resolution Malin has given us so far.
And if you scroll, I think in the presentation on the website, it's from left to right.
art bell
Yes.
richard c hoagland
It's horizontal as opposed to vertical.
art bell
Yes.
richard c hoagland
All right, if you start, and I don't know which, because I haven't been able to get into the website.
You know, my little bandwidth here doesn't allow me.
Is the raw image on the left or right?
art bell
Well, are you referring to, you don't know the photograph number, huh?
richard c hoagland
It's number 12, I believe.
No, I'm sorry.
It's not number 12.
It would be number 7.
art bell
Well, okay, 7.
7 is a graph, Richard.
De Palma's Spinning Ball.
No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.
unidentified
No, that is number 6.
No.
art bell
No, Richard, it's number 7.
De Palma's Spinning Ball.
richard c hoagland
No, no, no, no.
The image I'm talking about, which is a close-up of the DNM, should have been number seven.
So I don't know where he's put it now.
art bell
All right.
Well, the one with the.
Let's see if we're okay through number six, all right?
Number six had the yellow squares.
richard c hoagland
Yes.
art bell
The one we just discussed.
And then when you go to number seven, as I just mentioned to you, it is a spinning ball.
richard c hoagland
No, that's for the next discussion we're going to have.
So the close-up that I was going to show you, we can't show you.
art bell
There are a total of 11 photographs up there.
richard c hoagland
There should have been 12.
art bell
Okay.
unidentified
But have you refreshed your screen?
art bell
I'll do it right now.
richard c hoagland
Because I sent him another one.
That may be our problem.
We need to refresh.
art bell
Okay, yes, you are correct.
I needed to refresh.
Let's see what number 7 brings us now.
Ah, yes.
It's R1102437, DNM, top left.
richard c hoagland
That's the close-up of the top of the DNM.
art bell
Okay, it's been corrected.
Okay, go ahead.
richard c hoagland
Now, is the real image on the left or the right?
art bell
It would appear to be the left.
richard c hoagland
Excellent.
So if you simply scroll to your right, you'll see successive drawings that Steve has done of the detail that we see on the apex of this structure.
art bell
Correct.
richard c hoagland
Now, back in 1987, when I first published Monuments and I was doing my initial analysis, by the way, that's the Monuments of Mars, a Sitting on the Edge of Forever, a book that I always forget to plug, which is the chronology of this independent investigation going back now 20-some years.
Anyway, in that first edition in 87, I predicted that this structure, this incredible five-sided structure, was in fact an arcology, an enclosed artificial building of stupendous size, built on Mars because that was appropriate to the Mars environment when whoever did this was there doing it.
It has now taken till 2003 for Dr. Malin to release to us from Surveyor an image with enough resolution, as you can see here, to verify that in fact on this structure we see myriad replicating cell-like features looking for all the world like the exposed interior of a multiple honeycombed-like arcology on Mars.
And Newcomb, in color, at the right phase angle, and in stereo, will be able to confirm all this under a political system which has not been historically dissembling to us for the last 20 years on this subject.
That's why that camera and that individual is so important.
And the fact that we've got a healthy Mars Express spacecraft in orbit around Mars tonight is a major step forward in maybe finally answering this huge question.
Which, of course, brings us to the question you posed earlier.
Why the hell should we care?
art bell
Why is it important to us?
What questions will be answered or created or in what way will life change for us if you are correct?
richard c hoagland
Well, let's start with the big and work backwards.
You know, human beings have been looking for the last couple hundred years, ever since we invented the telescope, for company.
Right, Art?
art bell
Yes, sir.
richard c hoagland
I mean, we have looked out there.
There have been more books written on the subject, are we alone?
Every NASA mission that leaves, there will be a press conference, and somebody at one of those press conferences will say, oh, and this mission will, you know, give us more information on is the human race alone?
NASA has sold its entire soul and its budget on the concept of people want to know the answer to that question.
It's right up there along with, you know, why are we here?
Why do we exist?
It's almost art-like as if the human race was really, really, really lonely.
And until it finds something that it can compare itself with, it is missing a critical part of its own identity.
And there's this subliminal part of each of us that yearns to know the truth behind that question.
art bell
I know, I sure do.
richard c hoagland
And I mean, the polls show us when we did the conference in Wisconsin a couple of months ago, where you were predicting that we were going to have some fireworks because religious people of a fundamentalist fan would come up against this question.
art bell
Yes.
Well, you had it planned that way.
richard c hoagland
Well, we didn't have it planned exactly that way.
art bell
Well, I mean, there was going to be that controversy.
richard c hoagland
There was going to be that dichotomy present.
art bell
All right.
hold tight, Richard.
unidentified
We are at the top of the hour.
art bell
It really is a critically important question for the human race.
All of us.
unidentified
All of us.
Before I get stuck with me now.
You wanna stay out with your plans and friends I'm telling you we gotta be in the end Baby, when you're near the clouds There's no shadow, there's no way Who would come to me?
Baby, you'll see Who's gonna help you through the night?
Who's gonna love you, love you?
Who's gonna love you, love you?
Who's gonna love you?
Who's gonna love you?
From coast to coast and worldwide on the internet.
This is Coast to Coast AM with guest host Art Bell.
To talk with Art Bell, call the wildcard line at area code 775-727-1295.
The first-time caller line is area code 775-727-1222.
To talk with Art Bell, from east of the Rockies, call toll-free at 800-825-5033.
From west of the Rockies, call 800-618-8255.
International callers may reach Art by calling your in-country sprint access number, pressing option 5, and dialing toll-free 800-893-0903.
And now, sitting in for George Nori, here is Art Bell.
art bell
Good evening, everybody.
You see, I don't have this iron-clad religious faith.
Well, I do, I think I generally believe in a maker and a creator.
Beyond that, I don't know about every word written in the Bible.
And I do want the answers to these questions, and they are very important to me.
Who are we?
How did we get here?
What's our destiny?
What are we supposed to be doing?
Is this a giant classroom?
I mean, what's up?
You know, these kinds of questions.
I really do want those answers.
And while I don't agree with Richard on every aspect of his presentation with regard to the secrecy behind all of this and the relationship, for example, to Egypt and a lot of other aspects that he will discuss with regard to the Mars mystery, can we call it that?
Whether or not there is a civilization that at one time thrived on Mars is critically important to answering some of the aforementioned questions.
So I'm with Richard on some of it.
There's something on Mars.
I'm pretty well convinced of that.
And therefore, this subject is not only viable, but critical to all of us.
And that's what we're kind of right in the middle of right now.
We'll be right back.
unidentified
We'll be right back.
art bell
When you do a program like this, you receive an enormous number of emails.
And by the way, I'm very thankful for that.
And you can email me if you wish, artbell at mindspring.com or artbell at aol.com.
Both are good addresses.
That's artbell all lowercase, either at mindspring.com or aol.com.
So I get a lot of emails.
I get thousands and thousands of emails.
And over the years, I've had countless emails.
And I would say 20%, maybe 30% of those emails are from the Bible belt and from hardcore religious fundamentalists.
20 to 30%.
I'll hold it down at 20%.
Really hardcore religious fundamentalists.
And I can tell you right now that that group of people, not a small group, not 20%, Richard, you disagree with that figure, by the way?
20?
richard c hoagland
No, it sounds about right.
art bell
Yeah, it does it?
Okay.
richard c hoagland
Now, keep in mind that those people are more motivated to email you on this subject than, let's say, a more secular mainstream.
art bell
I absolutely agree.
richard c hoagland
So you have to weight your numbers that way.
art bell
Even if I were to cut it in half and make it 10%.
richard c hoagland
It is not a trivial percentage.
It's an important part of American society.
I will totally grant you that.
art bell
Okay, well, the temperature of those emails is out of sight, Richard.
They think all of this is absolute bunk.
Not only were there never living things on Mars or beings or intelligent beings, but such an idea, it goes against everything they know and they believe and they were told.
Genesis explains every word of how it happened, and that's literally how they believe it occurred, and there are no others.
We're it.
richard c hoagland
Well, see, this is the discussion that has to occur, and we formally began it, you know, from our side at the University of Wisconsin last October, October 25th.
art bell
How'd it go?
richard c hoagland
Well, we had a 13-hour conference.
We had myself, Mike Heiser, David Flynn, Paul Nelson, and Hugh Ross.
I think Hugh Ross has been on your show a couple, three times.
He was a fascinating guy to argue and discuss with.
I mean, he is a mainstream scientist and astronomer, came out of Caltech, now does work in Pasadena.
art bell
Yeah, so how'd it go with you, Ross?
richard c hoagland
He and I had an extraordinary set of exchanges.
art bell
I bet.
richard c hoagland
And this is all on videotape.
What I had planned to do is to, for all those people that wanted the tapes of that conference, which is 13 hours, I think it's 10 or 12 tapes, something like that, I'd hoped to get them to everybody by Christmas.
And as you know, the flu got me instead, and so we're a month behind.
But it was an extraordinary day that went from like 9 in the morning till almost midnight.
art bell
How did it go with you, Ross?
unidentified
It was, well, he actually softened.
richard c hoagland
As the day went on, he started out very dogmatic and very rigid.
And in the three-hour panel discussion, you will see that he actually began softening at the edges as he saw evidence and he saw a logic train that did not contravene his fundamental religious perspectives.
Mike Heiser and David Flynn were eloquent in demonstrating with literal chapter and verse from the Bible.
art bell
I wish I had Hugh here.
richard c hoagland
How, well, someday maybe we can have a debate or a discussion.
But until that time, you know, if anybody really wants to see how a fundamentally religious perspective confronts Sidonia.
That tape would be worth seeing.
And it can be seen.
In fact, if I can break into a commercial here, we can actually make it available if you call an 800 number.
Get a pencil and paper here, and I'll give it to you in a second.
The most important thing is, as you know, Hugh's perspective is that we're the only thing that's it.
Earth was prepared by the deity for human beings.
We reign supreme in the cosmos and the universe.
We are the only galaxy and the only place where we can see things.
I mean, it's an extraordinary litany of numbers and logic that he uses for mainstream science to defend his religious perspective that we're it.
So, of course, I asked him, but could not God, if he wanted to glorify himself, have created humanity in more than one place?
Because, as you know, my model, art, is that we're looking on Mars at stuff that we ourselves created.
And then David Flynn came in, and his thesis is that what we're seeing on Mars is humanity before the fall.
That the splendiferous, incredible architecture and science and engineering that is implied by the scale and the kinds of things we're seeing in these images would only be possible for a human species before the original sin, before the fall of Adam.
art bell
Put it another way, we are the Martians.
richard c hoagland
We are the Martians.
And this kind of took Ross aback, because obviously he had never really come up against this idea that you could divide human beings in those different eras to different places.
The Bible does not specifically exclude that kind of approach, it turned out from those that are textual biblical scholars like Heiser and like Flynn.
So, look, if you're interested in this dialogue, which we started in October, and you want to help us, what I want to do is to frankly get a lot of people in this audience to get these tapes and then send copies to various universities around the country and churches and theological groups and prayer groups and whomever and have us invited on the road to go and speak on this subject with other
people from other faiths, from other denominations, from, you know, ultimately I want to include Islam in this.
I want to include the Jewish community.
I want to have this discussion joined as to what this means at the most fundamental spiritual level when we confront the fact that the human species is a lot grander and has had a most astonishing history that up until now has been kept either by design or by accident come off of it.
art bell
Why would our Martian origins make us grander than if you took the literal meaning of Genesis?
richard c hoagland
Well, I'm speaking now directly to what the data is saying.
For someone to build an inhabited structure a mile on a side, two miles long, containing several cubic miles with all the stunning suburbs you see around it and all the filigree, even in ruins, there is an awesome, aching splendor there.
It just cries out for a majesty of accomplishment.
And when you read the Bible and you read the concept of humanity before and humanity after, from Flynn's perspective, this fits perfectly the concept of a fall, a fall from some extraordinary height where we were created as the chosen of God, put in a place where everything was at our beck and call.
There was no want, there was no suffering, there was no privation, and then something happened.
Well, scientifically, I can defend the idea that something awful happened, and we are here as refugees as the result of that something awful happening.
So whether you're coming at it from the religious point of view, and you want to finally know, and in God's good grace and time, ultimately he will reveal it, right?
That's what those people believe.
Or you come at it from the scientific point of view, Which is where I'm coming from, which is we have a right to know.
You know, we wouldn't have been, we wouldn't be thinking rational beings with the capability of asking these questions and finding the answers unless we were supposed to find the answers.
So, no matter which side of the coin you want to look at, ultimately, the knowing is where we have to go.
art bell
I'm all for that.
I'm all for that.
richard c hoagland
Let me give you that number.
For folks that want to really get into this and see how we discuss for the first time with religious scholars the concept of the Bible, Sidonia, the fall, Satan, you know, the whole everything was thrown in the mix.
We had an extraordinary day.
I wish you could have been there.
art bell
Okay, the number is...
richard c hoagland
That's 1-800-350-4639.
There is a tape system on there.
If you leave your name and phone number, they'll call you back.
And I promise we will have this out before the end of January.
And I really want a lot of messengers in this audience to send copies to their universities, their churches, wherever they think this discussion should be joined, because the Europeans have the wherewithal to bring it right to our front door if they so choose.
unidentified
Hmm.
art bell
Let's go back to this knowing.
And let us suppose for a moment the Europeans are successful, and we find out that there indeed are cities beneath the soil of Mars.
Cities.
So then what you said becomes somewhat logical that we are Martians.
richard c hoagland
Well, look, Mars.
art bell
So then there's these 20%.
10% of the audience out there that writes to me would be fundamentalist and would be extremely upset by that news.
richard c hoagland
Very upset.
I don't buy that.
art bell
Well, you can buy whatever you want, Richard.
I'm telling you about the emails.
I read them.
I get them.
I know.
richard c hoagland
We're talking in a vacuum.
This is before it's a reality.
It's before the churches have spoken, before the Baptists and the Lutherans and the Methodists and the Catholics.
And, you know, everybody has said, okay, this looks interesting.
What you're getting is that what Zogby gets when he does a poll, who can beat George Bush?
art bell
It's a lot more passionate than that, Roger.
We're dealing with really fundamental core beliefs.
And I'm telling you right now, there would be an incredible, incredible upset.
And you finished telling me that very few people could accomplish a great deal, a very few very determined people.
And if you had 10% or even a portion thereof, and I've already halved it again, it wouldn't matter.
That would be an enormous number of the, however many we are now, 300 million people in America, whatever the current figure is.
It's a lot.
richard c hoagland
Yeah, let's count up on 300 million.
art bell
Yeah, okay.
10% of that would be a bunch.
Right?
And they could accomplish a great deal in terms of turning things upside down.
Governments, religions.
unidentified
I think that's a little extreme.
art bell
Well, of course it is.
It's an extreme group.
And I'm going by what I've received, Richard.
I've had thousands, maybe hundreds of thousands, maybe a million emails since I've been doing this show.
richard c hoagland
Well, my take is that we need real information.
That's why I want to do this college tour.
I started in Wisconsin with Mike, and we're going to continue it.
You know, we're looking at a couple of other possible invitations already.
And when people get these tapes, then they can look at them and digest what's on them and see how the discussion flowed.
I mean, Hugh Ross actually came from a very hard position to a very interesting collegial position.
art bell
Explain it.
richard c hoagland
Well, I mean...
I don't want to go that far.
art bell
But I bet you can't.
richard c hoagland
Well, but I don't want to speak for him.
What you need to do is to have him on the show, maybe have me on, and we'll discuss the specifics.
But seeing the actual evidence and then seeing in context how the text in the Bible don't confront it but actually allow for it depending upon how they're interpreted.
art bell
He may have, as the night wore on, become perhaps more polite or circumspect in his...
Well, all right.
richard c hoagland
Laughing.
You've got to see.
That's why television is so important.
See this.
art bell
I would bet you a very great deal of money, Richard, that if I were to have him on the program right now and ask him if that conference changed his core beliefs, his hard, fundamental core beliefs, there'd be a great big no way.
richard c hoagland
Well, here's what's so interesting.
At one point in the conversation, I decided to make things intriguing, and I said, okay, look, you, I said, I will bet you a dinner at the fanciest restaurant you can pick out anywhere in Los Angeles that I'm right and that you're going to come around to seeing that it's there.
And he took me up on the bet.
art bell
I bet he did.
richard c hoagland
Now, here's what's interesting.
About an hour later, he said, can we put a time limit on that?
And I thought that was most intriguing.
art bell
Well, yeah, that's because he felt like otherwise it might not get answered in our lifetime, and what good then would a dinner do him?
richard c hoagland
Well, but that's not really playing fair, is it?
He wanted to put a two-year limit.
art bell
Richard, he has.
richard c hoagland
Two years.
Remember, here is a gentleman who was connected by way of Caltech and JPL.
He wanted to put a two-year limit.
Two years is when the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter, which will photograph things the size of this laptop in my lap, will be orbiting Mars.
And there will be no doubt if we don't get the data from Dr. Newcomb and Mars Express, the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter is being touted to get this as the people's camera.
They are already soliciting on the JPL website for people to submit targets for that camera to photograph.
And they have an elaborate plan for involving the general public in an ebb and flow discussion of what they're seeing on Mars from that stunning, incredible camera, which just happens to fall at the end of Hugh Ross's two-year cutoff.
I thought that was most interesting.
art bell
Pretty interesting.
But he hasn't changed his core views.
richard c hoagland
When you talk to him, let's see what goes on.
art bell
Fine.
Fine.
But I know that he hasn't changed his core views.
And I've interviewed Dr. Ross, and I just know that what he believes so passionately has not changed.
And nor would that be the case with most religious fundamentalists.
Now the average Catholic out there is going to write in and say, hey, no problem.
I don't have any problem with this kind of information.
It doesn't conflict with what I believe.
And that's quite correct.
But that average Catholic needs to understand that there are fundamentalists in many faiths, not just Christianity, who would be extremely challenged by the information.
richard c hoagland
Well, life is a challenging experience, Art.
And fortunately, most of us are, I think, up to the challenge.
And that's why it's time now that we join this discussion and we confront the implications.
Because, for instance, it says biblically that God created man in his image, right?
art bell
Yes.
richard c hoagland
We find our image lying on Mars.
That was one of the key things we discussed that day.
What does that mean for that particular phrase?
art bell
All right, hold it right there, Richard.
Bottom of the hour.
From the high desert in the middle of the night.
As you can see, these are very profound questions for all of us.
unidentified
Thank you.
From coast to coast and worldwide on the internet, this is Coast to Coast AM with guest host Art Bell.
To talk with Art Bell, call the wildcard line at area code 775-727-1295.
The first-time caller line is area code 775-727-1222.
To talk with Art Bell, from east of the Rockies, call toll-free at 800-825-5033.
From west of the Rockies, call 800-618-8255.
International callers may reach Art by calling your in-country sprint access number, pressing option 5, and dialing toll-free 800-893-0903.
And now, sitting in for George Norrie, here is Art Bell.
art bell
And indeed, tonight we will open the lines for Richard, which is always a very interesting experience.
Get his point of view on a lot of things.
So if you have questions for Richard C. Hoagland, questions perhaps you've always wanted to ask, this is going to be your opportunity.
unidentified
The End.
The End.
art bell
All right, Richard, I do want to get people on the line with you tonight and let them ask some questions.
But I'm sure there is a thing or two you wish to get in first.
richard c hoagland
Well, we were working our way down the list of why should we care about this.
art bell
That's right.
richard c hoagland
And I wanted to start with the biggest because who are we really is a question that everyone wants religious or scientific or an agnostic or even an atheist.
art bell
Yeah, sure.
richard c hoagland
Everybody wants to know the answer to that question.
art bell
Agreed.
richard c hoagland
And I believe fundamentally that staring us in the face, pun intended, some major new answers are waiting for us on Mars tonight, and we have to go and find out what those answers are.
Now, in a slightly lesser realm, you know, there's a lot of practical benefits that we could garner from unearthing, literally, an extraordinary high-level civilization.
art bell
For example.
richard c hoagland
Well, every previous civilization we found on Earth has been more primitive than we are.
You know, if you go to the Sumerians, the Egyptians, the Mayans, you know, these are Bronze Age cultures.
These are, you know, extraordinarily learned cultures in many areas.
The Mayans, of course, look at their mathematics and their astronomical systems.
But they really don't answer fundamental questions of the 21st century.
I want to read you an email that came in a couple days ago from someone who I think very eloquently speaks To what I want to talk about now.
His name is Mark Chuddy.
He's in Little Rock, Arkansas, and he doesn't know I was going to do this, but I wanted to do it just because I just thought it was very appropriate.
He says, Dear Richard, it's approximately 4:55 a.m. Central Standard Time in Little Rock, Arkansas.
I just finished donating to your site via PayPal, and I am currently listening to you converse with Art Bell on Coast the morning of December 21st.
I thoroughly enjoy your passion for Sidonia and pray that your wishes are granted, rather illuminated, with the new photographs that are being taken of Mars.
I am on total disability, four spine surgeries, and the implantation of a morphine pump for pain relief.
And late-night listening of Coast has gotten me through many a sleepless night.
Thank you for taking on the good old boy network of NASA.
As a side note, the VA graphics under your direction have created a stunning new look to your website.
My hat is off to you.
I look forward to contributing on a regular basis, kindest regards Mark.
Now, Mark is in an incredible medical condition.
The answer to Mark's problem, which lies in nerve regeneration art, may well lie in what we find on Mars.
If we had access to the libraries, particularly if they're libraries dealing with Homo sapiens, human beings, and a stunning technology, a medical science that is light years beyond that which we currently can do here and now, and it was a full-blown technology.
It's not like, for instance, they're carrying out certain experiments on the space station in zero gravity in the hopes that somehow that will contribute down the road toward this medical problem or that medical problem, et cetera, et cetera.
But if we were to find access to the science and technology of a species that was so far ahead of us that they could build encapsulated cities miles on a side and miles in the sky, the impact for all kinds of fundamental human problems on this planet would be incalculable.
unidentified
Agreed.
richard c hoagland
We literally would only have to bring the knowledge back and put it out there.
We would have textbooks, we would have videos, we would have literal living records because this is a high-tech civilization.
And high-tech civilizations will record more and more and more of what they do if our own experience is any guide here.
And given that our model says we're dealing with a human civilization, we can extrapolate from what we're doing that we simply did it better then than we're doing it now and we did more of it.
So if you now look at that, take it from the medical, which goes everything from Mark's problem to the fundamental problem, which is, do we really have to die?
Remember the night that you had the anti-aging guy on?
Sure.
The doctor?
art bell
Sure.
richard c hoagland
Who is struggling mightily against great odds and minuscule funding to find out why this fundamental disease strikes down all of us?
Bar none?
art bell
Yes.
richard c hoagland
Is it not possible in that milieu that at the very least human beings lived a lot longer and not with pain and suffering and senescence?
In other words, growing old, growing feeble, growing less virile, growing less capable?
Even the Bible suggests that now this is where David Flynn's perspective comes back in because he says, and he did a brilliant lecture, which again is on one of these tapes, illustrating how a lot of the textual support for these miracles in the Bible is answered if they are referring to a pre-fall state for humanity lying just next door.
And, you know, for Mark there in Little Rock tonight, that is a real doable thing because we wouldn't have a learning curve.
wouldn't have to spend years figuring out how to make this work of course would require uh...
art bell
our actually going to mars as in putting man But more than likely.
richard c hoagland
No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.
Think of this.
You had another guy on last Saturday, or this Sunday.
Your robot guy, Mr. Fink.
unidentified
Yes.
richard c hoagland
Imagine if the autonomous systems he's creating could be incorporated into a rover, which could be landed at Sidonia and could literally find the libraries, plug into the crystals or the CDs or whatever matrix that this data is recorded, and it will likely be underground.
Because if you look at the close-ups now we're getting of that area of the DNM, there's an incredible pattern which indicates we're looking at a surface porous structure that is hiding a lot of stuff beneath.
art bell
Well, if it survived, it had to be underground.
richard c hoagland
The stuff beneath will have survived.
The planet is a literal museum art.
It's kind of like a planetary Smithsonian because there is no oxygen.
There's no oxidation.
There's no corrosion.
The air is CO2.
I mean, the Constitution is protected in a glass case in Washington with CO2.
art bell
Sure.
richard c hoagland
So if we find stuff underground, and you would want to use robots probably because of the problem of potential landslides and cave-ins and stuff like that, even when you have a manned expedition, you're going to have robotic help to go to places that are too dangerous for you to go to until they're made safe.
art bell
Incidentally, side note, the President was going to make a speech, which could be delayed perhaps until, I'm told, the State of the Union.
unidentified
Yes.
art bell
In the speech, it is rumored the President was going to suggest we go back to the moon or perhaps even to Mars as a national goal.
What do you know about that?
richard c hoagland
Well, according to, again, my sources, that is all absolutely true.
The good news is, according to one contingent, the Bob Zubrin contingent, you know who Bob Zubrin is.
He's the avid.
He's almost as rabbit about Mars as I am.
The engineer who's been trying to sell for years and years the so-called concept of Mars Direct, how to get to Mars cheaply and quickly with current technology.
art bell
What do you say?
richard c hoagland
He says that we passed a kind of a drop-dead date on the 17th.
The fact that the president did not use the 100th anniversary at Kitty Hawk to announce this grand plan, which he claims was a basic stopgap effort by NASA to head off a real decision.
You know, to say we're going to go back to the moon in 20 years is basically a meaningless pronouncement.
It would be out of his administration, out of the next administration.
So there would have been no commitment of resources, no going to the Congress for money and actual technology and all that.
Well, Zubrin now says that having passed that date, the people at NASA that are trying to head off the Mars option have lost.
And that, in fact, it is a very viable option that if enough people let the White House know that they want to go to Mars, that by the time of the State of the Union, we could have that on the table and the President could well enunciate it as his big vision having passed through this window that NASA set up, this kind of trap that they tried to set up for the White House.
I'll go back to the moon.
art bell
Well, will he set it up as a vision with funding?
richard c hoagland
That is, of course, the major question.
And we won't know the answer until the speech is made.
But I do know that we had major input on the State of the Union last year.
You know, we turned out almost 20,000 responses in a couple of days.
art bell
Well, you know, I do agree that just announcing an effort to return to the moon, I don't think would light many fires out there.
richard c hoagland
Been there, done that.
art bell
Been there, done that.
richard c hoagland
The only reason to go to the moon.
art bell
And going back would be interesting enough from a lot of perspectives, actually.
richard c hoagland
Well, from my perspective.
art bell
Yes, but in terms of exciting the nation, exciting the world, giving us all a vision, Mars would have to be it.
richard c hoagland
The theory now, and I tend to agree, is that the President is going to wait to see what happens with the two NASA rovers on the 3rd and the 24th.
The State of the Union follows, like on the 27th, I think.
So with one or both of them down successful, and with the avid flux to the websites, you know, that will happen a la Pathfinder in 97.
art bell
Now, of course, if the President had in his pocket remarkable geographic subterranean anomalies, well, then you could really say Mars with some zip in your voice, couldn't you?
richard c hoagland
It depends on how politically courageous the administration wants to be.
art bell
Well, yeah, but if you had these great Anomalies that would demand investigation, then you really could justify a let's go to Mars.
richard c hoagland
That is the ideal scenario.
art bell
Yes.
richard c hoagland
Now, the reason for doing this, I am told again by our sources, is because this administration is fearful that the United States is losing its perennial supremacy in the world.
art bell
Well, they've got good reason to worry.
Look at China.
richard c hoagland
Exactly.
And look at Europe.
Europe, by the way, not only has got a successful mission around Mars tonight, Mars Express, did you know that they're a major player on the NASA mission to Saturn, which will get there on July 1 of 2004?
The Huygens probe, which is named after Christian Huygens, who was a very famous astronomer back in the 16th century, is going to plunge into Titan's atmosphere and soft land on Titan.
It is a European ESSA, European Space Agency mission.
art bell
Well, if you think we don't have a lot of control over the Europeans, because they might be miffed at us, then imagine how little control we have over the Chinese.
richard c hoagland
So whatever is happening now, India has announced it wants a manned Mars, a manned lunar mission within the next 10 years.
art bell
Yes.
richard c hoagland
Then there's Japan.
art bell
Yes.
But the Chinese are just going to listen to one word of p politically what we've got to say.
richard c hoagland
And so there has to be that's why the the um um uh speaker uh speaker of the house uh uh ha yeah the speaker of the hou not speaker what's his name uh Tom DeLay.
He's the um imperative, meaning that he's part, Cheney has been met with delay over the last several weeks and had several conversations.
And Dick Cheney, vice president, is the guy running this analysis that's going to present to the president whatever options for a revitalized NASA and a big vision, a big mission will be ultimately announced.
So if delay is on board, you know that the Republicans are going to be behind it with funding, and it's being looked at as a kind of a parallel to the strategic high ground of keeping the United States supreme technologically.
art bell
Suppose the president were to announce an intent to go to Mars.
Could we do it?
unidentified
Yes.
art bell
What would it require?
richard c hoagland
We know so much more about Mars than we knew about the moon when Kennedy made that pronouncement.
More important, we've had 40 years of space development on Mars.
art bell
Okay, how would we do it?
I mean, Saturn's her history.
richard c hoagland
Saturn's your history.
We don't need a Saturn.
art bell
Okay, what do we need then?
richard c hoagland
What you would do is you would redesign the shuttle system.
You would take off the orbiter, and you would turn the shuttle, the engine, the tanks, the guts of it, with an upper stage into a heavy-lift launch vehicle that would be the equivalent of the Saturn V. You would then, in Zubrin's vision, send a remote habitat to Mars first.
It would land autonomously.
It would begin to make rocket fuel.
And when you got signals from telemetry that the lights were on and it was safe to come home, you would then send your crew via a second launch to go to Mars a year or two later.
And you'd already have waiting for you the means to come home.
You would make your rocket fuel out of what's available on Mars, like living off the land.
A little bit like the Lewis and Clark expedition.
You know, Lewis and Clark, when Tom Jefferson penned personally, sat in the White House and penned the instructions for Lewis and Clark to explore this continent and gave us eventually the United States of America, he knew that they could live off the land, that they didn't have to take everything with them and bring it back.
That's Zubrin's model, and it works.
Now, NASA has other plans in parallel, which are the nuclear option, nuclear rockets and that kind of thing.
But we don't have to wait for that.
We can go to Mars with what we know now safely and relatively inexpensively, provided there is the political vision.
And if there are cities waiting for us, and if the Europeans are going to basically hold out the red flag and say, look what's there, this nation cannot afford to not rise to the challenge.
And I think that's what you're hearing echoes of in all these trial balloons in the Washington Post and the New York Times and the wire service.
art bell
I agree.
richard c hoagland
This foreshadowing of a big announcement.
art bell
Okay, let's talk about timetable.
With regard to the ongoing European mission, by what date might we, the public, have, I don't know, the smoking gun or the clear photographic evidence?
What's your best guess on dates?
richard c hoagland
Well, the only hard evidence we have is how long it's going to take the spacecraft to get into the right orbit to begin its mapping mission, which will be January 4th.
art bell
Yes, and when might they do the images that we're interested in?
richard c hoagland
Well, that depends on the orbit.
And they're not going to make special plans to go over Sidonia unless they have a secret agenda to do that.
So in the normal state of affairs, it takes about a month to fly over any particular spot on Mars from the orbit they're going to be in.
art bell
And the flow of information, how is it going to be?
richard c hoagland
It's supposed to be fairly real time.
art bell
Fairly real time.
richard c hoagland
Fairly real time.
In other words, within a few days of getting data, we're supposed to know about it.
And I would say politically, it's going to be paced politically much more than scientifically, Art.
And it all depends on the relationship between this administration and Europe and how much Europe wants to tweak the tiger's tail.
And remember, Europe is a very powerful economy with hundreds of millions of people who are much more attuned and open.
I mean, I am invited to Rome this summer.
I guess I didn't have a chance to tell you that.
To speak in Rome at a conference?
art bell
No, you didn't tell me.
richard c hoagland
And one of the things that I have specifically asked when I'm there, this is going to be after Steve Bassett's political conference in Washington in April.
We're going to fly directly from Washington to Rome and then back to Washington.
I have asked to speak with the Italian members of the Mars Express team, both the Marsis people and the camera people, to lay out for them the photographs of what we want them to help us confirm.
And I have been told for many years that the Europeans are much more open to these ideas than Americans, particularly the NASA people, have been.
And my emails and faxes over the years have confirmed this and requests for interviews from magazines and all that.
art bell
All right, Richard, you're going to have to hold it there.
We're at the top of the hour.
I do want to get some phones when we come back, all right?
richard c hoagland
Okay.
art bell
All right, good.
Hold it right there.
I'm Art Bell and this is Coast to Coast AM.
Anybody want to go to Mars?
unidentified
I'm Art Bell and this is Coast to Coast AM.
I'm Art Bell and this is Coast to Coast AM.
Anybody want to go to Mars?
I'm Art Bell and this is Coast to Coast AM.
Anybody want to go to Mars?
I'm Art Bell and this is Coast to Coast AM.
Anybody want to go to Mars?
I'm Art Bell and this is Coast to Coast AM.
Anybody want to go to Mars?
Once in her life, she musters a smile for his nostalgic tear.
Never come and dare what you wanted to say.
Wanted to realize it never really was.
She had a place in his life.
Ain't got no trouble in my life.
No foolish dream to make me cry.
I'm never frightened or worried.
I know I always get by.
I get up cool down.
Something gets in my way, I'm awhile.
Don't let life get me down.
I'm taking the way that I found it I got music in me I got music in me I got music in me I got music in me I got music in me I got music in me They say that life is a circle I
ran in the way that I found it But I'm moving a straight line Keeping my feet Found me on the ground I hit up, hit up, come down I got words in my head So I say that From coast to coast, and worldwide on the internet.
This is Coast to Coast AM with Desktop Start Bell.
To talk with Art Bell, call the file card line of Ariad Code 775, 7271295.
The first time call the line of area code 775-727-1222.
To talk with Art Bell, from East of the Rockies, call full-free at 8008255033.
From West of the Rockies, call 8006188255.
International callers may reach out by popping your in-country spring access number, pressing option 5, and dialing full-free 800893-0903.
And now, sitting in for George Norway, here is Art Bell.
art bell
Well, not everybody loves Richard C. Hoagland.
R.B. from out there somewhere says, I'd rather be have an ice pick stuck right through my eye than stay in the same room with Richard C. Hoagland.
So there are people out there who find this man extremely irritating.
I am not necessarily one of them.
There are times he's an extremely passionate person.
And frankly, we don't have anybody else out there this passionate, this involved in what might be on Mars.
A totally non-trivial question and perhaps soon to be a national goal.
I find Richard to be very, very important from one perspective.
Very important indeed.
And that's why he's here.
And he'll be right back.
And we're going to the phones in a moment.
unidentified
The End.
End.
art bell
The End So you see, Richard, not everybody loves you, but you knew that already, right?
richard c hoagland
You know, that has kind of been hinted at from time to time over the years.
art bell
Well, I mean, there is a group out there, Richard, and they don't like you at all.
But on the other hand, the way I look at this is you're the only really passionate person that I know that's saying the things that you're saying, and they are non-trivial.
And so you're very important.
And I think you're very important.
richard c hoagland
Well, thank you, my friend.
art bell
First time caller line, you're on the air with Richard C. Hoagland.
unidentified
Hello.
Hello?
art bell
Hi.
unidentified
Oh, okay.
Sorry about that.
Yeah.
This is Mark, Christian Fundamentalist, I guess, calling from Idaho.
Cool.
art bell
All right.
unidentified
Hi, Mark.
art bell
Welcome to the program.
unidentified
Well, I have a lot of things, but I guess I need to just narrow it down to one question, right?
So, um, yeah, that highway coming from Sidonia, it really looks to me like erosion line.
And I was wondering, uh, you know, we've seen a lot of pictures of these.
art bell
You mean instead of a highway, it looks more like erosion, as in water erosion or something like that, right?
River.
Okay, river.
There you are, Richard.
unidentified
And along that line, is there any kind of data as far as the gradient around that area?
Could it just be a downhill slope, and that could be water or carbon dioxide?
richard c hoagland
The only data we have at the moment is Dr. Carlado's shape-from-shading technology.
That's why the German camera on the Mars Express mission and Dr. Newcomb's willingness to re-photograph Sidonia in stereo is going to be so important because we'll have actual ground truth, real stereo imagery if he does what he says he's going to do.
unidentified
Okay.
And then I just have a comment right now.
art bell
Okay, fine, but you didn't answer his question, Richard.
The question was, couldn't it be erosion?
It doesn't have to be erosion.
richard c hoagland
It doesn't look to the geologist that we've shown this to like, you know, it just doesn't look like erosion, and it doesn't look like faulting.
Erosion doesn't have that surface texture.
art bell
But if I had you on a witness stand and I said, could it be erosion, you would probably have to answer yes.
richard c hoagland
Well, it could be anything until you constrain it with more data.
That's why we need higher resolution data and then color from Dr. Newcomb's camera.
art bell
All right.
Mr. Fundamentalist, anything else?
unidentified
I just, yeah, a comment.
About the rift, I guess, between fundamentalist and this Mars, pre-existing life on Mars, there is rift.
I mean, it has absolutely no impact on Christianity.
art bell
If there was life on Mars in the past, that would have no impact on Christianity?
unidentified
Well, no, no, that's not what I'm saying.
art bell
Well, that's good.
unidentified
I'm saying if there was life before the earth, because at the beginning of the Bible, it says that the earth Was null and void.
There was no creation of the earth.
So it could have pre-existed.
So there could have been a history before what we know now.
It's just not important.
richard c hoagland
That was Mike Heiser's position that textually is exactly what the Bible says.
There's this void where a lot of other stuff could have gone on that we're not privy to yet.
art bell
Yes, but quite clearly, if we are Martians, he wouldn't be happy about that at all.
Right?
Right.
Wildcard line, you're on the air with Richard C. Hoagland.
Hello.
unidentified
Hello, am I on?
art bell
You are indeed.
unidentified
Oh, this is incredible.
I've been trying to get on for 10 years.
art bell
That's incredible.
unidentified
Go ahead.
Go ahead.
art bell
No, I was just saying that's very persistent of you.
richard c hoagland
Christmas wife.
unidentified
Well, okay, you know, you talk about the power of prayer and those kind of things.
Well, my girlfriend's writing with me, and she prayed, and boom, got on.
art bell
Power of prayer.
unidentified
Maybe there's something going on there.
art bell
All right.
Anyway, here you are.
unidentified
Okay, well, I have a question.
I'd like to say, first of all, that I, too, am a Christian fundamentalist, and this is probably one of my favorite radio programs it's on.
art bell
First two calls, Richard.
One, two.
unidentified
Yeah.
And I love this subject.
richard c hoagland
That just means Christians have good sense to listen to Art Bell.
art bell
Anyway, you no doubt I have a question, right?
unidentified
Yes, I do have a question.
I'm definitely not one of the more intelligent people out there, but I've done a lot of research.
That's okay.
art bell
You don't have to qualify it.
Just get us.
unidentified
Okay, okay.
The question is, have you ever heard any of the parallels between the Nephilim of Genesis chapter 6, which is after the fall of man, but that the sons of God or otherwise the creatures from the heavens who came to the earth and created Nephilim.
art bell
What about the Nephilim?
unidentified
That somehow that these creatures from the heavens have something to do with the construction on Mars.
richard c hoagland
That's exactly David Flynn's position.
And, you know, if you want to see his full thesis, you know, you can get the video.
But he makes a very interesting case that the size...
art bell
But if that was true, Richard, then we would not be Martians.
If the Nephilim did everything that's on Mars, then we would not be Martians.
richard c hoagland
But how do we know that we're not related?
art bell
Well, the Bible is very clear about what the Nephilim were, and they were not fully us.
unidentified
But, but.
I think this subject would challenge every Christian to totally evaluate.
And they have to really, you know, we really have to wait for the evidence to be given to us.
Is this a separate species?
Or are they our descendants?
Is the Bible true?
richard c hoagland
Well, what does it say in the Bible about the Nephilim?
It says they saw that the women of earth were fair, and they took wives from them, right?
unidentified
Exactly.
richard c hoagland
Now, the only way that you can have a family is if you're genetically related, Art.
art bell
Right.
richard c hoagland
Which means the Nephilim are somehow a part of the human species.
art bell
Yes.
unidentified
Well, here's something that might be kind of interesting to think about.
These Nephilim, if they are spiritual creatures and if they've come here through some kind of a porthole, when they enter into our existence, there's still laws of physics and laws of science that they have to comply with.
So they have to take on a body or they have to actually take some kind of craft to fly in because they can't just float through the air.
So there's certain laws of physics that they have to comply with.
So when they come to Earth, they come in crafts and they actually have physical type bodies that they're able to interact with human beings and create the secondary race of people that's called the Nephilim.
richard c hoagland
You need to really see what David Flynn said in Wisconsin because it's exactly up, you know, that plus his book.
Flynn has a very excellent book out where he goes literally chapter and verse through all the textual references that refer back to Sidonia, including those in the Bible.
I mean, this, all right, we've had two callers so far who say they're Christians, right, Art?
Most of them appear to be open-minded and want to know, which is where I'm coming from.
I want to know.
art bell
Well, yes, but when you directly ask them, for example, would it upset you to know that we are Martians, then the line is drawn.
richard c hoagland
Do we still have our caller with us?
art bell
Not that caller, no.
East of the Rockies, you're on the air with Richard C. Hogan.
unidentified
Hey, good morning.
How are you guys?
art bell
All right.
Where are you, sir?
unidentified
Let's see.
I'm somewhere on I-75 running down to Florida in Georgia.
art bell
All right, got it.
unidentified
But hey, I was over by Perrump the other day.
Yes, sir.
I've got a couple things.
One, I guess you first off have to say that by definition, for all the Christians out there, I'm sure I'm going to make them mad, God or Jesus or Big Daddy Jr. and the spook are aliens.
By definition, if God created the world in seven days, he's not from the world.
He's not from Earth, which means if the face on Mars has anything to do with the human race, and we basically terraformed Earth, God, by definition, is an extraterrestrial.
richard c hoagland
This point was made in Wisconsin very several different ways.
art bell
Okay.
unidentified
Right.
You know, which means that one of the reasons that people hate you, Richard, and sad to say you are, which I'm never going to be used to hearing you as a guest host, but you guys, you're sitting right there in the forefront, pulled to shatter the world's religious belief system and, you know, kind of come forward and give answers to people that are looking for them.
So that's why I believe that most religious fanatics are afraid of you.
But it kind of brings me to another thing.
Sitting in this truck, I've got a lot of time to think about a lot of things.
art bell
I bet.
unidentified
And one of the things that I've come to realize is that the phrase, a mind is like a parachute, it only works when open, is incorrect.
It should read, a mind is like a parachute, it only works when open, but that only breaks your fall.
Our minds are like a parachale.
art bell
We soar above it all.
All right, sir.
unidentified
If you're willing to open your mind and think about it, there's no way that a parachute's going to help you because you're not going down.
art bell
All right.
I appreciate your call.
Thank you.
Well, let's just keep on moving.
West of the Rockies, you're on the air with Richard C. Hoagland.
unidentified
Hi, how are you?
art bell
Very well, thank you.
unidentified
First of all, I want to say I really like Richard C. Hoagland.
I love his passion and enthusiasm and his risk-taking.
art bell
He's got all of that in me.
unidentified
And yours, too, Art.
art bell
Thank you.
richard c hoagland
That's kind of, I think, why we're friends.
unidentified
Yeah, really.
And I'm so happy to be able to look forward for good or ill instead of just listening to people narrow-mindedly reacting to what's already happened.
Anyway, could I, I'd like to make a suggestion as to how knowledge about Mars having been inhabited by people, perhaps, might actually please the fundamentalists.
And then I want to ask a big question, if I could.
If it turns out that this is the case, I would think that the fundamentalists could feel validated and perhaps even triumphant if they can correlate the things that are in the Bible, like the Garden of Eden, let's say, like what the first callers have talked about, and say, see, it really was true.
art bell
If that's the way it worked out.
richard c hoagland
Can I interrupt you for a second?
unidentified
Yeah.
richard c hoagland
One of the maps that I showed in Wisconsin art was of Schaparelli's original maps of Mars made back in the late 1800s, around 1877.
And he named the various features on Mars that are common nomenclature today.
Well, just next door to Sidonia, you'll never guess what region he named on Mars after a certain place.
He called it Eden.
unidentified
Ah, interesting.
art bell
Yes, it could have been Eden.
I can see how you could slide that right in, and then, of course, when the old bite out of the apple went, so went the atmosphere.
richard c hoagland
Well, remember, our thesis is that some people know more than the rest of us.
They have access to some information somehow handed down through time.
Is it possible some of the early Mars scholars like Scaparelli, who so determinedly argued that those canals were artificial, that he knew something and that he made those maps so that someday that knowledge would come full circle?
art bell
well the ladies right i mean if they were to discover that to mars was the garden of eden for example uh...
it would validate a great deal it Sure.
That would be wild.
But that's a great big if.
And you had a big question.
unidentified
Yeah, right.
And may I also say that I think that we could say that if we really had been visited by aliens, that the big guys might be cloned drones and the grays might be android robots created by the original inhabitants of Mars.
And maybe what they're doing, if the cattle mutilations and the various samples that are taken and the abductions and whatever are true, maybe they're trying to recreate their original masters.
art bell
All right, well, let's hold it there, and let's ask Richard about contemporary ufology, crop circles, animal mutilations, the kinds of things she just talked about, the larger aliens, and then the manufactured graves.
That's a popular theory, Richard.
I mean, how do you handle all of that?
Might as well say.
richard c hoagland
Well, you know, it's interesting because I kind of half-expected tonight you were going to give me the Lear test at the top of the show.
art bell
No, because you disappointed me.
I know how you'd react to the Lear test.
richard c hoagland
Okay, good.
Look, given that we're looking at ruins, and I'm 99% convinced now that they're really there, and given that we may be looking at human ruins in an extraordinarily ancient and wondrous epoch, you then have to ask yourself, if only some of us came here, where do the rest of us go?
And my answer is that they're also here.
They've come back and they're meddling.
And part of the reason, Art, that maybe there has been an inhibition in letting the rest of us know our true history is that some of us out there have been meddling with the timeline, meddling with the historical curve to keep us in the dark.
art bell
Well, since you're that far out on a limb, then why don't you go ahead and tell us why would they meddle?
Motivation?
Why?
richard c hoagland
Well, what do human beings do to each other all the time?
art bell
Kill each other.
richard c hoagland
And control each other.
And knowledge is power.
Now, given that we're a pretty nasty species, I mean, look at what we do better than anything, and you just said it.
We kill each other.
Suppose the guys out there that didn't go through the fall don't think that we're ready for prime time, that we're people that should be allowed to associate with civilized races and human beings.
And they are determined to keep us down on the farm.
How better to keep us down on the farm than to meddle in our politics, to meddle with our spacecraft by remote control through human agents to simply keep us in this somnambulance so we don't really understand what it is we once had and what we could have again.
art bell
Well, there are many who believe that when we reached the moon, we were told that we should really go back home and we were met and that we were instructed that if we were to come off the farm, we'd be slaughtered.
I mean, that's putting it very gruffly, but there are people who believe we have been so instructed.
richard c hoagland
Well, the fact is that we went, and remember, I was there.
I was sitting right beside Cronke when we went to the moon, and we haven't been anywhere near the moon in over 30 years.
art bell
Suspicious.
richard c hoagland
What makes that, what made that happen?
Why the interregnum?
And why now can a president be poised to maybe return us there?
Is it possible there's anything else?
art bell
Well, I don't see how we've improved much.
Look what's going on around the world.
Buildings are blowing up.
We're having a war on terrorism.
I mean, it's not looking good in the killing category.
richard c hoagland
Maybe there are other factors we're not aware of.
This is all speculation.
art bell
It certainly is.
But since we're out here on a limb, I thought, what the hell?
Might as well go all the way out.
richard c hoagland
But if we're dealing with human beings, if we're dealing with, I mean, what did we do, the Soviet Union and the United States, but to meddle in every other nation and to basically control them or try to control them as our puppets in the bigger war?
Suppose that kind of game has been going on with this planet because of things out there that we have no conception of as yet.
art bell
All right, hold tight.
We will be right back.
unidentified
We will be right back.
Baby on a shoulder Just trying to step like molasses in the sky I'm going to go to
the sky I'm going to go to
the sky From coast to coast and worldwide on the internet, this is Coast to Coast AM with guest host Art Bell.
To talk with Art Bell, call the wildcard line at area code 775-727-1295.
The first-time caller line is area code 775-727-1222.
To talk with Art Bell, from east of the Rockies, call toll-free at 800-825-5033.
From west of the Rockies, call 800-618-8255.
International callers may reach Art by calling your in-country spread access number, pressing option 5, and dialing toll-free 800-893-0903.
And now, sitting in for George Norrie, here is Art Bell.
art bell
Inside 495 in Washington, D.C. says, Hoagland has a vivid imagination.
Well, it's true.
Richard has a vivid imagination.
And it's certainly not our place on this program to have people with imaginative dysfunction.
You know, that's what we're all about here.
He's got passion, and yes, he does have an imagination.
In a moment, more of it.
unidentified
*Gunshot* The End
art bell
There's really nobody else saying the things that Richard C. Hoagland is saying with the passion that he says them, and there needs to be somebody saying them.
There's a very great, large body of evidence indicating that there's a big surprise coming on Mars, and even the moon, should we return there.
So we've got to have somebody like Richard.
Richard Billy.
richard c hoagland
I have an idea.
unidentified
What?
richard c hoagland
Well, that last emailer makes an interesting point because, yes, I have an imagination.
But science begins in imagination.
art bell
Yes.
richard c hoagland
If you can't imagine it, you can't send out a methodology to test it.
So let me make this suggestion, and you can crunch on this and decide, you know, in your own good time what you want to do.
We ought to do a show someday on all the things I've been right about.
art bell
And we could include all the things you've been wrong about.
Yes, I'll be fair.
You have been right about a lot of things.
And that really is the reason I keep having you back, Richard.
There is nobody else who has the passion and interest to be pursuing this the way you do.
There's nobody else.
There are other scientists who can confirm parts of your work and that you brought forward.
But I mean, in terms of somebody really pushing down the path you've been going, I don't know of anybody else.
You've got some people who have helped you, but you really are the lead voice in all of this, so you're important.
richard c hoagland
Well, I think it would be very educational for people to see how the process works and how many predictions, scientific.
I'm not talking political now, because political predictions are worth the powder and a shot to blow them away, because as I said, the politics can change on a dime.
But the science stands.
The science is there, and it would be interesting and very important for people to gauge how we do the science part of this to see how many times we've made predictions and have been right.
And we're going to make, you know, We've got some stunning images up on the site of Saturn that we're not going to get to tonight.
I have a major set of predictions about the Saturn mission, Cassini, which is closing in even as we speak, which is very relevant to the other question that was asked.
art bell
Let's not waste it.
Go ahead, make them very quickly.
richard c hoagland
Well, but we can't make it quickly.
I would rather talk to real people tonight, and we'll just come back and do that another night, since it needs some seasoning anyway.
It will not go away.
art bell
In your next life, Richard, you will learn to do things quickly.
First time caller line, you're on the air with Richard C. Hoagland.
Hello.
unidentified
Hi, Art.
Hi, Richard.
This is Jeff from Knoxville, Tennessee.
art bell
Hey, Jeff.
unidentified
Hi there.
Richard, you've got me sold on the fact that there are, in fact, ancient structures buried beneath the sands of Mars.
I guess where I really haven't seen you present much evidence is your theory regarding the migration of Martians to Earth.
Is that speculation on your part, or do you have...
richard c hoagland
I mean, tonight, Art.
art bell
All right, just give me the brief theory.
I mean, what did you do?
richard c hoagland
Well, the theory is that you had Mars, which had an enormous catastrophe.
Something, you know, unimaginable happened to that planet.
The mainstream guys have come to the conclusion that something catastrophic happened.
They don't know what.
Our model, which we presented, it's on the website, the Mars title paper, is that Mars used to orbit a bigger planet out in the asteroid belt, and that planet blew up.
You know, there was two options.
It could have blown up or it could have been hit by something.
art bell
No, it even could have been our sun.
richard c hoagland
No.
Oh, yes, not in this model.
art bell
Well, maybe not in that model, but in another model, believe me, it could have been our sun that suddenly had a gigantic storm.
richard c hoagland
Well, because of the garden.
art bell
There was a program called Planet.
It was on HDTV, which I've been watching a lot of lately.
richard c hoagland
They were discovery.
art bell
The Discovery Channel, of course.
And it was a planet storm.
That was it.
And they really don't know what our sun's done in the past.
They certainly speculated that it could erupt enormously.
And at a time, for example, when a magnetic field was at a low or a switch point, and whatever atmosphere had been on Mars was suddenly vulnerable when it otherwise would not have been, you know, protected originally the way our own planet's atmosphere is protected, that it got whacked by the sun at the wrong moment, and that is certainly scientifically plausible.
richard c hoagland
The problem, Art, is that Mars got physically whacked.
It got hit by a humongous amount of junk material.
art bell
Right.
Well, that would have happened anyway.
richard c hoagland
No.
It happened all in one hemisphere in a very brief period of time in this model that we're laying out.
And which has the prediction.
Remember, the model is only as good as your predictions.
And we have some more predictions for the tidal model based on what the rovers, the NASA rovers, are going to find when they get down on the surface and start analyzing the dirt.
art bell
If it was that fast, Richard, and there was a mass extinction, including of the atmosphere, then who had time to build spaceships and go to Mother Earth?
richard c hoagland
Because they saw it coming.
art bell
They saw it coming.
richard c hoagland
It's in the physics.
It's in the hyperdimensional physics model.
So we need some night to really grapple with all the cool things.
I was going to get into a bit of it tonight as the practical benefit of going to Mars.
Because what's on Mars, if I'm right, are hyperdimensional machines, a technology light years better than ours that doesn't use fossil fuels that would make Stephen Greer drool, okay, that he could take off the shelf and plug in, and it will run.
And I have some laboratory data, and I actually was going to relate it to what we're seeing at Saturn in terms of observation that Cassini is going to make, but we can hold that for another show.
The point is that there is a stunning amount that we can learn about the solar system if we simply look and not come at it with preconceived notions.
And someday, I think a show where we go through all the weird areas I've been right will be appropriate.
art bell
I'd love to.
All right.
Wildcard line, you're on the air with Richard C. Hoagland.
unidentified
Hi.
Hi.
My name's Meredith, and I'm calling from Georgia.
Meredith Meredith.
richard c hoagland
Can you speak up a bit?
art bell
Yeah, you're going to have to yell at us, hon. Okay.
unidentified
Well, I wanted to mention that when you just were saying that about Mars and, well, I know Jupiter.
You know, could there have ever been a planet in between those two?
richard c hoagland
That's the whole idea.
art bell
Yes.
unidentified
What I mean is that planet.
art bell
Yes, this is the one that Richard speculates crashed into Mars.
richard c hoagland
Well, no.
No, no, no, no, no, no.
What happened was, and this is not original with me.
It's Tom Van Planner that originally came up with the idea that Mars was a satellite of a larger planet.
art bell
That's right, but you buy into it.
richard c hoagland
Well, we don't buy into it.
We have data that confirms it's the tidal model.
It's the signatures on Mars that have been found by Odyssey and the other spacecraft that confirm that that appears to be the scenario.
So this other planet that used to be the parent, you know, Mars was the moon and it was the parent.
art bell
That's where people actually lived, and then they built this monument on Mars.
richard c hoagland
No, no, no.
art bell
That's what Tom said.
That's what Tom said.
richard c hoagland
No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.
Don't confuse Tom's ideas with mine.
Tom thinks they lived on this other planet.
I don't.
I think it was too big and nasty for them to live on.
art bell
Well, I think that's what I said.
richard c hoagland
They lived on Mars.
art bell
Okay.
richard c hoagland
And they saw what was going to happen to the parent planet because they had a physics light years beyond ours and they saw what was going on in the core.
And planets occasionally explode by natural means, and or there may have been a war.
The wild card is we may have done it to ourselves on a Planetary scale as opposed to just nuking each other.
art bell
Well, that would have historical precedence, anyway.
richard c hoagland
And it would also have precursors.
So you would know, so a small band of refugees, to go back to the first question, then escaped to the only other place within the solar system they could live without technology, which was here.
But there were already guys here, another part of the human race.
That's where the Nephilim, the sons of God, the big guys, meet the little guys that lived here on Earth, that were part of the same human family.
So they could interbreed.
And it gets more interesting from there.
art bell
How do you like that, ma'am?
unidentified
Can I say something?
richard c hoagland
Yeah, sure.
unidentified
I wanted to say that I do, I don't know where I have this knowledge from, but I have a lot of knowledge, and it just is there in my soul, I guess.
And about three years ago, it just started kind of unfolding, and I started having, well, I started seeing prophecies that are in the Bible.
Of course, I was freaked out.
art bell
Okay, is there something you want to tell us about specific that you saw?
Knowledge?
unidentified
Oh, I've seen a lot of it.
It's just about everything.
That's what I was going to say.
There's many.
art bell
Anything that impacts on this discussion?
unidentified
Okay.
Well, I think that all life is all life in the universe is spirit on Earth.
art bell
Is what?
unidentified
Spirit on Earth.
art bell
All life in the universe is spirit on Earth.
unidentified
Well, what I mean is, okay, we're kind of, we're all from all over the universe, but we all live here on Earth.
richard c hoagland
At this moment, you mean?
unidentified
Yes.
art bell
Okay.
unidentified
Life as we know it, anyway.
art bell
All right, it's all Earth-centric.
richard c hoagland
Well, no, she's saying it's a transmigration of souls.
We wound up here from all other kinds of places.
art bell
Yeah, there are many who believe that.
richard c hoagland
That is not forbidden by this idea.
art bell
For example, Richard, people who believe in reincarnation lately have been telling me they think that there's a great chance that you will be reincarnated as another intelligent being elsewhere in the universe.
richard c hoagland
Would it surprise you?
I've met people who claim the reverse has happened and they have come here from other places over the years of this.
art bell
No, I've talked to some of those same people, Richard.
Believe me.
East of the Rockies, you're on the air with Richard C. Hoagland.
unidentified
Hello.
art bell
Hello.
Yes, hello.
unidentified
Hi, I'm calling from Niagara Falls, New York.
My name is Mario, and I'm listening to you on WBEN 9.30 a.m.
art bell
Yes, sir.
unidentified
Okay.
richard c hoagland
Can you speak up a bit?
I can barely hear you.
unidentified
All right.
Is that any better?
art bell
Yes.
unidentified
Okay, very good.
I'd like to back up Richard's statement a little bit.
My father used to tell me this story when I was young, and he had a brother who is a cardinal in Rome.
And he used to tell me when I was young that we are the Martians and that Adam and Eve, first of all, the Garden of Eden was on Mars.
And Adam and Eve came to Earth from Mars.
And that's where how the story goes from there.
art bell
All right.
Well, in other words, that backs up what you were tossing around a little earlier, really, Richard.
unidentified
Yeah.
richard c hoagland
That's one of the reasons I want to go to Rome and talk to a few cardinals myself.
art bell
Well, I would imagine that if we were to make this discovery on Mars, there would be a very great deal of religious speculation right along that line, wouldn't you think, early on?
unidentified
Yes.
art bell
West of the Rockies, you're on the air with Richard C. Hoagland.
unidentified
Hello.
Yeah, hi, gentlemen.
It's Bob from San Francisco Bay Area.
art bell
Hi, Bob.
richard c hoagland
My old stomping grounds.
unidentified
Hi, Richard.
Hi, there.
I used to work for a fellow that I think you know that we took out Buckminster.
art bell
Where'd he go?
richard c hoagland
I don't know.
art bell
Are you there, Caller?
unidentified
Yeah.
Hello?
art bell
Yes, go ahead.
Please continue.
unidentified
Yeah, I took out Bucky Fuller on this guy's yacht, Sirona, this boat in San Francisco Bay.
And that was right after he did a seminar on tetrahedrons.
art bell
Yeah.
unidentified
Set up by the S Foundation.
You know, I used to work for Warner, you know.
richard c hoagland
Ah.
unidentified
Okay.
Yeah, if you want to keep me on the line, I could give you my phone number if you want to talk about that.
But I know it seems like you're interested in that.
You had that business about the old Navy and the tetrahedron.
And I just wondered if you had anything to share about that.
Any results from that little survey or experiment you did?
God, it's probably been eight or nine years.
art bell
I'll never forget if you want to.
unidentified
I'll never forget the organization.
art bell
I will never forget the old Navy thing.
One of the more interesting times we've had on the air together.
richard c hoagland
Well, I think what it revealed is that there are things going on beneath the surface that we're not privy to.
And when you strike gold like that, I mean, I haven't got any real new news except that I know there is a contingent which is following this story and from time to time do various things to try to, shall we say, advance the curve.
That's all I can say.
art bell
Okay.
First time caller line, you're on the air with Richard C. Hoagland.
Hello.
unidentified
Hi, how are you?
Okay.
richard c hoagland
We're doing great.
unidentified
I have a question about if, Richard, you think that we're Martians here on Earth.
How does that work with the whole… And also, what kind of animals do you think non-human animals were on Mars?
art bell
Okay, Richard.
First of all, what about Darwin?
richard c hoagland
Well, this is one of the things that Paul Nelson and I had a brief discussion on at Wisconsin, because, as you know, he's a creationist, and he believes, as does Hugh Ross, that life was placed here in all its various forms, Like, you know, Fiat Lux, like overnight by order of a divine creator.
art bell
Indeed.
richard c hoagland
One of the things that we found over the years in looking at this physics is that there are potential explanations that are alternatives to evolution for the biology that we see in the fossil record here on planet Earth.
When it comes to Homo sapiens, it's very clear now that we have not been left alone, that there has been something happening.
I mean, this is the story of 2001, that something from outside has influenced our evolution, as it were.
And the only thing now left is to figure out exactly what did happen and who was involved.
Major parts of this story, I think, are on Mars and on the moon and in the rest of the solar system.
And if we can ever get some honest scientists and government people in charge of the space program to tell us what they're really finding, we'll know a lot more of the story.
But if we're continually kept in the dark politically, then scientifically we can make no progress, and that's why we've got to solve the politics first.
art bell
All right, Richard.
I would like to give you another chance.
You know, the debate that occurred with Dr. Ross and many others, how many hours of tapes have been?
13 hours of tapes.
That would be very, very interesting.
I'm looking forward to getting my copies of them, Richard.
So those who would like to get copies of the tapes would do so by calling a magical 800 number, right?
unidentified
Yep.
art bell
Which is.
richard c hoagland
Which I don't have on the screen at the moment.
unidentified
Huh.
art bell
Well, I didn't write it down, so you're out of luck, buddy.
richard c hoagland
Okay.
art bell
They're going to have to get that from the archives, I guess.
richard c hoagland
Well, it's on the Enterprise Mission website.
Just go to www.enterprismission.com, and lo and behold, it will take you magically to the number, which actually is 1-800.
art bell
Oh, you found it.
richard c hoagland
1-800-350-4639.
1-800-350-4639.
And you can still go to Enterprise and copy it down at your leisure.
And as I said, during the month of January, I will finish editing with Laurie Hokkola, who is my editor, who's a stunningly talented guy, this 13 hours.
And I guarantee you will not be disappointed.
art bell
All right, I'll tell you what I would like to do, Richard.
In addition to that, now I give you a great big fat plug, right?
richard c hoagland
Thank you.
art bell
I'd like to get Dr. Hugh Ross on the air, on the program, along with you.
unidentified
Sure.
art bell
And just like let the two of you go at it for a while.
richard c hoagland
That would be fun.
unidentified
Good.
art bell
All right, then I'll look forward to that.
In the meantime, the tapes are available, and as always, I want to thank you for being here.
It has been a pleasure, Bridget.
unidentified
All right.
richard c hoagland
Merry Christmas, Happy New Year, and I'm so glad you're in that chair.
art bell
Good night, my friend.
richard c hoagland
Good night.
art bell
All right.
Remember now, beginning tomorrow night, we're going to take predictions.
Very, very serious predictions.
And they're going to be serious because you are going to take a few moments out of your life, get quiet, and try and imagine a large event that you see coming in 2004.
That's what we're going to be up to.
Open lines tomorrow night, then Wednesday night as well.
From the high desert for this night, I'm Art Bell.
Export Selection