All Episodes
Feb. 8, 2000 - Art Bell
02:42:32
Coast to Coast AM with Art Bell - Ghostly Communications - Joel Rothschild
Participants
Main voices
a
art bell
59:12
j
joel rothschild
44:22
p
peter gersten
19:02
| Copy link to current segment

Speaker Time Text
unidentified
Welcome to Arkbell Somewhere in Time.
Tonight featuring Coast to Coast A.M. from February 8th, 2000.
art bell
From the high desert and the great American Southwest, I bid you all good evening and or good morning as the case may be.
And welcome to another edition of the Best in Live Overnight Talk Radio.
From the Tahitian and Hawaiian Islands, commercially out west eastward to the Caribbean and the U.S. Virgin Islands, south into South America, north, all the way to the Pole.
This is Coast Close AM.
And I'm Mark Bell.
In a moment, coming up is going to be Peter Kirsten.
unidentified
It looks like Peter had a really good day in court.
art bell
We're going to find out all about it, what happened in Arizona, but let's put it this way.
It doesn't look like it's going the government's way.
So we'll have that update in the next hour.
Joel Rothkoff.
Joel is perhaps the longest living AIDS patient in America today.
unidentified
And he's just written a book called Signals.
art bell
And you know what it's about?
I guess a friend of his had AIDS as well.
And they made a pact that the first one to die would try to get a signal to the other.
unidentified
And he's written a book called Signals.
art bell
I've got a whole lot of stuff I need to get on the air tonight, so I'll just sort of do the best I can, but I want to get this whole Arizona thing covered, what's going on down in Arizona, because it is very, very important.
But first, I've got a sad note that I've got to get on the air.
You may have been seeing on CNN, if you've been watching the late news, the news on the two small planes that collided in Chicago with one of those planes landing on a hospital roof.
Unfortunately, a colleague in the industry, Bob Collins, who had been hosting the morning program for my competitor in Chicago, WGN, was in one of those planes.
He is dead.
And there just have been too many lately.
But Bob Collins, known to Chicago audiences, since 1974, dead in a plane crash.
We'll get more of that next hour.
Or I'll hit on it again, because actually that's when Chicago, I think, joins.
So in a moment, you're going to get to hear what happened in Arizona in a courtroom where I understand, thanks to you all, there was SRO, standing room only.
And I guess Peter really laid it on him.
That's coming up.
The End All right, as many of you know, my wife and I saw a large triangular object float, not fly, above our heads.
Millions of other Americans have seen them.
Peter Gerston filed a Freedom of Information request trying to find out about these triangular objects that those of us who have seen them know damn well are up there.
And we didn't think, you know, you just keep batting against the wall and you don't think anything necessarily is going to happen, but you keep trying because you got to.
Well, Peter went to court.
In a precedent-setting hearing, the federal judge has now decided to consider a UFO group's claims that the government failed to conduct an adequate search for information about a very unusual aerial object.
Well, hooray.
In the Phoenix, Arizona federal lawsuit, citizens against UFO secrecy, that's our Peter Gerston cause, versus the Department of Defense Chief Judge Stephen McNamee, once again ignored the government's plea to dismiss the case.
Hooray for you, Judge McNamee.
Instead, took under advisement the group's claim that the government was guilty of bad faith.
Our government guilty of bad faith?
unidentified
Hmm.
art bell
In its search for information about a very unusual triangular aerial object.
Though cause, which had brought the lawsuit under the Freedom of Information Act in 1999, submitted numerous affidavits from witnesses who had observed the aerial object, the Department of Defense, ours, continues to maintain in court that it could find no information, none, confirming the existence of this object.
And so they had like a 30-minute court go-round about all of this.
And it looks like Peter is standing, still standing, and the we'll find out right now.
Peter Griston, welcome.
peter gersten
Good evening, Arthur.
Isn't that a song?
I'm Still Standing?
art bell
I'm Still Standing, yeah.
peter gersten
I feel like I'm trying criminal cases in New York again, and the jury is out deliberating, and we're all waiting for a verdict.
art bell
Well, maybe you can give, I hear it was standing room only, is that true?
peter gersten
Yes, and I want to thank you for your help in getting the word out, because most of the people that came said they heard about the lawsuit on the Ott Bell show.
Thank you very much, my friend.
art bell
You're very welcome.
Now, for those who were not standing in there, standing room only courtroom, what was it like?
Can you give us a sense of how it came down and the expression on people's faces, the tone of their voices, the things that we all can't get from the story?
peter gersten
Well, first of all, the energy was great.
I had asked my membership to send me positive energy starting at 10 o'clock Arizona time, and the energy was terrific.
It was really positive.
And the courtroom was packed, and I had some of my closest friends there as supporters.
Ted Lohman, the deputy director of CORES, came all the way up, and you know, he's legally blind, came all the way up from Tucson to sit at the table next to me.
We had Jim De La Toso there.
We had some of my other friends who showed up, members of Coors.
And then we had some people that came in.
It's interesting because after I was on your show the other night, before I even hung up, I got a call from an individual who wanted to know if I wanted him to bring his friends down to federal court in order to be rowdy.
So I suggested that this is federal court, and I don't think that's in his best interest.
art bell
Not a good idea.
peter gersten
Not a good, but I think they were the ones that showed up with purple hair and green hair and things like that.
And then a couple of individuals walked in the courtroom before the case was called with some cups of water and coffee, and of course you're not allowed to do that.
Federal court is very strict and very conservative and very professionally run.
It's totally different than state court.
And you're not allowed to have audio or video equipment not only in the courtroom, but in the courthouse.
art bell
Well, that's why when on the evening news you see a description of a court case, you see only artists' renderings of what was going on.
They sit out there and sketch what was going on because that's all they're allowed to do.
peter gersten
That is correct.
And then they had some cases called before they called the cause case and they actually even admitted some attorneys into federal court right before they called the case.
So I was watching the judge and the judge was schmoozing with some of the new attorneys that were being admitted and he was asking them about what alma mater they went to and they were talking about basketball and the NCAA.
So it was a pretty light atmosphere as well as high energy.
So I felt pretty comfortable and then they called the cause case and there's a podium and each of the attorneys have to get up and speak in front of the podium, you know, looking at the judge.
So I couldn't see how many people were coming in.
And the court, I guess, held about 70, 80 people.
And unbeknownst to me, while I was speaking, more people were coming in.
And basically, it was standing room only.
So there were close to about 100 people there that came for that particular case.
They came for this case from all over.
And it was great.
art bell
Do you think that that kind of attendance has any effect on a federal judge?
You know, I mean, he can obviously see it's packed.
There's tremendous interest in this.
Would it have any subtle effects?
peter gersten
Well, I think maybe not generally, but in this particular case, it might have because one of his questions during the arguments was directed to the fact that I only had a sample number of affidavits from certain locations that he considered populated.
And he wanted to know if this object was seen in populated areas, how come I wouldn't have more affidavits?
So basically, I indicated to him that I could have produced hundreds and thousands of affidavits.
These were just samples.
And I alluded to the audience.
And I made reference to the fact that I would say that at least half the people in the audience, if not more, has seen this object.
So I would think the fact that not only was the audience packed, but it was full of people who were eyewitnesses to what it is that I was trying to prove existed, to infer that the Department of Defense would have to have information on it, I think for that effect it was effective.
art bell
What was the other side of the aisle like?
What kind of attorneys were there representing the DOD?
peter gersten
Well, it's funny because the DOD didn't even show up.
I think they thought they had this in their pockets.
art bell
Excuse me?
they didn't have any representation there at all?
peter gersten
No, I don't think...
The U.S. Attorney was there, two U.S. Attorneys were there, the one that has been handling all my cases that cause has brought, including the evasion case.
And he seemed so unprepared and so as if uncomfortable that he didn't want to be there.
I was surprised because usually you would think that Central Cosmic Casting would send down somebody that was on an equal level so that you would rise to the occasion.
And that's what I like, somebody who is at least at the same level so that I can rise to that occasion.
art bell
Yes, indeed.
peter gersten
Rather than lowering race.
But he was so, he got up, he spoke first because it was his motion.
And he basically initially even conceded the fact that Koors had raised issues in response to his motion.
He said they didn't reach the threshold of bad faith, but he, you know, so that was the concession right there.
You know, before I even got up.
art bell
He admitted that you had raised valid issues.
peter gersten
Yeah, and as a matter of fact, this judge was so perfect.
As I was saying, that it was so well choreographed.
art bell
But he was arguing that these issues didn't raise to the level of bad faith.
peter gersten
Exactly.
In other words, these were issues, but not issues that would change, would be a triable issue, would defeat a motion for summary judgment.
Because all I had to do is raise a triable issue.
A motion for summary judgment only exists if there are no issues in the case.
In other words, if, in fact, they did a reasonable search, they found no documents, there's no issues.
art bell
Well, maybe then he was an attorney, and of course I'm speculating, but he was just sent down there as a matter of course without any DOD consultation whatsoever and said, handle this case.
And so what the hell is he going to say?
peter gersten
Yeah, it probably came close to that because the word is that the DOD is not cooperating with the U.S. Attorney's Office in several of the cases.
And as a matter of fact, before I even stood up to argue, he was still presenting his position.
And the judge said, I have a question before I even stood up of the U.S. Attorney.
And the question was, what is your argument as to Mr. Gerston's suggestion that the search that the DOD did was not specific enough?
art bell
That's a good.
Straight-out question.
peter gersten
Which showed me that the judge had read the motion and my response as well as each and every one of the affidavits.
So the judge, and these are federal judges, and not only that, they're appointed for life.
And somebody sent me an email tonight saying, well, what are you going to get from a judge who's appointed?
But they're appointed for life.
art bell
That's correct.
peter gersten
They don't owe any favors.
And he's the chief judge, which I didn't know until I got there, the chief judge of the district.
art bell
Well, they sure don't owe any favors after the administration that has appointed them has passed away, as administrations always do.
Whether you you might argue that appointed judges by the current administration might be subject to a little back pressure.
peter gersten
Well, I guess, you know, they're subjected to certain concerns.
And if, in fact, the Department of Defense had found documents and had withheld them on national security grounds, like the government usually does in UFO cases, then I'm sure he would have sided with the government, as they all do in these type of cases.
Because how do you attack an exemption of national security?
art bell
Well, because that reveals a lie.
I mean, if they were to say that, they would then be admitting a lie.
The first lie, saying they had no information on any object of that sort or description.
So if they said national security, then they would be admitting they lied.
peter gersten
Well, I mean initially.
I mean instead of saying they didn't find any documents, they initially said national security.
Yeah, now I would say it's too late unless somehow they say, well, we went back and we did another search and we looked in areas we never looked in before and we found them.
But now that affects national security.
It's possible they can say that.
But we're not even at that stage.
The judge still has to decide on my suggestion that he don't decide the motion for summary judgment, but put it over for 90 days and allow me during those 90 days to assist the Department of Defense in finding and locating the documents.
Because there is no doubt in my mind that somewhere within the Department of Defense are those documents.
art bell
Yes, yes.
How would you propose to assist DOD in searching through their files?
peter gersten
I would like the judge to give me subpoena power.
In other words, allow me to subpoena certain military and civilian officials within the O.D. Peter, Peter, you're on a portable phone, aren't you?
Yeah.
art bell
Yeah, you're going to have to either stay real close to the base or pick up a regular one.
peter gersten
Okay, can you hear me better now?
art bell
Yeah, as long as you're not moving, I think.
peter gersten
Okay, I'll stay still.
art bell
All right.
peter gersten
All right.
art bell
I know it's exciting, but you guys.
peter gersten
Well, it's hard.
The judge wouldn't let me move around during my argument.
art bell
Really?
peter gersten
Well, you have to stay at the podium.
And during my summations in New York and criminal cases, I would move up and down the jury.
I would walk over to different witnesses and things.
art bell
Sure, sure.
So that's it then.
That's it.
He's proposed, or you've proposed, that you be given 90 days to work with DOD to help them find information on a triangular object that does, in fact, exist.
peter gersten
Exactly.
art bell
And so that's your argument right.
Now, when does he come back and rule on that, in all likelihood, or is that simply unknown?
peter gersten
Well, he can rule anyway.
He can come up with his own solution.
He can decide on a hearing and bring in the witnesses and allow me to cross-examine them as to their search.
He can give me subpoena power and allow me to take depositions from some of the officials within the Joint Chiefs of Staff and the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency.
I can renew my application to subpoena and depose Stephen Greer and Peter Davenport, which he denied.
art bell
All right, hold it right there, Peter.
We're at the bottom of the arrow.
We'll be right back.
Peter Gerston is here, and looks like he won one.
Sort of.
We'll be back with more in a moment.
unidentified
You're listening to Art Bell somewhere in time.
Tonight, featuring a replay of Coach to Coast AM from February 8th, 2000.
But she lets me down every time Can't make her mine She's no one's lover tonight with me She'll be so inviting.
I want her all for myself.
Oh, temptation eyes.
Looking through my, my, my.
Oh, temptation eyes.
You gotta love me.
You gotta love me tonight.
Love me, baby, yeah.
Love me, baby, yeah.
It's just a game, but just the same.
My head is spinning.
She's got a way to keep me on her side.
It's never ending tonight with me.
She'll be so exciting.
I want it all for myself.
I'll transition eyes, look and prove at my mind.
I'll transition eyes, look and prove at my mind.
Walking in with them, moving in sound on the field of music.
Trying to move home.
I'm walking in with them.
Singing my song.
Thinking about my baby.
Trying to get home.
Walking in with them.
Moving in sound.
On into the music.
Trying to move home.
You're listening to Arkbell Somewhere in Time on Premier Radio Networks.
Tonight, an encore presentation of Coast to Coast AM from February 8th, 2000.
Good morning.
art bell
Peter Gerston is here, and I think Peter's had a victory.
There's no question about it.
One resolution could be that Peter would get subpoena power, and in that way he could help the Department of Defense find the documents about the triangles that we know damn well are there.
That'd be interesting.
Cpena power.
We could actually bring Department of Defense people in and put them under oath.
Something they'd have to think real hard about before they answered.
Now that, that might almost be fun.
unidentified
Now that, that might be fun.
art bell
Well, you know, I'm not sure that an attorney is supposed to think of it this way, but hey, Peter, if you got subpoena power and you could actually bring DOD people in to be deposed and put them under oath and ask them questions, would that be fun?
peter gersten
I don't try to do anything that isn't fun.
art bell
I think that would be grand fun.
peter gersten
I think it definitely would be fun.
art bell
And just to, if nothing else, to observe the expressions on their face as they realize they are under oath.
I mean, that, to me, would be fun.
Now, I may be a little perverted, but that sounds like fun.
peter gersten
Well, I heard it's more than a little.
But in any event, I would videotape them.
art bell
Well, would you be allowed to take those videotapes and do anything with them afterwards?
peter gersten
I would assume so.
Why not?
I'm paying for them.
art bell
well in that case uh...
you'd be there that would be some to see uh...
would you just come straight how would you approach Well, I haven't really sat down and thought about this.
peter gersten
I have a list of questions that people have been sending me for the last six months if I had the opportunity.
But basically, it has to do with the policies and procedures on UFOs in general, on these particular objects, on this search, the methods they do with search, the classification of the analysts that do the search.
In particular, you know, hopefully this SD Form 472 where this declassification specialist Betty Goode initially indicated that records were found, I hope this is the document, so-called Smoking Gun, that will sway the judge in favor of allowing me these additional.
art bell
Yeah, people need to understand that.
Originally, in response to the FOIA request, they came back and they actually checked the box saying documents had been found.
Then that was followed up with a second document, the Terono documents had not been found.
peter gersten
Same document.
Basically, it has component search results.
One box says records found and the other box says no records.
So what you have in the records found box is an X that is blacked over and in the no records box is an X. Now of course they would have to check the records found box first.
Would there be no reason to check it after the no records, you know.
So for some reason they checked that, crossed it out, then checked the no records.
Now I don't know why.
It's a regular form, why they didn't just destroy the form and start over again with a clean copy.
But it's funny because this judge was so open to my arguments.
He was very sharp.
He was an independent thinker.
And usually, I can use a comparison.
In a criminal case, when you sum up the summations, the closing arguments, you're supposed to confine yourself to the evidence that was introduced at trial and not go outside of the evidence and make all kinds of inferences.
Well, it's the same thing in the argument before the federal judge.
I was supposed to confine myself to my responses that I had made, my arguments, on paper in response to the summary judgment motion and comment on that, argue those points and not argue points that weren't in those papers.
But in referring, it's funny, I think I'm hanging out with Richard too much.
In referring to this SD Form 472, where it initially had record found, checked, and then crossed out, then no record, I said to the judge, judge, there is some belief that within the Department of Defense there are the good guys for disclosure and the bad guys who are for secrecy.
And maybe, maybe this is some type of message from the good guys that there are records.
art bell
You're right.
You've been hanging out with Richard too long.
That was good, though.
That was good.
peter gersten
So he didn't stop me, and he was receptive.
And I even brought in Roswell.
I said, we're not looking for an object that crashed 52 years ago in a place in New Mexico.
And he smiled a little bit at that.
I said, we're looking for an object that's seen almost every month, and as recently as two weeks ago, and that wasn't in my papers either, as recently as two weeks ago in Illinois.
art bell
Well, you know, Peter, you've got airline pilots, 747 pilots, if you need them.
You've got policemen in the state of Illinois, if you need them.
You have really significant professional witnesses.
I don't see how they can stand up to that.
And it almost sounds like they don't want to stand up to it.
Are they going to let you be the guy who removes his finger from the dike and starts a flood?
Do you think they might let you be that guy?
peter gersten
Well, I would think so.
I would, in choreographing this script before I came into this 3D reality, I would think that that would be part of the script I would do for myself.
In auditioning for the role of the UFO lawyer, I think that was one of the things I had to audition for.
So with my creativity and imagination, sure, I would program that into my cosmic computer program when I came down here and became the UFO lawyer.
Why not?
That's good to me.
And you're part of it.
If it wasn't for you, CORES wouldn't be where it is today, and we wouldn't have those people in the courtroom.
Because it was in January of 1998, after being on your program, that I resurrected Cause and made it an Internet organization with a website that is now, you know, with the same web web wizard Keith Rowland.
It's unbelievable.
And you are a main co-conspirator in this whole thing.
unidentified
God, I hate that language.
art bell
Main co-conspirator.
Yeah, I guess I am.
Well, I hope that it results in something.
Anything.
Now, what is the most likely, or in order of likelihood, what are the most prominent possibilities of resolution here or next step?
peter gersten
As you mentioned, there's plenty of evidence out there that the object exists, reliable, responsible, credible evidence.
art bell
Sure.
peter gersten
But that's not the issue.
The issue is, separate and aside from whether the object exists, is whether a reasonable search, that's the law.
All they have to do is a reasonable search, not an exhaustive search, a reasonable search.
So the question is, and they have to accept, the judge has to accept the affidavits from the DOD at face value.
In other words, unless I can raise an issue of bad faith, then they're presumed to have good faith and the lawsuit's dismissed.
So I'm hoping that this SD Form 472, as well as the other arguments I made about the predisposition of the DOD prior to any appeal on my part, they ignored my initial appeal.
They saw citizens against UFO secrecy, and that was enough to send me a denial without even doing a search.
So hopefully my arguments were persuasive.
And if they were, then the court can do several things.
And it wasn't until I suggested that they not rule, that the judge not rule on the motion until 90 days and allow me to assist the agency in trying to find the documents.
And if I can't get any closer in 90 days, come in and dismiss it.
What's the sense?
They say they can't find it.
I can't tell them where to look, dismiss it.
He started making notes.
He started writing a little bit for the first time.
So I don't know.
I'm very hopeful.
He was very receptive.
art bell
So you gave him, what you really did was give him an out.
peter gersten
Exactly.
Exactly.
Now, you have to also remember that this case has a far-reaching effect beyond UFO disclosure.
art bell
I have one really important question here.
In your opinion, would it be I don't want to say legal, would it be something the government would do in response to an FOI request of the sort that you made, if there is a national security issue at stake here, for them to reply no?
In other words, under the guise of national security, could they politically check the no box and get away with it?
peter gersten
Well, that would be deceitful.
And I only can go by past experience.
In the lawsuit against the Central Intelligence Agency, they found documents, stated they found documents, and withheld them on national security grounds, which was upheld by the district court and the U.S. Court of Appeals.
The National Security Agency searched their files, found documents, stated they found documents, and stated we're not giving them to you on national security.
That was upheld by the district court, the U.S. Court of Appeals, and the U.S. Supreme Court.
So there's precedent for the Department of Defense saying, we have documents, you're not getting them, national security.
And I'm sure Judge McNamee would upheld that decision.
art bell
That would just start a firestorm by itself, though.
peter gersten
Well, you would get a lot of publicity.
Yeah, you sure would.
You would get an acknowledgment that the object exists, at least.
But, you know, basically, the agency has done it in the past, and they're still, you know, the CIA is still withholding the 57 documents after, what, 20-something years?
art bell
Yeah, I noticed also the President just the other day, without referring to Area 51 by name, said the military facility or secret facility near Groom Lake, and he signed another document holding that as secret.
peter gersten
Yeah, of course.
They would withhold the documents, national security.
It might get some attention in the beginning, and then it would blow over like it always does.
art bell
Sure.
So, okay.
So how do you most effectively use the time you've got?
peter gersten
Which time is that until the judge decides or once he decides?
art bell
Well, if he gives you the time.
If he doesn't decide, in other words, he decides not to decide right away.
peter gersten
My time won't start until he decides.
art bell
Yeah, but then what?
peter gersten
If he's going to give me.
Well, then I'm going to sit down and I'm going to speak to some of my associates and I'm going to put out some queries on my website and we're going to go forward.
We're going to, you know, like we would in any kind of case, we would plan strategy.
We would decide who we're going to subpoena, when we're going to subpoena them.
I would speak to the U.S. Attorney and try to do it.
art bell
What kind of positions would you subpoena?
peter gersten
I'm sorry?
art bell
What kind of positions would you subpoena?
I say that as opposed to asking you for names.
peter gersten
Well, it depends.
The judge might set certain limitations on my subpoena power.
In other words, he might say, well, start out with the person that submitted the affidavits.
Right.
Start out with Betty Good.
You can start out with interrogatories.
You can submit 100 questions to the DOD.
Okay, we can do that.
You can subpoena your civilian researchers or submit a list of people you want to subpoena, and the U.S. Attorney or the DOD can select like 10.
But me, I would start at the top, Secretary of Defense, if I had a choice.
art bell
They probably won't let you.
peter gersten
No, they won't let me.
But basically, in any civil suit, if you subpoena an officer of the corporation or the corporation, they can supply any person who has knowledge and information about the subject matter that's the basis of the lawsuit.
So somebody who would be in a position to provide information, assuming they had the information.
art bell
All right.
As usual at this juncture, I would ask, what would you like the large audience out there to do to help?
peter gersten
Well, first of all, they can support COUSE by going to the website and signing up for the free CARES updates, the mailing list.
art bell
Yeah, it comes to your email, folks, free.
I mean, just absolutely free.
All you've got to do is sign up and you get this daily report of what's going on in the world of ufology, free of charge.
You can't beat that price.
peter gersten
And that website is www.caus.org.
And if you don't have a pencil with you, then just go to ArtSite because there's a link there.
art bell
Okay.
And so they sign up for it.
It comes to their email.
You'll also have a newsletter?
peter gersten
Yeah, there's a newsletter that Well, if they have access to the website, they wouldn't want to sign up.
But if they don't have Internet access or email access, they can write to CARS and sign up for the monthly newsletter, which is the highlights of the daily CARS updates.
Now, that address is CARS, C-A-U-S, 8624, San Bruno, S-A-N, B-R-U-N-O, two words, Drive, Scottsdale, Arizona, 85258.
And we have to charge because there's printing and posting.
art bell
Obviously.
peter gersten
And that charge is $20 for 12 issues.
art bell
All right.
That's not at all expensive.
No problem there.
peter gersten
No problem.
art bell
Once a decision is made by the judge to give you the time, then will there be anything the audience can do?
Or is it still you and your colleagues?
Or is there any way we can all help out?
unidentified
No, that's very optimistic.
peter gersten
Because it's possible the judge can eventually grant the government's motion and dismiss it by saying I did not raise enough issues of bad faith.
But I agree with you.
I think he's going to give me the time.
And once he does, then I will come back on your show and say we have to raise some kind of legal fund for these depositions, for the transcripts, for the videotaping, for the court reporters, for the travel expenses.
Because as far as I'm concerned, that's what I want to devote my next 90 days to, doing this and doing as many people as possible.
art bell
Well, if you can get the time and if the judge rules your way, I'm confident that we can raise enough money to get the depositions done.
I'm really confident.
peter gersten
Well, then let's ask your audience to focus in on Judge McIntomy and send him positive energy to rule in favor of cause.
art bell
All right.
Let's do that.
Again, toward proving, you have to prove in some way that they acted in bad faith, that they didn't conduct enough of a search.
Do you think that, for example, you mentioned opposing the young lady that answered your form.
That would be pretty interesting to do, wouldn't it?
Because you're obviously going to early on ask her, excuse me, why did you put the check mark over here?
peter gersten
Exactly.
It'll be like cross-examining a police officer in a criminal case again.
They always make mistakes.
And I said that basically this form is more than just an inference of indifference.
It's possibly the smoking gun.
It's possibly bad faith.
And as I indicated before, as Richard would say, it might be even a message that, you know, subpoena me and I'll tell you where the documents are.
Oh, yeah, I would love to talk to her.
art bell
I've run into that before.
A lot of people are hesitant because they don't want to lose their jobs, of course.
And so they want to be forced to tell what they know.
And they feel once they're forced that the burden is lifted from them and they can talk.
peter gersten
Exactly.
art bell
Yeah, I guess I've learned too much about law over the last couple of years, Peter.
peter gersten
Unfortunately.
art bell
Unfortunately.
All right, my friend.
Carry forth.
A warrior of justice is the way I think of you.
And one way or the other, it looks like we're going to find out something.
At least we're going to rattle their cages.
Peter, thank you.
peter gersten
Well, thank you, King Arthur.
art bell
And later.
That causes Peter Gersten.
And yeah, you can go to his website and sign up for the free update.
And it's one of those things that's really worth getting in your mailbox.
Find out what's going on out there.
And you can't beat the price.
It's dead free.
If you don't have the internet, why there is a newsletter, and that's relatively cheap.
I'm Art Bell.
And coming up next, I've got a whole variety of things for you.
So don't touch that dial.
unidentified
You're listening to Art Bell somewhere in time on Premier Radio Networks.
Tonight, an encore presentation of Coast to Coast AM from February 8th, 2000.
We've been trapped in far without a far free.
Only one will be free With heart unclosed Hang on to a dream.
On the boat and on the plane.
Yeah.
Imagine there's no chance.
It's easy, easy to try No hell below us Above us only sky
Imagine all the people living for the day I imagine there's no country It's hard to do Nothing to kill or die.
And no religion too Imagine all the people Living life in peace you Premier Radio Networks presents Art Bell Somewhere in Time.
Tonight's program originally aired February 8th, 2000.
art bell
Last hour, we spoke with Peter Gerston, who had a Hanuma victory in an Arizona court, trying to encourage the Department of Defense to Go back and look again.
Do a more thorough search and find whatever they've got on this triangular object.
So it's a victory, in my opinion, for the good side.
And you can kind of sit back in a lot of ways and wait and see what's going to happen.
You can join the cause at CAUS website.
It's link through mine.
And when you do, you'll get a daily free report about what's going on.
And you can bet this is going to be highlighted in that.
So thanks to everybody, standing room only in the courtroom, as Peter stopped them in their tracks.
Now, I've got a number of things that I really would like to cover.
My sympathies to the family of Derek Thomas.
As you know, he just died after an automobile accident.
There have been a lot of very untimely deaths lately.
Derek Thomas was one of those, of course.
And also, I note that Bob Collins, who did the morning show and has done so for about a decade now in WGN in Chicago, who is a private pilot, today collided, had his private plane collide with another private plane.
You may have seen all of this on CNN.
Well, piloting one of those planes was Bob Collins, 57 years of age, who had been doing the morning show and very well known in Chicago and to all of you in Chicago for a full decade now, is dead, much too early, at 57 years of age.
So a colleague in the industry and my sympathy, of course, to his family as well.
So there seems to be a lot of that going around.
In a moment, you're going to be hearing from Joel Rothschild.
Joel is perhaps the longest surviving AIDS patient, AIDS survivor, in the world.
He's written a new book called Signals.
So he's here not just to talk about AIDS, but about signals.
Now, what do we mean by signals?
Well, signals from the other side.
Because before his friend died, they made a pact.
They made a pact together that whichever one went first would attempt to send signals from the other side.
And in talking to Joel just before this hour began, he said, what are you looking for?
And I said, just the truth.
So that's, I hope what we're going to get.
I trust what we're going to get.
And it's yet another attempt to find out if there really is more to this world than the material world that Mr. Lennon was calling for us to ignore in the bumper music coming in to this hour.
Should be a very, very, very interesting interview.
There is so much going on out there right now that I want to comment on that I've got to get a word in on that I hope Joel will be patient with me.
Number one, I do not send you to the web for idle stuff, but we've got a photograph up on the web right now, which I would like your interpretation of, please.
It's obviously a legitimate photograph.
The picture taken by, well, I don't know who took it, is of Mike.
And it was taken on his prom night.
You know, everybody takes a picture on their prom night, right?
But Mike's picture, when you look at it, you're going to go, oh my God.
Located in the chest and stomach area, you're going to see what I would describe as a demon.
This is not a double exposure.
Whatever it is, it's really there, and it's really visible, and when you see it, it's going to remind you.
You know what it reminded me of?
You remember the monster?
Well, let's see, which movie would most closely resemble what I think is on his chest?
I'm going to give that a little thought.
unidentified
You know what?
art bell
I'm not going to tell you because I would like you to form your own opinions.
It is easy to see, perhaps not at first.
Turn the light up on your monitor if you don't see it.
But it's on his chest, and that's a ghost, or in my estimation, some kind of demon.
It is a shockingly good photograph.
And so I would not idly send you up there.
I'm telling you, we got a whopper up there right now.
So go take a look.
It's in the new items section.
Let me see.
It's newest site editions.
You'll see the story on the tragic death of radio personality in Chicago first.
And then new ghost photo with description of haunted house.
But boy, when you see what's on that man's chest.
So, www.artbell.com, that's my address, www.artbell.com.
The reason I think ghost photographs and demon photographs are so important, well, that should be obvious.
If we are on a quest to try and prove something, then when you occasionally get your hand On really good forensic material of this kind, it's irresistible.
And so go take a look, and you tell me what's on that man's chest.
unidentified
You tell me.
art bell
Latest news on the Alaska Airlines tragedy is that radar signals may show a piece of that plane may have broken off before the final one-minute descent to the ocean floor and death for everybody aboard.
There have been too many coincidences lately involving the MD-80 series.
On Saturday, an Alaska Airlines MD-83 returned to the airport in Reno, Nevada, minutes after taking off for Seattle.
NTSB is investigating now, said, though it probably was caused by an overheated stabilizer motor.
On Thursday, an Alaska MD-80 taxiing toward the runway in Seattle experienced intermittent problems with the stabilizer motor.
An American Airlines MD-83 flight out of Phoenix returned to the gate last week after a stabilizer problem, and they think that it may be a faulty control switch in the cockpit on that one.
But this is getting pretty weird, I would say.
Now, the only explanation that you could offer for this seemingly impossible chain of coincidence regarding the MD series of aircraft would be that after an accident of this sort, pilots are particularly sensitive to MD-80 stabilizer hiccups at all, and so we're hearing more about it, maybe.
Or there really is something going on.
And if that's the case, you begin to look for any common thread, obviously, between any of these things and where that would take you.
Then they said an asteroid would hit Earth, possibly, in the year 2022.
And then they said, no, it won't.
Now, whatever happened to the, we're going to wait three days before we announce this and do the math.
Didn't we just go through this a little while ago?
Asteroid's going to hit?
Then it's not going to hit.
So anyway, the latest math says it will not hit.
Personally, I wouldn't put a lot of faith in math structured on what we know about something that might or might not happen 20 some odd years from now because just a slight encounter with something out there that would change even the earth's encounter with the earth might change it just enough you never really know there's cyberterrorism going on out there eBay was shut
down by.com was shut down hackers people with denial of service and they're just essentially doing what I do when I send you all up to my website to see a ghost photograph so many people hit it with requests at one time that the server can't take it and it goes and dies now that occasionally occurs when I send you all up like this
incredible ghost or demon photograph is more like it.
Some of you may be denied service for a little while trying to get in to see it because so many people are trying to see it at once.
unidentified
So hang in there.
art bell
You obviously will get through after a while.
But this looks like an orchestrated effort to deny service to cause trouble for e-commerce companies, and the FBI is going to catch these people.
And when they do, they won't like it.
the people
people all right now Mr. Rothschild coming up he wrote the following this story proves there is more to heaven and earth than has been dreamt in the minds of men an illuminating and inspiring read signals the book is wonderful proof that we are never apart from those we love as a quote from Deepak Chopra the AIDS
pandemic was over 12 years old in 1994.
AIDS, the leading killer of men between the ages of 25 and 40, and hundreds of thousands of people had already died from this disease.
Nowhere was the devastation more horrid than amongst urban gay communities.
Tragically, it enveloped the lives of two best friends in Los Angeles, having AIDS.
They feared, obviously, their deaths to be imminent, so they made a pact.
They promised if there was a possibility to contact the other after death, they vowed to try.
Skeptic Joel Rothschild was the one who got left behind.
Signals, his book, chronicles a series of miraculous experiences and coincidences that offer proof of an afterlife.
His cynicism fading, his health improved, and he is now one of our nation's longest living AIDS survivors.
His forthcoming book is an engaging true story of love, hope, and healing.
It will take you on an adventure that we are going to take you on tonight.
Here is the author of that book, Joel Rothschild.
Joel, welcome to the program.
joel rothschild
Joel Rothschild: All right, thanks for having me on.
art bell
Oh, I'm glad to have you on.
joel rothschild
Joel Rothschild: You know, the best place to start is in the beginning.
another pact that albert and i have have to do with the first bit of proof of life after life wasn't just this one pack and i have to tell you that i was a card carrying member of the national atheist association for ten years old really madeline got my money so i was at this skeptical as anybody could be and i went along with the pact to have that that's not even skeptical if you're a uh...
art bell
if you know how to sell her yet what well okay if you're an atheist actually you almost Doesn't it go beyond just simple skepticism?
Absolutely.
joel rothschild
Now, I'm going to tell you we had another pact that got violated, and that has to do with the first signal from beyond.
At this time, in the early 90s, there was no hope for people with AIDS.
unidentified
That's right.
joel rothschild
There was a closed window.
There was none of the new drugs.
There was no hope.
art bell
It was a death sentence.
joel rothschild
Absolutely.
And at that time, I had already lived through pneumocystis pneumonia several times.
I expected to be dead.
And actually, my doctors told me that I would be dead in about a year and a half.
art bell
In what year did you contract AIDS or find out that AIDS were positive?
joel rothschild
Full-blown in 1986.
art bell
Now, let's back up.
When did you find out HIV positive?
joel rothschild
Well, I found out as I was full-blown.
art bell
Oh.
joel rothschild
I found out with pneumocystis.
But let me skip ahead if I can.
art bell
Sure.
joel rothschild
Albert and I and a couple other friends decided another thing that we would do.
We went down to Mexico and we got the suicide drugs because we all felt, my little group of friends, that there were certain things that could happen physically that we wouldn't want to live with.
And my particular thing was, I thought if I lost my eyesight, I wouldn't want to live.
Well, Albert, my best friend, best friend since high school, whom I had the pact with about signaling from beyond, was the one in the group that was in perfect health.
June 1st, oh, I'm going to skip the point.
The pact with the suicide was, with Albert and myself, if either one of us decided to take our own life, we would support the other.
We would be there with that person.
We would help them to die.
And this may sound very morbid, but that's what life was like.
art bell
No, it doesn't.
It sounds realistic.
joel rothschild
That's what life was like at that time.
June 1st, 1994, 11 o'clock in the afternoon, I go over Albert's house and I find his dead body.
He took the drugs without calling me.
unidentified
Oh, God.
joel rothschild
Okay?
Finds his corpse.
And that was the ultimate betrayal.
this is a best friend, lifetime friend, never lied to me about anything.
At that moment, the pact about life from beyond meant absolutely, Nothing.
art bell
Why do you think?
And I'm sure you've thought about this a million times, that with health, when he had not yet begun to deteriorate.
joel rothschild
Why did he do it?
art bell
Yeah, sure.
joel rothschild
Well, there were a lot of issues, you know, and there were a lot going on with his life.
All of our friends were dying.
He really couldn't bear to see me get sick, and that was a big part of it.
But here's the first signal.
This is the first time I had held a dead body.
On one hand, I was crying.
I was devastated.
On the other hand, I was angry that he had taken his own life.
So angry, I was shaking his body.
The coroner arrived.
The police arrived.
I'm screaming.
I'm hysterical.
And I'm not rational.
And in the midst of all, and there's no notes, no explanation.
And I needed an explanation.
I needed to know why.
Not only why, I needed to know that he loved me when he was alive.
If he wrote my name across the sky in a rainbow, at that point it didn't matter because he had violated this commitment that we had and not said goodbye to me.
It was horrible.
Anyway, the very first signal, I hear his voice.
I'm holding a dead body and I hear his voice.
And he says to me, get yourselves together, hop the wall to the house next door, go in the trash, and you'll find a note.
art bell
What?
joel rothschild
Yeah, that's what happened, the very first signal.
And I don't know.
I didn't have time to think about it.
art bell
All right, hold it right there.
We're already at the bottom of the air because I consumed so much time with what I wanted to get to you.
I'm sure you can see why we're going where we're going.
We're talking about what exists if there is something after this life.
Now, I was about to suggest to Joel that his mind in that condition might well hear voices.
But not voices that would instruct in that manner, that's for sure.
I'm Art Bell, and this is Coast to Coast AM.
Stay right there.
unidentified
You're listening to Art Bell somewhere in time.
Tonight featuring a replay of Coast to Coast AM from February 8, 2000.
You're in me Cause you gave me the love Love that I never had Yes, you gave me the love Love that I never had You and I
Don't be love.
I can't feel anymore that I'm singing.
Yeah.
My big top never fucking stops.
But the hint that she leaves.
These days she says I feel my life just like a wave running through the air of the cat.
I feel my life just like a wave running through the air of the cat.
I feel my life just like a wave running through the air of the cat.
Listening to Workbell Summer in Time.
Tonight featuring a replay of Coast to Coast AM from February 8th, 2000.
art bell
Wondering what's on the other side?
This morning's show might be productive.
My guest is Joel Rothschild.
unidentified
He, uh, has a still alive.
art bell
Somehow, he made a pact with his friend, who took his life early.
Committed suicide.
And we'll pick up exactly where we left off in a moment, which was at the discovery of his friends.
The End Okay, like Peter Gerston, with respect to a search for this thing we know is in our skies, flying in our skies, we know it's there.
unidentified
We're looking for the truth.
art bell
And toward that end, there are several areas that I look toward when I'm trying to figure out this great question for humanity.
And it's the biggest question I think any of us have and will ever have in our lifetime, as well as our greatest mortal fear, that is of death and whether there is anything that follows it or whether it's just lights out.
The worms crawl in and the worms crawl out and all the rest of that.
I cannot think of any greater question.
Can you?
I don't think so because there's so much at stake.
Well, I look at a lot of things.
I look at forensic evidence and one piece of really good evidence is up on the website tonight.
It's a photograph of Mike.
And I'm telling you right now, what's on his chest can only by me be described as a demon.
A demon.
You look and decide for yourself.
I don't frequently, you know, I get a lot of, I can't tell you how many supposed ghost photographs I get.
And I only very occasionally call attention, probably one out of a hundred.
This one you better see.
It's on my website now at www.artbell.com and I would appreciate one way or the other your comments on it.
It's not a fake.
You know, whatever's there is there.
I guess it could be some sort of trick of light and shadow.
I sound like NASA, don't I?
But I don't think so.
And then, of course, there's my guest tonight.
By the way, the foreword to his book called Signals was written by guess who?
Neil Donald Walsh of Conversations with God, who did a guest whole slot here a few nights ago.
He wrote the foreword to the book.
We'll talk a little bit more about that.
But Joel and his friend had gone to Mexico to get the appropriate medicine to make final exit.
You know, they had AIDS, and it was at that time an absolute death sentence.
And for some reason, Albert, though he was still healthy, decided he was going to go and go right then.
And unfortunately, Joel was the one to find his body.
He was shaking his body.
And a voice said to jump the fence, go next door, get into the trash can, and you'll find a note.
And that's where we left off, I think.
Welcome back, Joel.
joel rothschild
Thanks, Art.
And that is where we left off.
I did it with the police there.
LAPD was there and saying to me, don't go.
You can't trespass.
I jumped.
I was frenetic, crazed.
I jumped in there underneath cat litter and debris.
I found his last written note.
That was the beginning, Art.
That was the beginning of two years of miraculous and events that are documentatable.
And I think prove, as Neil says, prove that there is life afterlife.
That was the very beginning.
That was the very first thing that happened.
And I questioned that.
I thought, well, could I have put that into my own mind to go into the trash next door?
art bell
Could I mean I say no.
joel rothschild
And let me tell you, that's not the only type of event that happened.
art bell
No, no, we'll get to the others.
But my answer to your question is no.
A lot of things I can imagine could have happened, but to direct you next door to a trash can to get a note for a suicide for a body you were holding, no, not coincidence, definitely not.
Might I ask why he decided to go early?
Did he explain that in the note?
joel rothschild
Well, he did.
He had lost a job.
He had lost another friend of ours who just passed away.
And he was tremendously fearful of losing me.
And I was very sick at the time.
art bell
Gotcha.
joel rothschild
And he was depressed.
Depressed with AIDS.
But that note got me home.
That night I experienced him coming to me again.
art bell
Back up again.
What did the police say?
I mean, you come back over.
joel rothschild
You know what the police said to me?
art bell
What?
joel rothschild
The police said it's very common for people who are committing suicide to leave notes in trash.
That's what the policemen said.
art bell
That's what they said to you.
joel rothschild
That's one of the policemen said, very common to leave notes in trash.
But I didn't even say that I did.
At that moment, I didn't say, well, I just heard his voice go in the trash.
They just thought I was crazy.
I said, I got to go over there.
And I just hopped the wall.
The police thought I was crazy.
My friends that were there thought I was insane.
what is he doing?
And I came back with the note, and I had this sense of peace.
art bell
You know, if I was a cop, I might regard you with some suspicion.
I mean, that's so beyond all reasonable coincidence that I might look at you a little warily for having that kind of knowledge.
joel rothschild
Well, glad that didn't happen.
art bell
It didn't happen, huh?
joel rothschild
Yeah, glad that nothing like that happened.
And that was, you know, that was the beginning.
That was the very, very first thing that happened.
And, you know, and I'd like to tell you about a couple others.
Please.
And, you know, and some of the other ones you might consider a coincidence.
Some might be stronger.
And I'm not, you know, there's so many that I don't know where to begin.
But I'm going to tell you a small one, and you tell me whether or not you think it's a coincidence or you think it's proof of life after life.
One of the things that I've always done is I collect quotes, and I collect quotes for friends.
And my quote for Albert was a Benjamin Franklin quote, best friends are one soul in two bodies.
He had copied me at everything in life.
I got a Harley, he got a Harley.
I got a tattoo, he got a tattoo.
So he found a quote for me.
It was an ancient Chinese proverb, meeting is the beginning of parting.
Very sad quote.
Hated the quote.
art bell
Well, it's kind of like living is the beginning of dying.
joel rothschild
Right.
Okay, year after he dies, I'm in a thrift store going through a bunch of old books.
I find a book called The Wealth of Friendship from 1878.
Compilation of quotes.
Buy it for a buck, take it home, reading it, get to the middle of the book, there's a bookmark acid-etched and stuck on the page.
One quote in the entire book was underlined.
Meeting is the beginning of parting.
Is it a coincidence?
You tell me.
art bell
To me, it would not be.
joel rothschild
No.
art bell
To me, it would not be.
joel rothschild
I had so many events like that.
art bell
Impossible.
joel rothschild
Well, and thank God that some of the events were witnessed.
And I'll tell you a type of event that got witnessed, because otherwise I would have thought I was cracking up.
It was so overwhelming.
He had a thing about hummingbirds.
And I'll skip the whole story about why he had a thing about hummingbirds.
Twice since then, I was consoling sick friends.
One was on the 10th floor of a high-rise building in Los Angeles.
My friend Rita Wayner, her husband wrote all the music for Lee Wayner for Billie Holiday and Bessie Smith.
A hummingbird flies in the window and lands on me.
That's happened twice.
Happened in my home here in Los Angeles.
I was consoling another friend, Ed Auger, who his partner had just died.
Hummingbird flew in the room and landed on me.
Does that happen?
Is that a coincidence?
I don't think so.
art bell
No, that doesn't happen.
joel rothschild
And one time at night, I'm not sure.
art bell
Once in my life, I saw at an airport outside, it was really interesting, a hummingbird came right up to somebody's nose, literally just sat there in front of his nose, and it totally freaked him out.
That's the only time I've seen a hummingbird approach a human, and that was outside.
joel rothschild
Okay, let me tell you one other thing.
You know Neil Donald Walsh, and he's a good man.
art bell
Yes.
joel rothschild
Okay.
I've never met Neil Donald Walsh.
He got a hold of my manuscript through his secretary, read the book, fell in love with it.
But I've got to tell you, here's a signal that happened with Neil Donald Walsh.
Neil took my manuscript.
His secretary fell in love with it.
She put it in his luggage.
He was doing a European tour.
He carried it all over Europe.
And he writes in the foreword to my book that he got to the Piazzo Michelangelo.
He's looking at the River Arnault, and he felt this huge urge, compelled to read my manuscript.
And he reads it, and he calls it the treasure of treasures for which every thinking person has ever searched.
It meant a lot to me because it meant that people would read my book and read my story.
What's the coincidence?
One month before Albert took his own life, we were in a thrift store downtown L.A. We bought an engraving, and he actually picked it up.
He said, you've got to buy this.
You've got to take it home with you.
I didn't even like it.
What was it an engraving of?
The Plaza Michelangelo, the view looking at the River Arnaud.
art bell
Oh, boy.
joel rothschild
Is that a coincidence?
I don't think so.
art bell
No, I don't think so either.
joel rothschild
These things happened for two years.
art bell
Two years.
joel rothschild
And some very, very powerful, some much more powerful and much longer stories than we have time for on the radio.
art bell
Oh, we have time for a lot on the radio.
joel rothschild
Well, I'll tell you.
not stuck for time all right well talk about to talk to you really that And I feel like a little like Jodi Foster in the movie Contact.
I don't know if you saw the movie, but she comes back and she has.
art bell
Only about ten times.
unidentified
Okay.
joel rothschild
And what does she have as proof?
Only her own story.
So this is the worst for me to, this is the hardest story for me to tell you because it's the most powerful signal and the most powerful contact, and I don't have a witness.
It's just myself.
art bell
Sure.
joel rothschild
The night he died, I got home, and it's about 2 o'clock in the morning.
It's a hot California night.
I hadn't the air conditioning on.
The blinds were drawn.
I had blackout shades.
My room was pitch black.
And I know this is going to sound like a typical life after life story, but there was a light.
There was a veiled, dim light above my bed.
And he says to me, you know it's me, don't you?
And I was frozen.
Absolutely frozen.
And in that moment, I was ready to take my life because I had lost my best friend.
I had lost all faith, all hope.
unidentified
And he says to me, I couldn't even move.
joel rothschild
I couldn't even acknowledge.
art bell
At the point that this happened, one of the possibilities that you would have to consider is that this was coming from your own mind.
joel rothschild
Grief, mind.
art bell
You know, a grieving mind, sure.
joel rothschild
Absolutely.
Absolutely.
And this event, which was the most Powerful event, I seriously have considered that over and over and over again, except for one thing.
What had happened wasn't something, and what he said to me wasn't something that I ever intended to write a book or to share.
And the message in what he told me that night carried me through the rest of my life, carried me through chemotherapy, carried me through AIDS.
The message that he said to me was that every moment of life, every breath you take, good or bad, happy or sad, in pain or not, all have meaning and all have a purpose that you're not going to understand from where you're at now.
So live your life, Joel, as much as you can, go as far as you can and endure as much as you can because you are working things out that are connected to a greater good that you won't understand from where you're at now.
art bell
Well, with that perspective, he would have realized that he made an error, or is that not right?
joel rothschild
Well, that's not right because one of the things he says to me at that time was that it was his path and his destiny to take his life at that time.
So he didn't acknowledge that he made an error.
art bell
That's important because a lot of us don't understand the nature of life after life with regard to suicide and other things like it.
joel rothschild
Well, we have different opinions on that.
I mean, plenty of people have told me that, you know, they go straight to hell, and I've heard all different opinions on that.
I personally believe that they don't.
And, you know, this was my experiences.
art bell
Well, I personally believe that we don't have a vengeful God, you know, a really angry God, and that if you take your own life, he punishes you for that by sending you to hell or even something in between.
Particularly in the case of somebody who has a fatal disease.
To me, God is not like that.
But that's just an opinion.
joel rothschild
Well, that contact that night gave me the hope and the courage to go on living and to live through some opportunistic infections that were 80%, 90% fatal at the time.
So, you know, that was a very powerful experience that evening, and it's not one that's documentatable.
It's not one that happened with someone else there, and it's not one that was well-witnessed, and it would be very easy to chalk it up to grieving.
But I can tell you, it wasn't.
art bell
Well, and take it with all the rest of it, too.
How are you still alive today?
joel rothschild
Great question.
Very, very good question.
I'll tell you, I don't believe, Art, that any disease in the history of mankind has ever been 100% fatal.
And there have been people that have come out of the Eboli comas and lived.
And I think that part of surviving and part of my surviving is achieving a state of forgiveness, being able to let go of things, reduce stress, strong inner will to live.
I believe that this book is my purpose.
I think I'm here to serve people with this book.
And I think a lot of it is miraculous.
art bell
Well, at some point, yeah, but that changed.
In other words, at the point when you went down to Mexico and got the stuff for suicide, I was ready to go.
You obviously had a different mental state.
joel rothschild
Right.
It changed with these experiences.
I mean, if you lived, you have to understand, if you lived through your best friend or your partner dying and coming to you, you know, telling you that there's a note in the trash and you find the note, no matter how skeptical you are, that happens to you, you're going to live a different life after that because you're going to have knowledge that there really is something after this and that there's meaning and there's purpose in all of these moments of life.
It's a tremendous experience for me and I can only go so low no matter what happens to me in life.
art bell
Well having come from the background you've come from, you know, being an atheist, where have you come from?
In other words, you no longer are exactly an atheist.
Do you believe in the traditional God of the Bible now as written?
Have you made a conversion?
Are you simply somewhere in between now or what?
joel rothschild
I have a different sense of God.
In my description of God, I can tell you in a very simple, quick analogy.
I saw a very famous rabbi and a cardinal one time debating the nature of God.
And at the end of the wrap-up, the rabbi says to the cardinal, look, let's just cut through to the chase.
For 2,000 years, Christians have believed that mankind is intrinsically bad.
We inherit original sin.
And we have to go to Jesus.
We have to go to God for forgiveness, God being an outside source.
For 4,000 years, Jews have believed that mankind is intrinsically good.
When we mess up, we go to God for forgiveness.
My personal philosophy after living through these experiences is that God's not an outside source, that we are all a grain of sand.
Collectively, we make up a beach.
The beach is God, and it's the responsibility of each of us to shine our own grain of sand so the beach is as beautiful as it can be.
I don't know if that makes sense, but that's the way that I feel about it.
art bell
Does that philosophy include, you know, a grain of sand and a greater consciousness all sounds like a collective thing, but the messages you got were individual and specific and not from a collective?
Do you think there's a period of time when the individual is not yet part of the collective, when individual action of the kind that began when Albert died can occur?
joel rothschild
Wait, are you asking me if the individual is part of the collective after death?
art bell
Well, in other words, not immediately part of the collective.
joel rothschild
I tend to believe that we're all connected, even in this life, even though we're in separate containers and separate vessels.
I think we all, in some way that maybe we can't fathom, we are all collective.
We all influence this thing we are.
art bell
All right, I'll try and sharpen that question when we Get back.
Stay right there.
I'm Mark Bell.
unidentified
You're listening to Mark Bell somewhere in time on Premier Radio Networks.
Tonight, an encore presentation of Coast to Coast AM from February 8, 2000.
My sweet Lord, my Lord, my Lord, I really want to see you.
I really want to be with you, I really want to see you, Lord.
It takes so long, my Lord, my sweet Lord, my Lord, my Lord.
I really want to know you, I really want to go with you.
I really want to show you love, but I won't take off.
I really want to know you, Lord.
Lord.
Even tonight, my body's weak.
I'm on the run, no time to sleep.
I've got to ride, ride like the wind to be free again.
And I've got such a long way to go.
So forward to bring it to the wall, Mexico.
To my ride, like the wind.
I'm a bomb, I'm a longest man.
I'm a bummer man with a gun in my hand.
You're listening to Arkbell Somewhere in Time on Premier Radio Networks.
Tonight, an encore presentation of Coast to Coast AM from February 8th, 2000.
art bell
Well, this is interesting.
I guess not totally unexpected.
Here's a fax that just came in in the last hour.
It simply says, please get the fag off the air.
He can have his time on the radio in hell.
And with all due respect, screw you.
We're going to do exactly what we want to do here.
And this gentleman is here with a poignant and important story.
If you don't care about your afterlife, that's your business.
and if you carry a prejudice this time in my opinion you'd better be worried about your afterlife All right, I'm trying to pursue a path to the truth, which is what I told Joel before the broadcast.
He said, what are you looking for?
He said, the truth.
Looking for the truth.
And there are various ways of looking for the truth.
One is with the kind of forensic evidence that I've got up on the website tonight.
You might take a look.
There is an image on this man's front of his jacket that you've got to see.
It's one of those classic photographs.
I would suggest you take a look at my website at www.aracl.com.
The other is life after life is probably the biggest question that man faces because without something after this life, then what are the motions that we are going through?
What do they mean?
And toward the end of the hour, I was asking about the collective versus the individual.
Joel, you're back on the air again.
Here's what I mean.
It seems as though ghosts, if you want to call them that, for lack of a better name, or spirits departed, are able to be in rather direct contact many times in the way contact was apparently made with you, but then at some point pass into another realm or the contact ceases for whatever reason.
That's why I said, I wonder if there is a period of time where that kind of contact is possible, probable, whatever, and then something changes in the afterlife.
joel rothschild
I'm not sure.
And I tell you, I have to tell you a little story that's the flip side to that fact that came through.
Sure.
The flip side in all of this.
And that's a really good question.
I do have a philosophy on your question and what happens afterwards.
And I'm sort of putting those pieces together in my mind.
But more important is the fact that is there something there?
And the flip side to the negative stuff is that I get a lot of people coming forward to me and telling me their own stories.
I'm at a book signing recently.
A guy comes up to me.
His wife had been killed by a drunk driver five years ago.
He's got a six and a half year old little girl.
And his father's alive.
No one else was alive in his family except for his father.
His mother had died.
And her parents were dead.
Anyway, the father has lung cancer and is in the hospital, expected to live for another year and a half.
Goes to the hospital.
This is about a month before my book signing.
And the father dies.
And he's dreading going home to his six-year-old daughter.
And how is he going to tell the daughter, who's at six years old, had this much loss, and now grandpa is gone, right?
Dreading seeing her face.
Walks into the house.
She runs up to him with a huge smile, grabs him and says, Daddy, grandpa came to me.
Grandpa came to visit me today.
He told me he's not going to be around for a real long time.
I'm not going to see him for a long time.
He's going to be with grandma.
The guy tells me that story.
very, very close to the things that have happened to me.
You know, this guy was also very skeptical, but, you know, the six-year-old girl had no way of knowing that the grandfather had died.
art bell
Of course not.
You know, you heard about the Alaska Airlines Flight 261 going down, right?
joel rothschild
You heard about the ring on that?
art bell
Yeah.
joel rothschild
Yeah, I believe that.
art bell
That's what I was about to say.
joel rothschild
Absolutely.
art bell
It seems so unlikely.
This woman lost, I think it was her husband.
joel rothschild
It was her father.
art bell
Her father, I'm sorry, her father.
joel rothschild
Yeah, and they had made the pact that whoever died first would try to signal the other one that it's okay on the other side.
art bell
Yeah, this is L.A. Times article, and sure enough, you know what happened?
They brought up a Mason's ring.
joel rothschild
Right.
It was the father's ring.
art bell
Yeah.
Now, that's so incredibly unlikely.
joel rothschild
Right.
art bell
They had made it, just like we're talking about right now.
This is in today's news.
joel rothschild
Exactly.
art bell
And there's a signal.
Now, how likely is it that of all the things they bring up, it would be a Mason's ring, which would not float, obviously.
joel rothschild
Right.
No, and these are the things that happened to me.
And that's the nice thing about my book signals is that, forget about all the hatred and the crap like that facts.
I'm getting people coming forward and telling me that they were embarrassed to tell these stories.
This guy at the book sign said he never told anyone the story.
And it's amazing how many people.
I'm getting 20, 30 emails a day, people telling me similar things that have happened to them.
art bell
Are you willing to accept email?
I guess I better ask you that.
joel rothschild
Oh, yeah.
art bell
What is your email address?
joel rothschild
It's AbookForall at AOL.
art bell
A book for all?
joel rothschild
Number four, a book for all.
art bell
Oh, the number four, okay.
joel rothschild
Yeah, at AOL.
Or JoelRothschild.com.
I have a website.
art bell
Okay, a book, the number four, all at AOL.com.
Right.
joel rothschild
There's also another one, One Good Book at AOL also.
Got a couple of items.
art bell
One good book?
joel rothschild
Yeah.
20.
One good book.
art bell
Oh, okay.
Actually, you spell it out there.
joel rothschild
Yeah, it's easier.
All right.
art bell
All right.
You said you had begun to form some opinions yourself on the nature of the chronology of how it might happen.
joel rothschild
Well, now we're going down a road with less documentation and less evidence.
And I will tell you that when Albert came to me, it did not feel like he was alone.
Now, I have to tell you that I had other friends die that year.
My three other best friends all died that year.
I had no signals from them, no contact, nothing.
art bell
But you also had not made a pact with them.
joel rothschild
No, that's true.
But I still kind of hoped that I would see them or have some sort of contact.
My feeling was that when he was with me, he wasn't alone.
That there were other spirits with him.
And I do think that since this has happened, I read the Tibetan Book of the Dead, I've read a lot of spiritual books.
I get a feeling, what I'm getting a sense of, is that after the soul leaves the body, there's a period very briefly, and I've had this debate with a lot of people, people disagree with me, that the soul leaves the body, is alone, and then joins the collective numbers of souls.
But even when it joins that collective number of souls, it can still signal, because I really believe that when Albert was with me, when Albert came to me, there were other souls with him.
But I don't know if it matters.
I think what really matters ultimately is to have faith that there is something after this.
I think that we, at least in some of us, it will instill a better consciousness and a better style of living, taking care of it.
art bell
Yeah, we'll do all of that.
Well, it's always been said that religion is the taskmaster that keeps everybody in line.
The threat of the threat of hell and the threat of all the things standard religion talks about, or even many religions, actually, for that matter, to keep people socially in line.
In fact, if there is an afterlife, it certainly is going to keep people to some degree in line, I would think.
Do you believe in reincarnation?
joel rothschild
Ah, what a good question.
I'm not sure.
I'm not sure.
Part of me does, and part of me doesn't.
And I don't know if I'm going to have these answers until afterwards.
art bell
It doesn't seem like one life is enough time to work it all off.
joel rothschild
No.
art bell
You know, that's what it's based on, of course, that you keep coming back until you get it to some degree right.
And one life doesn't seem like a long enough time to do that.
joel rothschild
There's a great book.
There was an MD, Brian Weiss.
Do you know Brian Weiss?
art bell
I do.
joel rothschild
And he wrote a book that sort of gives an MD, and he wrote a book about reincarnation.
It gives as accurate documentation, I think, and evidence of reincarnation as you could probably give Many Lives, Many Masters.
But I don't know.
And I don't know.
For me, I don't know if it's important to know.
What was important in all of this for me, at the very core of this, is the realization that all of life matters.
That the good, the bad, the happy, the sad, when you're suffering, you're still working things out.
I mean, we all want to be happy.
We all want to have good health.
But that there's meaning and purpose even in those periods that don't feel so good.
I don't know if that makes sense.
art bell
My wife years ago, and I know my audience may have heard this several times from me, she told me something.
I always thought, you know, if I had a fatal disease of any kind that was going to be a very painful, prolonged death, that I would seek that out, you know, read Final Exit, go to Mexico, get whatever you need, and check out, rather than going through a long, painful death.
And my wife told me that no, no, no, she said.
You're supposed to play out the hand you're dealt.
And I don't know if that's true or not.
I've given it a lot of thought, and I think now, more than not, it's probably true.
You're supposed to play out the hand you're dealt because your friend took his own life before he was even ill.
You were ill at the time.
You're playing out your hand.
I don't know.
On the other hand, maybe it was his hand to take his life, but it seems an unsatisfactory conclusion.
joel rothschild
Well, I think you all have to go with what you know at the time.
I mean, I got the drugs.
I had decided that I would do it.
You know, up until 1994, 95, I was ready to take my own life to not have to suffer.
My feeling now is, after going through these experiences, that those moments of suffering serve some sort of purpose that I can't understand.
And so, you know, it's changed for me.
art bell
Well, maybe some are meant or supposed to go through that, and maybe others are not or are not prepared for it in this life.
joel rothschild
Well, I think we all suffer.
I think everybody, every human being suffers.
I don't think we suffer equally, but I think we all suffer.
And, you know, maybe there is a maybe suffering functions if we're all collected, we're all connected in this collective body of God, perhaps suffering is like the liver in a body.
You know, it cleanses.
I don't understand the meaning and the purpose in suffering, but one of the things that Albert said to me the night that he died was that there is meaning and purpose in the suffering.
And it's something that I profoundly believe.
And it was one of the biggest changes throughout this.
art bell
There's a meaning in the suffering.
Meaning and purpose in the suffering.
joel rothschild
In every moment of life.
And I don't think we're going to know it.
I don't think we're going to know it from this plane of existence.
I think we're grappling to know that there's something after this.
And I think my book offers good documentation.
art bell
You know, that's not the message I would have expected from him.
I mean, he took his own life.
So the message I would have expected, or I would have expected, let's put it this way, your mind to generate, would have been one that justified his death.
But that statement doesn't necessarily justify his death at all to suggest that every moment of life, good, bad, or ugly, is precious and important.
joel rothschild
Well, maybe he was telling me and giving me hope to go forward, because at that time I was suicidal.
And so what he was trying to instill in me is a sense of hope that there was a meaning and there was a purpose in this.
And if I could have experienced that knowing from someone departed who I shared this great friendship and this great love with, I would have that seed of hope in my heart.
And, you know, hope is an amazing thing.
I mean, ultimately, you asked me earlier, how am I still here?
I have to say that a big chunk of it is hope.
art bell
hope and uh...
improved medicines no doubt but i mean you have to You really should not have made it this far.
joel rothschild
I shouldn't be here.
I've gone through four bouts of pneumocystis pneumonia before there was treatment for it.
And that was at that time, you know, a fatal infection.
So I shouldn't be here.
art bell
How close did you get to taking your own life?
How close did you actually get?
joel rothschild
Ready.
Completely ready.
I had the drugs in the house.
I was ready to mix them up and ready to go.
And that little seed of hope that I got from Albert that night is what kept me going.
And I was tremendously ill at that time.
And I was frail and thin, and taking care of three other friends that were dying, it was a tremendous challenge.
But that experience was the seed of hope that's kept me alive.
And now I'm in great shape.
In great health.
art bell
You're taking the new protease inhibitors and all the new drugs I have I take it.
joel rothschild
Well, I've been on them since they weren't in study.
art bell
Experimental.
joel rothschild
Right.
Because I'm such an old timer at this.
art bell
What is your prognosis now, by the way?
The doctors who gave you not very long to live so long ago, what do they say now?
joel rothschild
They don't know.
they're discovering now that the immune system does bounce back, but the longer, the quicker...
What they're finding now is that people that seroconvert or come down with AIDS now, they get on the medicine, the immune system really bounces back very quickly.
They can get the virus to a level of undetectable in the system, and their system bounces back.
But what they've found with me is that it won't bounce back to anywhere near a normal level.
So I'm functioning as an AIDS patient, but a healthy AIDS patient.
If that makes sense?
art bell
That's not killing you.
joel rothschild
What?
art bell
It's not killing you.
joel rothschild
No, it's not killing me.
And I haven't had a serious opportunistic infection in a number of years.
So obviously there's a big shift, and I think I represent that shift.
art bell
Well, then maybe Albert's message was specifically for you.
Maybe he was looking down a timeline and saw that you could live a productive life being hence the words.
joel rothschild
You got it.
And there you have it.
It wasn't meant to be a book, and it wasn't meant for other people.
These messages and these signals were really specific to me.
And the way that it came into being, into a book, into sharing this, is that things would happen with friends, like a hummingbird landing on me, and friends said, you've got to write this.
Everybody said, you've got to write this.
You've got to write this.
So, of course, this is a very personal experience.
It wasn't meant to be shared.
It wasn't meant for a radio show or a television show.
art bell
I got you.
joel rothschild
Yeah, and that's how the book came into being.
It's just that so many things happened where there were witnesses.
art bell
All right.
Hold it right there, and we'll be right back.
I'm Art Bell.
This is Coast to Coast AM.
Good morning.
What do you believe?
unidentified
You're listening to Art Bell somewhere in Time.
Tonight, featuring a replay of Coast to Coast AM from February 8th, 2000.
Oh, it's true, oh, I love you.
You showed me how to say exactly what you say in that very special way.
Oh, it's true.
You fell for me too.
And when I tried it, I would see you fall.
And I decided it's not the truth.
Oh, you taught me too.
Exactly what You do, and now you love me too.
Oh, it's true.
Guess there's no use in hanging round.
Guess I'll get pressed into the town.
I'll find some crowded avenue.
Oh, it will be empty without you.
Can't get used to losing you.
No matter what I try to do, God will live my whole life through loving you.
Call some girl I used to know.
After I heard her say hello, couldn't think of anything to say.
Since you got it happens every day, can't get used to losing.
No matter what I try to do, gonna live my whole life through loving you.
I'll find somebody to wait and see.
I can't believe Premier Radio Networks presents Art Bell somewhere in Time.
Tonight's program originally aired February 8th, 2000.
Joel's book is called Signals.
art bell
Simply Signals.
And we are going to open the phone lines here in a moment, and it should be interesting to see how it goes.
I'm getting more faxes.
I'll catch you up on some of them in a moment.
unidentified
I'll catch you up on some of them in a moment.
art bell
All right.
Once again, my guest, and we are about to go to the phones here.
So if you have a question, I can imagine you might.
You're more than welcome to ask it.
This is kind of interesting.
Something I want to cover with you, Joel.
It says, Art, your homosexual guest on the air is experiencing a series of demonic visits.
The entity appearing and or communicating with him is a personifier of his dead gay friend.
Demons have been known to do that.
Now, that's really interesting because I've noticed that when a Christian dies and a relative is left behind and there's a signal or a voice, it's because of God.
But because you're homosexual and your friend was, it's going to be a demon, according to this factor.
Interesting twist.
joel rothschild
Well, my answer to that is that ever since this happened, I've been the best Joel that I could ever be and the kindest and done more good than I've ever done in my life.
So is that what demons cause you to do?
art bell
And then there's this, and you might give an answer.
After considering the question, Art, for about 40 or of my 50 years, I've decided there are only two possibilities.
One, once someone stays dead for an extended period, there is no way to return, no matter how badly the person wants to return or send a message.
Two, the afterlife is so incredibly wonderful of an experience or existence that once we have passed over, we have no need or desire to ever return.
I subscribe to the second option, it says.
Kneel at Topaz Ranch, Nevada.
joel rothschild
In other words, got it.
Great point.
What if there's a great love?
Yeah, a really beautiful friendship, a really beautiful love between two people.
And there was a desire to signal.
Out of that loyalty, out of that friendship.
I think he has a great point.
but in this in in my particular case there was you know there was a friendship like brothers better than brothers i mean best best best friends well that must have been a rather interesting conversation when you During the break, I went in.
art bell
My wife said, you know, if I go first, do you want me to try to signal you?
And I thought about it and I said, yes.
What kind of conversation did you have with Albert?
joel rothschild
what kind of conversation you have to do what kind of deal That's right.
That was a good point.
It was during a card game with a group of friends that had AIDS.
He brought up the idea and he said, you know, why don't he posed it to the whole gang, you know, everybody in the card game.
And everyone in the game pretty much laughed at the idea and scoffed at it and thought it was a silly thing.
And since I respected him so much and I cared about him, I almost was patronizing as I went along with it.
And I kind of jokingly said, you know, Albert, if I go first and I'll probably be the one that goes first, I'll signal you.
I'll flicker a light in your room.
And then over the course of the following year, we talked about it 20, 30 times.
He kept saying to me, well, if you go first, you're going to signal me, aren't you?
And I said, yeah, I'll flick a light in your room.
I'll try something.
And he goes, well, I promise you with my heart and soul that I'll signal you if I can.
We talked about it 20, 30 times.
But it was more his, it was totally his idea.
And I kind of was paganizing, going along with it.
I mean, I didn't want to say, how can you say no to somebody's hope?
art bell
Well, you know, while a lot of people in my audience I know don't agree with your lifestyle, it is my view, Joel, that love is the strongest binding force in the universe.
Period.
Strongest binding force.
You agree with that?
joel rothschild
100%.
Absolutely.
art bell
All right.
Let's see what's out there.
Wildcard line, you're on there with Joel Rothschild.
unidentified
Hi.
Good evening, Art.
It's William from Portland.
art bell
Hi there.
unidentified
Hello, Joel.
Very quickly, I'd like to recount to you, Joel, my own experiences, which are very similar to yours.
My brother passed on with AIDS in 95, and we were always best friends.
I was with him all through till the end.
I was holding his hand as he went.
And when I returned home that day, he came to me, and I saw him clearly.
He said, Greg, I made it.
And then he turned literally to stars and was gone.
Now, I felt his presence for about six months, and we had incredible strokes of luck.
We won a couple of lotteries and contests and things.
And then suddenly one day, it was as if he was literally gone.
I did not feel his presence anymore.
And to support what you said about suffering, he had a life with many personal demons, and he also had the suicide drugs.
At the end, he did not take them, though.
He suffered terribly.
And in the last three days of his life, there was this glow that developed about him.
And I felt that he did much of his life's work and his processing of these demons out, and he came to peace with himself.
And I know that he died a very happy person.
So I support your decision and what you've done also.
And I just wanted to relay that story to you.
joel rothschild
I appreciate that.
And I have to add to what I didn't say is in the years after Albert's death also, I had the best luck.
unidentified
Really?
joel rothschild
Yeah, everything went my way.
And it had never been that way in life before.
unidentified
The same for me.
I won a contest for about $1,000.
And I found a camera I hadn't had for years.
It was amazing.
joel rothschild
I mean, I had great luck that 18-month period.
Just the best.
I could do no wrong.
unidentified
He was with you for a year and a half?
joel rothschild
Yeah, no one has ever shared that with me before, that they had good luck after someone passed.
unidentified
Well, we were both very good friends, and I miss them terribly, and I just wanted to relay that to you.
joel rothschild
Thank you.
art bell
Thank you for the call.
Take care.
He's to the Rockies.
You're on the air with Joel Rothschild.
Hi.
Hello, Art.
unidentified
This is Mark in Indianapolis.
art bell
Hi, Mark.
unidentified
Hi.
Joel, how are you?
joel rothschild
I'm okay.
unidentified
I'm the guy who just sent you the life-after-death photographs on the email.
joel rothschild
Okay.
unidentified
Yeah.
My best friend, Jim, also died of AIDS, and we made a pact that he would give me a signal once he made it to the other side.
And, Art, one of the photos that I sent to Joel, my friend Jim died on the 8th of September, 94.
My next-door neighbor was taking a photograph of the moon with a flash camera exactly one year to the day after Jim's death.
Jim showed up in the photograph.
This has happened so many times in my life.
My loved ones who have died have kind of barged their way into photographs.
What I have found as time goes along, for those who are interested in contacting people or being contacted, it calls for a change in perspective.
And this is the change.
We tend to think of ourselves as being visited by them, like they peek through our windows, like they come into our world.
That's not true.
We are right now living in their world.
Once you let that change in perspective take over in your life, you will be more open to it and you'll be amazed at the things that are going to happen to you in terms of getting contacts from the other side.
art bell
That is an interesting perspective.
Have you yet, Joel, seen The Sixth Sense?
joel rothschild
Yeah, I did see that.
art bell
I did see that.
It makes you wonder if there's, you know, we talk about the other side like it's far away.
Maybe it isn't far away at all.
Maybe it's all happening at once, and it's all around us.
That's what the man just said, and that reminded me of The Sixth Sense.
joel rothschild
And that's, you know, certainly a lot of people believe that.
Again, you know, I defer to my standard answer.
I don't know, is it important to know art?
Is that important?
art bell
I don't know.
joel rothschild
What was important for me is to know that there was something there.
art bell
Yeah, I think it's important to me, too.
I want to know, and I think it's the biggest question that all men and all women face, period.
It's that simple.
joel rothschild
Now, before these experiences happened to me, a caller like that would have called on a show, and I would have said that he was full of it.
I would never have even believed him.
And having lived through it firsthand, I think, yeah, it's amazing it's happening to other people.
So, you know, it's changed me, and hopefully the book changes other people and opens the door to them having their own experiences.
art bell
I remember the beginning of the AIDS epidemic, because I was on the air, Joel.
And I remember all the people who said, it's God's wrath on the homosexuals.
There's still a few total nutcases out there saying that today, but not so much anymore.
Then they did.
It was God's wrath on the homosexuals.
How'd you get through that period?
joel rothschild
Boy, that was really tough, Laura.
That was really, really tough.
Difficult for so many people, so much hatred.
There's that preacher somewhere, I think, in Oklahoma that protests at AIDS funerals.
art bell
Oh, yes, he goes to funerals, yeah.
joel rothschild
Yeah, it's always tough to deal with hate.
I mean, it hurts, and it's incredibly difficult.
art bell
Well, hate of your fellow man, that's one thing, and it's hard enough.
But to be suggesting that the Creator, the God, would bring this forth on homosexuals, that was predominantly said at that time.
That must have been really rough.
Maybe not so rough for you.
I don't know.
I don't know what you're saying.
joel rothschild
Well, the intellectual answer to that is that it's predominantly heterosexuals in Asia.
It's predominantly heterosexuals in Africa.
And now in this country, it's predominantly heterosexual women that are getting it, women of color.
art bell
Oh, I know.
joel rothschild
So, you know, the intelligent answer is that, you know, that's obviously not the case.
It's still painful to hear.
art bell
Welcome to the Rockies.
You're on the air with Joel Rothschild.
unidentified
Hi.
Hi.
This is a great show.
I'm really enjoying it, Art and Joel.
I'm David from San Francisco and very much a heterosexual Christian.
But I read the book and loved it.
art bell
Oh, you read Signals?
unidentified
Yeah.
There was a big stack of them at Borders.
And it's got a great cover, and I picked it up.
It's a beautiful read.
And I've been telling people stories from it.
The stories are so incredible.
Joel, I wish you could tell the story of the pregnant woman.
Maybe even the stop the car one.
art bell
You can.
Joel, we've got time.
Tell the stories.
joel rothschild
Okay.
I was living in a high-rise building.
And this, boy, this is a tough one, Art.
This is like the Sixth Sense, one of those stories.
And there was a woman working at the front desk, kind of cold, Hispanic woman, never acknowledged me.
Used to try to be friendly to her every day.
And I'm leaving one day, and I could feel Albert say, you've got to give her a message.
And I left the building, and I thought, you know, she's going to think I'm insane.
And I was going to the library, went to the library, he kept saying, you've got to go back, you've got to give her a message.
Just go to her and tell her her sister's pregnant.
And then I'll tell you what to say.
I went back to the building.
I said, Carmen, is your sister pregnant?
She looked at me, flabbergasted and pissed off.
How the hell did you know?
Anyway, it turns out that her sister was pregnant.
She was having an affair with somebody, and she was considering an abortion.
Anyway, the message from Albert at that time was to tell her not to have the abortion and that the child was indeed the brother's kid.
art bell
Wow.
joel rothschild
Yeah, it was a miraculous story.
art bell
So nobody else knew about that?
joel rothschild
No, she was shocked.
No one knew.
The sister had just confessed to the other.
She actually was her sister-in-law, married to her brother, just had confessed that she was having an affair and thinking about the abortion.
So anyway, after that, needless to say, we were very close friends.
art bell
Wow, that's an amazing story.
And he referenced one other story.
joel rothschild
I don't remember which one.
art bell
Yeah, I don't either.
I heard him say something about, he said, the pregnant woman.
Then he said something else as well.
I wish you could tell that story.
So there must be a lot of stories in your book.
joel rothschild
Well, there was a good year and a half of psychic events and involving other people as well.
Oh, he said the car accident.
art bell
Yeah, that's it.
joel rothschild
Okay, yeah, the car accident.
About a year after Albert died, I was in my new building, and a bunch of us went out on a Saturday night, and I'm sober, and so I was the designated driver, and we're on La Cieneca and Santa Monica Boulevard, which is a huge intersection.
And about 90 feet before the intersection, I heard Albert's voice say, stop the car.
So I slammed on the brakes.
Everybody practically had whiplash in the car.
Anyway, a few cars passed us.
Needless to say, there was a huge accident.
One of those great big semi-trucks hit a car.
Somebody was killed at the scene.
And yeah, that was another one.
I had actually forgotten about that story.
art bell
Boy, these aren't just signals.
They're like telegrams.
joel rothschild
Yeah.
art bell
Now, I guess from the moment you held his dead body and got that first message, you learned to listen.
A lot of us get messages and we dismiss them as sort of random firings of synapses in our brain, you know.
joel rothschild
No, I'm not patronizing you, Art.
You are one bright man.
Because I'll tell you, you really are.
I'm amazed that you got that.
Because that's how I learned.
If I hadn't gone through that first experience, I would have thought maybe I was paranoid or it was self-talk.
art bell
Sure.
joel rothschild
You're right.
I mean, you're absolutely 100% right.
That's how I learned to listen to the message.
art bell
You're so fortunate.
joel rothschild
I mean, I can't believe that you got that.
art bell
So many of us, you know, we want to know, we want to believe, and that's why I have people like you on the radio, because I haven't met that same kind of concrete proof that you have.
I wish I felt it.
I wish I was as confident.
joel rothschild
Well, read the book.
It may give you some.
I mean, you know, it's secondhand, but it's pretty close to documentating it.
art bell
Do you think that when somebody is open to this, when you have made yourself receptive to these sorts of messages, that they are very much more likely to be received?
I guess the answer to that is absolutely yes.
joel rothschild
I would assume so, but I don't know.
You know, these were thrust upon me.
I didn't ask for any of this to happen.
I didn't expect any of this.
And there's times where I wish it would happen more.
If something goes wrong, I'm wishing I would know I could hear Albert say what to do.
It's just not something that you can turn on and off.
art bell
Do you now feel his presence really gone?
In other words, from where it was when you would get occasional signals, messages, suddenly gone?
I mean, you can feel the vacuum.
joel rothschild
Yep, absolutely.
And I'm very sad to admit that.
And, you know, a lot of friends would probably say, oh, you're wrong, and he could never have left you.
But yeah, it's not the same.
It's not the same as it was in 95, you know, when these things were happening bang, bang, bang, right after another.
art bell
Were there ever moments when you wished that presence that you felt, those voices that you heard, were not happening?
joel rothschild
Yes, absolutely.
Another on-the-mark question, boy.
There was a time when, like that story with the girl that was pregnant, there was a couple other experiences where I had a message similar to the sixth sense someone.
And after the experience, I was drained, almost felt physically jet-lagged.
And there was a period of a time where I wished it wasn't happening.
art bell
Where it was taking your energy.
joel rothschild
Yeah.
art bell
All right, hold on.
You good for one more hour?
joel rothschild
Sure.
art bell
All right.
Well, the phones are stacked, so we'll do one more hour.
I'm Art Bell.
unidentified
We'll be right back.
You're listening to Ark Bell somewhere in time on Premier Radio Networks.
Tonight, an encore presentation of Coast to Coast AM from February 8, 2000.
In my arms, I know the magic of her charms Cause I want a girl to call my own I want a dream lover so I don't have to dream alone Dream lover, where you're going Where are you with a love for so true?
And the hands that I can hold, here and here as I grow old'Cause I want a girl to call my own I wanna dream, lover, so I don't have to dream alone Some day I don't know how I hope she'll hear my breathing.
Some way I don't know how you'll bring her love to me.
dream Sweet dreams are made of visions.
Who am I to deserve?
I travel the world and the seven seas.
Everybody is looking for something.
Some of them want to use you.
Some of them want to get used by you.
Some of them want to abuse you.
Some of them want to be abused Sweet deep darling.
You're listening to Art Bell somewhere in time.
Tonight, featuring a replay of Coast to Coast AM from February 8th, 2000.
art bell
It is at.
Good morning, everybody.
My guest is Joel Rothschild.
He'll be back in a moment.
We're into Open Lines Now with Joel.
And this is kind of interesting, Art.
I recently read Joel's book, Signals.
Apparently a lot of people have.
And what's amazing about the book is that it transcends sexuality and the fact that it was written by a gay man.
The book is for everyone.
Joel hasn't said much this evening about his psychic experiences since Albert's death, but for me, it was like reading those accounts of his psychic experiences in the book that have made me realize how much more there is than just the tangible things that we can see or hear.
His book is one of the most significant things I've ever read.
This is interesting.
By the way, he says, when I was trying to find time to read signals, which I really needed spiritually at the time, there was a hummingbird outside my window for a long time, and it stayed there until I finally sat down and read the book.
The following is from Gail in Las Vegas, and Gail says, you know, before Albert's suicide, Joel had no faith in God, no hope of any kind.
What a wonderful gift Albert left behind.
It doesn't sound like he was escaping.
It sounds like he was lighting the way.
Interesting.
Beautiful point.
All right, to the phones.
First time caller line, you're on the air with Joel Rothschild.
Hi.
unidentified
Hi, this is Jeremy in Burlington, Vermont.
art bell
Hello, Jeremy.
How are you doing?
unidentified
Pretty good.
About a year and a half ago or so, I discovered that I actually have this somewhat of a psychic ability.
Pretty much a friend told me, you know, you've got to listen to these signals, pretty much like what your guest was saying.
And I was wondering, now, since I have these, I can pick up on these things, would I actually be able to communicate with somebody who's already passed away, or is that along the same lines as that?
I'm relatively new to this.
joel rothschild
Asking me?
art bell
Yeah, I guess he is.
joel rothschild
I don't know.
I mean.
unidentified
I mean, because I want to you describe it as.
art bell
In other words, there are people, and I've had several of them on the show, nationally famous mediums, yeah, who are able to communicate with somebody who has passed away.
Now, that seems different than what happened to you, Joel.
Yours was specific.
joel rothschild
Well, I had some mediumistic experiences.
art bell
Did you?
joel rothschild
Yeah, and that was what the caller earlier was saying with this girl that the sister was going to have the abortion.
And the only thing is, I've never been able to turn them on or off.
art bell
I understand that.
I've had a couple in my life, and I couldn't control them starting, and I couldn't control them stopping.
And I even tried to bring them on on purpose and couldn't.
It was a total waste of effort.
But when they came to me, they were so strong that they could not be ignored.
the comparison i made with the experience i had was like ocean waves washing over me uh...
compelling me to go and do something which i ultimately finally did which was silly um...
unidentified
i don't really want to lose all story again but someone There you go, Art.
joel rothschild
You had one.
art bell
It was a signal.
joel rothschild
You had one.
There you have it.
That sounds just about what it felt like to me.
art bell
Yeah, it was so compelling that you could not possibly ignore it.
That's the way it was for me, but it only happened once.
Wildcard line, you're on the air with Joel Rothschild.
Hi.
unidentified
Hi, Art.
This is Jim in Byron Center, Michigan.
art bell
Yes, Jim.
unidentified
And, well, first I want to make a quick comment to you.
You had the show on with the anti-aging thing the other night.
art bell
That's right.
unidentified
And I thought you missed the perfect opportunity for a bumper song by Queen, Who Wants to Live Forever.
I waited for it all night.
Well, you're right.
art bell
I got 25, 25 in there, but I didn't get that.
unidentified
You can't do it all.
Well, my question for him, for Josh, is the process or what he's going through right now, is it healthy for his grieving process, or is it extending maybe the grieving for this person?
I know I'm married to my soulmate, and we've made Kind of a similar pact, and I've been concerned that maybe it'll extend the pain rather than let it just go.
art bell
Yeah, that's really, oh boy, is that a good point.
joel rothschild
I'm way past the grieving period myself, and what a clinical social worker said to me who called me on another show is that in some cases, these type experiences are written off to grieving, to people's grief, grief hallucinations.
art bell
Sure.
joel rothschild
The bulk of my experiences happened a year after Albert was already dead, and I was already past my grieving.
So this caller said that that was incredibly unusual.
But what I will say is that none of this protracted a grieving period.
If anything, it helped.
I mean, it gave me hope.
art bell
Yeah, but you were mentally set for it.
I mean, at the moment you were holding his dead body and you got that message.
From that moment on, you would be unlikely to ignore any other message you would get, I would think.
joel rothschild
Yeah, I still was, I was in a cloud.
I mean, you know, you go through a death, you're holding a dead body.
I was wrecked.
I had lost my best friend.
So I was grieving then.
And I did, you know, it was, I didn't give that whole situation a lot of thought.
You know, for years I looked back and analyzed hopping that wall and getting that note.
And I thought about it time and time again.
But at that point in time, I didn't think about it.
I just was reacting.
And that night that he came to me, I was just, you know, it planted a seed of hope.
I didn't digest it for years.
I didn't think that.
art bell
When you say he came to you, do you mean you were mentally aware of his presence?
Do you mean you saw something?
joel rothschild
There was a physical light in the room.
There was a light, a very translucent light.
You know what dust looks like coming through a stream of sunlight in a window?
art bell
Sure.
joel rothschild
Or smoke above a candle?
art bell
I know about smoke, yeah.
joel rothschild
There was a little bit of veiled light in the room above me.
art bell
And so all of a sudden, the dust or whatever it was, particulate matter in the air, was illuminated.
joel rothschild
Right.
And Albert's presence was there, and he said, you know it's me, don't you?
And I was frozen, completely frozen.
art bell
With terror?
joel rothschild
No.
I had some fear.
Another good question.
I had some fear for a few seconds.
I don't know what time frame this whole thing transpired, but initially I had a sense of fear.
But as I realized he was there, it was very calm.
But I was just frozen.
I couldn't move.
I was just completely immobile.
art bell
I've got you.
East of the Rockies, you're on the air with Joel Rothschild.
Hi.
unidentified
Good morning, Very.
art bell
Good morning.
You're going to have to yell at us a little.
You're not too loud.
Where are you?
unidentified
Okay, I'm sorry.
This is Chris in Seminole, Florida.
art bell
Okay, Seminole, Florida.
unidentified
All right.
art bell
Go ahead, Chris.
unidentified
Well, first, you're very fortunate.
It just crossed my mind to say, to have seen your lover's light after you've died, or after he's died.
In any case, I want to preface what I wanted to say here with that we need to understand the mechanics of how creation works.
I know you said there's some things that it's not important to know.
Well, sometimes it is, but maybe just not right now.
I wanted to remark about my brother who committed suicide about 10 years ago.
art bell
Yes.
unidentified
And apparently he felt obligated to signal back.
My mother and I especially and other members of my family saw lights, a sequence of lights of different colors going through different periods of time.
And because the dead apparently can see into the future, we found that Bardoth et al.
later on, and it says the Tibetan Book of the Dead that Joel mentioned that he read earlier.
And by the way, that means after-death hearing, which implies the need to listen after you're dead to progress spiritually.
But in any case, we found that the sequence of lights that we saw matched exactly the phases in the Tibetan Book of the Dead.
And the Tibetan Book of the Dead also says that I believe this to be true, that during the first seven days are days, not literal days, but the days after death that we go through meeting relatives and having a good time, is basically having what we want, being able to create what we want.
And then we go through, it transits into a period of seven days of meeting our conscience, which are in the form of wrathful and terrifying deities, they call them, or demons or whatever.
And it's important, the Tibetan Book of the Dead, says, and I feel this to be true, to tell the dead to bless these and to recognize that they're reflections of our own soul as soon as possible after death.
And that's the whole purpose of the book is to coach the dead into the light, so to speak.
And, you know, I just wanted to make the point, and Joel can respond to this, that, you know, find, communicate telepathically with your dead, but I just don't think it's good to ask for the deceased to expend any extra energy for any special things.
art bell
What about making a pact, though, prior to death?
unidentified
That's a good point, and that's, I believe, you know, yeah, we do want to move on after death, but yet that pact was so ingrained in Albert's conscience that, yes, it's good that, you know, that gave it energy.
He gave energy to that commitment long before he died, is my belief.
art bell
All right.
Thank you very much.
joel rothschild
Artie may have a point about asking for special favors and asking for things.
You know, I hear what he's saying, and it sounds balanced to me.
I don't ask for special favors.
I don't ask for things.
I didn't ask for any of these.
art bell
You actually, despite your illness, you've prospered fairly well, haven't you?
Your success in business.
joel rothschild
I've been very successful.
I've been very blessed.
art bell
Was it true prior to your illness as well as after your illness and after the death of your friend?
joel rothschild
I've always done well, and I've always done.
I've had a fairly successful life, but after Albert's death, it was tenfold.
No comparison.
I couldn't do anything wrong.
I bought a piece of property.
It doubled in value.
I was always at the right place at the right time.
I wasn't asking for it.
what reminded me of it is that other caller that said that he won the lottery afterwards.
I don't know.
It was the easiest time of my life those years afterwards, especially economically.
art bell
That's really interesting.
That's really interesting.
And yet so many people not only ask for it, but beg for it and pray for it and never get it.
And yet there it was for you.
joel rothschild
It was handed to me.
art bell
Yeah.
Yeah, I know.
I hear you.
joel rothschild
And I don't know, you know, maybe that's just the fate that that was the timing of my life and that's the way it unfolded.
I don't think so.
But it was almost like he was in a corner pulling for me, you know, maybe whispering in my ear signals that I couldn't hear.
Go there and buy that house.
Go there and do that.
art bell
Have you done any research on NDEs, near-death, and all the rest of that?
joel rothschild
I read Ray Moody's book, Life After Life, and I spoke, I did a chat with Peggy Guggenheim.
Do you know who she is?
art bell
Yes.
joel rothschild
Does some research there, but no, I've never done anything.
And I've never been included in anybody's studies or anything like that.
art bell
All right.
And Albert, did Albert ever relate to you in any way where he was and what he felt?
unidentified
Did he ever do anything like that?
joel rothschild
Another good question.
No.
But I had a sense, and there wasn't a specific thing said.
I had a sense that one night that he was at peace and that he wasn't alone.
But no, not at all.
art bell
A lot of people feel that God as such doesn't render up some judgment after you die and you go on to whatever is next.
That in effect, you judge yourself.
And probably if you really think about it, if you really were forced to look at the mirror of your life as it really was, not as you have glossed over it or conveniently forgotten it, then you would be a very harsh judge of yourself indeed.
Seem logical to you?
joel rothschild
Yep.
Absolutely.
art bell
West of the Rockies, you're on the air with Joel Rothschild.
Hi.
unidentified
Hello.
art bell
Hello.
unidentified
My name is James.
art bell
James, oh, I can barely hear you.
Where are you?
unidentified
Orange County, California.
art bell
Okay, yell at us.
unidentified
Alrighty.
I'm just wondering, after a similar pact, okay, Harry Eugenie's wife tried to make contact.
And I'm wondering why she did not receive similar results.
joel rothschild
I don't know if she did or she didn't.
I've never met her.
I mean, I don't know.
I had heard about that pact, and people say that they never had contact.
I don't know.
art bell
Maybe, caller, it has to do with the fact that that pact was only for the purpose of trying to prove there was an afterlife, as opposed to trying to send a signal to somebody you loved.
unidentified
Okay.
joel rothschild
I don't know.
I mean, it's a good question, and I imagine that there must be other people that made similar pacts that didn't have this experience.
All I can think of is, wow, I was really blessed.
I mean, how amazing is it then?
It's even more amazing.
art bell
All right, caller?
unidentified
Okay, thank you very much.
art bell
All right, thank you.
First time, caller line, you're on the air with Joel Rothchild.
unidentified
Hi.
Hi, this is a damn from Long Beach.
art bell
Yes, sir.
unidentified
I was wondering if it would be a normal pattern when someone passes away that, you know, good things should happen to the person's family and friends.
did it happen to you uh...
It's kind of hard for me to say, though, because I know this one woman who passed away from having cancer, and the only regret that I have is I've never really gotten to know her.
And so I can't really answer that.
But I was just wondering, you know, for any close friends or family, if any good things would happen afterwards.
joel rothschild
The only time I ever heard of anything like that was tonight on your show, Art.
The guy that called and said that.
The first time I've ever heard of anything like that.
art bell
Well, where there's one, there'll be more.
joel rothschild
Yeah.
And in my particular case, yes, that was the case.
art bell
All right, Color?
joel rothschild
It was amazing.
unidentified
All right, back to you later, Art.
art bell
All right, take care.
Wildcard Line, you're on the air with Joel Rothchild.
unidentified
Hi.
Excuse me?
art bell
You're on the air.
Turn your radio off, please.
unidentified
Okay, my radio is off.
art bell
Okay, go right.
Go ahead.
unidentified
Good morning, Art.
This is Steve and Pike Latinxi.
art bell
Yes, sir.
unidentified
I had a dream.
I had them when I was younger about my grandfather.
When we were children, we were really close.
And when he passed away, I'd had dreams that he would come to me and ask me if I wanted to go to heaven with him.
And then, of course, I'd say yes, and he would come, and he'd take my hand, and we'd walk into this life, and we'd go into heaven.
And I'm just wondering if this is sort of the same thing because of the close bond that we had when I was a child.
joel rothschild
Well, I'd say yes, wouldn't you?
art bell
i would but you know i don't know i mean we're we're off into You experienced it.
You tell us.
I think we lost a medium.
joel rothschild
I mean, that sounds like it to me.
I mean, I think the one thing that's happened to me, two things have happened, Art.
I got the hate mail, and I got the name-calling.
And the other thing I got is the stories about people experiencing similar things and different things in their own way.
And that's an example.
art bell
No, exactly.
joel rothschild
It's been a catalyst for a lot of people writing me letters and sharing stories that are fairly miraculous that I never would have believed until I lived through it firsthand.
art bell
What do you think you're going to get as a result of tonight's program?
You think you're going to get a lot of hate mail?
joel rothschild
I got a feeling I'll get 50-50.
You know, I think there's a lot of great people out there, a lot of really good, kind people, and I think that there's a lot of people with a lot of hate out there, too.
You probably go both ways.
art bell
Hold on, Joel.
We'll be right back.
It probably will go both ways.
And one would hope that as the world's consciousness, hopefully, is raised a little bit, the ratio would begin to change.
That would be one sign.
We'll be right back.
unidentified
You're listening to Art Bell somewhere in time.
Tonight, featuring a replay of Coast to Coast AM from February 8th, 2000.
When the trees are mound with leaves, and the ash and look at their birds and you, and dress in ribbons here.
When hours cold, the breathless moon in the moving of the night.
The shadows of the trees appear, and beats the lantern light.
We got the night standard.
Every time we breathe again, who go down to the shady clothes,
some of the shadows.
If you could read my mind, love, what a tale my thoughts could tell.
Just like an old-time movie, about a ghost from a wishing well.
In a castle dark or a fortress strong, with chains upon my feet, you know that ghost is me.
You're listening to Arkbell Somewhere in Time on Premier Radio Networks.
Tonight, an encore presentation of Coast to Coast AM from February 8th, 2000.
art bell
Oh, you got to think about those words.
I'll never be set free as long as I'm a ghost you can see.
I wonder if we hold, in effect, spirits here.
Certainly is worth considering.
And when we no longer hold them and bind them with our minds and our thoughts and our love, then they go.
I don't know.
something to think about.
All right, well, here's what brought that on and reminded me of that song.
Hi Art, Life After Life.
My white cat, Bobby, died.
Bobby had a twig of hair always sticking straight up on her head.
After she died, my cat, Bunky, had the same twig of hair.
Now Bunky has died.
Yet she still walks through my house.
And I sometimes wonder if our love holds the spirit here when maybe it needs to move on, Joel.
joel rothschild
Wow.
I don't know what to say to something like that.
art bell
Well, I mean, it almost goes to the sixth sense, and I don't want to give that away because a lot of people have yet to crash into that movie, or the movie crash into them.
But that is kind of what it was about there.
joel rothschild
Well, in my case, I would want to hold on to Albert if I could now more than ever, or as much as ever, and things haven't happened.
So I don't know.
I don't think we're that powerful.
art bell
Yeah, that's a good point.
First time caller line, you're on the air with Joel Rothschild.
Hi.
unidentified
Hello.
Hello.
art bell
Again, I can barely hear you too, dear.
So you're going to have to yell at us.
unidentified
Oh, I'm sorry.
Yeah, this is Gemma from Portland, and I don't really listen to this show that often, but I have pretty much every night for a week and a half.
art bell
A week and a half, huh?
unidentified
A week and a half, every night.
I get it pretty late.
But I wanted to relate a story about the filtered.
I've never talked on the radio, so this is a little different for me.
art bell
New for you.
unidentified
Hello?
Yeah.
Okay.
I don't want this to sound silly or flighty or anything, but I had a cat whose name was Kitten Fuzzy Paw, and I loved him a lot.
Of course, he loved me.
He was my kitty cat.
And he was at my mom's house.
I had just moved to Oregon from San Francisco, and he was at my mom's house.
And I was moving into a house, a whole new town where I didn't know anyone.
And I had met a few people, and I met this person, this guy who was in my life, but I had only just met him.
Oh, God, I'm kind of embarrassed.
Anyhow, he was at my mom's house, and I had had a dream.
I was asleep.
I had had this dream that I was holding Kitten Fuzzy Paw and rubbing his stomach, like I always did, and he was introducing me to this guy, Trace.
And then I woke up from the dream, and I sleep on my stomach, and I woke up on my stomach, and it was sunrise, and it was like an early summer morning, and I could see the brick wall outside of my window, and I could hear birds chirping and whatever.
But I had this really pleasant feeling all over.
And then about 10 minutes later, I started dozing off again, and my mom called me, and she had called just about 20 minutes earlier.
She had let Kitten Fuzzy Paw out to run around, and he got hit by a car and was killed.
And that was like right when I was dreaming the dream.
And then this person that I had met, I'm not going to say his name, but he was in my life for five and a half years, and it was a pretty intense love.
And I just, I don't know.
I've always wanted to tell people that.
And I tell people that, but it just sounds silly.
Your cat?
art bell
No, it doesn't sound silly.
joel rothschild
Well, see, that's the reluct that reluctant sensibility, not wanting to tell.
I mean, I still have it.
I mean, here I have this book out, and it's still difficult to share these stories at times.
art bell
No, I have this definite feeling that while I'm still searching for evidence of life beyond, I have this feeling that love is such a bindingly, incredibly strong force that if anything can pierce the veil, that is what does it.
And that is what does it.
I mean, you could listen to these stories, whether it's a cat or a prison or a loved one, somebody desperately loved.
You could hear these stories all day long.
And a lot of them cannot be attributed, just like the beginning of your story, to some sort of random protection of the brain grief exhibiting itself in your brain.
That's not what I would call your stories, and a lot of the other ones I've heard.
Wildcard line, you're on the air with Joel Rothschild.
unidentified
Hi.
Hello.
art bell
Hello.
unidentified
Hi, Art.
And hi, Joel.
I've got one comment.
Well, actually, two.
First of all, Joel, that idiot who called and said the demons were visiting you, I don't think the devil would send anything that would produce you closer to God would come from the devil.
It would only come from God.
So actually, that's probably the purpose.
On suffering, I used to volunteer with children in Dallas that were HIV positive.
We had a home for the children.
And a lot of times the children, we would go to their hospital and basically on their deathbed, and the children would talk about the light and everything.
And I had one child in particular who was only four years old who would tell me about the light man, who would take away all his hurt because everybody was worried about all the suffering he was going through.
And what I found out, and through this child, what I learned was suffering, it's like natural disasters.
People are drawn together that normally wouldn't be drawn together, and there is this unconditional love that comes around.
And sometimes when people are sick and they're suffering, people who would not be drawn together tend to have this unconditional love and surpass the things that we look at here on earth.
And their purpose seems to be to draw those people together and to produce an unconditional love.
And I know with this child, what's really odd is it's like he's been reincarnated through my nephew.
The things that this child did, my nephew does.
And then we found out my nephew is terminally ill.
And what's really odd is everybody in my family, nobody would be a genetic match except me to donate a kidney to him, which is really, really odd because the child that I took care of would play with the lights, and he would talk particularly about the light, and so does my nephew.
And so it's like this reincarnation, and he doesn't seem to be suffering at all physically.
It's just this learning process that he has taught the whole family and everyone else.
And I was just wondering if that you have experienced that a lot of people through that suffering have learned unconditional love because of your friend.
joel rothschild
Well, you remind me of, your story reminds me of my favorite book of all time, which sort of says the same thing that you said.
There was a Holocaust survivor, Viktor Frankl, wrote a book called Man's Search for Meaning, greatest book I've ever read in my life.
And actually, my inspiration for putting this thing on paper, because I didn't want to share these stories, even though friends were telling me to share these stories.
And his courage in telling his Holocaust story is what encouraged me to do this.
And I couldn't agree with you more.
I mean, there's a solidification.
There's people coming together.
There's lessons to be learned here.
Lessons about hope.
Lessons about love.
I mean, there's so many lessons that are learned in this suffering.
I mean, AIDS, for example, we're all going to die.
I mean, we're all dying.
And one of the things that AIDS did for me, which was a gift, is stripped away my natural human denial of my own death so that I was able to live in the moment, which was actually a gift.
art bell
Yeah, actually, in a way, it was, because a lot of people have absolutely no warning of their demise whatsoever.
They never get to consider it and life and the meaning of life and the value of life versus what they're facing.
They just get sort of, they just blink out, you know, instantly.
So in a way, knowing or facing your own mortality is a kind of a gift in a way, and it lets you get square with yourself and a lot of other things.
joel rothschild
Absolutely.
art bell
Yeah, that's all true.
East of the Rockies, you're on the air with Joel Rothschild.
Hi.
unidentified
Hi, good morning, Ari.
My name is John.
I'm calling from Yonkers, New York, listening on 77WABC.
art bell
Hi, John.
unidentified
Hi.
My viewpoint is that of someone who has lost two close family members to cancer.
I've wondered why, in America today, only house pets and convicted serial murderers are given the painless death of chemically induced execution until I came across a rather startling statistic, and that is that of the several billion dollars spent every year by Americans for medical services,
hospitals, doctors, prescription drugs, fully 70% of all that money is spent on maintaining individuals in the last 60 to 90 days of life.
It's a phenomenal amount of money to maintain people who are virtually at death's door.
And I was curious to know if Joel and his friend Albert's experience with self-euthanasia by choice, if he feels there is any hope for Americans to break this medical deadlock so that people will not have to seek painful deaths through self-inflicted gunshot wounds or whatever when they finally reach that Point where they can no longer tolerate the pain.
art bell
All right.
Well, obviously, it's a doctor-death kind of question, and I'm sure that you've mightily considered that for a long time, Joel.
joel rothschild
Well, I mean, I personally believe that it's I wish we had that freedom as they do in a few other countries in the Netherlands.
But then spiritually, having gone, and this is going to go, boy, right against what I just said, and I'm someone who got the drugs and planned for my final exit, having gone through these experiences, spiritually I now believe that I would never do that, that every moment of life matters.
And, you know.
art bell
I wonder if that's a universal truth or an individual truth.
joel rothschild
It's my truth, so it's probably individual.
We would take an animal out of pain that we wouldn't take a human being out of.
art bell
Yes, we would.
joel rothschild
I've seen some horrible deaths from cancer and from AIDS, and protracted and long and very ugly.
And I've also seen some deaths where people went a long period of time in their suffering and was in the room with them when they died, and there was this amazing sense of peace and transition.
art bell
have you ever being with a dying person and i i i i talk to a lot of people who are with dying have you ever actually felt something at the exact moment of transition at the moment of physical death have you ever It is, I guess.
joel rothschild
A bizarre Kvorkian question.
But I can tell you that three friends died, and I was with them when they died.
I was in the room.
And so I don't know when the exact moment was.
I'm not sure of the exact second.
I was there the millisecond, but there was a sense of peace.
And there was a sense of peace before that, but there was a stronger sense of peace after that.
art bell
Afterwards, yeah.
joel rothschild
Okay.
art bell
All right.
Welcome to the Rockies.
You're on there with Joel Rothschild.
unidentified
Hi.
Yeah, how are you doing tonight?
joel rothschild
Fine.
unidentified
You guys are having a great show tonight.
I really have enjoyed listening to you.
I'd just like to say I believe that there's something to the strong bond of love that makes you maybe see something that other people don't see or feel something that other people don't feel.
The best thing I can relate it to is my dog, Max, died of throat cancer.
And Max was just the greatest dog.
I mean, I loved him to death.
To this day, I just still can't get over his passing away.
But every night for about a week, Max would come to the foot of my bed, and he would just sit there, and I would wake up, very peaceful, warm feeling, and I'd look at him, and he would just vanish after a few moments.
art bell
Yeah, I know a lot of people scoff at this, but I had a cat that died, and I went through that with my cat.
still do um...
it's you know People who have not experienced it, I'm afraid, are going to be scoffing and scoffing and scoffing, but that's all right.
I felt it.
I know what you have felt and seen, and it's true.
I mean, it's true.
Whatever you want to say, it's true.
I appreciate it.
First time caller line, you're on the air with Joel Rothschild.
Hi.
unidentified
Oh, hi.
Hello.
Your book was amazing.
I read it, and I gave it to some of my friends to read, and I found it very helpful.
joel rothschild
Thank you.
art bell
a lot of your readers are out there your book must be Yeah, it's everywhere.
Is it everywhere?
All right.
unidentified
I've been positive for 14 years.
So reading your book, well, it's just helpful on all kinds of levels.
And I listened to Art Bill.
I've been listening to him for years because I like the tough questions and he takes a detached stance and allows us to come to our own conclusions.
And I felt from reading your book, you wrote it in that sort of an intelligent way where you didn't say, I know this for sure.
This is just, I'm putting this out there, you decide.
And it was an amazing book to read.
I've been giving it to my friends.
We've sort of been talking about it and calling up other people and talking to them about it because it really transcends gayness or straightness.
It's about love.
The message was about love, you know, and that it lives on.
And Art's always talking about that.
And I think it's true.
joel rothschild
In writing it, it was that Viktor Frankl thing again.
I just wanted to, I didn't want to be emotional about the experiences and I didn't want to editorialize.
I just wanted to present them as they happened.
unidentified
i felt you i thought this guy really wrote from the heart because when i was reading the word It came right off the page as though I was talking with you.
And I thought, how ironic.
I really lived close to this guy and I might have met him at some point.
And one time, about eight years ago, when my niece died in Germany, she was in the Navy.
She was 22 and she hit a tree and died.
I woke up and knew.
And when they called me, they said we're having a hard time getting the body into the country from Germany through all the difficulties they had with the Navy and all the red tape.
And I heard her voice.
I was standing in my room and she said, I'll be home in seven days.
And she told me when and where and what.
And I called my mother and she says, oh, no, that's impossible.
We tried doing that, and they said it couldn't happen.
I said, she's going to be there at this time, and it happened.
So that was a very unexplainable thing.
And it happened to me.
And I did hear a voice, and it did come to me like that.
And I didn't try to go against it.
I just went with it and told the people I needed to be told.
And it did happen.
How can you explain these things?
art bell
Only in the way we're doing that tonight.
Thank you.
Wildcard Line, you're on the air with Joel Rothschild.
Hi.
unidentified
Is that me, Art?
art bell
That's you.
unidentified
Hey, listen, Joel, bear with me just a moment.
Art, I have some information related to Daniel Brinkley, Ramona, and some UFO pictures that came my way related to crash sites and bodies.
art bell
That's fine, sir.
If you want to hold on, no, I can't do it while we've got a guest on.
If you want to get that kind of thing on, you'll have to wait in door and open lines.
unidentified
Okay, thank you.
art bell
Right, thank you.
East of the Rockies, you're on there.
unidentified
Hi, Art.
Great show.
Thank you.
Joel, I have a very strange question.
While Albert was still alive, Like with my friend, or my better half of 21 years, he can hear what I think.
Did you have any experience like that with Albert?
joel rothschild
Great question.
One of the strangest things in our relationship is that there was this synchronicity, not hearing things like that, but we were constantly running into each other.
There were odd coincidences our whole life.
We live on opposite ends of town.
We used to see each other every day, and on a particular day, I would say, well, I'm going downtown, and he'd say, well, I'm going to Long Beach.
And we both changed our minds, and we're in the valley and run into each other at a major intersection.
unidentified
For no reason at all, and you just run into each other.
joel rothschild
We constantly were having these synchronicities where we were running into each other and odd events like that during our lifetime, during his lifetime when he was here.
art bell
And in Los Angeles, that's pretty synchronistic.
unidentified
Yeah, that's pretty cute.
joel rothschild
Anchorsham Boulevard in Sun Valley when, you know, I live in West Hollywood and he lived in L.A. I really appreciate that.
art bell
All right.
Well, I really appreciate your call, sir.
Thank you.
Amazon.com has your book.
joel rothschild
Selling well there.
art bell
Selling well.
And I guess selling, it's a good deal for people.
I tell them that.
I've got a book up there, too, and you can get like a 30% discount or something.
joel rothschild
Yep, they've already put it on sale.
They're a new book, and they've got it on sale.
art bell
Oh, they do it right away, actually, from day one.
So did you birth this book with trepidation?
Were you wondering how it would be received?
joel rothschild
Wow.
Can you imagine?
Do you know what it's like to tell the whole world you have AIDS?
It's got to be, you know, you can imagine how scary it is.
I mean, then to talk about these things.
Yeah, I mean, tremendous trepidation.
art bell
Is that something you kept secret for years and years?
joel rothschild
Well, no, I mean, I didn't keep it as a secret, but it's not something that, you know, it's a difficult thing to tell the whole world.
And, you know, these are difficult things to talk about.
I'll tell you, I was really inspired.
I don't know, did you read Viktor Frankl's book, Man's Search for Meaning?
art bell
I have, yes.
joel rothschild
It's a brilliant book.
And I thought if, you know, he spoke so honestly and candid about that horror, well, I certainly can talk about my little tragedies.
art bell
Little tragedies, not, I think not.
joel rothschild
Comparing them.
art bell
Well, it's a very brave thing you've done, in my opinion, coming forward.
Very, very brave.
And I don't know, I guess as Spock would say, all I can say to you is I hope you sell a lot of books.
I hope a lot of people read them because those who have responded said they got a lot out of it.
It really helped them.
And as Spock would say, live long and prosper.
joel rothschild
And if Spock, Spock had one thing that I always wanted to have that I couldn't do with my book, the Walton Minecraft.
Nothing would be a greater gift than to be able to hook up that way and other people's final pain and knowledge.
I wish I wouldn't have.
art bell
Good night, my friend.
joel rothschild
Thank you, Mark.
art bell
Listen, tomorrow night, Peter Davenport is going to be here.
And you're going to be hearing lots of very valuable material because that's what Peter Davenport has.
And then Friday or Thursday night, Friday morning, Matthew Alper comes back.
The God part of the brain.
From the high desert, I'm Mark Bell.
Export Selection