All Episodes
Feb. 26, 2026 - Timcast IRL - Tim Pool
02:29:08
THEY KILLED THEM | Timcast IRL #1457 w/Jay Dyer & Jake Botch

Jake Botch and Jay Dyer dissect the FL7726SH speedboat shooting near Cuba, questioning motives amid Venezuela’s oil asset seizure straining Havana’s economy, while linking it to U.S. geopolitical strategy—like past Venezuela raids—and Monroe Doctrine revival. They debate company towns vs. communism, framing private property rights through Christian ethics but dismissing modern ideological consistency, then critique Democrats for allegedly eroding American traditions via immigration-driven shifts (e.g., Bears’ relocation, statue removals). Seth Rogen’s bizarre Kim Jong-un claim sparks comparisons of North Korea’s isolation to progressive admiration for its authoritarian "nature," while the segment contrasts China’s Xinjiang crackdowns with U.S. interventions, arguing both stem from ideological hypocrisy. Ultimately, they suggest modern politics—left and right—have abandoned Founding Fathers’ principles, prioritizing power over coherence. [Automatically generated summary]

Participants
Main
e
elad eliahu
09:09
j
jakey botch
08:41
j
jay dyer
infowars 15:05
p
phil labonte
05:02
t
tim pool
01:24:20
Appearances
Clips
c
carter banks
00:20
d
david chalian
cnn 00:26
|

Speaker Time Text
Cuba's Desperate Stand 00:04:56
tim pool
Four Americans shot dead.
A U.S.-flagged speedboat near was entering Cuban waters when the National Guard killed them all.
Now, the Cuban guard's saying that these Americans opened fire on them.
I don't believe it.
The latest reporting is since Venezuela's oil's been cut off and U.S. has taken back control of their oil assets, Cuba's been cut off.
No tourists, no fuel.
Their country is grinding to a halt.
They've become desperate.
So there's a lot of questions we have over this breaking story right now about a U.S. speedboat getting shot up by Cuba and what that could mean for the United States.
People need to understand.
Well, Cuba is decently far away from Florida.
It's actually not that far away from Florida.
And there are a lot of people, a lot of Americans who are in Florida, and they do like going and partying in Cuba.
It's not that uncommon.
Perhaps this could be Cuba is at its wit's end and is overreacting or angry or retaliating.
We'll talk about that.
Plus, more information on the cartel violence.
Mexico's considering suing Elon Musk because he said that the president works for the cartels.
He said she has cartel bosses and thought, how dare you say something that most people think is true.
And then, of course, my friends, the results from Trump's State of the Union.
The polls are smashing good for the president.
It's two to one.
And the funny thing is, CNN can't just say viewers liked speech.
I kid you not, despite the fact the CNN poll says 70% of people liked what Trump said, they headline the article.
Trump's speech leaves some viewers questioning blah, blah, blah.
Some.
Yes, because the minority exists.
Absolutely incredible.
So we're going to talk about the aftermath of that.
And then, guys, we got to talk about the Bears.
The Bears, we got to talk about them.
They're leaving Chicago.
And this may be the most catastrophic thing I've ever heard.
I have talked to you about statues being torn down.
I have talked to you about the changing of the name of the Redskins.
And that meant nothing to me.
A little bit.
I was kind of pissed off about it.
But the Chicago Bears, I am from Chicago.
And so this, this is like a nuclear bomb dropped on my childhood.
And I'm declaring war.
I will not stand for the failures of the Democratic Party if Chicago is to lose the Bears.
And apparently they're going to, no matter what.
Pritzker said that we're basically resigned to the Chicago Bears being the Indiana Bears or the Hammond Bears.
Is it a joke?
Do you spit in our faces?
I'm pissed.
We're going to talk about that and more before we do.
We've got a great sponsor for you, my friends.
It is Field of Greens.
You see, I get all riled up hearing about the Bears leaving and I'm ready to just destroy everything.
So, you know what?
I got to calm down and drink this delicious strawberry lemonade, Field of Greens.
It actually is really, really good.
It's like they grind up all these great veggies and they make it taste really good.
You put it in your drink.
My friends, most people don't look forward to their annual physical because they're nervous what the doctor might find.
Me, however, I got great blood pressure.
That's why what you do before the appointment matters.
So before your next checkup, make the one health change your doctor should notice or your money back.
Make it Field of Greens.
Doctors today look beyond your calendar age.
They look at biological age, how healthy our cells and vital organs are.
Field of Greens was designed with that in mind.
Each fruit and vegetable is doctor selected to support your cells, heart, lungs, kidneys, and healthy weight.
In fact, a university study found that participants who only added Field of Greens saw measurable improvements in key health markers.
Just one change changed everything.
That's why Field of Greens promises your doctor will notice your improved health or your money back.
Go into your next physical confident.
One scoop, once a day, done.
Make Field of Greens your one smart change this year.
Check out the university study and get 20% off Field of Greens promo code Tim.
That's Field of Greens promo code Tim.
You know, I just want to say too, I see a lot of people, they got those weird little spritzer bottles of flavor stuff.
They squirt in their water.
That's nasty.
That's like weird artificial sweetener garbage.
This is, it's a bunch of grinded up veggies with delicious flavor.
If you want to flavor your water, make it healthy.
Check it out.
Field of Greens promo code Tim.
Don't forget, my friends, we also got Cast Brew Coffee.
Look at this.
You don't want to miss this one.
Oh, we put the bottle back.
These glass bottles of the Cast Brew Vault Black are incredible.
I am so impressed with the team organizing this.
This is a cold brew concentrate, lightly sweetened, just a little bit, about seven grams per serving.
You put a little bit into a cup, you add some water to it.
Bang, you got a nice, delicious cup of cold brew coffee from Casper.
Check it out at CastBrew.com.
My friends, smash that like button.
Share the show with everyone you know.
Literally, if everybody took the URL, posted it everywhere on the internet right now, we'd have the biggest show in the world, and that would be great.
So if you really do like what we do, please share the show.
Joining us tonight to talk about this and so much more, we got Jake Botch.
jakey botch
What's going on?
tim pool
Who are you, man?
What do you do?
jakey botch
I'm a union guy.
I work for the city, and I just have my opinions on life.
That's pretty much it.
Cuba's Complex History 00:10:08
unidentified
All right.
tim pool
That's good.
It's good to have you, man.
This should be fun and fun.
Absolutely.
jakey botch
I wish they could see what you got going on here.
tim pool
We got skateboards.
We got coffee.
jakey botch
I didn't expect it to be.
tim pool
We got Jews.
jakey botch
Oh, a lot of Jews here.
unidentified
A lot of Jews.
jakey botch
I'm Jewish.
You understand?
unidentified
I know.
tim pool
That's what I'm saying.
unidentified
Two of them.
tim pool
Two of them might be too many, but okay.
jakey botch
It's the massage.
tim pool
Right on, thanks for hanging out, brother.
We got Jay's back.
jay dyer
Jay Dyer, Jay's Analysis, host the Alex Jones show, The Last Six Years, writer for the Sam Hyde Show, YouTuber.
Check out my YouTube channel, Jay Dyer.
I've got four books, three on Hollywood.
Check them out at my website, jaysnels.com.
tim pool
We thought it was unfair that he got mogged by Trump.
So we were like, you got to come back.
jay dyer
I mean, I'm clearly at the same status of Trump, so it's kind of unfair that he would mog me like that.
But it's beautiful.
unidentified
Glad to be back with you.
tim pool
Right on.
Well, the Jews here.
elad eliahu
Good evening, everybody.
My name is Elad Eliyahu.
I'm the White House correspondent here at Timcast.
Looking forward to the show.
Phil, what's going on?
phil labonte
Hello, everybody.
My name is Phil Abante.
I'm the lead singer of the Heavy Metal Band All That Remains.
I'm an anti-communist and counter-revolutionary Carter.
carter banks
What's up, everyone?
Carter Banks here.
Welcome back, Jay, and welcome, Jake.
Let's get into it.
tim pool
Here's a story from the BBC.
Yo, this is absolutely insane.
Four shot dead on U.S. registered speedboat by border guards.
Cuba says.
They say in a statement, Cuba's interior ministry said the speedboat's passengers opened fire on a Coast Guard vessel that approached them, which I don't believe.
That makes no sense.
Six additional passengers were wounded in the incident, which took place near an island on Cuba's northern coast.
Marco Rubio said the nationalities of those on board is unclear.
The U.S. will make, okay, so correction.
We don't know if they're Americans.
U.S. will make determinations based on the facts.
Right now, we're still gathering facts.
He said the boat was not carrying U.S. government personnel.
Cuba's government said it did not know the identities of those on board the vessel, nor what it was doing in the area, and that an investigation has been launched to clarify the event.
In a statement posted X, the ministry said the Florida registered vessel with the registration number FL7726SH was detected near Keo Falconez in the country's central villa, Clara Province, on Wednesday morning.
When a Cuban boat carrying five members of the ministry's border guard approached the vessel for identification, the crew of the violating speedboat opened fire and wounded the Cuban commander.
As a consequence of the confrontation, as of the time of this report, four aggressors on the foreign vessel were killed and six injured.
Those who were injured were evacuated.
Now, the important context here is also this: CNN reporting last week: no food, no fuel, no tourists under U.S. pressure.
Life in Cuba grinds to a halt.
Since we seized back, that's an important thing to understand.
Since we seized back our oil assets from Venezuela that were stolen from us, even though we had a treaty in 2009, okay, this is an important, I'm going to say it again.
We had a bunch of oil investments in Venezuela.
We had a treaty.
We were doing peaceful trade, and the commie government came in and stole all our stuff, and we didn't do anything about it.
That pisses me off.
Since we took it back, Cuba's not getting the free energy from Venezuela they were before.
Now they're in trouble.
So when you hear a story like this, you have to wonder what really happened.
That being said, I will stand corrected.
I thought it was Americans.
We don't know.
I would say there's a decent probability, surprise, surprise, these could be drug runners operating in a U.S. boat.
And when the Cubans approach them, they think, oh, crap, what do we do?
Maybe.
We're not entirely sure.
But the big concern, I think, here is the animosity between Cuba and the United States since the Venezuela operation is bubbling up.
It's getting pretty intense.
So that's why my immediate assumption was a U.S. speedboat was driving around and the Cuban National Guard just killed them.
But we don't know for sure.
This guy, to be honest, if they came back and said, actually, it was a bunch of Venezuelan narco-drug guys on a speedboat selling drugs, I'd be like, well, you know, that's been happening too.
But I'm curious if you guys think this means, let's just, I'll just crank the knob all the way to 11 and rip it off.
U.S. is going to war with Cuba.
phil labonte
I think that Marco Rubio is going to invade him personally.
He's going to be down there on the first boat.
I mean, he's got every other job in the federal government essentially lately.
So I don't see any reason why he wouldn't be leading the charge into Cuba.
tim pool
Everyone just resigns and Rubio just does all of it.
phil labonte
Yeah, he's the only guy.
tim pool
They're gearing up to make him king.
elad eliahu
That would be so based.
Imagine they're going to fire off from Havana next year.
phil labonte
The king of Cuba or the king of the United States?
elad eliahu
King of Cuba.
phil labonte
King of Cuba.
tim pool
You know what I like about Cuba is that it's frozen in time.
You know what I feel like?
If you ever want to go to the 1950s, you go to Cuba.
jakey botch
Is this guy still alive?
Do they even know for sure if he's alive?
tim pool
Which guy?
jakey botch
What's his name?
The guy who runs the joint.
tim pool
Oh, no.
unidentified
Castro.
tim pool
Castro, the first Castro, died a while ago.
jakey botch
So it's his brother now?
tim pool
Yes, Raul, right?
jay dyer
Raul, yeah.
unidentified
Raul.
jakey botch
For sure.
They know for sure that's what's going on.
tim pool
Pretty sure it's still Raul Castro.
Yeah, the younger brother of Fidel.
He's old, man.
Oh, no, no, no, wait, wait, wait.
Hold on.
Is he still doing it?
He is a president.
No, no, he left a while ago.
So who's the current president of Cuba?
See, I don't pay attention to Cuban politics.
It's Miguel Diaz-Carrel.
jakey botch
Oh, wow.
tim pool
Miguel.
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
Yeah, I didn't know that.
jakey botch
I could have sworn it wasn't.
unidentified
Mike.
phil labonte
You go, Mike.
Mike Diaz.
jakey botch
Now, we had assets in Venezuela.
I didn't know that.
Yeah, so pretty like an average American that doesn't have all this information.
tim pool
This is fantastic.
Let me learn you some something here.
elad eliahu
We have a military base on Cuba or a gym rather in Cuba.
tim pool
But he's talking about Venezuela.
jakey botch
He's talking about Venezuela.
I'm definitely not liberal, but what all these people were fighting for, that we just went in there and took their shit and just, you know.
So we had assets there.
phil labonte
Originally ours?
tim pool
Yeah.
Indeed.
So here's the story.
Venezuela is like the most oil-dense.
Actually, it's in the world, right?
jakey botch
Major over there.
tim pool
It might be, I think it's gotten more than Saudi Arabia.
jakey botch
Don't they own Sitco?
unidentified
I don't know.
tim pool
No, they don't own it.
jakey botch
I thought it was American.
Oh, I thought Sitco was Venezuelan.
tim pool
Well, I'm pretty sure it's not.
I don't know.
But here's the story.
U.S. oil companies.
So the U.S. had a treaty with Venezuela for a long time.
Venezuela was one of the most prosperous, it was the most prosperous nation in South America.
And our oil companies went there under our normal trade agreement and said, we're going to invest billions of dollars building oil refineries, bringing in oil tankers.
And then the country voted for socialism.
And again, I'm not being cute or insulting.
It literally they voted for the socialist candidate, Chavez, who then, I think it was 2009, announced the nationalization of all oil assets that were built, paid for, and owned by U.S. interests.
The U.S. government said, I guess they just stole $20 billion worth of our oil infrastructure and did nothing about it.
Then Venezuela started pumping that oil, burning down their economy with weird commie practices like mandating jobs that don't need to exist, and then using that oil to give to our enemies, largely to Cuba, but also they've been trading with China, Russia, Iran, et cetera.
jakey botch
And that's just not public knowledge.
tim pool
It absolutely is.
jakey botch
It's public knowledge if you want to look for it.
unidentified
Yeah.
jakey botch
Guy like me who's working a union job ain't looking for that.
So I just see Instagram, oh, oh, the blueheads, they're really pissed about this Venezuela thing.
You know, like you don't, you don't, you don't get that knowledge unless you come, and that sucks.
tim pool
And then what happens is when you talk to a conservative, they're like, yes, of course, I knew this.
When you talk to a liberal, they're like, Trump's an evil dictator who's stealing stuff.
phil labonte
Media doesn't inform people.
No, you know, media stop.
Like, there's no backstory.
Even with, like, if you watch long form shows like this, you might get it, right?
But if you're just watching, if you're an average person that gets, you know, maybe an hour of news a week when you're making breakfast or throwing.
jakey botch
I don't even get that any drink.
TikTok swipes.
You're just 30 seconds of an hour show.
phil labonte
And so to your point, it is, you know, most people don't realize the history with most of the things that are going on internationally.
And believe me, most of the stuff the U.S. is doing when it comes to foreign policy and stuff, it's not been created in the past six months.
I mean, the whole change of focus from Europe to South America, which I mean, I'm not even sure if you know that's going on.
jakey botch
I have no idea.
phil labonte
So the U.S. used to really be close with or close with Europe.
There's been significant changes in Europe and not only the policies that Europe has, but also the makeup of Europe because of all the immigration from like the Middle East and from North Africa.
And so the U.S. is looking at Europe and they're saying, well, they kind of don't really share our values.
We're going to refocus our interest.
We're going to refocus onto South America and we're going to really kind of enforce the Monroe Doctrine.
I mean, most people don't even know what the Monroe Doctrine is.
jakey botch
I'm looking at a guy who don't know what the Monroe Doctrine is.
phil labonte
James Monroe said that we don't want Europe meddling in the affairs of our hemisphere.
So basically the Western hemisphere, North, South America, the U.S. is like saying, hey, Europe, keep your business in Europe and in Asia and stuff, and we'll keep our business here.
We don't want you influencing countries here.
And so that had kind of gone away for a long time.
But now the U.S. has decided that South American countries actually have more in common with the United States than Europe will likely have in, say, 25, 30 years.
jakey botch
I did kind of hear about that with the hemisphere thing.
jay dyer
Here's a crazy history of the communist stuff down there that a lot of people don't know.
When Che and Fidel were working together, they were actually guarding the oil fields for Standard Oil.
They had a huge battle between them.
They ended up falling out.
And Fidel basically ran Che away because Che seemed to be a committed communist.
But there's a good book by Servando Gonzalez on this.
He argues that the Council on Foreign Relations, because they always favored a synthesis of communism with capitalism, that they actually wanted Fidel to take Cuba, even though there was interest with certain elements of the organized crime that took over, or that opposed Batista when they took over.
So basically, organized crime, the CIA, they wanted resorts in Cuba.
Cuba's Complex Political Landscape 00:15:25
jay dyer
And that's what Godfather 2 is about, if you watch Godfather 2.
phil labonte
Oh, really?
jay dyer
They overthrow Batista and Fidel comes to power.
But the question is, well, if we have a base there, why did that ever happen?
And Gonzalez has a thesis that the Council on Foreign Relations had a bunch of communists amongst their members that actually wanted Cuba to be communist to have an excuse to promote the dialectic down in South America.
jakey botch
Standard Oil is American?
unidentified
Yeah, it's extremely important.
jay dyer
That's Rockefeller, right?
unidentified
Oh, really?
Yeah.
jay dyer
So they guarded the Rockefeller oil even as communist revolutionaries, right?
jakey botch
Wow.
A lot of information on this temple.
tim pool
Yeah, you know, today's political debates are largely, I would describe it as the people who actually know what's going on and the people who have no idea what's going on.
So the Democrats are composed largely of an ignorant voter bloc that believes what they're being told by the Democrat politicians and Democrat politicians that are intentionally lying.
The Trump voter bloc is a mixture of different political ideologies that often disagree quite a bit, but know what's going on in the world.
So you'll get, you know, we call them disaffected liberals, people who used to be Democrats who are now like, y'all have gone crazy.
My favorite part of last night with Donald Trump's State of the Union is when he pointed to the Democrats and said, these people are crazy because they're trying to give children sex changes.
You'd think, you'd think going to somebody and being like, don't you think we can draw the line at giving a child a sex change?
And the response from most of the Democrat voters is, that's not happening because they listen to their politicians who are lying.
One of my favorite things, actually, I fact-checked this this morning.
I'll pull it up for you guys when we get into the CNN, Trump State of the Union address.
But Trump says, like, they want to kidnap your kids.
He said, they want to take your kids from your parents and then transition their genders without the parents' consent.
There's a big piece of news right now where like 16 states are filing a suit saying we can't allow that to happen.
And all of these fact checks get written where they're like, no, Washington did not pass a law saying they can kidnap your kids to give them sex change.
Right.
The law basically just says if a child is a runaway, they can provide shelter and they have to inform the parents of the runaway's whereabouts unless they're seeking gender-affirming care.
So they put one headline saying, no, it's not happening, and then literally three paragraphs down say, yeah, absolutely it is happening.
And so I just got to say, bro, I don't care if you're a communist where you're literally like, we should seize all of the means of production.
We call this the dirtbag left.
They just go, yeah, but the weird thing the Democrats are doing with child sex changes like and the woke stuff, nah, none of that.
If you're like economically far left, socialist, communist, or whatever, but you're not violent and all you do is have, have cordial debates that we're friends.
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
Totally friends.
If you're going around saying you want to give kids sex changes or whatever, then I'm going to be like, you're just a lying psychopath.
unidentified
Evil.
tim pool
Yeah, it's just, it's lunacy.
Absolutely insane.
But I know a lot wants to invade Cuba.
elad eliahu
I was going to say, let's get conspiratorial for a second and have some reckless speculation.
I think one could argue that this may have been an operation to try to do something in Cuba.
I don't see people trying to smuggle drugs from the United States into Cuba.
It wouldn't be very lucrative for the drug dealers.
tim pool
You're saying, to clarify, a U.S. intelligence or some kind of U.S. operation.
Or like maybe take out Miguel.
elad eliahu
Maybe do something similar to what they did in Venezuela while we have a lot of our military assets in Iran and everybody's distracted right now.
Everybody's pitching and moaning about Iran, Iran, this, Iran, that.
No, no, no.
Marco Rubio is pulling the distraction.
You can't go for the wheel.
tim pool
You're saying, okay, hold on.
Just to clarify, you're saying that with Venezuela, we do this pulse blast that knocks out their power and causes their skulls to vibrate.
elad eliahu
Discombobulator.
tim pool
Is that what it was?
elad eliahu
I think so, allegedly.
tim pool
Discombobulators.
And then they go in the middle of the night, drop down in Maduro's compound and kidnap him.
And then phase two is we get a single speedbutt with 10 people on it and charge the shores of Cuba.
elad eliahu
Well, I'm sure they were trying to be inconspicuous and maybe got found out.
And now Orange trying to claim responsibility because there are four dead.
Famously, the Maduro raid had zero dead, so they were very impressed.
And maybe the president was feeling emboldened.
It's regular speculation.
tim pool
They'd go in the middle of the night.
They'd land on Miguel's rooftop and take him.
jakey botch
What do we get from them, though?
Venezuela, you get oil.
unidentified
Oil?
tim pool
Well, Cuba, we have.
jakey botch
1950 Chevy?
What do you get from Cuba?
tim pool
Let me tell you about Cuba.
Are you familiar with the Cuban Missile Crisis, Bay of Pigs?
unidentified
I am.
Yeah, yeah.
tim pool
Right, so the deep concern the U.S. has is 90 miles off the coast of Florida, we've got an adversary.
It's not so much just Russia, but the BRICS nations, Venezuela.
There's an adversarial nation.
It used to be largely Cuba, which was favorable towards us.
We actually have a military base, Guantanamo Bay, on the Cuban island.
Then they became communist and opposed us.
And so you had Russians wanting to put missiles 90 miles off the coast.
Yeah, so we very much want, again, like Monroe Doctrine, stay out of our hemisphere.
jakey botch
Yes, yes.
elad eliahu
Well, I think also geopolitically, Cuba is particularly important because if you look at the map in the Gulf of Mexico, the main exit is having to go north or south of Cuba.
Cuba is a sort of Taiwan equivalent, if you will, of a way of blocking trade and shipments from large parts of the United States.
So part of the reason why China wants to take back Taiwan is to get those critical shipping lanes.
If you look to go through the Gulf of Mexico, you have to pass Cuba.
And it's sort of, you know, an island just directly a threat to the United States.
And then I think the leftovers from the Cuban missile crisis and then also so many refugees, Cuban refugees that left Cuba, came to America, continue to influence our politics right now.
Marco Rubio is famously a descendant of Cuban immigrants.
So yeah, that plays into a lot of this.
He's been famously a hawkish senator from Florida prior to this, where there is a large Cuban population.
That largely influences this thing.
tim pool
I have a question real quick before we go to the next segment a lot.
You know how, like, when we're talking about the Middle East, some people say just turn it to glass.
You know how they say that?
Yeah.
Like, the implication is if you drop a series of nuclear bombs, it will melt and then fuse all of the sand.
What would the equivalent for Cuba be?
Turn it to.
I don't know.
phil labonte
I think a nuclear bomb would probably do the same thing.
tim pool
But there's not sand.
Turn their beaches to glass.
phil labonte
I mean, turn them back into the ocean.
elad eliahu
Turn them back to the glass.
tim pool
See, because like turning it to glass is like, you might not get it.
You go, oh, now I get it.
jay dyer
But if we talk, if we said we're going to turn to a smoldering crater, you'd be like, is the only reason, given the Monero doctrine, though, the only reason that the U.S. never took Cuba from the communists, because like we have Guantanamo Bay there, is it just because of the ramifications of what it would do in other countries?
tim pool
It's because the neocons are weak.
They talk a big game.
They talk.
I mean, seriously.
unidentified
Right.
tim pool
The neocons have consistently talked a big game and failed every step of the way.
phil labonte
Or was it allowed to be?
elad eliahu
It's the neocons vengeance right now.
Marco Rubio.
They took down Venezuela.
Don't tease them.
Right now is a bad time to tease the neocons with what's going on in Iran right now.
tim pool
Regular humans.
jakey botch
What is a neocon?
tim pool
It's neoconservative as a reference to like Bush.
unidentified
Okay.
tim pool
Bush aeropolitics.
elad eliahu
No, but here's what neocon really is.
If you are willing to go to war for anything, then you are a neocon.
In effect, in politics, when you support any conflict anywhere for any reason, you are a neocon.
tim pool
Let me give you the...
elad eliahu
That's how it works in actual politics.
tim pool
Neocon is a tribal reference to a group of people, but there are ideologies that people would then associate with what we would call neoliberal and neoconservative.
It's actually quite simple.
Hillary Clinton is neoliberal.
What does that mean?
She's on the liberal side of American politics, but she wants to, well, no, now.
jakey botch
Well, I feel like if you support that, like my family, my other side of the family is liberal, but not bluehead liberal.
They're like Bill Clinton liberal, like Bill Clinton Democrat.
You know what I mean?
Like, like could have a conversation.
tim pool
Hillary Clinton is in favor.
Well, she actually recently came out against illegal immigration.
jakey botch
But yeah, even if you get votes, though, is she leaning towards this psychotic way?
tim pool
So neoliberal and neoconservative refers to the uniparty establishment force in the United States.
They're very much in favor of invading foreign countries to maintain the liberal economic order, things like that.
So we call Hillary Clinton a crotchety, a crotchety old neoliberal lady.
And neo, it's like, it's a stupid way to describe it because neo, of course, references like a new generation.
And so they were calling Bush neoconservative because they're conservatives, but they want to go and invade.
And so it defined this tribal group.
But then based off of their worldview, we now have this general idea of what these words mean.
So you vote for the Mitt Romneys, the McCains, you get invasion of Iran.
Hey, surprise, surprise, Trump might get us that anyway.
jay dyer
Neoconservative is out of the UK, Bernard Lewis, who is the father of Samuel Huntington, who wrote books that influenced the Bush administration.
So the Bush, Cheney, those are like sort of the arch neocons, but it's actually out of the UK from Bernard Lewis.
And then they are also influenced by Leo Strauss, who was influenced by Hitler.
But they also have an influence.
jakey botch
The guy that made jeans?
jay dyer
Strauss.
unidentified
No.
jakey botch
Levi Strauss.
jay dyer
Leo Strauss.
jakey botch
It's a joke.
It was an hungry joke.
jay dyer
Jeans were made actually, I think, originally for communist purposes.
tim pool
No, no, no.
jay dyer
The suits were actually.
tim pool
Blue jeans was like American.
It was like mining.
jay dyer
Well, they wanted to have a standard for like in a company town, like everybody had the same outfit.
So I'm not saying they make profits.
I'm just saying like a company town, you could say it's Levi Strauss invented blue jeans, and it was in the United States.
tim pool
Denim work pants.
elad eliahu
But it was made by San Francisco.
jay dyer
Company town.
jakey botch
You made everything.
What are you kidding me?
tim pool
You mean in the U.S., it was like company towns?
jay dyer
Like a company town is not really a capitalist institution.
Like they make money, but like you have to buy everything from the company town.
tim pool
Well, I disagree with that.
I mean, if there's a barren wasteland and a company is like, we need to import a bunch of people and there's no industry here, then they have to create means by which people can choose to buy food.
jay dyer
But it's not classical libertarian free market if everybody has to shop at the company town.
It might be the.
tim pool
But again, the point is, if no town exists and they build it, they're sure it's like a commissary.
jay dyer
There's other options, right?
tim pool
So I wouldn't call it communist.
Well, it's called monopolistic.
jay dyer
Okay, but I mean, if you're a libertarian, monopolistic capitalism isn't classical libertarianism.
Also.
tim pool
Again, so like if I personally have a private piece of land and I hire a bunch of people and they're like, hey, there's no restaurants anywhere.
What do we eat?
And I go, all right, I guess I'll have the crew come and open up a restaurant, but you got to pay for the food.
Is that communism?
jay dyer
It's, I mean, again, monopoly capitalism isn't really.
tim pool
Hold on, this is not, this is, this is not an issue of there's no competition.
Like, it's an issue.
unidentified
It is.
jay dyer
There is no competition.
tim pool
No, no, no.
I mean, it's an issue of there's no competition, not forcing people to do anything.
So is the alternative I just go, you know what, guys?
I'm going to open a restaurant where only I get to eat.
You're actually not allowed to eat it because I don't want to be a communist.
unidentified
Right.
jay dyer
But this is the same argument as to why people would own an entire water supply.
unidentified
Right.
jay dyer
So if you privatize water, then no one has a right to the water.
tim pool
But I'm not talking about that.
jay dyer
I'm saying there's a company town could own the water.
tim pool
Indeed.
What right do you have to take it?
That's communist.
jay dyer
It's not communist to have public municipalities.
tim pool
Wait, what?
jay dyer
It's not.
tim pool
I own a swath of land and I invite you to come work on it.
I have to now relinquish my right to the water body and my property.
jay dyer
No, I'm saying if you're going to create a society or civilization and you have, if you own the entirety of company towns.
tim pool
We're talking about a company town.
jay dyer
Well, that's the beginning of a civilization, right?
It's no different.
unidentified
Right.
tim pool
So the point you bring up is that if I own, let's say, 100 acres and I have a grain mill on it, and then I can't produce that much.
So a handful of people are like, howdy good, sir.
We could increase the output of the grain if you give us, if you let us come.
And I say, all right, you know what?
I'm going to actually, I'll pay you guys a share of the grain that you mill.
Thank you for voluntarily coming and offering this service.
They then say, there's nowhere to eat for miles.
And I go, well, unfortunately, if I were to create something by which you could purchase food, that would be communism.
So no.
jay dyer
It's not communism.
tim pool
So then if I, as the landowner and the company owner, then say, I will open a restaurant on the property from which you can purchase goods, that's the beginning of communism.
jay dyer
So, but you're describing a situation of a small microcosm where there's no competition.
tim pool
Like a company town.
jay dyer
Right, where there's no competition.
Doesn't capitalism require competition?
tim pool
And who's stopping people from opening a restaurant across the street?
jay dyer
Well, you would if you have a company town.
No, If I own property and- You said monopoly capitalism, you would be then stopping the competition in a monopoly capitalist situation.
tim pool
No, no, no, no.
We're talking about a company town, right?
Privately owned property.
So do they have to relinquish their water rights?
jay dyer
If the city, if it grows to a certain size where you begin to have competition, that's literally communism.
No, it's not.
tim pool
Seizing the assets from the private landowners.
No, literally going to a guy who owned land and says, there's too many people here now, so your water is ours.
That's competition.
phil labonte
No, no.
jay dyer
If you grow to where you have a society that requires competition, then the people can seize your assets.
tim pool
Agreed.
We're communists.
jay dyer
If there's competition.
But first of all, by the way, Marx was a libertarian.
So it begets really.
tim pool
What I'm talking about.
I don't care about Marx.
elad eliahu
Marx was a liberal.
jay dyer
Well, you're accusing me of communism.
tim pool
Then that's not accusing you.
I'm arguing if your argument is private land ownership is void upon excess population.
That's literally a function of communism.
That's what the Venezuelans did.
jay dyer
What you're describing is literally just communism itself.
A company town is essentially the same as a communist setup.
tim pool
It is not.
jay dyer
It is identical.
tim pool
It's completely.
unidentified
Absolutely.
I don't know.
tim pool
So the people own the land in a company town?
In a company town.
The people have in it.
If we're talking about the structures of communism by which there is a private committee, and there's two ways we can look at it, your argument seems to fuse together both the authoritarian dictatorship components and the economic – That's monopoly capitalism.
jay dyer
That's where you're arguing.
tim pool
If the argument is people can voluntarily choose to come and work for a company, but there is no competition because there's no market reason for it.
It's not communism.
It's just a monopoly, but there's no oppression and it doesn't matter because you can always choose to leave.
jay dyer
You can always choose to leave if you're out in the middle of nowhere.
tim pool
Why did you go there?
jay dyer
In the West.
tim pool
Again, bro, I got to tell you, if the argument is I have no choice in my circumstances, therefore I should get public rights, it's literally this guy's a communist.
So then leave, right?
Why can't you leave?
jay dyer
Well, you can say that, but in a company town, especially like in situations when in the 1800s company towns were being set up, you didn't have the ability to just leave, right?
tim pool
Why not?
Well, but they're holding you at gunpoint.
jay dyer
I mean, well, if you're under a contract, you might have to be there.
tim pool
Why did you sign the contract?
Grounding Moral Structures 00:14:52
jay dyer
Well, again.
tim pool
Is it communism to voluntarily enter into an agreement with a company?
jay dyer
Yeah, but you can call it voluntary.
Even there's situations where something can be voluntary that you're actually locked into, right?
I mean, I can.
tim pool
You chose to enter into a contract.
jay dyer
If Amazon owns an entire area and it's the only place to work, then to say, well, you can move and you can.
But it's, yeah, but it's still a form of wage slavery, right?
You don't think there's such a thing as I think that's commie talk.
tim pool
Well, I think this is quite literally the arguments of Chavez and the arguments of Bernie Sanders.
And my point that I often bring up to these leftists is, what's stopping you from just being a vagrant on federal land?
jay dyer
There's no difference.
tim pool
You want from my system without input.
And that is the component of the left that I disagree with.
jay dyer
No, your argument is a leftist argument, actually.
tim pool
That people should have to work.
jay dyer
Classical liberalism is a leftist position.
You argue classical liberalism.
That's a classical position.
tim pool
What I'm arguing.
What I'm arguing for merit-based capitalism is leftist.
unidentified
Yes.
jay dyer
Classical liberalism out of the Enlightenment.
tim pool
That is incorrect.
unidentified
No.
jay dyer
Out of the Enlightenment.
tim pool
The origin of the left is the left aisle in the French Revolution referring to those who wanted a socialist, anti-monarchist, and the right wanted a top-down monarchist system.
Okay.
So your argument.
jay dyer
Not in the French Revolution.
No.
tim pool
It was the French Revolution.
It was the left and the right.
jay dyer
The French Revolution wanted a constitutional monarchy on the right, and they wanted private property on the right.
The leftist wanted communism.
unidentified
Indeed.
tim pool
So when we say left and right in an economic sense, it refers to left meaning communal, right, meaning closer to laissez-faire.
jay dyer
That's classical liberalism, which is against the traditional position of church and state.
phil labonte
And this is the state.
This is the argument that Carl makes about liberalism now.
tim pool
What's the argument?
phil labonte
I'm only saying that they're similar.
That liberalism is actually a creation of the left and that the ultimate form.
tim pool
I am not advocating for, in this circumstance, classical liberalism.
I'm advocating for private rights.
unidentified
Yeah, yeah.
phil labonte
But the point that I'm making is his perspective is similar to Carl's perspective, you make it.
tim pool
Sure, but that's immaterial to the argument being made.
jay dyer
It's not because you're saying that you're a socialist, you're a Marxist, but what I'm arguing would be the same as any medieval village philosophy.
And they weren't Marxists or socialists back in the Middle Ages.
Like you went to the French village.
tim pool
Okay, again, the core of your argument is there's a private landowner.
20 years later, there's now 300 people working in this land.
We now transfer the private rights from the landowner to a communal function.
jay dyer
Again, it's complex when you have something like the total ownership of something like a water supply, right?
So when you have people that need that, that's different than a situation where Nestle's trying to buy an entire country's private water supply.
tim pool
So again, the issue was company towns.
I have 100 acres.
I own the body of water on that land.
I invite a bunch of people to work.
They say, I'll work here.
I need a place to stay.
I say, I'll bid you a house.
They say, where do I get food?
I'll build a store.
And they say, we need water.
I say, I'll set up a water pump for you.
That's communism.
jay dyer
Well, let's go to the rights then because you're arguing that you have this right as a company owner.
And I would agree, but on what basis do you have those rights?
Because classical liberalism lost this whole argument, but it came out.
tim pool
I don't know why you're bringing up classical liberalism.
It's not a problem.
jay dyer
That's your position.
tim pool
No, it isn't your ethical.
jay dyer
You're not aware of that, but it is your position.
tim pool
No, you're throwing a blanket to encompass one point and combine it with a bunch of other points you're going to be doing.
jay dyer
Because your arguments come out of that ethos, whether you know it or not, they're classical liberalism.
tim pool
And you can have varying ideologies mix and match.
Let's make an argument on what I actually think.
jay dyer
That's the basis for the rights.
tim pool
The basis for the right to own private property.
jay dyer
Well, now your ethos.
tim pool
So I argue that the rights of man are derived from the will or the duties God bestows upon man.
The requirements that we have from God, which is be fruitful and multiply, require a handful of things for which we recognize in the United States that we allow other people to do.
Fully recognizing that other groups have different ideas of what rights are.
So I would argue rights are we need to be able to communicate, we need to be able to protect ourselves, and we need to be secure in our possessions.
These are principal rights that we struggle to survive without.
As the basis of this is look at communism in general in the Soviet Union.
And when you don't have property rights, congratulations, look what happens.
When you have mass monopolization and oligopoly, you get something similar.
So in a simple sense, certainly it is my moral worldview and faith-based structures that define what I think someone has an inherent claim to.
Progressives think you have an inherent claim to someone else's labor, which would just, I would describe as slavery.
So when it comes to the idea of private land ownership, the argument is fully understanding population expansion can come to a point where some people will never own land.
But the idea is I need to be secure in my possessions to know and prepare for harsh winters, for instability, so that I can survive, so that I can be fruitful, and that I can multiply.
jay dyer
So you appeal to Genesis and God.
What God?
What principles of Genesis tell you that?
tim pool
What are you talking about?
I'm not a Christian.
jay dyer
Then how are you going to base this argument for rights in God?
tim pool
What do you mean?
jay dyer
What God?
tim pool
My God, my moral worldview.
jay dyer
So it's not a universal principle.
It's just subjective.
tim pool
Well, I think to a lot of people, they have a moral worldview and a philosophical understanding of some things and not others.
And I base mine largely on, first, I would argue that perhaps there are greater moral philosophies than the Christian moral structures.
We just don't know them yet.
I would say historically, based upon what we have seen throughout the world and what we think we know, the Christian moral worldview has been dramatically superior to other moral structures.
That being said, I am not a Christian and I don't believe in the faith structures they have.
However, I have recognized that the moral structures of a Christian society tend to make life more successful for individuals, which is ultimately beneficial to the standard function of life, which is organizing complex, organizing free energy into complex systems.
jay dyer
So just utilitarianism, because it works well.
That was utilitarian.
tim pool
You're wrong.
jay dyer
That's utilitarianism.
unidentified
No.
tim pool
Jay, if you don't have an argument for what I said, stop trying to blanket it with something else as a straw man.
jay dyer
Argument was utilitarianism.
You didn't make it.
tim pool
It's literally not.
unidentified
I did.
tim pool
We can talk about.
jay dyer
Why is it not utilitarian?
tim pool
Well, we can talk about deontological ethos.
We can talk about.
jay dyer
It has nothing to do with.
tim pool
No, indeed.
My point is.
jay dyer
Enlightenment.
tim pool
Instead of arguing what I said, you're going, you're arguing thing.
I'm like, well, I gave you a specific outline.
jay dyer
So I'm giving you the problem with utilitarianism.
I'm sorry that you're not aware of the problems with that.
tim pool
I'm sorry that you can't actually address what I told you.
jay dyer
I'm addressing it now, which is that utilitarian arguments are pragmatic and it's not a justification.
unidentified
Great.
tim pool
I'm not a utilitarian.
jay dyer
But you made a utilitarian argument.
tim pool
A component of some, perhaps.
So I don't believe in utilitarianism because that would sacrifice individuals.
Again, do you know what deontological moral ethos is?
jay dyer
Yeah, it's complex.
tim pool
Okay, great.
So when you say something like you're utilitarian, and then I bring up, we do not take immoral actions against an individual for the betterment of the.
I know.
jay dyer
So why are you bringing up Kant?
tim pool
You are making an argument.
The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few, which I did not say.
jay dyer
You can have different types of utilitarianism.
You have to have that.
tim pool
Instead of arguing the point that I made.
jay dyer
You have a pragmatic point.
You argued a pragmatic point.
tim pool
Argue the point I made.
Stop trying to blanket into other.
jay dyer
How does pragmatism justify the rights?
That's what you argued.
unidentified
Okay.
tim pool
I made an argument about private land ownership as a benefit to human survival.
unidentified
Right.
jay dyer
Pragmatic.
unidentified
Okay.
tim pool
So address what I said.
jay dyer
How does appealing to the power of the system?
tim pool
I made a point.
You make yours addressing what I said.
jay dyer
Yeah, that's not a justification.
It's a bad argument.
tim pool
Explain why.
jay dyer
Because appealing to things that work or pragmatism isn't a justification.
tim pool
Explain why I'm wrong about the requirement of private land ownership for survival.
jay dyer
You grounded the right in utilitarianism and pragmatism, and I'm saying that's not a good justification.
It's a bad argument.
tim pool
So explain it.
jay dyer
Because anything that works could be all over the place.
That could be subjective.
tim pool
Indeed.
That was my point in which I said there are probable moral structures that work better we have not discovered yet.
jay dyer
Then it's not a justification.
So you don't know.
So if it's a future thing that you haven't figured out yet, then you don't know right now that it would be a justification.
tim pool
I understand certain principles of gravity and the speed at which things fall, but we don't know for sure how the structures work.
jay dyer
And it wouldn't.
tim pool
We operate based on probabilities.
unidentified
Right.
jay dyer
But then that would not work to justify the rights as grounded in an unknown.
tim pool
Then go jump off a building and see how it works for you.
jay dyer
You told me I have to, so I have to.
tim pool
Go jump off a building and see how it works because you don't know gravity.
It's a future thing you haven't figured out yet.
We operate on probabilities based on what we think we know because we actually don't know.
jay dyer
But that doesn't ground a right.
That's the point.
In future probabilities?
I asked you for the grounding for the right to private property.
tim pool
So far, human history has proven private land ownership is beneficial to human existence.
jay dyer
That's a circular argument.
I'm asking how you know that it benefits and what does it mean to benefit?
And you're saying because it was good.
tim pool
It makes more of it.
jay dyer
That's a circular argument.
unidentified
Why?
jay dyer
Well, why maybe making more of it's bad?
tim pool
It's certainly not.
jay dyer
Okay, but why not?
That's the point.
That's why it's a circle.
tim pool
Well, let's go back to the origin of what we think we know.
Again, because everything we think, everything is rooted in what we think we know, right?
Some people think the earth is flat.
They're probably wrong.
But honestly, I've not done the experiments myself to a great degree.
I've just been in a plane.
So if we go back to, again, the roots of science, we can take a look at a few things.
Free energy tends to coalesce into complex systems, starting with the baser elements, or we can say quirks, I'm sorry, quarks into particles, into atoms, into elements, into compounds.
At some point, for some reason, you get gravity, likely because if you're familiar with our current understanding of gravity, mass creates attraction, et cetera.
And this results in certain masses coming together.
Eventually, you'll get something like a gas giant.
You'll get something that compresses, then ignites fusion, and you get a sun.
We get all this stuff.
Then you get an earth.
Earth is the result of certain things slamming together, creating a bunch of complex elements through process of fusion, et cetera.
And then at some point on Earth, for some reason, again, we don't really know for sure, these molecules and compounds start forming self-replicating proteins.
Again, in modern science, the one thing we recognize is that there is greater entropy and limited entropy, negative entropy, can only exist in a slightly greater entropic system.
But we do see free energy organizing into complex systems throughout the earth and in the universe.
That's what we monitor.
Eventually, these complex systems ultimately become multi-the-cellular organisms, single cells, and multicellular organisms, by which they then create complex organism systems.
They create ecosystems.
Now you've got a squirrel planting a nut growing a tree.
The tree then drops the food for the squirrel.
And now you've got two distinct life forms that form a complex system within its own free energy.
And then we get to the craziest part with humanity in the creation of abstract complex systems.
That is, humans give names to things that don't exist anywhere in reality except in the energy transference between the mind and the vibrations between their mouths.
So what we then see is the function of life is negative entropy within a larger entropic system.
If we, as life, which are driven to reproduce and are, and we typically associate all of those things with being good and enjoyable, like having kids, having Christmas morning, then we track, based on what we have seen throughout the earth, what is the most beneficial to that?
There are a few answers for this.
Islam could be one of them.
They've certainly been massively successful, have lots of kids.
We can take a look at Africa and say, certainly, that is beneficial.
However, I would make the argument that the European cultures that developed science, space travel, cures for diseases, and then effectively colonized the whole planet, as well as the Asian cultures, have proven greatly that these moral worldviews lend themselves greater to the ectropic system within the entropy.
And then we would say, well, it's maybe a toss-up, but I do think that the American Judeo-Christian or just Christian moral values, which include things like private property, have lended itself to the formation of complex systems.
That is, life expansion and all the things that we cherish in the world.
And thus, those are the things we aim for.
Certainly, these things are very subjective, and some people believe other things.
Some people might think it's better to watch the whole world burn because humans are a virus that spread like a plague.
I don't believe that, but I do recognize I can't convince other people, nor do I know everything.
So, in the end, I ultimately conclude: if we want people to have families and have kids, private land ownership is probably the best thing we can do.
jay dyer
That's a good story, but it doesn't get to grounding or justification for why the right is actually something that is grounded in God.
So, storytelling is one thing.
tim pool
Yeah, right.
It's grounded in God because God commands us to be fruitful and multiply.
jay dyer
And the but you don't accept that revelation, so it's just a dispute.
tim pool
I do appeal to.
jay dyer
Well, you said you're not a Christian.
tim pool
Indeed, just because you're not a Christian, you can't believe some things Christians believe.
jay dyer
Well, but I mean, you could do that, but it's not a consistent position, is all I'm saying.
tim pool
It's a consistent position to believe that humans should be fruitful and multiply.
I didn't argue that I believe Jesus died on the cross.
jay dyer
But to pick and choose elements of the worldview as a grounding for rights and private property is what you're saying.
tim pool
Is something that everyone will do?
jay dyer
But that's another fallacy.
tim pool
The fact that people do it, I don't have to confine myself to one of someone else's books.
jay dyer
These are fallacies.
The fact that people do things doesn't have anything to do with whether that's correct or whether that's right.
tim pool
I agree.
jay dyer
Then you're admitting it's a fallacy.
tim pool
No, you're arguing that if I believe one thing from Christianity, I have to believe everything.
jay dyer
No, again, it was an argument about grounding the idea of private property.
So maybe you're not familiar with what grounding is.
That just means giving an epistemic justification for why that's the case.
Good reasons.
tim pool
And so, what's yours?
jay dyer
Well, I believe the Christian worldview, and I would defend that.
tim pool
And now explain it.
jay dyer
But it's coherent.
It's consistent.
unidentified
Right.
How?
jay dyer
Well, if you don't have that worldview, you are immediately caught in a bunch of contradictions.
tim pool
Like what?
jay dyer
Like picking and choosing.
tim pool
Like what?
jay dyer
Like picking and choosing.
Well, I'll believe this thing and then I won't believe this thing.
That wouldn't be consistent.
tim pool
What things are contradictory?
What are you talking about?
jay dyer
Well, to say that we do it because it works is a contradiction.
tim pool
Why?
jay dyer
Because it's a fallacy.
Works to do what?
tim pool
Explain your idea.
jay dyer
I explained the fallacy right there.
tim pool
That's a fallacy.
Coherent Contradictions 00:15:13
jay dyer
Explaining it?
tim pool
I don't have to.
It is.
You've contradicted yourself.
jay dyer
How?
tim pool
Because that was a contradiction.
It's paradoxical.
Well, you said one thing was and one thing wasn't, so you're wrong.
I'm not going to elaborate.
jay dyer
I mean, I have been elaborating.
So if you're characterizing my position as not elaborating, I've been very explicit.
tim pool
So what makes the Christian moral worldview on private land ownership?
jay dyer
Well, we're made in God's image, so we have the Ten Commandments.
It has a position where you can't steal.
So that's a basis for private property right there.
But I can't just pick and choose.
tim pool
You can't explain it.
jay dyer
What do you mean by explaining?
tim pool
Like, is your answer just God said?
jay dyer
No, the answer is that your worldview is inconsistent and contradicts.
That's a transcendental argument.
That's the argument.
tim pool
What is inconsistent about my worldview?
jay dyer
You gave no justification for why rights are a thing.
You just said because you literally did.
That's not a justification.
It's a fallacy.
tim pool
That I explain the function of existence.
jay dyer
That's not a good argument.
Explaining functions.
tim pool
That's not an argument at all.
jay dyer
Explaining functions.
That's a good idea to justification.
tim pool
That's a bad argument.
jay dyer
So you're just saying things.
tim pool
Well, you're just saying things to me.
jay dyer
I'm explaining to you how it would work in a college class if you took an epistemology class.
You would be getting the same critique.
tim pool
Is your argument God wills it?
unidentified
No.
tim pool
Then what is.
jay dyer
The argument is that the worldview as a whole is coherent and gives a justification and a grounding for the ethics for these things.
tim pool
And why explain the coherence of it?
jay dyer
Well, if the world is made by God, if we have ethics being made in the image of God based on the Ten Commandments, these kinds of things, then it makes sense why things are wrong and right.
tim pool
Are there other religions?
jay dyer
Of course.
tim pool
Do they think you are wrong?
jay dyer
That's a fallacy.
It doesn't matter.
tim pool
So why wouldn't you?
jay dyer
Are there people that don't believe 202 is four?
tim pool
Yeah, sure, sure.
My point is.
jay dyer
Because it doesn't have anything to do with any.
Does that have anything to do with it?
tim pool
Let's try this before we actually go to the next segment.
If your argument is I am right and other worldviews are just wrong and don't matter.
jay dyer
That's not what I argue.
I argue they're contradictory.
tim pool
Okay.
I argue yours is contradictory and you're.
jay dyer
Well, that's not an argument.
tim pool
It is.
jay dyer
I gave you arguments.
tim pool
The argument you gave to me.
jay dyer
I showed your contradiction because you said you said that it's true because it works.
tim pool
I didn't say it was true.
jay dyer
You said that that's why you believe it.
tim pool
That was the fact that based on what we think we know right now, and there may be better structures we discover in the future, this seems to be the best course of action for promoting human existence.
unidentified
It works.
jay dyer
That's an it works argument.
tim pool
I think that's an oversimplification of we act upon probabilities to do the best we can.
jay dyer
But again, none of those things work to ground why private property should be something that everybody should accept.
tim pool
I think my argument is it helps people survive better than any system we have.
jay dyer
So it works.
That's a pragmatic argument, and that doesn't work to justify or ground the position.
tim pool
It certainly does.
unidentified
No.
jay dyer
Not in episode 10.
tim pool
Why should we use a fire hose to put out fires?
jay dyer
You keep thinking that working means that it's a justification.
That's not what grounding is even asking for.
It's a different type of question.
tim pool
I understand, but you are not actually making any point at all other than God wills it.
jay dyer
That was not the argument.
The argument was that the whole worldview.
tim pool
Your argument is I have a Christian worldview that is.
jay dyer
It's a transcendental argument for the whole worldview.
tim pool
And I have that same exact thing.
jay dyer
No, you didn't argue that at all.
unidentified
I do.
jay dyer
You argued utilitarianism and pragmatism.
tim pool
I argued that the structure of life is organizing free energy into complex systems.
jay dyer
But that doesn't tell me what I ought to do.
That just says what is.
tim pool
It indeed tells you what you ought to do.
phil labonte
Why?
jay dyer
How is that universal?
tim pool
You are to be fruitful and multiply.
jay dyer
Is that universal?
tim pool
Indeed.
unidentified
How?
tim pool
That life procreates and creates more life?
jay dyer
Well, that's a universal claim, but you said that it's subjective to you.
tim pool
Well, no, I recognize that other people believe other things.
jay dyer
That's not what universal means.
tim pool
just means is it binding everywhere at all times you said it was subjective to me and i said you said that I said, no, I recognize other people believe other things.
jay dyer
That's not what universal means.
tim pool
Other people could perceive that as subjective.
jay dyer
Universal means it applies at all times, at all places, to all people.
They ought to do this.
tim pool
They should ought to do this.
jay dyer
Okay, what is the basis for the ought in your position?
tim pool
The basis for why people should have children.
jay dyer
And have private property or whatever.
tim pool
God wills it.
jay dyer
But you don't believe in God in any specific way.
So how does that have anything?
tim pool
I literally do believe in God.
jay dyer
But you said it's not the Christian God.
It's just parts of Genesis.
tim pool
Correct.
I don't believe in Christian God.
jay dyer
So what's the principle of this God?
tim pool
The principle of God is largely a Christian God.
jay dyer
So you do, but don't.
I don't get it.
tim pool
Do you have the ability to understand that there are different faith structures?
jay dyer
Yeah.
tim pool
By all means, you're allowed to say my religion is wrong.
jay dyer
But it has to be coherent.
tim pool
To argue that I don't have a religion, certainly my religion is consistent.
jay dyer
Okay.
What is the basis for when you know when to pick from what text and which ones to reject?
tim pool
I'd ask the same question of you.
jay dyer
Well, that's a two-quote.
That's a fallacy.
tim pool
To ask you to define so you can explain.
jay dyer
Ask me the question I just asked you is a fallacy in the bay.
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
Can you do it or no?
unidentified
Yeah.
jay dyer
I don't pick and choose, so I don't have that problem.
I accept the totality of the Christian paradigm.
So for me, it's not a problem to pick and choose.
Orthodox.
tim pool
So are there things in the Bible that you do not adhere to?
jay dyer
No.
tim pool
Explain to me, like, there's modernization, correct?
jay dyer
Of what?
tim pool
Of the Christian, I don't know.
I guess moral structure is what you're supposed to do, what you're not supposed to do.
Like, talk to me about Leviticus.
jay dyer
What about it?
It's a typology.
tim pool
Do you follow it?
Are there things to be followed?
jay dyer
Yeah, there's principles in Leviticus, sure.
Jesus references those.
tim pool
Is it okay to not follow some of them?
Is it okay to follow some of them?
jay dyer
Well, Jesus, being the one that gave Leviticus as the law would have the ability to decide how it's interpreted.
So, yes.
tim pool
Are there things in the Bible that you are supposed to do that you don't?
jay dyer
There are temporary ceremonial commands that are fulfilled.
So you're talking about like sacrificing animals, sure.
tim pool
Sometimes you do, sometimes you don't.
jay dyer
If the principle is that Jesus gave the law and he says how it's exercised and fulfilled, that's not inconsistent.
tim pool
What I don't understand is there are Christians that don't eat meat on Fridays.
jay dyer
That's just a fasting position that Catholics do.
tim pool
Yeah.
Is that right or wrong?
jay dyer
But what does it have to do with Leviticus?
tim pool
I'm now moving forward and asking you about a specific thing I don't understand, that there are Catholics.
They don't eat meat on Fridays.
Is that not cool?
So again, I think you don't view Catholics as coherent.
jay dyer
Right.
tim pool
That is, we'll end the argument there.
You view your religious structure as the coherent structure and other structures are incoherent.
Okay.
I disagree, and we are allowed to disagree that we have two different moral religious worldviews, and that is the inherent disagreement.
So in my moral worldview, I believe there is a basis in private ownership because if you are to fulfill God's will of having children, having families, you need a way to control your resources so that you can do that without it being taken from you.
I actually think we agree on that point.
jakey botch
I do.
tim pool
Yeah.
So I don't know why you were arguing when we had completely agreed on that other than to say I'm not a Christian.
jay dyer
Because it's not just a question of having the right position, but what are the good reasons for no, it's not.
That's what epistemology is.
tim pool
Let's go talk about Trump State of the Union and CNN.
And it was fun debating, though.
I appreciate it.
jakey botch
Did you know what started at all?
unidentified
What?
jay dyer
Yuba.
jakey botch
Believe by Strauss' comments.
Believe by Strauss' comment.
tim pool
Company towns, communism, and I'm sure it'll be an entertaining clip for so many people.
But let's talk about Trump's State of the Union because there was one really great point from it.
And check out this headline from CNN.
Boy, oh boy, Trump's State of the Union left some viewers unconvinced that'll lower the cost of living CNN poll fines.
unidentified
Wow.
tim pool
I saw that headline and I was like, geez, it must have been a pretty awful State of the Union address, guys.
As it turns out, instead of headlining the article with Trump's State of the Union viewed positively by masses, which is actually what they concluded, they tried to still make it negative.
Some viewers are unconvinced.
How many are some viewers?
38%.
Indeed, my friends, the polls show 63% of people polled by CNN viewed Trump's State of the Union positively.
Yet, of course, and this is for you, Jake, when you're talking about how regular people don't know this stuff, when you read a headline that says some people are unconvinced by Trump, according to our poll, the immediate assumption most people make is, wow, Trump must not have done a good job.
When in actuality, the poll is Trump won two to one.
This is the world that we live in.
I thought it was a tremendous State of the Union address.
And I think it's more than that.
We actually have this.
Check this out from CNN themselves.
david chalian
The polling universe here is about 13 points more Republican than the overall population usually is.
So just keep all that in mind as we go to the results of our instant poll.
Get this reaction from those that watched the speech tonight.
38% said they had a very positive reaction to the speech.
25% somewhat positive.
36% negative.
So roughly two-thirds in the positive territory.
One-third negative among speech watchers.
The poll.
tim pool
Indeed, my friends.
So what are we going to do, you guys?
phil labonte
I mean, look, it's worth noting that CNN did the poll, and CNN viewers came back two to one saying that it was positive.
I imagine if you get a broader, a more broad.
tim pool
I don't know.
I think the argument CNN's making is that their viewers are heavily Republican audience.
phil labonte
I don't buy that.
elad eliahu
I think he said of the people who watched two, 13-some odd percent leaned Republicans.
So the people viewing would be skewed.
phil labonte
Yeah, but it does make sense that pollsters wait for these things.
tim pool
The pollster would intentionally say, well, you want 10 Democrats, 10 independents, and 10 Republicans.
They wouldn't just be like, literally anybody, tell me what you thought.
That's not doing a poll.
I guess if the argument is Democrats don't care about the State of the Union address and tuned out, that would be a great point for them to make.
elad eliahu
Totally.
Look, I do think it was, he did put on a good performance.
Trump, always the showman, did a really good job, I think, creating a lot of images for Republicans in the midterm with the constant like applaud and then the Democrats not applauding and the contrast between the two, especially when they're bringing up things for like obviously bringing in the Olympians too.
But when they referenced Ina, the woman who got stabbed to death on public transit in Charlotte, and then the Democrats didn't stand up, I think that made for a poll image.
So stuff like that.
But otherwise, I mean, the State of the Union, I don't think most people tune in.
I think after the first 10 minutes, 50% of the people who are watching generally tune out.
I think you really know what the president's going to say.
Nonetheless, it was a good speech.
I was unimpressed.
I think Republicans are obviously going to cheer this on because it's the president.
And if it was Joe Biden or whatnot, they would say.
jakey botch
Why is that?
tim pool
This.
This photo.
You see that photo?
unidentified
Yes.
tim pool
What do you think about that photo?
jakey botch
I see gold medals, baby.
unidentified
That's all I see.
tim pool
You don't see anything else?
jakey botch
A guy with a mask on.
tim pool
A guy with a mask on who's all pissed off.
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
And this is why, you know, after this speech, you know, Donald Trump says at the speech, he goes, stand up if you agree that the duty of, what do you say, of government is to protect the American citizens, not illegal immigrants.
And the Democrats did.
jakey botch
They didn't stand up.
unidentified
No.
jakey botch
That's wild.
tim pool
Yeah.
jakey botch
I mean, but is it a spiteful thing?
Is it, well, screw you, Trump.
I don't want to stand with you.
Or do you really not believe that?
tim pool
I think they don't believe it.
And I think there's an easy way to put it.
Like, let's say you live in a house and you got two roommates.
unidentified
Okay.
tim pool
And you guys are buddies since grade school.
You all love going bowling together.
You all completely agree on everything.
And then one day a guy comes into your house and he's like, I got nowhere to sleep.
I'm sleeping on your couch.
And you guys go, well, I don't know.
I guess it's okay.
Now all of a sudden, this guy votes too.
So when you guys are like, what's for dinner?
This guy in the capital.
You guys are like, pizza night.
He goes, no, no, no, I want to do chicken.
And you guys go, sorry, bro, it's pizza night.
And so then a week later, his buddy comes in and you guys are like, well, I guess it's fine.
Now there's two guys on the couch.
And one day you go, all right, pizza night.
And one of your friends goes, I actually don't mind chicken.
And now pizza night's gone.
And then third guy shows up and the two guys say, I vote we let him stay.
And one of your buddies goes, I think it's fine.
Now it's three versus three.
And one guy's leaning towards them.
Now everything you built, everything you paid for is being voted away.
And that's what this is.
So when you take a look at like Zorhan Mamdani, when you take a look at Chicago, Chicago's losing the Bears, okay?
And I'll tell you why it's losing the Bears, because Chicago is a city of people who never cared for what the Bears were or are.
And I left because of the corruption.
But let me put it like this.
If 100% of the people are like, the Bears, the Bears are going to get all the funding in the world.
Everyone's going to do it.
So when they say won a new stadium, everyone screams and cheers and says, we're getting a new stadium for the Bears.
Over 30 or 40 years, you bring in a bunch of migrants from other countries who don't watch football.
And then what happens?
Now it's 60-40.
You say, we want to vote to give a billion dollars to the Bears for a stadium.
And 40% says no.
And only 30% show up in the pro-Bear side to even vote.
And now all of a sudden, the Bears are going to Indiana.
You can tell I'm pissed off about it.
jakey botch
The Indiana Bears.
tim pool
The Indiana Bears.
jakey botch
You really think they're going to leave?
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
It's a fact.
It's confirmed.
It's confirmed.
jakey botch
That's crazy.
They're at Chicago's pride.
unidentified
Chicago's.
tim pool
They got guaranteed rate field with the White Sox.
jakey botch
They got Mike Ditka and the Bears.
unidentified
I know.
jakey botch
And they're going to just lose that.
tim pool
Indeed.
It's over.
jakey botch
Because of immigrants.
jay dyer
Are you telling us?
tim pool
Well, I wouldn't say only immigrants.
jakey botch
They have a big part of it, though.
tim pool
It is, but it's cultural degradation.
Like, again, this photo.
You got these guys wearing USA sweaters and gold medals who just beat Canada.
jakey botch
Why is he miserable this way?
tim pool
And, you know, I don't know who this guy is.
Maybe his dog died, right?
But it really does exemplify the liberals, the left, wearing masks, pissed off, hating America.
They won't stand up when Trump is like, are you for the American citizens?
And the reality is this.
There are two countries.
There are two nations.
A nation is its people.
A country is its borders.
And there are two nations within the borders of the United States, a multicultural democracy and a constitutional republic.
The constitutional republic are the traditional Americans.
You might be liberal.
You might be conservative.
You might be libertarian.
The Democrats represent a multicultural democracy largely of leftist ideologues, Marxists, and immigrants.
They don't care about American history.
They don't care about the founding fathers.
They don't care about the 4th of July.
You want to know what else?
Chicago don't have the 4th of July anymore.
unidentified
What?
tim pool
It's been gone for years.
phil labonte
Really?
tim pool
Yep.
unidentified
What do you mean?
tim pool
Chicago ain't got no 4th of July.
phil labonte
They don't deserve the Bears, man.
If they don't have 4th of July, they don't do fireworks.
elad eliahu
What do they do?
They just do gunshots?
unidentified
Nope.
Multiculturalism's Hidden Slaves 00:15:28
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
Still in some parts of the city.
People will be letting off fireworks.
You'll see it all over the place because people do this.
And Navy Pier does a private firework ceremony every weekend, but they ended the 4th of July celebration for the city because it is being run by communists who hate America.
jakey botch
You guys turned into Detroit over there.
jay dyer
So this whole time you've been talking about sports.
I thought you were talking about big gay dudes that are hairy.
Bears?
tim pool
Well, Chicago has.
Chicago's going to keep their bears.
They're all on North Hallstead near Wrigley Field.
elad eliahu
You're too well versed in the gay lingo.
That's a red flag.
That's a huge red flag.
jay dyer
I don't know sports hole.
tim pool
Do you know about the handkerchiefs?
jay dyer
I don't know.
elad eliahu
That's what you want to say.
unidentified
That's right.
jay dyer
I figured that's what I'm saying.
unidentified
He really does.
elad eliahu
I don't know.
tim pool
So, you know, and again, we'll say this to, we'll go to the Bears thing in a second because I'm going to go nuts.
But the leftists, they say, like, oh, it's all about love.
You know, like, you know, two guys they want to get married.
It's no big deal.
And that was the trick people like me fell for in 2008, 2010, where it's like, yeah, man, I don't care.
And then the reality was, and I, and I did kind of know this because my family owned a coffee shop on North Halston, on Halston and Waveland.
And what do you find?
It's just always been about sex.
It's fetishism.
It's always fetishism.
There was almost never a circumstance where I saw like a guy just hug another guy and say, I love you.
It was a bar themed with people being raped in prison.
And on the window, it's a guy grabbing the bars.
jakey botch
And they are very, yeah, it's not a bad thing.
tim pool
And they put handkerchiefs.
elad eliahu
They're not deliberate.
They're very sexual.
tim pool
So we'll explain this.
The handkerchiefs in the pocket.
On the left side, it means you take.
On the right side, it means you give.
Different colored handkerchiefs symbolize different fetishes.
And so you walk down the street with the handkerchief in the back.
That's why they used to say having your left ear pierced was gay.
jakey botch
No, no, right ear pierced.
tim pool
It was the right ear piercing.
jakey botch
They make me gay now.
tim pool
A right ear?
unidentified
Yeah.
Yeah, that's what I thought.
jakey botch
If you only had your right.
elad eliahu
Dude, I thought it was the national earring that made you gay.
jakey botch
That's extremely gay.
tim pool
And they had it backwards.
elad eliahu
Well, that's the one you have.
jakey botch
Because when I was a kid, I only had my left because I was straight.
And then I got earrings and they got another.
tim pool
And maybe it's the other way.
I'm like, if it's in the left, it means you give, and the right means you take or something.
unidentified
I don't know.
jakey botch
Either way, it's gay.
unidentified
All these codes.
jay dyer
Like, I was walking with, I had a handkerchief, and now I'm thinking, like, half of the city was seeing my handkerchief coming out of my pocket.
I'm like, now there is.
elad eliahu
I thought that made you a gang member, but now it just makes you gay.
jay dyer
Gang.
tim pool
Gang.
jakey botch
Gay gang.
tim pool
When the gangs don't do that, they don't wear handkerchiefs.
unidentified
What?
jakey botch
Cripple bloods?
unidentified
Of course.
tim pool
I'm talking about in Chicago.
You put a handkerchief in your pocket.
You're asking for some dude to come up on you.
jakey botch
Gang, get up in there.
tim pool
And the gangs know that.
unidentified
Rough.
tim pool
So there's a bunch of different gang colors.
And if you walk around anywhere in gang colors, you're getting stopped.
So like my friends, I had a friend who made a mistake of wearing a black shirt with gold basketball shorts.
unidentified
Not good.
tim pool
And a car pulls up and they said, y'all, homie, what you is?
jakey botch
What set you banging?
tim pool
And he was, yeah, and he was just like, nothing, bro.
unidentified
What?
tim pool
And they were like, yo, I said, what you is?
And he's like, skateboarder?
And they started laughing and they drove off.
elad eliahu
Even if I'm white?
jay dyer
If you're a white dude, yeah.
tim pool
Yeah, of course.
elad eliahu
This isn't just the black thing.
jakey botch
No, you could be white, dude.
tim pool
But the Latin kings are black.
elad eliahu
They might as well be.
tim pool
Bro.
elad eliahu
Black-coated.
phil labonte
Latin king.
unidentified
Black-coated.
jay dyer
Can you be a Latin king?
Well, that ain't a white dude.
tim pool
Yes, of course.
unidentified
Can you?
Of course.
phil labonte
Latin guys.
elad eliahu
The whites still have gangs, too.
I guess white power.
unidentified
Yeah, man.
jay dyer
We have the sharks in the drain.
jakey botch
They got the biggest gang in the world.
jay dyer
Westside story, and we dance.
When you are red, Jay.
elad eliahu
No, and you guys used to be Italians.
You guys used to act up.
tim pool
We're going for it, guys.
The most important story ever.
We have this in the Chicago Tribune.
Governor J.B. Pritzker suggests no matter how Indiana v. Illinois fight goes, the new Bears home won't be in Chicago.
And I knew this because Chicago bought, I'm sorry, the Chicago Bears bought land in Arlington Heights, Illinois.
And they're looking at a swath of land in Hammond, Indiana, which, to be fair, is basically, it's still a Chicago.
Like it's still the metro, but you cross the border.
It doesn't matter because Arlington Heights is not Chicago and Hammond is not Chicago.
So Pritzker said, let me read this.
He was like, I think now there's a common understanding for most of the General Assembly, they're not going to be able to build in the city of Chicago.
For at least a year and a half, there's been a significant effort by the Bears as well as Chicago lawmakers and others to try and figure out if the Bears could build what they need to build in the city of Chicago.
They looked and they, I think, gave the old college try, so to speak, to try and find a place where within the city of Chicago and they couldn't.
So that's why I think we're down to the question of whether they're going to build in Arlington Heights or they're going to build something in the state of Indiana.
He said it's very hard to find in a dense city, a dense city like the city of Chicago, he said.
This is, I remember when the Redskins lost their name.
They lost their mascot and they lost their logo.
And we mocked it.
But you know, I didn't feel for it.
I did.
But I did immediately buy Redskins Ziploc bags.
I went on Amazon, and I said...
jakey botch
They're probably worth a fortune now.
tim pool
Yeah, now $2,000 Ziploc bags.
And they're currently locked away in a vault.
I'm not joking.
They are protected.
And I still see people wearing the Redskins, but it's the Commanders.
And they have a war pig for their mascot.
jakey botch
I like the Washington football team.
I thought that was American.
tim pool
I think it's better than the Commanders.
jay dyer
I'll trade you three Aunt Jemima's for one Redskin.
tim pool
I miss Aunt Jemima too.
You know, the Aunt Jemima thing really pissed me off as well.
You know why?
When I saw that box with Aunt Jemima on it, it gave me a warm, fuzzy feeling inside from when I was a kid.
We always had a box of Aunt Jemima.
We sometimes had Mrs. Butterworth's, but I would make the pancakes.
I'd mix it with the milk or whatever.
And my view of Aunt Jemima was not that she was.
jakey botch
It was not racial and slave.
tim pool
They tell us we're supposed to feel like she was our slave making our breakfast.
I was like, I kind of just viewed it as a nice old lady.
phil labonte
Mom was the slave making the breakfast.
unidentified
Exactly.
jakey botch
My white mother.
tim pool
Guys, they have tore down our statues.
jakey botch
No, it's so sad about the bears, bro.
You guys have sucked for so long.
And you finally get this kid, right?
You finally get this kid, this team, this tight end, and you finally got a good team.
And they're like, yeah, let's get out of here.
phil labonte
She's just like, yeah, it's fine.
jakey botch
Let's blow this popsicle stand.
tim pool
He had the 80s.
And this is when I'm growing up with SNL and Ditka and Dub Bears.
phil labonte
And so the Patriots in the 80s.
tim pool
Hey, look at that.
And so let me tell you guys, let me, because I'm going to, I'm going to, I'm ready to just, I'm going nuclear.
I remember when they tore down the statue of Jefferson.
I remember when they tore down the statue of Columbus.
I remember when they tore down the statue of Frederick Douglass.
He was a slave.
jakey botch
I was going to say, wasn't he black?
tim pool
He got his freedom.
He fought slavery.
And they tore it down because every argument the radical left makes is not actually the argument.
They hate this country.
They want to destroy our history and burn it to the ground.
And what I see with Illinois and Chicago is, admittedly, okay, I'm going to be logical for you guys.
Not the most egregious thing you can do.
Like literally tearing down Jefferson is.
But in my heart, taking Chicago out of the Bears is like igniting, it's like ripping the souls out of a generation and smashing it with the hammer.
jakey botch
It's like taking New York out of the Yankees.
It makes no sense.
tim pool
And this is what the Democrats do.
They invite people into our cities who are not from here under the guise of multiculturalism.
And then one day we find ourselves up for a vote.
Do we want to cut a tax break for the Chicago Bears and grant them money so they can have a stadium and be our team?
And what happens?
The city and the state say no.
jakey botch
And they're finally good, too.
I can understand.
phil labonte
Finally good for real.
jakey botch
If they suck, screw it.
Get them out of here.
But they're good, man.
tim pool
Even if they suck.
jakey botch
What do the Cubs truly want?
Like you just said, you know, they hate America and everything.
Okay, so well, if you have it your way, if you have everything your way and everything you want, what is America if they get what they want?
tim pool
I don't think it's that the Democrats, I wouldn't necessarily say the Democrats liberals.
unidentified
Right.
tim pool
The argument is there is a faction, a political faction in this country that hates this country, views it as evil, and wants to destroy it.
Many, many of much of this is guided by manipulations and propaganda from overt communists and socialists who literally want to destroy our economic system and create a communist system.
They use these arguments like racism as a vehicle to trick people into voting against their interests.
So Democrats as politicians, they're just, you know, like the Democratic Party I would describe as basically just like if you took 200 Candace Owens and told them to go campaign.
They're going to just spread around like nasty little NPC and go into each campaign district and just say whatever needs to be said to get the votes.
Conservatives, unfortunately, keep fighting.
Like Thomas Massey is fighting with the Republicans and the Epstein stuff and they're always going at each other.
The Democrats, to a certain degree, sometimes do this with circular firing squads, but they largely march in lockstep.
jakey botch
But is there any precedent for communism working?
So why do you want the why?
tim pool
At first, you don't succeed.
Try again.
unidentified
Yeah.
Why?
elad eliahu
Because America is irredeemably bad because of our history, is what roughly they would say.
They would say that we were founded by white supremacist slave owners, and there's no way to reform a broken system like this.
Our police department is irredeemably racist.
Therefore, we need to completely abolish.
There is no reforming.
Same with our DHS and ICE and Border Patrol and stuff like that.
That's what they would argue.
So it's complete abolishment.
And then what would replace it?
Probably some People's Republic of retards and some socialists think that they could scramble together.
That is the ideology, though.
It truly is that we are irredeemably white supremacists and founded.
Not only that, the Bill of Rights is not humanistic or maybe you'd want to call them Christian principles, but like beyond that, that they are fundamentally white supremacists.
tim pool
But look, they don't actually believe that.
elad eliahu
That's what the left argues.
tim pool
If you actually talk to any prominent organizer on the left, I don't mean prominent, they're famous, they will outright tell you they don't think it's white supremacy, but it's a vehicle by which stupid people react.
phil labonte
Yeah, and that's because postmodernism has taken over the left and it's all about power.
So, you know, ever since the 60s and with like Foucault and stuff, like they, the fall of the Soviet Union was a big deal, right?
So it used to be that vulgar Marxism was going to be, which is like economic Marxism, the classes, money class, the property owners versus the bourgeoisie, the working people.
I'm sorry, yeah, work versus the working people.
And then when the Soviet Union proved that it didn't, you know, that it didn't work and capitalism kind of made it clear that even the workers could have a good life.
Then you had people like Herbert Marcuse saying, oh, hey, look, this is all false consciousness.
You believe that you're free.
You believe that you have a good life, but you don't really.
And so what they did is they said, well, we have to find a new place to find the revolutionary energy.
And that's when they went into the race communism.
So they said, basically, it turned into racial stuff.
jakey botch
I mean, but what I've learned about race from slavery and everything was that, first of all, blacks were not the only slaves.
tim pool
First slave owner was black.
jakey botch
Well, exactly.
And they sold themselves.
elad eliahu
In our country, to be fair, they were disproportionately black.
tim pool
They were.
jakey botch
But only when you had a massive amount of property did you have true slaves.
I heard that it was a lot like regular people that they kind of were part of the family.
Like, you know, you had a slave for real.
You had a slave.
tim pool
There was a word for that, but we don't say that.
jakey botch
Oh, yeah, yeah.
tim pool
So, so there, hold on, hold on.
But there's a lot that liberals don't know about slavery.
They think, like, when you ask a liberal to describe slavery, what are they going to tell you?
Black men in the field being beaten with a whip.
It's like, okay, how about a man in a suit in a store making shoes?
That was also slavery.
jay dyer
Even in my liberal college classes when we did American history, they made us watch this video of an interview from probably the 60s or 70s with one of the last living slaves who was still, you know, around.
And he said, well, you know, I remember it.
It wasn't that bad.
jakey botch
And I'm like, oh, man.
tim pool
Wait, what?
unidentified
Oh, God.
tim pool
Well, the thing is, the North was as racist as racist could be.
I mean, come on, we had the civil rights era 100 years later.
jay dyer
They were wage workers.
unidentified
Right.
tim pool
And the South, it was around 3% of people who owned slaves.
So the Civil War, yeah, 3%, because it was wealthy.
It was like big companies.
You know what I mean?
Like, how many people own an Amazon warehouse or like a distribution warehouse?
It's like not that many relatively.
So how many people need 100 workers working for cheap?
The other thing is they never really asked themselves these questions of like, how did slaves buy their own freedom?
Because the origin of slavery was that there was an indentured servant to a black man who could not pay off the debt no matter how much like a lifetime of work would not pay off the money owed.
So a court ruled he would remain indentured for life, which created de facto slavery.
And then, of course, certainly people were bought and sold.
All of that was miserably bad, but it was much more complex than you'll get from the average left.
So there were circumstances.
So then the question is, question I asked a long time ago: hey, how did people buy their own slavery?
It doesn't make sense.
You're a slave.
Oh, well, they were allowed to make money.
Okay, so how did it work?
Slaves answered to the slave owner, and the slave owner just defined the parameters by which the slave could do things.
That is, there were many slaves where the slave owner would be like, I need you to be a shoemaker, right?
We're going to make 10 pairs of shoes.
And then the slave would be like, well, what if I do 12?
And he goes, if you do 12, I'll give you some money.
After the work you are supposed to do, if you're going to do more, we'll pay you.
That happened in some circumstances.
jakey botch
Some incentives.
tim pool
They saved up.
And then eventually one day said, all of that money you gave me, I saved.
I want to be a free man.
And they'd say, okay.
And to be fair, often they go buy more slaves.
But it was possible.
I think slavery was wrong.
It's stupid.
It's bad.
All that stuff, obviously.
But very few people actually own slaves.
And slavery was not all just people being beaten.
Not that any of it was good.
elad eliahu
I will say this also isn't unique to the United States.
Many other countries have slaves.
And some countries around the world still have literal slavery.
A lot of Middle Eastern countries and North African countries are heavily involved in slavery.
And then there's the de facto slavery and things like happening in the country of like Qatar, where it's like literally slave labor where these people have their passports and whatnot taken away from them.
So to go back to your original question, though, is what was the left or liberals' goal in the United States?
And for the left, I do think it genuinely is to weaken the United States from inside because they believe that many of our enemies are righteous.
So I do think leftists and communists in our country do believe that, you know, the CCP is righteous, that they do think China is good.
And they look to them as a model of something that is good and just in the world.
And then they look at us as evil and such.
And a lot of their rhetoric actually comes from the CCP.
jakey botch
These are people born in America.
Fascism, Nazism, and Cultural Enforcement 00:05:37
unidentified
Yep.
elad eliahu
You remember uploating Americans?
You remember when suicidal empathy?
tim pool
You know the BLM fist, right?
jakey botch
Yeah, of course.
tim pool
That's the communist red salute.
jakey botch
Oh, yeah, yeah.
tim pool
It's like, imagine if people were walking around with swastikas, identical.
jakey botch
And now we change it to like, you know, Green Lives Matters, but it's a swastika logo.
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
So the guy who killed Aaron Danielson had a, it's the communist fist.
And you'll see people walking down the street and they'll raise their fist and the fingers face out.
That's the communist fist.
jakey botch
Black Panther, did they stand for communism?
unidentified
Yes, they were communist.
tim pool
They were communist and that's the communist fist.
So the reason why you make a fist and you point the fingers forward is the ethos is the same as the fascists.
The fascists had the fascists, which is a bundle of sticks bound together with a blade.
It's a weapon.
jakey botch
I could have swore that was another word for that.
tim pool
It's the same word.
jakey botch
Oh, F-A-G-S?
unidentified
Yes.
tim pool
Fascists and faggot are the exact same word.
They're just different languages.
Literally, bundles of sticks wrapped together.
They put a blade on it.
And the argument was.
We did this with the Simpsons joke where Martin, was it Martin?
He was like, alone we are like the weak twig, but together we form the mighty faggot.
And it puts the sticks together.
And so that's literally what fascists meant.
The communists argued the exact same thing.
jakey botch
The fingers thing they would say.
tim pool
A finger alone is weak.
The fingers together make a fist.
So that's why you're supposed to show your fist facing forward to show all the fingers together.
phil labonte
Ape strong together.
unidentified
Indeed.
tim pool
So what you end up with is economic instability in Europe.
And then you get authoritarian traditionalists, fascists and Nazis.
they're distinct from each other but similar and the communists which are internationalist uh uh progressives that want to erase the the difference you know people like you're a fascist you're a communist They're both authoritarian governmental structures where an authority tells you what you can or cannot do.
You have no freedom.
jakey botch
What's the distinct differences?
tim pool
So when it comes to the Nazis and the fascists, functionally, economically, I'd argue we're splitting hairs.
They're both authoritarian, but the communists want to erase your history and they believe everyone's a blank slate who should be wearing a great jumpsuit.
The Nazis are my nation and my people are the best and we should preserve our history and traditions.
jakey botch
What makes my grandmother call Trump a fascist?
That makes me so angry.
elad eliahu
Derangement syndrome.
tim pool
ignorance like if if you watch your grandma well she's jewish so you're allowed to offend her And you are too?
elad eliahu
I noticed the cross on your hand.
It was a little bit...
jakey botch
Well, my mother's Christian.
My...
unidentified
My father's side was not like practicing Jew, but Hungaria, Austria-Hungary.
jakey botch
Like we had people that got killed, so I rip it.
tim pool
The saying we have is, I wish Trump was 10% of the fascist they claimed he was.
Maybe he would actually send in the police to stop all the rioting.
jakey botch
Yeah, like it makes me so angry.
I literally want to punch her on the head.
tim pool
Your grandmother.
jakey botch
I love her with all my heart.
tim pool
I'm your grandma.
jakey botch
I love her with all my heart, but she's like, what?
Trump's a fascist.
tim pool
I don't know.
Part of me thinks your grandma would kick your ass.
jakey botch
No, no, no.
tim pool
She'd take off the slipper and she'd be hit.
jakey botch
You self couldn't handle me anymore.
But yeah, it makes me so angry.
But she really does have TTDS, bro, and it's sick.
It's crazy.
phil labonte
It's like nowadays fascism is just a it's a catch all word for someone that's authoritarian or they believe is authoritarian.
They don't understand what, they don't understand any of the tenets of fascism.
They don't understand that there's a difference between Nazis and fascists, even though Nazis are fascists.
Not all fascists are Nazis.
Any of the nuance is all gone.
It's just bad person that I don't like, you know, that is pro-conservatives.
jay dyer
Fascism is the melding of the private and the public sector into one.
Like a company, like a company town.
tim pool
One of the principal arguments was it's the lucrative merger of corporation and state.
And one of the reasons people conflate the Italian fascists with the German Nazis was that while you'll hear a lot of people say that the Nazis were socialists, it's the National Socialist Party, the left will argue they weren't actually socialists because it wasn't a command economy the way they want communists to be.
But the structure of the German economy when the Nazis took over was, I would describe it the way our economy functioned from 2018 until like 2022, which is if you don't adhere to the cultural mandates, we will end your company.
So that's why you end up with people bending the knee.
Everybody's scared to speak up.
They fired an executive from Netflix for explaining racial slurs.
So you had this, the culture was, but aren't you against racism?
During Nazi Germany was, you're not going to produce steel for the war effort?
What are you doing?
And you'd be canceled.
So the difference with the communists, they would be like, here's your book.
Here's what you're entitled to.
And then it's like, the state's doing it.
The fascists were like, why won't you do what we demand of you?
And then you'd have all these social pressures, which I think is to a degree scarier in some ways.
jakey botch
So the cancellation thing is more fascism.
tim pool
Nazis.
unidentified
Communism is more kick your door in and kind of kill you if you don't do it.
tim pool
Like the fascists and the Nazis are very, very similar in the general description, the fascists being the merger of corporation and state, where the state would basically go to the corporation and be like, you're going to do what we want you to do.
The Nazis basically did the same thing.
The argument, however, was that it was cultural enforcement.
You don't want to be.
There's that famous picture where everyone's doing the Nazi salute and the one guy's like this.
And it was like, you don't want to be that guy.
You are going to march with everybody in lockstep or else you will not work in this place.
So it was more de facto.
Geostrategy and Proxy Forces 00:15:08
tim pool
And that's pretty worrying.
The thing about the communists is that everyone was just scared and would do right.
So there's similarities.
The principal differences I see was in both systems, the authoritarian state is going to make you do what they want you to do.
You're only allowed to buy what they let you buy.
There's limited degrees of freedom in certain areas.
But the communists' argument is your history is bad, should be destroyed.
And the fascist of the Nazis are like, our history is good and should be preserved.
jakey botch
Does North Korea entice you?
tim pool
It makes me, I am so interested in what goes on there and like how my great-grandfather is from where is now North Korea.
jakey botch
What do they have that they're making money?
Like what are they exporting that finances are still going into that country?
How have they not just ran out of they're subsidized by China?
elad eliahu
And they are starving.
unidentified
Right.
Yeah.
elad eliahu
Their people are starving.
tim pool
Their economy is stagnant.
They like they don't they have that skyscraper in Pyongyang that never finished because they don't have the what goes on there?
jakey botch
Is there any jobs?
unidentified
Is there like what?
tim pool
Yeah, I think you'd be surprised that, you know, one of the challenges we have in North Korea is they potempkin village everything.
The argument the North Koreans make is that it's not that they're tricking us.
It's that when a guest comes over, you dress in your finest and you present your best meal.
You don't have him show up at the house a mess.
jakey botch
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
tim pool
However, that means that for the most part, when we go now, we can't actually see how people are living.
But largely farmers living farm lives.
And the challenge is there was one story I was told where a cow died and you're not allowed to take the meat.
The meat has to be taken by the state and distributed evenly.
So if you have an animal on your property and you're a farmer and it dies, you can't have the whole thing.
And it'll just spoil.
And so what happens is everyone joins the military.
So there will be a young man from the area who will just come over and then he'll be like, uh-oh, it's tainted.
I have no choice.
And then the people come and take it and eat it.
And then he reports that it was diseased meat and they couldn't take it.
So they lie.
So you'll breed a lot of corruption because people are starving and they don't like it.
jakey botch
His life entire, like, it makes me so baffled of like how.
tim pool
Part of it sounds awesome.
jakey botch
It really, he's a god and he believes he's not.
I don't think he.
jay dyer
Are you saying he's not?
How do you know he's not?
jakey botch
Yeah, he doesn't poop according to Seth Rogen.
tim pool
He went to school in Sweden.
Here's what I would say about North Korea.
You got to admit, as bad as it is, some of it, like the cultural cohesion may be a little too extreme, but I'll take a little bit of that.
jay dyer
He likes Dennis Rodman.
He likes Dennis Roddy.
unidentified
That's true.
jakey botch
And it's the only place on the planet that's still like that, right?
tim pool
You know, they're...
jay dyer
Were they like Dennis Rodman?
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
Yeah, here's, here's, I'll tell you this.
You'll find a lot of these progressives in the United States love North Korea.
And the reason why is when we, you ever see that map of North and South Korea?
jakey botch
Yeah.
tim pool
Where the lights are all off?
jakey botch
Oh, yes, yes, where there's no electricity and yes.
tim pool
Nighttime North.
jakey botch
South Korea is thriving, right?
I mean, they got K-pop.
tim pool
Sure.
I think that's taking the world.
I'm going to pull up this image for you guys.
jakey botch
Cool haircuts.
tim pool
Check this out.
People go, how's communism doing?
And then here's South Korea and here's North Korea.
But you know what?
unidentified
What is that?
jakey botch
How is that possible?
tim pool
But here's the thing.
When communists look at this, they say, I wish.
Because do you know what that argument is?
Nature.
jay dyer
Return to nature.
tim pool
Return to nature.
Exactly.
The communist view is like.
When we all look at this and say, wow, look how amazing China and South Korea is.
The communists to go, wow, look how amazing North Korea is.
jay dyer
You're not alienated.
tim pool
They have real nature.
They have real wilds.
There's not light pollution and noise pollution and smog everywhere.
And they're closer to nature.
Many of these communists, that's why you see the climate change stuff.
They're like, y'all should be living in the woods like monkeys.
jakey botch
Now tell me this.
How is South Korea not able to go take over North Korea?
Why is China?
But why does China want that?
tim pool
There's a lot of arguments.
China wants a buffer against U.S. colonial force.
jakey botch
Which is South Korea?
tim pool
So basically, what happens with the Korean War is China was with the North and the U.S. with the South, and they went back and forth and then formed this line, the DMZ.
And China's attitude is like, we do not want the United States on our doorstep.
jakey botch
Even close to us.
Yeah, because they're going to be, I mean, it's like having Cuba, you know.
tim pool
Exactly.
And for the United States, we want to stop the spread of communism.
Which, you know, it really is interesting.
And I know a lot agrees with this.
When I grew up hearing about the Vietnam War and all this stuff, it's painted in modern history as like this terrible unjust thing that never should have happened.
And while I do largely agree it was a mismanaged, botched thing, we used a false flag to enter it.
I then go back and think, but isn't it good to stop the spread of communism if the United States was facing a imagine what would have happened if the U.S. did not win the Cold War?
We'd be surrounded on all fronts by a unipolar communist Soviet force of people that are half-starved and they're trying to steal our stuff like a zombified planet.
That's terrifying.
jakey botch
Think it would have gotten that far?
tim pool
Yeah, absolutely.
And but fortunately, the U.S., well, to be honest, maybe not because communism struggles.
You know what I mean?
elad eliahu
Full circle, Tim is now sounding like a neocon because he's starting to defend the Korean War.
And even though it was a very just cause to fight against the expansion of communism, you know.
tim pool
Yeah, but my point is that I, of course, think which I do support too.
I think my point is that Vietnam was wrong.
It was a failure of an operation.
elad eliahu
Well, it was wrong or a failure.
jakey botch
And we were fighting communism.
tim pool
The false flag, the Gulf of Tonkin incident to get us involved in Vietnam is evil.
Like, if the American people say we are not interested in this fight, you can't force them to do it.
That is wrong.
Sending by draft young men to go fight in a war they didn't understand under false pretexts is wrong.
And it was a failed operation, flubbed miserably by terrible military leaders.
elad eliahu
So I think we get to benefit from the hindsight.
If shit hit the wall in Korea and North Korea just managed to completely take over, then all of that would also be true for Korea.
So it's hard to like, you know, you're kind of judging with Korea.
tim pool
I don't believe we staked a false flag to justify our occupation invasion.
elad eliahu
No, it was because the North reinvaded.
But even then, some people would say it would be unjust to use a draft to defend a foreign nation when we weren't being attacked ourselves in Korea.
But I think still that the Korean war was justified.
If we had completely lost and South Korea never had been a thing, I think people would be saying the same thing about South Korea.
tim pool
Well, you know, fair point hindsight is 2020.
I don't think, I think Vietnam certainly has its problems today, but things have cooled off quite a bit.
jakey botch
I certainly think communism with the Vietnam War.
unidentified
That's the attempt.
jakey botch
That's what it was.
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
Yeah.
jakey botch
Stop working.
elad eliahu
Well, not only so.
tim pool
Well, I mean, to be honest, communism still exists in some form, but what China is is some kind of like I don't think it's fair to call China communism.
It's there's a third way.
The third way.
jay dyer
Yeah, it's like fascist.
unidentified
Right.
tim pool
Oh, they definitely think of themselves as the idea is that the Chinese Communist Party said we need to allow certain forms of economics, but we need to maintain absolute authority.
So they'll let people file to open a business and try it out.
But if you get to a certain size, the Chinese Communist Party gets an office in your building to make sure you're operating under their purview.
elad eliahu
Well, there's no free speech laws.
There's no property rights.
There's no freedom of religion.
In my eyes, no freedom of religion.
No freedom of religion.
And in my eyes, that is scribes, that's communism.
And they're actually abusing Muslims with genocide in Xinjiang in the West because they want to assimilate all of the Chinese.
tim pool
The issue that I think many people on the right in this country have with China is the function of their ideology.
Let me clarify that.
The ideology they have, not the function of their governance.
Meaning, if you had a United States that operated similarly under a Christian nationalist structure, many Americans on the right would completely agree with it.
If the argument was run your business, do what you want.
When you get to a certain size, you're going to have an ideological minder, but it's to the betterment of the Christian ideals.
Many people on the right would be like, yeah, I'm okay with it.
Yeah, and that sounds exactly like China, but the point is, if you replace the ideology of China with Christianity, a lot of Christians would be in favor of it.
jakey botch
I think I would as a Christian.
Honestly, I would.
tim pool
What say you, sir?
jay dyer
How do you mean that?
tim pool
So like, let's say you had a country and the government was Christian.
They allowed people to live and work.
You can open a business, but everything is going to be under Christian doctrine administered by the state, a Christian state.
And they did things like Muslims were heavily restricted and not allowed.
Things like that.
Yeah, I agree with that.
Right.
My point was China's doing a lot of things that, again, I'll be specific.
Like with Muslims being what's the difference?
jay dyer
them as proxy forces from the west right i'm not for this but i'm saying like china does yeah Yeah.
So Islam, the what's the weird sect?
elad eliahu
The Falun Gong.
jay dyer
Falun Gong, the project, the Tibet project with the Dalai Lama.
That's all CIA stuff.
That's declassified too, by the way.
elad eliahu
Wait, you don't actually believe that?
You think that's just what the CCP calls them?
Or do you think it's legitimately?
jay dyer
No, I think those are all Western projects.
elad eliahu
So anything that is threatening to the CCP is what, therefore, a CIA-backed project?
These are all just separatists who are going to want to be assimilated.
jay dyer
Well, in the case of the Fallen Gong, they may not be directly run by the CIA, but they would be supported by the West as something aggressive.
In the case of Free Tibet, that actually was a CIA project, and the Dalai Lama has worked with the CIA.
tim pool
Let me put it like this.
So they've got these, they've got the Uyghur Muslim camps, right?
jay dyer
Yeah.
tim pool
And they say, well, no, these are just prisoners.
And the West argues they're people being oppressed.
The stories that we get are horrifying.
If you were, my point is, if the ideology of China was purely Christian and it was like a Christian nationalist country and the perspective of the people was we have arrested Muslim criminals.
Like, again, I'm clarifying from what the West is saying about what they're doing versus what they say they're doing.
My point is, if in the United States we had a Christian nationalist government and many extremist Muslims were arrested and put into prisons, people on the right would be like, yes, absolutely.
jay dyer
Sure.
elad eliahu
Sure, there are other things in the government that I think are what some Christians would argue is antithetical to their values.
The one-child policy for a while, at the very least.
tim pool
Yeah, I think so.
jay dyer
You're just about religious dissidents.
Is that what you're saying?
Just putting them in?
tim pool
No, no, I mean like Muslims specifically.
I believe there are many Christians that would have no problem if the government said, look, this is a criminal who committed a crime.
We are putting them in prison.
elad eliahu
We call them terrorists as well.
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
That's my point.
So we look at what they're doing as a Chinese Communist Party with these camps with Muslims, and we're like, that's horrifying and wrong.
If it was our government, they would be justifying it in a way that people would be like, well, I trust my government.
jay dyer
This is the same reason they have a state-controlled Catholic church because they don't want the normal.
Yeah, they have a state-run Catholic church.
So they don't want the normal Catholic church because they believe that it would be a tool for espionage.
tim pool
And aren't they forced to actually believe certain like Confucius or Buddhists?
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Right, right.
elad eliahu
I want to follow up on something you said, Jay.
It's not that I think I'm trying to understand.
You legitimately think that all Tibetans that believe in separatism are all okay.
unidentified
All right.
elad eliahu
It's just because I believe.
tim pool
And he's right.
jay dyer
No, I'm saying the Free Tibet movement, all the way back in the 1970s, LA Times first reported on this, that it was supported by CIA money.
And then it was just recently declassified that the CIA was involved in the Free Tibet Project.
unidentified
Sure.
jay dyer
Just as a buffer against the CCP.
tim pool
And this is the U.S. soft power where USAID, largely what they were doing, was providing aid to NGOs, but it was for the goal of destabilizing.
elad eliahu
I think we have common interests.
jay dyer
I'm not pro-CCP.
elad eliahu
I think we have common interests with these groups.
I don't think that inherently makes them CIA, though.
And I feel like some people on the left would just use that blanket term.
Well, anybody who is who has similar end goals as us.
So again, we might want to see parts of Tibet break off because we don't believe that's a legitimate part.
Or we would like to see Taiwan remain independent.
Some people would imply that they are CIA just because they have similar interests.
jay dyer
No, in the case of the Dalai Lama, this is declassified, but also this was a relationship going all the way back to the Nazis, right?
He was actually, when it looked like the Nazis might win, there were those famous meetings with the Dalai Lama and the SS because they were trying to curry favor with him, establish a relationship because the Nazis also were concerned with that geostrategic location.
Like you're talking about earlier with Cuba, Cuba relationship to the United States, Taiwan with China.
Well, Tibet as well, right?
Because it's kind of like Ukraine.
If you can break Ukraine off, that's a, which Hitler wanted to do that too.
He wanted Ukraine.
That's a buffer against Russia.
So a lot of it's just geostrategy.
I'm not pro-CCP.
I'm just saying that I think that's the geopolitics.
tim pool
Before we go to the chat, let me ask you: would you be in favor of a U.S. government that its basis for its laws was Christianity?
jay dyer
You would have to have the majority of the population accepting something like Orthodox Christianity before anything like that would even be sensible.
unidentified
Sure, sure, sure.
jay dyer
The last time there was something like this was like 1800s Russia, where you had a symphony, a relationship of the Byzantine two-headed eagle is the model.
So you have church and state.
They worked in symphony.
But you don't try to.
tim pool
I just more so mean, like, is it a desirable outcome that the people of the United States all agree an Orthodox Christian?
jay dyer
Ultimately, but I mean, if that happened, I'd be like 200 years away.
tim pool
Sure, sure, sure.
I'm just curious on if the end result was you had government that would go in, they'd say prayer, they would have discussions with religious leaders on does it make sense to implement a certain law?
jay dyer
There would be a close relationship.
There'd be two spheres, but there'd be a close relationship.
tim pool
But just it is desirable.
I ask this in all sincerity.
jay dyer
I would argue that.
tim pool
I think most people would argue that their religion is the way in which their country should be.
jay dyer
Sure.
tim pool
I think so too.
I would argue that as Tim Cast or Tim Colt.
No cult.
My argument is the function of Christianity is superior to everything else we have seen throughout history, and that the United States would benefit from actually having Christianity in its government as it did historically until we started to pull it out.
Liberals don't know history.
And, You know, so one thing that I've talked about quite a bit, you know, I grew up Catholic and ultimately just left the church and then became like an angsty teenage atheist, but then kind of realized I was wrong.
And I remember reading about Blackstone's formulation, which is it is better that 10 guilty persons escape than one innocent person suffer.
Why Christianity Matters 00:06:03
tim pool
And I thought, man, what a beautiful thing, right?
And then Benjamin Franklin said it's actually better that 100 guilty persons escape than one innocent person suffer.
And I said, yeah, but why?
I mean, like, if you've got a rapist running around and you're like, we're going to have 10 rapists running around just so that one, don't aren't there sacrifices.
So I decided to read into it and like, why did Blackstone say this?
The Bible.
It's rooted in the story of Sodom and Gomorrah.
If there's but one righteous man, I will not destroy this city.
And the legal framework by which the U.S. operates for its innocent until proven guilty is quite literally from the Bible.
unidentified
That's true.
tim pool
And I believe it is logically and mathematically correct.
And this is my argument about my worldview on private rights: that we can actually mathematically map out why Christianity is correct.
And that is the founding fathers argued: if you take the religion out of it, you can go very simple and say, this is what God wills of us.
It is better that, you know, if there's but one righteous man, we do not condemn, right?
However, how does that translate to a functioning society?
The founding fathers said, if you tell a man, regardless of his innocence, we will punish you just in case, you have created an incentive for a man to be derelict.
You will tell the person, why bother being righteous and moral if we're going to harm you no matter what you do.
In fact, the incentive then is if I'm going to be imprisoned unjustly, I might as well try and get what I can while I'm at it.
So they ultimately logically came together and said, then in fact, it quite does make sense that we should tell the people, even if a guilty person escapes, we are going to make sure the innocent, the burden will be on the government.
And I believe that is the righteous thing and the just thing.
It also completely adheres to the Bible and the perspective on, you know, it was Sodom and Gomorrah, but it also makes complete sense when we watch how humans are.
And when you take a look at what the left is doing, releasing criminals intentionally, it is, I believe, anarcho-tyranny.
They want to create violence and instability.
But it also, I believe, is an attempt.
I believe largely what the left is doing is trying to destroy Christianity.
It is what these communists have argued for quite a bit.
And I think a lot of what they do, and maybe not as directly, but it's a way to say, see, your ethos doesn't work.
We let these guilty people escape and crime has been miserable and everyone's upset.
Maybe we shouldn't adhere to this.
And you'll end up with an Otto von Bismarck where he said, it is better that 10 innocent people suffer than one guilty person escape.
And what do you get with that?
You get oppression, authoritarianism, command economies that ultimately collapse and everyone's pissed off.
jay dyer
In the French Revolution, they let the prisoners out to engage and to be the front, the front, you know, the tip of the spear for the revolution.
The revolutionaries were like antifa, right?
phil labonte
The revolutionary exactly.
tim pool
We're going to go to your chats and Rumble Rant.
So smash the like button, share the show with every person you've ever met.
Go through your phone book.
I bet if you open your phone book right now, there's like 30 phone numbers.
You can't even remember who they are.
Just text them like, hey, here's the link to Tim Castillo.
I'm kidding, man.
That's a bad idea, but who knows?
Don't text your.
You guys remember number neighbors?
phil labonte
Yes.
tim pool
People would text a phone number, one number up or down from their phone number.
So if like the last four of your number was like 9331, they would text 9330 and they'd be like, I'm your number neighbor.
unidentified
Who are you?
jay dyer
Sounds like some boomer shit right here.
unidentified
Uh-huh.
Uh-huh.
jakey botch
Oh, look, this guy's putting it.
tim pool
Anyway, anyway, we're going to have that uncensored portion of the show over at rumble.com slash Timcast IRL, where we have a special treat for you that certainly can only be played on the uncensored show, and you will laugh.
But you got to go to rumble.com slash Timcast IRL at 10 p.m. to watch it.
In the meantime, we're going to see what y'all have to say.
All right, Jacob Hawley says, from what I understand until the investigation is over, is that they were potentially drug traffickers trying to smuggle drugs in Caribbean.
That is still unverified, but that's from the Cuban embassy.
Agreed.
And maybe that is the case.
Maybe that is.
elad eliahu
Cubans are so poor.
I don't know how it would be so lucrative to smuggle drugs into Cuba, but St. Miles says it's Gulf of America, a lot.
Oops.
tim pool
It actually is.
unidentified
It is.
Yes.
elad eliahu
That's a genuine mistake.
tim pool
It's funny that Trump just declared it, right?
elad eliahu
Gulf of America.
tim pool
That's what it is, right?
Like Trump was like, that's it from now on.
And then they're like, okay.
unidentified
Yeah.
elad eliahu
And everybody had a voice.
jakey botch
He looked really good.
unidentified
Oh, I don't know.
jakey botch
You do really good as voice.
tim pool
I could probably do it better if I try.
We're just moving off.
All right, what do we got this?
Alex says, hello, Tim and Crew, continuing with the tradition.
I'm in the hospital with my beautiful wife, and we are welcoming our third and fourth children, Ellen and Twin, into the world.
Stay salty, Patriots.
phil labonte
Awesome to hear.
unidentified
All right.
phil labonte
Congratulations.
elad eliahu
Like Timcast fans are the only one that queens.
tim pool
Omega Rosetsu says, classical liberalism is not left.
Also, Tim, economics are not attached to the XY axis.
There is a third axis that is ignored.
X equals morality, Y equals authority, Z equals econ.
I think we're both going to agree he's wrong.
jay dyer
That's fine.
tim pool
There's a bunch of, so left and right is the challenge with a lot of these ideologies, how you define them in different contexts.
For a while in the 2000s, many people defined left as lacking authority and right as more authority.
But that doesn't necessarily, because that goes more to like the French Revolution vision of it.
But it didn't make sense because then people started to define capitalistic economics as right-wing and socialist as left-wing, which created two distinct and then a third left-right acts emerged of culture where the right is traditionalist and the left is progressive.
So you actually have a bunch of different left-right paradigms that that's why we have to try and figure out what that means.
The funny thing is, actually, there's one leftist paradigm and then three different right-wing branches.
Left-Right Paradigms Explained 00:04:19
tim pool
Because like, you know, I always point this out.
Dave Smith and Nick Fuentes have wildly different political ideologies, but they are both called right-wing by the media.
And I'm like, that is not a good descriptor of what these views are.
Whereas the left, you pretty much can nail it.
Someone's a liberal, they're going to believe the same thing as everybody else.
And we actually, the data bores this out.
There was a graph that we showed on the show a while ago where they had a social access and an economic access.
So it was the further down you were, the more socialist economics.
And the further left you were, the more, oh, no, no, no, I'm sorry.
The further left you are was socialist economies and the further down was progressive culturalism.
And you found the Trump voter base was spread out evenly across the top, meaning you had the dirtbag left.
They're more socialist, but they voted for Trump.
On the bottom, everything was in a tight pocket of leftist ideology for culture and economics.
So when you call the leftist a leftist, you can pretty much agree they're going to be for trans and the kids.
They're going to be communist.
They're going to be pro-war with Ukraine.
Whatever that stuff is.
phil labonte
All right.
tim pool
What do we got here?
Let's see.
A lot of people weren't fans of the debate.
Zet says, uncertainty principle says nothing can be known with absolute certainty.
Certainty equals forbidden.
Nothing equals forbidden.
Therefore, nothing equals certain.
Give it up, y'all.
jay dyer
Well, is that certain?
tim pool
Indeed, it's not.
jakey botch
Get into a debate without it.
tim pool
On a Sith deals in absolutes.
jay dyer
Is that absolute?
tim pool
Kishim says, UPS is trash.
Got updated on a cast brew cold brew as delivered, but the notes say it was damaged and discarded this morning.
Oh, that is highly unrealistic.
phil labonte
Unreal.
tim pool
We also have big news.
New shipments of pool water are on the way.
We are introducing pool water cans.
jakey botch
I was going to say, can people actually get this?
Because we sold out.
It's a phenomenal idea.
tim pool
And I was like, shout out to Andy.
unidentified
Sells this.
jakey botch
And that's what I'm saying.
elad eliahu
Where's the endorsement?
jakey botch
It tastes exactly like chlorine water.
tim pool
No, it does.
jakey botch
No, it tastes like 100% Audison water.
tim pool
Yeah, it's a TJ in Virginia water.
It's effectively an aquifer in Virginia.
It's basically the same water that we get, we drink out here.
And it's pure, filtered, delicious with all the good stuff in it.
And we made it as a gag because I was beefing with Liquid Death over the plastic contents of their cans, for which Liquid Death has plastic in their cans.
jakey botch
I don't like Liquid Death.
tim pool
It's plastic in their cans.
And so they say, death, the plastic, but I'm like, hey, yo, there's plastic in your cans.
And the argument was, yeah, well, there's more plastic in a bottle because the cap has plastic in it.
I'm like, yeah, that's fine.
Just say that.
And then we got this whole beef.
So then I was like, why don't we launch our own water company?
And then Andy goes, pool water.
And we all laughed.
And we were like, that's great.
That's a great idea.
And so we did it.
And we've got pool water is going to be available soon at cashbrew.com.
We're going to do cans as well.
And there's actually one simple reason we do it.
We actually buy a bunch of water bottles for guests.
And so we were like, why the hell are we giving them?
We'll just do our own.
The left made fun of Trump for having Trump water.
This is what the left never understood.
It's so annoying.
They'd be like, Donald Trump's Trump steaks failed and Trump magazine failed and Trump water failed.
And then you go to a resort and what do they have?
Trump steaks, Trump Water and Trump Magazine.
And I'm like, these people don't get it.
Trump-branded products are internally manufactured products for his facilities.
Like McDonald's makes their own mayonnaise.
jakey botch
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
tim pool
Trump, so Trump has resorts.
jakey botch
He doesn't need you to buy them.
tim pool
So here's the thing.
Trump probably went, how much does it cost us to get a steak to serve it one of our, you know, to a customer?
And they're like, ah, it's going to cost you $10.
Okay.
And why?
And they're like, well, we order it from Steak Co.
He was like, oh, okay.
What if we make it ourselves?
Seven bucks.
So we can save $3 a steak if we do it ourselves.
Do it ourselves.
And so that's why he has Trump Water.
That's why he's got Trump Magazine and all that stuff.
I was when Trump was running, I worked for Fusion, this leftist rag, and they were talking about how Trump water was gone.
And then I go to Trump Dora, which is literally down the street from Fusion's office, and there's bottles of Trump water.
And right next to it is Trump magazine.
And I was like, I'm so confused.
Charleston's Socialist Vision 00:04:25
tim pool
Why are they lying?
It's the stupidest thing ever.
It's what they do.
phil labonte
Because they don't like Donald Trump.
unidentified
That's it.
phil labonte
All right.
tim pool
Shador says, Tim, you got to have a tiki history on culture war to explain the proper differences of socialism, communism, capitalism, fascism.
Sure, but I would also say everybody argues even academics.
I think I've read like four different academic papers on the definition of fascism, for which one of the most common is the lucrative merger of corporation and state.
Then you'll get others that argue, well, you know, technically, you'll get some people saying the Nazis were socialist, as self-described.
And then you'll get other academics being like, well, actually.
elad eliahu
And then you've got people saying the USSR, no, they weren't real communism.
And the CCP, they call themselves communists, are communists in every way, but occasionally have some free market aspects.
So no, they're not really communist either.
phil labonte
It is possible to have socialism that's not Marxist socialism.
I mean, socialism kind of started in the French Revolution.
Like Marx, Marxism and Marxist-Leninism is like what people think of as socialism, but it is possible to have socialism.
unidentified
It's not.
elad eliahu
To me, it's a distinction without a difference.
phil labonte
Okay.
tim pool
Well, they are different.
elad eliahu
I think socialism is ultimately trying to lead to communism.
tim pool
So, I mean, that's well, that's the communists said the ultimate goal of socialism is communism.
But I would say that if you're trying to make a distinction between the two, a simple way is that socialism defines the economic system and communism is the political infrastructure of it.
So I do agree it's splitting hairs.
elad eliahu
I understand Leninism wanted to use vanguardism and they had different ways that they hoped to achieve communism.
And then Maoism had a little bit differently.
And then North Korea has their own strain of leftism, Marxism, and it's all the same.
BS to me.
tim pool
Here's how I can explain communism very easily to people, right?
Because they're always like, you know, how come we've never seen a real communist country?
It's like, we have because there is reality and there is fiction.
Fiction is the idea that you can strip possessions from everybody and then they'll all hold hands and sing songs under the sun.
Reality is you do this and then someone has to enforce it because everyone's pissed off and killing each other.
jay dyer
If Timtown was a company town, would we be allowed to leave or would we?
tim pool
You would be allowed to leave.
In fact, you'd be encouraged.
Like, it's the opposite.
It's like, guys, I'm going to do whatever I can to make you get out.
jay dyer
You want everyone out or just?
tim pool
Well, no, I want only the people who really want to be here to be here.
unidentified
Okay.
tim pool
And so it should actually be kind of annoying to be here, but you're going to fight really hard to make it work.
And that's how you know it's.
elad eliahu
The real question is, are you going to let everybody in?
jay dyer
There are borders to Timtown.
tim pool
There are going to be borders.
unidentified
Okay.
jay dyer
Yes.
jakey botch
Sounds like how I want America to be.
tim pool
But my plan is, the borders aren't so much you can't come in.
It's it when you come in, 20 bucks.
Leaving's free.
jakey botch
That sounds pretty mafia to me.
tim pool
This is how New York does it.
This is how San Francisco does it.
When you try to enter New York to the tunnels, you got to pay, was it 15 bucks these days?
jakey botch
17.
tim pool
17.
And when you leave, it's free.
And you know why they do that?
jakey botch
No, not anymore.
unidentified
What?
tim pool
It's free now?
elad eliahu
They only charge you one way.
jakey botch
Maybe through Jersey.
Maybe through Jersey.
But in New York, like from Brooklyn to Staten Island, they split the toll.
tim pool
Well, yeah, that's because it's still New York.
unidentified
Yeah, yeah.
tim pool
If you're leaving.
jakey botch
Yes, yes, into Jersey.
I mean, coming into New York, you only pay when you're in the business.
tim pool
The reason they do it is it creates net poverty outflow, meaning it's harder for poor people to enter the city and easy for them to leave.
jakey botch
Now, but what about Jersey, though?
Jersey doesn't get any cut of that.
tim pool
They probably do.
It's a poor authority.
So it's like, it's split.
But again, the idea, like San Francisco does the same thing.
When you enter San Fran, you got to pay.
But when you leave, it's freaking because the city's basically like, let's make it easy for the poor to leave.
Make it hard for them to get in.
unidentified
Yeah.
jakey botch
It's pretty smart.
tim pool
Unfortunately.
All right.
What do we got here?
Tyron says, just got VIP tickets for me, my wife, and friends to see all that remains in Charleston.
Superstokes.
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
And Amon Amarth and Death Clock.
unidentified
Nice.
tim pool
Then Creator.
Ooh, Death Clock.
Yeah, they're great.
phil labonte
It's going to be good shows, man.
elad eliahu
That's Charlestown or Charleston?
phil labonte
Charleston.
Charleston, South Carolina.
At the music farm.
tim pool
Jason says the glass made from a nuclear explosion is called Trinitite.
Is that it's called?
unidentified
Trinitite?
Constitutional Blasphemy 00:10:38
elad eliahu
Sweet.
Do they have a lot of that in Japan?
jakey botch
I was about to say, do we actually know this is a real thing?
unidentified
Yes.
tim pool
Yeah, Google it.
elad eliahu
Yeah, but I think in glass since when they nuclear tested in Nevada or whatever, that's what they produced.
tim pool
Randy says Levi Struss's original label said made by white men.
jakey botch
Aha, classic.
I need a vintage pair of those jeans.
elad eliahu
And now his great-grandson is a representative from New York City who impeached the president the first time around, was the lead lawyer impeaching Dan Goldman, Representative Dan Goldman.
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
Okay.
Raymond G. Sandler Jews says, arguments based on 200 years ago is deaf nonsensical.
I'm not sure.
jay dyer
Sure, you want to say that about the Constitution?
tim pool
Oh, I will in two seconds.
I say it all the time.
jay dyer
It doesn't matter.
tim pool
That what we think of when the left and the right both say, like the right says the left is trampling the Constitution, the left says the right's trampling the Constitution.
What they're literally describing is a Constitution is shout out to Wait Stotz.
What constitutes the people and the right view their constituency, what constitutes the Constitutional Republicanists, and the left views what constitutes the multicultural Democrats, both are completely meaningless to what the Founding Fathers intended.
The Founding Fathers, blasphemy was illegal.
You could not go out and besmirch the good name of Jesus Christ.
Today, the argument from both sides is that it's allowed.
jakey botch
Burn the flag if you want.
tim pool
You couldn't do that back in the day.
jakey botch
No, you couldn't.
tim pool
Back in the day, if you burned the flag, like, here's the thing: back in the day, gun rights.
The argument was the federal government could not take your guns away, but the states can do what the states can do.
We've changed it now to, no, no, the states can't take your guns because the federal government protects that right for all.
I'm actually fine with that distinction.
jay dyer
You just appealed to Black's law dictionary, right?
tim pool
To what?
jay dyer
Earlier.
So that would mean that's old, right?
So we can't not care about what was written 200 years ago.
That's what he was saying.
tim pool
You're saying his argument.
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
I'm not sure the context of whether he's trying to agree or disagree that as well.
Yeah.
Like he, I'm not, that's why I was like, Raymond, I'm not entirely sure.
Are you saying that like arguing against what they had laid down is nonsensical or arguing for what they laid down?
I would argue that if we want to adhere to the Constitution, blasphemy is illegal.
Christian blasphemy would be illegal.
jakey botch
Do you agree with that, though?
tim pool
I'm saying if no, but the founding fathers, the last blasphemy case was what, like 1830-something.
Like, which was a guy, a guy was espousing.
I can't remember exactly the details.
He was like, he was espousing something that Jesus was not the Son of God or something like that.
And then he argued that it was not insulting or demeaning to question as other religions did.
Therefore, it was not true blasphemy.
He got convicted.
unidentified
So that's that's that's bro.
tim pool
If in 1706, 1790, if you walked into the heart of New York and started holding up a sign saying Jesus, well, that's a little vague, but literally saying like, like insults, insulting Jesus, they would arrest you under obscenity and blasphemy law.
jakey botch
Now, where does that change throughout the process?
tim pool
In the 1830s, I think it was, maybe like 1829, there was the final case where a guy, he was like a, what was he?
He was like a universal Unitarian or some function, some weird religion, and he was challenging Christianity.
So they arrested him.
And then arguments were made that don't we have religious freedom and freedom of speech?
He got convicted.
The Supreme Court said no, but then ultimately, like, that was the last time anyone ever went for it.
jay dyer
Were blasphemy laws state laws?
tim pool
So I'm going to say, I think it was held under, I believe it was state.
I actually think it was federal as well.
I think this, where the Supreme Court was specifically, let me let me know.
jakey botch
Does the law change because the Supreme Court rules on like it's actually written or just the case?
tim pool
Nope, that's not it.
That was 1976 in the UK.
No, no, no, no.
Although that one's interesting, too.
The Commonwealth v. Nealand in 1838.
jakey botch
This is the last case that you were talking about.
tim pool
Yeah, that was the last conviction under blasphemy.
jakey botch
When was the last?
tim pool
No, no, it says 1928.
Why are they changing it on me?
elad eliahu
Beyond the actual law, I remember a decade ago, South Park refused to blaspheme Muhammad because they were scared of the First Bank.
Yeah, it was both legal thing.
jakey botch
And I love that.
elad eliahu
What's fascinating to me is the Christian response to people blaspheming Jesus, which is to say almost none at all of the Christians who I'm around who see Jesus being blasphemed, they don't seem to care much or are just very tolerant of people doing it as opposed to it.
tim pool
Let me tell you this over blaspheming.
Did you know that this is a Christian nation founded on the requirement to profess a faith in a Christian God?
jakey botch
I know it was a Christian nation.
tim pool
And in order to run for office, you had to swear a faith in a Christian God.
And it started to change around the time of the revolution.
Maryland was one of the only states, it was like, I think Maryland, Connecticut, where you didn't have to say Protestant, but many of the states required you to be a Protestant.
Maryland, because of a high density of Catholics, said just Christian.
And because of Thomas Jefferson, largely, Virginia said, just say God.
But now today, you'll hear these liberals say, we have a separation of church and state.
We never required a belief in God.
And it's like, no, actually, all of the colonial charters required it.
jay dyer
That comes from Roger Williams, the Baptist, who was a strong proponent of the separation of church and religion and state.
So it goes from, like you said, there even used to be church taxes in some of the colonies.
jakey botch
How do you feel about the separation of church and state?
Me, honestly, I don't like it because I like my ideologies and everything like that.
tim pool
The problem with it is that the mistake made by the, it's not necessarily even the founding fathers, because separation of church and state is not the constitution.
It was largely born of like the First Amendment, the right to practice religion, your own religion.
The problem is the assumption of 5 million people who are 99% Christian was our moral worldview is already absolute.
We don't need to make the government start telling Christians and Protestants because we don't need to deal with that.
What ends up happening then is the moral worldview erodes and starts incorporating degeneracy and very bad things that are detrimental to our country.
And we have this enshrined now that you cannot have your ideology in your law, which to be honest, look, there's a lot of bad laws that we got rid of, but there's a lot of really bad things we've adopted.
And I do believe that even like if you go back to the 50s, largely we were still like a 90-some-odd percent Christian nation.
People were still going to church.
And the moral worldview was still culturally enforced.
Since we've had an expansion of multiculturalism, immigration, and what we would describe as heritage Americans, I guess, like long-standing American families have stopped reproducing.
You have an erosion of your moral worldview.
So now you are getting rampant degeneracy across the country.
I have no problem with Christianity in government so long as constitutional rights are protected.
That would be, you can't give a blowjob in the streets of San Francisco.
That's not a joke.
They're doing it.
elad eliahu
Well, you need to have a blowjob at all.
tim pool
In San Francisco, they have men in the streets engaging in sex acts with children all around them.
And the police refuse to do anything about it.
And this has been going on everywhere.
And they won't enforce it because everyone's like, well, you know, they're free.
jakey botch
What do you bother them?
elad eliahu
When you say Christian nation, what do you mean specifically?
tim pool
Me?
elad eliahu
Yeah.
tim pool
Like the moral framework of our laws and structures are under a Judeo-Christian framework.
elad eliahu
I agree on that.
I think there's a lot of connotation comes along with Christian nation that I am not suggesting mandated churches or that people will be forced to buy Bibles.
tim pool
I'm saying that Blackstone's formulation, the foundation of like the fourth, fifth, and sixth amendments is understood and taught to our children.
They understand their heritage.
They're explained to, here's why we do it.
The founding fathers didn't simply say, you know what?
Christianity is absolute.
Therefore, we don't got to think about it.
No, they actually debated it and said, you know, I thought about it.
I don't think divine mandate describes in and of itself.
Like, there is a logic to why it actually is true.
It's not just that we have to bow down to this idea.
We can actually understand it and provide to the people: here's why it works.
And they did.
They wrote that, again, the point was: a society that tells an innocent man, regardless of your virtue, you will be punished, incentivizes a man to do whatever they can, regardless of honor, because they will be punished.
But a society that says even the guilty will get their chance tells a man of virtue, do your best, and we will protect you.
It creates an incentive for people to try and be good, trustworthy, and honorable, which, of course, a high trust society is a successful society.
So the Founding Fathers are literally basically like, Hey, you know, I know it says it, but when you think about it, it's true.
And so that's the basis by which I think if we were more informed of the roots of our ideology and laws and why they work, we would be much better off today.
And you could still have, like, we don't torture people, like, we do away with these things.
We have civil rights for people of different race.
You can have interracial marriage and all of that stuff.
These things are not restricted under a Christian worldview.
jakey botch
Do you think we torture people in Guantanamo Bay?
tim pool
Well, I mean, waterboarding is torture.
elad eliahu
Only people that deserve it.
tim pool
Guys, we got to go to the uncensored portion of the show where we got a special treat for you.
So smash the like button, share this show with everyone in your life you've ever met.
You can follow me on X and Instagram at Timcast.
Jake, do you want to shout anything out?
jakey botch
My Instagram, it's Jake Botch, ITS, Jake Botch, YouTube, Jake Botch, same content, kind of.
And TikTok, Jake Botch.
Jake Botch, everything.
tim pool
Jay, what do you got going on?
jay dyer
On my channel, we lecture through all the global elite texts.
We do this all the time.
We've done about 60 or 70 of them over the last 10 years.
Jay Dar on YouTube.
We're doing The Old Boys, The History of the OSS, and the CIA from the Council on Foreign Relations, authors themselves.
And right now, I have Esther Claywood 3.
This is my third book in my Hollywood trilogy, over a thousand pages on film symbolism, sex, cults, and symbols in film.
Go To The Uncensored 00:04:07
tim pool
Amazing.
unidentified
Nice.
jakey botch
I want to read that.
That's extremely interesting to me.
jay dyer
You got one.
elad eliahu
Good evening, everybody.
I hope you guys enjoyed the show.
I am Alad Eliyahu, the White House correspondent here.
Phil?
phil labonte
I am Phil That Remains on Twix.
The band is All That Remains.
You can check us out at allthatremainsonline.com.
We're going on tour this spring with Dead Eyes and with Born of Osiris.
We start in Albany on April 29th, go through the end of May.
You can check out All That Remains Music at Apple Music, Amazon Music, Pandora, Spotify, YouTube, and Deezer.
Don't forget the left lane is for crime.
Carter.
carter banks
What's up, everyone?
Carter Banks here.
You can follow me every at Carter Banks.
Follow our record label, Trash House Records, on YouTube.
Also, I want to get a shout out to Fox Era, this band called Micah Relicate.
I used to listen to a lot, dropped a song today, and I think it's really good.
I pinned it to my Twitter thing, so you can check it out there.
tim pool
Right on.
We will see you all over at rumble.com/slash Timcast IRL in about 30 seconds.
Thanks for hanging out.
phil labonte
Okay.
tim pool
Go.
unidentified
Yeah!
tim pool
All right, let's get it.
Hey, there we go.
Ladies and gentlemen, I give you the Hiles.
phil labonte
The Hiles?
unidentified
Oh, man.
tim pool
Wait, wait, hold on, hold on, hold on.
I screwed it up.
phil labonte
Hate to say it.
Rike and roll.
unidentified
Ah!
King, yeah, I want him.
Blitz and the cream stand in London Crease Marine Blake has surrendered.
Shannon free to head with the fear of a sitting, not bloody lenders.
They just say, I sold you so.
See, I'll soil.
tim pool
You believe I'm sold you so long for salute if you can't keep the pace without the text that the tweet says, We've crossed over into something, but I don't know what it is.
phil labonte
Followed.
tim pool
He misses Dr. Foxotic.
Save Yourself from Prince Andy 00:14:24
tim pool
What else has he got?
Bro, it's kind of wild that you could be like, you go to an AI thing and be just like make Hitler sing the vines and change the lyrics.
Oh, did it get banned on YouTube?
phil labonte
Of course it did.
tim pool
No, it got reinstated.
It's removed.
It's so dumb, it's a joke.
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
You know, oh, yeah, did you guys see this one?
unidentified
No.
jay dyer
It's Prince Andy.
unidentified
Save yourself from Prince Andy.
Oh, you clear the way to the old chamber.
Oh, you let us through.
It's the Prince of Windsor.
Lock up all your sons and your daughters, too.
Run away, here he comes, so to speak.
That's a pun tell.
Every gel to run, then hide, Prince Andy.
He always did a little bit of a children.
Later, Jeffrey is on the iron with Mrs. Gisley Maxwell.
Blue Clinton as well.
And the gates in Trump and Eel on the stand of steam.
Prince Andy, and says he, did he likes them on the younger side, there's no doubt.
Now try to ask yourself why.
Minos, private chefs and the like would email each other 50,000 times about Jesus, All paid for with taxpayer funds.
The sweatiest hands in all England.
One handshake and then you will be drenched from your head down until your toes exceed.
So it is headlined.
and kids to me scream but the royals can do what they want for the rest of you are we blunt come just not lucky as long as we're not getting here he's got 72 stops teddy bears seriously just he's got lawyers and sir the man up to him surely will end up like virginia
he's actually a good tool daughter's a sight to be known, And the devil is why he's decided to stop by.
He'll take her off your hand straight to the island.
They'll be her to amend and bury her in the sand, never to be seen or heard again.
tim pool
Commentary on, it's all the parts of the band, All right, We get it?
Uh, he actually does have 72 teddy bears.
jakey botch
Question for you now, with this whole entire thing, children, Epstein Island and everything do you think it's an actual fetish?
Do you think it's trying to hold things over other powerful people's head?
Do you think it's a adrenochrome that gives them special powers, like well, do you think they just really like being weird with children?
tim pool
Uh, there's a couple conspiracies.
The leading conspiracy theory right now is that uh, Les Wexner hired Epstein to be his criminal fixer and uh, I don't know if that's true, but uh, is Lex Wesler Mossad?
Or uh, he's a billionaire.
What, what did?
What did he do?
What company was?
jay dyer
He was the ceo Victorious Secret.
jakey botch
Yeah, there was a lot of things about Epstein being Mossad too.
tim pool
No uh, maybe that's because Ghilain Maxwell's dad was like uh Very, he wasn't overtly known to be like an agent, but he was treated like one when he died.
And so uh I I, I think it's fair to say uh, one of the theories, the first theories, was that he was, he would get dirt on powerful people to leverage against them for intelligence agencies.
However, right now many people are arguing, powerful people want to do illegal things and Jeffrey Epster was their guy.
So they, they basically bring this high school teacher Epstein, and say, you're gonna live like a king of an island and when we want something done, you you're the guy who gets it done and then all the bad stuff falls on you.
If it happens and Epstein's like wow, I get to be worth 500 million dollars, all I gotta do is evil shit.
And they go that way.
If you're the fall guy, the fall guy.
So why was Epstein acquiring these young girls?
Powerful men wanted wanted to bang young girls in a place where they're not gonna get caught.
jakey botch
Young Epstein was the 19 like, or 15, I know, but do you really think they like that, Those guys?
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
Fuck yeah, they did.
They're creepos.
They're fucking.
Then Ian's going to be like, well, they're actually hippophobiles.
Yeah, except for Epstein has been accused of procuring some kids who are as young as 10 years old.
And there are videos of 10-year-olds in these videos.
Like kids in bathtubs.
jakey botch
He's 70 years old.
Fucking a 22-year-old ain't enough for you.
tim pool
Even that's creepy.
I think that's like we all go like, okay, fine.
That's legal.
An adult can make their own decision.
jakey botch
No, that is creepy.
unidentified
That is.
jakey botch
That's 70.
That is creepy.
tim pool
Yeah.
So when we learned that, you know, Bill Gates, he admitted that he had that affair with those two Russian women.
So that corroborates what Epstein was saying in that email.
Epstein was like, Bill Gates got an STD and accidentally gave it to his wife.
Then he needed antibiotics to secretly give to his wife to cure her of the disease he gave her.
Holy shit.
So this is part of the theory that Epstein's existence was Bill Gates would go to him and say, I need antibiotics that no one can know about and a way to secretly give it to my wife.
And Epstein would be like, I'll do it.
And the billionaire.
jakey botch
You know what I mean?
Was it like the clap?
tim pool
It's probably the clap.
I mean, like, if he's going to slip antibiotics to her, it's going to be either gonorrhea or chlamydia.
The clap.
jakey botch
The clap.
Classic.
tim pool
Syphilis, maybe.
Yeah, but they got divorced.
So she figured something out.
jakey botch
And she became a really rich woman.
tim pool
Well, she was the whole time.
I mean, like, she's married to Bill Gates.
She's got a credit card.
You know what I mean?
Melinda Gates walks into a bank.
They'll give whatever the fuck she wants.
unidentified
Yeah.
jakey botch
Same thing with what's her name?
That broad Amazon Jeffrey.
tim pool
McKenzie Bezos.
jakey botch
What's wrong with him?
Why would he get married again?
unidentified
One.
jakey botch
I mean, I'm sure there's a lot of stipulations in that marriage, one.
But two, like, this guy always says, like, he's got so much money.
Why wouldn't he put a lot of money towards reshifting the laws towards men and marriages and getting just completely like you can't fix that?
Bro, these guys get killed.
tim pool
Well, I do think one of the biggest problems we have culturally is no-fault divorce.
jakey botch
That nobody's at fault?
tim pool
Basically, women win, is the way the law works.
So if a woman gets married to a guy and then decides she doesn't like it, she can get half his stuff and just leave.
jakey botch
That's crazy.
tim pool
Yeah.
So like the issue with the way divorce used to work was you can't just leave and a court could order you to therapy and like because it was like, hey, you can't, you know.
And the idea was the reason why the wife would get half your stuff in alimony is because she's not working to generate revenue.
The man is income.
But now if they, if they're divorced for a legitimate reason, the man is responsible.
Divorce requires something.
It required fault.
So the woman would be like, my husband is abusive.
Here's proof.
They'd say, okay, well, then you're free to go.
Like, this is wrong.
And now you got to pay your shit.
Or she'd be like, he cheated on me.
He's unfaithful.
Now it's just literally like a woman can be like irreconcilable.
jakey botch
Yeah, I don't like this anymore.
tim pool
Yep.
And then she's like, so I get his stuff.
Yo, you got to be a dumb guy, unfortunately, to marry a broad that you don't know and trust, that provides nothing.
Because then this is why, especially right now.
So I don't blame all the red pill guys who are like, don't get married.
jakey botch
People who you know and trust do you the same way?
It happens quite often when you feel you know and trust somebody and you get done.
tim pool
I think the issue is marriage used to be for all of humanity, you married someone you knew since you were a child.
unidentified
Yeah, yeah.
tim pool
So we have some cultures with arranged marriage where you're like 10 and you meet and they're like, you're going to get married to my family already.
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
And so it used to be you lived in a town of 300 people, you went to school, and then as you got older, like even in the 50s, you were dating the girl from your school, your high school square, you got married.
Today, the problem is, yeah, some dude from New York met this wacky from California who loves surfing, and he's a finance bro, but she's really hot and he has fun with her and he's like, this is amazing.
jakey botch
And they click after three months.
tim pool
And then they get married.
And then she goes, My plan for the future is to get a van and drive around the coast of California with our babies.
And he goes, He's like, Whoa.
Yeah, I'm not doing that.
I'm going to get a penthouse.
We're going to live in New York.
And she goes, Whoa, hold on a minute.
unidentified
F.
tim pool
So I look at it like this: you got, throughout human history, here's a guy, here's a chick, and here's their lives, and they're going like this.
And then they get married and they stay exactly where they are.
Today, you got a guy over here going like this, and then they go like that, and they get married.
Exactly.
So, I will say this for me and my wife.
We're both from Chicago.
We grew up listening to the same music.
We like the same restaurants.
We enjoy much of the same activities.
We are both lapsed Catholics.
It's like we've known each other for decades.
I have no concerns at all.
jakey botch
That she's going to wrench you in the end.
tim pool
Never going to happen.
She is the best person I know, and I can say that with ease.
I know that if I put on Alkaline Trio, she and I are going to sing the exact same song, that we know all the words to the same music.
I got to be honest.
jakey botch
You got lucky, though.
tim pool
I agree and disagree.
I got lucky in that I'm doing what humans have always done: marrying someone who grew up the same way as you with similar goals and desires.
Like we don't even argue about stuff because we're like the exact same way.
And so the arguments we have are usually just like, well, you know, if we do that, I mean, I'm not sure that will work.
Well, I think we have to because we'll do this.
And I go, well, okay, well, I see what you're saying.
It does make sense.
jakey botch
I think you have to work for that, but in a sense of luck, because it's so easy to fall for not that.
It's so easy to get into a situation where you guys aren't perfect for each other, but like you said, for this 30 minutes, whoa, this is really fun.
And you don't realize that 40 years is not the same as this 30 minutes.
I think it is beautiful and in a way lucky, but you do have to work for that.
And it is a people, bro, because it's such a beautiful thing to have.
tim pool
People also need to have these conversations before they get married.
Like, hey, my ultimate vision is I'm going to go A, B, C, D, and then what do you want to do?
Well, I want to do ABCF.
And it's like, you know, I compromise a little bit.
I could work with that.
I mean, I think we're, you know, like my wife very much wants to go skiing all the time.
And I said, then we'll figure out how we find a good opportunity for doing winter sports and doing skiing stuff.
I'm not a big skier.
I skateboard.
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
She doesn't skateboard.
jakey botch
Did you snowboard at all?
tim pool
Actually, I'm better at snowboarding than skiing.
jakey botch
Yeah, yeah, me too.
tim pool
So I like skiing, and I have fun.
I have a lot.
I love skiing.
unidentified
It's fun.
jakey botch
She won't let you snowboard in her ski?
Like, that's not the same thing.
tim pool
Well, no, I can do whatever I want.
I'm saying she's like, if someone said, do you plan on going skiing this year?
I go, I don't know.
If you go to her, she's like, yes, here are the times I'm going skiing.
And so I'm like, yeah, absolutely.
Have fun.
That'd be great.
And for our anniversary, she was planning on doing the ski trip.
And I said, no, no, like, why don't I go with you?
And then we'll do our anniversary dinner and everything.
And I'll go skiing.
And I was miserable at first because I'm not, I'm good enough at snowboarding, but we went to Jackson Hole, which is, are you familiar?
jakey botch
I'm pretty sure it's a hard place to ski.
tim pool
Exactly.
It's notorious for having limited beginner slopes.
And even the beginner slopes are a little like advanced.
So when I show up, I'm like, I ski maybe like three times.
I've skied maybe like three times in the past 10 years.
jakey botch
She's good.
tim pool
She's super good.
She's double black diamond jumping off mountains.
jakey botch
Oh, really?
unidentified
Yeah.
Wow.
tim pool
And so it's really funny when I'm like, are you going to come skiing with me on the greens?
jakey botch
And it's hysterical that you're not as good as her.
tim pool
And, you know, I'm good at skateboarding, but she's like, she's like flying.
She's jumping, cutting corners.
She's like, I'm going to go on the double black diamonds, but I'll come ski with you.
unidentified
Bro, that's ridiculous.
tim pool
So I told her, I was like, I got really pissed because I'm like, I'm going down the green just like people.
jakey botch
Snowboarding or skiing.
Why do you choose to ski if you could snowboard?
tim pool
So I'm better.
jakey botch
What I'm saying, like, is it the skiing way you guys?
Oh, it is.
tim pool
Skiing is way easier and more relaxing.
jakey botch
It is 100%.
It is work to snowboard, but aren't you good at it?
Aren't you like?
tim pool
I am good enough at snowboarding.
I can actually do some tricks.
jakey botch
Yeah.
But if you could do tricks, bro, you could get down a mountain.
tim pool
I just am bored.
Oh, I can easily get down a mountain.
I've gone on double black diamonds on a snowboard.
unidentified
Oh, all right.
Yeah, yeah.
tim pool
I can, I can rip on a snowboard.
I can do all sorts of crazy shit on a snowboard.
So you want to ski for it's it's so much easier, dude.
jakey botch
It is way more legal.
tim pool
You just put them on and you just stand there.
And so I'm like, if I put on the snowboard, I do, I snowboard once a year, and I'm going to have to get warmed up.
jakey botch
Yo, your legs can't take it.
tim pool
Well, I mean, I skate all the time.
So I don't really have a big yeah, but skating is bro.
jakey botch
Snowboarding is so much leaning and legs do it and then I go to get a drink and eat at the at the top.
I do it and then get back to the hill and I go, whoa, my legs aren't there anymore.
They're gone from underneath me.
tim pool
If someone said, we're like, if I don't know, so when we got there, I was like, I think I'd rather just snowboard because I want to just strap on and just go.
And I was like, yeah, but the problem is if I'm snowboarding, it's going to be a task.
jakey botch
Like, it's intense.
tim pool
I'm going to be actually trying to do things.
And I probably like jumping, maybe some grabs, some spins.
I just want to chill.
And I can put on the skis because I'm also pretty good at rollerblading.
And I can just stand.
I just go.
And then just be like.
jakey botch
You said you were pizza in the whole time?
tim pool
When I first got there, I was like, I need to get warmed up.
Where's the magic carpet?
And Alison's like, there isn't one.
And then I'm like, what?
And then we ask Guy, where's the beginner?
And he's like, right there.
And it's like.
unidentified
It's blue.
tim pool
No, well, it's next to a blue and notoriously difficult.
And there was no powder.
It was a lot of ice.
And I'm like, oh, I got to get warmed up on this.
So I was stressed the whole time.
I just, I'm skiing for the first time in a year.
Regina's Snowboarding Spins 00:05:55
tim pool
And so I was not happy.
And I said, I'm going to go to snowboard.
And then I was like, like, snowboarding's fine.
It's just with skis.
You go to the lift and you just sit.
unidentified
Yeah.
jakey botch
Oh, the snowboarding getting over, bro.
It hurts your knee.
tim pool
You're bending your leg and you're pushing.
jakey botch
And I'm like, you're going to tear your ACL at any moment.
tim pool
Yeah.
unidentified
Yeah.
jakey botch
It is such a pain in the ass snowboarding.
tim pool
And so I was like, I don't feel like snowboarding.
I just don't feel like it.
And there's, and there's traverses and there's flats, and I like having the poles.
And then I was like, you know what?
I'm just going to go chill.
And I said, all right, screw it.
I'll go skiing.
Let's just go to the top.
And then we went back to the top.
And then we literally, I was like, wait, what's that?
There were a bunch of little kids and they were going to the magic carpet.
Three runs in the magic carpet and I was warmed up and ready to go.
And then I skied the whole time with no problem.
jakey botch
Yeah.
tim pool
You just like, I can't just go on a green without having skied in a year.
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
Because it's just locking my muscles and I'm not, I can't do it.
jakey botch
Have you ever seen the little ski blades?
Like the oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Those are cool.
And now I've seen also the little bikes.
tim pool
Yep.
jakey botch
The tripod three wheels, not wheels, but three blades.
Those little blades and they ride the bike.
tim pool
Yeah, you know, to be honest, I might, we're actually going skiing soon.
And I might go snowboarding because I like doing tricks.
The problem is a lot of these places have traverses, which is like, it's a long flat.
unidentified
Yeah.
jakey botch
And that is, woof, you get a lot of stuff.
And then you just pull out measurable.
tim pool
Yeah, but I got a snowboard and it's the step-in.
It's great.
unidentified
What is that?
tim pool
You just stick your foot in and snap your foot down.
jakey botch
Yeah, it's not like the old school buckles and stuff.
Yes, yeah.
tim pool
But the skis are so much easier.
You just snap, snap, and you go.
So if I'm trying to just chill, skis are so easy.
jakey botch
The ski boots are horribly not comfortable, though, right?
tim pool
I think they're fine.
jakey botch
I heard snow boots, snowboarding boots are way better.
tim pool
Yeah, they're way more comfy.
Let's go to callers.
I'll start with Kelnan.
What's going on?
unidentified
Hey, thanks for taking my call tonight.
tim pool
Indeed.
unidentified
So my modest proposal for tonight to deal with the growing communism problem is to give them exactly what they want, but a twisted way.
Bring back McCarthyism on steroids, proceed to put them into labor camps consistently, and if they do not work, have escalating punishment that ultimately results in capital punishment.
Now, there will likely be many who do not wish to work, and therefore we will likely need an area such as a wall to deal with that.
jay dyer
Sold.
elad eliahu
And a re-education.
tim pool
Hey, I say, like, let's take a big, like 10,000-acre swath and call it Commutown and tell all the communists, this is yours to be a communist nation, special economic zone.
There.
And you know what will happen?
Nothing.
phil labonte
You listen to communists now talking about why Cuba is failing as always.
Well, the embargo, the embargo.
Why is it always that communists always need to trade with capitalist countries?
tim pool
You guys know that famous commune we've talked about, right?
Where it's like there's 100 people.
They only allow someone in.
If someone leaves, it can never be more than 100 people.
The funny thing is, it's a commune with an authority structure for admittance.
So it's not communism.
unidentified
Nope.
tim pool
It's impossible.
jakey botch
They don't accept anybody.
They don't accept everybody.
tim pool
We got border walls.
jay dyer
The company town.
unidentified
The problem is you keep mentioning they don't work.
That's why my proposal requires the work.
phil labonte
Look, you already sold me.
I'm already on your team.
tim pool
What if, hear me out, we promised all of the communists at, let's make a city.
Let's call it Chicago.
No, no, no, no.
Chicago's too big.
Let's say something like, hold on, hold on.
Give me a second.
I'm going to go to Google Maps real quick.
jakey botch
Small town.
tim pool
My is my proposal.
We are going to go to, let's find.
elad eliahu
Canada, please.
unidentified
Oh, yeah.
phil labonte
If it's in Canada, make it Regina.
No, it's a nation like we need to do.
Regina.
Regina.
tim pool
All right.
Let's go with.
Let's go with Yakuts, Oregon.
jay dyer
Canada is a giant vagina.
unidentified
It is.
tim pool
So let's go to Newport, Oregon.
unidentified
All right.
tim pool
And what we'll do is we'll eminent domain all the people who live there.
It's not a very big place, but it's big enough.
Everyone who lives there.
Let me pull this up.
This is going to be great.
You guys are going to love it.
Newport, Oregon.
Let's see how many people live there.
I'm hoping it's like 30,000.
10,000.
Okay.
We're going to eminent domain it.
Everybody's going to get a beautiful, beautiful compensation package.
The best sub-say, better than anyone's seen.
And I think maybe a million dollars on top.
And they can move out.
We give the communists Newport, Oregon, move them all in, and then shell it.
jakey botch
Let's see how it works.
phil labonte
Get by with a little help from Artie.
The king of battle.
tim pool
Indeed.
unidentified
Yeah.
elad eliahu
Like a helicopter ride.
tim pool
Here's what we can do.
We can have a big, free theme park with helicopter rides, only self-proclaimed communists.
The helicopters go up and they bring you to the communist paradise.
And when it comes back, it's empty because we dropped you off.
phil labonte
I'm loving all of this.
tim pool
If there's one thing I have to praise Stalin and Mao for doing, it's killing communists.
phil labonte
Communists killed a lot of commies.
tim pool
They did.
jakey botch
What was that?
tim pool
No one killed more communists than Mao, right?
jakey botch
How did he kill communists if he was like kind of what?
I don't get that.
elad eliahu
First, he ruled with an iron fist, and that killed a lot of people, and he had to persecute a lot of people to secure his place as the leader and the dictator.
But then unfortunately, communism leads to a lot of famine and ends up killing a ton of people.
And then he also famously used this as a weapon of war against the Ukrainians.
Really, Stalin did in the Holden War by not giving them food, right?
Export Selection