All Episodes
Jan. 9, 2021 - Timcast IRL - Tim Pool
02:48:16
Timcast IRL - Trump Has Been PERMANENTLY BANNED, Democrats WILL Impeach w/ Minds CEO
Participants
Main voices
b
bill ottman
23:48
i
ian crossland
20:01
l
luke rudkowski
32:18
t
tim pool
01:29:01
Appearances
l
lydia smith
01:01
| Copy link to current segment

Speaker Time Text
unidentified
you you
tim pool
you ladies and gentlemen I'm not sure what the biggest news of
the day is but But apparently it is that Donald Trump has been permanently
banned from Twitter.
They've outright removed his account.
All of his tweets just gone.
Memory hold censored.
Out of there.
The reason I say I don't know the biggest news story of the day is because the Democrats also announced they are going to be impeaching the president on Monday.
Things are getting just very, very weird.
So we heard that Apple and Google were threatening parlor.
that if they didn't overhaul their moderation or introduce heavy moderation, they would remove
Parler from the app stores. I don't know exactly what's going on, but I can tell you I pulled up
the Google Play store and Parler ain't there. So maybe it's already happened because we actually
have one of the experts, not to mention Ian is an expert as well, on social media censorship and
moderation. We've got Bill Ottman, CEO of Minds, MINDS.com, one of these other social media platforms
which has a unique approach to rule breaking and censorship and stuff, the jury system, right?
Yep.
bill ottman
Juries, I mean, why not empower the community to help moderate?
And imagine if Facebook, Twitter, they took their tens of thousands of moderators and actually proactively engaged with people who have mental issues or are extreme.
We have to realize that Extreme psychology is just something that exists, and we have to deal with it in a way that's not banning them off the platforms.
tim pool
Well, because then what happens now is they're saying, you're going to get banned, everybody goes to Parler, and so then the big companies attack the infrastructure that allows people to even find Parler.
But everybody, as you know, Ian, who is a regular on the show.
ian crossland
Hello, yes.
tim pool
You ran moderation.
ian crossland
Yeah, I co-founded Minds with Bill.
Technically, I came in, what, six months after you guys had it.
bill ottman
2010.
No, no.
20, like a year.
ian crossland
It was with the OG developer.
And that was really fun.
It was before Jon got involved.
And it was just me and you in Jon's basement, you know, talking about where the future of tech is going to be in 2010-ish.
Then we went to Occupy Wall Street.
I think we were all at Occupy Wall Street, actually.
tim pool
But you were the band hammer.
You were removing these awful Trump supporters, just getting rid of them, saying, you can't like Trump, you gotta get out of here.
bill ottman
So the way it would work is if an admin on Mines makes a wrong decision, then a user can appeal it, and then it goes to random 12 users who vote on it.
And so we launched a jury system to keep ourselves in check.
tim pool
Yeah, I think you got to have more than 12 people though, because like, there's margin of error, I guess.
But I understand the 12.
bill ottman
No, no, that's a variable.
tim pool
Because like, you know, you know, what I see happening is not first of all, I'll say that's like an excellent system.
But I see what I see happening is look at Twitter, you know, they keep banning Trump supporters.
Eventually, the 12 people you're going to get are going to be one political ideology who are going to be like, yeah, ban him.
ian crossland
In the early days, it was just me.
I would be sitting in a queue, looking at stuff, and be like, okay, our policy is we only ban it if it violates the U.S.
Constitution.
So I have to define the U.S.
Constitution for each post.
I have to, like, make these Supreme Court judgment calls.
It was insane stress for one human to have to go through.
tim pool
But, like, you probably saw pictures where you're like, that's easy, gone.
ian crossland
Yes, there were easy ones and there were really hard ones.
And this is what they're doing.
But can we just say that someone's saying go kill that guy?
tim pool
Well, that's illegal.
ian crossland
No, it's not imminent.
So imminent threat is different than a threat.
bill ottman
They changed it from imminent to true threat.
Who did?
One time we got contacted by Pennsylvania and they were telling us that legally true threat is the language.
ian crossland
How do you know if someone's being sarcastic half the time?
Sarcasm is out the window.
Sarcasm, by the way, guys, does not fly on social media and text.
Do not be sarcastic in text because they will define it as not sarcastic for the sake of moderation.
tim pool
Absolutely.
All right.
So we'll get into all this stuff because, well, you know, not to bury everything in the intro, but Luke is hanging out, of course.
luke rudkowski
Yeah.
Talking about sarcasm, I just wanted to say I'm so happy that our tech overlords, unaccountable multinational corporations with unlimited power are not keeping us safe.
I think We all needed to be safe from, you know, words and sounds and speech from our little small little ears and our feeble minds and especially words from democratically elected government officials.
I feel safe just like if I would be in the Matrix in that little bubble energy blanket.
unidentified
Luke, Luke, Mark Zuckerberg is successful.
tim pool
Okay, it is by merit that he has gained the power to shut down the President of the United States.
luke rudkowski
Yes, and I'm saying, I'm so happy he did this because I'm safe from, you know, the bad words and sounds and, you know, we're so safe that you don't have to go to wearechange.org and in the right top hand corner put in your email.
You could definitely follow me on all the mainline channels under We Are Change, so you got nothing to worry about.
We're safe and happy and protected now.
unidentified
That's right.
luke rudkowski
What are you talking about?
tim pool
All right.
unidentified
All right.
tim pool
Look, the president, there's a ton of stuff going on.
But beyond all of this, I think we are looking at the exponential escalation.
Joe Biden went on TV and he likened Hawley and Cruz, two sitting U.S.
senators, to Goebbels.
This is Absolutely off the rails, and it's not a joke.
What we saw yesterday, I have some ideas about what I think is going to happen and what I'm really worried about, but it's going to get bad.
All right, so we'll start the show.
We're going to talk about Trump being banned permanently because there's a lot of questions here.
This is a removal of historical record.
Before we get to finishing introductions, of course, don't forget Lydia's here.
lydia smith
I am here.
I'm pushing all the buttons over in the corner.
tim pool
And now that we've had that long introduction, because everybody wanted to, you know, we have so much to talk about, let's just jump to the first story.
From CNBC, Twitter permanently suspends Trump's account.
They say, the company said in a tweet it made the decision due to the risk of further incitement of violence, saying after a close review of recent tweets from the from real Donald Trump account and the context around them, we have permanently suspended the account due to the risk of further incitement of violence.
The suspension accounts to a ban.
Trump can no longer access his account, and his tweets and profile picture have been deleted.
Trump had 88.7 million followers prior to his suspension.
Institutional accounts like POTUS and White House are still active.
So what if he tweeted through at POTUS something ridiculous?
bill ottman
Why wouldn't he?
You don't think he's going to?
ian crossland
I hope he does.
tim pool
He still has access to Twitter.
Maybe.
And he has the POTUS account.
It's at P-O-T-U-S.
ian crossland
They would suspend it until Biden got inaugurated and then they'd reinstate it.
lydia smith
Probably.
tim pool
Yeah.
They say it's a step Twitter has resisted taking for all of Trump's presidency.
While President Barack Obama was the first president to use Twitter, he mainly used the institutional POTUS account and did not rely on it as heavily as Trump has to get his message out.
Trump used his personal Twitter account to stoke supporters and even make personnel changes before they can even make it to the press release.
Yeah, you know what it was?
This allowed Trump to bypass the media and they hated him for it.
Now I'll tell you, we got a lot of questions here.
This was a historical record, the things that the president had been tweeting.
But before we bring that up and those issues, let me tell you, Donald Trump I cannot believe the biggest mistake made, and I don't necessarily blame him.
He's an old guy, you know.
He's not social media savvy.
He is pretty savvy for his age, and I'm not trying to disparage, you know, people who are older.
He could have, at any moment, tweeted out to 88.7 million people, follow me on Parler, follow me on Minds, follow me anywhere else.
And then he could have had those 88.7 million choose to go somewhere else.
In fact, just by posting on any of these other platforms, many people would have said, what did he say?
Where did he say it?
Let's go check it out.
The media would be forced to cover it.
He didn't do it.
Now there are reports that Donald Trump has joined Parler, and this is according to Fox News' Sean Hannity.
Parler is currently being hugged to death, is what they say.
What it basically means is so many people are flocking to Parler that the traffic is kind of overloading it, making it slow and hard to use.
I've had no problem logging... Well, I've had a little trouble logging, but once I got logged in, it seemed like everything was fine, so they must be dealing with it.
But it's something Trump could have done a long time ago.
Now, I guess we should just start by talking about the historical precedence of Jack Dorsey and Mark Zuckerberg and these tech CEOs having the ability to tell the president, you cannot speak to the American people.
bill ottman
Well, why is it that an avalanche of bans happen every time?
It's just like, is there communication happening between them?
Is it social pressure?
Like, what do you think is really going on here?
tim pool
I think they're all cowards.
And then when one network says, we have to remove this, all of the rest of them go, now it's safe for us to do.
luke rudkowski
Another thing we really have to understand here is that this is a transition of power.
Speech is power.
And if you're not able to talk to your supporters, if you have a whole political party that right now is voiceless, that's a major step in what I believe in an extremely wrong direction.
The last time we had censorship, the major censorship story, was of course the Hunter Biden story.
It was wrong.
They were wrong about that story.
They censored it for, I believe, in my own opinion, political needs.
And then it came out that, oh yeah, the Hunter Biden story was true all along.
tim pool
After the election.
luke rudkowski
After the election.
After, of course, Joe Biden, you know, I don't even want to... We've got to be careful with our language here.
tim pool
After the election was called for Joe Biden, the story popped back up in the media.
luke rudkowski
Yeah.
This is, I mean, in my opinion, 1984 just happened today.
Wonder Woman 1984?
ian crossland
No, not that one.
Is that a coincidence?
tim pool
Unless, of course, it was Joe Biden who grabbed the Dreamstone and said, I want to be president!
The whole world's on fire.
luke rudkowski
A lot of this is being done, allegedly, for your safety, but let's not disguise it.
Let's not lie about it.
This is essentially political and cultural dominance.
That's exactly what it is.
This whole system was abused before, and this is the continuation of that abuse of power.
tim pool
I'll tell you what I said.
It's a major political party.
Demanding of massive, multinational, billion-dollar corporations the removal of their political opposition.
It's a cultural coup.
They are removing their opposition from the discourse, period.
And it's been happening for some time, and this is the most dramatic escalation.
We saw back in, what was it, 2018, when they got rid of, like, Jones and, like, Milo Yiannopoulos.
And they targeted certain people.
That was, you know, a slow uptick.
Now, it is the most dramatic.
People, high-profile personalities, not just on the right, are reporting they're losing thousands of followers.
We can't actually see the level by which this purge is happening.
The censorship is bigger than just the president, and it could be even hundreds of thousands of people.
luke rudkowski
I mean, I think I just lost a thousand followers on Twitter myself, but we can't say that we didn't see this coming.
I mean, just even, what was it, a couple weeks ago, we were talking about this very topic, And we talked about, will Donald Trump be banned?
And we both agreed and said, yes, Donald Trump's going to be banned.
Our timeline was wrong because we said after the inauguration.
tim pool
No, I disagreed.
I said they would lose too much money.
Early on, I thought they would totally do it because they hate the guy.
But then I started talking to people who said, you know, look at their user base.
It was in decline before Trump.
So I think someone mentioned Twitter stock went down when they banned Trump.
Like, it's probably going to plummet.
In my opinion, I'm not, you know, I don't own any stock in Twitter, but I imagine it would go down because Trump made that platform.
luke rudkowski
It didn't take a genius to understand that this was going to be their crisis.
This was going to be the event that they use, that they're going to exploit, and that they're going to purposefully inflate as a major threat.
And that's exactly what they're doing.
They're doing it very disingenuously.
And they're doing it on a bed of lies.
And that's another important aspect here.
Nothing good is done based on a huge foundation of lies.
So we have to understand that this huge major move, this huge transition of power, all is
happening under fake pretenses.
And it's worrying.
bill ottman
They are engineering.
echo chambers. This is a global echo chamber.
luke rudkowski
And radicalization.
bill ottman
And radicalization. And see, the studies show evidence actually on both sides. It is true
that social media can cause you to go down a rabbit hole of ideology. But it is also
true that communication and social media is the only way you can become de-radicalized.
So there's evidence on both sides, but the overwhelming evidence shows that there's massive
blowback of censorship.
You're shutting down dialogue, which is our only option other than taking it to other levels.
luke rudkowski
Our only option for de-escalation is communication, is being able to hear people out, and not putting people on the fringe.
More people are going to be on the fringe, and more people who are on the fringe are only going to become fringier.
tim pool
It's not the fringe anymore.
It's when when they start banning your run-of-the-mill conservatives who voice their support for the president
You don't like the president you can disagree with them These are not like you got a lot of regular people and what
you're doing is we I think we talked about before bill It's actually I think I mentioned we talked about it on Joe
Rogan You take a regular person and he gets arrested for pot and
you put him in prison with hardened criminals And you are guess what happens to that person
You know, you take some young person who's like, you know, first charge, they go to prison, and now they're around all the, you know, burglars, robbers, murderers, and that's what you're doing.
You're putting people in these environments.
luke rudkowski
It's 70 million.
It's 70 plus million people.
unidentified
75.
luke rudkowski
75 million plus people that voted for Donald Trump.
And again, last night, I said on the show, the censorship is about to reach levels that we have never seen before.
We are here today.
And again, it's only going to get worse.
Sorry, Ian, I cut you off.
ian crossland
No, it's okay, man.
Brandon Strock.
I don't know if you're familiar.
He does the walk away campaign.
Hashtag walk away.
His campaign was banned off.
Off Twitter.
This is like a kind hearted, good dude.
And he's the kind of guy that if you bust him for pot and put him in prison with a bunch of criminals, he's going to get twisted.
And so they banned him.
They banned his entire Facebook page campaign of, I don't know, 50,000 people.
lydia smith
All his people.
ian crossland
All his volunteers and employees have now been banned off Twitter or off Facebook.
luke rudkowski
This is another thing.
Books are being unpublished.
There's even Democratic committees calling for no-fly lists for individuals who are a part of the right.
I mean, this is a new level of authoritarianism.
It's here.
It's real.
tim pool
I remember I had a conversation with Joe Rogan, Vijay Gadde, and Jack Dorsey.
On The Joe Rogan Experience.
I think I remember that one.
At the end of the episode, I said, if you keep doing this, it is going to get really bad in this country.
What you are doing, and then what did we see all throughout this year, and what did we just see in the Capitol?
And then I said, I'm gonna build a van!
And they all laughed, and everybody laughed.
unidentified
I got emails, they're like, oh you crazy dick, you're gonna go build a van, nothing's gonna happen!
tim pool
Where are we now?
So here's what I think.
I think we're not looking at a linear path of escalation.
I think we're looking at an exponential path of escalation.
We went from a bunch of people in D.C., many of them breaking into the Capitol, which I think was ridiculous and stupid.
People are now dead.
A cop was bashed over the head.
That's insane.
But many of these people walked right in.
There's videos where the cops open the door.
And one cop says that he agrees with their right to protest.
And as they waltz on in, some of these people are bewildered.
I saw that and I thought to myself that the initial reaction will be overwhelmingly negative.
Now I think because of the mass purge, you're going to start seeing an overwhelmingly positive reaction from people who feel like they've been excised from society.
So there were a lot of people posting on Twitter that they felt that their opinions were watered down out of fear of being banned.
Well, don't worry!
Twitter just did the hard work for you.
Now these people have been kicked off after they said they followed the rules.
Not everybody did.
A lot of people being banned are, like, you know, advocating for some crazy stuff.
But there are a lot of people who are saying things like, well, I shouldn't say anything, you know, and there's tweets saying, I think we're all holding back.
They get banned.
Now what?
Okay, I guess there's no point anymore.
So here's what I think.
I think after what we saw, the immediate reaction was insane.
You've got politicians like Cori Bush and AOC demanding the expulsion of Republicans that supported Trump.
Simon & Schuster, a major book publisher, announced they're breaking their contract with Senator Josh Hawley.
He challenged them, saying he's going to sue them.
This is, I mean, it's dramatic escalation where the culture is being split.
People are being demonized at an ever-increasing rate.
And now we've come to the point where you actually have Joe Biden going on TV and likening two sitting U.S.
senators to Nazi propagandists.
This level of demonization and dehumanization is the precursor to horrifying things.
I'll spare some of the more hyperbolic words, but when you look back at history, historical civil wars, the start of major wars, this is the kind of thing that happens just before.
And what do you think's gonna happen when the incoming president announces,
the Wall Street Journal reported this, sweeping new domestic terror laws, Joe Biden's announced,
while calling sitting Republicans, likening them to Nazi propagandists.
What do you think that demonization will lead to?
The demands for expulsion.
Do you think that the Republicans are gonna be like, we're so sorry, Democrats?
No, the supporters are being forced into a totally different echo chamber reality
where people are angry.
We had David Cross tweet that he wanted blood.
Whether it was a joke or whatever the point was.
unidentified
Yeah, we don't know.
ian crossland
That's the problem.
tim pool
Don't know, don't care.
Sarcasm doesn't work on the internet, I guess.
ian crossland
Not in text.
bill ottman
It's similar to Sacha Baron Cohen being, you know, so pro.
Yeah, it's like, don't you understand that comedians need to be protected too?
This is coming for you.
luke rudkowski
Yeah, people don't understand.
People on the left, you're going to be affected by this sooner or later.
As soon as your paths cross the establishment and the talking points and the narrative that they want to push, I don't care who you are.
It could even happen to BLM.
BLM still hasn't had their meeting with Biden.
Last I saw in a couple days, I don't know if I may stand corrected here.
But anyone could stand in the way of this big, unaccountable, totalitarian monster that holds one of the biggest sacred powers in the world.
One of the things that makes America great, more than any other place in the world, is our free speech.
Once you get rid of that, once you limit that, once you stop allowing people the ability to freely communicate with each other, we are in uncharted territories where it is ripe for abuse.
bill ottman
The heartbreaking thing, Tim, that you kind of alluded to is that regular Democrats and Republicans cannot even speak to each other.
tim pool
Families are being torn apart There is a tweet from a young woman ratting out her mom for being at a protest, I think the precursor protest, not the one at the Capitol but the night before, saying, this is my mom, here's her name, here's my dad, and then the mom got fired.
That's crazy stuff.
They're breaking up families.
ian crossland
Do you see the USA Today article where they put out 29 pictures of people that were at the Capitol?
If you can help us find their names and phone numbers, give us their information and help us find these criminals.
tim pool
Remember when Andy Ngo just tweeted out, this individual has been arrested?
And the left said he is creating kill lists and doxing people.
And they started smearing him and attacking him.
And now media across the country is putting up people's names saying, find them, find them.
Sure, criminals, people accused of committing crimes, by all means, send your tips.
But I'm talking about the double standard.
Andy Ngo would simply be like, the police arrested this individual, and then they would attack him for it.
Then you get the media coming out now saying, we don't know who these people are or what they were doing.
In fact, what if some of these people were credentialed journalists?
Elijah Schaefer, for instance, of Blaze TV, a reporter, was getting attacked relentlessly by people on social media.
I'll admit, some of his tweets were a little bombastic.
He had one tweet where he called it a revolution?
Okay, dude, chill.
But he is a credentialed member of the press who works for the Blaze TV.
He got banned by Facebook, probably because of these hit pieces.
And then only after I think Glenn Beck came out and said, you know, and complained about it, they reinstated him.
That's the danger of publishing a face and then saying, find him!
Because we all saw what happened after the Boston bombing on Reddit.
When all these good-hearted Redditors said, we must find these criminals, and they ended up doxing random innocent people.
That's the problem.
So you have Andy Ngo.
Here's the persons whose picture, they were arrested on this charge, and they threaten him, and they attack him, and they accuse him of doxxing, and he's a villain.
He's a bad guy.
Now the media is totally on board.
Totally okay with going even beyond that and saying, identify these people.
And they're doing it.
They're doing it.
They're doing, you know, they're publishing names.
bill ottman
And here's the problem.
There's no actual empirical data or evidence that shows what they're doing is making the world a safer place.
In fact, the opposite.
And so what we're actually trying to do is on a 10-year basis, AB test.
AB test a strategy and see who can have a higher rate of de-radicalization.
Here's the thing.
We are going to be able to prove that we have a higher rate of de-radicalization on minds because you cannot de-radicalize someone that you have just banned.
Their rate of de-radicalization will be zero And I say this all the time.
tim pool
If if you have somebody who does bad things and then one day they come out and they apologize,
accept their apology.
I mean, maybe not the second or third time, you know, it's up to you.
But if someone's like, you know, I shouldn't have been doing those things, please accept my apology. You say yes.
Please come join us doing the right thing. If you don't, they'll say that I have no opportunity
but to go to anyone who will be willing to accept me.
So if you've got someone who makes hate speech and they're, you know,
they're going on Twitter and they're saying rabble rabble and offensive words,
and you decide the best way to get rid of them is to ban them.
The only place they can go is to where everyone agrees with them, and they're allowed to, you know, say whatever they want.
If you truly don't want them to believe these things, the best thing you can do is talk to them.
Like that woman from the Westboro Baptist Church.
That was on Twitter, right?
People started reaching out to her, and then she flipped from being a member of this church to being like, hey, that was wrong, I shouldn't have been saying these things.
People really changed my mind and were nice to me.
I don't think they want this.
This is what I think, you know, in my opinion, I think they want the violence.
Ted Cruz came out and said, we all need to put the anger aside and come together.
And AOC responded by saying, no, you should be expelled from Congress.
OK, well, that's just going to make things worse.
He literally said, can we put the anger aside and come together?
And you attacked him for it.
To score brownie points on the Internet or whatever, I guess.
So then Ted Cruz has no opportunity whatsoever to come together with anyone.
So they won't.
And then his followers won't either.
And then the hyperpolarization continues.
CNN getting 9 million, you know, viewers.
Their biggest ever.
And you have this handoff between Cuomo and Don Lemon where they're scoffing and insulting and berating and degrading.
Instead of being calm and serious.
Even Shep Smith.
Get that off the TV!
We're not showing this!
That's not true!
That is not how you handle conflict.
These people have no idea what they're doing.
luke rudkowski
Yeah, the only answer to bad speech is good speech.
And if you start to limit it, you again, putting people on the fringe and you're starting to expand it.
I remember during the kind of infancy of the internet and kind of growing up in that day and age and thinking, this is absolutely incredible.
This is an amazing tool that allows people to speak to each other.
And then I realized, just like any kind of great technological advancement, it's a tool, it's a weapon, it's a sword, and it has blades that go both ways.
And just like it has the potential to help people, it has the potential to hurt a lot of people.
And now we're seeing a huge backswing.
I remember, I remember warning about this all the way back in 2008.
I have We Are Change videos on my channel warning in 2008 saying, hey, They're already starting to turn on the boilers.
The water is starting to get warm here.
And look what they did here.
They did it very methodically.
They did it very slowly.
They didn't just ban everyone all at once.
tim pool
Or they're starting to actually now.
luke rudkowski
Now, we're seeing the first bubbles in that pot.
Now, we're starting to turn a little bit of a different color.
It's too late.
tim pool
Here's what I want y'all to understand.
What Twitter is doing, what Facebook is doing, and YouTube is doing, is actually diminishing their ability to control anything, and will result in substantial chaos.
If there are 100 people in a room, and you have rules, and some of those people break the rules, then you can slowly start to remove some of those people, or you can compromise and say, here's what we'll accept and here's what we won't.
And what happens is, If you decide to ban 10 people, now you have 10 people in one room and 90 in the other, and you have no say over what those 10 people are doing.
We're going to come to the point where Twitter has half of the people in one room and half in the other, and then it's going to be two equal-sized rooms with no control over the other side.
No ability to influence or de-radicalize or communicate at all, and that's when the clash happens.
bill ottman
And the chilling effect, you're talking about friends who are just deleting all their posts because they're scared they're going to get banned now.
And I mean, the psychological impact that it has just on the people who are allowed to be there.
And Snowden has brought this up with, you know, how surveillance impacts your brain and how you want to communicate.
luke rudkowski
He said today is a major turning point in history.
tim pool
Snowden did.
luke rudkowski
Yeah.
Go ahead.
Sorry.
bill ottman
No, yeah, but it's just the chilling effect and the mass sort of social, psychological implications that this has, like, in the herd mentality when everybody's posting, like, either in support of it or against it, but, like, at the end of the day, all that matters is data.
What actually works?
And they're not publishing.
They know this.
tim pool
They know this.
They have to be able to see that what they're doing is making things worse.
And they have to know this.
There's no way.
They've seen it before.
They've banned people before.
They've seen the reaction.
And they have to... You know what it is?
Maybe they don't have the data from external platforms.
But I'll tell you this.
Anyone with a brain can take a look at the bannings they did, and then the chaos that ensued yesterday, and be like, hey, remember two years ago when you banned all these people?
How did that work for you?
Now they're on Parler, and you have no control at all.
You've given it up.
You've said, go do your thing.
They could have compromised.
Well, now we have the next level of how insane this gets.
Confirmation from Axios.
Google suspends Parler from App Store after deadly capital violence.
This is not gonna stop it.
It's a simple APK download, okay?
Google takes it out of the Play Store, and then they put it up on their website.
So when you open your phone, and you go to parlor.com, eventually at some point, I assume, it'll say, download the APK, you'll click it, boom, you got it.
What does removing it from the Play Store do?
bill ottman
It slows things down, significantly.
I mean, we were suspended from Google Play and App Store for like six months.
So you go to minds.com slash mobile and get the mobile app.
Now you can get the APK or you can get us in the app stores.
But like, you know, that hurt us and it will hurt Parler.
And, you know, it's and the thing is that it's become too polarized.
It's like the left, you know, Twitter, the left wing social network, Parler, the right wing social network.
It's like it need we need from a high level at the companies to be having serious conversations, live streaming and saying, how are we going to bring this community together?
How are we going to deal with these people?
tim pool
Or a nationalized social media.
ian crossland
Or a globalized one.
One that follows the U.S.
Constitution that we create.
I mean, it will be globalized.
It can be anybody in the world can use it.
tim pool
And it will follow the U.S.
Constitution.
ian crossland
Yes.
tim pool
I don't think they would ever, ever.
ian crossland
And an app we need, a website, social network that does it, and we need an ISP that follows the U.S.
Constitution that's not a private company.
tim pool
So let me read a little bit of this.
this, they say, quote, in order to protect user safety on Google Play, our longstanding
policies require that apps displaying user generated content have moderation policies
and enforcement that removes egregious content like posts that incite violence.
Jose Castaneda, a Google spokesperson, said, in light of this ongoing and urgent public
safety threat, we are suspending the apps listing from the Play Store until it addresses
these issues.
What does that mean?
You're not allowed to incite violence on Parler.
They'll ban you for it.
No joke.
In fact, Parler's got very strict rules.
My understanding is that they operate on what's called a broadcast standard, meaning you actually can't say certain things that are free speech.
And that's the way they run their platform.
bill ottman
I mean, it's a Gab 2.0 situation, basically.
And the problem, you know...
Free speech policies every network should have, but like the fact that there's, you know, there are privacy issues and transparency issues with Parler.
I'm just gonna, you know, be upfront about that.
Like, their code is not open source.
You can't see their algorithms.
If you're listening guys, open source your code.
Like...
Networks have to be open source, otherwise it's not viable in the long term.
tim pool
I don't know if the Fediverse is the answer, we've talked about it before, but some kind of decentralized, federated social network.
The way it would work, it's very simple, this is how the Fediverse works, is that you don't have to use Parler.
You would use just Fediverse apps, a regular old app you download, and then you sign into your server or their server or whatever server, and it connects all the different companies into one social media system.
bill ottman
Yeah, the Fediverse is great.
It's the ActivityPub protocol, which Mastodon uses, which many sites are integrating.
There's another one, Polaroma.
We're working on ActivityPub integration.
It's taken way too long for us to do it.
It's a great protocol.
The problem with it, though, is that when you subscribe to someone on another node, the comment threads don't work.
Right.
So it's sort of messy.
It's still good, and it's a step in the right direction, but it's not truly decentralized social media because the admins can still ban the whole node.
tim pool
They can cut off, like, if there was a networked gab connected to mines, one platform could cut off the other platform.
unidentified
Right.
tim pool
Yeah.
Well, the idea is preliminary, I suppose.
But how do we get to the point where if I choose to follow the president for his updates, no one can take that away, ever?
ian crossland
I think they call it Internet 2.0.
The Tron network was working on something like that.
bill ottman
Well, that's what we integrated with the PermaWeb, with the Arweave blockchain.
Basically, you have the option when you post to post to the PermaWeb.
Obviously, you don't want every post to be permanent.
But the reality is that we're moving into a blockchain decentralized world.
And that is a little bit scary.
tim pool
So Ethereum is going to skyrocket.
bill ottman
Ethereum.
tim pool
Yeah, I just bought some.
unidentified
32.
tim pool
But you bring up a blockchain.
I think what a lot of people need to realize is that a lot of these networks that use crypto, they're built off of the Ethereum cryptocurrency.
bill ottman
And there are some other amazing decentralized social networks like Scuttlebutt is fully decentralized.
It's sort of like techie and tough to use, but it is fully decentralized.
So it's on your machine, everything.
ian crossland
So regarding the Arweave network, if you were to post something on the Arweave blockchain and then you owned that post and it was there forever, could it then generate crypto tokens for every view that it accrued?
bill ottman
That's not how their system works, but I mean, theoretically, you could build whatever you want.
luke rudkowski
I remember at Burning Man, some people started to do peer-to-peer Bluetooth communications.
tim pool
Yeah.
I was on a cruise and they told everyone when you come on to download this app, I forgot what it was called, but you turn on Bluetooth and then it is the craziest thing.
You can walk past one person and all the data is being transmitted from like my app to their app.
And then when they walk past another person, it bounces to like five more people and then created this mesh internet.
where if I was standing ten feet from you, you were ten feet from me and Ian was ten feet from, you know,
you know, Bob Smith, and then Bob Smith sent a message, it would relay through everyone to me.
bill ottman
Absolutely. Yeah, local networks. That's amazing.
And that's really important for countries that don't have serious infrastructure.
luke rudkowski
Yeah. Well, also in the United Kingdom, when rock and roll was banned,
what they started to do is literal pirate ships.
They had ships that would broadcast, uh, rock and roll.
bill ottman
Oh, I saw that movie.
luke rudkowski
Yeah.
Pirate radio.
There's, there's, you know, there's whole movies about this.
You know, censorship throughout history is something that is more common than uncommon.
So we have to understand, you know, this is going towards a trend that I don't want to be on.
tim pool
Well, so here's what's going to happen.
The left controls the cultural institutions.
So a political coup, in my opinion, is totally meaningless.
It is.
What we're seeing right now is... Actually, I'll step back.
As they say, politics downstream from culture.
By getting rid of all of the voices that can, you know, propagate certain ideas, those ideas cease to exist.
That's it.
They're gone.
They've been slowly and methodically removing certain ideas and certain people from these platforms.
luke rudkowski
And they've been doing it for a very long time.
And I remember they were doing it to individuals that I didn't like.
I didn't agree with.
I didn't identify with.
I was like, yeah, I don't like these guys too, but...
But I don't think their voice should be censored.
And I've been saying that consistently from the very beginning, but they used our own fears, our own emotions against us to justify it slowly and surely.
And now we're here today.
ian crossland
I think the argument is it can't be stopped.
Like, it is downstream from culture and the technology.
So we need a technological revolution that will prevent anyone from being able to do that.
bill ottman
It is happening, but that's why it's crazy Bitcoin's hitting all-time highs today.
I mean, that is the decentralized infrastructure for the new system.
Yeah, it's incredible.
tim pool
What does a Bitcoin get you in terms of that system, though?
bill ottman
You can do things on top of Bitcoin as well.
There are projects that are trying to build Layer 2 solutions on top of different blockchains.
luke rudkowski
This is the thing.
It's an encryption peer-to-peer technology, and it's something new like the printing press.
So when the printing press came out, everyone in the beginning was like, oh, this is nothing, this is an old machine, this is not gonna do anything.
But it revolutionized.
the way people gathered information Bitcoin is ...
revolutionizing the way people transact and just like the ...
internet double-edged sword could go either way could go ...
towards the total Venezuelan Russian cryptocurrency ...
track trace and database system or it could go towards a ...
decentralization Liberty Sovereignty Freedom ...
technology that helps people be individuals helps me will be ...
tim pool
secure and most and most importantly helps people be ...
independent and that's the radicalization of the left in ...
this country. In 2016 I did an ...
interview with Oliver Darcy when he was working at ...
He's now at CNN on Reliable Sources.
The interview was because I tweeted out defense of alt-right white nationalists who were being removed from Twitter.
Now, these people weren't saying, you know, inciting violence.
These were people who were posting nasty opinions I didn't like.
These are people who don't like me at all because of my family's, you know, regional heritage, I'll put it that way.
And so Oliver Darcy asked me, like, what are your thoughts on this?
I said, it's a slippery slope.
You start removing people because you don't like these ideas, then eventually they're banning the left.
That was Oliver Darcy.
Recently, so the past day or so, he advocated for cable providers to ban Fox News, OAN, and Newsmax because they spread lies.
Talk about a dramatic change from where he was only four or so years ago when he was interviewing me because he thought it was newsworthy.
I said we must have free speech even for those we don't like.
I am still standing here on the same hill saying we must have free speech for those we don't like otherwise you create conflict and he now has gone so far that not only is he advocating for the removal of entire cable channels He's contacting AT&T and Verizon and Comcast and saying, will you remove them?
You're responsible, etc.
ian crossland
You're allowed to spread lies in the United States.
It's protected.
luke rudkowski
Again, that's still absolutely unhinged, dangerous behavior that corporations who want more power With little fleeing individuals coming to them ... saying please take away all my rights take away everything ... take away the most important right of what my ears could ... listen to of course they're going to be like yes give it to ... me I'll be your overlord daddy come on here again we've seen ... this coming for a long time one of the major criticisms ... against Donald Trump within the last few years is that he's ... not making a stand against free speech he's not making a ...
For now.
tim pool
of his critics. What do you mean stand against? You mean not standing up for?
luke rudkowski
Standing up for the First Amendment, standing up for free speech and and it's
interesting to see Laura Loomer tweet this out today. She said according to a
telegram post, at least Trump can still order a sandwich on Uber Eats though.
I can't say the same, sadly. So again this has been happening to a lot of his
core supporters.
tim pool
We, you know, again, you know, you know, you know, the interesting Laura Loomer was was beyond the canary in the coal mine.
I mean, this was like someone yelling the coal mine is full of carbon monoxide.
Get out now.
And the Republicans weren't smart enough to push through legislation while they had the chance.
ian crossland
So did Loomer get taken off the stripe or the the was it the Swift payment system?
She got banned from the global payment system.
tim pool
I don't I don't I've never heard anything about Swift.
ian crossland
I think so, yeah.
tim pool
Wrong Spencer.
Yes, yes, I get it. I get it. But when did you ever hear anything like that?
ian crossland
No, why can't she use money? Who banned her? What do you mean? What are you talking about?
Laura Loomer can't use Uber Eats. She's specifically banned.
She's not PayPal.
tim pool
You can't get banned from Swift. Not her finance. No, she was banned,
I believe, from those platforms as well. But not Swift.
That is not the case.
ian crossland
Are you sure you can't be put on a blacklist of Swift?
tim pool
Probably. I mean, Mastercard reached out to Patreon over this guy. What was his name?
Robert Spencer? I think so, yeah.
unidentified
Wrong Spencer. Yeah, what?
lydia smith
It was the wrong Spencer.
It wasn't Richard Spencer.
tim pool
Yeah, it was Robert Spencer.
Yes, and what do you mean the wrong Spencer?
He was the person they were targeting on purpose.
He writes about Jihadists.
lydia smith
Oh, that's right, that's right.
tim pool
He writes about radical Islam, and Mastercard got angry and said to Patreon, remove him, otherwise we'll cut off services to your system.
ian crossland
I think Mastercard was forced to do that by Swift.
I could be wrong about that.
bill ottman
I mean, this is actually a historic day.
I think we actually have to zoom out and let it sink in for a second.
This proves corporations have more power than the government.
tim pool
Private corporations have just removed the speech of the sitting U.S.
president.
luke rudkowski
Michael, Michael Tracy has a comment here that I think is really timely.
He says, quote, Corporate left liberals are desperate for revenge.
They will use all powers at their disposal, public and private, to neutralize their purported insurrectionist enemies.
And they absolutely do not care one bit what civil liberties are destroyed in the process.
ian crossland
That's what Michael Tracy said.
And they don't sound like they're being too divisive.
I don't want to think of this as left and right.
tim pool
But why is speeding this?
ian crossland
Yeah, absolutely.
unidentified
It is.
ian crossland
It's not though, it's way more than two sides.
It's a bunch of people with a bunch of different ideas.
bill ottman
But it is very frustrating that Trump didn't facilitate a cross-spectrum conversation more directly.
Like, he had the opportunity, and it seems like he really did not bring the people- Wait, Bill, you and I were in the White House at the social media event.
Yeah.
tim pool
You're the CEO of a company he could be using, and someone said, will you just use another platform?
He said, which one?
Which one?
I don't know.
bill ottman
Donald Trump and Joe Biden.
And all the progressive, both sides.
We have to constantly be disclaiming that we need both sides.
ian crossland
Yes.
bill ottman
There's no network without both sides.
ian crossland
Would you consider using MindsTech for a government program that we could use?
bill ottman
Yeah, they can use it.
Hey, call me up.
Government?
Yeah.
I mean, make your own.
ian crossland
A national social network with the Minds software they could integrate with.
bill ottman
Absolutely.
I mean, the government just okayed banks running Bitcoin and Ethereum nodes, which is a very big deal.
tim pool
What we're seeing, unfortunately, is tribalist divide.
There's not just two factions.
There's hundreds and probably thousands.
But there are two overarching parent factions.
Of these overarching parent factions, we just typically refer to them as left and right, but that means very little.
For instance, how is it that Tim Pool, who's economically left and even socially left, is considered right-wing?
Because I believe in freedom, free speech, liberty, principles, integrity, etc.
That is not something that exists, for the most part, among the left.
What the left believes in is, for one, what did we see from Cuomo on CNN during the riots?
He said, who says protests have to be peaceful, right?
And then Ramen Guy comes out and says it's right there in the First Amendment.
Mr. Cuomo, he's got to look it up.
Then you get Jake Tapper and CNN saying, oh, I can't believe what they're doing!
When the riots happened, I said, those riots are bad.
When the riots at the Capitals happened, I said, those riots are bad.
There is principle.
And I'm not saying everybody on the right has it.
I'm saying it's not something typically of the left.
It is a tendency.
ian crossland
I can't take the right and the left stuff, dude.
The Chinese used the rightists.
Mao's communist takeover was against the rightists.
They focused on dividing people into these camps and then targeted, used them against each other.
tim pool
Yes, but what you need to understand is the divide is a real thing, not made up by someone talking.
ian crossland
It's a many fractionalized divide of many millions of different concepts at once.
And to just think that we're in different camps of Of types is crazy.
tim pool
Are conservatives right now calling for the removal of their political opponents from major platforms?
ian crossland
That's not a conservative move.
It's a very liberal move.
tim pool
Exactly.
And it's only coming from what we colloquially refer to as the right.
There are some on the left, liberals and progressives, people like Glenn Greenwald.
But now they call him alt-right.
And Matt Taibbi.
And Michael Tracy.
ian crossland
But who does?
I don't.
tim pool
There are two tribes.
You can call them tribes.
A and B. One or two.
It doesn't matter.
ian crossland
Where are these two?
tim pool
They are the overarching parents to numerous other tribes.
bill ottman
You have to use words, Ian.
ian crossland
Yeah, I will.
And is it because there's Democrat and Republican?
Two power parties?
So we say then there's left and there's right?
tim pool
It's a reference to the French Revolution.
To those who sat on the left and those who sat on the right.
And those on the right were, you know, moderates, and those on the left were radicals who wanted revolution.
ian crossland
I think it's so dangerous to get into that mindset.
unidentified
Well, using more specific language is actually very important.
tim pool
I'm not going to sit here and say, the socialists, the anarchists, the communists, the tankies.
unidentified
Just use their names, man.
ian crossland
Don't blame their group for what they did.
If someone does something, they're responsible for that.
tim pool
It is a tendency among all of the factions on both sides to hold certain ideals and principles.
They don't completely agree with each other.
The left fights themselves all the time.
On the right, you have people who are awful and white nationalists who would defend Donald Trump, and the left doesn't.
But that is not overwhelmingly the majority.
or even a large portion of what the right represents. In fact, the alt-right and the
white nationalists actually agree with the left on a ton of left-wing policy issues.
The point is, when it comes to the cultural debate, there are two parent factions. Fine,
we won't say left and right, we'll say one and two. There you go.
ian crossland
Well, you're not one or two, dude.
luke rudkowski
I know. Right.
ian crossland
There's more than one and two.
bill ottman
Pragmatically, Ian, you have to use words in order to have a conversation.
ian crossland
It's like saying, are you going to vote Republican or Democrat this time?
bill ottman
Well, yeah, absolutely.
You should be talking about all the options.
luke rudkowski
There are some initial reports.
I haven't been able to independently verify this, but we're hearing that President Donald Trump was trying to use the POTUS account.
And then he was tweeting from it, but Twitter removed the tweet instantaneously that it happened.
Again, that's just some of the reports that are coming in right now from the at POTUS account.
Now the POTUS account is still active.
The latest allegations and reports that are coming in now that I have not verified is that he did tweet and it was deleted by Twitter.
ian crossland
That would be a shadow.
luke rudkowski
So that's what I'm hearing right now.
It's happening.
tim pool
Who's reporting it though?
luke rudkowski
I mean, I just had it here.
I just went up here.
I already saw like three people tweet it.
tim pool
Well, we'll search for it and we'll see what we can find.
ian crossland
So he's been purportedly shadow banned on his other account.
Well, it's not his account.
It's our account.
tim pool
Yes, we have images here.
Josh Kaplan, verified Twitter user.
He is a homepage editor for Breitbart News.
Tweets.
Twitter deletes series of tweets presumably written by President Trump on the POTUS account following the permanent ban of his account.
Wow!
He tweeted 8.29 p.m.
today.
As I've been saying for a long time, Twitter has gone further and further in banning free speech and tonight Twitter employees have coordinated with the Democrats and the radical left in removing my account from their platform to silence me and you, the 75 million great Patriots who voted for me.
Twitter may be a private company, but without the government's gift of Section 230, they would not exist for long.
I predicted this would happen.
We have been negotiating with various other sites, and I will have a big announcement soon.
While we also look at the possibilities of building out our own platform in the near future, we will not be silenced.
Twitter is not about free speech.
They are all about promoting a radical left platform, where some of the most vicious people in the world are allowed to speak freely.
Stay tuned.
This did come from the president to the voter's account, and it has been removed.
luke rudkowski
And another thing that we're hearing is that he might give a publicly televised address soon.
But the thing is, who's going to hear it?
Because when we saw during the election, many news organizations just cut him out.
They said, no, we're not going to play the president's address.
We're just going to stop it here.
What the president is saying is wrong.
We don't agree with it.
And there was huge editorializing, even on Fox News.
I'll tell you what I'm worried about.
Before the mass purge they just pulled off, I think many people were willing to accept that Trump had finally been defeated.
If he does a national address now, I mean, well, you want to hear it.
tim pool
I'll tell you, you know, you know what I, what I'm worried about before the mass purge,
they just pulled off.
I think many people were willing to accept that Trump had finally been defeated.
Mike Cernovich, for instance, one of the most prominent Trump supporters ever in the Trump
He put up a poll and he said, did Donald Trump concede?
Yes, no, unsure, show me the results, something like that.
And around 25% said no.
Donald Trump made a video where he said there will be a new administration and we will peacefully transition.
I made a video, Trump confirms defeat, Mike Pence certifies Joe Biden, Trump said it, I don't know what else you're supposed to take from that.
But many Trump supporters, around 25% of Mike Cernovich's, you know, polled, said he didn't concede.
Mike responded by saying, to those who believe this, I love you, please unfollow people who have made you believe this, go home to your loved ones, they miss you, and, you know, it's time to stop.
Essentially, I'm paraphrasing.
He's right.
There are people who are ardent and prominent Trump supporters who are saying, guys, please, please, enough, okay?
Trump has said he's lost, it's over.
Then they do this.
Then Twitter comes out and does this, and they do more, and they do more.
Now they're purging people left and right.
And I think many of those people who are probably like, yeah, you know, that was probably dumb at the Capitol, and I guess it's over, now they're enraged.
Now they're angry.
You took, like, it's like, here's how I imagine it.
You've got a guy at a bar, right?
And he's disparaging you.
And then you're about to fight.
And then he goes, you know what?
You know what?
I'm not doing this.
I'm outta here.
He turns around and walks away, so you throw a can at his head.
And then he turns around and says, that's it.
That's what we had.
People were right.
Not everybody was walking away, for sure.
A lot of people were saying crazy things.
But a lot of people were like, alright, alright, walking away.
And then Twitter was like, not yet.
Whipped him in the head.
And then they turned around, and now I think they're gonna explode.
And now my concern is, After seeing this, there is real fear about multinational corporations shutting down the president.
It should not be allowed, in my opinion, by U.S.
law, that our executive, our chief executive, could be shut down on a major communication platform that has essentially seized the commons in terms of communication.
luke rudkowski
This is a major power grab.
We have to understand, historically, when an entity or a force go after power and they get it, they go after more.
You know, there's an expression, if you give your pinky, you're gonna give up your whole hand eventually.
tim pool
Give an inch to take a mile.
luke rudkowski
Exactly.
So, this is a slippery slope.
This is the snowball that's been happening ever since 2008.
And it's been snowballing and it's getting big and it's only going to get bigger because who's going to stand in the way?
Who's going to promote free speech?
Who's going to uphold it?
Who's going to protect it?
What institutions are out there that could actually make a stand here?
I don't see Fox News doing that at all.
I don't see any other website.
All of the means of communication have been hijacked and are in the hands of special interests and few people.
Is there any hope, guys?
tim pool
Let me tell you something.
When Trump won, there were a lot of Trump supporters being mean and snide and mocking and belittling as people screamed and cried and memes went crazy.
And now we're seeing the same.
We're seeing a lot of the same on the other side.
But now it's not coming from random people on the Internet.
It's coming from CNN.
We have Asha Rangappa.
She is, I'm pretty sure, let me make sure, yes, FBI, former FBI special agent and CNN analyst said, I'm not even going to screenshot what he's tweeting from the POTUS account.
Twitter has already taken it down, but boo-boo mad.
This is the kind of dismissive and insulting and humiliating content coming from prominent institutions, which will trigger mass rage.
I don't care if random Twitter user 123 tweets nasty things at me.
I don't care.
I don't know who you are.
I don't care to make YouTube videos about random Twitter users who say dumb things.
But when it's someone who works for a major cultural institution or politics and they have power and influence, I think it needs to be talked about and called out.
They disagree.
And the funny thing is, this is actually a left-wing principle.
They say, don't punch down.
Then why is it that mainstream media is punching down, calling regular Americans stupid, mocking the way they live, mocking the way they work, mocking their lives?
Now I get it.
Mocking the president is not punching down, by all means.
Mock him.
My concern is when CNN comes out and attacks the people who are angry.
luke rudkowski
You can't, also another thing, you can't really fight fascism with fascism.
Like that's something also a lot of people need to realize here.
tim pool
You can.
Except those who don't like fascism are going to be really angry about it.
luke rudkowski
You're going to get fascism.
unidentified
That's the thing.
tim pool
Right, right, listen.
If authoritarian leftists want authoritarianism, and they just don't want authoritarian rightists to win, well then there you go.
Authoritarianism is the battle.
luke rudkowski
I don't think a lot of people realize the larger kind of implications here.
I don't think a lot of people realize where this is going and the
historical precedent that this is setting as well.
ian crossland
So augment what you said, look, you can fight fascism with fascism, but
you can't defeat fascism with fascism.
tim pool
Yes.
luke rudkowski
Or that's better.
tim pool
You can fight fashion with it in a fascism fight.
All you'll get is fascism.
unidentified
There you go.
bill ottman
So to talk a little bit about the fact checking strike, quote unquote,
fact checking strategies at Facebook What they're doing is basically bringing in a small group of think tanks, and it's not a real system.
So, what we're actually talking about doing is working with this group, Ground.News.
I don't know if you've ever heard of them.
For every article, their algorithm grabs all the articles and shows on both sides.
And they sort of are doing the best, it seems, good faith effort to show all the coverage on both sides.
And so that when you're scrolling down your feed, you can get context to what you're seeing.
And, you know, that's where we need to be going, giving people access to all of the data around the post so that they have the most information, not just saying this is true or this is false.
tim pool
Facebook knew what they were doing.
Facebook knew early on that they were feeding, you know, hyper-partisan content to different sides.
In fact, there are some news organizations that knew this too and created two different versions of their content because one would feed to the left and one would feed to the right.
And there was a thing they would do, it's just general journalism A-B testing,
where they'll write an article and in some regions they would use certain titles,
different in other regions, total different framing, to see how it would perform to maximize
the amount of ads they would get, the amount of clicks they would get, and in turn the revenue.
Because they knew that somebody who lived in Texas would probably see, you know,
rather see an article that says Nancy Pelosi is bad. And the people who lived in San Francisco
ian crossland
probably would like to see Nancy Pelosi good. They were doing like experiments on users,
Facebook was, where they would feed them emotionally charged articles to see if it
would produce more clicks.
tim pool
Nice and a maze.
ian crossland
Now they've got, you know, artificial intelligence or whatever this algorithm is that's private, you know, tweaking and deciding what people see and what gets flagged.
tim pool
So I'll tell you, you know who our government really is?
It's the robots.
ian crossland
It's who controls the narrative, yeah.
What is to govern is the control, the mind control of the system right now.
tim pool
If Facebook uses an AI to feed content to people, I think it's AI.
ian crossland
It might be on machine learning.
tim pool
I'm not sure.
Listen, okay.
Speaking colloquially, Facebook creates an algorithm that feeds certain content.
All that matters is, this is what I've said, Jack Dorsey has swallowed so much of his own refuse, I think he's actually been radicalized by what he's created.
If you look at him compared to where he was when Twitter launched to where he is now, he's a dramatically different person.
And why does he believe the things he believes?
He created a platform that incentivizes rage content, And then he started eating that content, which changed his brain, and then he had the keys to the castle, went in, and changed more of the platform to keep feeding into that... It's an insanity loop.
He created it.
It radicalized him.
ian crossland
And then he sold it.
tim pool
And then he made it crazier and crazier to fit his new radicalized mind.
Think about what he said in the beginning.
We're the free speech wing of the free speech party.
But that was just a joke.
Think about what I said to him when I said, your misgendering rule is ideological because conservatives don't understand that view.
They have a totally different worldview.
But he couldn't see it because he had been swimming in the refuse he created.
luke rudkowski
Yep.
And he didn't just create it.
He made the world crazier in the instant that you brought it up.
But also another aspect to understand here, mental health has been in decline ever since we saw the rise of social media.
Many people say that is a massive correlation.
That's another way that it impacts people with depression, suicides, and a lot of other mental health defects that are skyrocketing right now as we're speaking.
So if you go out, you know, on an average day, if you talk to a neighbor or if you talk to a stranger, They're not as crazy as they are online.
You will talk to a random person.
You have a lot more in common.
You used to, but now it's becoming less and less rare.
More on average, if you go out there, if you talk to your neighbor, you're more likely to get along with them than not.
The world is not as crazy as it was purported, but the reporting of it as being as crazy makes it crazy.
tim pool
I think that's how it used to be.
I think you're wrong now.
I think the radicalization of social media has now led to people just outside at random being tribalized and radicalized.
bill ottman
And not to mention people will barely talk to each other because they have a mask on their face.
And it's like a whole other level of isolation in your own house.
So even if you're not on social media, you're not going out and being social.
ian crossland
Is he going to shake my hand?
Am I allowed to touch this guy's hand?
It's so weird.
tim pool
Or think about when you're in a city where there's a political event going on, and they think you look like a Trump supporter, or they think you look like Antifa.
Where can you walk based on how you appear?
Imagine walking around New York City wearing... Actually, people have done this.
Walk around L.A.
wearing a MAGA hat.
See what happens.
Blaire White did it.
She got attacked.
ian crossland
A fingernail ripped off.
I would say a lot of the chaos today, and the mental health issues, comes from text, and people attempting to communicate through text, which is a new form of communication with humans.
They used to send letters before that.
You know, written language, they all communicated with words and sounds.
And we've lost so much touch of our ability to communicate with our words.
I find, I have so much, you know, faith and love for people that make internet video, because you speak your mind with your words and your sound and your vibration, and it's completely different than etching something onto a stone for someone else to attempt to interpret it.
tim pool
But even...
Like, this is one of the reasons we don't do Skype here, and we never... First of all, we're not set up for it.
There could be maybe some exception in the future, but we don't, because it doesn't work.
Even hearing their voice, you gotta see their face.
You have to be able to... I interrupted you, Ian.
ian crossland
You know what I mean?
I did notice that, yes.
tim pool
To jump in and make that point.
ian crossland
Good.
That's what we're supposed to do.
tim pool
You can't do that on a Zoom call.
ian crossland
In text, it wouldn't work.
Because the digital overlap, a lot of times there's a problem with delay.
tim pool
The time delays and the awkwardness of, you know, you're standing at a camera, you're not standing at a screen, you don't see their face.
People don't realize that.
They think when you're doing a Skype debate or a Zoom call that you can see each other's face and look into each other's eyes.
No, you have a camera.
When I would do a Fox News or, say, in the past when I did go on MSNBC, Or some of these other networks.
I'm staring into a black hole.
That's it.
I don't see myself.
I don't see them.
And you know what the worst thing about these cable networks is?
You can never hear anything.
There's a delay.
Yeah, you get an earpiece and it's so quiet and you're like, can you turn it up?
I can't hear anything.
And then they're like, uh, so we're going to go live.
The producer's always loud.
We're going to go live in about 10 seconds.
And then you hear the house go...
And I'm like, dude, I can't hear you.
You're ready to talk.
OK.
You need to be sitting down with someone to have a real meaningful conversation.
bill ottman
But at the same time, we're seeing all the news networks now are doing remote video chats.
And like I agree with you, it's not as good.
But I mean, to Ian's point, A video message is more effective.
ian crossland
Or a phone call.
Compared to a text.
A text message is dangerous.
You cannot get emotion from it.
bill ottman
And then people freak out because they over interpret what they're writing.
ian crossland
Like sarcasm is completely lost in text.
bill ottman
Well even just like in relationships and like people like people's girlfriends send them messages like oh my god.
ian crossland
Dude, and we live in this world of it now that's radicalizing and making people insane.
I don't know how to overemphasize how dangerous it is to communicate with text and rely on it as your form of communication.
We're vibrating monkey bodies that speak words for a reason.
I think text is a great way to relay information.
bill ottman
Text was a revolution.
ian crossland
But not to communicate feelings.
It is.
bill ottman
Yeah, it is.
It can be.
It can be, but it depends on the context.
ian crossland
I think that if I want to, I can write something with a feeling in it, but if you read it, you're going to interpret your own feeling.
But if I say something to you with a feeling, you're going to feel what I'm feeling.
tim pool
I was going to pull up a tweet based on what you said.
I tweeted this.
If history has taught us anything, it's that you should trust the government in times of emergency to do what's right, keep us well informed as the ongoing legitimacy of the threat, and give up emergency powers once the crisis is averted.
I intentionally just said it, but I call it a filter.
I call tweets like that a filter.
Clearly, to anybody who is hearing me talk, if I was to say this in real life, I would say something like, if history has taught us anything, it's that you should trust the government in times of emergency to do what's right, keep us well informed of the ongoing legitimacy of the threat, and to give up emergency powers once the crisis is averted.
Clearly knowing I'm being facetious.
In a tweet, people thought it was real.
Now most people retweeted it laughing.
They understood the context.
Tim's being sarcastic, facetious, etc.
But a lot of people saw that and they were like, dude, what is wrong with you?
ian crossland
And those people can become crazy dangerous if they don't understand.
tim pool
I have a friend who's a prominent leftist who told me that people don't understand my tweets are jokes.
And I'm like, what am I supposed to do when I say something so absurd and ridiculous?
Like, I have another one.
ian crossland
Put a smiley face at the end.
tim pool
I said, or a goofy face.
ian crossland
Yeah, that's all you gotta do.
tim pool
So, you know what I do now is I actually reply with, hello, you must be new to Twitter.
This is a joke.
I'm not serious.
I said, the good news is now that, now with Democrats in full control, we can finally lock down the country for a couple of years to make sure COVID goes away.
And a lot of people are like, what, are you crazy?
unidentified
What's wrong?
ian crossland
Some people really think that stuff.
lydia smith
They believe it.
unidentified
Right.
ian crossland
They'll tweet that out.
Serious.
So people are like, is he, has he switched?
Has he, has he changed?
bill ottman
Dude, Ryan Long just tweeted.
It's the funniest thing.
Not that I, you know, want to be looking at Twitter right now, but Jack Torcy just yelled, I'm a golden God before jumping into his pool.
tim pool
Yeah.
ian crossland
So there's this phenomenon where you can sell your company.
That's kind of a problem.
You create this phenomenon like Twitter, Jack did, and then he sold it.
He owns like 6% of it now.
He gave up power, gave up control.
Google was started by Larry and Sergey.
tim pool
They've become monsters.
ian crossland
They're gone.
They're not even part of the company anymore, as far as I know.
tim pool
Well, they're Alphabet.
ian crossland
Yeah.
Well, you said they were even off the board of Alphabet?
bill ottman
I heard that.
tim pool
Really?
bill ottman
Yeah.
Maybe confirm.
They silently stepped away.
And the odd thing to me about Dorsey is that he's all about Bitcoin.
He's tweeting about Signal, which is actually a great open source.
You know, Elon was tweeting about Signal the other day.
Like, amazing project.
tim pool
That was Signal.
Was that Moxie Marlinspike?
bill ottman
Yeah.
tim pool
Interesting.
unidentified
Yeah.
bill ottman
And so it's like he's aware of this.
But for some reason, the speech thing, he doesn't get.
unidentified
Who?
Who?
bill ottman
Dorsey.
tim pool
Dorsey.
bill ottman
Why does he care about Bitcoin and Signal?
luke rudkowski
Well, you have to ask yourself, is he really in charge?
tim pool
He's not.
I don't think so.
I think he's a figurehead.
And so he got fired a long time ago.
And they brought on Dick Costolo.
And then when he left, I can't remember why, I think he may have been fired, Dorsey became the CEO.
I think it was Costolo.
Maybe I'm getting my people mixed up.
And Dorsey, I think, was just brought on to appear to be in control, and really he's not.
I don't think he is.
ian crossland
I think he owns 6%, yeah.
luke rudkowski
Well, another thing to really kind of consider here, when you look at a lot of the big tech companies,
they either have direct involvement with the startup of them and intelligence agencies,
or they have ongoing contracts and cooperations with continued government agencies that they are working hand-in-hand
with.
Case in point, Amazon, and the CIA, and the Department of Defense, Facebook, and what was that startup connected to the intelligence agency that was Integro in their start?
We have Google, and of course Google Maps, working with of course the US Pentagon to make that happen, and there was another one, In-Q-Tel I think?
No, I don't know.
tim pool
That's a lot of factoring we have to do for a lot of that stuff.
luke rudkowski
Yeah, I'm gonna have to look into that stuff to talk more clearly on it.
ian crossland
Let's talk about... Yeah, this says Dorsey owns 2% of Twitter's outstanding shares.
unidentified
Wow.
ian crossland
Does that mean total stock?
Outstanding shares?
Worth $531 million.
2%?
He's not involved at all in that company.
tim pool
Yeah, he runs Square.
ian crossland
Square is his company.
bill ottman
He splits.
He's CEO of both.
tim pool
Right.
Yeah.
But I think he's just... He owns 13% of Square.
Oh, really?
Yeah.
ian crossland
So really, he might be CEO entitled, but that doesn't mean he runs the company.
tim pool
Well, let's talk about where the escalation has brought us.
From Fox 4, Josh Hawley speaks out, arguing Biden called him a Nazi when talking to reporters.
unidentified
U.S.
tim pool
Senator Hawley fired back Friday, saying President-elect Joe Biden compared him to a Nazi propagandist.
He didn't say he did.
Joe Biden did.
From the Dallas News, Joe Biden likens Ted Cruz to Nazi propagandist Goebbels for helping Trump spread big lie about election fraud.
It wasn't just Cruz.
It was also Josh Hawley.
Now Hawley's firing back, saying, President-elect Biden has just compared me and another Republican senator to Nazis.
Think about that for a moment.
Let that sink in.
Holly argued he raised lawful questions about the way elections were conducted, just as Democrats did in previous years, but saw a much different outcome.
This is undignified, immature, and intemperate behavior from the president-elect.
It is utterly shameful.
He should act like a dignified adult and retract these sick comments.
The president-elect made the comments while answering reporters' questions in Washington, D.C.
Friday afternoon.
A reporter asked Biden if Senators Hawley and Cruz should resign after a violent mob contesting the election results stormed the Capitol.
Biden said the two senators should be flat-beaten in their next elections.
Biden then referred to the big lie and said that those like Goebbels, Hawley, and Cruz kept repeating the lie.
Goebbels was a member of the Nazi Party and a Reich Minister of Propaganda under Adolf Hitler during World War II.
It's exactly the kind of rhetoric everybody would want to hear from the incoming president-elect, right?
The one who's calling for unity?
unidentified
No.
tim pool
This is... this is...
A level of depravity and insanity.
bill ottman
So what should he do in his last few weeks?
tim pool
Trump?
A few days.
I don't know, but they said they're going to impeach him on Monday.
The Democrats are going to impeach him.
I don't know if he'll get removed because if Republicans and Democrats split 50-50, then Mike Pence breaks the tie.
But what if Mitch McConnell says, nah, I'll break the tie.
And he decides Trump's gotta go.
And then he votes him out.
bill ottman
Are we going to get any declassified files?
tim pool
No, I don't think so.
I don't.
Trump has been unable to get anything declassified.
They don't listen to him.
He's talking about firing people.
I don't know what he's gonna do.
But listen.
You know, I was mentioning this earlier.
When you have the people who are willing to walk away kind of conceding with their tail between their legs and then you throw something at the back of their head.
This from Joe Biden is like they're pouring fuel on the fire.
Why?
Why would he say this about these senators?
Why?
Why would he tell?
bill ottman
Look, it was over.
tim pool
Right, right, right.
Yeah, it's done.
And I'll tell you what's what's really crazy about the scenario.
What Ted Cruz and Josh Hawley did was entirely constitutional.
Yeah, they were allowed to do it.
It was not out of the ordinary.
It's happened before.
It happened 2005.
It happened a bunch of times.
I mean, 2016 was crazy.
And the end result would have been Biden getting certified as president.
It would have given Trump supporters their voice on the Electoral College count floor.
It would have satisfied many, not all, to be like, well, at least the American people can hear what we have to say, and we weren't denied that opportunity.
Now, unfortunately, It was the Trump supporters who stormed in and stopped that from happening.
But to criticize Josh Hawley and Ted Cruz as though they're Nazi propagandists, or in any way like him, simply because they wanted to say, here's what's happening, and here's why we have concerns about this, that's... I think that should be evidence that people don't want unity, and that this is likely going to escalate, and escalate faster than you realize.
ian crossland
It reminds me about what the Nazis did, because they would demonize the communists, and then He's like, we need a new national crackdown on terrorism.
Those people are acting like the Nazi party from old.
It's like, that's what the Nazis did to the communists.
They cracked down and they said that they were the evil from, you know, the 10 years ago in Russia or whatever.
I'm sorry.
bill ottman
The first sentence is you're a Nazi.
The second sentence is unity.
Everyone come together.
Like, Really?
Are you really trying to act like you're bringing people together if you're using hyperbolic language like that?
tim pool
Well, so we have had for years people tweeting things about killing Nazis and punching them, but then they go and call literally everyone Nazis or compare everyone to Nazis.
And so, what are people supposed to think?
You want to hurt us, you want to attack us, because it's not about attacking Nazis, it's about using the worst possible smear you can against those you don't agree with.
That way, when you advocate for some- like, listen, there are people on Twitter who are saying, you know, kill Nazis or whatever.
Twitter allows it.
Then, once that's been approved, they then tack onto it, here's a list of who the Nazis are, and they grab random people they don't like.
And now Twitter's approved that.
So I'll tell you, when Joe Biden says that the protesters are domestic terrorists, those that stormed the Capitol, he says these senators are basically propagandists for the insurrection.
The Wall Street Journal reports, Mr. Biden has said he plans to make a priority of passing a law against domestic terrorism, and he has been urged to create a White House post overseeing the fight against ideological-inspired violent extremists and increasing funding to combat them.
luke rudkowski
Is it called the Enabling Act?
Yeah, you know, I said it's gonna be called like the SAFE Act, like Securing American Freedoms, you know, Enhanced or something like that.
unidentified
Oh, jeez.
tim pool
The SAFE Act.
ian crossland
The SAFE for everybody.
tim pool
The He's in his ear.
He's an establishment candidate.
He's a lobbyist.
And he's going, what they're probably thinking, these establishment people, is once we get power, we better make sure these people never win again.
And he's not just talking about Trump.
He's talking about Bernie Sanders, too.
And that's why I think it's hilarious.
Many of these leftists walked right into this.
It should have been obvious.
I said it.
If the establishment gets back in, they're going to lock the doors and no populist will ever see it, whether it's left or right.
ian crossland
Yeah, they would do the same thing to Cortez, I would think.
luke rudkowski
Cortez is trying to play the game right now, calling for people's censorship.
Another scary aspect of this is that, you know, Biden, he kind of showed that he's not really there.
He's not on it.
He doesn't have the ball in front of him.
It looks like someone else has the ball and is carrying this whole program here.
When you look at his speech, when you look at his mindset, Competent doesn't come to mind and when you have that you also understand that this is the person that sold out to the special interest almost more than any other president before him.
He argued with Barack Obama saying that there needs to be more special interest inside of the Obama administration and Obama had to tell him no.
So when we have big tech executives inside of the Biden administration, Goldman Sachs, the military-industrial complex, and you have unlimited power, you look at that entire recipe, there's no one or nothing that could check him.
Another thing that I kind of wanted to bring up is that if you remember Chuck Schumer literally brought up that if you mess with the, this is not his exact phrase, but he said when Donald Trump messes with the intelligence agencies, they have six ways to Sunday to get back at him.
In relation to that, I also want to bring up this CBS News article that is literally titled, Social Media is a Tool of the CIA, Seriously.
That is the title of their article on CBS News, and they start off by saying, quote, you don't need to wear a tinfoil hat to believe that the CIA is using Facebook, Twitter, Google, and other social media companies to spy on people.
That's because the CIA published a helpful list of press releases on all the social media ventures it sponsors via its technology investment firm In-Q-Tel.
So again, that's that's the firm that I brought up here previously before.
So there is a lot of things to talk about there.
There's a lot of room for kind of speculation here, even though I don't like doing that.
But we have to understand when we look at these big tech companies, they're not just outside entities outside of the government.
They are entities that work with the government hand in hand, not just spying on you, but in more severe ways than we even know.
And this is truly an emerging power that can't be unchecked.
ian crossland
And Amazon.
It's not considered a social network, but they have that 100% computer that everyone's got people have in their
house that you can command and listen. Well, this is another thing with Amazon with Amazon
luke rudkowski
They're working. They're working on new Technology that will break encryption they're working on
they've got it. Well, yeah Well quantum supremacy, you know, you know about this,
tim pool
right?
luke rudkowski
Oh, yeah, but I don't think it's it's we don't know the exact levels Yeah, we don't know the exact details here.
They were heavily criticized for developing facial recognition technology I was used by ice, but that's only just the tip of the iceberg here literally Comparatively to all the other big deep state projects that they're working on that they're developing that need to be brought up Have you seen go big show on TBS?
Oh Uh, we were slowly... I was watching two minutes of it when you were watching it.
tim pool
Why can't you just let them have the power?
Didn't you want to see the man do the backflip on the tricycle?
luke rudkowski
I was too busy working out.
tim pool
There was another guy I heard, Luke, who got a football to the groin.
Now, wouldn't you much rather just order a pizza, sit back, watch a football to the groin show, and leave the Democrats to have their power and let them do what they want?
luke rudkowski
Wasn't that in Idiocracy, where they had a show where the guy was just getting hit in the balls?
Really?
The show that you were watching?
Was there really a segment?
No, no, no.
tim pool
I wouldn't be surprised.
luke rudkowski
I wouldn't be surprised either.
tim pool
Yeah, idiocracy, man.
Mike Judge nailed it.
luke rudkowski
Yeah.
tim pool
I mean, to be honest, Donald Trump's in the WWE Hall of Fame, and then Camacho, the president, was a wrestler, so... Beavis and Butt-head's coming back, I heard.
Oh, it comes back every so often, doesn't it?
I think we're headed for dark days, man.
Because what's happening is happening faster and faster.
And what we saw at the Capitol was... I think in terms of the political ramifications, it was serious.
And the craziest thing is when you look at photos and there's a photo going around of a guy with zip tie handcuffs, and people are like, what were they planning on doing with that?
Like taking hostages?
And then there's a picture of a grandma who's just like waving a little flag and she has no idea what's going on.
It's really, really weird what we're seeing, but the media is treating this like the apocalypse.
It's exactly what the left, the establishment, the cultural institutions needed to take action to start purging everybody.
So now there were reports earlier before the show that Steve Bannon's show has been deleted from YouTube.
So I think, you know, and they said it was for election related misinformation.
luke rudkowski
Yeah, that wouldn't surprise me.
And there's a very famous meme going around now that says, quote, we spend $750 billion annually on defense and the center of American government fell in two hours to the duck dynasty.
And the guy in the Chewbacca bikini.
And they have a photo of the guys in costume.
tim pool
You know what's really funny?
As this purge is going on, I do think some people are leaving Twitter.
That they're deactivating their accounts and they're going to parlor because the president has been removed.
But I think a lot of people are being banned and a lot of people are noticing.
I think it's probably a lot of people purposefully leaving.
I wonder if the majority is actual bannings.
But my Twitter following is like, it goes down and it spikes really high.
Because I'll tweet something and then the people who remain will start following me.
But then as people are leaving it goes down.
A lot of people are down, like I saw one tweet just now, 16,000 people.
luke rudkowski
That's huge.
unidentified
This is a mass purge.
tim pool
This can't just be people leaving.
Twitter is going through networks.
They're probably looking at a network and just removing people.
Well, so there's a Twitter bot that will tell you when someone in the Trump network follows
or unfollows. And it was this massive lift saying Rudy Giuliani unfollowed this person,
and this person, and this person, and just a huge list of people saying Rudy Giuliani unfollowed
these people. And I'm like, did Twitter just pull up Rudy Giuliani's following list and just delete
everybody he followed? Because they all got nuked. He was trying to protect people, maybe?
No, I don't know.
Rudy Giuliani is fighting for Trump.
So, you're removed.
ian crossland
When I was down there in the bathroom, I just thought about that we need to break up these
corporations again.
This is this monopoly on public speech.
And I just don't see a value to shattering the corporations into a bunch of proprietary
networks like why would we break Facebook into Facebook Prime and Instagram again that
Zuckerberg owns both of that the code is still.
So I keep going back to the way we would break up a social network's monopoly is by freeing
their software code after they reach a certain level of user base.
And people's argument is, why would I give up my work for all this my life's work if I've attained 100 million followers?
Now I lose my code.
And I'm like, well, your code going free doesn't mean you lose the network, you still own Facebook, you still can profit off of all that activity on Facebook, but the code Yeah, a code should be like an idea.
luke rudkowski
I think it should be open sourced, and I think if we did have open source technology, the world would be a lot better and freer.
bill ottman
And the network effects that you can achieve.
My opinion.
The network effects and growth you can achieve, not to mention because your community will trust you more now, because you're being transparent with them, but the reason Bitcoin is exploding right now is because it's open.
There's not going to be a closed system.
tim pool
But I understand that you guys view the code as our code.
I think that sometimes the code can be my code, and you're all just dirty commies who think that.
And I actually believe in private property, so I disagree.
But in all seriousness, no, I think there can be, I think a lot of things need to be open, depending on what they are.
Probably social media.
If it's something that has a serious impact on our politics, civics, then we should probably understand how that works.
But if it's a proprietary service, I don't think that code should be forced open.
ian crossland
Like a city?
bill ottman
You know, not forced, but like it's in your interest to do it.
ian crossland
Well, I'm suggesting...
Yes, absolutely.
tim pool
We need to know how they're working, why they're working, and we should be able to watch.
Because think about it this way.
If we could see the voting counting going in in real time and how the code worked, and
then something weird happened and a vote flipped, everybody would see it.
The problem, I guess, is that it's connected to the internet, but then everyone's watching
So, I don't know.
There's challenges to this.
luke rudkowski
It's just accountability.
Why can't we have accountability?
We should have accountability for so many different things in our society that would clear things up.
If you're gonna say that there was Russian collusion with Donald Trump, show us the evidence.
It took them a while to reveal absolutely nothing.
And then, in the meantime, they slandered and discredited and threw people under the bus, including myself and WeAreChange.
We're talking about, you know, the voting that just happened.
Be transparent.
Do investigations.
Look into it.
Show us the evidence.
Again, that would have proved and solved so much angst.
That would have proved and solved so much of the uncertainty.
And again, when these companies make these large decisions, banning people, destroying people's voice, they're doing it in a way where there's no accountability for that.
There's no way to appeal it.
We don't even know why the decision was made.
We don't know exactly what even led up to it.
It's just a totalitarian saying, that's it.
I get my way.
I don't even have to say why I did what I did.
And that's a dangerous, unaccountable power that surely...
I was saying this years ago, is going to be abused, is being abused right now.
tim pool
A lot of people want to talk about civil war and stuff.
And they think the right has some tremendous advantage because they're the tough guys, because they're the survivalists and all that stuff.
But I said, listen, man, they'll sever the lines of communication in two seconds before anything starts.
And then you'll be sitting there looking at your phone saying, I wonder what's going on.
The lines of communication are being severed.
It's what they're doing.
ian crossland
Yeah, Zuckerberg's kind of like a mayor of a city, of a town.
And right now, it's like a private town.
tim pool
He's not a mayor.
ian crossland
Well, it's kind of like he's an internet mayor or an internet governor.
tim pool
Well, have you ever seen those old westerns where, like, the guy rides into the town and he's like, it's my town!
ian crossland
Sheriff, you work for me!
It's my town now.
And he owns the town.
So our government is in place to make sure that no individual owns these cities.
Like, no one owns New York.
It's controlled by all of us.
And I think that Facebook has gotten to the strength of power.
Well, someone governs it that's put into power.
tim pool
Look at what De Blasio's doing.
Look, his wife's got a $2 million staff while the city burns.
ian crossland
The way the law is built, I'm just talking about, is that I think that Facebook is powerful enough and influential enough that we should treat it like a city and not a piece of ownership of something that someone can own.
I'm just talking about the code.
He can still own the domain and people can still use Facebook and he can have stores and everything.
Publicly owned and open with guaranteed rights and we don't need to worry about making money on or they could have utility it could still be Private and all the code could be a utility that we could build another network.
That is a utility with the same code They could integrate with Twitter Yes.
Because if you shatter it into a bunch of proprietary networks, it wouldn't stop the monopoly on the behavior.
tim pool
Right.
I think we need platforms that are free speech, you know, open, publicly owned.
And that's just me.
Look, maybe I'm lefty, huh?
Taxpayer funded, nationalized with guaranteed rights.
You break the law, someone reports you, it's a criminal offense.
You broke the law.
If you say a nasty opinion, you block them and say, don't want to see you.
That simple.
What do you do?
Harassment laws apply.
Harassment is a crime.
bill ottman
This is how the big networks grew, under that premise.
Their content policies were always pretty restrictive, but to a certain degree they rode the whole wave of letting people say most of what was okay, and now they're doing the bait-and-switch.
ian crossland
So the company that's a big problem too is that you can make a company make it huge and popular and then sell it to some totalitarian dictator and then all of a sudden a hundred million people are now being Driven by this this guy that now owns the city you basically handed the keys of the city of this next guy So yeah, I agree.
I don't think that These networks should be controlled by the bait-and-switch.
Even the potential for the bait-and-switch shouldn't exist.
bill ottman
You would just expect that executives with billions of dollars, thousands of developers at their disposal, could come up with realistic problems for breaking echo chambers.
Here's recommendations of stuff that you might disagree with or from people from the other side of the spectrum.
Here's recommendations for this.
Here's how to curate your algorithm so you know, so you're getting a balanced diet of information.
Like they just literally, it is intentional.
tim pool
But you know the problem with that is, for like Twitter, is that if you're somebody who's like, is a far leftist, and they say, why don't you follow Tim Poole?
He's a, you know, moderate individual who believes in free speech and liberty.
Then they're going to start spamming me and insulting me and it's going to be really annoying.
The problem is, ultimately in the end, you have many different kinds of people but there seems to be two overarching kinds of people.
The if someone is bothering me I'll block them group and the if someone's bothering me I demand Twitter block them from everyone group.
And so there's no negotiating.
It's one of the things that I think Jack Dorsey actually said in one of his testimony, in his Senate testimony, he was like, we have people who are demanding on the left that we ban people for this reason, and then the right demands that we don't ban them for this reason, and we have to figure out, like, we have these both, you know, both groups screaming in our ears.
Now I guess ultimately, because the cultural institutions and the media are controlled by the left, these big tech companies know exactly who butters their bread.
They want to sell advertisements, right?
Well, if a news story comes out in the Wall Street Journal that YouTube does bad, then YouTube says, we're so sorry, Wall Street Journal, please.
And then they cave.
That's what happened with PewDiePie in the first adpocalypse.
And the crazy thing is these news outlets know YouTube is their competition.
So they're doing it on purpose for probably for a financial gain.
luke rudkowski
But they also learn that people like to hear their own thoughts regurgitated to them so they created echo chambers through the algorithm and I remember back in the day when the Internet was still amazing in a beautiful place and was a free place because it didn't have any algorithms it didn't have any news feeds it didn't have any curated Timelines with these corporations deciding what ... you should hear if you would subscribe to something you ... would actually see it you would actually hear it this ... curation has essentially led to these larger echo ... chambers to these larger to these larger radicalizations ... and have pushed people further and further apart on the ... political spectrum.
We're now we are in a situation where people are at ... each other's throats and we have to wake up and realize ... that this was done by social media so what makes you think ... giving all your power to social media is going to fix it ... this is such a frustrating thing you see the direct ... fingerprint whether it's the mental health crisis whether ... it's the algorithm whether it's the echo chambers whether ... it's them colluding with intelligence agencies and ... government agencies when you see this problem.
And they're a part of it.
And now you have people saying, they're going to fix it all if you just give them all of your power.
And people are falling for it, celebrating this today?
You've got to be freaking kidding me.
tim pool
It's like the monkey's paw.
You know that story?
It's like you get three wishes, but then it twists your wish.
These leftists are like, yeah, censorship, yeah.
They're going to get censored.
ian crossland
Censor all the bad people.
The definition of bad changes.
tim pool
It's like a Twilight Zone episode, where it's like, it was time now.
It's not fair.
It's like, why am I being banned?
No!
Everyone was finally banned and I could finally have peace!
And then they drop their phone and the phone shatters.
No!
You know that episode, right?
unidentified
No.
It sounds awesome.
tim pool
It's the episode where the guy just wants to read and the world ends.
ian crossland
Oh, and he breaks his glasses.
tim pool
Yeah, and he's got big, thick glasses.
So I'm imagining it's like a leftist demanding everyone be banned.
And then finally, once everyone's banned, he has his phone.
He's like, now I can look.
And he drops his phone.
ian crossland
No!
luke rudkowski
Well information, people need to understand, information is key during war.
One of the first things that was done during the Iraq war from some of the reports that I heard from frontline soldiers is that there was leaflets dropped on populations.
tim pool
Oh yeah, of course.
luke rudkowski
Saying Americans are coming, they're here to liberate you and here to free you.
So this has been done as a part of psychological warfare many times throughout many important battles and this is the information war ramping up to huge just astronomical levels where Even fifth generational warfare doesn't put a candle to it, to what's happening now.
And that's another term that people should look up and should research themselves when they want to understand what is deeply happening and what is going to happen from here.
ian crossland
In Vietnam, they used to blast audio in the jungle.
This, like, demonic sounds at night.
No, no, no, no, no.
And it would scare the Vietnamese because they were all emotional and they wouldn't come out that night.
tim pool
No, I gotta correct you.
ian crossland
Talk about informational warfare.
It was just like... Let me, let me, let me... You know, medulla oblongata.
tim pool
Let me correct you.
ian crossland
Please do.
tim pool
During Vietnam, the U.S.
would blast audio of wailing Vietnamese saying, Why did I do it?
I made a mistake.
Run while you still can or you'll be trapped here for eternity like I am.
Because their religious belief was that if they weren't properly buried, they were trapped to roam the area where they died forever.
The problem was it was too effective.
And the South Vietnamese, I believe it was the South who was working with us, panicked and ran when they heard it.
But imagine you're in the jungle, in the dead of night with your gun, and then you hear a wailing ghostly voice crying and begging you, saying, don't become trapped like I am, run while you still can.
Psychological warfare is crazy stuff, man.
You know that old fake story about the general and the pig's blood?
Apparently it's not a real story, but they talk about this general who, after killing a bunch of Muslim soldiers in the Middle East, poured pig's blood on them and left one alive and let him leave, so that he went and told them and then they all stopped fighting.
I believe that story's not true, but people tell it all the time, the idea being that he's like, oh no, this is bad, it's against their religion, and so he panicked, told everyone, and then they refused to engage.
Psychological warfare.
You know what?
It's simple.
Pen is mightier than the sword.
That's what they say.
luke rudkowski
The first step in it is to control communication.
Once you control communication, once you control what people can and cannot listen to, you have such a severe advantage over your supposed enemies or even someone you think are the Nazis.
tim pool
You know what Trump's mistake was?
He didn't watch Revenge of the Sith.
Because I just watched Revenge of the Sith.
unidentified
That was his mistake.
tim pool
And you know what Palpatine did?
Smart.
Palpatine feigned a assassination attempt, you know, when Mace Windu comes in and then Anakin's there and then he's like, don't let them kill me!
I'm too weak!
And then Anakin, you know, ends up killing Mace Windu and everything.
I'm kidding, by the way.
But it is it is it just like you know Trump is sitting there. I think I don't think Trump had uh to be honest
They're saying trump incited and all this stuff. I don't I don't think so
I don't think trump intended for this to happen when we had we had jack murphy on recently and he was saying that it
sounded Like when trump was giving his speech, it was a concession
speech He said sometimes it takes more courage to do nothing and
he was like, what does that mean?
You know, yeah, like trump was trying to wind things down.
luke rudkowski
Well, he said it's gonna be up to mike pence Yeah.
So he made sure he had no responsibility at all.
And everyone was like, OK, let's see what Mike Pence is going to do.
And he released that statement, which got around.
tim pool
Somebody tweeted something really funny.
They said, how long until Trump uses the presidential alert system to send a message?
ian crossland
I was thinking about that when he tweeted he's going to presidential alert his new parlor account.
unidentified
Yes.
luke rudkowski
Well, there's even some scuttlebutt of them creating their own social media networks.
tim pool
Well, he said that.
ian crossland
That's what they should do.
They should use the Mines Code.
They should take the codes there.
bill ottman
Take the code and just build your own network with Mines Code.
ian crossland
We need a government site, man.
bill ottman
More diversity.
I mean, Tim, you've known.
You've known to back up your social situation the whole time.
Of course.
You have to.
You have to protect yourself.
And the fact that, you know, he didn't, it's...
tim pool
There's troubling questions and troubling and dark times ahead.
And you know, Joe Biden, he warned us.
He said a dark winter.
That's what he called it, a dark winter.
And I think the challenge for us is, well, I should rephrase this.
I don't think there is a path towards de-escalation.
And I've said this quite some, a long time ago.
And I had, it's really interesting, the left repeatedly claimed that I was wrong and hyperbolic and fear-mongering and all that for simply saying, look what happened.
This is freaky.
Why would it stop?
I'm worried about this.
And then when it does happen, they're like, why were you talking about it?
You shouldn't have mentioned that Atlantic wrote about a coming civil war.
Like, how dare you read what the mainstream media is saying?
The issue, there was a tweet earlier from the, someone wrote in the Washington Post, I think it was Margaret Sullivan.
She said it was Tucker's fault.
It was Hannity's fault.
It was Fox News's fault.
And I'm like, if I recall, they were condemning the violence all year.
And it was CNN who said protests have to be peaceful.
But when you see tweets like that, when you see Democrats calling for expulsion, calling for escalation, then I would be more than happy to have everybody just be like, we don't want to do this anymore.
Who wants to go see a movie?
I'd be like, I'm down.
I don't care what your politics are.
Let's go grab pizza and a beer and hang out and just stop all this.
But you've got a constant berating and beating and suppression happening where they didn't just go for the president today.
They're going for his supporters and they're nuking everybody.
Steve Bannon's War Room deleted.
The YouTube channel's gone.
They're making sure they're purging this aspect of American culture.
ian crossland
I think there's no linear path to de-escalation, maybe.
Like you said earlier, it's a compounding or an exponential escalation in any direction.
Because of the way the system works now, it started with radio and television that you could speak for an hour, but then people could listen to it for 10,000 hours.
Even though you only spent an hour of your time, 10,000 hours of listening could accrue.
Or a hundred thousand or a million.
And now with internet video, it's not just on for an hour a day.
It's on there permanently for like exponentially more listening hours or potential.
So change can happen exponentially in any direction, including a deescalative function.
bill ottman
Totally agree, man.
It could happen within days if with the right powers in place.
luke rudkowski
Bill, you brought up a good point.
You got to be prepared for this stuff.
You guys were preparing.
You guys have an alternative.
I was preparing.
I've been collecting emails on, you know, wearechanged.org because I knew something was coming.
Donald Trump supporters are screaming about this, saying this is going to happen to you.
You need to do something.
You need to prepare.
Some of us have prepared, but essentially, you know, let's just be honest here.
He, I mean, It's not just that he wasn't prepared.
He was sometimes ignoring individuals telling him directly, this huge censorship hammer is coming your way.
tim pool
Well, how long ago was it that we were at the White House?
bill ottman
A year or something?
tim pool
A year?
Longer than a year.
It was like a year and a half.
And Trump was just like, what platform should I use?
Didn't think to ask someone?
bill ottman
Well, he invited us.
Yeah, but he was resisting because he has a very mainstream approach to things.
tim pool
He's an old guy and he's very TV, watches Fox and all that.
I don't understand why Dan Scavino didn't.
He's savvy.
Or at the time it was Brad Parscale.
Why didn't any one of these people say, let us run the account for you?
We'll set up a parlor, we'll set up a mines, whatever.
bill ottman
I mean, what really worries me is just the normal people sitting on social media watching the preaching happen and, you know, glorification of this kind of event.
And like, people with good intentions actually do think that this is helping.
And that's what's really scary.
It's like people genuinely believe That this path is going to make the world safer.
tim pool
I'll tell you one thing.
You take a look at the people with connections, the people with resources, and the people of great success, and what have they been doing?
They've been buying Bitcoin.
I wonder why.
They've been buying land in rural areas and fleeing cities for some time.
They certainly must know something.
Maybe they don't all think the same thing, but they think something similar.
And when you see people like, I don't know, a couple years ago, going on a major podcast and warning about a coming conflict due to censorship, and then saying, I'm going to build a van, so, you know, a bug-out van.
And now here we are with the Capitol being stormed.
You know, I don't expect, like, a plumber to be fully tuned into what's happening, but there are people who base all their investments on just, they wait for Warren Buffett to do something.
Like, he must know something, so I'll just buy what he buys, right?
Well, when you see all of the people who have access to government officials and media institutions and intelligence agencies fleeing to rural states, red states and rural areas and buying up swathes of land, it should make you think something about what's going on and what you should maybe consider.
luke rudkowski
Another thing to really kind of deep dive into and to really think about is we're also seeing something that is curated for us.
So the algorithm, the newsfeed, the curated timeline, they're showing you people celebrating, but that doesn't essentially mean that a lot of people are celebrating and those viewpoints can be manipulated.
Our perceptions can be manipulated by what we're selected to see, and already there have been studies done showing how the timeline could manipulate your emotions and how they can make you feel different emotions just by deciding what to show you.
They could do that on so many other different levels.
tim pool
Do you know about the Confessions of the Economic Hitman?
luke rudkowski
Yeah, of course.
tim pool
Yeah, one of the things he talks about is that in order to stage a coup in a foreign country, one of the things you do is you hire about 1,000 people to protest and film it, and then from those tight camera angles showing massive crowds, you say it's 100,000.
And then people believe it, and they think the country is in chaos, and then it makes regular people freak out.
We've seen a lot of things done through various intelligence agencies with sock puppet accounts, which is, you know, bots.
Sock puppet accounts, basically one person will have 50 accounts with fake pictures, with fake names, and they'll post things attempting to manipulate and influence people.
And this is an ongoing problem around the world.
The US used to do it all the time to manipulate foreign countries.
luke rudkowski
The US government and the Israeli government admitted that they had government agents that are trying to sow a particular viewpoint and a particular narrative that are working from the tax dollars to push the government's agenda.
So this is something also talked about by Cass Sunstein, Obama's former information czar, who talked about how there needs to be an effort to undermine individuals who are affected by 9-11, like family members who had questions about that event.
He specifically talked about how the online community needs to be infiltrated.
needs to have people who go on there and make everyone else look bad so people don't take some of these serious
legitimate questions seriously.
And he talked about pretty much informational warfare about how to undermine any legitimate form of criticism of
government.
tim pool
Well, there are, I'm not going to name the companies for, you know, legal reasons, probably litigious, but they
dominate Reddit.
There are political organizations that have training manuals on how you derail conversations and manipulate opinion.
So when a post pops up and says, you know, Donald Trump does backflip, Someone will comment, I like Backflip.
And they tell you, if someone says, I like what Trump is doing, respond with this.
And they have a script.
And so these people, their whole job is to go on and comment on each other's posts.
There was a really funny incident where two people who clearly worked for two different companies were commenting on each other.
And someone pointed out, it was robotic, almost.
And they were like, this is where you can see where the tangle happens.
when two companies trying to promote I think it was promoting Democrats collided and
It created this weird loop of nonsensical comment every comment because they were just they weren't actually
responding They were like, well the chart says if they say this I say
luke rudkowski
this and so then it creates like a feedback loop You know, I mean it makes you really wonder because I'm
right now on Twitter and I'm seeing a lot of people celebrating
I'm seeing a lot of people. I'm seeing a lot of the reply guys who are gonna be out of work now
Yeah, I know, I love it.
And let's be honest, some of it is legitimate, but then I also wonder maybe some of the celebration, maybe some of the victor all that's promoting this larger narrative and agenda could be potentially manipulated.
I don't know.
I haven't proved it, but I just know for a fact.
That it happened before with other agendas, with other special interests that manipulated the system to procure a perception that leads you to be programmed in a way that is beneficial for those doing the programming.
And that's exactly what we have to understand here.
When we're giving our attention, when we're looking at this timeline, we are giving a part of ourselves into this larger company that could now take so much from us.
When something's free, you are the product.
and they could twist it turn it and they could be like well you know well maybe he does need to buy this or this they already know so much about you it's absolutely terrifying so what can they do with that information the possibilities are endless and we should not be kidding ourselves if those possibilities aren't being used and institutionalized and implemented right now well That's the problem with proprietary code, in my opinion, is that you don't know what the algorithm is doing, which is why I'm obsessed with mines.
ian crossland
I didn't even know when I met you, you were like, hey, let's build a social network.
My first thought was another one.
Why?
There's already Facebook, Twitter and YouTube.
We don't need one.
But then you started telling me about free software and the power of knowing what the algorithm is doing to you.
tim pool
So it's literally doing things to us. So is you bill who radicalized him into screaming free the code I did it was
bill ottman
Introduced him to Richard Stallman and Linus Torvalds But I mean it is true like Linux for an example like which
took over the whole operating system infrastructure of the whole
Financial system the whole world because it's free. It's free. I mean it and that is going to happen with everything
tim pool
Well, so let me just explain something real quick to people and understand
Linux is an operating system.
It's free.
It's great.
And people realize that if you're using some of these traditional operating systems, which you probably know, like Windows, you gotta pay for licenses.
Linux is free.
So just put Linux on all your servers.
Yeah, you go.
You save a lot of money.
bill ottman
Yeah.
So in the biggest, even Facebook and Twitter and Google use Linux heavily.
tim pool
Yeah.
bill ottman
But then they build on top of it and they don't share their little secret sauce.
ian crossland
And that's because it's an open source code and not a free code.
bill ottman
Like isn't there software codes where if you build on top of it, you have to make different licensing structures.
ian crossland
And so the difference is an open source software like Linux, you can build on top of it and make it private and then call that whole thing private.
But with a free software code, you can build on top of it.
It has to remain free.
And so any changes you ever make going forward remain free.
bill ottman
And yeah, it's called copy left.
Copy the principle of having to share copyright.
unidentified
Yeah.
bill ottman
Copyright.
Yeah.
So, you know, and everyone should be able to do whatever they want to do.
But that's the funny thing that, you know, it's sort of a left principle.
I mean, both are good, but it's everything switching.
And what you were saying about, like, where you find the source of truth.
When you look at what the left and the right agree on, like the progressives and libertarians, like find those people who can talk.
You know, Dennis Kucinich made a really interesting statement where he's like, you know, me and Ron Paul are like best friends, basically.
tim pool
Back in the day.
bill ottman
Back in the day.
And they would he said that on many votes, if you look back in the record, it was always like hundreds to two.
And it was, it was them.
It was the two guys from the government, both sides of the spectrum.
So if it was like something involving civil liberties or surveillance or we're not, it would, it would be those two guys who, who voted together.
And so, you know, that's where the truth is.
And that's why, like, you know, some people don't like Tucker Carlson, but like Glenn Greenwald will get on there and talk to Tucker.
I mean, you have like, that's an important, so yeah.
So these people who are willing to have the conversations, but have radically different political beliefs, but that's why they're all called right wing.
unidentified
Right.
tim pool
Now the weird thing is they can't call Jimmy right wing, so they smear him in other ways.
They call him a shill or whatever because he's not right wing.
He's like screaming, we gotta have Medicare for all and they're not fighting for us.
It doesn't work.
But he criticizes the Democrats all the time.
Now Tulsi Gabbard, she's not right wing.
She's also for... She's for universal healthcare with private insurance.
That's what I agree with.
And they attack her for it, for not being left enough.
It's crazy!
Like, most countries in the world that have universal healthcare, when the left is like, oh, all the countries do it, yeah, they have private health insurance on top of it.
And that's what she's for, but they call her right-wing.
They call all- Glenn Greenwald has been right-wing for a long time.
It's hilarious.
ian crossland
It's easy to slap that label on somebody.
bill ottman
But the funny thing is, with Biden, he's always been generally moderate, hasn't he?
Traditionally, was he a radical left?
tim pool
No, he wasn't.
The better way to put it is, he says what he thinks he needs to say to reach the lowest common denominator.
luke rudkowski
But we also have to understand when we're talking about individuals like Tucker or Greenwald or Tracy, these are individuals who also criticize Trump, right?
These are individuals who actually have, you know, virtues, who actually have principles, who actually have ideas that they believe in that they don't flip-flop on no matter what the political alignment is.
They rather go on merit rather than political ideology which is something that's extremely rare should be promoted more but sadly we're seeing less and less of and we're going to see a lot less of that especially because behavior like that was not incentivized by the algorithms people knew if they wanted more followers they wanted more engagement they would Metaphorically take a dump on their political opposition and they were dunking on them and everyone was celebrating and they were fighting and then until the fighting gets so out of hand where here we are today in this censorship.
They know it's going to spread more paranoia.
They know it's going to spread more fear.
They know it's going to spread more conspiracy theories disinformation and false news and it's going to make it worse.
So the fire is being fueled.
It's it's out of hand already.
And it's going to get a lot hotter in here.
So that's my two cents.
bill ottman
Yeah, it's burning up.
And it's it's crazy that, you know, there are internal wars happening at these companies as well.
Like one of the anomalies that I am trying to understand is like Peter Thiel, for instance, is on the board of Facebook.
He was a big Trump supporter.
lydia smith
I didn't realize he was with Facebook.
tim pool
Yeah, he was.
bill ottman
Peter Thiel was Facebook's first.
Do you see the movie The Social Network?
tim pool
Yeah.
bill ottman
You know, when he walked in that guy's office and he gave him his first hundred K check or whatever?
That was Peter Thiel.
Peter Thiel is like a traditional libertarian guy.
And granted, he does invest in companies that I think have really bad privacy abuses.
I mean, Facebook, Palantir, these kinds of things.
But he's also big on Bitcoin and he's playing both sides of the spectrum.
And so it's just like unbelievable that they're not seeing the long game here.
ian crossland
Yeah, his argument with starting Palantir was that there was going to be a 21st century spy tech, and so it may as well be us.
Because we have good intentions for people.
That was his mentality.
luke rudkowski
I hear a lot of dictators use that same kind of logic.
tim pool
We should go to Super Chats!
So, uh, man, we got so many super chats in today that once we get too many, YouTube's actually removing a bunch of them.
Well, no, that's bad.
I mean, it means, yeah, too many come in and then the old ones just fall all over.
I'm just saying, I feel bad for people whose messages, you know, ended up getting erased.
Yeah, you know, so about half an hour's worth of super chats, you know.
ian crossland
Sure, tweet any ones that you got on.
lydia smith
Yeah, tweet them at us.
ian crossland
Destroy, tweet them at us.
tim pool
Let's see what we got here.
So, if you haven't already, smash the like button, subscribe, hit the notification bell, and if you want to support the show, you can go to timcast.com slash donates to donate directly, assuming, you know, eventually something happens to this channel, but we should have the full site up and running soon.
lydia smith
Yes!
tim pool
And by soon, I mean like a few days or so.
So, That'll be good.
And then we'll have, you know, exclusive content on the website, and it'll be great.
But let's read some of these superchats.
ian crossland
Let me also suggest you smash that gorilla and buy a t-shirt.
tim pool
Oh, and I'll let you guys know, the I Am A Gorilla t-shirt is officially up on the Teespring store.
But YouTube has to approve of it, so if you go to the Teespring store, which I think might be linked below, I don't know.
Oh, it is, yeah.
Then there's the I Am A Gorilla shirt, it's in there.
ian crossland
I saw you guys bought a bunch of Harumph t-shirts last night, that was exciting.
unidentified
Oh, did they?
Yeah.
They did.
tim pool
Well, next we're going to put the Gorilla one up.
ian crossland
Ooh, yeah.
tim pool
And then we have the I Am A Gorilla Love Yourself, which will be fun.
ian crossland
I like it.
lydia smith
Correct.
tim pool
Daniel Maxwell says, they want to prevent the center and right from organizing and planning out a political counterattack.
The problem is doing this is going to force us closer to a violent solution, which is not going to end well for anybody.
I think, I don't think there's an organization necessarily other than they don't like, the other is bad.
I think both sides think the other is bad.
And one side is calling for censorship and one side is calling for free speech.
The censorship side is winning because these people are squeaky wheels that never stop complaining.
When, you know, well, they control news organizations, but I'll leave it there.
Somebody mentioned that Trump tweeted using the government account, everyone go read, which we did read.
lydia smith
Yeah, I deleted it.
tim pool
Let's see.
Oh, that was an important one.
Omega Blade says, can you bring the puppy back in to help promote a healthy safe space during this time of strife?
luke rudkowski
Jim doesn't want the puppy in the house.
tim pool
You can bring it in the show if you want to go bring the puppy.
Luke doesn't want to get up.
He's too lazy.
ian crossland
The puppy peed too many times?
lydia smith
Yeah.
unidentified
A few.
lydia smith
It's a lot of work.
luke rudkowski
We're training.
ian crossland
He's chewing up the carpet too.
tim pool
Running around shaking all flopping all happy.
luke rudkowski
Making everyone joyous.
unidentified
All right, let's see.
tim pool
S-Head says, I've seen too many people calling for revolution and all the actions that will be the precursor to civil war.
Everyone needs to watch the Peter Capaldi Doctor Who speech about revolution.
Maybe then they will understand where it all leads to.
I wrote a song about that!
ian crossland
What's it called?
tim pool
It's called Will of the People.
lydia smith
Oh yeah!
ian crossland
You guys should listen to it.
tim pool
On this YouTube channel.
So it's actually one of the top videos now, because it's got like 700,000 views.
That's crazy.
I didn't think, you guys are awesome.
bill ottman
Get it to a million.
tim pool
But, uh, that would be great if those who are watching should check it out.
But if you haven't seen the video and I, and I, look, it's a video I made.
It's a song I wrote and performed.
It was produced by Nishra Allman.
It is about the cycle of revolution and how these people who think they're fighting for a better future will not get what they think.
And, uh, as the saying goes, be careful when fighting monsters, lest ye become one.
For when you gaze into the abyss, the abyss gazes back.
But yeah, check it out.
Will of the People on YouTube, on this YouTube channel.
You can search for it.
luke rudkowski
I'm also hearing the quartering was just taken down.
unidentified
What?
tim pool
No, but that looks like he deleted it.
unidentified
Okay.
luke rudkowski
That's the initial reports.
Unverified now.
tim pool
What I'm seeing on Twitter says the account doesn't exist.
lydia smith
I got a message.
tim pool
As opposed to this account has been suspended.
ian crossland
Jeremy got rid of his YouTube channel?
tim pool
No, Twitter.
ian crossland
Oh, Twitter.
tim pool
But he did it before.
lydia smith
He's done it before.
unidentified
Yeah.
Yeah.
lydia smith
It's not new.
tim pool
All right, let's see.
Timothy Hediger says, terms of service greater than First Amendment.
Well, that's the problem now, isn't it?
ian crossland
Yeah, does mine's terms of service strictly adhere to the First Amendment?
bill ottman
Mostly, but like there's certain things like malicious spam that isn't in the First Amendment.
ian crossland
So I've been talking a lot about rewriting a bill of rights, like an internet bill of rights.
bill ottman
There have been documents.
I mean, there's like the Manila principles.
There's the Santa Clara principles.
There's a number.
Like, yeah, go to manilaprinciples.org, actually.
It was drafted by the EFF, who, you know, in some ways... I think it's a similar ideology coming out of them as the ACLU.
It's like they sort of start... John Perry Barlow... They're authoritarians.
But also not.
Also not.
No, I mean, like... They're pro-censorship.
There are very good people that I know at the EFF who are not pro-censorship.
They're not pro-censorship, though.
tim pool
As an organization, they tweet pro-censorship stuff all the time.
They used to be, I used to be a big advocate, I donated.
Go to the hacker conventions, EFF.
I actually fundraised for the ACLU at one point.
Now they're pro-censorship.
They advocate for removing people's right to speech.
lydia smith
Yeah, repeatedly.
bill ottman
Well, they're standing up for 230.
tim pool
Standing up for 230?
Yeah.
Yeah, but we need 230 reform to protect people's right to speak.
Not just blanket keep it or leave it.
Yeah, nah, I'm not a fan.
Anyway, Daniel Nelson says, to make matters worse, we can't even go to open mics right now.
Our literal public town square for locals is currently not available.
I am trying not to be very frustrated right now.
And that's a very important point.
None of us can go out to public squares, or to town hall, or even church, where we normally communicate, and you're forced into these ideological bubbles.
Now they're banning, they tell you you can't go to church, then they ban you from social media.
These people are gonna burst, man.
luke rudkowski
And the church and the pubs have historically been a place for organizing rebellions.
tim pool
Now they're shut down.
unidentified
Coffee houses.
tim pool
He goes on to say, anyway, which foot should I be catching pop shoves?
lydia smith
Good question.
unidentified
What, what, what?
tim pool
That's not a good question.
It's your front foot.
End of story.
I don't understand.
I guess if you're doing like a nollie pop shove it, you do your back foot.
ian crossland
Left foot or right foot.
Was that the question?
tim pool
I am clueless.
Everyone in the room but Tim.
Do you know anything about skating?
regular shove it. So are you regular goofy? What are you talking about? You do a
nollie shove it, you could maybe use your back foot, but I guess a front foot would
still be cool if you did a nollie pop shove it. Some jargon there for all of
you have no idea what I'm talking about. I am clueless.
ian crossland
Everyone in the room but Tim.
luke rudkowski
Do you know anything about skateboarding? I have no idea what that's like. That's like Ewok talk.
tim pool
Kelty skateboard jargon?
Come on.
Kelty said, my company in Seattle just announced it will hunt and fire outwardly racist people online or in private life participation.
Chilling.
Who judges outwardly?
NRA, Republican?
Who are the fascists?
If you're not, if you're, look.
You ever see that episode of Rick and Morty where the giant heads come and then the guy forms a religion where they wear clay heads?
lydia smith
Show us what you got.
ian crossland
I think so.
tim pool
And then, like, whatever the faces do, they interpret it in some ridiculous way.
And when Rick and Morty's parents are like, we don't want to be involved in this, then they tie them to balloons and prepare to send them to their deaths.
Like, that's basically what it is.
We don't know what we're talking about.
It's very Bronze Age tribal religious type behavior.
Just adhere to the tribe, do as you're told, no wrong think.
You know?
ian crossland
Yeah, saying racist is a weird term.
tim pool
It's not even about racist, though.
It's just about, are you a member of the tribe or not?
Will you conform or not?
Otherwise, they'll chase you out.
That's about it.
All right, let's see some more super chats here.
Timmy Rice says, my question is for everyone in the room, lids included.
Would you sideline your social beliefs for free speech and freedom?
What does that mean?
lydia smith
You could be quiet.
tim pool
Would you sideline your social beliefs?
unidentified
Yeah.
ian crossland
Like, I'm not going to push some personal narrative to destroy your ability to speak freely.
lydia smith
Yeah.
tim pool
Wait, I think it's a hard question.
Would I, my beliefs for freedom of speech, like would I ever give up on my belief in freedom of speech?
ian crossland
Would you give up your beliefs in order for other people to have free speech?
tim pool
But my beliefs are for free speech.
bill ottman
Sort of an oxymoron.
ian crossland
But what if your beliefs were, maybe they're not, maybe you think they are, but would you put down what you truly believe?
tim pool
Those who would give up a little bit of freedom in exchange for security deserve neither.
unidentified
We'll lose both.
tim pool
Sam Good says, Hey, how does Ian get things done?
If you have to break things down to complete individuality.
Tim, you get angry too east?
lydia smith
Too easily.
tim pool
Too easily.
I'm a social liberal and a financial conservative.
Okay.
ian crossland
Depends on get done what?
Sometimes I write it down.
tim pool
People are warning about what's going to happen on the inauguration day.
People are posting things online about the 20th.
bill ottman
I think Tim and Ian arguments are becoming a meme in themselves.
tim pool
Well yeah, but that's partly the point.
ian crossland
Tim reminds me of a lot of people I've known throughout my life.
tim pool
Well, it is a meme.
Like when you weren't here the other day, people were posting, no Ian, no peace.
And then they were posting free the code.
ian crossland
Dude, you should hear us sing together.
It's magical.
unidentified
It's great.
lydia smith
Yeah, it's awesome.
tim pool
No, but people were posting free the code in chat because you weren't here.
unidentified
And the Fed and stuff.
bill ottman
I can't believe I radicalized you.
luke rudkowski
I say we get boxing gloves and a live feed.
lydia smith
Yes, let's do it.
tim pool
Oh, Lord.
lydia smith
I'm here for it.
ian crossland
Oh, God.
tim pool
Dan Orlowski says, the FCC sent out a message stating that broadcast station that they have an obligation to play the messages put out by the emergency alert system.
Wait, really?
lydia smith
I don't know.
Never heard that.
tim pool
Akapot says, Ian, you're way smarter than people give you credit for.
You rock, man.
Keep it up.
ian crossland
Thanks to all of you.
tim pool
Keep it up.
ian crossland
I'm just an amalgam of all the people I know.
tim pool
Your comment on the limitation of right-left is astute.
Google political circle.
It's not a line.
Actually, Gavin McInnes drew a picture and posted it once, showing the political circle.
But it's just another way to interpret certain beliefs in a spectrum.
If you talk about left and right economically, it's easily aligned.
When you talk about tradition versus progress, it's easily aligned.
When you talk about authoritarianism, then you can make it a circle because there are certain groups that align with each other, but based on ideological differences like racism or something, they'll agree completely.
Like, there are alt-right people who are for universal healthcare and left-wing politics, but they're racist.
So it's like their politics, their market ideas, are very similar, but they have weird, you know, cultural ideas.
ian crossland
Or like people that want Medicare for all, but they're authoritarian about it, versus people that want it, but they're libertarian about it.
tim pool
Like ban private health insurance versus let people buy private health insurance.
It's the authoritarian versus the libertarian.
Bernie Sanders says, ban that.
Take that away from people.
They have no right to choose.
ian crossland
That's very authoritarian of them.
tim pool
It is, yeah.
Only the government can give you your health care.
The libertarian approach is, we will create the option for universal health care, and then you can choose to get private insurance, because then you can have something, you know, supplemental if you can afford it, or if you need it.
I don't understand the logic of taking away people's right to choose.
That makes no sense.
DTRJr says, radios equal free speech.
Bring radio broadcasting back.
unidentified
Okay.
bill ottman
Have you considered doing terrestrial?
tim pool
I don't know anything about it.
bill ottman
That'd be hilarious.
tim pool
I mean, they're a lot of fun to do.
They do terrestrial.
ian crossland
We were looking at getting a ham radio, shortwave radio.
tim pool
Yeah, we should do that.
ian crossland
We'd have to get like a band and then we'd be able to broadcast.
bill ottman
There are certain licenses you need, I think.
tim pool
We have way too many Super Chats today, guys.
I'm so sorry.
So let's see.
Corey Blair says WikiLeaks just dumped.
Link on Parler.
I'm not going to read any of that based on what he's saying because I don't know if it's true, but there's a lot in there.
So I don't know if they actually released anything, but you know, there you go.
Oh, more people are saying it.
WikiLeaks just dumped all their classified files on Clinton emails.
lydia smith
Interesting.
tim pool
Really?
lydia smith
I had to look that up.
tim pool
Wow.
lydia smith
Curious now.
tim pool
Alright, let's see.
Travis Ruiz says, Hey Tim, thanks.
I was an active DNC supporter until I saw what you were talking about.
Facebook is building a data center in Huntsville, Alabama.
The FBI is also building here.
And it's... And then he made an emoji face.
Hmm.
Yeah, I don't like the Republican Party, obviously.
I don't like the Democrats.
That's why she didn't vote for these people.
You know, Donald Trump was different.
But not like Donald Trump is necessarily a good president.
Look, I think in terms of certain issues that I've talked about, particularly war and dealing with critical race theory, he's been a lot better than any president in my lifetime.
Like, no new wars.
unidentified
Yep.
tim pool
He's had problems with some conflicts, but it's been, you know.
ian crossland
Once I found out about the drone war and his escalation and secretization of the drone wars I got, I lost a lot of respect for Donald Trump.
And that was only like a few months ago when I was talking to Luke about it on the show.
I didn't realize that he had secretized government authorization of drone strikes now.
It's like on the high command of the military.
tim pool
Dan Scope says, Order 66 has been called.
The Jedi, defender of law and order, have become enemies of the Republic and must be removed.
Next step is transfer emergency powers to the Chancellor to get us through the crisis.
I just watched Revenge of the Sith the other night.
Man, it's so different watching that movie now that I'm older.
I can't remember, when did that come out?
Like 2000s?
ian crossland
2001 is when the first one came out.
tim pool
The first prequel?
ian crossland
Yeah.
tim pool
But man, the dialogue is so corny and like, oddly acted.
ian crossland
I mean, what's his name?
George Lucas?
Just not a good dialogue writer.
tim pool
I don't think so.
And his directing, making him act that way was weird.
But it is, I don't know, I think it's an interesting, you know, analog in a sense, or analogy.
Like, Order 66.
They're now purging people.
I wouldn't necessarily call the people being purged Jedi, you know, because it's, you know, it's nuanced politics here.
ian crossland
Force sensitive?
tim pool
No.
Well, depending on who's getting banned, you could say that there are people who are perspicacious.
ian crossland
What's that mean?
tim pool
An acuteness to comprehension of reality.
ian crossland
Like, oh, that's awesome.
tim pool
Yeah.
ian crossland
Perspective.
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
Right.
Yeah.
Perspicacious.
Yes, let's see.
Nate Hammer says, removal from office after impeachment requires 67 senators, two-thirds, to vote for it.
That's right.
So a simple majority would not be enough.
It's not going to happen.
I mean, I really don't think so.
There are people posting something.
I've seen some Democrats post this.
They said something to the effect of, Josh Hawley and these other Republican members of Congress will gladly accept a Trump fundraiser down the line.
And I'm like, yes, they will.
What do you mean Trump fundraiser?
trying to imply is it's a bad thing that must be stopped.
ian crossland
What do you mean Trump fundraiser?
tim pool
Like in the future Trump will hold a fundraiser for political candidates.
And then they'll go and shake his hand and all his supporters will be there and some
outlets have said he'll be a kingmaker.
He'll choose the winners and losers when it comes to the Republican Party because they
love Trump.
And the argument from these people who are posting about it is that it's a bad thing
that must be stopped.
What did ABC say?
ABC wrote an article saying, how do you cleanse the Trump movement from the Republican Party or whatever?
bill ottman
Yeah, that's scary language.
tim pool
Exactly, right.
Key Lo says, if they expel all the senators and reps that supported Trump, how do you think the states they represent will react?
unidentified
Hmm.
tim pool
Secession?
No taxation without representation?
If they expel representatives from a state that supported Trump, that would be crazy.
The senator?
There's no representation for the state.
It would be outrage.
bill ottman
What were you talking about before about sort of the governmental sort of check that they're doing on people's beliefs with cops?
tim pool
Oh, Luke brought that up.
Luke brought that up.
bill ottman
Okay.
luke rudkowski
Well, I'm just looking at my Twitter.
Sorry, I was distracted.
tim pool
There was something going on.
luke rudkowski
I just lost a thousand followers just now.
tim pool
Mass purge going on.
luke rudkowski
It's crazy.
tim pool
But you were saying that the cops are going to be vetted now?
They're going to go and check them?
luke rudkowski
Well, there was a new report that the Capitol Police officers will be investigated for ties with white supremacy after Debbie Washerman Schultz, Congresswoman, released a statement saying that she thinks that there was insider... It was an inside job?
Yeah.
tim pool
She thinks the U.S.
Capitol was an inside job?
luke rudkowski
No, she thinks that there was officers who helped people get in.
tim pool
They did.
luke rudkowski
It's on video.
And she thinks that some of them had ties to some of the protesters and now we're getting information that all the officers will be investigated for, quote, ties of white supremacy.
tim pool
But what does white supremacy mean?
We've heard that argument before.
luke rudkowski
We've heard people called Nazis for just the simplest, smallest, littlest microaggressions.
So again, who knows?
tim pool
I'm seeing rumors that Cloudflare has removed 4chan, but I'm not... I saw it earlier, I wasn't able to confirm it.
ian crossland
Cloudflare, that's like Amazon Web Service, right?
bill ottman
They're like a CDN.
luke rudkowski
This is slowly becoming China when it comes to their control of the internet.
If you look at what happens when a small group of people control the internet, you essentially have China.
Then you essentially have the social credit score.
Then you essentially have them literally using American Twitter to talk about how great it is that Uyghur women are no longer baby-making machines and that it's great for gender equality that they have pretty much essentially concentration camps for them.
bill ottman
It's so important to contextualize how the rest of the world is looking at us right now.
OK, yes, people are probably disgusted with what happened at the Capitol, but like people in oppressive authoritarian government regimes are looking at this censorship and like being like, what are you doing?
I mean, they are problems are just so much less than what's going on in in these countries where they can't even go on the Internet at all.
And we're banned.
Our our companies, our private companies are banning people from the Internet.
tim pool
We've got major.
Major breaking news.
I don't know if you guys saw this earlier, but Olive Garden put out a statement about Sean Hannity and banning him from the NeverEnding Possible.
unidentified
Oh no!
lydia smith
His viscous attacks.
tim pool
Uh, we have a statement from Sean Hennedy saying, I never signed up for Olive Garden's never-ending pasta pass.
Hennedy says it's fake news.
ian crossland
How can you ban someone from something they didn't have?
tim pool
I don't know.
I don't think Olive Garden ever actually said it.
I think someone made a graphic because it was hilarious, this idea, like, we're- They misspelled vicious.
lydia smith
Oh, what in the- To viscous, yeah.
tim pool
Oh, to viscous.
lydia smith
Everyone was mocking it.
Matt Taibbi was mocking it.
tim pool
Interesting.
ian crossland
That's like who got banned from some service from like monkey something they didn't have.
lydia smith
MailChimp.
unidentified
Yes.
ian crossland
Who got banned from MailChimp?
unidentified
Enrique, yeah.
ian crossland
They didn't even have a MailChimp.
tim pool
Yeah, so they just claimed it because activists claimed he did.
So then they announced they banned him even though he was never with the service.
Yeah.
Let's see.
Airsoft Master says, Hey Tim, if Google, Facebook, and Twitter kind of companies keep heading the way they are going in regards to limiting speech, do you think we will ever be able to backtrack to before all of this, or is it to the point of no return?
Look, if you only ever ban more and more people, then eventually there's no more people left to ban.
And it'll be Jack Dorsey sitting in a small room going like, I think, um, um, there's, my opinion is bad.
I'll ban myself.
And then it's an empty server with nobody in it.
ian crossland
They're going to build AI for you to interact with.
If you want a social network where they're still populated, it'll just be a bunch of artificial bots.
I'm wondering when they're going to build Love Simulator, the video game.
luke rudkowski
Some people say TikTok was allegedly doing that, but who knows?
ian crossland
Wow.
tim pool
When you ban everybody, then nobody is banned.
I guess technically that doesn't work because then nobody will be on the platform.
But imagine Twitter just bans everyone.
And then what happens when the left can't actually get to an argument anymore?
So they start going to parlor.
Because they've started doing it.
They actually go there.
And then they post screenshots laughing about, you know, owning the cons or whatever.
And like the stupid things they post.
And I'm like...
There you go!
So it'll be like digital drive-by arguments where like Twitter will be left-wing and Parler will be right-wing and then someone on Twitter will go to Parler and then say something and screenshot it and go back to Twitter and post it.
lydia smith
It looks like they banned Rush Limbaugh.
unidentified
Whoa.
Yeah.
lydia smith
Yep.
Good times.
Yeah.
He's totally gone.
ian crossland
I don't think we're ever going to be able to go back to where we were.
lydia smith
No way.
ian crossland
We'll be able to move forward to a different dimension, like a different way of Internet.
Like, I don't think the centralized proprietary services are going to be the future of social media.
It'll be more of a, you know, decentralized.
I like this are we've block blockchain, you know, mesh net type.
bill ottman
I think there is a large group of people who do want to talk to people who are different from them and, you know, rational Democrats, Republicans, people on the left or right who want to go and find someone that's different from them.
There's a pocket of people that exist like that.
It's probably a small group.
That's more what we're trying to do on Minds.com.
Have the conversation cross-spectrum, be open to both sides, not just Not just one side or the other, but, you know, it is definitely, you know, you can either ride the divide, and that's what all of these big networks are doing, and that's what some alternatives are doing, or, you know, you can try to bridge people together, but it's way harder.
tim pool
We got a super chat here from Christopher Yager.
He says, Tim vastly overestimates the degree to which the right would be using social media and internet to organize in a civil war scenario.
Not necessarily.
I just think it's a powerful tool.
But with that being said, there's a really interesting story I read once that, I don't know if it's true or not, but I read it in the context of nonfiction.
I think it was in a magazine or something or some website.
They talked about how there's, you know, modern warfare, and then there's the archaic forms of warfare we used to have.
And they were doing a training scenario where they brought in a retired, you know, general or high-ranking officer.
To lead a group to do a war game scenario against the current, you know, military, the modern warfare.
And the modern group, with all their new technology and everything, lost to rudimentary and old school tactics and technologies.
And what they did was, the linchpin for how the retired guy defeated the modern army was that the modern groups were relying on digital technology for communication.
And so the old school guy slipped a note into the pocket of a guy on a motorcycle to transfer the orders, and they didn't know how to track what was being done or what they were saying or what they were going to do, and they were trying to monitor communications through radio, and it was just a guy on a bike with a note in his pocket.
Gave him the orders, and then took him by surprise.
It could be just an apocryphal story about not forgetting your fundamentals.
Maybe it's not true.
But it was a much, much, much longer story.
Maybe someone online has heard that story before.
But it's really interesting.
Because it makes sense.
You get caught up in what you expect, and you ignore the simple solutions.
So yeah, ham radio.
People talked about that.
And ham internet.
Do you guys know about that?
No.
I don't know a whole lot about it, but people using ham radio to get really...
Some internet signals.
ian crossland
Yeah, but it's real slow, but you can send like characters and text and stuff.
tim pool
Yeah, using him.
Yeah.
Yep.
Deniz Atik says, Luke, where did you get your shirt?
luke rudkowski
Oh, that's such a nice, great question.
I really appreciate that.
Yes.
You could get my shirt on wearechange.org forward slash shirts, and they go towards keeping me free and independent and here.
So thank you guys so much for, uh, where, you know, buying and wearing my shirts.
It means a lot to me.
tim pool
Dennis also says, Tim, you would make my day if you said, I am a gorilla in a deep voice.
I did my best.
Um, we do have the I am a gorilla shirt coming.
It is done.
It's on the Teespring store.
In the description below is the link to the Teespring store.
It should be there.
You should be able to see it.
And then YouTube has a separate approval process.
And then once it's there, we'll feature it.
And then the next one coming is the I am a gorilla love yourself.
See, you know, the shirts we're making are silly.
Like me with a bubble pipe saying Harumph.
And Luke's got these very serious, like the world, the apocalypse is here and we're all doomed.
luke rudkowski
Essentially, but they sell pretty good and I think it's a great way to meet people.
When I wear the shirt, especially the toilet paper one, I have one that talks about the pyramid of control and on top is the toilet paper manufacturers.
It starts conversations and then underneath is the Illuminati and then underneath is the CIA and the media.
But again, it starts conversations, which is important because then you could see someone is a part of your tribe.
Someone is thinking the way you are.
And it's a great way to build a community.
I mean, when I'm walking around, people are like, man, I love that shirt.
I love that hat.
And I'm able to talk to them and know someone in the community that is thinking the way that I am.
So it's a great way of bringing people together.
tim pool
Garhentz says, Tim, the military one is the Millennium Challenge 2002, and it's Lieutenant General Paul Van Riper.
I'm sure I got a lot of the story wrong, because it's like 2002.
I probably haven't read it in a long time, but that's the gist of it.
So I'll look into that to see if that's the story, because it was a really cool story when I read it.
Let's see.
Scott Brumley says, any truth to Google and Apple banning the Parler app?
Yeah.
Yeah.
I don't know if Apple's done it yet, but I know Google has.
luke rudkowski
Yeah.
ian crossland
And you've already talked about that.
Mines has been through this before.
bill ottman
Yeah, you have to basically... To the parlor people, here's my recommendation for how to get out of the Google thing.
Well, email them and say, hey, did you see... Well, for us, we got banned because of an explicit image of a woman naked.
It was behind a blur, and I just emailed them back after six months, and I was like, you realize Twitter has full porn?
And they were like, oh yeah.
And so I think you just gotta find someone inside.
Honestly, it's the only way.
tim pool
But they were accusing you guys of not moderating or something?
bill ottman
Yeah.
tim pool
But you do moderate.
bill ottman
Yeah, we do, of course.
We have deep NSFW filtration tools, and I don't know if Parler has that, but you need that.
tim pool
I'm pretty sure Parler has pretty strict rules.
Yeah, I thought I thought that they used to be more strict.
bill ottman
They were doing like FCC policy.
tim pool
That's what I thought they were doing.
bill ottman
Then they switched.
tim pool
Oh, yeah, I didn't know that.
Yeah, so I it was people were getting banned for like, not that crazy.
Like it was worse than Twitter.
ian crossland
Like swearing.
bill ottman
Yeah, they were banning people for like dropping F bombs and comments.
tim pool
Yeah, because it was FCC broadcast standard.
And it made sense.
Like I got the idea.
bill ottman
I don't think it makes sense.
tim pool
No, I mean, like, someone had the idea, like, I know, what if we use a TV standard, that way people have, they can say things you can't say on Twitter, but we're still having moderation, that should be satisfactory, because the TV does it.
Like, you can turn on TV shows and they, I'll tell you this, Cobra Kai, right?
You guys ever see Cobra Kai?
ian crossland
A little bit.
tim pool
I watched the first season, it was awesome, I just stopped watching after that because, you know, I don't really watch a whole lot of TV.
But they said things in that show I can't say on YouTube.
But it was a YouTube original on YouTube!
How does that make sense?
ian crossland
Pre-vetted.
tim pool
That's crazy.
ian crossland
I like the guy that plays Johnny.
He's a good actor.
tim pool
Yeah, it's a good show.
It's a good show.
TJL431 says, I'm just joining and I know it's late, but have you discussed Google has taken down Parler?
It doesn't work on my Android anymore.
Wait, it doesn't work on your Android?
I know you can't go to the store and get it anymore.
lydia smith
It wasn't working because it was overloaded.
tim pool
So Lauren says, Tim, you said to buy Ethereum and the price jumped 0.15%.
Well, just before the show, we were talking about crypto like before we went live and Bill was like, oh, Ethereum, man, you got to buy it.
And I was like, you think I should?
And you're like, oh yeah.
And I was like, okay.
And then I bought it.
So then we were talking about crypto.
I was like, you know, Bill mentioned buying Ethereum.
I have Ethereum.
I'm not a big fan of talking a lot about crypto, but it needs to be talked about.
But the risk is there's a lot of people who try and like talk about something because they want the price to go up.
That's stupid.
ian crossland
Can you explain the proof of work to proof of stake that they're doing?
bill ottman
Yeah.
So, I mean, Ethereum is proof of work like Bitcoin.
All the miners are running around the world and basically securing the network and the miners are earning money from that process.
But they're moving towards more of a proof of stake.
So you will in the future be able to mine Ethereum on your laptop.
tim pool
Oh, I see.
bill ottman
So you can stake your 32 ETH on your laptop.
And it's more decentralized, theoretically more secure.
But some people like proof of work.
Bitcoin is, you know.
tim pool
It basically just means, like, mining is the way Bitcoin produces coins.
bill ottman
Ethereum is... It's the same, currently, but it's going to be transitioning.
tim pool
By holding a certain number of the coins, you facilitate the Ethereum network.
bill ottman
But you have to stake them into the protocol and run a program on your computer.
tim pool
Oh, but that takes up energy and costs money.
bill ottman
Yeah, but you can run it on a laptop.
The thing with Bitcoin mining, you need serious equipment to be able to have cost benefit.
What is the program called?
It's just the ETH protocol.
An ETH full node.
tim pool
You'll have to explain it to me, I guess.
bill ottman
Oh, and basically you earn interest.
You earn like 6% a year by staking your ETH.
luke rudkowski
And you need 32 of it.
bill ottman
Yeah.
ian crossland
Where do you need to put it in order to start staking it?
bill ottman
I'm honest.
I honestly don't know.
tim pool
You get 6%.
Yeah, you get 6%.
That's huge.
bill ottman
Yeah.
And there's actually a cool, this is a little bit of a name drop, but particularly for Bitcoin, you can earn interest at this site BlockFi.
This guy, Anthony Pompliano, is on their board.
Definitely anyone interested in Bitcoin, check out Pom.
He's an animal.
He's amazing.
I went on his podcast a couple years ago.
But block by you can earn interest on your Bitcoin and ETH just by holding it there now granted
I'm not necessarily recommending that because you're putting custodial custody with them, but it's this I mean
Gemini and coinbase You're giving them custody. So right the beauty of crypto
is you can hold on in your own device, you know And you're saying you got a ledger. Yeah, which is great
You can do that, put into cold storage and you can have sovereignty or you can use these services that can give you interest.
But with ETH, it's moving towards more of like decentralized finance and there's all these protocols like Uniswap and whatnot where you can plug into and earn interest by providing liquidity.
And it's like a whole new financial system that is blowing up.
There's even like decentralized insurance protocols and lending protocols.
You know.
ian crossland
Have you considered doing it with the Mines token?
bill ottman
Mines is an Ethereum-based token and it's on, yeah, we are doing that.
ian crossland
So you'll be able to earn interest in Mines tokens by storing it and by staking it?
bill ottman
You will be able to in the future.
unidentified
Excellent.
tim pool
Wait, really?
Look at this guy.
He's got a smirk on his face when I said that.
bill ottman
It's not out yet.
That's a teaser.
That's a teaser.
But definitely check out Mines.com slash token if you want to learn more about that.
tim pool
Or Mines.com, which is a platform you can use for social media as the great purchase place.
bill ottman
Yeah, and our whole thing has been to help pay people.
And we're doing rev shares as well with Mines Plus.
Minds.com slash plus.
We're taking 25% of the revenue of the company and proportionally sharing it with all of the users who submit content to that.
unidentified
Wow.
bill ottman
And, yeah, so, you know, fiat, crypto.
tim pool
That's the biggest thing that helps, you know, YouTube maintain its position, is that it's where you can have a job.
It's where you can make money.
So that's the big challenge.
Most of these networks can't handle it.
Google subsidizes it.
bill ottman
Absolutely.
That is the amazing thing about YouTube.
tim pool
I mean, maybe crypto will be the key.
ian crossland
Maybe the value of crypto is going to go up so much that it makes a new... Yeah, the library token went from like $0.02 to $0.10 in like the last couple months.
I can imagine as the Mines Utility Token starts to gain, what's the trajectory of the Mines Utility Token?
What's your plan for the next couple of years for it?
bill ottman
Coming soon.
ian crossland
Oh, interesting.
But you can buy it.
tim pool
Somebody just made a comment.
Stephen Vuro says, just sold my Ethereum and will buy Twitter options.
Puts, Twitter will tank soon.
Let's make some money, boys and lids.
bill ottman
I don't know if that was a good bet.
tim pool
Listen, I don't have any stock in Twitter, but I wouldn't be surprised if Twitter tanks with Trump being gone.
luke rudkowski
And maybe it's not thousands of people being censored.
Maybe it's thousands of people leaving.
tim pool
That's what I was saying.
Yeah.
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
Trump's gone.
So they're like, I'm out.
ian crossland
Yeah, I didn't even want to mention Twitter earlier in the show, just because of all this, what we're talking about today.
I was like, tweet me out.
I feel so dirty saying that.
tim pool
You know what?
bill ottman
You feel better when you leave.
Come to the... Oh, I'm on mine.
tim pool
All the Trump reply guys, people who built careers off of waiting for Trump to tweet to say something dumb.
They're out of jobs.
All of these journalists.
There was one journalist from BuzzFeed.
She tweeted that my mornings were haunted by Trump, who at 5am my phone would buzz and I'd have to see what it was.
Well, you are now being relieved of duty.
Congratulations.
Trump is gone.
You don't all have to wake up early in the morning when Trump tweets.
I feel bad for some of these journalists.
They're not all the Trump haunting, you know, rage bait.
There's like some legit reporters who are like, they're going to make me write about this, aren't they?
This is so dumb.
And they're going to be like, look, people want to know what Trump is saying.
It's all over.
It's gone.
ian crossland
The idea that people are going to chase him just to complain about him.
tim pool
Yeah, it's going to happen.
bill ottman
Dude, I worry about his mental health.
I'll be honest.
I feel like he gets, he gets bullied hard and he is a bully.
And so he, he asked for it full out.
But like the way that people treat him, it's like, it's like your family member who you just like their attitude.
There's something about them that you just can't talk to them because they're so annoying and they just always need
to win He's he is that but at the same time it's just like people
need to realize that that that's his personality and just yeah
luke rudkowski
well he's also on social media a lot and
Anyone who's on social media and doesn't take a break that has an effect on your mental well-being
I always recommend and I always do this personally myself once a year at least take one week or two weeks
No cell phone nothing No Facebook, no Twitter, no Instagram, no e-thotting, nothing.
Two weeks, clear.
tim pool
Somebody just made a comment, we were talking about this earlier.
Aurora Diaz says, in Rwanda, the media called on the public to kill their Tutsi neighbors and the moderates that defended them.
Are we heading towards genocide?
You know what's funny?
People always think it can't happen here.
And I was reading about... You mentioned this before the show, Ian.
The Jews fleeing Germany.
Yeah.
And I was reading about... A lot of them did.
A lot of Jews in Germany left once they saw things getting crazy.
ian crossland
I used to wonder, why didn't they all just leave before when they saw it getting crazy?
tim pool
And I'm not a historian or anything, but I was reading an article that said they thought it can't happen here.
And so they just...
ian crossland
Dude, if Don Lemon, no offense Don, I'm not parrying you, but if someone went on the news and said that, to go kill people, it would happen.
That's crazy that people would go out there and hunt them down.
The people are that animalistic.
tim pool
Listen, look, when Cuomo is on, as CNN is basing their ratings, like predicating their strategy upon demonizing 75 million people, they know they've lost the audience and they've given up.
So instead of saying, let's make a network that is more balanced so we can communicate to as many people as possible to make money, they said, now we're not going to get those people, just get the others.
What happened was the polarization started getting so extreme that networks started picking a side that would make them money.
Because the center don't pay that well.
Let's be real.
bill ottman
That is the problem.
That's honestly our, the demon that haunts us.
It's like we're trying to play the center role and not polarize.
But people love the drama.
They love the extremes.
luke rudkowski
Well, the algorithms love it too, and they incentivize it.
bill ottman
And I've been saying... You have to train yourself to want to see people's opinion on the other side.
It's actually a reflex that you have to build.
tim pool
I've always followed left and right.
And that's one of the biggest problems they have.
The left doesn't follow the right.
The right follows the left.
That's a common theme we see on major social platforms.
And so I'll see BuzzFeed writers tweet about Trump, and then I'll see a Trump supporter tweet about Trump, and I'll be like, Ah, I see what they're saying.
And then when I tweet, the craziest thing is, I'll tweet something like, you know, Ted Cruz condemned the violence and called for reconciliation.
And then AOC immediately responded with, you should be expelled and resigned.
But the left doesn't see what the right is talking about.
And they're like, but AOC is right.
He should be.
And I'm like, yes, you're part of the, you're the problem.
They call that the demand for escalation.
luke rudkowski
And what's really interesting is even during Obama's first administration, when he was still the hope and change guy, end the wars, bring back privacy for the individuals, I had a subsection of my audience that was like, just admit it, you should be an Obama supporter.
I was like, no, some of the things he's saying and promising is good, but it won't happen.
Same thing with Donald Trump.
People are like, just support Donald Trump.
Just do it.
I'm like, no.
He's sitting down with Kissinger.
I criticized him throughout his presidency, but now people are like, he's not doing anything.
They're not doing anything regarding Joe Biden.
There is no spirit of hope and change.
There is no spirit of, of people that baseline support him.
So it really, really, really makes you wonder what's going on.
bill ottman
He's the meh president.
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
No, I think it works out really well for the far left.
They didn't like Trump.
They don't like the populist right.
They were able to get rid of the populist right while putting in a very weak president, which they say is easier for them to overthrow.
So what they did was they created a universal enemy for the populist faction.
luke rudkowski
But he didn't sound weak today when he compared US representatives.
tim pool
No, he did.
unidentified
He did.
tim pool
He actually did.
luke rudkowski
Weak?
You think that was weak?
tim pool
He was mumbling and like... He always mumbles.
luke rudkowski
When doesn't he mumble?
tim pool
Him sounding weak isn't the issue.
It was the demonization.
luke rudkowski
It was very strong words.
tim pool
Yeah.
unidentified
Indeed.
tim pool
You know, I went down, I, I went down, uh, I, you know, the, the shop, I, I went down the shop, uh, I was at the shop.
not hearing him. What the journalists do is they translate for Biden. Joe Biden could
say like, you know, I went down, I went down, I went down the shop, I was at the shop. And
then the article will say, quote, I was at the shop. They cut out all the struggling.
And then, and then they say, but he has a stutter.
It's like, come on, dude.
That's not stuttering when you say the things he's saying.
luke rudkowski
The speeches he was given just a few years ago compared to the speeches now, you see a big, big difference.
unidentified
Big time.
tim pool
So look, the rhetoric is, they bring up Rwanda and the Tutsi and stuff.
You know what, man?
We're not there right now, but they've been saying for a long time to kill the Nazis.
And Twitter allows this.
ian crossland
Do they say that?
Kill them?
tim pool
Yes.
ian crossland
Really?
tim pool
Yes.
That explicitly.
ian crossland
That's like illegal, constitutionally illegal, right?
luke rudkowski
Well, it started with punch.
ian crossland
Punch, yeah, I remember that.
tim pool
And so the issue is, when I was on with, you know, it was two years ago now, with Joe and Jack.
There was a tweet from Antifa explicitly advocating for violence, and I said, this has been reported hundreds of times probably, so it won't be removed.
And then Joe pulls it up, and it's like, oh yeah, wow, they're like explicitly telling people to go take an action and go do something illegal.
Twitter won't remove it.
So what happens when, it's not so much about people going on TV and doing it, but on Twitter, they're literally doing it right now.
I bet you can go on Twitter, you can pull it up, you'll find it.
And then what happens is they're going to start saying, and they've always been saying that Trump supporters
unidentified
Right.
tim pool
are Nazis.
Trump is Hitler.
And so what happens when they go on and they say, it's not your Tootsies, they say it's the Nazis.
They go on the media and say, you have to go, stop these people before it's too late.
ian crossland
So if you say to go kill a type of person, and then you say that guy is that type of person,
you're essentially saying- But Twitter allows it.
Is it not constitutional?
tim pool
I bet if you posted, you know, to take action against a communist, you'd be nuked in two
seconds.
But Nazis, different.
bill ottman
It's the Brandenburg test.
The Brandenburg test is the legal precedent for imminent violence.
ian crossland
What is it?
bill ottman
It's just, is it imminent or not?
tim pool
Yeah.
ian crossland
And that means, is it true?
You said it was changed now to, is it a true threat of violence?
bill ottman
Yeah, it seems to be sort of changing.
I think in the state law of Pennsylvania, they were using the language true threat, but the Supreme Court precedent is the Brandenburg test.
tim pool
Whether or not they're actually telling someone to do something right now.
That's so weird.
Well, we can take a couple more Super Chats, see what's going on over here.
People are talking about Rush Limbaugh getting suspended.
Let's see, Woody would like me to read his Super Chat.
Let me see if I can find it.
So look, I apologize to a lot of people.
When we get slammed with Super Chats, it's huge.
And then we can't actually track everything.
So I'll try and see if I can find this Super Chat.
And when you have thousands, it just becomes... It's a lot tonight.
lydia smith
Thank you, guys.
tim pool
Oh, here we go.
Woody says, Tim, I understand non-violent civil disobedience, but the point of 2A, to bear arms, is to provide that check on government tyranny.
My question is, when is such action necessary?
A misguided attempt from the mostly peaceful protesters, for sure, but where's the line?
Um, we had Vosch on the show, and he mentioned Nazi Germany.
And I think everybody would agree, if they're rounding people up onto trains to bring them to concentration camps to be, you know, max genocided, you'd probably have to fight back.
You have no choice.
ian crossland
Crazy thing is they didn't know where those trains were going.
tim pool
Yep.
And then we have that bill coming out of New York.
Have you seen this one?
Was it A14 or something like that?
That says that they can remove and detain people suspected of having contact with someone who may have a communicable disease.
lydia smith
Any disease.
tim pool
Now it's not passed, but it's been introduced.
Basically it would allow Cuomo the power, and anyone who signs the power, to remove anyone without legit cause.
Now, of course, the bill says they must have clear and present evidence of a communicable, you know, public health threat, epidemic, or contagion, contagion, or whatever.
What does that mean?
It means they're gonna be like, your delivery guy tested positive for COVID, so you are coming in the truck.
ian crossland
Yeah, and like, where is the truck going?
They didn't, that's the thing, the Jews didn't know.
They were like, hey, we're gonna put you on trains and take you to a resort.
They were telling them we're gonna take you to like another town or another place to set you up.
They didn't tell them they were gonna go take them, throw them in ovens.
So, Yeah, maybe they should have used weapons to defend themselves, but they didn't know that that's... And that's, and that's the problem.
tim pool
What happens when someone comes to your house and says, we'd like you to come with us, sir.
And you just say, okay.
So that's, it's tough.
I don't know, man.
bill ottman
It's crazy that it's almost the perfect storm of, of reasons and rationale you like with, with all the COVID stuff, all of the political as well.
It's like, there's these two major reasons that people are sort of getting isolated into these groups and, It's crazy that both are happening at the same time.
luke rudkowski
Yeah.
Well, I think it's fair to say it's going to get worse, not just because of the political collapse of the right, but because of the oncoming tsunami of financial consequences that are going to be there because of the lockdowns, because of this kind of larger idea of the Great Reset, which the Biden administration is going to be pushing, admittedly.
John Kerry said it.
Yeah, John Kerry, a part of Joe Biden's administration, admitted that the Great Reset is going to come faster and quicker than many people expected, and it's going to be done under the Joe Biden administration.
So when that happens, that's going to be another major ramification.
The major efforts to take away people's Second Amendment is going to be another major clash point, and we're headed towards a trajectory that is really, really dangerous for everyone, even if you're in the middle.
Especially, and again, not just even if you're in the middle, to the people on the left as well, it's going to be against anyone not toting the official line, not loving the government, not being obedient to them in every possible way.
tim pool
So keep that in mind.
So we had somebody comment saying that it was really easy to, you know, advocate for peaceful non-violence or non-violence of disobedience when you haven't had your life destroyed by the lockdowns and all that stuff.
And that's a fair point except, you know, a fair point in terms of the stress.
I just don't think what they did at the Capitol will actually make things better or make things worse.
It'll justify the lockdowns.
Like Gretchen Whitmer said when they protested the lockdown, she goes,
well, now we got to extend the lockdowns because you all came outside.
That's what you get.
So I guess what I advocate for is self-sustainability and independence and security.
Protect yourself, protect your family and your friends, learn how to survive and be self-reliant.
Try and get away from the cities to the best of your ability.
But I do feel that, you know, with the talk from Fauci and Bill Gates about this extending into 2022, going through another, what, year and a half or two years of this?
I think that statement alone is them telling us they intend for violence.
Because they know.
We've seen the mass rioting already, now on both sides.
The rage that came from this lockdown.
ian crossland
Also, that would insinuate that they're going to print another $30 trillion.
tim pool
If they're saying the lockdowns are going to... Specifically, they said, new normal.
We'll be in this.
Normalcy won't come back until 2022.
Which means, yes, people either are going to get their stimulus checks, or they're going to get crazy.
bill ottman
Yep, it's almost like UBI is here.
Yeah, to a degree.
Like, they might just keep doing it on a regular basis.
tim pool
And the idea might be, by giving people a UBI, but taking away their ability to work and produce things, you end up with people only being able to buy bare necessities.
It's almost like, if I were to imagine, It being on purpose, I'm not saying it is.
But it's almost like trying to sweat out a fever.
You ever hear that?
You know, you get a fever, so you throw all the blankets on and just sweat as much as you can to just end it.
ian crossland
But then you gotta rinse that salt off your skin.
tim pool
Well, so the idea would be, they think the world is being depleted of resources, and it's true to an extent.
It is.
And there's fishery collapses, there's insect population collapses, there's some really scary stuff going on.
They fear climate change, and now the Great Reset explicitly talks about this.
And so the idea is simple.
Interesting.
It's really weird.
Give them only just enough to survive, to eat, and recalibrate them.
That's what they mean by the reset.
lydia smith
Interesting.
tim pool
So everybody says they don't care about the movies.
Verizon tweeted the other day, do movie theaters have a place in the new normal?
And I quoted, I said, this is a really weird tweet.
It's really weird.
They deleted it.
It was really weird.
Yeah.
And I think most people said no.
It was a Twitter poll.
So, ultimately, they will probably have lockdowns going on for a few years.
They'll give people only just enough, and it'll be fought over relentlessly in Congress, and then I think some people will snap.
If the left doesn't get their $2,000 per month, they'll snap.
If the right sees the country printing and just essentially devaluing the dollar like crazy, and then they can't run their businesses and fulfill their own lives and purposes and have freedom, they'll snap.
So, I'm not optimistic about the future unless everything comes back to normal, which is probably not going to happen.
ian crossland
I don't think so.
We're at $28 trillion deficit, or uh... Close.
luke rudkowski
$27.7 trillion right now.
Closely approaching $28 trillion.
ian crossland
They had to print like $6 trillion this year.
In order to match that, it would have to be more next year because the dollar is worth less.
So you're looking at at least like Uh, 10 trillion next year, but that, but we haven't, we're not locked down this whole year.
So it'd be like 10 to 12 trillion next year.
And then that would extrapolate into 2022 to like another 18 or 20 trillion.
So like your dollar might be worth.
It's not just three times less.
It's like.
tim pool
We should open the show with a debt clock calculator every time.
ian crossland
Put it in the corner, pop it up like the smash the like button.
tim pool
The federal debt to GDP is now at 130.51%.
130.
It was at 126 two weeks ago.
Yeah.
ian crossland
124.
luke rudkowski
And then Joe Biden announced his economic team today and his larger economic plans of spending more money to help deal with this.
tim pool
An immediate, he says, an immediate $2,000 stimulus check.
ian crossland
To every person, to every 200 million people.
tim pool
Um, 330 because they give kids, they give money for kids.
So like if you, if you're a family of five, you, your wife, and then all your kids get compensation.
I think kids will get less.
That's like, you know, a couple hundred bucks per kid.
luke rudkowski
But what is that going to do when the dollar's worthless?
tim pool
People who have bought Bitcoin will, in the land of the collapsed dollar, the man with Bitcoin is king.
ian crossland
So that's like $600 billion a month is what they're looking at.
$2,000 a month is what they're looking at.
tim pool
I mean, Ilhan Omar has called for $2,000 a month.
Think about the mass amount of money they're printing every month if that was the case.
luke rudkowski
I think Canada implemented a kind of similar system.
I have to look that up, though, to be honest with you.
tim pool
What's interesting is a lot of people are saying, you know, the other day I mentioned I bought Bitcoin and they're like, Tim's buying the top.
You know, you should wait till it goes down.
And I'm like, well, you can look at the massive spikes of Bitcoin in the past where it's broken all-time high, broken all-time high, and then it does fall down.
I think Bitcoin may go down as possible, but I also think those dips didn't happen right after a bunch of people stormed into the U.S.
Capitol building, and there was a chaotic transition and mass purging on social media, and 66% of all U.S.
dollars being printed in one moment.
So I kind of think people are buying Bitcoin in fear.
bill ottman
You have MassMutual, an insurance company, putting $100 million of their treasury into Bitcoin.
No, really?
You have Fidelity.
You have MicroStrategy, a publicly traded company, putting $500 million of their corporate treasury in because it is digital gold.
Ian, you mentioned the crypto market cap is now a trillion.
The market cap of gold is $9 trillion.
We're going there.
Bitcoin is eating the financial system.
luke rudkowski
It is the new printing press and Elon Musk, one of the world's, if not the world's richest man, hinted at even investing in it with Tesla.
tim pool
I'd like to tell everybody something.
Okay.
Uh, what was it?
unidentified
2012?
tim pool
Bitcoin was at, what, like a dollar?
You could have walked outside.
Excuse me, sir.
Might I have a dollar from you?
I will pay you back.
Sure.
I don't care.
Keep the dollar.
Okay.
Bought one Bitcoin, and then just walked away.
You'd have $40,000 right now. $40,000!
luke rudkowski
You could buy a Tesla with one Bitcoin.
tim pool
You could buy a Tesla with one Bitcoin.
Okay, in November, it was at 13.
It is at 40 now.
But the thing is, like I said, we are seeing people storm into the Capitol building.
We are seeing mass printing of the dollar.
It is not the same as it was last time.
Some people did sell off when it hit like 42, because it's like, whoa, they get scared.
And then I'm like, I'm buying the deal.
ian crossland
It's a big market money.
luke rudkowski
How can you have faith in a financial system that literally is just hitting zero on the keyboard?
unidentified
Wow.
Wow.
ian crossland
One problem with crypto is the entire market is a trillion right now.
The entire crypto market cap of the world is one trillion.
tim pool
And so it's going to get really big.
ian crossland
The US government just printed 6 trillion, so they could have bought, for all we know that market could have been co-opted, and it's being controlled, it probably is, by big money.
tim pool
I was talking about this, we were talking about this before the show, the likelihood the US had the ability to just buy 51% of Bitcoin to control the network, perhaps, and you mentioned we won't know, and that's a good point.
I'll put it this way.
I am, I personally am confident in Bitcoin.
And I'll tell you this, if you mentioned, what are these companies?
Mutual Insurance?
bill ottman
Mass Mutual.
tim pool
Fidelity.
bill ottman
JP Morgan just predicted that Bitcoin will hit like 150K.
tim pool
I think Bitcoin's going to go over a million.
bill ottman
Yes.
Yeah.
tim pool
Yeah, absolutely.
And I think not, I'm not going to say that I think it's going to happen.
I don't know when it'll happen, but I certainly think so.
Because if we're talking about one trillion market cap for Bitcoin, And entropy, meaning a lot of Bitcoin just doesn't exist anymore.
It's already out of the supply.
bill ottman
21 million caps.
ian crossland
It's one trillion for the entire, all the cryptos combined.
tim pool
Oh, all the cryptos.
bill ottman
Bitcoin's at like 600 or 700 billion.
tim pool
That actually is better for my point.
My point is, if these big companies are hedging in Bitcoin and it's nowhere near enough compared to the size of the U.S.
economy, then Bitcoin has to become worth more because of the finite amount of Bitcoin available.
ian crossland
I wonder if Bitcoin's an inferior coin and it's only super valuable because it's popular.
tim pool
First and best dressed.
Yeah.
A lot of people have said that.
bill ottman
It is the fairest system that we have.
tim pool
What about Litecoin?
bill ottman
It's a fork of Bitcoin.
tim pool
I know.
And it's like 86 million coins.
So they used to say Litecoin was the silver to Bitcoin's gold.
bill ottman
Yeah, I don't know.
I'm more just bullish on ETH and Bitcoin particularly.
Mostly Bitcoin.
tim pool
When Ethereum came out, people were like, this is a revolution.
It was like, Bitcoin was a revolution and Ethereum is like a revolution on top.
Because the smart contracts, the programmability of Ethereum, essentially.
ian crossland
Bitcoin was like the Bible.
When the printing press came out, it revolutionized.
And the first thing it printed was the Bible to show that it was a revolution.
Bitcoin is the Bible.
It's the first printing on this new revolution of the blockchain.
The blockchain is the printing press.
Yeah.
tim pool
So I'm not a big fan of these like alt coins.
These other, you know, I think it's silly.
And that's why I do have a couple like on my website, you can donate some couple addresses.
luke rudkowski
There's a lot of scams out there.
There's also a lot of predatory behavior.
You have to be aware of that.
And you always have to be super careful.
And it could go back the other way.
It's a new technology.
bill ottman
It will go back the other way.
luke rudkowski
And it could be used to track, trace, database, and spy on you.
And some people even believe it's a honeypot.
Who knows?
bill ottman
That's why there are privacy coins like Zcash and Monero, which actually are interesting.
They just got banned from some U.S.
exchanges for, like, probably surveillance reasons.
luke rudkowski
Yeah, the IRS released a statement that they're trying to crack and break down Monero.
So that led to a lot of people investing in Monero, essentially.
ian crossland
I saw Ripple got shredded.
bill ottman
They're proprietary, dude.
ian crossland
And the CEO sold $1.6 billion of it without notifying the SEC, I think, got in trouble.
Yeah, I am not a fan of Ripple.
luke rudkowski
Ripple was kind of the big brother, big bank coin.
And they got chewed up by the big establishment that they were trying to cozy up to.
tim pool
So we got a funny super chat.
Let's read this.
Minute Man says, Elon Musk said he's more worried about population collapse than too many people.
If you work out the math of population in Earth's livable land, there's not too many people.
P.S.
Got pulled over by a cop who's a fan of yours.
How did that come out?
Like, you got pulled over?
ian crossland
He was listening on the podcast?
unidentified
Yeah.
tim pool
Or like, were you listening in the car?
And he was like, oh, you're listening to this?
unidentified
Oh, nice.
ian crossland
Probably.
bill ottman
Dude, there's a hilarious visualization.
tim pool
Read the code and then he fist bumps him.
bill ottman
Of all the humans on earth in a pile.
That was an actual visualization.
It fits in like an area.
Look up the visualization of all the humans in a pile, please.
luke rudkowski
It's funny.
tim pool
But look, the issue is not the livable land.
It's the impact of a person per, you know.
ian crossland
And transportation of goods.
tim pool
Well, so we had on Chris Martinson, a PhD, and he said insect populations are collapsing, and that's the bottom of the food chain.
It's going to affect birds, it's going to affect a bunch of other things, and we're going to see that.
It's going to be bad for us, plus pollination of plants.
So that's a serious crisis.
luke rudkowski
Yeah.
There's a great video called The Overpopulation is a Myth that brings out some scientific data that kind of suggest a lot of different things that you don't really hear on the mainstream media that people should check out, in my opinion.
ian crossland
I think that Elon's boring company is way bigger than people realize right now.
I was trying to invest in it, but I think Tesla owns it.
It's still owned by Tesla right now.
lydia smith
How boring.
ian crossland
Or it's owned by him.
It's not public.
But once we start living underground, like if we can have livable tunnels, we've just doubled our land space without going very far.
Yeah.
unidentified
It is a beautiful thing.
ian crossland
Or tripled or quadrupled or quintupled.
bill ottman
That a guy trying to move the world to sustainable energy is now the richest man in the world.
luke rudkowski
And he wants to do implantable microchips in your head.
bill ottman
Yeah, that's the odd part.
tim pool
I don't think so.
ian crossland
They're not chips, yeah.
tim pool
They're just tethers.
bill ottman
It's a health benefit for people who are struggling.
That's one of their use cases.
tim pool
Like, if we had brain-computer interface on the scale of USB, I think it would be amazing.
The challenges are encryption, security, and making sure that when you plug something into your brain, you can't be compromised.
Anybody who's a fan of Ghost in the Shell?
You guys familiar with Ghost in the Shell?
ian crossland
I haven't seen it.
tim pool
Long story short, in the future, people have cyberized brains.
People can hack your brain.
So that's a consideration for if you get a Neuralink.
I'm not saying that... I think a lot of people get scared of it, like, I would never get it.
And I'm like, well, look... If you were losing your memory and you could... Right.
Technology is neutral.
Somebody... If you have a parent who has Alzheimer's and they said, with Neuralink, we can use a USB that would act as a memory backup and make sure their brain, you know... People would be like, absolutely, yes.
ian crossland
Yeah.
tim pool
It's just an issue of security.
Technology is neutral.
It's the application.
And so there are risks, for sure.
bill ottman
Did you see the pig demo of Neuralink?
tim pool
I saw just like snippets.
I didn't know.
luke rudkowski
There's a pig.
ian crossland
Oh, you gotta watch it.
bill ottman
There are three pigs with, yeah.
ian crossland
It's the demo.
bill ottman
And you can hear the data.
ian crossland
It's read-only right now, so it's just transmitting what the pig's smelling and seeing and showing you as like... What's it, Dolly?
bill ottman
I think is her name.
I want to say.
ian crossland
Dolly was the sheep that they called.
bill ottman
Oh, Dolly's the sheep.
tim pool
It's like the Matrix.
I probably shouldn't read that.
I want to read this.
lydia smith
Read it.
tim pool
Sparky the Pyro says, apparently 4chan is now trying to get everyone to change their name to Donald Trump and use his picture.
It's called Operation Spartacus.
lydia smith
Love it.
I love it.
ian crossland
I can't stop them all.
tim pool
Timothy Hediger says, wrong dollar equation.
Why?
Turnover is at zero.
When money turnover goes from one to two, watch out.
I don't know.
432 cycles per second says, all Bitcoin maximalists are now Ethereum maximalists because they are not stupid.
Also, don't count on the blockchain failing except for solar flare or nuclear war.
Interesting.
ian crossland
You could also store it in glass in the blockchain in orbit, so maybe a flare wouldn't affect it.
I don't know.
tim pool
Did you guys hear this?
Phoenix says, Tim, the US seized Pirate Bay's Bitcoin, billions worth, and it just moved recently.
Look it up.
Anyone hear about that?
bill ottman
No?
tim pool
Didn't know that.
bill ottman
But if the any all governments who are smart are stockpiling for the purposes of the treasury, and you were saying that there is risk and that there is for sure.
tim pool
I think I've been, you know, I have some Bitcoin.
I wish I bought way more, you know, back in the day.
And I regret not listening to Max Keiser.
bill ottman
Max and Stacey.
tim pool
Max and Stacey.
I love that meme.
Have fun staying poor.
And it's like him drinking a martini or whatever.
bill ottman
Did you hear Sean Lennon's intro to their podcast?
tim pool
Oh no, he did one.
bill ottman
Yeah, he did it for them.
It's really good.
ian crossland
Oh, it's awesome!
I didn't know that was Sean.
bill ottman
That was Sean, yeah.
tim pool
I'm just gonna say it again.
If you listen to Max and Stacy, you'd be super rich right now.
History repeats itself.
I know, I know.
He's been right about so much for a long time.
And this was back in like 2012.
He was like, you gotta buy Bitcoin!
And it was like a couple bucks.
ian crossland
I love the way he just went for the throat of the banking system after the collapse in 2008.
Man, he was vicious.
And just right on about how criminal they were, about the money they took, and Obama bailing them out.
tim pool
We're hoping to get them on the show soon.
They don't want to travel for obvious reasons.
But Max and Stacey are amazing.
lydia smith
Eventually.
tim pool
Do you love Max and Stacey?
Yeah.
And I wish I listened more to them.
bill ottman
They're actually advisors of mine's.
Oh, really?
unidentified
Yeah.
Oh, cool.
tim pool
Yeah, they're good people.
ian crossland
Well, you've been on Max's show.
bill ottman
Yeah.
tim pool
If you have the Orange Pill podcast?
bill ottman
Yeah.
tim pool
Right on.
Yeah.
unidentified
No, no, no.
bill ottman
It was on his RT show.
tim pool
Oh, yeah.
bill ottman
I haven't been on that.
That's a new show, the Orange Pill.
tim pool
Are they still doing the RT stuff?
bill ottman
I don't know if they are.
unidentified
I don't know.
tim pool
They're doing the orange pill podcast and it's like the orange pill.
There's a colored pill for everything.
But it's Bitcoin.
And I think he's right, man.
bill ottman
He's right.
tim pool
Yeah.
If you haven't already, smash that like button.
We'll do one more.
We'll do one more Super Chat here.
Let's see, we'll do two more Super Chats.
MickeyThe4th says, There's an amazing channel called Radical Liberation focusing on in-depth analysis of geopolitics doing weekly streams.
They recently did an episode on how the scientific theories of overpopulation have been here to justify stuff for 200 years.
Must watch.
Interesting, we'll check it out.
And we'll just do one more.
It's the perfect segue as we begin to sign off.
Julie Simone says, Love the addition of Luke to the show.
Hit me up if you need any puppy training tips.
Congrats on becoming a dog dad.
luke rudkowski
Oh, thank you.
I'm doing a lot of training.
It's a lot of work.
And keeping up my own independent media organization and coming in here, it's a lot of stuff.
But we'll see where it goes.
bill ottman
The cuddles are worth it.
luke rudkowski
Yes.
tim pool
Does she bite your feet in the middle of the night?
luke rudkowski
No, we're crate training her.
tim pool
That's good.
bill ottman
You want her to like the crate?
ian crossland
Yes.
bill ottman
As sick as that sounds.
luke rudkowski
They feel like it's their own home and they actually prefer it.
ian crossland
My friend had a dog that when you would train her she would bark, you'd grab her throat and pinch it.
And then she's never barked.
luke rudkowski
Well, you want to use positive reinforcement.
So whenever she does something good, like when I call her, she comes to me.
I give her a treat.
When she potties outside, I give her a treat.
You don't want to really use negative enforcement, especially with breeds that are known to attack their owners.
You kind of want to keep them.
bill ottman
They say that works with humans too.
luke rudkowski
Yes, there we go.
You want to keep things happy.
So the dog's always happy and always pumped up and always, you know, the tail is wagging.
So that's what I've been doing.
Maybe I'm making a mistake.
Let me know.
So.
tim pool
Right on.
My friends, smash the like button, subscribe, notification bell.
It really, really does help.
Engagement is good for YouTube.
YouTube loves it.
And now the fun part.
If you want to follow me, I'm on Twitter, Instagram, and Parler at Timcast, presumably for the foreseeable future, but you never know because things are getting absolutely crazy.
So you can also check out my other YouTube channels for the time being, hopefully for the foreseeable future.
YouTube.com slash Timcast and YouTube.com slash Timcast News.
And we do the show Monday through Friday live at 8 p.m., so subscribe.
Give us a good review on iTunes.
It really, really does help.
And if you haven't checked us out there, you can check us out on all podcast platforms.
Bill, thanks for coming and hanging out.
bill ottman
Thanks for having me, man.
I love you guys.
tim pool
Not only do you have social media accounts, you have an entire social media network.
bill ottman
Yeah, yeah.
Tim is one of the rock stars over at Mines, so don't forget to shout out Mines and your little reg list.
You know, it's funny with the little social media icons that people put on their website.
It's like, you know, the trendy ones and, you know, you just gotta, yes, all the alternatives.
Cover yourself.
Cover your own bases, everyone out there.
Join them all.
Just do what you can.
So, mines.com slash ottman, O-T-T-M-A-N.
tim pool
Right on.
Luke.
You sell shirts?
luke rudkowski
Yes, I sell shirts.
I was gonna say check out my small independent mom and pop media organization on the YouTube channel We Are Change, but I think it's more imperative you go to wearechange.org and definitely sign up on that email list so we could talk together without some head honcho oligarch standing in the way between me and you.
There's also wearechange.org forward slash donate, which you could support my independent voluntary efforts here.
And there's like 20 different ways where you could get involved.
And I really, really, I mean, I got to admit it, like the people you have here, the people you've been able to galvanize, top A, amazing individuals.
Some of them are like facetious, and they make a lot of funny comments.
But I seriously, seriously, one of the best communities that you've been able to foment and build here.
Awesome, amazing human beings.
Thank you guys so much.
Thank you for coming to my channel too and checking it out as well and spreading the support and love.
It truly is crucial and important more than ever that we get the word out now.
tim pool
While we can.
luke rudkowski
Exactly.
ian crossland
Oh, well, hello, Tim.
Thank you.
Yes, you can follow me in Crossland at most social networks, Twitter, YouTube, Facebook, which I don't really check, Instagram, and Mines, of which I was a co-founder with Bill.
And it could be very well the future of social media if we maintain its free software methodology.
Also, smash that gorilla.
And share this.
Share this.
I don't think Tim mentioned yet to share this, but I want to encourage you to share this content because in the day of, you know, computer simulated algorithms that are deciding what people see, you still have the power to show people things you like.
tim pool
And Ian, if every single person who tuned in today shared this, we would be bigger than CNN.
ian crossland
Okay, then it's possible.
tim pool
Shares are more powerful than ever.
That's right.
You can also follow at Sour Patch Lids.
lydia smith
You can.
You can follow me on Twitter.
I'm on Twitter at Sour Patch Lids.
Sour Patch L-Y-D-S.
And I post random stuff.
tim pool
Is today Friday?
lydia smith
Today is Friday.
unidentified
Wow.
lydia smith
Yes.
tim pool
We'll be back Monday.
I will be back tomorrow morning on my channel over at youtube.com slash timcastnews.
But we'll be back with this show live 8 p.m.
Monday.
So again, smash the like button, subscribe, check us out on all podcast platforms.
Thanks for hanging out and we will see you all next time.
Export Selection