Skeptoid #829: What ASMR Will Do for You
What is the state of the science behind this online video genre that combines relaxation with chills and shivers? Learn about your ad choices: dovetail.prx.org/ad-choices
What is the state of the science behind this online video genre that combines relaxation with chills and shivers? Learn about your ad choices: dovetail.prx.org/ad-choices
| Time | Text |
|---|---|
|
The Braingasm Experience
00:10:22
|
|
| You're feeling a bit stressed, so you turn to one of your favorite remedies. | |
| You go to YouTube and you navigate to one of your favorite channels and commence watching a one-hour video of someone whispering and brushing the camera lens. | |
| Suddenly, an intensely pleasurable tingling spreads across your scalp and down your neck. | |
| Your stress melts away and your whole day is turned around. | |
| Congratulations! | |
| You've just enjoyed an ASMR experience. | |
| That's coming up right now on Skeptoid. | |
| Hi, I'm Alex Goldman. | |
| You may know me as the host of Reply All, but I'm done with that. | |
| I'm doing something else now. | |
| I've started a new podcast called Hyperfixed. | |
| On every episode of Hyperfixed, listeners write in with their problems and I try to solve them. | |
| Some massive and life-altering, and some so minuscule it'll boggle your mind. | |
| No matter the problem, no matter the size, I'm here for you. | |
| That's HyperFixed, the new podcast from Radiotopia. | |
| Find it wherever you listen to podcasts or at hyperfixedpod.com. | |
| You're listening to Skeptoid. | |
| I'm Brian Dunning from Skeptoid.com. | |
| What ASMR will do for you 10 years ago, you could have been forgiven for having never heard of ASMR. | |
| You might have been familiar with what it was, even if you didn't know the term for it. | |
| Five years ago, you'd still get a pass. | |
| Maybe you'd heard the name, maybe you hadn't. | |
| But today, if you haven't seen ASMR go by on your social media, you must have been living under a rock. | |
| And I know that you do have social media because you're listening to a podcast right now, and that's even more archaic. | |
| ASMR is a pleasant tingling sensation that some people experience when they watch a certain type of pleasurably relaxing video. | |
| And it's triggered a whole cottage industry in the creation of such videos. | |
| So the many of us who have never experienced this claimed ASMR sensation are left wondering, is this a real thing? | |
| People describe the experience in varying ways, but the most common is a pleasant tingling like pins and needles or goosebumps on the scalp, which then may spread to the spine and neck or down the back. | |
| It's nearly always pleasurable, sometimes intensely so. | |
| It's been called a braingasm by some. | |
| Even though it's not explicitly sexual, some report it can put them in the mood. | |
| The triggers tend to be stimuli that are relaxing, intimate, comforting, hypnotic, and personal. | |
| First of all, what's in a name? | |
| It's important to note that the term ASMR, although it sounds science-y, does not come from the science community at all. | |
| It was invented by a layperson, Jennifer Allen, in 2010. | |
| She'd been experiencing the sensation for a long time and wanted to start a Facebook group about it, but she couldn't find any name or formal description for the phenomenon. | |
| So she made one up. | |
| She called it the Autonomous Sensory Meridian Response, with meridian referring to the pseudoscientific energy meridians that carry the hypothetical flow of qi in traditional Chinese medicine. | |
| Whatever it's called, enough people heard about it who all raised their hands and said, I get that too. | |
| And the online communities filled quickly. | |
| Discussion of popular triggers, getting a haircut, listening to peaceful repetitive sounds, even watching the old Bob Ross painting show on TV or Roy Underhill's The Woodwright's shop. | |
| I've even seen glowing recommendations for the teletubbies. | |
| All this led to people creating online content specifically intended to provoke an ASMR response. | |
| There are countless channels on YouTube and TikTok. | |
| Think of very long, slow, calming shows shot on sets that look like massage studios with dim, colored lights, very soft music, a host who whispers comfortingly. | |
| They may fold napkins, crumple paper, stir bowls of soup, tap on things, brush the camera lens. | |
| anything that seems close up and personal and intimate, and some of these have tens of millions of views. | |
| Many more are the kind of videos simply tagged as satisfying. | |
| Methodical slicing of clay, pressing things into forms, cutting or whittling soap, or watching machines that wind ropes, wrap things, cut grooves, anything at all that's hypnotically repetitive. | |
| There are creators making millions of dollars a year just making videos intended to trigger ASMR. | |
| We can use the Google Trends web tool to track the popularity of a given topic over time. | |
| When we apply the search term ASMR, we can see that there was no mention of it at all prior to Jennifer Allen inventing the term, obviously. | |
| Then it began to show trackable numbers throughout 2011, and since then it's grown steadily all the way through the present date. | |
| This tracks well with the steady growth of YouTube and TikTok channels of ASMR content. | |
| Today it represents a solid genre segment in online media. | |
| When this topic was first suggested to me a few years ago, I had never heard of it. | |
| A few quick online searches told me it didn't seem to be any big deal. | |
| That is no longer the case. | |
| These days, I get ASMR video channels recommended to me by the algorithms wherever I turn, even though it's not something I'd ever watched. | |
| So I really had no idea where this episode was going to lead. | |
| Is ASMR simply a passing fad like the Tide Pod Challenge? | |
| Is it a scientific field, possibly a relaxation technique in medicine or psychology? | |
| Is it a full-throttle scam, some pseudo-scientific dime-a-dozen self-help technique sold by certified coaches who will help you unlock your fullest potential? | |
| In my work, I encounter all of these regularly, and quite frankly, I saw signs of each of these in ASMR. | |
| Really, all of these questions can be answered by surveying the scientific literature to see what's been learned about ASMR. | |
| Luckily, the body of work that exists does use the term ASMR, which makes it possible to do a literature search. | |
| This tells us two things. | |
| First, that nobody had bothered to study it before the made-up name became popular, and second, that nobody has decided it needs to have an actual scientific name. | |
| Obviously, the term meridian would be somewhat problematic as a scientific name. | |
| So we have a bunch of scientists of various disciplines who have been looking at ASMR, but they're really not too sure what they're looking at, and not at a point where they're ready to declare that there is a concrete medical or psychological application for it. | |
| Anyway, what's there to study? | |
| The whole thing starts with plain old relaxation, and that doesn't need a new name. | |
| Relaxation is great, whether it's by reading a book, meditating, chilling in a hammock, or even watching satisfying videos. | |
| It reduces stress and anxiety, and that has undeniable health benefits. | |
| Relaxation and stress reduction are deactivating. | |
| But ASMR is something more. | |
| It's something on top of that. | |
| It's also activating this new sensation, even as the rest of the body is deactivating. | |
| And that is something worth studying. | |
| In a world that can feel overwhelming, spreading thoughtful, evidence-based content is one of the best ways to make a positive impact. | |
| Ask your local public radio station to air the Skeptoid Files, a 30-minute radio-friendly version of Skeptoid that pairs two related episodes promoting real science, true history, and critical thinking. | |
| And in these challenging times for public media, we're offering these broadcasts for free to radio stations, available on the PRX Exchange or directly from Skeptoid Media. | |
| It's an easy ask. | |
| Just send a quick message to your station's programming director. | |
| By helping to bring the Skeptoid files to the airwaves, you'll help promote the essential skills we all need to tell fact from fiction. | |
| Just go to your local station's website, find the programming director's email address, or just their general email address. | |
| You can even use the telephone. | |
| I know that might sound crazy. | |
| It's an old legacy device that allows real-time voice communication. | |
| I know that's weird, but hey, it's an option. | |
| The world can feel chaotic, but you're not powerless. | |
| When you promote critical thinking, you can help your community tell fact from fiction. | |
| And that's how we shape a better future. | |
| In uncertain times, spreading good ideas can make you feel helpful, not helpless. | |
| Let's stand up for reason, truth, and understanding together. | |
| Get them to air the Skeptoid files from Skeptoid Media, available on the PRX Exchange, and they'll know what that is. | |
| One of the first published studies came in 2015 in the journal PeerJ and used an online questionnaire to ask 475 people who watch ASMR videos all sorts of questions. | |
| The overall conclusion was that it's real, and it can be consistently induced in susceptible people by reliable triggers. | |
| The most common of these were whispering, personal attention, and crisp sounds such as fingernail tapping or crinkling foil. | |
| The sensation significantly boosted their mood, and this effect lasted up to three hours. | |
| Then in 2016, a study in the International Journal of School and Educational Psychology did a literature review to learn more about a suggestion made in 2014 that the ASMR sensation may simply be frissant. | |
|
ASMR and Brain Activation
00:04:45
|
|
| This is the name for what we commonly call shivers up the spine when something gives us the chills as an emotional response to music or other stimuli. | |
| It often includes goosebumps and pupil dilation, but it's mainly characterized by skin tingling called paresthesia. | |
| The author's conclusion was that ASMR and frisson are at least related and perhaps variations of the same phenomenon. | |
| My own read was that they sound very much like two different names for the same thing. | |
| In 2017, another survey was published, this time in Frontiers in Psychology. | |
| This one looked at five personality factors of 290 people who experience ASMR compared to 290 others who don't. | |
| They found ASMR experiencers score significantly higher on openness to new experiences and neuroticism, and significantly lower on conscientiousness, extroversion, and agreeableness. | |
| Tellingly, the authors found that these results were strongly consistent with published personality factors associated with frisson. | |
| This similarity to frisson was underscored by a 2018 study in PLOS One, which did a lab study of 56 ASMR experiencers and 56 controls. | |
| They watched ASMR videos, and the ASMR experiencers showed a significant increase in skin conductance levels, just like frisson experiencers. | |
| Also in 2018, researchers finally decided to put ASMR experiencers into the fMRI machine to see exactly what's going on in their brains when the tingling sensation strikes. | |
| It was a small study, only 10 participants, and it was published in the journal BioImpacts. | |
| The results are probably something you can guess by now. | |
| The subjects watched ASMR videos while in the fMRI machine, and when the tingling sensations struck, their brains showed significant activation in several regions. | |
| These included all the same regions as those that activate during frisson, except one, the MPFC, medial prefrontal cortex. | |
| During ASMR, the MPFC activation increases, but during frisson, it decreases. | |
| The ASMR events also activated brain regions associated with relaxation and social bonding, two of the primary qualities of the ASMR sensations reported by those who get them. | |
| Way back in 2012, Dr. Stephen Novella suggested in the Neurologica blog that the ASMR sensation might be a type of seizure, but nobody had really ever investigated this. | |
| But with the convergence of ASMR and frisson in the literature, this isn't really the case anymore, because the relationship between frisson and seizure has absolutely been studied. | |
| Seizure is a scary word, but all it really means is an unusual atypical burst of electrical activity among brain cells, which can have unpredictable results on whatever part of the body might be associated with those cells. | |
| One such study was presented at the 2019 International Joint Conference on Neural Networks. | |
| Study participants wore electrodermal activity sensors while listening to various types of music, and what the researchers found was that skin conductance results reliably correlated to the genre of music being played. | |
| Noting that one type of epileptic seizure can be triggered by nothing more than hearing music, it's called musicogenic epilepsy, the researchers wondered if some extension of this kind of study might offer potential treatments for musicogenic epilepsy. | |
| This relationship between seizures and frisson, and by extension, to ASMR, is not yet thoroughly understood, but the body of research on musicogenic epilepsy is vast and goes back decades. | |
| Who knows? | |
| It may well turn out to be the case that ASMR videos on YouTube might actually end up playing some role in the treatment or prevention of seizures. | |
| The question that's been burning in your mind is how many people are susceptible to ASMR? | |
| The reason I haven't given any answer to this basic question is that we really don't have one. | |
| There does not appear to be any data on this yet. | |
| Lots of estimates are published, but they're just that, estimates. | |
| Most say about 20%. | |
| Some estimates range from 20% to 70%. | |
|
Seizures, Frisson, and Hope
00:02:46
|
|
| Your guess is as good as mine. | |
| My guess is something less than half of people. | |
| I'll gladly post an update if any solid numbers come out from further research. | |
| And so, there we have it, about as clear a survey of what we know so far about ASMR as is possible to put into a 10-minute podcast. | |
| It's basically another way to experience frisson, though it may be slightly distinct physiologically. | |
| It's an excellent form of relaxation, stress reduction, and sleep inducement, at least for that unknown percentage of people who are susceptible to it. | |
| Beyond that, there's not a whole lot we can say about it, except that it's real and it seems to be pretty nice. | |
| I just wish it wasn't named after Chi. | |
| You know another place you won't find any qi? | |
| In the bodies of Skeptoid's premium members like Stephen Sanderson, James EverHopeful, Pete Tuckerman from Almost Heaven, West Virginia, and Jay from Orlando. | |
| Are you getting the Skeptoid podcast companion email? | |
| It comes out each week along with each new episode, featuring the Wonder of the Week article, show notes, and much more. | |
| If you don't get it, you're only getting half the show. | |
| So come to Skeptoid.com and click on Podcast Companion Email. | |
| You're listening to Skeptoid, a listener-supported program. | |
| I'm Brian Dunning from Skeptoid.com. | |
| Hello, everyone. | |
| This is Adrienne Hill from Skookum Studios in Calgary, Canada, the land of maple syrup and mousse. | |
| And I'm here to ask you to consider becoming a premium member of Skeptoid for as little as $5 per month. | |
| And that's only the cost of a couple of Tim Horton's double-doubles. | |
| And that's Canadian for coffee with double cream and sugar. | |
| Why support Skeptoid? | |
| If you are like me and don't like ads, but like extended versions of each episode, Premium is for you. | |
| If you want to support a worthwhile nonprofit that combats pseudoscience, promotes critical thinking, and provides free access to teachers to use the podcast in the classroom via the Teacher's Toolkit, then sign up today. | |
| Remember that skepticism is the best medicine. | |
| Next to giggling, of course. | |
| Until next time, this is Adrienne Hill. | |
| From PRX | |