All Episodes
Previous Next
Plain Text
June 11, 2019 - Skeptoid
17:07
Skeptoid #679: The Greenbrier Ghost

A skeptical look at the time a ghost's testimony resulted in a murder conviction. Learn about your ad choices: dovetail.prx.org/ad-choices

Transcriber: nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v2, sat-12l-sm, and large-v3-turbo
|

Time Text
The Ghost That Convicted a Murderer 00:07:00
At the end of the 19th century, a thuggish man murdered his wife.
Everyone knew who did it, but it was still necessary to secure a conviction.
And then, at the trial, a bombshell.
It was revealed that the victim's ghost came to her mother in a series of dreams and revealed all the details of the murder, which then all checked out true.
The Greenbrier Ghost is said to be the one time when a ghost's testimony was admitted in court.
But the truth behind the case might not necessarily support that.
The Greenbrier Ghost is up next on Skeptoid.
Hi, I'm Alex Goldman.
You may know me as the host of Reply All, but I'm done with that.
I'm doing something else now.
I've started a new podcast called Hyperfixed.
On every episode of Hyperfixed, listeners write in with their problems and I try to solve them.
Some massive and life-altering, and some so minuscule it'll boggle your mind.
No matter the problem, no matter the size, I'm here for you.
That's Hyperfixed, the new podcast from Radiotopia.
Find it wherever you listen to podcasts or at hyperfixedpod.com.
You're listening to Skeptoid.
I'm Brian Dunning from Skeptoid.com.
The Greenbrier Ghost.
The year was 1897.
The place, a courthouse, in Greenbrier County, West Virginia.
The accused murderer stood grinning, confident of acquittal.
He'd broken his young wife's neck and left her to be found by others, sure that no evidence linked him to the brutal crime.
But then his mother-in-law took the stand, and all present sat transfixed as she told how her daughter's ghost had come to her over each of four nights and revealed the grisly details of her own murder.
The killer's grin melted away and he was soon convicted and sent to live out his life in prison.
We know the Greenbrier Ghost as the only documented case in which a ghost's testimony convicted a murderer in an American court of law.
Today we're going to find out whether that reputation is both justified and true as reported.
The murder happened over a century ago among ordinary people in a rural area.
Thus, not very much about any of their lives is known beyond the basic facts of the case.
The young woman was Elva Zona Heaster and went by Zona.
Her new husband was a rough drifter named Erasmus Shu.
Zona's parents didn't like him at all.
He'd been married twice before.
He spent most of his first marriage in jail for horse theft and the rest of it beating his wife and was generally believed to have killed his second wife, though was never charged.
Zona was to be the third of what Shu often said he hoped would eventually be seven wives.
Zona had served in that capacity for only about three months when Shu, working as a blacksmith, sent a boy to his house to fetch some eggs, where he discovered Zona's body laying at the foot of the stairs.
Dr. George W. Knapp was summoned.
He had been treating Zona for several weeks for a condition recorded as female trouble, but this was clearly different.
He found bruises on her neck, but Shu angrily prevented him from examining her neck further.
Dr. Knapp listed the cause of death as everlasting faint, changed a week later to childbirth, and Zona was buried.
However, the court of public opinion, led by Zona's mother, Mary Jane Heaster, held that Shu had murdered her.
Mary Jane told the county prosecutor that Zona's ghost had appeared to her on each of four nights and revealed that she'd been murdered.
But it was only upon learning that Shu had prevented Dr. Knapp from doing a proper examination that the prosecutor ordered Zona's body exhumed and an autopsy performed.
In its March 9th edition, a local paper, the Pocahontas Times, gave a gory account of the autopsy's results.
The discovery was made that the neck was broken and the windpipe mashed.
On the throat were the marks of fingers indicating that she had been choked.
The neck was dislocated between the first and second vertebrae.
The ligaments were torn and ruptured.
The windpipe had been crushed at a point in front of the neck.
Shu was arrested for Zona's murder.
Much has been written about his braggadocio and defiance of the charges, but it's unclear how reliable this is.
We do know that the transcript of the trial has been lost, so little is known about what evidence was presented.
Except for one part.
At one point in the trial, Mary Jane was put on the stand and questioned about her ghostly visits from Zona.
And this part was reported in various publications, so it survives.
Here, as it appeared in the Greenbrier Independent on July 1st.
Mary Jane.
It was no dream.
She came back and told me that he was mad that she didn't have no meat cooked for supper.
She came four times and four nights, but the second night she told me that her neck was squeezed off at the first joint, and it was just as she told me.
Lawyer.
And was this not a dream founded upon your distressed condition of mind?
Mary Jane.
No, sir, it was no dream, for I was as wide awake as I ever was.
She wore the very dress that she was killed in, and when she went to leave me, she turned her head completely around and looked at me like she wanted me to know all about it.
Lawyer.
Then you insist that she actually appeared in flesh and blood to you upon four different occasions?
Mary Jane.
Yes, sir.
Upon Shu's conviction, it was indeed widely reported that this ghostly testimony is what tipped the scales.
The Baltimore American newspaper put it this way.
The principal evidence was that of Shu's mother-in-law, who testified that her daughter's spirit had come to her at a seance and said Shu had killed her by breaking her neck.
All the other evidence was purely circumstantial.
In the years since, the Greenbrier ghost convicting a murderer has become a mainstay of West Virginia culture and paranormal culture.
At least three stage adaptations have been made, including a musical.
It's been dramatized and novelized at least twice, and a state historical marker outside the cemetery where Zona was buried declares it the only known case in which testimony from a ghost helped convict a murderer.
With so much corroborating information out there supporting this extraordinary tale, how should we respond to it intellectually?
Sailing Into Skeptical Adventures 00:02:17
Should we accept the popular tale as told to be the null hypothesis?
Should we flip the logic upside down and assert that it's the claim that this might not have happened as reported, is the extraordinary claim requiring extraordinary evidence.
Fortunately, we do not need to do either of these things, because even though this is an old story that's relatively thinly documented, there is still enough information out there that we can piece together a non-paranormal narrative that fits the facts quite neatly.
Hey everyone, I want to remind you about a truly unique and once-in-a-lifetime adventure.
Join me and Mediterranean archaeologist Dr. Flint Dibble for a skeptoid sailing adventure through the Mediterranean Sea aboard the SV Royal Clipper, the world's largest full-rigged sailing ship.
This is also the only opportunity you'll have to hear Flint and I talk about our experiences when we both went on Joe Rogan to represent the causes of science and reality against whatever it is that you get when you're thrown into that lion pit.
We set sail from Málaga, Spain on April 18th, 2026 and finish the adventure in Nice, France on April 25th.
You'll enjoy a fascinating skeptical mini-conference at sea.
You'll visit amazing ports along the Spanish and French coasts and Flint will be our exclusive onboard expert sharing the real archaeology and history about every stop.
We've got special side quests and extra skeptical content planned at each port.
This is a true sailing ship.
You can climb the rat lines to the crow's nest, handle the sails.
You can even take the helm and steer.
This is a real bucket list adventure you don't want to miss.
But cabins are selling fast and this ship does always sell out.
Act now or you'll miss this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.
Get the full details and book your cabin at skeptoid.com slash adventures.
Hope to see you on board.
That's skeptoid.com slash adventures.
Unmasking the Australian Ghost Story 00:05:29
A more skeptical study of all these stories of what transpired reveals that Mary Jane's ghost story, while she did indeed tell it, played little or no part in the conviction.
It was reported that the ghost story was never mentioned at all by the prosecution and had no part at all in the government's case against Shu.
Mary Jane was called to testify only by the defense and was asked about her ghost story in an apparent attempt to discredit her and make her come off like some sort of kook.
And indeed, the papers reported that her testimony left the jury with an unfavorable impression.
They needed only an hour and 10 minutes to complete their deliberations and convicted Shu on other evidence, despite the defense's attempt to discredit Shu's adversaries with Mary Jane's rambling ghost story.
The author who's done the most digging on the Greenbrier ghost story is Katie Letcher Lyle, an amateur historian who wrote The Man Who Wanted Seven Wives, The Greenbrier Ghost and the Famous Murder Mystery of 1897.
Even though her book is almost entirely dramatized with invented dialogue and events to read like a novel, Lyle wrote from a pragmatic perspective and sought to find the real, rational reason that Mary Jane had told the ghost story in court.
In a 1999 issue of Wonderful West Virginia magazine, Lyle explained her conclusion.
Mary Jane knew Shu to be clever, unprincipled, and persuasive.
If he'd murdered once, he could murder again.
Perhaps she feared that if no one validated her accusations, Shu would prove extremely dangerous.
So pretending to receive the news directly from Zona, she could appeal to the superstitions of her mountaineer neighbors and get a lot of public attention.
As it turned out, she didn't need the ghost story, for Shu was convicted, according to every account, strictly on earthly considerations, without any unearthly ghosts.
When you're an author, especially if you've been working at length on a specific project and have interviewed people who were involved with the original story, word of your book tends to get around.
And when it does, sometimes surprising people contact you out of the blue.
As Lyle was wrapping up her book, satisfied that Mary Jane made up the ghost story to ensure Shu's conviction, this phone call came unexpectedly late one night.
It was Fred Long, the editor of the Hinton News Leader, who advised her of a previously unpublished detail.
When Zona was killed, one of the places her death was first published was in the Greenbrier Independent on page 3 of the January 28th, 1897 issue.
A brief mention reading simply, Mrs. E.Z. Shu, wife of E.S. Shu, died at her home in the Richlands, this county, on Sunday last, the 24th, aged 22 years.
However, the following article was found on that same paper's front page, entitled, A Ghost Story.
One of the most famous murder cases in Australia was discovered by the ghost of the murdered man sitting on the rail of a dam, Australian for horse pond, into which his body had been thrown.
Numberless people saw it, and the crime was duly brought home.
Years after, a dying man making his confession said that he invented the ghost.
He witnessed the crime, but was threatened with death if he divulged it as he wished to, and the only way he saw out of the impasse was to affect to see the ghost where the body would be found.
As soon as he started the story, such is the power of nervousness that numerous other people began to see it, until its fame reached such dimensions that a search was made and the body found, and the murderers brought to justice.
A person who concocted a ghost story in order to ensure the conviction of a killer they knew to be guilty.
Successfully in the unnamed Australian's case, unnecessarily in Mary Jane's case.
Now it seems probable that Mary Jane would have seen her daughter's obituary in the local paper.
Is it not also possible that she read, or was told about, the front page ghost story in the same issue?
It was only a few days after this paper came out that she first went to the county prosecutor to tell her ghost story.
The timing fits, the logic fits, the motivation fits, and the stories are identical in the relevant details.
We will never know if Mary Jane was indeed inspired by the frightened Australian story, but even if it's a colossal coincidence, her reasons for making up such a tale on her own are no more or less than those of the Australian who did so.
Either way, she got her wish, and her daughter's killer went to jail.
Even urban legends as seemingly innocent as a ghost story like this one, or Bigfoot or a UFO sighting, are important to think about with rational skeptical analysis.
Accepting them simply because they sound compelling is the same broken thought process that leads us to accept much more impactful claims like vaccine denial, the flat earth, or assertions that the moon landings were faked.
Why Critical Thinking Matters 00:02:16
Enjoy your ghost stories, and rather than dismissing them as simply fun diversions, recognize the important opportunity they offer to sharpen your critical thinking skills.
A great big shout-out to Skeptoid Premium members, Dr. Joseph Parker, Allie Foote, Andres Ortiz, and Joel Lynch.
We are a member-supported educational nonprofit, so please consider becoming a supporting member if you aren't one already.
It's tax-deductible.
You get cool stuff plus access to the ad-free premium feed.
But more importantly, you bring this show to hundreds of thousands of people all around the world who aren't yet familiar with the basic principles of critical thinking.
It's easy to do.
Just come to skeptoid.com and click Go Premium.
You're listening to Skeptoid, a listener-supported program.
I'm Brian Dunning from Skeptoid.com.
Hello, everyone.
This is Adrian Hill from Skookum Studios in Calgary, Canada, the land of maple syrup and mousse.
And I'm here to ask you to consider becoming a premium member of Skeptoid for as little as five US dollars per month.
And that's only the cost of a couple of Tim Horton's double doubles.
And that's Canadian for coffee with double cream and sugar.
Why support Skeptoid?
If you are like me and don't like ads, but like extended versions of each episode, premium is for you.
If you want to support a worthwhile nonprofit that combats pseudoscience, promotes critical thinking, and provides free access to teachers to use the podcast in the classroom via the Teacher's Toolkit, then sign up today.
Remember that skepticism is the best medicine.
Next to giggling, of course.
Until next time, this is Adrienne Hill.
From PRX.
Export Selection