All Episodes
Previous Next
Plain Text
April 5, 2016 - Skeptoid
17:22
Skeptoid #513: Why Musical Aliens Probably Use the Same Scale We Do

Reliance on universal mathematical principles may mean alien music is similar to our own. Learn about your ad choices: dovetail.prx.org/ad-choices

Transcriber: nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v2, sat-12l-sm, and large-v3-turbo
|

Time Text
Music Built on Fractions 00:07:43
Today's episode is a little bit of hard science combined with pure speculation, two things that are usually uneasy bedfellows.
I've got an argument for you today that I hope you will find persuasive.
If there are any extraterrestrial aliens out there who have hearing and who have music in their culture, I'm convinced that science shows their music will probably be built on the exact same structure as ours.
And I'm going to prove it right now on Skeptoid.
A quick reminder for everyone, you're listening to Skeptoid, revealing the true science and true history behind urban legends every week since 2006.
With over a thousand episodes, we're celebrating 20 years of keeping it focused and keeping it brief.
And we couldn't have done it without your curiosity leading the way.
And now we're even offering a little bit more.
If you become a premium member, supporting the show with a monthly micropayment of as little as $5, you get more Skeptoid.
The premium version of the show is not only ad-free, it has extended content.
These episodes are a few minutes longer.
We get rid of the ads and we'll replace them with more Skeptoid.
The Extended Premium Show available now.
Come to Skeptoid.com and click Go Premium.
You're listening to Skeptoid.
I'm Brian Dunning from Skeptoid.com.
Why musical aliens probably use the same scale we do?
Today we're going to take one aspect of the popular belief that aliens from another world must necessarily be radically different from humans, not only in appearance, but also in art, literature, culture, and behavior.
Today, I'm going to present a case that the fundamental unit of their music, the musical scale, is almost certainly surprisingly similar to our own and even uses the same 12 notes found on an earthly piano.
The basic argument is that our chromatic scale of 12 notes is based on the most fundamental fractions.
By fundamental fractions, I mean the most obvious ones, fractions that every primitive culture would understand.
Two early hunter-gatherers would understand the concept of dividing food in half, even if they didn't have the language syntax for it.
Three hunter-gatherers would understand dividing food into thirds.
Larger social groups in any environment on any planet would be exposed to the concept of fair division of food or other goods.
Even when a society develops that divides nothing equally, they would still have been exposed to the concept.
You're trying to grow three plant crops, you put an equal amount of water on each.
The understanding of basic fundamental fractional portions is one of the mathematical concepts that would be known to every culture everywhere.
Every tuned musical instrument depends on fractions.
The sizes of the keys of a xylophone are based on fractions.
The lengths of plucked strings are based on fractions.
The resonating space inside a flute and the parameters that can tune a drum are all based on these same fractions, though in different ways.
So although any individual primitive musician who builds his own instrument might create a scale of notes unlike that of any other musicians, it would be those musicians using the common fractions whose work would be recognizable and repeatable by others.
Thus, the music most likely to gain widespread acceptance across diverse segments of a population is probably going to be based on fundamental fractions.
By extension, it is equally probable that music from different planets will also be based on the same fraction-based chromatic musical scale.
How does dividing the day's gathering of berries among three primitive foragers translate to a universal chromatic scale?
On Earth, we trace this tradition back to Pythagoras, the Greek polymath, who absolutely did not invent the system, but was the first to devise the mathematics that describe it, or at least the first whose work survived and was popular enough to be known for it.
It was understood in China at least 2,000 years earlier.
So how exactly does one turn fractions into music?
Well, much of this may be very familiar to many listeners, but there is a twist that many of us may not be aware of.
We begin with a string of a given length that we can pluck and produce a tone.
The most basic fraction we can apply to this string is one half.
Imagine a guitar and you put your finger down on the fretboard half of the way down the length of the string, and you pluck it again, producing a higher tone.
That's an octave.
If our original note was an A at 440 Hz, this higher note with the string half as long would also be an A, with exactly twice the frequency, an A at 880 Hz.
Similarly, we could go on all day cutting the string in half, or making it twice as long, and play all the A notes there are, and all would have a frequency that is some multiple of 110, 220, 440, 880, 1760, and so on.
Pythagoras noticed that the most common musical interval also happened to match the next most common fraction, 1 third.
When you place your finger one-third of the way down the guitar string and pluck, the remaining 2 thirds produces a tone at 660 Hz, which is 2 thirds the wavelength of the 440.
And today we call this note an E. Like the A's, E's also come in multiples of 2 times that 660, such as 165, 330, 660, 1320, and so on.
This interval between one note and another formed by shortening the string by 1 third is called a perfect fifth, which is defined as two tones having a frequency ratio of three to two.
Pythagoras repeated this again, taking two-thirds the length of his E string to go up another perfect fifth and produce a B at 990 Hz.
And a fourth time to produce an F sharp at 1485 Hz.
And a fifth time to produce a C sharp at 2,227.5 Hz.
Once he had these five perfectly calculated tones in hand, Pythagoras discovered that he could play almost any popular song.
A scale consisting of these five notes is called a pentatonic scale.
The Power of Black Keys 00:06:52
You're already familiar with the pentatonic scale.
They're the black keys on a piano.
Go to any piano and play anything you want using just the black keys and you're playing Pythagoras' pentatonic scale, all based on that super simple fraction, one-third.
Music from every populated region on Earth has been found to use the pentatonic scale.
Other systems also existed here and there, and some musicians also tweaked the notes in the pentatonic scale a bit.
But that pure pentatonic scale is the one that became the universal musical language on Earth, all stemming from one-half and one-third.
By the same inescapable progression by which the concepts of one-half and one-third permeated every society on Earth, we can reasonably expect that the pentatonic scale will be found in every musical society anywhere in the universe.
Hey everyone, I want to remind you about a truly unique and once-in-a-lifetime adventure.
Join me and Mediterranean archaeologist Dr. Flint Dibble for a skeptoid sailing adventure through the Mediterranean Sea aboard the SV Royal Clipper, the world's largest full-rigged sailing ship.
This is also the only opportunity you'll have to hear Flint and I talk about our experiences when we both went on Joe Rogan to represent the causes of science and reality against whatever it is that you get when you're thrown into that lion pit.
We set sail from Málagas, Spain on April 18th, 2026 and finished the adventure in Nice, France on April 25th.
You'll enjoy a fascinating skeptical mini-conference at sea.
You'll visit amazing ports along the Spanish and French coasts and Flint will be our exclusive onboard expert sharing the real archaeology and history about every stop.
We've got special side quests and extra skeptical content planned at each port.
This is a true sailing ship.
You can climb the rat lines to the crow's nest, handle the sails.
You can even take the helm and steer.
This is a real bucket list adventure you don't want to miss.
But cabins are selling fast and this ship does always sell out.
Act now or you'll miss this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.
Get the full details and book your cabin at skeptoid.com slash adventures.
Hope to see you on board.
That's skeptoid.com slash adventures.
But there are still some gaps between the five-note pentatonic scale and the 12-note chromatic scale.
On the piano, these gaps are the white keys.
But notice two things.
There are more white keys than black keys, and the black keys come in a group of three and a group of two, the groups being separated by two white keys, whereas the individual black keys are separated by only one white key.
This is because that pentatonic scale covers enough of the keyboard to allow you to make great music, but it does not completely cover the entire frequency spectrum with evenly separated intervals.
Pythagoras decided to keep going, to continue splitting off one-third of every string to create a new musical note.
His sixth note was a G sharp.
His seventh note was a D sharp.
He continued this interval and created an A sharp, an F, a C, a G, a D, and then, miracle of miracles, cutting off one-third of his D string and plucking brought him all the way back around to an A. Pythagoras had found the mathematically perfect solution to a 12-note chromatic musical scale.
Now I know some of you are screaming at me and tearing your hair.
Relax.
I said there was a twist.
We'll get to it right now.
The twist is that I lied.
Pythagoras knew it was not exactly right.
Starting at A440, Pythagoras had originally followed 12 perfect fifths to produce an A exactly one octave up an A880.
880 Hz was the target frequency to create a perfect chromatic scale.
But when he went all the way around his 12 divisions of the octave, that last note, his A, was not exactly 880.
It was pretty close, but it wasn't exact.
It was just a little bit over 892 Hertz.
It was close enough, though.
It was close enough that most music listeners would probably never know the difference.
Pythagoras could have gone around the world again, finding new notes, each a perfect fifth up from the last, and created a much finer scale with many more than 12 gradations of the octave, and gotten closer to 880.
But that wouldn't have been a good solution.
Music sounded really good with just those 12 notes.
Pythagoras also could have taken a smaller number of notes.
For example, the eighth note in his process was an A sharp, and he could have squeezed them all down a little bit for an eight note chromatic scale.
But that wouldn't have been any good either.
For a long time, Earth musicians tried various ways to deal with this imperfection in the musical scale by making various adjustments called temperament.
Leaving the notes just as Pythagoras calculated them, based on mathematical perfect fifths but with one little off interval, is called Pythagorean tuning.
A temperament called just intonation was developed where all the notes were jostled around just a tiny bit such that they were related by frequency ratios that could be expressed using whole numbers that were as small as possible.
An important development was well temperament, popular in the 18th and 19th centuries, which brought everything closer into line and allowed songs to sound good when played in any key, but with enough variation that the same song played in the same mode would have a slightly different feel when transposed to a different key.
Today, nearly everything is based on equal temperament, where the intervals between all adjacent notes are exactly the same, which is 2 raised to the power of 1 twelfth.
Might aliens have taken a different option than Pythagoras did to resolve the fault in the scale?
Why Just Intonation Works 00:02:43
Certainly.
But 12 notes is a great number.
The 12-tone diatonic scale and the pentatonic scale as well are in the same ballpark as the number of digits on human hands, which makes an instrument easy to handle.
It's a good ballpark, and the next higher round the world of perfect fifths starts to get out of control.
My bet is they would have stopped within one round of where Pythagoras did.
I've heard it argued that rhythm is probably also the same in alien music, based on ambulation and a host of influences in nature.
It may be that the diatonic scale, perhaps even the chords, match our own.
Steven Spielberg's Close Encounters of the Third Kind certainly portrayed such a parody.
If the fundamental fractions that informed the music of every culture on the planet Earth also did the same on other worlds, then it may indeed be the case that music is, as bards have long proclaimed, the universal language.
If you ever want to verify or track down anything that I say on the show, come to the transcript for each episode on skeptoid.com and you'll find complete references and further reading suggestions if you want to know more about it.
You're listening to Skeptoid.
I'm Brian Dunning from skeptoid.com.
Hello everyone.
This is Adrian Hill from Skookum Studios in Calgary, Canada, the land of maple syrup and mousse.
And I'm here to ask you to consider becoming a premium member of Skeptoid for as little as $5 per month.
And that's only the cost of a couple of Tim Horton's double doubles.
And that's Canadian for coffee with double cream and sugar.
Why support Skeptoid?
If you are like me and don't like ads, but like extended versions of each episode, Premium is for you.
If you want to support a worthwhile non-profit that combats pseudoscience, promotes critical thinking, and provides free access to teachers to use the podcast in the classroom via the teacher's toolkit, then sign up today.
Remember that skepticism is the best medicine.
Next to giggling, of course.
Until next time, this is Adrienne Hill.
From PRX
Export Selection