All Episodes
Previous Next
Plain Text
Sept. 1, 2015 - Skeptoid
16:27
Skeptoid #482: Franklin's Cannibals

The fate of Sir John Franklin's Lost Expedition gives a valuable lesson in types of evidence. Learn about your ad choices: dovetail.prx.org/ad-choices

Transcriber: nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v2, sat-12l-sm, and large-v3-turbo
|

Time Text
Franklin's Tainted Legacy 00:07:33
The name of the great British explorer, Sir John Franklin, has been somewhat tainted by the popular belief that, as his fourth voyage to the Canadian Arctic ended in tragedy, some of the men in his command were forced to do the unthinkable and turned to cannibalism in a desperate attempt to survive.
It's a serious matter and it's not something we want to be wrong about.
So today we're going to lay out exactly what we know and exactly how we know it.
Franklin's cannibals are up next on Skeptoid.
Hi, I'm Alex Goldman.
You may know me as the host of Reply All, but I'm done with that.
I'm doing something else now.
I've started a new podcast called Hyperfixed.
On every episode of Hyperfixed, listeners write in with their problems and I try to solve them.
Some massive and life-altering, and some so minuscule it'll boggle your mind.
No matter the problem, no matter the size, I'm here for you.
That's Hyperfixed, the new podcast from Radiotopia.
Find it wherever you listen to podcasts or at hyperfixedpod.com.
You're listening to Skeptoid.
I'm Brian Dunning from Skeptoid.com.
Sir Franklin's Cannibals.
1845 saw the departure of Sir John Franklin's fourth voyage to the Canadian Arctic, this time in pursuit of the British Admiralty's goal of completing a northwest passage eastward across the top of Canada.
When he left England with his two steam-powered three-masted ships, the HMS Terror and HMS Erebus, it was to be the last time any member of the expedition would see home.
Two months later, they encountered whale ships in Baffin Bay, and then no European ever saw Franklin and his 128 companions alive.
Whatever followed has been a mystery ever since, clarified by only the scarcest specks of occasional evidence and clouded by scuttlebutt and speculation and tall tales and the darkest rumor of all, cannibalism.
What can we know about the real fate of Franklin's lost expedition?
Two years after Franklin's departure, the Admiralty decided he was lost.
Over the next decade, no fewer than 30 expeditions were launched in search of Franklin.
Only a few found anything at all.
What eventually became clear was that all members of the expedition had perished, but the circumstances remained a mystery.
This opened the door for all sorts of rumors and crazy claims.
In 1928, British naval officer and historian Rupert Gould wrote Oddities, a book of unexplained facts, in which he reported that several ships plying the Atlantic in 1851 spotted two ships embedded in an iceberg off the coast of Newfoundland.
According to the details that were visible, the ships were tentatively identified as the Terror and the Erebus.
Could this have been the expedition's end?
Or were starvation and cannibalism their ultimate fate?
There is still another hypothesis.
Like all popular mysteries, the story of Franklin's lost expedition has been gilded with its very own conspiracy theory.
Some say that Franklin was sent on the voyage to investigate a mysterious phenomenon, perhaps something like that which is believed by adherents to one of the hollow earth theories, that an alien race lives inside the earth and comes and goes via great big holes at the north and south poles.
When Franklin failed to return from his journey to investigate these giant holes, the British Admiralty decided to cover it up, and the expeditions sent to search for Franklin failed intentionally.
Well, what evidence is there for this?
Well, none.
None whatsoever.
In fact, it is so comprehensively unevidenced that nobody even suggested it until author Jeffrey Blair Lotta dreamed it up out of whole cloth for his 2001 book, The Franklin Conspiracy, An Astonishing Solution to the Lost Arctic Expedition.
Speculation can only take us so far.
Let's look instead at the evidence that does exist, scant though it may be, and see what we can learn.
An early discovery in 1850 was an abandoned winter camp on Beachy Island with the graves of three Franklin crew members.
Several search parties visited, but nothing there gave any hint of what became of the rest of the expedition.
But over the ensuing years, more evidence was to be forthcoming from much farther south.
Follow the Northwest Passage south from Beachy Island a few hundred kilometers and you will come to King William Island.
It's a vast sheet of flat rock scraped smooth by glacial action.
12,500 square kilometers of barren tundra dappled with uncountable melt ponds.
Its western coast is waterfront property on the Northwest Passage.
All along the island's western and southern coasts, at least 20 sites have given up artifacts from Franklin's party.
Importantly, these artifacts included two notes placed inside a stone cairn by Franklin's party, a year apart.
The first note revealed that they'd spent the winter of 1845 to 1846 at the Beachy Island camp, during which the three men in the graves died of tuberculosis.
That spring, they continued their voyage south toward King William Island until their ships became stuck in the ice at the end of 1846 off its coast.
They spent the winter ashore and left the first note in May of 1847, saying that all was well.
But things would not stay well.
Franklin himself died shortly thereafter, and the ice clung to the ships throughout the summer of 1847 and into the winter of 1848.
At this point, the survivors decided to abandon them.
They left the second note, saying that 24 men had died so far, and that they would take the small boats south along the coast of King William Island and head for the mouth of the Back River, the principal waterway into the safety of the Canadian mainland.
This would be a journey of some 500 kilometers.
And from that point on, from the date of that note in April of 1848, we have no documentary evidence of what became of the men, or whether they ever resorted to cannibalism, or what ultimately killed them.
So this brings us to what we learned from the search parties from the 1850s and over the subsequent 150 years.
In 1854, an expedition led by John Ray, chief factor of the Hudson's Bay Company, collected silverware and other various artifacts that had belonged to the crew, proving that they had indeed made it all the way around King William Island and had started down the Adelaide Peninsula toward the Back River.
In 1859, a sledge party under Sir Francis McClintock found the cairn with the notes, skeletons at some of the coastal camps, as well as one small boat containing two skeletons and loaded with supplies abandoned at the western tip of King William Island.
Many other expeditions found the camps and graves as well as skeletal remains, but none passed a certain point down the Adelaide Peninsula.
Inuit Histories and Evidence 00:06:39
Hey everyone, I want to remind you about a truly unique and once-in-a-lifetime adventure.
Join me and Mediterranean archaeologist Dr. Flint Dibble for a skeptoid sailing adventure through the Mediterranean Sea aboard the SV Royal Clipper, the world's largest full-rigged sailing ship.
This is also the only opportunity you'll have to hear Flint and I talk about our experiences when we both went on Joe Rogan to represent the causes of science and reality against whatever it is that you get when you're thrown into that lion pit.
We set sail from Malaga, Spain on April 18th, 2026 and finished the adventure in Nice, France on April 25th.
You'll enjoy a fascinating skeptical mini-conference at sea.
You'll visit amazing ports along the Spanish and French coasts and Flint will be our exclusive onboard expert sharing the real archaeology and history about every stop.
We've got special side quests and extra skeptical content planned at each port.
This is a true sailing ship.
You can climb the rat lines to the crow's nest, handle the sails.
You can even take the helm and steer.
This is a real bucket list adventure you don't want to miss.
But cabins are selling fast and this ship does always sell out.
Act now or you'll miss this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.
Get the full details and book your cabin at skeptoid.com slash adventures.
Hope to see you on board.
That's skeptoid.com slash adventures.
Modern forensics has also contributed to the picture.
Beginning in the 1980s, Canadian anthropologist Owen Beatty spent many years at the Franklin sites.
His analysis of the corpses at Beachy Island showed high levels of lead poisoning, almost certainly from the lead solder used in their food tins and the plumbing on board the HMS Terror and Erebus.
Beatty and others have concluded that the lead levels were dangerous and likely weakened the men, perhaps making them more susceptible to tuberculosis and pneumonia, but was probably not sufficiently debilitating to have been the ultimate cause of death.
No evidence ever suggested the men were affected by late-stage symptoms like dementia, for example.
Beatty's studies did find significant evidence of cannibalism, as have subsequent studies.
Bones had telltale knife marks, and some had also been boiled.
Sadly, this type of evidence was found at multiple sites, not just at one or two.
It seemed that this darkest of rumors surrounding the Franklin expedition was all too true.
But although evidence has led this far, it still didn't give a detailed history of the men's final months, or of exactly how far, how many of them had made it.
But historians looking to reconstruct the fate of the Franklin expedition have one ace in their hand that investigators of other mysteries do not.
Eyewitnesses.
When Franklin's party was in the Arctic, they were not alone.
Inuit natives lived there and interacted with the expedition on many occasions.
While the Inuit did not have written histories in which they could have made records of use today, they did have oral histories.
Clearly, oral histories are imperfect as they're subject to many sources of distortion, but they are still useful as anecdotal evidence.
The value of anecdotal evidence is often to suggest directions for additional research, and it turns out that that is precisely the role it has played in the search for Franklin.
Perhaps the best book on this exact subject is Unraveling the Franklin Mystery, Inuit Testimony by David Woodman.
Ray, McClintock, and many other searches had all collected large amounts of testimony from Inuit on their expeditions.
The Inuit histories provided many details, although often with somewhat ambiguous times and locations.
An Inuit party had even boarded one of the two abandoned ships while it was still stuck fast out on the ice.
Taken as a whole, the Inuit stories supported the tale told by the archaeological and documentary evidence.
As men died along the route and splinter parties broke off here and there, a core group of 35 to 40 men made it as far as a spot on the Adelaide Peninsula now called Starvation Cove.
Here, the last of the men died, using the flesh of their deceased comrades in a desperate and ultimately unsuccessful attempt to save themselves.
Woodman's emphasis on Inuit oral histories has not been without criticism, which was the case with John Ray as well back in the 1850s.
Ray, who lived among the Inuit, had learned to place a great deal of trust in their oral histories.
One reviewer of Woodman's book wrote, One bias, however, Woodman does stand by.
In oral cultures, stories of fact, as distinct from myths, however old and told at however many removes, possess kernels of truth.
They may be imbricated by cultural biases.
Aspects of some individual stories must be dismissed as unreliable.
There's one quote given by Woodman in his book that I think bears a special mention, and it's this, in reference to his reconstructed timeline of the Franklin Party.
Analysis of the wreck and the artifacts within will certainly disclose other errors in the reconstruction presented here and force major revisions.
I welcome this.
No one is more aware than I that the current fragmentary state of evidence makes it possible to construct competing narratives of equal probability, and that the one presented in this book is simply my best imperfect effort.
New evidence of any kind will reduce the number of possibilities and hopefully lead to a fuller understanding.
Woodman's attitude is the very heart of science-based investigation.
Just because we don't know something doesn't mean that it's unknowable, nor does it mean that we don't have a pretty good idea.
And when we do have a pretty good idea, we must always welcome improvement and correction.
By this process, we can be assured that our current theories are as good as we're able to make them, and will almost certainly get even better.
In 2014, the wreck of the Erebus was found on the seafloor near where the crew abandoned it in the ice.
Welcome Skepticism 00:02:11
It was the biggest and most solid piece of evidence yet supporting the currently accepted timeline.
But like all the evidence in this case, it doesn't tell us much by itself.
We need a combination of physical, documentary, and even anecdotal evidence to get even a nearly complete picture.
Franklin's Lost Expedition provides an elegant example of the value of all types of evidence.
Writing and producing this show is not just a hobby, it's my full-time job.
Just as you depend on a new show every week, I depend on your monthly micropayment.
If you're not already a supporter, please come to skeptoid.com and click on Support Skeptoid.
Please join me to make this a two-way street for both of us for many years to come.
You're listening to Skeptoid.
I'm Brian Dunning from Skeptoid.com.
Hello, everyone.
This is Adrian Hill from Skookum Studios in Calgary, Canada, the land of maple syrup and moose.
And I'm here to ask you to consider becoming a premium member of Skeptoid for as little as $5 per month.
And that's only the cost of a couple of Tim Horton's double-doubles.
And that's Canadian for coffee with double cream and sugar.
Why support Skeptoid?
If you are like me and don't like ads, but like extended versions of each episode, Premium is for you.
If you want to support a worthwhile nonprofit that combats pseudoscience, promotes critical thinking, and provides free access to teachers to use the podcast in the classroom via the Teacher's Toolkit, then sign up today.
Remember that skepticism is the best medicine.
Next to giggling, of course.
Until next time, this is Adrienne Hill.
From PRX.
Export Selection