Skeptoid - Skeptoid #154: Was Chuck Yeager the First to Break the Sound Barrier?
Aired: 2009-05-19
Duration: 21:30


=== Unofficial Sound Barrier Claims (11:57) ===

[00:00:03]  If you're an aviation nut and I am guilty as charged, you probably know that Chuck Yeager was the first to officially break the sound barrier in the Bell X-1.
[00:00:13]  But what about unofficially?
[00:00:16]  Going all the way back to World War II, we had rocket planes and jet fighters already vying for that honor.
[00:00:23]  And some say one or more of them may have succeeded.
[00:00:28]  Today, we're going to find out.
[00:00:30]  The first to break the sound barrier is coming up right now on Skeptoid.
[00:00:39]  Hi, I'm Alex Goldman.
[00:00:41]  You may know me as the host of Reply All, but I'm done with that.
[00:00:45]  I'm doing something else now.
[00:00:47]  I've started a new podcast called Hyperfixed.
[00:00:50]  On every episode of Hyperfixed, listeners write in with their problems and I try to solve them.
[00:00:55]  Some massive and life-altering and some so minuscule it'll boggle your mind.
[00:00:59]  No matter the problem, no matter the size, I'm here for you.
[00:01:02]  That's HyperFixed, the new podcast for Radiotopia.
[00:01:05]  Find it wherever you listen to podcasts or at hyperfixedpod.com.
[00:01:15]  You're listening to Skeptoid.
[00:01:17]  I'm Brian Dunning from skeptoid.com.
[00:01:20]  Was Chuck Yeager the first to break the sound barrier?
[00:01:26]  We all know the story of how Captain Chuck Yeager opened the throttles of the Bell X-1 Glamorous Glennis in October 1947.
[00:01:35]  Breaking the sound barrier was to aviation what Neil Armstrong's first step was to the space program.
[00:01:42]  No matter how many others went higher or faster later, it will always be that seminal, unassailable first that can never be topped.
[00:01:52]  Jaeger's name will always sit atop every list of record-breaking pilots, up there by himself in his own special stratosphere.
[00:02:01]  But was he really the first pilot to fly faster than sound?
[00:02:08]  Plenty of stories out there say Jaeger wasn't the first.
[00:02:12]  How do we know what to believe?
[00:02:14]  Do we accept the popular official story, or do we give credibility to the other claimants with good evidence of their own?
[00:02:22]  Today we're going to point our skeptical eye at some of these other claims and see who really deserves the credit.
[00:02:31]  There are certainly many pilots who approached the sound barrier but didn't live to tell about it.
[00:02:36]  The years preceding Jaeger's flight were among the most exciting in aviation history as World War II drove aeronautic advancement like never before.
[00:02:46]  Planes that had been shot down often entered the transonic realm as they plummeted and were torn apart by the resulting shockwaves.
[00:02:54]  Dive bombers had to have special air brakes developed to prevent them from breaking up, which sometimes happened anyway.
[00:03:02]  Of the many pilots who toyed with the sound barrier in World War II, all unintentionally of course, most never survived the adventure.
[00:03:12]  During World War II, engineers didn't yet have any flight test experience that taught us how to design aircraft capable of supersonic speed.
[00:03:22]  Even in 1947, Jaeger's X-1 was designed after a 50-caliber bullet, known to be stable at supersonic speeds.
[00:03:31]  World War II had seen widespread use of the German V-2 rockets, which were supersonic, so we knew such flight was possible.
[00:03:40]  But the V-2 was ballistic.
[00:03:42]  It didn't require a controllable airframe.
[00:03:45]  And designing a supersonic, controllable airframe was the problem for aeronautical engineers.
[00:03:51]  The main issue is called shock stall, and it's what happens when a control surface approaches the speed of sound.
[00:03:58]  A shock wave forms around the control surface, rendering it useless, and the pilot has no way to control the craft.
[00:04:07]  Propeller aircraft can never reach the sound barrier, since the tips of propeller blades hit the sound barrier before the rest of the plane does.
[00:04:16]  The propeller blades go into shock stall, and the plane can no longer accelerate.
[00:04:22]  There are many claims of propeller-driven dive bombers breaking the sound barrier during World War II, but these have to all be considered implausible.
[00:04:30]  Approaching the sound barrier, an airplane is already well above its terminal velocity, the speed at which drag matches the acceleration imparted by gravity.
[00:04:40]  Propellers are shock-stalled, and there is neither thrust nor gravity available to accelerate a diving airplane past a certain point.
[00:04:49]  As any aircraft approaches the speed of sound, airflow over some parts of the plane will exceed Mach 1 and create shock waves.
[00:04:59]  These shock waves cause intense buffeting.
[00:05:03]  Many propeller-driven World War II fighter planes, including the Supermarine Spitfire, the Lockheed P-38 Lightning, and the North American P-51 Mustang, experienced these effects at Mach 0.85.
[00:05:17]  Similarly, jet engines of the day were not designed to work with supersonic airflow entering through the compressor vanes.
[00:05:24]  Such engines would flame out.
[00:05:28]  However, one particular fighter plane of World War II was not driven by either propellers or jets.
[00:05:36]  The German rocket-powered Messerschmitt 163 Comet.
[00:05:41]  The Comet was designed by the great Alexander Lippisch, a pioneer of delta wings and ramjets.
[00:05:47]  By the end of World War II, Lippisch had a test glider of a supersonic ramjet-powered aircraft actually undergoing flight tests.
[00:05:57]  He understood the requirements of supersonic flight.
[00:06:00]  The Comet was designed to fly as fast as possible while staying under the critical limits at which trouble happens.
[00:06:08]  The Comet's delta wing was exceptionally thin.
[00:06:12]  This delays the onset of shock stall over the primary airfoil and allowed the comet to remain stable up to Mach 0.85.
[00:06:21]  However, Lippisch had no answer for shock stall at the control surfaces on the trailing edge of the delta wing, and so the comet was destined to remain subsonic.
[00:06:32]  In combination with the relatively low 3,800-pound thrust of the comet's Walter rocket engine, about half the power of Jaeger's X-1, the Comet had little expectation of going supersonic, except in an uncontrollable, powered dive, which would probably be unrecoverable.
[00:06:52]  Nevertheless, stories persist of Comet pilots breaking the sound barrier, years before Jaeger did.
[00:07:00]  Comet test pilot Heine Dittmar, flying an early prototype in 1941, reached an officially measured speed of 1,004 km per hour in level flight.
[00:07:12]  This was probably around Mach 0.95, but we don't know for sure since the flight was classified until after the war and the altitude is unknown.
[00:07:21]  However, Dittmard made the flight at partial throttle to avoid buffeting, using an engine only half as powerful as that which went into production.
[00:07:30]  But just because later versions were more powerful doesn't mean they wouldn't run into exactly the same limitations at the same top speed.
[00:07:38]  One unofficial report claims that Dittmar hit 1,130 kph in 1944, Mach 1.06, and another states that in a steep dive, he created sonic booms that were heard on the ground.
[00:07:54]  However, these stories first appeared in a 1990 book written by Dittmar's friend Mano Ziegler and do not have contemporary corroboration or documentation.
[00:08:07]  But the best evidence against comets breaking the sound barrier is the fact that the Allies did capture all of the program's classified data and no supersonic flights were ever recorded, even in secret.
[00:08:22]  Claims you'll find on the internet that comet pilots routinely broke the sound barrier cannot be given much weight, given the aircraft's limitations well understood by Alexander Lipisch.
[00:08:35]  As an aircraft approaches the speed of sound, the shock wave over the wing moves the center of lift backwards and the plane noses down.
[00:08:44]  This is a condition called mock tuck.
[00:08:48]  Normally you'd pull back on the stick to correct this, but conventional elevator controls on the trailing edge of the tailplane would be unable to get any bite since the elevators would be shock stalled.
[00:09:00]  The only way out of mock tuck is to use an all-moving tail plane to trim back to level.
[00:09:07]  With its delta wing, the comet had no tailplane at all, let alone an all-moving tailplane.
[00:09:14]  It had fabric-covered elevons on the trailing edge of the delta wing, which would always be shock-stalled.
[00:09:21]  Even if a pilot opened his comet's rocket engine to full throttle to muscle his way past the sound barrier, mock tuck would send him tumbling out of control irrecoverably and probably destroy the airframe.
[00:09:38]  In a world that can feel overwhelming, spreading thoughtful, evidence-based content is one of the best ways to make a positive impact.
[00:09:46]  Ask your local public radio station to air the Skeptoid files, a 30-minute radio-friendly version of Skeptoid that pairs two related episodes promoting real science, true history, and critical thinking.
[00:09:59]  And in these challenging times for public media, we're offering these broadcasts for free to radio stations, available on the PRX Exchange or directly from Skeptoid Media.
[00:10:10]  It's an easy ask.
[00:10:12]  Just send a quick message to your station's programming director.
[00:10:16]  By helping to bring the Skeptoid files to the airwaves, you'll help promote the essential skills we all need to tell fact from fiction.
[00:10:24]  Just go to your local station's website, find the programming director's email address, or just their general email address.
[00:10:29]  You can even use the telephone.
[00:10:32]  I know that might sound crazy.
[00:10:33]  It's an old legacy device that allows real-time voice communication.
[00:10:38]  I know that's weird, but hey, it's an option.
[00:10:41]  The world can feel chaotic, but you're not powerless.
[00:10:44]  When you promote critical thinking, you can help your community tell fact from fiction.
[00:10:49]  And that's how we shape a better future.
[00:10:51]  In uncertain times, spreading good ideas can make you feel helpful, not helpless.
[00:10:58]  Let's stand up for reason, truth, and understanding together.
[00:11:02]  Get them to air the Skeptoid files from Skeptoid Media, available on the PRX Exchange, and they'll know what that is.
[00:11:16]  It's also important to be aware of a limitation of early airspeed indicators.
[00:11:21]  One built for subsonic speed is probably going to give unreliable readings in the presence of shockwaves.
[00:11:27]  A phenomenon called compressibility error gives inaccurately high airspeed readings as the aircraft approaches the speed of sound.
[00:11:36]  This error is called mock jump.
[00:11:39]  To counter this, supersonic aircraft use a mock indicator instead of an airspeed indicator.
[00:11:46]  The speed of sound at any given pressure and altitude is determined primarily by temperature.
[00:11:52]  A Mach indicator is essentially an airspeed indicator mounted on an aneroid diaphragm to correct for static air pressure.

=== Compressibility Error Explained (07:08) ===

[00:12:00]  Since Mach and airspeed are both dependent on temperature, they cancel each other out and no temperature diaphragm is needed.
[00:12:09]  Comets had airspeed indicators, not Mach indicators, and so even the speeds logged by the German test pilots are probably incorrectly high.
[00:12:20]  One of the best known claims to the sound barrier comes from German World War II fighter pilot Hans Guido Muttke, flying perhaps the most devastating fighter of the war, the Messerschmitt ME-262.
[00:12:34]  The 262 was the first true operational jet-powered fighter plane in the world, sporting twin BMW 003 turbojet engines mounted below the swept wings.
[00:12:46]  Although the 262 entered the war too late to have any real impact, it boasted a 5 to 1 kill ratio against Allied fighters.
[00:12:55]  Mutke was cruising at 36,000 feet when he began a steep dive under full power.
[00:13:01]  With his airspeed indicator pegged at its limit of 1,100 kph, just over the speed of sound, but remember the airspeed indicator problem, Mutke reported severe buffeting and loss of control.
[00:13:15]  Suddenly, the buffeting stopped and he regained control, with the airspeed indicator still pegged.
[00:13:22]  And it's this that could indicate that he had broken the sound barrier.
[00:13:26]  Unfortunately, his engines flamed out, not being designed for supersonic speeds, and he slowed and the severe buffeting returned.
[00:13:36]  Finally, his speed dropped enough that he regained control and was able to restart his engines.
[00:13:42]  He returned to base and it was found that his aircraft had lost many rivets, and its wings had become so distorted that the plane had to be scrapped.
[00:13:53]  Mutke never understood what had happened until Chuck Yeager's flight was declassified and the supersonic flight profile became known.
[00:14:02]  Severe buffeting while approaching Mach 1, then the shaking stops above Mach 1, and then resumes upon deceleration below Mach 1.
[00:14:12]  But unfortunately for Mutke, there was not, and could not have been, any independent verification of his speed or of the period of smooth supersonic flight.
[00:14:24]  Nobody denies the damage done to his plane during the buffeting period, but supersonic flight was not necessary for this to happen.
[00:14:33]  The designer of the ME-262, Willie Messerschmitt, always stated emphatically that the 262 was incapable of supersonic flight.
[00:14:43]  In flight tests, he found that at Mach 0.86, the 262 experienced Mach tuck.
[00:14:49]  It lost control and assumed a nose-down attitude that could not be corrected by the pilot, and throttling down was the only way to resume control.
[00:14:59]  The 262 only had conventional elevators along the trailing edge of its tailplane, like all aircraft of the day.
[00:15:06]  So these would have shock stalled and not been able to correct the Mach tuck.
[00:15:11]  But the 262 also had an additional feature.
[00:15:15]  The tail plane was actually all-moving for trim purposes.
[00:15:21]  This was a separate electrically operated control, and it was normally used to keep the plane level as its fuel supply was consumed.
[00:15:29]  Mutke reported that he had actually employed this all-moving trim control in order to get out of the nose-down state, a technique which may not have been considered in Messerschmitt's own tests.
[00:15:41]  Mutke's report was given additional credibility in 1999 when computer modeling and scale model wind tunnel testing conducted at Munich Technical University found that the 262 was capable of reaching and passing Mach 1.
[00:15:59]  So, while we cannot prove or disprove Mutke's claim, it is possible that he did reach supersonic flight.
[00:16:07]  However, like in sports, it's not what happened, it's what the referee says happened that matters.
[00:16:13]  Mutke's flight was unverified and unofficial, and certainly unintentional.
[00:16:18]  So even if he did break the sound barrier before Jaeger, it, quote, doesn't count.
[00:16:25]  There are two other flights that don't count, both accomplished by George Welch, a civilian test pilot for North American Aviation.
[00:16:35]  On October 1st, 1947, just 13 days before Jaeger broke the sound barrier in the X-1, Welch took the new XP-86 fighter prototype up for its maiden flight.
[00:16:49]  In a powered dive from 35,000 feet, Welch reported Mach jump on his airspeed indicator, showing that he was traveling supersonic.
[00:16:59]  Anecdotal stories say that a sonic boom was heard on the ground.
[00:17:04]  Welch's airspeed was not being officially recorded, and no official record states that he broke the sound barrier.
[00:17:11]  If he did, it was either unverified or classified.
[00:17:16]  Welch believed that he did, and to hammer the point home, he gave a repeat performance.
[00:17:22]  While Jaeger was strapped into the X-1, still attached to its B-50 mothership, just before the historic flight, Welch again put his XP-86 into a steep dive.
[00:17:35]  Some stories say that he buzzed the B-50 close enough for those on board, Jaeger included, to hear his sonic boom.
[00:17:44]  He made a 4G pullout from his dive, and those same stories say that his sonic boom was louder than Jaeger's just 20 minutes later.
[00:17:54]  There is no engineering reason to doubt Welch's claim.
[00:17:58]  The history books credit George Welch with breaking the sound barrier in the XP-86 in a dive six months later, on April 26, 1948, with official measurements and a proper mock indicator on board.
[00:18:15]  But did he do the same thing before Jaeger's flight?
[00:18:18]  Well, he may well have, and a lot of people say he did.
[00:18:22]  But there's a significant difference between Jaeger's flight and those of Welch, Mutke, Dittmar, and probably others.
[00:18:30]  Their claims to the sound barrier were all in dives and were transient at best.
[00:18:37]  Glamorous Glennis, on the other hand, was the first aircraft capable of sustained supersonic level flight.
[00:18:45]  Sure, being the first to break the sound barrier becomes less glitzy when you have to pile on qualifications.
[00:18:52]  But every aviation milestone has been an incremental one.
[00:18:56]  Few are truly revolutionary.
[00:18:59]  Jaeger, Welch, Mutke, and Dittmar all made real contributions to the science of aviation.
[00:19:06]  All had the right stuff.

=== Sustained Supersonic Flight (02:21) ===

[00:19:09]  At some point, any lines you draw to separate their achievements come down to semantics.
[00:19:14]  Yet you still have to draw those lines somewhere.
[00:19:17]  Flights have to be official.
[00:19:20]  They have to be verifiable.
[00:19:22]  And they should demonstrate a deliberate capability.
[00:19:25]  And so, while it's a virtual certainty that the sound barrier was broken by someone somewhere in some circumstance, Chuck Yeager's flight of the Bell X-1 is the only flight to meet all the criteria of a true aviation first.
[00:19:48]  Quality science podcasts need your support to stay in business.
[00:19:52]  Skeptoid is made possible only by support from listeners like you.
[00:19:57]  If you want to be a part of Skeptoid's ongoing mission and get your free gift for supporting Skeptoid, please consider coming to skeptoid.com and become a supporter.
[00:20:08]  Your help is greatly needed and greatly appreciated.
[00:20:14]  You're listening to Skeptoid.
[00:20:15]  I'm Brian Dunning from Skeptoid.com.
[00:20:24]  Hello, everyone.
[00:20:25]  This is Adrian Hill from Skookum Studios in Calgary, Canada, the land of maple syrup and mousse.
[00:20:33]  And I'm here to ask you to consider becoming a premium member of Skeptoid for as little as $5 per month.
[00:20:42]  And that's only the cost of a couple of Tim Horton's double doubles.
[00:20:46]  And that's Canadian for coffee with double cream and sugar.
[00:20:50]  Why support Skeptoid?
[00:20:52]  If you are like me and don't like ads, but like extended versions of each episode, Premium is for you.
[00:20:59]  If you want to support a worthwhile nonprofit that combats pseudoscience, promotes critical thinking, and provides free access to teachers to use the podcast in the classroom via the Teacher's Toolkit, then sign up today.
[00:21:12]  Remember that skepticism is the best medicine.
[00:21:17]  Next to giggling, of course.
[00:21:19]  Until next time, this is Adrienne Hill.
[00:21:29]  From PRX