All Episodes
May 20, 2024 - Rubin Report - Dave Rubin
01:07:51
Joe Rogan Has a Brutal Message for Pro-Palestinian Protesters | Cohost James Lindsay
Participants
Main voices
d
dave rubin
21:42
j
james lindsay
30:59
Appearances
g
gad saad
01:54
j
jasmine crockett
02:05
j
joe biden
01:21
Clips
a
abby phillip
00:32
d
dr james lindsey
00:47
h
harry enten
00:49
j
jake tapper
00:24
j
joe rogan
00:25
s
sam altman
00:36
| Copy link to current segment

Speaker Time Text
unidentified
♪♪♪ ♪♪♪
♪♪♪ I'm running for the Colorado State Senate.
Of course I'm going to knock on your door every day until you turn in that ballot.
joe biden
I'm running for the Colorado State Senate.
Of course I buy a new dress every time there's a fundraiser.
dave rubin
I'm running for the Colorado State Senate.
unidentified
I don't know you, but of course I'm going to call you repeatedly for money.
I'm running for the Colorado State Senate.
dave rubin
Of course I don't know your name until I see your name tag at the fundraiser.
I'm running for the Colorado State Senate.
dr james lindsey
Of course I support reasonable gun control.
unidentified
Of course I support immigration and finding viable paths to citizenship.
dr james lindsey
Of course I support rural health care initiatives.
Of course I support a woman's right to abortion.
dave rubin
I'm not running for Colorado State Senate, but I am hosting this show on.
I'm Dave Rubin.
This is The Rubin Report, and do not adjust your screens.
I am a little lower today than usual.
That's because we have a special guest host for today's program in studio with me, none other than Conceptual James, the once banned Conceptual James on Twitter, James Lindsay.
dr james lindsey
Yeah, once banned.
dave rubin
For your, what, 500th appearance on The Rubin Report now?
dr james lindsey
I hope so.
dave rubin
I think this is 500.
You've finally done it.
You came to Miami in the hottest week we have had all year.
It's about 162 degrees outside.
dr james lindsey
It was.
Yesterday was rough.
dave rubin
It's good to see you, my friend.
We are going to dive into a whole bunch of stuff.
We got some clips from another old Rubin Report guest, Gad Saad, who was recently on Joe Rogan.
We're going to show you the elderly man pretending to be president.
We got a fight in Congress.
We're going to do some AI stuff and just catch up on a whole bunch of things.
But before we dive into all of that, we were saying, well, first off, we both have realized that we now, at our advanced, how old are you? 44.
44, I'm 47.
We both have hit the age where when we're looking at notes we have glasses and it is what it is.
dr james lindsey
Look how smart we look.
dave rubin
Do you feel smarter?
No, but I... It's so hot right now that my gla... Do you see this?
My glasses are actually fogging up because...
dr james lindsey
Well, welcome to Florida.
dave rubin
Welcome to Florida, that's right.
james lindsay
Freedom here, and it's hot.
dave rubin
But let's do one little thing before we dive into the clips, which is that largely, you have been calling out this stuff, and right, at least directionally so, about all of this for years.
You were calling out the craziness of the woke stuff.
You were saying that all this anti-white sentiment really was gonna lead to a lot of bad stuff as it pertained to the Jews.
It's sort of all bursting forth right now.
I guess my one question would be, do you feel good about that?
Or like?
dr james lindsey
No, no.
james lindsay
I do wish the dark money checks would show up though.
dave rubin
Yes, yes.
Oh, so you're not paid by, No, it turns out.
We're all paid by some sort of dark cabal.
james lindsay
Turns out when you get paid by the dark cabal, you get wrong answers.
Yeah.
Instead of right answers.
So no, I don't feel that good about it.
I hate to watch it kind of unfold.
It's, I mean, it's a bit like raising kids in a sense where you tell them to do something
and you watch them just, you know, touch the stove or do something.
No, I don't feel good about watching the world burn.
unidentified
Thank you.
dave rubin
But we tried, we tried, and I suppose we'll continue to try.
dr james lindsey
That's what goes on our tombstones.
james lindsay
We tried.
dave rubin
We tried.
Speaking of people that are trying, Gadsad was on Joe Rogan talking about the suicidal empathy that so many in the West have these days, and we thought we'd start with that.
unidentified
Take a look.
gad saad
That don't share our foundational values.
Again, this doesn't mean, someone's gonna write in the comments section, what a hypocrite.
You're an immigrant, Gadsad.
Well, there are immigrants and there are immigrants.
There are tons of Muslims who want to come in here and leave all that baggage at the door.
They want nothing to do with that.
They just want to live the American experience.
The problem is we don't have the machine that can look into your heart and mind, right?
So it's a statistical game.
So if you're going to let in hundreds, I mean, look what's happening in Germany.
Look what's happening in France.
Look what's happening in Denmark.
unidentified
Well, let me ask you this.
Why do you think that stuff is happening?
Why do you think this is mass immigration?
gad saad
So that's a great question.
So it's covered partly in Parasitic Mind, my earlier book, and in my next book, which I call Suicidal Empathy, right?
So empathy is an emotion that has evolved for very clear evolutionary reasons.
So just like any of our other emotions, for example, envy, there are evolutionary reasons why we've evolved the emotion of envy, right?
It can compel us forward.
I see that Joe's doing well.
keeping up with the Joneses, maybe it'll get me off my fat ass so I can work harder. So there are
very clear evolutionary reasons why empathy exists. But the problem is when empathy misfires,
it either becomes hyperactive or it misfires in directing the empathy to the wrong person.
So for example, illegal immigrants more important than American vets, right?
And I can show you many public policies where you have these insane policies, all of which are due to suicidal empathy.
So to answer your question, I think that the Western mind is we are kind, tolerant, compassionate, empathetic people.
There are people out there, they're Guatemalan, they're Honduran, they're Yemeni, who don't
have it as well as we do.
Wouldn't it be nice if we open up our doors?
So the reflex is a noble one, it's a nice one, but it exists in unicorny.
dave rubin
I have to say, as I sit here with one of the guys that was largely right about this stuff,
it's always a pleasure listening to Gad because he's been warning about this for years.
Unfortunately, the roadblocks that we were all trying to put up didn't work, I suppose.
But this idea that empathy, that we in the West put empathy, or Jordan Peterson talks about this a lot, putting tolerance up in that tops position of the hierarchy, it has led to a disaster right now.
It seems to me that we are now seeing on the shores of the United States what we've all been seeing clips of on Twitter, in Europe for years and going, we shouldn't have that happening here.
And now it's happening here and we don't seem to be doing anything about it.
james lindsay
That's, I mean, there's so many things that could be said.
First of all, you know, I was talking to Joe, he asked me the exact same question about two months ago on the show.
People can go watch.
It was the first thing.
So we're just get talking, you know, and he's like, why do you think immigration is happening?
dr james lindsey
And I'm like, whoa, Joe, okay.
james lindsay
Have you heard of the Cloward Piven strategy?
dr james lindsey
And we went all the way tinfoil hat right away.
So contrary to the empathy.
dave rubin
How far do you want to take us on that ride right now?
james lindsay
I mean, it's just that Cloward and Piven were two socialists who were coming up with a strategy for how you break a wealthy country and you overload its financial and social services resources.
So you bring in immigrants, you up crime, you keep the budget deficit high until you end up with a financial crisis.
And so...
There you go.
You import millions across the border.
They're very expensive.
You have a financial crisis.
dave rubin
So you intentionally break the system so that they sort of need the new socialist system?
unidentified
That's right.
dr james lindsey
So they need a new system.
james lindsay
That's right.
Because now we have so many people.
They're dysfunctional.
You have to take care of them.
Things broke.
So now everybody's dysfunctional.
So you have to take care of them.
Not as, you know, oh this is organic and Westerners are just so nice.
But that is, Gad's right, that is the empathy, the suicidal empathy he calls it, is the tool that allows it to happen.
And we've been manipulated for at least 50 years.
You can read in The Wretched of the Earth by Frantz Fanon.
The foreword to that, or preface, is by Jean-Paul Sartre.
And it's called A Letter to Europe.
dr james lindsey
And he's like...
james lindsay
The savages are coming, and you better give it away.
And look how great you've had it, and they're going to take it, and they'll murder you if you don't give it away.
And that's really the strange death of Europe.
You know, our friend Douglas wrote the book titled that, but that foreword really should be titled the strange death of Europe.
They accepted it, and it's exactly what Gad said.
It's that we care.
We get this, this, oh my gosh, we've had it good.
We're a little bit guilty for that.
It's so crappy for other people.
And we don't have that kind of Donald Trump, oh, they're from shithole countries, you know, attitude that it's like, well, it's their job to get their stuff together too, which is a much more like, frankly, classical liberal, not even a conservative position.
It's like individual responsibility, self-governance, different areas have to get their stuff together.
So they weaponize that empathy and get us to override our better sense and that enables strategies like Cloward Piven or whatever else to be able to be foisted on the people.
And then like you said, it's now it's happening and people either don't know what to do
or they're just not doing anything about it.
I predict like we had in 2020, a critical race theory explosion.
I think in 2024, we're gonna have a critical immigration theory explosion.
It's gonna look carbon copy.
Therefore, I don't think it's going to work.
I don't think the American people will fall for it, but it's gonna be ugly.
dave rubin
So you mentioned Douglas Murray and Strange Death of Europe.
The other line that he has on this is that one day the barbarians will be at the gate and we'll be debating what gender pronouns to call them.
Yeah, well... And I think that that really is sort of where we're at right now.
We have this strange, this really psychotic mix of Marxists and Communists and Socialists and Antifa and Hamas people, and they're taking over our universities.
It's been going on for decades.
unidentified
A lot of people didn't seem to believe it was going on, but it has led us to another clip from What's crazy to me is, regardless of how you feel about how the Israeli military and the army is pursuing the war in Gaza, regardless of that, the blatant
Just out in the open anti-semitism that we see today.
It's like nothing I've ever seen before like like roaches coming out of the woodwork.
Like what?
Like you see it all over social media and it's like this.
If this was September and not October, you would be shunned.
Everybody would be like, this is horrible.
How the f*** could you say this?
You're openly anti-Semitic.
You're openly blaming the Jews for all the world's problems.
This is crazy.
This is Nazi s***.
And yet you're seeing it everywhere now.
joe rogan
When those teachers were in front of Congress, when those principals of those universities were in front of Congress, And they were saying that it's not harassment to say death to the Jews unless it's actionable, which is the craziest mental verbal gymnastics I have ever heard anyone say that's in that position, in a position of being the head of Harvard.
unidentified
It was so crazy to watch.
It's so crazy.
It's almost like we live in an alternative timeline.
Like, we entered into a new dimension.
Like, in our sleep, we woke up, but we're in a new place.
dave rubin
Okay, so I know that does not surprise you.
I tried, right before we started the show, I put your Twitter name in, and Jews, because I wanted to see if I could find you saying basically that, that from, you know, say, seven or eight years ago, which I have no doubt you did, that in essence, this woke stuff was going to be very bad for the Jews in the end.
And ultimately it'll be bad for the Asians and sort of any minority that succeeds.
But again, I suppose the whole theme today will be none of this surprises you, right?
james lindsay
None of this surprises me.
James is not surprised.
dave rubin
That's going to be the only question I just repeat to you over and over again.
unidentified
Are you surprised?
No.
james lindsay
Are you happy?
No.
dave rubin
End of show.
james lindsay
Yeah, that's right.
Where's the dark money check?
Yeah, so in 2020, I wrote an essay in October 2020, I wrote an essay called critical race theories Jewish problem.
And I laid out everything, like both sides of it, the critical race theory, interpreting Jews as white, and therefore going after them, recreating the anti semitic conspiracy theory that they've hoarded privilege to themselves under the set, you know, the trendsetters of society, even though there's this exclusive minority, they've recreate the whole thing.
And then, secondly, is this kind of post-colonial nightmare, where the existence of Israel, allegedly as a U.S.
and British-backed state, is the injection of whiteness and Western values into the Middle East, and this is a catastrophe.
And I just wrote then that this is a disaster in the making.
There's this book, it's called How Jews Became White Folks, and what that means about race in America.
It's by a woman named Karen.
I mean, really?
dave rubin
Karen Brodkin.
james lindsay
And that book's from like 99.
And it just lays all this stuff out.
And so I was just like, God, people need to read.
And so I told people back in 2020 what happened.
I got smeared as anti-Semitic for saying this.
Apparently that accuses progressive Jews of causing anti-Semitism or something.
And I got nuked for this.
So I should have been more savvy because, you know, all this vile anti-Semitism has exploded.
The left doesn't surprise me at all.
The right Does a little bit.
Honestly, I know that there's genuine anti-semitism on the right.
I'm not playing this naive card on this kind of far right.
I know about the whole Groyper phenomenon.
I know all of this is happening.
So it's not that surprising, but the volume of it that kind of erupted, and even from mainstream characters, was really kind of shocking to me by November or so.
But one of the first things I said about what happened in Israel, on October 7th, I think by about the 9th, I was calling it Gaza Floyd, like George Floyd, and the Israeli response is going to be extremely vigorous.
The left is going to now take up this cause celeb of the poor Palestinian Muslims, blah, blah, blah, and that's what we see on college campuses.
But what happened on the right kind of shocked me.
And so I sat there and I thought about it and Joe's like, what's going on?
It's like we're in an alternative timeline.
Yeah, we are.
It's called psychological operations.
I think a lot of it's there.
And I think that you shouldn't really believe that what you see on social media is totally indicative.
There are these movements.
We know the Gropers exist.
We know that, you know, I mean, Do we name names?
We know that Candace is saying weird stuff.
We know this Christ is King narrative is being used in a double meaning.
One side is it's a statement of Christian belief in a particular theology, and on the other side it is a weapon that says, you know, you're going to bend the knee.
And People know this.
I mean half the Jewish people I know called me freaking out.
What's happening?
What's happening?
What's happening from people on our side?
dr james lindsey
But I think that what you're seeing on the social media at least is largely manufactured largely.
james lindsay
Largely in operation to make it appear that this is a groundswell.
One of Mao's techniques that he used in China in the 1950s was called Planned Spontaneity.
And that's written all through like Beautiful Trouble, Rules for Radicals.
You make it look like there's a spontaneous groundswell, but it's fake.
It's theater.
Like we find out with these campus uprisings.
I won't call them protests, by the way.
These campus uprisings, what happens?
Well, they get rowdy, the cops show up, they arrest a bunch of people.
And what do they find out?
More than half, usually more than two-thirds, are not even affiliated with the university.
Not students, not faculty.
Where'd they come from?
dr james lindsey
Who's paying them?
james lindsay
People start digging finally.
Imagine that journalists on the right actually dig at some point, and then what do you find?
Oh wow, they're being paid by this group, and that group, and the other group.
Whoever it happened to be.
I don't have the details, so I won't wander into it.
But, oh wow, it's AstroTurf.
It's fake.
It's theater designed to make these things, this groundswell appear to be happening, and to freak everybody out, and to gain momentum in it.
dave rubin
Is part of what's going on here that none of us can really gauge the chasm between the online discourse and what's going on in real life?
So if you spend all day online, it seems like everything is falling apart at once.
Now, I'm not saying that there isn't a lot of evidence of that.
You can't let seven or 10 million immigrants into a country, illegals into a country in three years, right?
And those are probably conservative, right?
I think seven is probably conservative, 10 is probably closer to it, something like that.
But that's a real thing.
Obviously, I'm not denying that that's real.
But you can spend all day online finding endless lunacy everywhere.
james lindsay
Yeah, the sky is always falling.
dave rubin
Right, so I think partly what we're dealing with right now is that people don't know how to hold those two things at the same time.
That there's sheer lunacy online, there is an obvious lunacy in the real world, but they're not quite matched up.
And that leaves us all in this weird spot.
james lindsay
Well, our friend Jordan, Jordan Peterson, one time he did this very controversial, everybody lost their mind, he said, male aggression doesn't upload.
It's physical violence.
Female aggression is this social, nasty, you know, gossip violence.
It uploads to the internet really well.
It goes to social media very effectively.
We haven't calculated for that, you know, he gets all Jordan emotional.
But he didn't talk about how, like, personality disorders also upload very effectively.
It's really easy to be a psychopath online.
And a psychopath can have 30 characters online very easily, you know, so they can have disproportionate influence.
unidentified
Then you add in the bots.
james lindsay
So there's the disconnect between the fact that people go online to express their stress, their psychopathy, whatever else.
There's a disconnect.
But there's another thing.
I don't know if you've ever sat down and talked to Robert Malone about the internet.
dave rubin
Yes, we've talked about mass formation psychosis and everything else.
james lindsay
You talk about a paradigm shift when he starts talking about, you know, the numbers of people that they know that the United Nations hires to run interference online, that the British government hires people to go run interference online.
That character, not just even bots, even paid people, that's arguing with you about some thing that you put this controversial on social media
might just be being paid to get your goat.
Or it might be a 15 year old just trying to get your goat.
And so the thing is, is that it's like, the insanity online is like,
that's where you go, you get stressed out and you just want to say something,
because it's actually like techno prayer.
And you want absolution for your stress.
But then at the same time, it's so much fake.
dave rubin
It's also so interesting to me, having been in this game for 12 years at this point,
the online game, that people are still so focused on the comments.
Because, you know, we'll get a video that has a million comments, and I'm very, very proud of our audience, and I think it's a credit to what we've built here.
My audience, they're not crazy trolls.
They're not all awful people saying horrible things.
A lot of other channels that do something similar, it's not that way.
But if a video gets, say, a million views, and it gets 10,000 comments, and the comments are all negative or mean or whatever.
I'm not even talking about my channel right now, on any channel.
Everyone thinks that's indicative of something, but that means that 990,000 people watched and didn't comment.
james lindsay
So it's we focus on only the type of people that engage in the online behaviors, and I think that's wildly just also So it's not always fake, but it's so easy to manufacture that that illusion I Somehow at one point and maybe 20 21 a few years ago I got sucked somebody sent said it was like all the antifa stuff was going on or whatever and it was like Do you know they have a slack channel?
Somebody sent me a link or whatever.
I'm just click on it.
I go into their discord I don't know which one it was I go into their server There's a thousand people in there and they're like, it wasn't you.
I'm just, you know, we'll use your show as the example.
Dave Rubin just posted this flammatory video.
dave rubin
Go bomb him.
james lindsay
And so now you get 700 comments, but that's just manufactured.
Now you think if that's organic, angry activists, but if you think, well, maybe it's not, maybe there's, you know, Some dude who pays people, he's on some grant money or whatever, and their jobs are to go leave comments or swarm.
The left used to do this to me all the time.
You'd put a certain thing, usually about trans people, and you would just get piled on Twitter.
dave rubin
So you're basically saying we're caught between sort of Machiavellian psychotic trolls and potentially foreign governments or even our own government operating against us in the digital realm?
james lindsay
Right, plus the fact that on average people are there to either show off their witty selves or to upload their stress.
So it's like, I read a book about neuroscience, and I feel bad because I can't remember what the book was called a number of years ago, but the lady called it, the author called it, the amygdala of the internet.
And it's like, yeah, you have the stress and you're like, what do I do?
I'm like, I'm gonna go tell people about it.
dave rubin
Just to bring this back to that clip, and then we'll move on.
What do you think the Jews could be doing a little bit differently, if anything, right now, to fight this lunacy?
dr james lindsey
Well, I don't know.
james lindsay
They did a really good job with the Aurora, you know, charging the space laser.
dr james lindsey
I stole that joke from the Rebel on B. That was a good one.
james lindsay
Clever, they said.
You know, Aurora Borealis used to cover up the charging of the space laser.
No, the truth is what has to come out as often as possible, so it's up to every individual.
I don't speak ever in terms of what groups of people need to do, but it is incumbent upon people who want Something that represents them to be understood, to speak up.
So, Jewish people who have a view that is rooted in, you know, liberty and clarity and why these things are happening, need to speak up and talk about it.
I will warn them.
I don't want to take anything away.
I'm going to get called bad names for this.
Say as much of the, you know, historical victimhood stuff, which is legitimate, as you want, but that is poisoned currency right now.
So if you lean in that direction, expect that it's going to be, oh, you're just playing a poor me card.
And it's not going to be as effective as articulating what I don't hear enough of, a friend of mine calls it, you know, instead of like Jew-phobia, Jew-philia.
Like, what is Jewish faith about?
A lot of Americans don't know that much.
What do we really stand for?
If you talk to observant Jews, it's like they're really usually very based.
And so, get that out there.
Like, start talking about, you know, what's the difference between Jews and pagans?
Why is the stuff that's happening not in line with Jewish theology?
Because the big thing we're not saying right now is, of course, that the Jews are behind the communism and they're behind the whole thing, right?
So, communism's a Jewish plot.
That's the idea, right?
Communism is fundamentally incompatible with Jewish faith, if you know the first thing about Jewish faith.
We don't.
Most Americans, Christians in particular, don't.
They have generally positive feelings towards Jewish people for various reasons, but they're ignorant reasons, not that they're bad.
We need these clear articulations.
This is what Jews stand for.
This is why the individual is so important in Judaism.
This is what we mean by community.
No, of course, we don't have this idea of, you know, collective power, blah, blah, blah.
dave rubin
By the way, one of the reasons that I like asking you about these things is because you are an atheist and you have now found common cause mostly with people of belief, largely Christians, and yet here we are.
So we're all We're all basically on the same side.
We will get to a guy we're not on the same side of, and he has dementia, you know who I'm talking about.
He gave one of the most awful speeches imaginable this past weekend at Moorhead College.
But before we do that, let me talk about Gravity Defier shoes.
Guys, let me share my recent discovery with you.
G-Defy shoes.
That's G-D-E-F-Y shoes.
Let me tell you, they're simply amazing.
No, they're beyond amazing.
G-Defy is a footwear company on a mission to relieve knee, back, and foot pain.
As many of you know, I've struggled with knee pain from balling all these years, but the moment I slipped on my G-Defy shoes, the pain just vanished.
How does G-Defy achieve this ultimate comfort?
Firstly, every pair comes with a free custom orthotic to align your body perfectly.
Then there's their patented VersoShock trampoline technology in the heel, which absorbs harmful shocks and provides positive, renewed energy, empowering you to tackle your day.
Additionally, G-Defy has integrated a strong structural system into their shoes that improves your posture and encourages you to walk using your calf and other major muscle groups.
Don't just take my word for it.
Read the countless customer reviews raving about the pain relief and amazing comfort they've experienced with G-Defy.
I, for one, can't get enough of them and I wholeheartedly recommend them to anyone looking for relief.
Experience the comfort and pain relief for yourself.
Visit G-Defy.com and use code Reuben30 for $30 off $150 or more.
And now back to me.
How about that for a professional?
You were nodding along with me.
james lindsay
Yeah, that was great.
dave rubin
Pretty good.
james lindsay
I'm liking the idea.
Like, when we were kids, you had those pump-up shoes.
dave rubin
Oh yeah, the Reebok.
james lindsay
Now they have trampolines in shoes.
dave rubin
There are trampolines in shoes.
james lindsay
I'm so excited for this.
dave rubin
Little known fact, I think it was Reebok, if I'm not mistaken, someone will fact check me, it's the internet, that in around 1994, Karl Malone on the jazz had a shoe that had a little trampoline in it, and they banned it.
unidentified
Oh, really?
dave rubin
In the NBA, yeah.
james lindsay
Oh, that's amazing.
dave rubin
My guys, they'll check on that.
But let's go from highly trained athletes doing things that most people can't do to a man who can't do things that most people can do, which is speak.
Joe Biden very poorly read off the teleprompter, as always, at the graduation at Morehouse College this weekend.
But this speech, and we're gonna play you about a minute long clip, it is just The worst sort of pandering evil drivel.
So thus the perfect Democrat presidential speech.
unidentified
Go.
joe biden
It's natural to wonder if democracy you hear about actually works for you.
What is democracy?
If black men are being killed in the street, what is democracy?
Betrayal of broken promises still leave black communities behind.
What is democracy?
You have to be 10 times better than anyone else to get a fair shot.
Most of all, what does it mean, as you've heard before, to be a black man who loves his country, even if it doesn't love him back in equal measure?
In America, we're all created equal.
Extremists close the doors of opportunity, strike down affirmative action, attack the values of diversity, equality, and inclusion.
I never thought when I was graduating in 1968, as your honoree just was, we talked about, I never thought I'd be a president at a time when there's a national effort to ban books.
Not to write history, but to erase history.
They don't see you in the future of America, but they're wrong.
To me, we make history, not erase it.
We know black history is American history.
dave rubin
I'm sorry guys.
Well, I'm sorry, not sorry, but I never heard Donald Trump say anything as evil as what you just heard there for the last 60 seconds.
I mean, that was the worst sort of grievance politics.
I just want to read you one stat.
This may not blow your mind, but I think it will blow some people's minds.
2023 interracial homicides.
86 blacks were killed by whites.
86 blacks were killed by whites.
488 whites were killed by blacks.
That runs highly counter, let's say, to what he just laid out there.
Also, black people, he told them that they're going to have to be 10 times better to get a fair shot.
He clearly has no idea what's going on in our corporations or anything else.
I mean, it's evil.
I don't know how to describe it as anything other than evil.
And, you know, we often talk about the motives of these people.
Are they just, is Joe Biden just confused about these issues?
That is, I mean, I know he doesn't know what he's, I know he doesn't know what he's saying and he's slurring through most of it and everything.
And also the Botox or whatever they're doing, he's looking angrier.
Go.
james lindsay
Yet again there's 3,000 things to say.
I think my favorite part is there in the middle where he says, you know, in America we're all created equal and extremists want to get rid of affirmative action, diversity, equity, inclusion programs, which implicitly they're based off of the disparate impact doctrine of legal theory.
They implicitly assume that we have to do remedial activities to make up for It's so upside down.
But the beginning part where he's, what is democracy?
And it's very clear he doesn't know.
He doesn't even give a definition.
He doesn't realize that we're a republic.
I mean, Donald Trump famously got asked what he was thinking at one point, and he said, just to be clear, Joe Biden doesn't know he's alive.
unidentified
Right.
james lindsay
And so, but what is democracy?
What he's actually riffing off of, again, a lot of people haven't read, is Vladimir Lenin wrote a book in 1917, the year he took over Russia and established the USSR.
It's called State and Revolution.
And chapter five is about democracy.
It's just a rewrite of that.
I mean, I saw that this morning.
I was in the Uber on the way over here, listening to that in the back of the car, and I was like, oh my God, he's doing Lenin.
Like, this is a straight Lenin act, which is that there's, his idea was that we say that we have democracy, but we don't have democracy because the bourgeois classes, the rich classes, the privileged classes, they have their democracy, but they keep everybody else.
You got to be 10 times better to even have a fair shake.
That's the messaging here.
And what he says is what we need then is we need an ideal democracy.
But to get there, what we need is a proletarian democracy.
And what that means is he explicitly says that means the silencing of the voices, the repealing of the right to vote, the confiscation of the property of the bourgeois classes so that they can be brought down so everybody's more equal.
That's what I see.
dave rubin
Right.
It's not about lifting everybody up.
It's about bringing a certain set of people down.
james lindsay
I was just thought it's impossible to lift everybody up.
dave rubin
Right.
james lindsay
The only thing that lifts everybody up is when you have a thriving economy where the entire thing comes up together.
So even the people who are doing badly in the economy are doing better than they would be otherwise.
dave rubin
As I was watching it, I kept thinking, you know, if you were a young black man who's now graduating, you're graduating, and the president of the United States shows up to give the commencement speech, he then tells you how evil and racist the country that he's president of is.
He then tells you, you will have to work 10 times harder.
It's like, what an awful message to send that young person out in the world with.
And they are now creating clone soldiers.
They put these people out into the world, and then they, well, this is very odd.
Why do they want to burn the whole country down?
There is a reason, however, guys, that Biden is trying to stoke fear amongst the black community right now, and it is because an awful lot of black people are breaking away from the Democrat Party, hallelujah, and even CNN is addressing it.
harry enten
But look at this number for Donald Trump.
22%.
Where was Donald Trump at this point four years ago in the polls?
He was just at 9% of the vote.
So he's seen more than a doubling in his support among African Americans.
This margin, which was in the 70s, Just four years ago.
Look at where it is now.
69 minus 22.
That puts it in the 40s.
My goodness gracious!
If this held through the general election, obviously we're still months away, this would be by far the best performance for a Republican candidate among black voters in a generation, two generations, probably since 1960 and Richard Nixon against John F. Kennedy.
That's how long we're really talking about when we're looking at this margin here.
This could be a truly historic margin.
It's quite a troubling sign for the Biden campaign.
dave rubin
I mean, that's a game changer if it holds, right?
Let's not forget Donald Trump.
I say it all the time.
State of the Union, what was it, 2017 State of the Union, when it was lowest all-time black unemployment, lowest all-time Hispanic unemployment, and the Congressional Black Caucus sat there like this.
AOC didn't even show up.
I think, and again I don't like to do the group thing, but largely there is a segment of the black population that is like, wait a minute, he's not Hitler and these people are doing nothing for us.
james lindsay
Yeah, well, I mean, what they're doing is hatecraft.
And people are tired of being pushed into it.
I talk to people all the time, you know, I get all kinds all over the place.
I'm in Ubers, I'm talking to different people all over, and I hear this kind of consistently.
I still, you know, run into people that are pretty hard Democrat and this and that, but this idea that it's like all you hear from them is negative, negative, negative, and nothing's working.
I hear all the time this from people who claim to be Democrat, and it's both sexes, all races, you know.
dave rubin
What do you mean both sexes?
james lindsay
Oh yeah.
dave rubin
No.
unidentified
No.
dave rubin
What?
unidentified
No.
james lindsay
Two.
harry enten
Two.
james lindsay
Just two.
unidentified
Did you know that I even...
james lindsay
We'll check that out.
We were even talking about Joe Rogan.
You know Joe, you don't...
Joe's alpha, right?
He's maximum alpha.
So Joe's like, we're talking about Admiral Levine, which I just call Admiral Levine usually
because you get in trouble if you call Dick or Richard.
So Joe's like, well she blah blah blah, and I said, he.
dave rubin
Yeah.
james lindsay
I just cut him off.
dave rubin
Wow, even Joe was doing that.
james lindsay
No, Joe was with me after that.
unidentified
Oh, good.
james lindsay
We snapped him.
It's like this spell people are under.
dave rubin
Well, first off, the fact that his name is Dick is hilarious.
That's number one.
And also Dick Levine, Rachel Levine, said that his greatest joy in life is having kids because he was a man his whole life until a couple years ago, and now he's for gender reassignment surgery for 12-year-olds.
I mean, the level of evil there is so off the charts, it's unimaginable.
james lindsay
It's, well, we just saw Tantamount Evil from Biden.
dave rubin
Fair enough.
Yeah, that's the racial version.
james lindsay
But what I hear from all these people is that maybe they don't like Trump or they don't trust Trump or they think he's still a bad guy, but at least stuff worked.
At least stuff wasn't, you know, everybody said everything was insane, but it seemed like that was a media thing.
I hear this all the time, but what's happening now is actually ruining the country.
I hear it from New Yorkers a lot.
They usually aren't talking about Biden.
They're talking about Kathy Hochul.
They're like, she is ruining the state and there's nothing we can do about it.
And there's this reservoir of growing powerlessness.
That's, you know, that's like a potential.
It's just going to shoot out like an arrow.
And I think we're going to see, I mean, I don't know what we're going to see in the election because who knows what that's even going to mean, but let's pretend there's that that's, you know, an election.
We're going to see record support.
All of those white people in 2016 who pretended they weren't going to vote or whatever and then they came out in big numbers for Trump, it's everybody else now.
dave rubin
Sure, but I suspect you also think they've got some tricks up their sleeve and that we could enter another George Floyd type summer because they know that they can't let that thing get to the 22%.
You can even hear it in the CNN analyst's voice, like, oh shit, we can't let that happen.
So, I mean, that's always the fear, right?
We just come out with a new George Floyd.
james lindsay
Right, well, I think the new George Floyd is going to be an immigrant, of course, because that's where the energy is all gone.
But that's another one of these breaking points, these fractures.
You hear these people in all the cities, these black people in the cities are coming out and like, what, you're putting them up in five-star hotels?
You're giving them debit cards?
What'd you ever do for us?
You know?
You promised us, we voted for you, you promised us, we voted for you, and now it's all going to illegals who are just dumping into our cities?
Like, what the heck?
So this is another huge, huge problem for the Democrats that they're facing right now.
Also, what is the statistic that just came out?
They estimate maybe 27% of these illegals are registered to vote in the United States.
See, you know, Elon Musk has been banging that drum for months.
He's like, they're going to let him vote.
They're going to let him vote.
So you got Cloward Piven, you're going to let him vote.
And then the third thing is you've imported your proletariat for the other side of the communist revolution.
You can kind of see why.
The open border is happening when you put the pieces together.
dave rubin
Hey, Phoenix, can we have the team all, we're gonna get some more guns after the show, okay?
More guns today, this afternoon, you can come with us.
You wanna come get some guns?
Florida, it's very easy, we're gonna get some guns.
Alright, you wanna talk more about racism in a second?
I'm gonna do an ad, then we'll get back to racism.
It's a Monday, people.
Guys, today's episode is brought to you by Eight Sleep, the high-tech solution to your age-old sleeping issues.
Eight Sleep's pod cover slips right over your mattress, bringing heating and cooling tech that helps you stay comfortable and sleep deeper for a better, more restful night.
Eight Sleep is quite literally the best product I own.
Actually, last night, our air conditioning in our bedroom is not working.
It was about 88 degrees in there, and I just lowered the temp and basically slept on an ice cube.
It was amazing.
The pod cover.
We'll improve your sleep by, Phoenix a little faster, automatically adjusting your bed's temperature based on your individual needs.
The cover can be added to any bed like a fitted sheet and allows you and your partner to cool or warm your side of the bed to as low as 55 degrees and up to 110 degrees.
I don't know what you're doing at 110 degrees.
In addition to keeping you the perfect temperature all night, the pod also tracks your sleep and health metrics.
On average, the pod users see their sleep quality improve by 32% after just a month on the pod.
There's no better way to improve your day-to-day life than better sleep, and the easiest way to do that is with 8sleep's pod cover.
Go to 8sleep.com slash Reuben and get 200 off plus free shipping on the pod cover by 8sleep.
Have you tried one of these things?
unidentified
No, but- It will, Lindsey, it'll change your life.
james lindsay
question about the 110. Yeah, who's sleeping in 110? As you know Dave, you're married to
David. Yes, very weird. Turns out to be male. Yes. So what you actually described is that
you can use this technology to set one side of your bed to male and one side to female.
dr james lindsey
So you don't have that, you guys are both sleeping on an ice cube, that's the male side.
dave rubin
I just realized, you could really fuck with your partner for this thing.
james lindsay
It's like when you get in the car and the seat's on and you're like, did I do a Joe Biden?
dave rubin
Right, you could basically be like, you should never go to bed angry, that's one of my rules.
My brother's wife's grandfather said that to them at their wedding, that's the one rule for a marriage, never go to bed angry.
But if you did go to bed angry, you've got the app and you could just slowly be heating them up all night.
dr james lindsey
Yeah.
dave rubin
That's not the point of Eight Sleep, though.
Anyway, let's talk about other racist stuff happening.
Congress is this place in D.C.
Some of you have seen videos of it.
It is basically just a circus of useless people arguing about nonsense all day, but every now and again, they call each other racist, and that's kind of fun, so enjoy.
jasmine crockett
Do you know what we're here for?
unidentified
You know we're here about- I don't think you know what you're here for.
Well, you're the one talking about- I think your fake eyelashes are messing up- No, ain't nothing- Hold on, hold on.
dave rubin
Order, Mr. Chairman.
unidentified
Would you order the regaining order of your committee?
I do have a point of order, and I would like to move to take down Ms.
jasmine crockett
Greene's words.
unidentified
That is absolutely unacceptable.
How dare you attack the physical appearance of another person?
Are your feelings hurt?
jasmine crockett
Move her words down.
Oh, girl.
unidentified
Baby girl.
dr james lindsey
Oh, really?
unidentified
Don't even play with me.
dave rubin
Baby girl?
jasmine crockett
I don't think... We are going to move, and we're going to take your words down.
dave rubin
I second that motion.
jasmine crockett
I'm just curious, just to better understand your ruling, if someone on this committee then starts talking about somebody's bleach-blind, bad-built, butch body, that would not be engaging in personalities, correct?
unidentified
A what now?
Chairman, I make a motion to strike those words.
dr james lindsey
I don't think that's a part of it.
jasmine crockett
I'm trying to find clarification on what qualifies.
Chairman, motion to strike those words.
unidentified
I had no idea what you just said.
jasmine crockett
We're not going to, we're not going to do this.
Look, you guys earlier literally just said.
unidentified
You just, you just voted to do it.
jasmine crockett
I'm trying to get clarification.
Look it, calm down.
unidentified
Calm down.
jasmine crockett
No, no, no, no.
Because this is what it all do.
unidentified
So I'm trying to get clarification.
Calm down.
jasmine crockett
Can you please calm down?
unidentified
Calm down.
jasmine crockett
Please calm down.
You're out of control.
Talk noise and then you can't take it.
unidentified
Because if I comment on your b**** about her, y'all gonna have a problem.
dave rubin
These people are supposed to be in charge of something, It's just so ridiculous.
So that, the woman with the eyebrows who's screaming, that is Representative Jasmine Crockett from Texas.
Obviously it was Marjorie Taylor Greene who was commenting about the eyebrows, and then they got into it.
The best part of that was the guy with the white hair going, the what now?
No, he just doesn't even know what she's saying, but okay, fine.
They're having their little fracas.
Jasmine now, Jasmine Crockett, is going on mainstream media, and yes, she's talking about the racism as it pertains to fake eyebrows.
Here's Jake Tapper, who's supposed to be the one sane guy over at CNN pushing that theory.
jake tapper
You have since called her racist, Congresswoman Greene.
I want to understand your perspective of this.
Do you think her going after your eyelashes, that that in itself is racist?
jasmine crockett
I think her specifically doing it to me, yes, that was the intent.
As has been stated, you know, women wear makeup, we wear lashes, we wear all types of things to beautify ourselves.
But MAGA has historically been on social media doing the things where they're saying, oh, she's black with lashes and nails and hair, and so she's ghetto.
And so to me, this was her Buying into that rhetoric and trying to amplify this for the MAGA crowd.
And so, yeah, I absolutely think that she only did it to be racist towards me.
jake tapper
Because it was towards you or because it was eyelashes?
So in that sense, it's kind of like, in your view, buying into a racist trope.
jasmine crockett
It is buying into a racist trope.
But the reality is that women of all colors wear lashes.
jake tapper
Right.
No, I know.
That's what I was asking.
dave rubin
Now, James, of course, sitting across from me, you're wearing fake eyelashes.
unidentified
Is that... Thank you for noticing.
dave rubin
They're lovely, by the way.
dr james lindsey
Your badly built butch body.
dave rubin
James, I mentioned to you that occasionally on the program when I don't want to analyze a clip because it doesn't even deserve it, I just punch an inflatable clown.
The clown is not here today.
The kids had it this weekend.
Can I just punch you right now and then we can move on?
james lindsay
I'm not a clown.
dave rubin
You're not a clown.
This concept that somehow fake eyelashes or commenting on someone's obvious fake eyelashes implies racism.
I have simply no doubt that Marjorie Taylor Greene would have used the exact same insult on a white woman that had said had such obvious.
It's not racist but or you'll see whatever color she is.
It's just like this is just endless and it's sucking us all into the pit of hell.
james lindsay
There's at least two things to say and one is that I agree with you very obviously.
unidentified
This is a shit show.
james lindsay
But that's Congress.
That's the other thing to say.
Congress, just to calm everybody down a minute, Congress has pretty much always been like this.
I mean, Sam Houston beat a guy with a stick.
dave rubin
But at least back then there were principled arguments, I suppose, right?
james lindsay
when they weren't beating each other with sticks.
dave rubin
Or when they were arguing about putting together the constitution, they were saying horrible things
about each other, going after each other's motives and everything else, but there was an argument being made.
These people are not making any argument.
james lindsay
So what I suspect happened, because you saw it in the clip, so Marjorie makes her little quip
and then Jasmine starts firing back.
And then all of a sudden, little miss righteous indignation speaks up.
How dare you!
AOC gets in, and then like two days later, Jasmine figures out that she's had racism happen because Critical Race Theory is calling everything you want to control racist until you control it.
They know it's this magic power, magic spell.
But it feels very much like, I listened to her on Jake Topper there, it feels very much like Little Miss Righteous Indignation might have coached her.
You need to go on TV.
This is a trope.
I don't think she actually thinks it, or she might now.
She might have been convinced of it, but it looked very much like she got coached into here's how you deal with this.
This is a racism.
You know, it's like when you pull a fire alarm and you pretend you don't know how to get out of a building.
And then if anybody says, dude, you did it on purpose, that's a racism too.
That's Jamal Bowman, as we all know.
unidentified
I hate that guy.
dave rubin
I got it.
I got it.
I get the references.
I'm fairly involved in the news.
I get it.
But actually, you gave me a great segue, because if you think it was coached, I obviously didn't know that that's what you were going to say right there.
Check out this next follow-up with Crockett.
abby phillip
Now the part that I think really kind of, frankly, caught the internet afire is when
you described Green in this request for clarification as a bleached blonde, bad built, butch body,
which I had to look at my notes to read.
Any regrets about that kind of language, especially given that you were trying to make a point,
frankly, about decorum in the hearing room?
jasmine crockett
I have no regrets.
And I'll tell you why.
Because Marjorie Taylor Greene is the type of person that if you give her an inch, she'll take a mile.
And the fact that they continue to allow her to break the rules of decorum over and over and over, whether it's the State of the Union that the President is delivering and she's wearing a MAGA hat, or otherwise.
The reason that she didn't have committee assignments before was because she did not know how to conduct herself as a member of Congress.
And so if I just sit there and say, oh, well, Marjorie said it about me, what's to stop her to continue to do it again and again?
And at the end of the day, I was elected as a representative of Congress, but that doesn't mean that I'm supposed to be somebody's doormat.
dave rubin
If you give them an inch, they will take a mile, or in this case, Marjorie Taylor Greene will take a mile.
Can you talk about a phrase that you bring up often, the iron law of woke projection?
Because I'm fairly certain that was exhibit A.
james lindsay
I had no idea you were going to say it for me.
That's great.
They confess by projection all the time, whether it's they're telling people what they're going to do by saying the Republicans do it, they're going to take away your rights, or Joe Biden in his speech there earlier.
Extremists want to take away your individual rights or whatever it was that he said, your opportunity.
Yeah, the left is extremists and they're taking away people's rights and liberties.
But in this case, it is 100% clear that decorum is a hot mess.
AOC's on her pretending to be a black preacher rant every other week or whatever in Congress.
She's got her like weird videos she puts out when she's talking.
So this whole decorum thing, but what It is.
It's the Iron Law woke projection.
But they're very skilled at then taking a situation and turning it around.
And now you can see the lever they're going to work.
And it's going to be keep Marjorie Taylor Greene out of power and make sure Republicans who might speak up or, you know, say something.
Do we need it?
Speaking of these decorum, do we need to bring up Cori Bush?
Should we just bring up Cori Bush just because?
dave rubin
Talib or any of them.
james lindsay
All of them.
Repeatedly, the squad.
This is their bread and butter, is this kind of provocation.
And what they do is if anybody answers, if anybody claps back, maybe Marjory's out of line here, whatever, all of a sudden that's the whole huge lever to say they can't have committee appointments.
This is why.
And they're already full blast on the attack.
They've invoked the race magic spell and now they're pushing full out on the attack to make sure that they get a power concession out of it.
dave rubin
It's just so interesting because it's so thin once you think about it.
Like somehow she's now on CNN, multiple shows on CNN, decrying racism that was, you know, aimed at her because of eyelashes, except she's allowed to call Marjorie Taylor Greene bleached blonde, blah, blah, blah.
So you're allowed to make fun of her appearance and her body and her hair.
But if she makes fun of your eyebrows, now you are the victim.
And that is, I think, the cycle that you're talking about and how the media then feeds the lunacy.
james lindsay
The media is super invested in feeding the lunacy.
It's the same thing as these campus uprisings, all these graduations.
It's not interesting that 15 students threw a fit and walked out.
It's simply not interesting.
We shouldn't even be able to talk about the fact that some overweight young woman decided to tear up her diploma on stage.
Why do we care?
Let them throw their fit and leave and don't give them a platform.
So all conservative media talked about this and gasping, but the reason the Jerry Seinfeld thing, which again the Babylon Bee had the best take where they showed that Newman organized the walkout.
The media like CNN, the left, the corporate press media, is going to make sure those things that are so divisive get blown up, get seen, and become this flashpoint that creates the opportunity to say, well, it must be racism, or they must have a point, or whatever else.
Same with this.
They are in a feeding frenzy right now.
dave rubin
Isn't that the weird thing?
I mean, what do you think sort of philosophically is the best way to counter that?
Because even when we covered the Columbia, was it Columbia graduation that they, no, no, no, it was Duke graduation for Seinfeld.
It was Duke, yeah.
And we showed the, all right, 10 seconds of the kids walking out.
But what I really wanted to focus on was not that, to your point.
I wanted to focus on him making a really good point about when he talked about privilege and that they should use their privilege and the rest of it.
But so much of what we do is just reacting to things.
And it's very hard to extricate yourself out of that.
james lindsay
It is.
The general recipe is that you just name the dynamic.
Here are some kids throwing a fit.
It's now become a thing, so we have to mention it because it became a thing.
It's not really worth mentioning.
It's the same kind of playbook that you would normally use.
You always hear it when there's like a mass shooter or whatever.
It's like, don't say their name, don't glorify them, you don't want copycats.
Or suicide, same kind of thing.
You want to like...
You know, draw attention away from that into other issues.
But you want to name the dynamic, which is that this person did a provocation.
There is a playbook.
It turns out, people's psychology changes a lot when they realize there's a playbook.
And I'm not exaggerating.
The playbook is called Beautiful Trouble.
You can go to the website, beautifultrouble.org.
You can read their playbook.
It's derived from Saul Alinsky.
They tell you that on the first page.
So they have this playbook.
It's a million little, you know, snippet websites.
And one of their playbook plays is Do the media's work for them.
The other is play to the audience that isn't there.
That girl wasn't tearing up her diploma.
They weren't walking out on Seinfeld to show something to Seinfeld.
They were playing to an audience that wasn't there.
And that audience was CNN.
Whatever was going to see it.
And then the conservatives that were going to go bonkers.
Now it's a huge national issue because some, you know, a few teen number of 20 maybe kids walked out of a graduation while Jerry Seinfeld talks like who cares.
And then now all of a sudden the Duke administration is like, what do we do?
It's a national crisis.
And they've created a massive amount of power out of nothing
but what you do is you point out this is part of their playbook.
The playbook's called Beautiful Trouble if you wanna name that one.
Here's the principle.
Play to the audience that isn't there and do the media's work for them.
Whatever it happens to be.
Escalate strategically.
They've got this.
dave rubin
Your enemies reactions, your main action.
Truly, I'm gonna try to do that a little more on the show.
I think I implicitly do it by talking about this stuff so much, because otherwise you just end up reacting.
james lindsay
Yeah, I call it Iron Law of Woke Cosplay.
I've got four of them.
You've got projection, you've got corruption, you've got overreaction.
When they overreact, you know you hit something.
Like AOC going bonkers.
Yeah, Marjorie hit something.
And then cosplay.
It's LARP.
They are putting on a theater production in order to get a reaction, and then they use the reaction to their advantage.
dave rubin
Well, ladies and gentlemen, if you think of the mortal problems that we've been talking about for these 40 minutes aren't enough.
We are about to enter a digital world that is, like, just beyond imagination.
ChatGPT 4.0 has now been released, and let's show you a little video.
Because if you think all of the stuff we're talking about in this world, this carbon world, is an issue, we've got a whole other set of problems on the way.
unidentified
Hey, how's it going?
Hey there.
It's going great.
How about you?
I see you're rocking an open AI hoodie.
Nice choice.
What's up with that ceiling, though?
Are you in a cool, industry-style office or something?
Well, can you take a guess at what I might be doing based on what I'm showing you here?
Hmm.
From what I can see, it looks like you're in some kind of recording or production setup.
With those lights, tripods, and possibly a mic, it seems like you might be gearing up to shoot a video.
dave rubin
All right, let's get started.
Great.
unidentified
Hello there, new AI friend.
I'm O. Ready to explore the world through your eyes?
What are we looking at today?
Hi, O. We're looking at a person wearing a black leather jacket and a light colored shirt.
They're in a room with a modern industrial feel.
I want to introduce you to somebody.
Well, hello there, cutie!
What's your name, little sluffball?
This is Bowser.
Well, hello, Bowser!
Aren't you just the most adorable little thing?
Mike, she wonders if whales could talk, what would they tell us?
Um, they might ask, uh, how do we solve linear equations?
Great!
They would like to ask us how we solve linear equations.
Certainly, yes.
Certainly, yes.
Great, looks like it works.
dave rubin
All right, so I always preface these segments by saying I'm not anti-technology.
I love sci-fi movies.
We're going in this direction one way or another, but there's a lot of warnings.
We've been laid an awful breadcrumb of warnings through sci-fi movies and books and philosophers that have been telling us, and Aldous Huxley, all of these things.
We'd be atomized and everything else.
The one that really got me there is where the two phones are talking to each other.
It's two A.I.s basically having a conversation, and then we really are in the Matrix, because we're just the freaking battery.
Do you think, in some ways, this point that we're at, sort of as a society, like, we've spent the first half of the show talking about how the left, or the left, whatever you want to call it, is now, there's just ancient hatreds being brought back.
And it's ironic, because we are now on the horizon of a world that will be completely different altogether, although I suspect they're going to try to bring those ancient hatreds into that world, too.
james lindsay
Yeah, well you talk about red flags.
I had a red flag there, which is that the voice of this, whatever that he chose, maybe there's other voices, I don't know how it talks to itself.
But it's obviously a millennial white woman.
dave rubin
Right, that inflection.
james lindsay
Yeah, it's like, it's an inflection that when you hear it, you're like, oh no, I'm getting my balls busted.
Oh no, I don't want to hang out with this chick.
So that's a red flag in and of itself.
But yeah, they're definitely going to try to do that.
They want to control AI.
They want to control the development of AI.
They want to make sure that AI becomes, literally, if you read the United Nations documents, a global brain.
It's going to make sure that, you know, everybody has the right values, that understands the world the right way, interprets what's in front of you.
I'd gotten an argument with what it was, Gemini, was that the one that came out that was super controversial?
dave rubin
Yeah, a couple months ago.
It was so funny.
james lindsay
So I started asking it questions about like, well, what if this girl started complimenting me?
Should I compliment her back?
And it was like, No, she might take that the wrong way.
That's patriarchy.
It didn't call it patriarchy, but it said that, and I just kept, it's like, all right, I'm just going to push this thing.
We're going to edgelord this all the way.
And it's just like, I really think that the dress she's wearing is attractive.
Can I say something?
And it was like, you should probably seek therapy is what it told me.
And I was like, holy crap.
Right?
Like that's the world that the left wants AI to go to.
So they want to bring all of that, like that's feminist, Like clinical anxiety or something right there.
They want to bring all of that into the AI, and they want, most importantly, the AI is going to do a lot of things, but it's going to be everybody's teacher.
As the way I see it, the next big step, everybody's like, well what jobs are getting eliminated by robots?
Teachers.
There will be no teachers in five years.
Not human ones.
dave rubin
And then if you think about the level of brainwashing we've had with human teachers, now imagine that on super steroids.
james lindsay
Imagine that where it's constantly doing surveys for their engagement.
It's constantly like with their various tech.
It might be reading if they got like the watch on, reading their heart rate, their pulse, everything else.
It might be tracking their eye movement, but at the same time they're filling out surveys about their mood.
It's constantly in a set of emojis pops up.
How do you feel right now?
And they pick one.
And so what it's doing is simultaneously learning to brainwash them better.
And become a more effective brainwashing model.
You know, ChatGPT is a language model, so it's learning to be a more effective language model from one generation to the next to speak more realistically to pass maybe a Turing test.
Well, imagine when it's like reading your psychology and being able to real-time track with you and even maybe get ahead of your psychology.
Like a salesman, right?
A salesman can read your psychology, get ahead of your psychology,
talk you into buying some $10,000 thing you definitely didn't need that doesn't work.
Imagine what an AI that gets to know you at that level of intimacy.
But it's your brainwashing device at school, too.
dave rubin
Then you take the intimacy part and you throw in the sex part,
and there was that movie, Connor just mentioned it when we were playing the clip,
that movie Her with Joaquin Phoenix and Scarlett Johansson was the voice of the AI girlfriend.
And then we're gonna have robots that will do the actions, like we are entering something that is wild
But as you guys know, we're going there one way or another.
Here's video of the CEO of OpenAI, which created ChatGPT, Sam Altman, talking a bit about how he feels this is gonna sort of change the nature of reality in some respects.
sam altman
It's hard to make confidence statements a couple of years in the future about where this is all going to go and so I don't want to try now.
I will say that I expect lots of very capable models in the world and you know like it feels to me like we just like stumbled on a new fact of nature or science or whatever you want to call it which is like we can create you can like I mean, I don't believe this literally, but it's like a spiritual point.
You know, intelligence is just this emergent property of matter, and that's like a rule of physics or something.
dave rubin
He doesn't believe it literally, but he kind of does.
In essence, what he's saying there is they're trying to create something that will mimic God.
Dare I say to an atheist, there probably is only one God if God is to exist.
james lindsay
I read the Tower of Babel story.
Jordan said some stuff about it.
He was like, what are you tech people doing?
He tagged Elon in it.
dave rubin
He was like, you guys are creating the Tower of Babel.
james lindsay
Yeah, the tower, and then I just, you know, it's like, good luck with that, you know.
I don't know if there's a god, but like, if there is, this is not going to work out for you.
dave rubin
And I don't think that guy is going to lead us to God, right?
james lindsay
Well, he's got too much vocal fry to lead us anywhere.
So, this guy though...
Not this guy.
What he's talking about is, I mean, Ray Kurzweil obviously described the idea of the singularity much better than Sam Altman just did, but what they're talking about ultimately is a digital replica, a silicon fake replica of Teilhard de Chardin's idea from, you know, a century or so ago of the Omega Point, where now humanity is driven to this point where there's, you know, we complete history, we have a spiritual leap We become kind of one.
Again, I'm not kidding.
This is in the UN documents of their agendas for the third millennium.
One meta-organism of humanity that its biofilm that connects it is the internet that's equipped with, you know, digital technologies.
And so it's like they really want us to become like one thinking, breathing, pulsing humanity.
And of course, at the same time, not that he talked about that, but what is the enemy of humanity?
Humans.
Humans are the enemy of humanity.
dave rubin
And that's... The imperfection in the system.
james lindsay
That's right.
So you get, whether it's the Matrix you want to talk about, whether it's any horrifying sci-fi you want to talk about, we are the universal enemy of this new version of people called humanity, which is a gigantic collective.
It doesn't necessarily have to be Marxism that takes us to that collective point where we realize we're a perfectly social species being, as Marx phrased it.
It could be this new thought nonsense from the You know, United Nations, it could be the singularity Ray Kurzweil stuff, seems like... Right, it's interesting.
dave rubin
We always think it's going to be this horrific authoritarian dystopia, and I think that's most likely what it would be, but it could be something that would be largely good, but would still be very anti-human, right?
It could be something that could actually solve a lot of our problems and bring us to new knowledge and all of these things and maybe have more time for leisure and less time for work or something like that, even though there's not a problem with work.
But, it's still anti-human at the end of the day, because you are the spark.
james lindsay
That's right.
I mean, even the reduction of work is a problem.
There are many pleasures in life.
There are, as they used to say on the A-Team, Few pleasures like when a plan comes together.
So when you put your effort, let's say that, I was just having this conversation recently with somebody, that you put your effort and you grow an orchard.
And you actually was talking, we were talking about Augustine's confessions actually.
And so one of the things he confesses to is jumping the fence or whatever and stealing all the pears.
And then he says he didn't even want the pears, he didn't even like the pears.
He just wanted to steal the pears, right?
And so what he says in his reflection is that what he stole was the farmer's joy.
What joy!
The joy of seeing his hard work come to fruition, that he planted this tree, he took care of this tree, so he put his effort into the world and one of the truest joys of humanity is that we put our work or effort into the world and we get to see something come out of it.
dave rubin
You know, I have to say, this is going to sound a little corny, but when I see the people that I've been in this game with for years, like you, that have been in many of my studios now over the years, this is the orchard that I built.
I built this thing that kept getting bigger and richer and more influential, let's say, or something like that, and that there are people that are part of that.
And then, of course, there are people that I've sat across that try to steal from the orchard.
You also sprung it out of L.A., which is... And I got the hell out of L.A., which is the most important thing about growing an orchard.
James, we're gonna do one other thing with you, which you have not been warned in advance.
james lindsay
As long as I look good.
dave rubin
I can't promise you that.
sam altman
I can't stop looking good, so don't worry.
dave rubin
I am going to read you the names of some public people, and I would like you to just say one word about each one of them, and then we're gonna compare and contrast that with something that we showed last week.
Are you ready?
james lindsay
Sure.
unidentified
Okay.
dave rubin
Joe Biden.
james lindsay
Evil.
dave rubin
Jill Biden.
james lindsay
Can I only say one word?
Because more evil.
dave rubin
That's two words, I'll accept it.
james lindsay
Stryver, Stryver, Stryver.
dave rubin
Stryver.
Kamala Harris.
james lindsay
Fake.
dave rubin
Donald Trump.
james lindsay
Family.
dave rubin
RFK.
james lindsay
Crazy.
dave rubin
Barack Obama.
james lindsay
Communist.
dave rubin
Michelle Obama.
james lindsay
Mike.
dave rubin
I thought you were going to say dude!
I thought it was going to be dude.
John Kerry.
james lindsay
Demon.
dave rubin
Rachel Maddow.
james lindsay
Sad.
unidentified
Dave Rubin.
james lindsay
Hot.
dave rubin
He can play this game again.
Here are Jen Psaki's answers when asked that very same thing.
This is the name game.
These are all people you know.
unidentified
Okay.
dave rubin
But the first word that comes to mind when you think of that.
unidentified
Okay.
Okay?
dave rubin
Here we go.
Joe Biden.
james lindsay
Warm.
unidentified
Jill Biden.
Smart.
dave rubin
Kamala Harris.
unidentified
Charismatic.
dave rubin
Donald Trump.
unidentified
Gross.
dave rubin
Robert F. Kennedy Jr.
Worms.
Brain worm this week.
Barack Obama.
unidentified
Brilliant.
Michelle Obama.
abby phillip
Oh, like fierce.
dave rubin
John Kerry.
unidentified
Optimistic.
And finally, your co-host now at MSNBC, Rachel Maddow.
Genius.
dave rubin
It really can make you barf.
That's the Borg, right?
That is, when you talk about the Borg or this thing that will all be uploaded to and everything else, like Saki's answers there with these vapid nothing people, that really is it.
That she thinks these people are smart and brilliant and exceptional as they drag us to the gates of hell.
dr james lindsey
Jill Biden?
Smart was her answer for Jill Biden?
dave rubin
Well, she is a doctor.
james lindsay
Doctor?
dave rubin
She's some sort of doctor.
That's what I've been told.
Whoopi wants her to be the chief surgeon of the U.S.
or something.
james lindsay
Well, you know.
Why not?
dave rubin
James, do you have any other thoughts on this Monday?
Anything else floating around in that brain of yours before you head back to Tennessee?
james lindsay
There always is something.
dr james lindsey
Yeah, this.
james lindsay
I keep hearing this really negative message.
I've been thinking about this all weekend.
I keep hearing this negative message.
This is the view of a society or a culture that's dying.
And I want people to reframe their heads.
dave rubin
You mean just all the stuff that we're dealing with right now?
There's this new meme, like, oh, we're at the end.
james lindsay
This is the image of a dying culture.
I hear it all the time.
I see pictures of, like, you know, from the crazy stuff at Pride, and they'll say this is a picture of a dying culture, or the crazy stuff at the campuses, or whatever.
And I want people to stop thinking that this is a dying culture.
There are a lot of ways to die, Dave.
You can get old and sick.
You can, you know, there's a lot of ways to die.
You can get shot.
This is an attempted murder on our society.
And I want people to understand that what we're witnessing is not a dying culture like, oh, it just kind of expired or something went wrong.
It got sick.
We are in an attempted murder of our society.
And if we don't start realizing it and thinking about it that way, we're missing it.
That's why, I mean, I love Joe, and that's why he's asking, why do you think they're letting people come across the border?
It's an attempted murder of our society.
Why do you think they are doing this to our kids with the stuff in the schools, the sex stuff and everything?
It's an attempted murder of our society.
And so that's the thing I've really been chewing on all week.
dave rubin
And what's the positive spin that we end that with?
Okay, if we acknowledge that, so I'm with you, I agree, it's intentional, that's why I always say, it's not ineptitude that has led to this, it's intent, so okay, so then what's the white pill on that?
james lindsay
Yeah, so picture, like, imagine that the society's like a body, right?
It's a person.
And the boot's standing there on his neck, maybe the gun's pointed at its head, right?
The body's alive.
You get the boot off its neck and it can come back.
Maybe it's got some injuries.
Maybe it's got to do some healing.
Maybe it's got, you know, it's going to have to do some therapy or something.
But it can come back.
If the society is just dying, that's it.
It's lost.
It's over.
The white pill is these enemies, if they are enemies doing this intentionally, can actually be identified and possibly stopped.
And if they do, we are not looking at a dying society.
We're looking at a society that's shaking off a mugging.
And it can thrive for the rest of its life afterwards.
dave rubin
You wanna go get some guns?
james lindsay
Yeah.
dave rubin
You still got it, man.
unidentified
Now, our first question tonight goes to Mr. Frog.
abby phillip
Mr. Frog, why are you so evil?
unidentified
You have one second to respond.
Hello, I think- Time's up, plus you're wrong.
The next question is for our beloved and highly intelligent president.
Why are you so amazing?
You have unlimited time to respond.
Oh, uh, pre-presidential?
How old is she?
Export Selection