David Menzies and Andrew Chapatos critique the Emergencies Act Inquiry as a "whitewash," citing limited press access (20 seats for 50) and omissions like frozen bank accounts and gas canister use during the truckers’ convoy. They mock Halton’s school board over "Busty Lemieux" impersonations, 16K+ petition rejections, and alleged misgendering of Curtis Innes while pushing anti-"wokeism" activism ahead of Ontario’s Oct. 24 elections. Meanwhile, Alex Jones faces a $980M Sandy Hook lawsuit, raising concerns about excessive legal penalties for conspiracy theories, though the host doubts its impact. Contrasting AOC’s Ukraine arms vote with her anti-war rhetoric, they accuse her of hypocrisy and enabling "Nazis," framing her as an establishment-aligned progressive. Alan Honor joins to challenge the government’s legal justification for invoking the Emergencies Act, questioning its legitimacy and public order claims. [Automatically generated summary]
The Alberta Prosperity Project has a solution for you.
Join the community and learn more at AlbertaprosperityProject.com.
And with you on board, we can achieve freedom and prosperity for all of us.
Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen.
You have tuned into the Rebel News live stream on this, a Thursday, October 13th, 2022.
I'm David Menzies and my co-host.
Well, folks, let me tell you a little bit about my co-host.
Please do.
Yes, I shall.
Do you know that today is National No Bra Day?
Wow.
And my co-host and I celebrated it yesterday.
I did it in a bigger fashion, however.
He is the warrior of Whitby.
He is the Khalese of Durham Region.
He is high energy Andrew Chapatos.
How you doing there, my friend?
I'm doing well, David Menzies.
I don't know why.
I don't live in Whitby, but I am from Durham.
Same thing.
Whitby.
Ajax, Kickering.
Yeah, the whole thing.
I will be heading.
I almost said heteroing all this talk about the teacher.
How dare you misgender me?
Yeah, exactly.
I will be heading down to the Dirty Schwab, I think, next week to investigate the.
They've got a noise box underneath a bridge to keep homeless people away.
It emits a high-pitched noise.
So I'm sure I'll be interacting with some lovely homeless and or high-intensity drug users while I'm down there.
Why would they stay there when John Torrey at the city of Toronto has the entire Novatel hotel available for them on the Esplanade, which, by the way, folks has made the life a living hell for the taxpaying citizens who live in the Esplanade and the businesses?
Crime is rampant, drug paraphernalia anyways.
But hey, I think the Novatel, that must have been at least a three and a half, four-star hotel.
I don't know why they just don't commute a little westward.
Well, maybe we could get one of those high-transmitting noise emitters to deter you from coming here as well.
I would love that.
And also, we're going to get right into your cross-dressing in a moment.
Oh, right off the bat.
But my show had a little bit of a new format.
We filmed it yesterday, and it actually ended with David Menzies as Kayla Lemieux being interviewed by Ben Bankus, who's also dressed up as her and done videos with Alex Stein, for example, out of the U.S.
So we had two impersonators of Kayla Lemieux doing a video together, and that's only on Rebel News Plus tonight.
Yes.
Don't you dare miss it, as Billy Red Lions used to say.
But before we get into the shenanigans, Andrew, usually my beloved co-host, Sheila Gunn Reed, lays down the rules.
I can do this.
There has to be rules, even when you're dealing with YouTube based in the U.S., which of course is governed by the First Amendment, you know, that silly free speech thing.
So this entity, which has already demonetized us, we don't want to be de-platformed because, you know, I've said this before, Andrew Chapatoz, you might know what I'm speaking of.
My relationship with YouTube is kind of like my relationship here in the GTA as a commuter with Highway 407.
My God, I love how it moves me.
And I'm never in gridlock.
But wow, do I get a nice surprise at the end of the month when my bill comes, right?
So it's a love-hate.
And much like YouTube, we have over 1.5 million subscribers.
That's fantastic.
That's great reach, but they're a governor In terms of what we can say and can't say, indeed, they are, David Manzies.
We're on YouTube, we're on Rumble, we're on Getter and Odyssey, and on Rumble and Odyssey, you can send us chats, uh, Odyssey hyper chats, and Rumble rants if you want to ask us questions, uh, give comments, links, suggestions.
There's always insults for me, I implore them.
I love it when you guys do that.
Ask David Manzies about old movies or Planet of the Apes, we often talk about for some reason.
Anything you want, really, and you can send it through a hyper chat or a Rumble Ramp.
By the way, sorry to interrupt, Andrew, but that I think was your greatest tweet ever.
It really made my day when you sent out a tweet saying, I have just learned more than I ever wanted about the Planet of the Apes movie series, thanks to a five-minute discussion.
It's not the mess.
That's not more than I ever wanted to.
I'm interested in these.
See, I didn't know there was an underground underground society in the old Planet of the Apes movies.
I've only seen all the new ones and then segments of the old ones on TV.
I never watched one of the old ones entirely.
Transphobia At Oakville Trafalgar00:16:00
The costumes are so bad.
Oh, I disagree.
No, no, no, no.
Wait a minute.
We're going back to the original Planet of the Apes, 1968.
Those monkey masks took about five hours to put on.
Remember, you see, you grew up in the day and age of CGI.
I'm old school.
You had to do the stunts with stuntmen.
You had to do makeup.
You couldn't.
Well, I don't want to give away the ending of Planet of the Apes, but they had to build a certain structure, not CGI it into the beach.
So, Andrew, I totally disagree.
That was a groundbreaking movie in terms of makeup.
I'm actually not a huge CGI guy, and I'm a huge fan of the original Ninja Turtles, which is costumes with animatronic heads.
So, there was actual ninjas inside the costumes, sweating to death, performing all these athletics.
I walked out of that movie.
You walked out of it so bad.
It's so bad.
I feel the best one of all Cisco and Ebert right now.
That's insane.
Let's move on before.
So, tell us what you did yesterday.
You came in as Kayla Lemieux to my set, and we interviewed you.
That's on Rebel News Plus tonight.
Then, what happened?
Where did you go?
Okay, so the backstory here, folks, is there is a shop teacher called Carrie Luc Lemieux, now going by Lemieux.
Oh, indeed.
And it's made worldwide headlines.
Not so much the local media because the local media, they champion radical transgenderism, but even they, even they know something's not right here.
So, instead of investigating this story like we're doing, they're ignoring the story.
So, yeah, your tax dollar is hard at work.
There's been a few exceptions.
There's been a story here and there in the National Post and the Toronto Sun.
But it comes down to this: this man is wearing giant prosthetic breasts.
He is breaking every shop rule in the book.
These breasts are barely contained by see-through blouses.
You know, the nipples are apparent.
If that was a female student at Oakville, Trafalgar High School, folks, she would be suspended.
Guess what?
The dress code does not apply to the faculty.
How does that make sense?
But here's the deal: there are three possible explanations for this.
One, this is a male genuinely transitioning to a female.
I reject that because I think those in the trans community, whether you're going male to female or female to male, you're doing it in a subtle fashion, wouldn't you say, Andrew?
You want to blend in.
You don't want to come across as a grotesque caricature of a female, someone that would be at home at a drag queen show.
So I discount that.
That leaves us with two other theories.
There's been chatter on social media about this individual.
He's allegedly anti-woke and anti-gender neutral bathrooms.
He's spoken out about it, allegedly, and has had his wrist slapped by the school board.
And so the allegation is, oh, okay, you want to go all woke?
Check out this.
And that's the reason for the ensemble.
The only other option is mental illness, Andrew.
Well, then.
That he, and if it is mental illness, we have to treat him.
We have to give him psychiatric help.
Should be a teacher at all, I think, based on any of these scenarios.
Yeah, but whatever the case may be, it's a completely inappropriate wardrobe.
And the parents are upset.
But this Halton District School Board, it might be the most woke and most incompetent school board in the province.
And given that the Toronto District School Board is part of the province, that's saying something.
So I decided, because it kicked me out when I went there at the last meeting, and they were so triggered, they actually canceled last week's meeting.
So last night, I went there.
I said, hey, you know, in for a pound, or sorry, in for a penny, in for a pound.
Let's go tit to tat, so to speak.
Let me get something off my chest.
Okay, that's enough boob metaphors.
So without further ado, I went there to deliver a petition that was signed by more than 16,000 of you to stop this perversity going on at Oakville Trafalgar School.
And let's see how the board reacted yet again.
Can you believe the transphobia here, folks?
Can you believe it?
I'm trying to deliver a petition.
Which one of you is going to take it?
Which one of you is going to take it?
What's that?
For you to leave the room.
Why?
Why did you show that?
No normal person in a right mind would dress up like that and go teach kids.
Come on.
Are you guys okay in your head?
Why is Oak Joe's becoming the mockery of the world?
What's wrong with you guys?
Come on.
Stop this.
Get this teacher out of here.
Shut him out of that school by Monday for sure.
What are you going to do?
Who's going to take this?
Who's going to take this?
Who is going to take this petition?
Can you believe?
I have so many questions, David.
First of all, I'll answer the first one you're going to ask because I'm a bit of a mentalist.
Those are Zed Cups.
Okay, no, I wasn't.
Were there any objections to letting you in at the door?
You know, it's funny.
Somebody, despite that wardrobe, recognized me as David Menzies and said, you're supposed to sign in because you're media.
And I said, how dare you dead name me?
I am not.
I am not that person anymore.
And he didn't do anything.
That's why I just waltzed in.
What was your new, what is your new name?
Memory Menzoid.
You know, there's many comments on the Instagram version of this video that think that it is the teacher that showed up.
That is spectacular.
You know, actually, Andrew, I got to tell you, for a security reason, I had that in the back of my head because I thought, what if there's some father who is so outraged?
He thinks I am Busty Lemieux and I get a haymaker.
But yeah, it was, I'll admit, Busty Lemieux is skinnier than I am.
But I guess when you have Zed cup breasts, a white sheer top and bicycle shorts, yeah, I can understand why people would get confused.
Well, you might want to start turning this into a real life, you know, a bit in the real world.
You're walking around, you're getting groceries, and all of a sudden there's going to be guerrilla footage of what they think is the teacher.
Really, it was David Menzies the whole time, you guys, is what it turns out.
But, you know, here's the thing.
This Halton District School Board has hoisted itself on its own petard, Andrew, because how can they tolerate Busty Lemieux in a school that is full of minors and yet somehow ban me from attending a school board meeting that is full of adults?
And the answer is they can't, but they only had a certain amount of tolerance, Andrew, because they all fled the building for the second time because evidently a thought crime at Halton District School Board is asking an impolite question.
And all I needed was for one of them to take delivery of that petition that has the more than 16,000 signatures of it on it.
They would not do so.
And I also had a couple of questions.
One is, forget about transgenderism.
As I said earlier, Andrew, how does a man teaching shop break every safety etiquette rule?
No shop glasses, you know, on, those breasts coming close to circular saws, long sleeves.
These are all no-nos.
So forget about the ministry, the long hair, exactly, not in a hairnet or a bun.
So forget about this being a ministry of education, it's a ministry of labor.
You couldn't get a pink shirt.
Better.
No, it's you won't believe how troublesome it is to find clothing that fits Zed breasts.
Secondly, and this is very important, for several days when this originally broke in the news cycle around the world, this disgusting, despicable, horrible Halton District School Board purposely allowed another teacher at the Oakville Trafalgar High School folks by the name of Stephen Hanna to be misidentified as Mr. Lemieux.
And, you know, we even have the proof.
I interviewed the director of education, Curtis Innes, he, him.
And when I was doing so, he was more concerned about me not misgendering Mr. Lemieux by calling him he.
But when I used the names Hannah and Lemieux, he had ample opportunity, as did Dr. Shuttleworth, as did the school, which I phoned and they hung up on me, to say, no, Menzies, your facts are wrong.
Hannah and Lemieux are two different people.
And I say, Andrew, this was done on purpose.
They wanted misinformation to go out there into the media to basically say, look, these guys can't get their facts right, but they could have corrected this long before this got into the news cycle, and they chose not to.
So those two questions plus the delivery of my petition, I didn't get my questions answered.
Nobody took my petition.
They left the building.
The parents were told to leave, and then they were locked out of the school board.
That's your tax dollars at work.
And by the way, where was the director of education last night, Curtis Innes, he him?
Where was that woaxter, that jokester?
He was too cowardly to even show his face.
And this is a guy, high six figures, drives a Tesla, and he has no accountability to the taxpayers.
But you know what?
What do you think, my friend?
Do we go back next week or whenever the next meeting is?
I'm glad you're pursuing this.
It's a story that I don't think should just be swept under the rug as much as they like.
And I like how city council members, school board members, they're so arrogant in their position.
Not all of them, of course, but certainly in this instance and in other ones we've seen, they're just like, oh, something's happening.
We don't like, we're just leaving.
We don't have any, we're paid by taxpayers, but we don't have any duty to stick this out and hear concerns or people using their voice against us.
We just can we can just leave.
Oh, our job isn't required, like we, but we'll get paid, of course.
Andrew, 100%.
Uh, the school board said if any parents have questions, and there were a lot of parents there that were angry parents that wanted answers to this ongoing freak show, which, by the way, even though that's in the newspapers the world over from India to Australia, that is not only not the lead agenda item, it's not even on the agenda.
Not even on the agenda.
Like, you know, nothing to see here, folks, right?
It's like Baghdad Bob back in the day saying, the Americans are not advancing the invasion.
You see a U.S. B-52 bomber drowning him out as it flies over his head.
So the thing is, they said, write down your questions, and they would vet the questions.
Of course.
And they would choose which ones to answer and which ones not.
And it would happen at about the three-hour mark of the meeting.
Oh, no, no, no, no.
Don't you dare show this kind of disrespect, you miserable trustees at the Halton board.
You are despicable.
The people in that room pay your salaries.
It's not the other way around.
You serve them.
They don't serve you.
Don't treat them with disrespect anymore.
And yeah, darn it.
I'm going back.
So zero progress on the story at all.
They have no response to anything so far.
They hope it is going to go away.
The only thing I've heard from my sources is that behind the scenes, I guess they're reaching out to the union.
There might be a matter where the union has to be consulted.
But they're looking at addressing the dress code issue for teachers, right?
If that is the case, Andrew, and they should be looking at this, why not be transparent?
Why not say that?
Why is everything being done in a star chamber at Halton District?
And the last thing I want to say is, you know, folks, October 24th, that's the municipal elections in Ontario.
They will be horribly attended.
The voting turnout will be horribly low, as usual, especially when it comes to the position of school trustee.
Here's what I'm asking of you.
Reach out to the candidates and the incumbents, wherever you live in Ontario, when it comes to school board trustee, and find out where they stand on this issue.
Find out where they stand on wokeism and critical race theory and Marxism and radical transgenderism.
You know, Andrew, last year, that's what happened in Virginia.
And the school trustee position is the absolute lowest elected position in our democracy and in the U.S.
And yet, what happened in Virginia?
Mama Bear woke up and they came en masse.
They were tired of CRTC and CRT rather and critical race theory and transgenderism and Marxism being shoved down their kids' throats.
And from that grassroots movement, the Democratic incumbent who was considered to be a lock to get re-elected, McAuliffe, he lost to the Republican Yunkin.
So what I'm saying is even at the various lowest levels, if you care and if you come out and make your views known, you can have change at the highest level.
Well, that's so much going on there, David.
I hope it continues to go exactly how you want it to go.
Well, yeah, well, how do you want it to go?
I want the guy, I want the whole school board to be fired.
I want the teacher to be fired.
I want the principal of the school to be fired.
I want everybody who's above this teacher in any sort of seniority, whether it's superintendent or comp troller or whatever.
I'm not up to, I'm not boned up on my school board positioning.
There's a punchline just dying to be said there, but I let it go past home plate.
They should all be fired.
If you hear about this story, oh, there's a guy wearing giant prosthetic breasts teaching our kids.
If your thought is not, well, if that's true, let's fire him, then you're an insane person, or you're just so crippled by your lack of freedom of speech.
And this is something I had to teach Ben Banks about yesterday, taking him out to do streeters.
He's like, nobody wants to talk.
They're all crippled by not being able to speak.
And I'm just like, welcome to journalism, David.
Well, you know, it depends on where you go.
I'll tell you this, Andrew.
Hopefully you didn't go to the corner of King and Bay.
I did Young and Dundas.
Oh, that's a good place because King and Bay, it's all these Armeni wearing stockbrokers and bankers, and their time is so precious to them.
They don't even say no comment or I don't have the time.
They just swat you away like you're a mosquito or something.
Worst intersection in Canada to do a streeter.
But before we go on to compare how transgenderism is okay 24-7 in schools, but Halloween one day a year is not, we got to run an ad, folks.
Cancel Culture Fears00:09:18
Check it out.
Summer.
Summer is over.
Some are even saying it might never return.
According to the prime minister, this is no time to be joking around.
In Switzerland, they're saying you'll own nothing and you'll be happy.
German guy.
Germany.
Germany never did anything wrong.
Not that I can recall.
Just like the doc set, don't ever go to 2020.
My dad, 30 years.
Dr. Fauci.
Yeah, it must have been him.
Dr. Fauci, give us next scene.
If freedom isn't free, but it has the word free in it, is freedom dumb?
What f ⁇ ing freedom have you lost?
What freedom have you lost?
Twelve feet in the cost.
I lost my money because I haven't slept in 20 f ⁇ ing days.
Maybe it is.
But at times like these, we can only look to our leaders to get us out of it.
Well, you know, Andrew, great ad.
Great spot.
That wasn't me.
Oh, okay, then.
How my hair is and look how thin I am.
Well, you do look dapper with that hat on, I must say.
I think it was you, but that clip of Justin Trudeau dancing.
I never know if that's the real Justin Trudeau dancing clip or the Radio Canada parody of him, which was just spot on.
And of course, they got vilified and crucified for mocking the sugar daddy that way.
But if you Google that, assuming you can still find it on the internet, when the French service of CBC did a parody of that, you really couldn't tell the difference what the real dance number was versus the satirical one.
Remember Canadian Heritage Moments?
Somebody needs to start paying for ads.
Doing paid ads of doing Trudeau Heritage Moments.
We've got a question related to the teacher, as I'm told.
Okay, then.
Well, super producer Olivia.
Still having TV troubles.
I think I have it on my phone here.
Well, the only reporter that's going to be able to read that type is Clark Kent.
Unfortunately, that's neither.
I have it here.
Don't worry.
Yeah.
Okay, Judah Bursey says, enough of Lemieux.
If the parents had any backbone, they would all keep their children out of school.
On a different note, I like Andrew's haircut.
Well, thank you.
Yeah, you are looking sharp.
I'm always sharp.
You know what?
That's a great point.
They should do that.
I would also say this: why not have all the students wear massive fake breasts, male, female?
They're expensive, aren't they?
And make sure, well, but you can just stick balloons in there and just make sure you're covered up because as we said earlier, there's a dual standard dress code.
So you won't be able to have protruding nipples or show cleavage or spaghetti straps, none of that.
But, you know, just wear enormous breasts covered by, hey, how about a burqa?
And man, you're going to get the.
The kids aren't brave enough for this.
Oh, well, you know what?
And I mean, they want, you know, they evidently understand the school is a shamble.
Sorry, that shop class is a shambles.
Kids aren't attending.
They're goofing around in there.
And how is that acceptable either?
But I would say the reason why parents are terrified to take their kids out, Andrew, is because in our woke cancel culture of political correctness, there is a fear that somebody will be outed.
And if that person has a business, guess what?
You know, the LGBTQ mafia does a boycott, does a demonstration there.
We know we live in cancel culture.
That's my theory as to why parents aren't doing such a move.
But I would do it.
Let's do the rest of the chats now and then people can send in more.
Excellent.
Conservative Gen Z says for $10.
Hashtag no bra day is trending on Twitter currently.
The timing is impeccable.
Also, the second I saw David yesterday, I said to myself, oh, look, it's David Menzies before I saw his face.
Well, you know, Rebecca, you either have superb eyesight or enhanced woman's intuition because as we discussed, there are people on social media saying, oh, the audacity, Busty Lemieu show.
How could they get it wrong?
How could that be Busty Lemieux trying to deliver a petition, getting hopefully trying to get Busty Lemieux fighting?
People don't watch things before commenting.
It's sad.
Canada Fun for $20 says, David, that video of you was so funny.
A great look.
Keep up the good work.
Well, believe me, my friend, inside, I was crying.
Annalisa S. Annalisa 1964 says for $20.
Hi, Andrew, and big hello to my sweet Menzies.
Oh, you know, Annalisa, do you still feel that way given my alter ego now?
Do you?
And there's also one from Shauna Marie, G83 from yesterday, who's talking about emailing us a link to Dr. Hodgkinson's reference.
So thank you for that.
There wasn't time to get to it, or it was missed somehow yesterday.
But keep your hyper chats and rumble rants coming.
We will read them throughout the show.
Now we've got Halloween Outrage.
If you want to pull that up, Olivia, Parents Speak Up after Pennsylvania School District cancels kids' outdoor costume parades.
You know about this story?
Yeah.
And basically, you know, they're really lacking because I remember back when I was a freelancer, this is early 2000s.
I had a commentary in the National Post, and it was about the six reasons why Halloween is not so much fun, according to, well, yeah, you guessed it, the Toronto District School Board, the former breeding ground of Curtis Innes He Him of Halting District.
And it was so ludicrous.
It was that, you know, you might scare someone.
There's a socioeconomic thing.
Some kids can't afford really good costumes or their parents can't afford to buy candy.
It was a school board, again, like this Pennsylvania one, seeking to fix a problem that doesn't exist.
That's what these guys do.
That's how they justify their salaries.
Now, fast forward some 20 years, and here's the angle I think.
When you have this Pennsylvania school board that says no more outdoor costume parades, that you know, that that's offensive for some bizarre and baffling reason.
And yet, these schools will tell a minor, little Andrew, do you feel like Andrea?
Well, that's okay.
Sometimes wear a dress.
We can look.
We don't need your parental consent.
We'll look at a hospital that might be able to slice and dice your genitalia and give you hormones.
And so what I'm saying, folks, is that we have a society where a child, a minor, can pretend to be a member of the opposite sex 24-7, and it's not only allowed, it's actually encouraged.
And yet, that one day of a year where a kid wants to be, I don't know, the werewolf or Dracula or Frankenstein, oh my goodness, no, we can't have that.
How do you make sense of this, Andrew?
You can't at all.
And like you said about the school trustee position, parents just have to start standing up.
You're able to overcome it.
They have this big story out of Tennessee where Matt Walsh from the Daily Wire was calling out the university there for their gender transition hospital that they have or clinic, whatever they wish to call it.
And they've actually ceased operations on children since this whole fiasco.
So the power of the media in a good sense, we all hate the media, even though we're a part of it, because 99% of them are crying online every day.
I get so many mean comments on Twitter and emails.
Yeah, boohoo.
But there is a place for good journalism and activism that goes alongside with it.
And if parents want to actually step up in Canada, like they do in places currently like Arizona and Virginia, like you spoke about, and so many other places where they've actually done it.
And Alex Stein, who's a comedian that a lot of people, he rubs the wrong way, but he's shown up at school boards and made mockeries of them.
PayPal's Pay Pirate Controversy00:02:26
And this is unfortunately some of the route you have to do, just like you did yesterday.
You have to make fun of these people into the ground.
They weren't bullied enough as children.
But, you know, Andrew, on your point of taking a stance, I think this is crucially important to get the pendulum swinging back the other way.
Yes, there is canceled culture out there, but what are we going to do?
Live up to the motto, all that's necessary for evil to take lease, is for good men to do nothing.
And there are success stories out there.
I was guest hosting for Ezra last night.
My monologue was on PayPal becoming pay pirate on the weekend.
And look what happened, folks.
If you don't know the story, PayPal decided upon itself that, and it has something like 429 million users and merchants, that if they didn't like something you posted on social media, they were going to fine you $2,500 U.S. Can you imagine?
And I mean, the first question is, how can you justify such a huge fine?
And the more important question, I should think, is who determines at PayPal, a financial conduit, what is and is not acceptable speech.
I think going by our friends at YouTube probably questioning the results of the 2020 election.
Oh, no, no, no, that's $2,500, please.
Although feel free to question the results of the 2016 U.S. federal election.
And of course, anytime you question the official COVID narrative, that's another $2,500 out of your bank account.
Here's the thing, folks.
There was so much outrage about this that PayPal quickly went into damage control mode.
They lied.
They said, well, this was never meant to be policy.
It was in the terms and conditions.
You know, those pages and pages of legalese we never read and we just say accept.
But somebody did read it and somebody found it.
I also think this, Andrew, PayPal probably thought in this climate we're in, not only would this be accepted, but it would be applauded by the usual suspects in the usual certain circles.
And lo and behold, people en masse were canceling their PayPal accounts.
The stock price, the last I looked, went down 6% overnight.
Big, big money there.
PayPal's Woke Policy00:03:39
And suddenly, no, this is not going to be a thing.
We're so sorry.
We're so sorry.
Mia Culpa, me a culpa.
Andrew, that's just one example of standing up to an outrageous example of wokeism.
And guess what?
We won.
It's this tried and tested story of just do nothing and everything will be fine, I guess.
I implore anyone watching to look up the words of their local school board, whatever region it is, and then put diversity, equity, and inclusion after.
And you'll find that you're paying tax dollars towards, you know, as Kanye West puts it, as a BLM hall monitor has been hired to, you know, in Whitby, as you mentioned, they had a racialized Easter egg hunt.
What?
Yeah.
Can we find that story?
It was diversity Easter egg hunt or sorry, diversity treasure hunt.
Let me guess, and I might be wrong.
If you're a white heterosexual male, you're excluded.
I don't know if that was the explicit rule.
What you're supposed to do is you go around find treasures, I guess, that we're supposed to teach you about diversity and black history and stuff.
Oh, we have that.
I see.
So instead of actually getting an Easter egg that you could eat and enjoy, you know, like one of those Laura Secord specials, you get some wokeism.
There we go.
Throw that up, Olivia.
Yeah, there you go.
Region of Durham under fire for events of Black History Month scavenger hunt for employees.
So they try so hard to be like, well, it's diversity.
And then some blue-haired white woman is like, this is what we need.
Let's make $100,000 for that position.
And I see they've accepted the new style rule, folks, where black is uppercase, but not white.
And somehow that's justified.
You know, Andrew, I got to tell you, my beloved bride, Lady Menzoid, moved from South Africa to Toronto.
It was a high school student.
Well, that was the accent she has.
Indeed, it is, not Australian.
And they gave up a good life and they gave it all up because they found the system of apartheid absolutely reprehensible, which it was.
I mean, in fact, it's almost like that Jerry Seinfeld line.
If professional wrestling didn't exist, it would be impossible to invent it, right?
And the idea that whites would be the, have all the rights and privileges, and the majority members of the country, namely blacks and colored people, as they were called then, would be second-class citizens in their own nation.
It's preposterous.
And what I see happening here is what my wife's family fled from, Andrew, it's coming back.
Of course.
It is a version of apartheid.
This sort of garbage that's coming into universities, employment offices, school boards, you name it.
If Martin Luther King Jr. were alive today, this would make him vomit.
This is not what he stood for.
He wanted equality.
He didn't want a kind of a reverse apartheid.
And yet, again and again, that is what we are seeing here.
It is completely racist, but the woke left progressive, actually, that's too kind for them.
The Marxists don't want equality.
They subscribe to, let's tear down society, build it back up as a Marxist utopia, which never happens, of course.
And that's really, I think, what's at play here.
Police, Disinfo, and Casualties00:14:48
Wolfies, talk about any of that stuff.
The left wing would have killed him sooner.
But go take a look at the other people in that movement and see why they needed to use Martin Luther King.
They were talking about Kale and Whitey a lot, especially the prominent women in that movie movement.
Anyway, go ahead.
So I believe we have another ad break because I see super producer Olivia teasing it.
And check out the new kind of merchandise you can buy from our wonderful Rebel News store, folks.
Well, again, folks, Christmas will be here before you know it.
Get those orders in as soon as you can.
Lots of lovely merchandise.
Now, oh, speaking of lovely, the Emergencies Act Inquiry kicks off today.
On one hand, that's a good thing.
On the other hand, Andrew, my spidey sense is tingling.
Is this what they call in the UK, a stitch-up, a whitewash?
That's not just your spidey sense tingling, David Menzies.
How dare you?
Some sort of serious illness.
Rebel News has a huge team in Ottawa there right now.
There are lawyers for other organizations in Ottawa right now.
People are watching.
So this is a huge deal because this is the truckers.
Bank accounts frozen.
Alexa shot with gas canister.
Woman trampled by horse.
Trucks destroyed.
Gas cans taken from people who were trying to help people stay warm at night.
Horns were honked.
That was then banned.
You forgot the biggest crime against humanity.
Bell Media's soyboy, Solomon, was called a soyboy.
And oh, yes.
Oh, wait a minute.
I haven't heard your fervor, if that's the correct word, against him before.
Yeah, I'm sorry.
That's kind of, I misnamed him because last week was his final day at Bell Media.
Really?
He is now working at the same outfit that Gerald Butts is the, I think, vice chairman of Eurasia Group.
I didn't know he was that bad.
Oh, yeah, he's in New York City.
It's like, see you later, suckers.
There's no sense pretending I'm a non-biased person.
I thought he was a staunch, believable conservative, you know, who's just going to take back the country and, you know, help Alberta become free.
Yeah.
No, money talks and you know what walks.
But in this case, it is you know what walking and talking.
So, yeah, it's kind of funny how mainstream media who had verbal insults delivered their way that caused them, like Evan Solomon and Rachel Crymore to roll up.
Soyloman.
Yeah, Soyliman.
But he's out of the journalism shtick.
But yeah, here's the thing.
Andrew, I said my spidey sentences were tingling about the stitch-up.
Our beloved colleague Sheila Gunread raised this in the morning meeting today.
Folks, there are enough seats in the press gallery area to accommodate 50 journalists, but only 20 are being allowed in.
Why?
There is massive interest in this very important inquiry.
Why are they limiting the number of journalists that can cover it by more than half?
Because then they'd have to let more than just CBC and CTV and global news in because they're not going to send that many people.
The way the mainstream media doesn't think that this is anything is the way that I would think that, you know, like George Floyd isn't a big deal.
That's right.
I said it.
So if you look at it from that perspective or choose anything that you don't think is a big deal that the mainstream media on the left in the U.S. or Canada covers with all eyes on and says this is the biggest deal of all time.
That's how they view it as the Commission.
They view it as it's not a big deal.
The government was right to lock us down.
They were right to seize the assets and the bank accounts of people, you know, putting money towards this terrible thing.
And there were casualties, but that's going to happen.
Just like it happens in socialism, David Benzies.
There's just going to be casualties of the state.
There's no avoiding that.
It's just for the greater good of COVID prosperity.
What's this video we have, Olivia?
Let's play this and we'll see how we feel about it.
This is the inquiry starting off.
Everybody's there.
Sheila's there.
I think Ezra is heading down.
William Diaz, as we call him, Big Willie style, or Wild Bill, is there.
Mauricio is going up there.
Pruduit Refron's there.
So many people.
Let's play this.
The public's legitimate right to know why the government proclaimed an emergency and whether the actions it took were appropriate.
When Cabinet took the step of establishing this commission, as it was required to do, it set out an additional mandate.
Our order in council directs the Commission to examine, first, the evolution and goals of the convoy movement and border protests and their leadership, organization, and participants.
Second, the impact of domestic and foreign funding, including crowdsourcing platforms.
Third, the impact, role, and sources of misinformation and disinformation, including social media.
Fourth, the economic and other impacts of blockades.
And finally, the efforts of police and other responders prior to and after the declaration.
There is, however, an important caveat to this mandate from Cabinet.
The Commission is asked to examine these issues, and I quote, to the extent relevant to the circumstances of the declaration and measures taken, end of quote.
In other words, although these topics have been identified as worthy of attention, it is the mandate that has been given to us by Parliament that drives the Commission's work.
While this inquiry will deal with a wide range of issues, its focus will remain squarely on the decision of the federal government.
Why did it declare an emergency?
How did it use its powers?
And were those actions appropriate?
Wow, there is a lot to unpack there, Andrew.
I will say this.
Again, when he mentioned the analysis of misinformation and disinformation, according to whom?
How do you define misinformation and disinformation?
By the way, might want to check how that worked out for PayPal on the weekend.
The impacts of blockades.
Folks, let me tell you this.
I did a story when I was in Ottawa for several days covering this freedom convoy, as was Alexa, as was Lincoln Jay.
And you know, Andrew, an interesting sidebar was that these were completely peaceful, as in 100% peaceful protesters.
They were, you know, the common man driving the common van.
And, you know, on those frigid days downtown, you would go from shop to shop to shop.
I remember we were outside of Tim Hortons.
All these people wanted to do, buy coffee, get a muffin.
And yet, more than 95% of the businesses were shut down, even though there was more than 100,000 people concentrated at Parliament Hill.
It was a financial bonanza for anyone who stayed open.
And the one or two restaurants that did, they had lineups literally out the door.
This is one of the biggest lies there is, that with that trucker convoy, businesses could not operate.
No, they chose to shut down, maybe because they didn't believe in the ideology of the trucker convoy, but maybe because they believed in the disinformation and misinformation from the CBC and the Toronto Star and the Globe and Mail and Global News that these were a bunch of anarchists coming in with trouble on their shirt.
They were going to smash windows.
They were going to harass staff.
Nothing could be further from the truth.
They just wanted to have a coffee and warm up on a minus 19 day.
So already, I'm very distressed at the way in which this inquiry might go.
And one last thing, Andrew, when the rubber hits the road, because even members of the government, they are under oath at this inquiry.
I want to see the first time, and I suspect it'll be not the first time, it'll be several times, where they try to invoke cabinet privilege.
I cannot speak on that because of cabinet privilege.
And if that happens, this makes this inquiry a farce.
Well, I would hope that there's some sort of method of forcing them to answer.
Like in Congress, the only people that can use that sort of privilege are, I think, law enforcement's FBI CA and the like, and most other people in lower level government.
As long as they're not part of, what's the word looking for?
A committee, like the intelligence committee, for example, they're not allowed to just say, oh, I can't answer that.
So we'll see what happens.
Let's show this article from the National Post.
We've got some more stuff to get to.
Civil Liberties Group concerned liberals will not share all evidence.
Oh, you don't say.
Oh, boy.
It's more than them concerned.
And could we also throw up our website for this entire spiel that we're doing here in Ottawa?
Because there'll be many spiels.
There'll be many of William Diaz reports.
There'll be Ezra reports.
There'll be Sheila Gunread Live tweeting.
Make sure you follow her on Twitter.
My thumbs is live tweeting.
That's what that's going on.
It's there.
And there'll be so many videos coming out because people are going to be watching this all across the world.
I'm sure there will be a Tucker Carlson segment on it, maybe a Laura Ingraham segment.
Even the Hill left-wing publication of the U.S. covered it last time.
There's the page, and there's where you can donate.
So please go to that.
What was that website called?
TruckerCommission.com.
Thank you, Olivia.
We've got so much.
By the way, before we go on, I just want to say the one question I am so much in anticipation to hear asked is to the Right Honourable Public Safety Minister, Marco Pinocchio.
I mean, Mendocino.
And it's this.
Mr. Mendicino, you are on record several times as saying that the very reason for invoking the Emergencies Act was on the request of law enforcement.
Which police services said this to you?
Which individuals on those police services said this to you?
Because we have also on record the RCMP saying, not us.
We have on record the Ottawa Police Service saying, not us.
Who oh who requested this?
And if that son of a, you know what, says, I have to invoke cabinet privilege, why?
Why would that be a secretive answer?
Because he has never offered a name or a police service name, Andrew, in terms of who told him to put that act into place.
They really put the worst people in all the high positions, the Trudeau, like worse than anyone else, like zero qualifications for these positions, and they put them in there.
So stay tuned to RebelNews.com for that.
Let's go through these paid chats we have.
Then we'll get to Alex Jones and then maybe some AOC before we go if we have time.
We've got to get to Alex Jones as well.
We put it in the title, the title track, as I call it on my show.
Okay.
Who are we at here?
Dilbo Pickens says, Chapados and Manzi's best Rebel News tag team.
Great ad.
Andrew, thank you.
Wow.
He says, again, we're the best news tag team.
Thanks for paying twice.
What was your favorite WWF or WWE tag team?
Oh, the Hearts, the whole Heart Foundation.
Owen Hart was my first favorite wrestler.
And Brett Hurt.
You know what?
The Heart Foundation, you're right.
As an ongoing tag team, I think I agree.
It is the Heart Foundation.
As a gimmick tag team, the Rock and Sock Connection.
It's a very good tag team.
The Rock and Mankind.
I just love the Attitude Era tag team matches where they're getting so concussed and so hurt all the time.
All the latter matches are great.
Adamot, I believe, is how we pronounce this next name for $5.
We got that one?
Adam Ottawa.
Adam Ottawa.
Okay.
It says, unfortunately, we know that it's bra free day for Boss DeLamieu every day.
Also, thanks for the Rocco, the Recco on Soylent Green, David.
Actually, I, oh, you recommended Soylent Green to him?
I made a Soylent Green reference.
A very eerie and apropos movie.
They're eating the people, David.
Don't give out the spoiler.
Nobody's going to go.
You're allowed to give out spoilers for movies that are 50 plus years old.
Yeah, but there are people that were born after they had the cinematic release.
Did you know that is?
Ben dies in Spider-Man?
Oh, no.
Aaron Burton32 for $10 says, keep up the great work, Rebels.
Thank you.
There's Aaron Burton32.
And by the way, if I may interject about Soylent Green, it is a film that is becoming eerily prescient.
It was filmed in 1973.
It was based on the novel by Harry Harrison called Make Room, Make Room.
It's about the planet under a population explosion.
Nuclear War Concerns00:11:34
They got that part right.
I mean, to the best of my knowledge, New York City is not 40 million people right now.
The thing is, it is set in our current year, folks, 2022.
And what do we see?
We see meal substitutes.
And, you know, I won't, again, repeat the spoiler, but what do we see the WEF and the United Nations championing?
Insects.
They want us to eat bugs.
Suicide in the 2022 Soylent Green World, it's not only allowed, it's encouraged.
In fact, the state will pay the remaining family members a bonus if you get rid of grandpa early so we can help deal with the population crisis.
It is absolutely uncanny how much that film got right in terms of our current 2022, given that it was shot way back in 1973.
Two Charlton Heston references in one day only from David Menzies.
Let's go to Alex Jones.
They're asking him to pay almost a billion dollars, David Menzies.
Now, you can hate Alex Jones.
You can say that he lied about Sandy Hook.
You can say whatever you want about him.
I don't care.
I'm not him.
He was nice to me.
I like Alex Jones.
But the idea that lying and perhaps not even on purpose, which I believe he was just, you know, what's the word?
Not prophesizing, but he was pontificating about what he had heard, what he thought, whatever it was.
I don't think he was doing it on purpose.
You could argue that he was, even if he was.
Let's say, and I don't believe that he was.
Let's say you thought he was saying this on purpose.
Lying on purpose is worth a billion dollars.
Justin Trudeau's been proven to lie.
Multiple press secretaries have been proven to lie.
This is what I tweeted out yesterday.
Former press secretary Jen Saki was mocking this.
And she's the one who was up there pretending that Joe Biden doesn't have any cognitive problems.
So she goes up there and lies all the time.
I'll circle back with you and never get back to you.
And she's not charged with anything.
Trudeau's not charged with anything.
George Bush, New York Times are not charged with anything, weapons of mass destruction.
You can go back to Vietnam.
No charges there.
What else can we talk about that the Democrats or the Liberals or even Republicans, whomever you want to talk about, that has lied?
Yeah.
Provable lies.
No, well said, Andrew.
I mean, Pfizer people lie.
Oh, yeah.
I think we're still on YouTube, so watch out.
Watch the Flying.
You know what?
Let me be blunt with you, Andrew.
I mean, I do like Alex Jones.
I like his spirit.
I like his comedic touch.
The story he did about Sandy Hook massacre, however, I find repulsive and despicable.
That was not a so-called false flag operation.
Real children who had real mothers and fathers were massacred at that school.
We know that, as a matter of fact, I wish, I mean, if you want to dredge up conspiracy theories, you know, say that the Apollo 11 moon landing never happened, I mean, that doesn't, you know, mock the massacre of children here.
Having said that, the award is excessive and I'm sure is going to be appealed.
As you said, well, it's more than a billion dollars in Canadian dollars, certainly.
And it brings to mind, you know, even before social media and the internet, Andrew, I grew up going to the supermarket and you would see all the supermarket tabloids.
There's hardly any left anymore.
My favorite one was Weekly World News.
One of my favorite headlines was Statue of Elvis found on Mars.
I mean, you got so much going on there.
But everything about those tabloids, well, almost everything, it's kind of like the Frank magazine comment, you know, the editor once said back in the 90s.
Half the stuff in Frank magazine is true, except we don't even know which half.
But the point is, it was all fabricated nonsense.
You know, a big part of the weekly world news wasn't just housewives, but a huge component was college frat boys.
They would buy it and get a laugh out of it.
It was kind of like that was the Sacramento B of its day.
The thing is, they dined out on falsehoods, lies.
And once in a while, I think, if memory serves, Carol Burnett took the inquirer to court over allegations, false allegations, as it turned out, that she was drunk at a restaurant.
But in any event, this is, I think, what you're alluding to, and I agree, it's a slippery slope.
If we're going to talk about people being fined a billion dollars for uttering a lie, where do we even start?
Especially, as you mentioned, the entire cabinet of Prime Minister Blackface McGroper.
Where do we start?
Like I said, I don't see this award standing.
I see it being drastically reduced on appeal.
But the fact that this is happening, especially in the U.S., Andrew, with the land of the First Amendment, it's disturbing.
Well, how many times are they going to try to award these people with different amounts of money?
Like $10 million, $20 million, and now we've jumped up to $965 million U.S.
So that's a fun time to be alive.
I'm sure they just want to completely end Infowars is the problem there.
But they probably won't be able to do it.
I mean, what if he just claims bankruptcy, liquidates everything, and then just starts a new company the next day, and then people just, he just says, everybody, please resubscribe.
He'll have no choice.
I mean, as successful as Alex Jones is, I don't think he's got almost a billion bucks tucked away in some Swiss bank account.
So we'll keep our eye on this story.
And by the way, I'm keeping my eye on the clock.
Man, time flies.
Let's get to AOC and then we'll do the rest of the chats and we'll call it a, I don't know, I don't have any references, a ding-dong doodly days that Flanders would say or something like that.
I don't know if Flanders references on this show.
Iron helps us play.
All right, go ahead.
Congresswoman, none of this matters unless there's a nuclear war, which you voted to send arms and weapons to Ukraine.
Tulsi Gabbard, she's left the Democratic Party because there are some more hot, okay?
You originally voted, you ran as an outsider, yet you've been voting to start this war in Ukraine.
You're voting to start a third nuclear war with Russia and China.
Why are you playing with the lives of American citizens?
You're playing with our lives.
There will be no neighbors if there's a nuclear bomb.
You voted to mobilize and send money to Ukrainian Nazis.
You're a coward.
You're a progressive socialist.
Where are you against the war mobilization?
He's telling the right truth.
You have done nothing.
Tulsi Gabbard has shown guts where you've shown cowardice.
I believed in you and you became the very thing you sought to fight against.
That's what you've become.
You are the establishment and you are the reason why everybody will end up in a nuclear war unless you choose to stand up right now and denounce the Democratic Party.
Will you do that?
Yes or no?
Okay?
Simple.
Are you going to stop nuclear war?
Yes or no?
There is no line because this is bullshit.
None of this matters if we're all dead.
None of it.
This is the only thing that matters right now.
We could be in a nuclear war at any minute, and you continue to fund it.
That's what's going on.
I'll get to the issue box.
I will get to the issue.
Why not right now?
You're the liar here.
Nobody has hold you accountable.
That's what's happening.
And it is time for you to stand up and realize that what you've been saying has been lies.
Let your conscious come through for once.
Wow.
So that's what happened at the Halton District School Board trustee meeting after we got kicked out.
And AOC doesn't even run away.
I'll give her that.
The Halton District School Board is more cowardly and insane than AOC.
The problem is believing that AOC was going to be not establishment.
I mean, she was found through a bunch of people.
They hired her through like basically an audition process.
The guy who wrote all her speeches and her policies left her shortly after she was elected, maybe a year or so.
And, of course, she's supposed to be pro-Palestine, but she'll never say anything bad about Israel.
She's supposed to be anti-war.
She'll always keep funding Ukraine.
Like, why did you believe her?
If you're not a teenage girl or a teenage boy that thinks she's hot, why did you believe her?
I don't know.
But these are the type of people.
It'd be like if I went out every day and was just like, the Ottawa senators are the best hockey team in the world.
And then all of a sudden you got a bunch of people who are senators fans being like, you're not a real fan.
These are the people you've, you know, you've farmed to be your followers.
And now they're just realizing you're a fraud.
Like, oh, sorry.
By the way, you mentioned she's pro-Palestine.
Andrew, what's her position on Narnia and the planet Vulcan?
That's what I love about David Menzies.
He's not willing to adhere to new maps and new districting.
David, they're just trying to pay their rent, okay?
You know what?
Those people in the audience had valid points.
And I will say this: go back to the Donald Trump years, folks, and think of how much more safe the world was.
And this was a Republican president who was a dove.
He wasn't a war hawk.
I mean, he took out some real scumbags out there like Solomani with assassination and made the world better for it.
But right now, this is a concern.
With what's happening with Russia and Ukraine, this could be the catalyst to the next world war.
These are terrifying times.
We have somebody who is incompetent in the White House, and we have somebody like AOC, or AH, as I call her, you know, just being, as that man said, part of the establishment.
When he says the establishment, I guess he's referring to the industrial military complex.
And the crooked Democrats that run their party, the Nancy Pelosis and Chuck Schumers.
Last couple of chats here, sir.
As we hit the one o'clock mark, or perhaps 11 a.m. if you're in a different province in Alberta.
Sean Marie G83.
Still, Shauna, you're going to have to tell us what the G83 stands for.
I'm going to go with Grandma, H83, but I have no kids.
I'm going to go with cup size because it is no bra date.
Anyways, so kids can't wear Halloween costumes.
Fun is illegal, but Bussy Lemieux wears a costume every freaking day.
What a clown show.
Sandy Hook Controversy00:02:24
She also says for another $5, so thank you.
My understanding with Alex Jones is that he was suggesting that it, Sandy Hook, was an inside job premeditated by the corrupt to push.
Yeah, that is what he yeah.
That is what he said, but he was wrong.
Very, very nice to talk to you again, David Menzies.
Andrew, it was a joy, and I want to say a special thanks to super producer Olivia, and I believe Danny is behind the board.
We have another chat.
My apologies.
Hold the phone.
Please watch my show tonight on Rebel News Plus.
The new format, David, is that I do streeters as well that are extended version on the show to go along with my bonus segments of the podcast.
portion of the show, which you were a part of.
So if you want to see David Manzies be interviewed as Boss DMU, you'll have to subscribe to Rebel News Plus because that won't be on the free version.
Oh, you know, and I'm looking at your swank news set.
It reminds me of the Menzoid Man Cave back in the Sun News days.
I think somebody tore that down immediately and put it up on eBay before.
Now you know where it went.
Like Kramer with the TV?
The Merve Griffin Griffin Show.
Do we have another one?
I don't have it here.
No?
Okay.
Oh, false alarm.
That's going to be a billion dollars, Olivia.
I'm sorry.
We're going to go to, I believe that's Alan Honor, lawyer for the Democracy Fund, if I'm getting my names in my places right.
I'm surprised I remembered that, frankly.
Ottawa Commission going on.
Please go to Rebel News for that.
David Manzies, play us out, please.
Yes, what a wonderful legal eagle Alan Honor is.
So, folks, I want to thank you for tuning in.
A special thank you to all those who were so generous with those super chat donations.
It's how we keep the lights on.
Thank you to Olivia and Danny, and thank you to my co-host, Cork, I believe you called me.
Yes, while you were doing the glass.
Hey, Clark, where'd you go?
I found a phone booth.
There will be two other Rebel News journalists here tomorrow at 12 noon Eastern.
And in the meantime, as always, folks, stay sane.
Don't call me shrewd.
My name is Alan Honor, and I am the litigation director for the Democracy Fund.
The Democracy Fund is a registered charity and a civil liberties organization.
As you've heard, we're sharing standing with the JCCF and with Citizens for Freedom.
Representing Pandemic Protesters00:01:46
Our interest in this inquiry arises from our legal work.
In February of 2022, we sent lawyers to Ottawa and to Windsor to provide demonstrators with legal information about their rights when protesting, as well as the limitations of those rights.
Around the same time, we were granted intervener status as a friend of the court at the Superior Court of Justice in Windsor over the Ambassador Bridge injunction proceeding.
Currently, we represent dozens of persons who have been criminally charged in relation to the protests at Ottawa, Windsor, and Coots.
And we represent thousands of others who've been charged under the Quarantine Act or provincial offenses related to the pandemic.
We've also brought applications before superior courts and the federal court of Canada challenging laws related to the pandemic.
Our objective is to participate in the fact-finding process of this inquiry, particularly as it relates to uncovering the truth about why the federal government invoked a public order emergency and how they used their powers.
From our perspective, the government did not meet the requisite legal grounds to invoke a public order emergency for the same reasons you heard from Counsel for the Freedom Corps.
It follows that the extraordinary measures the government invoked were therefore inappropriate and indeed outside their jurisdiction.
Our questions and our submissions will focus on these central issues.