All Episodes
July 24, 2017 - Andrew Klavan Show
43:46
Ep. 351 - Cracks in the Left's Fantasy World

Ep. 351 skewers leftist media bias through Sean Spicer’s resignation satire, mocking CNN’s Jim Acosta and NYT’s self-pity while contrasting it with Israel’s Temple Mount violence—where Palestinian terrorism is whitewashed as "protests." Trump’s deregulation and Scaramucci’s anti-leak crusade are praised amid administration chaos, while Jay-Z’s 4:44 is torn apart for its racial grievance lyrics ("N-word" in Legacy) despite financial responsibility themes. The episode pivots to Dunkirk’s war glory vs. Nolan’s cold storytelling, ending with a preview of Carrie Lucas and a defense of free markets as the antidote to progressive exploitation. [Automatically generated summary]

|

Time Text
Rock Through Window 00:02:41
John Spicy Spicer has resigned as White House press secretary.
In his resignation letter to President Trump, Spicer said, quote, it has been a great honor to serve my country, but now you can take this crappy job and shove it, unquote.
The resignation letter was tied to a rock and hurled through the window of the Oval Office, according to Jim Acosta of CNN, who was also tied to a rock and hurled through the window of the Oval Office, attached to a letter which read, and you can take this crappy reporter and shove it too.
Acosta complained about the incident, saying it should have been on camera so everyone could see him.
Acosta said the fact that he was not on camera was a violation of Americans' First Amendment right to see Jim Acosta on camera.
The Spicer resignation will have major ramifications on the behind-the-scenes power struggles at the White House, according to people who know nothing about the behind-the-scenes power struggles at the White House, namely Jim Acosta and his anonymous sources, who are also named Jim Acosta by some strange coincidence.
According to these sources, it was the appointment of businessman Anthony Scaramucci, also known as Anthony Scaramucci, that caused Spicer's face to turn scarlet while steam came out of his ears, making a high-pitched whistling noise that sounded like a tea kettle screaming Anthony Scaramucci.
Anonymous sources named Jim Acosta also say that presidential aide and evil demon from the bowels of hell, Steve Bannon, complained about the tea kettle noise, which he said disturbed his thought processes while he was plotting the white supremacist overthrow of the government.
This in turn disturbed Bannon's chief rival, Ryan's Priebus, who complained to the president that he wanted to plot the white supremacist overthrow of the government, which in turn caused Bannon to grab Priebus' nose between the knuckles of his first two fingers and twist it in a circle while Priebus flapped his arms in the air and said whoop whoop whoop knuck nuck nuck.
The New York Times, a former newspaper, celebrated Spicer's resignation with an editorial which read, quote, We hated Sean Spicer because he yelled at us when we lied, so he was yelling at us all the time, and it damaged our self-esteem.
In future, we look forward to lying without getting yelled at the way we used to do with Obama, who made our jobs much easier because we didn't have to make up our own lies but could just report his, unquote.
Spicer says he has already landed a new job as the chief bouncer at the Double Deuce House in Jasper, Missouri.
CNN's Jim Acosta says this is unfair because the Double Deuce doesn't have cameras, so no one can see Jim Acosta.
Someone should probably explain to Jim Acosta that no one can see him anyway because he's on CNN.
Trigger warning, I'm Andrew Clavin, and this is the Andrew Clavin Show.
I'm a hunky-dunky, life is tickety-boo.
Birds are also singing hunky-cocky cocky.
Ship shit, tipsy-topsy, go welcome to zippity zing.
It's a wonderful day.
Hoorah, hooray!
Kettle Corn Delight 00:02:34
It makes me want to sing.
Oh, hurrah, hooray.
Oh, hooray, hoora.
All right, the Clavenless weekend comes to an end, but not everybody made it.
Sean Spicer didn't make it through.
And O.J. Simpson is out.
He's been released.
That's what happened to Spicer.
That's right.
And he's singles, ladies.
O.J., what I like about the Sean Spicer-O.J. connection, though, is Saturday Night Live has made hay imitating Sean Spicer, how wonderful it is.
And the New York Times and then all the leftist press says, oh, how funny they are, Melissa McCarthy doing Sean Spicer.
But they didn't do jokes about O.J. Simpson because we'll remember that Norm McDonald was fired from Saturday Night Live because some of the brass at NBC were playing golf with O.J. Simpson and they didn't like McDonald making jokes about him slaughtering his wife.
Michael Knowles is with us today.
He will be talking about Jay-Z.
And, you know, I have my hands up and moving my hips like, yeah, and I can't wait.
And we'll also do a review of Dunkirk.
But first, you know, my nature box stuff arrived.
That was the highlight of the Clavenless weekend: my Nature Box stuff arrived.
And I have to say, this is my thing because I don't sleep at night.
That is when I do most of my snacking.
Normally, I'm very disciplined.
As the night wears on, I start to picket things.
I'm reading.
I'm watching TV and I like to have something there.
So whatever my wife buys is what I'm going to eat.
And so a lot of times, not that my wife eats junk, she doesn't, but if they're cereal, I'll eat that.
But the thing about Nature Box is they send you these snacks that, first of all, they are, they taste terrific.
They're actually great.
I mean, I was eating this.
They have this thing, kettle corn, coffee kettle corn, which is kind of like hits every kind of thing in my head.
You know, it's got coffee.
I don't know if you know kettle corn is so sweet popcorn, essentially.
It's so, so good.
These snacks taste great, but they're actually better for you.
They're created with high-quality ingredients that are free from artificial colors, flavors or sweeteners, so you can feel great about snacking.
You can see on the package where the calories are and all that stuff.
NatureBox recently made their service even better because now you can order as much as you want, as often as you want, with no minimum purchase required, and you cancel any time.
All you do is you go to naturebox.com and check out the snack catalog.
All you have to do is look at the page and you'll immediately be hooked.
There are over 100 snacks to choose from and they're always adding new ones.
Israel's Freedom of Speech 00:15:44
So it always changes.
You choose the snacks you want.
They deliver them right to your door.
And with NatureBox, you won't get bored because it always is changing up.
And if you ever try a snack and you don't like it, NatureBox will replace it for free.
So right now, you'll save even more.
NatureBox is offering our fans 50% off your first order when you go to naturebox.com/slash Claven.
How do you spell that?
I'm glad you asked me that question, Austin.
It's K-L-A-V-A-N naturebox.com/slash Claven gets you 50% off your first order.
Naturebox.com/slash Claven try this coffee kettle corn.
It's obscene.
It really is.
It's so good.
All right.
You know, I want to start talking.
Everybody's talking about the White House and this and that.
And I just want to start talking about something else, but for a very specific reason, I want to talk about some of the stuff that's going on in Israel.
That there's all this turmoil.
I guess it was last Friday or the Friday before last.
Two gunmen on the Temple Mount, you know, where the old temple was, the temple that's in the Bible was, there is now a mosque on that mount.
And it's a disputed site, and the Muslims kind of want it to be the capital of, you know, their new Palestine after they finish killing all the Jews.
And, you know, no Jews can go up into the mosque, and the mosque kind of dominates the view of Jerusalem.
And there's a fly in this studio.
Look at that.
There's a fly in our studio.
It's like, see if you get them to do a guest spot.
Anyway, so two gunmen kill cops, right?
Two Palestinian gunmen kill cops.
So the Israelis put up a metal detector to get into the mosque.
The place goes nuts, right?
There's rioting, there's all this stuff.
While the rioting goes on, a guy breaks into a Jewish home.
A Palestinian breaks into a Jewish home and slaughters three people in his family.
The poor mother is like locked in the room with the children.
The guy's coming.
They have to rescue her and all this stuff.
During these riots, because they're putting security in, because there was a terrorist act, or as the New York Times said, an act that seemed like terrorism.
I don't know what a guy killing, you know, a guy with guns, killing a couple of cops is going to seem like.
But so they're rioting, and three people are murdered in their home by a Palestinian terrorist, and three Palestinians are killed in the riots, right?
Because they're rioting.
They are having riots.
So the news all over, I'm quoting from CBS, but it was everywhere.
Three Palestinians, three Israelis killed in violence over Jerusalem Shrine.
So like the entire moral framework of the news is completely removed.
And that's a dishonest story.
I mean, that's a dishonest story.
This is not like a he said, she said operation.
Israel is a free nation.
Israel is a place where women are free.
Israel is a place where Muslims can worship.
Israel is a place where Muslims can worship.
Israel is a place where you can say what you want, where you can do the things that you want, or you can live a life, and all this stuff.
That is not true in any of the Muslim-majority countries, even Turkey, which is slipping into Islamism as we watch.
So the idea that Palestine, the Palestinians, made up, we used to call them Philistines, that's what they're called in the Bible.
The idea that Palestine should be a nation because we really need another oppressive Islamic nation and a free nation of Israel should be under fire and the killing that goes on in a house, a guy breaking his house and wiping out a family, is the same morally as people getting killed while they're rioting.
It's a lie.
It's a lie.
It's a big fantasy lie.
And you know, the same thing, the fact that all they want to do, it's kind of like the protest is, what do you mean you're going to put up metal detectors?
How will we get our guns in to kill you?
I mean, that's what they're saying.
It was like when they protested, they built that wall on the West Bank and they protested.
And oh, remember what a terrible thing a wall was?
I mean, that was the press was telling us, oh, how oppressive and how racist and it's apartheid.
That wall essentially eliminated suicide bombings.
It eliminated them coming across.
So it's like they're protesting, hey, we can't kill you.
It's not fair, you know?
And this is this fantasy world that the press has created.
And the point that I want to make about this, okay, is this is the same media that is reporting American news.
The fantasy that is going on in Israel, the world without a moral framework, the world where Israel and the Palestinians are on equal footing, where a terrorist act is the same as somebody getting killed while he's rioting, you know, all that stuff where that framework of reality of just an actual moral law, that's not, you know, it's not like a random moral law.
It's not like I happen to be rooting for the Israelis.
They're a free country.
I mean, this is the stuff that we're supposed to believe in.
That same press is reporting on Donald Trump and it's reporting on the, I mean, there's another story that's going on right now is the murder rate is spiraling upward in Democrat cities and especially in Democrat cities where there has been Black Lives Matter activity.
In Baltimore, it's spiraling out of control and they asked the police union.
I mean, if you read any stories buried like down at the bottom, they asked the guy in the police union, this is where Freddie Gray, remember Freddie Gray was the guy who died in the paddy wagon, basically, and they said, well, they were trying to kill him, and they started to put the six officers.
Freddie Gray was black.
Three of the officers were black.
Three of them were white.
They started to put him on trial.
Marilyn Mosby, was that the DA's name?
And it was just, they started to get off, and she finally had to drop the charges.
And now the head of the police union in Baltimore says, oh, you know, it's in the officers' minds.
Could I wind up being charged and being put in jail for doing my job?
In other words, they're not policing with the same intensity they were.
And now black people are getting killed.
Thanks, Obama.
Thanks, Black Lives Matter.
I mean, these are the things that are going on while the press is reporting.
Jared Kushner is talking about some meeting he had about Russia.
It's the same media.
Michael Crichton, the great thriller writer, guy who wrote Jurassic Park and so on, he was also a really good political observer.
And he once made the point, I've mentioned this before, but it's worth repeating.
He once made the point that when you hit a news story that you know something about.
So if I hit a news story that's about Hollywood, you know, about what business is like, doing business is like in Hollywood, you notice that they don't know what they're talking about.
But then when you turn the page and you go into the next story about Israel or Baltimore, you assume that they know what they're talking about because you don't know that information and you're getting it from the newspaper.
So you start, it's just a psychological thing.
So when these people who are lying so badly about Israel, who are just making up this fantasy Israel, who are not even talking about the fact that Black Lives Matter and Obama's constant attacks on the police, which were a way of distracting the public and the press from the fact that his policies weren't working, when that stuff is all fantasy and you move on to Donald Trump and you move on to what's happening and is the government in disarray and all this stuff, all that stuff is fantasy too.
I mean, you have to start looking for, you know, you have to start looking for the stories themselves.
You know, the funny thing about Trump, about Trump and the Trump administration, is I'm not a big fan of Trump as a human being.
Like, I think I really don't like the bullying and I don't like the rough talk and all this stuff.
But I do understand that he did something important.
He actually stopped the rolling tide of leftism that was engulfing the country and was really threatening to engulf the country and that it's still there.
That rolling tide is still there.
People who think that the Jews are the problem in the Middle East are still running our newspapers.
People who think that the cops or the problem in black neighborhoods are still there.
And the fact that Trump has put the brakes on them is important.
It's important.
And he's done good things.
I mean, I think his foreign policy is better in the Supreme Court pick, obviously.
I was reading in the Daily Wire, a lovely place where you should really subscribe to because, you know, if you subscribe for a year, you get the leftist tears mug.
So you should really is worth doing.
But I was reading in the Daily Wire that Trump has eliminated 16 federal regulations for each new one he's put in place.
So, you know, I think that this vision of the left is actually beginning to crack a little bit.
I saw Chuck Schumer on TV, and for the first time, Schumer was starting to talk about how losing the election was their fault.
I mean, he was really blaming Hillary Clinton, but he was talking.
Here he is explaining what has gone wrong with the Democrat Party.
Ready, comrades?
Yes, Comrade Varro.
It's real cool.
We got the red blues.
Now, that's an obscure joke.
You'll never hear anywhere else.
You've got the red blues.
No, but here is Chuck Schumer.
Suddenly, they're now going to bring out their Trumpian, their imitation Trump economic plan.
Listen to this.
When you lose an election with someone who has, say, 40% popularity, you look in the mirror and say, what did we do wrong?
And the number one thing that we did wrong is we didn't have, we didn't tell people what we stood for.
Even today, as your poll showed, they know we're standing up to Trump.
They like that.
But they want to know what do you stand for.
So tomorrow, Democrats will unveil our economic agenda.
It's called a better deal.
It has three components.
We're going to raise people's wages and create better paying jobs.
We're going to cut down on their everyday expenses they have to pay.
And we're going to give them the tools they need to compete in the 21st century.
So simply put, what do Democrats stand for?
A better deal for working families.
Higher wages, less costs, tools for the 21st century.
You didn't even go for eight years.
You had control of Congress for part of that time.
What took so long and why didn't it happen during the campaign?
Well, I don't know why it didn't happen in the campaign.
We all take blame, not any one person.
But now we have spent a lot of time working on this and it's going to really impress the American people.
Yeah, he dodged Stephanopoulos' question.
Stephanopoulos blew the question.
But the question is, you had eight years.
Where were you on all these working class things?
When you were telling us who should be using the bathrooms in our elementary schools, where were you?
You know, when you were doing this, putting this anchor of Obamacare on our economy, where were you?
Well, you were blowing up the Middle East.
Where were you for the working class people?
This is like imitation Trumpism.
As you know, you know the Democrats only have one policy forever for everything, which is steal people's money from people who are productive and give it to people who aren't productive.
And that's what they're going to do.
When he says, oh, we're going to create jobs, government doesn't create jobs.
The only jobs government creates are government jobs, which actually make fewer jobs because everything that the government does is a weight on businesses.
I got a break here to say goodbye to Facebook and YouTube, where you have been getting free video, but you can get video at the Daily Wire if you subscribe.
If you subscribe, this is what you get for a lousy 10 bucks a month.
You get to watch the video right there on the Daily Wire.
You get to, you can also, do you get ad-free Daily Month if you subscribe on the website?
Yeah, so that's pretty good too.
You get to be in the mailbag where I solve all of your personal problems.
I mean, look in the mirror.
You know, I mean, is that not worth $10 a month?
And if you get it for a year, which is only $100 lousy bucks a month, you get the leftist tears mug that keeps your leftist tears cold and my coffee warm.
Come on over to TheDailyWire.com.
Okay, so before we get to Knowles, let me just do a quick review of this new guy.
I have to say, now that I feel fairly confident that Trump is not evil, that he's not going to be like an authoritarian.
that he's not going to do anything to damage the actual polity of the American polity, the American way of life.
He may do things I hate.
He may go too far to the left.
He may mess things up and bobble the ball and all that.
But now I'm convinced that he's not going to do anything really evil.
I love how entertaining this all is.
I mean, it's so much more entertaining than the last eight years of being scolded and having Obama shake his finger at us and tell us who we are as a people when he had no clue who we are as a people.
And I was really sad when Sean Spicer stepped down because Sean Spicer made me laugh every time he was on TV when he would just say, it was really like, Mr. Spicer, shut up.
You know, I'll slap you around.
But this guy may be just as entertaining.
I mean, he comes on.
First, Spicer got a last hit.
He was on Sean Hannity and he didn't say the rumor is, the anonymous source story is that he didn't like Scaramucci.
He didn't think he didn't want him to be his boss because now Scaramucci is over him.
He's not the White House spokesman.
The White House spokesman is Huckabee Sanders.
And so that was the rumor that that's why he quit, but he was very politic about all that.
But he did have this to say about the press.
Most people aren't really privy to how stories are developed and what stories make it to the front page or to the mainstream media, whether it's in print or in broadcast.
And I think they'd be shocked and disappointed to see some of the bias that exists in some of the stories that don't get told or the manner in which they are told.
I was increasingly disappointed in how so many of the members here of the media do their job or rather don't do their job, the bias to which they come from it at.
And as I mentioned a while ago, I think that there's become a very clickbait mentality among a lot of reporters where they're more interested in their clip or their click than they are about the truth and the facts.
So I think that is certainly fair enough.
So I like the fact that he had a parting shot at the press.
And then Sarah Huckabee Sanders goes on with George Succalopagus.
And this is classic.
I mean, this is classic.
You know, we are so Democrat, we don't know how Democrat we are from the media.
Listen to this question.
I want to ask you the same question.
John Carl asked Sean Spicer on his first day.
Do you promise to always try to tell the truth from that podium?
Absolutely.
And not just to you, but I think that's our duty.
Certainly, I have three young kids, and I want to be able to go home and look my kids in the eye every single day.
And that's far more important to me to be able to do that and have the highest level of honesty and integrity.
And I want to do that not just in my job, but in every single thing I do.
And so this is just an extension of me being able to do that.
And I'm excited and honored to do it.
So, so I thought what she should have said is, me tell the truth.
What are you talking about?
Like, you're asking, you are asking me if I will tell the truth.
You're George Stephanopoulos.
You said, I love you, Hillary, and now you're pretending to be a journalist.
You know, I mean, this is the, I'm sure, I wonder, did they ask Josh Ernest that, Ernest, that when he took over Obama's podium?
I very, very much doubt it.
I couldn't find an interview that he did when he started, but I doubt they were asking that question.
The very question itself is offensive.
I mean, the question itself is offensive.
Do you swear to tell the truth?
How about, you know, how you know, like, bite me, George?
That's the answer to that question.
So now they bring in Scaramucci.
And the thing about Scaramucci is he supported Obama for a while.
He then supported Jeb, exclamation point, and he supported, who was the other one he supported?
Scott Walker, I think he supported, gave him money and talked him up.
And there's this old cut of him attacking Trump.
Scaramucci was in business.
Trump attacked his business.
Stop Leaking Secrets 00:03:13
This is the old.
Let me see if I can find this.
It is number two, cut number two.
He's a hack.
You're a trouble.
I'm not going to make Elizabeth Warren his vice presidential nominee with comments like that.
The politicians don't want to go at Trump because he's got a big mouth and he's afraid he's going to light him up on Fox News and all these other places.
But I'm not a politician.
Bring it.
So why is he resonating?
Why is he resonating, dude, from Queens County?
Bring it, Donald.
So bring it, Donald.
But I like Scaramucci now goes on and Chris Wallace asks him to respond to this.
And this is cut number three.
So this Garamucci, the thing I like about him is he sounds exactly like Donald Trump.
He's like mini-me Trump now.
What I love about you guys, okay, is it's a three-minute segment that I guess is going to be played for eternity.
We should put it on the Voyager spacecraft and send it interstellar, okay?
I love the guy.
Just the New Yorkers, and this is my point.
I want to finish my point.
I love the guy.
I have spent the last 18 months supporting him unyieldingly because he's a great person and he's going to be a phenomenal.
He is a phenomenal president.
He's even going to be a better president.
But you're not allowed to fight a little bit amongst your friends.
If you're not allowed to do that, what are we doing?
It's just like the New York, the New York administration.
It's like, Queens, what are we doing here, Chris?
If we can't fight, we can't fight.
And he talks about, he talks about how he's going to solve the leak problem.
This is cut four.
Tomorrow I'm going to have a meeting with the communications staff and say, hey, I don't like these leaks.
And so we're going to stop the leaks.
And if we don't stop the leaks, I'm going to stop you.
It's just really that simple.
So then he, that was yesterday.
So now he implemented the program today.
The most
fun administration ever.
I mean, these guys, they call him the mooch.
Mooch.
He made a speech today where he just talked about how wonderful Trump was and how he could, what did he say?
He could throw a perfect spiral with a football through a tire.
He is really.
I know.
I know.
But that's what I want in my president.
I want to throw a perfect spiral through a tire.
But I really like this guy.
I think he's going to be every bit as entertaining as Sean Spicer.
And that is the thing.
I am here to be entertained.
So that's what I want from this administration.
All right, let's bring on Knowles.
Knowles, are you there?
Oh, my God.
Hey.
I cannot believe.
Hey, hey, Knowles, Michael, it's good to see you.
I'm a New Yorker.
You're a New Yorker.
I'm glad you're here.
And don't mess with me, all right?
Because I slap you upside the head.
Jay's Confessional Message 00:12:28
You've got to see what I did to Ben to get this studio seat right now.
Broadcasting live from the Denjo Murrow Show studio.
We'll find him in like a bucket of lime.
So I feel like I just saw you 10 minutes ago.
We had dinner last night with the absolutely beautiful and charming and intelligent Ann Coulter.
My heart palpitations have finally quieted down enough so that I go, oh my gosh, beating out of my chest.
I know.
She is so nice.
You know, the funny thing about Anne is like, she's like one of the nicest.
She's just a charming, lovely person.
When you tell people that, they say, oh, well, then the whole thing on TV must be an act.
And I think, like, what does she, she's not mean on TV.
She's just a conservative.
She's a conservative.
She's extremely charming and she's extremely entertaining.
Yeah, that was my experience having dinner with her and having met her before.
Well, she says she might come on the show, so hopefully she'll come on later this week while she's in LA.
So I asked you to look at Jay-Z.
I'm going to stand back and let you talk in just a minute.
I just want to say this one thing.
I know nothing about Jay-Z.
I mean, everything I know about Jay-Z, I learned from Miley Cyrus, that song she does when she says, a Jay-Z song.
That's the only thing I know about Jay-Z.
And the reason I don't know anything about Jay-Z, I mean, I think in most of the arts, my critical facility is still pretty cutting edge.
I mean, I love new things.
I've participated in a lot of new things.
I've participated in a lot of new technology.
I hate this music.
And, you know, I was thinking about this over the weekend for another reason.
If you had lived from ancient Greece to, if you had lived in the centers of Western civilization from ancient Greece to, say, 1900 England, you know, Europe, you would never have heard music so loud that you couldn't hold a conversation, or music that was, you know, drowned you out, or music that made you bounce around like you were some kind of like primitive.
And the fact that we listen to this music, that we have devolved to listening to music that just does not contribute to the beauty of life, does not contribute to the serenity of the soul, does not add anything to our depth of information, I think is just a sign of decadence.
I think this stuff, this rock is bad enough, and I know that I sound like an old curmudgeon, but on this one thing, I really do not think the arts have advanced.
But rap to me is just trash.
And having said that, you can now say anything you want about Jay-Z.
If you like him, go ahead.
But he brought out this new album, which is making a lot of a big splash.
First, I'll say, I am Wonder Mike, and I've come to say hello to the black and the brown, the white, and the purple and yellow.
This is not a test.
I'm rapping to be.
I agree with you.
I think the Ann Coulter dinner was my gift for getting through listening to this stupid album.
I don't like rap as a genre.
I agree with you.
I just don't think it's a good genre.
I know that's a sweeping statement, but I don't think it contributes very much to the world or to my sense of aesthetics or beauty or truth or anything like that.
That all said, in its first week out, this album has made insane strides.
A lot of people are saying it's going to be the album of the year.
Puff Diggity Doodad or whoever says that it's the best album Jay-Z ever made.
What's the name of the album?
The album is called 444.
Okay.
I looked up and said, I wonder what that means.
Jay-Z says that he got the name because he woke up in the middle of the night at 444 and started writing a song.
Apparently, that's as deep as it goes.
What's interesting, because Jay-Z, the musician, is far less impressive than Jay-Z, the businessman.
This guy, I mean, he's a billionaire.
He and Beyoncé together are worth $1.1 to $1.2 billion.
He explicitly released this album only on his own streaming music service.
Wow.
So it was a big risk because it couldn't be considered for the chart rankings.
It couldn't be considered by Nielsen.
But even in its second week, it had so much momentum behind it just from his own service that it rose to number one in the charts.
So a really impressive business acumen.
The album is deeply confessional.
It's supposed to be a response to Beyoncé's lemonade album that came out last year, which talked about his infidelities.
It alluded to them.
Do we have a clip?
There's a little promo that he's been putting out of the album.
Do we have that?
No, no, this is my everybody loves to be needed on some level.
I feel like women often feel like you're a man.
And they're just like, okay, so does that mean we don't have emotions?
You know, people see your family, they see Instagram pictures of you smiling and happy and stuff all the time.
They don't think you got real issues.
You know what I mean?
I don't think you have to sleep back to back, like climbing in the bed and you might look over there and got that back roll, though.
It's the worst feeling in the world.
What I thought was when I met my dad was, oh, I'm free to love now.
This is the softer side of Jay-Z.
I mean, this is not the guy who rapped on the black album.
I got the hottest chick in the game wearing my chain.
It is a more probing piece, but it's an album of contradictions.
On the one hand, Jay-Z explicitly kills his ego in a song.
He's fighting his ego.
He's fighting for his humility.
The end of his career, probably.
The end of his career, yeah, his family.
But on the other hand, the whole album is navel-gazing.
It's all about his romantic problems about which I'm supposed to care for some reason.
I mean, he's cheating on Beyonce, isn't that basically?
He confesses to it in the album pretty explicitly.
But then on the other hand, so many of the innovative songs in this album, release the innovative lyrics, are about taking personal responsibility, financial responsibility, familial responsibility.
Then on the other hand, he airs racial grievance that ultimately excuses any sort of personal responsibility.
In particular, in a song about the real story of O.J. Simpson, which is a timely release.
You know, the New York Times, a former newspaper, actually sort of got this right.
They said, viewed from different angles, 444 is a long, simmering, eyes downcast confession, a relaxing of muscles that have been tense for decades, a marketing ploy intended to bolster two second-tier businesses, the streaming service title and the phone company Sprint.
Both of those are present.
He's getting plaudits from Monica Lewinsky for coming clean about his infidelities.
He's getting plaudits from everybody.
He said, quote, this is my real life.
I just ran into this place and we built this big, beautiful mansion of a relationship that wasn't totally built on the 100% truth.
Okay, tear this down.
Let's start from the beginning.
It's the hardest thing I've ever done.
More power to him.
Obviously, as a Knowles myself, I always like when the in-laws are good to our family.
Meanwhile, daddy are fighting, right?
But listen to some of these lyrics.
I think they'll explain the nice attempts of the album and why this art form is just dreadful.
You know, in the realm of ego, the first song opens up.
It says, kill Jay-Z.
They'll never love you.
You'll never be enough.
Let's just keep it real, Jay-Z.
F Jay-Z.
I mean, you shot your own brother.
How can we know if we can trust Jay-Z?
And you know better, N-word.
I know you do, but you got to do better, boy.
You owe it to Blue, his daughter.
You had no father.
You had the armor, but you got a daughter.
Got to get softer.
Die, Jay-Z.
This ain't back in the days.
Cry, Jay-Z.
We know the pain is real, but you can't heal what you never reveal.
Okay.
A vulnerable lyric.
Not a good lyric.
Not Wordsworth, but vulnerable, and in that way, I suppose, admirable.
On financial responsibility, there's a great song in the album called Legacy.
And it opens up with a little girl asking, Daddy, what's a will?
And he responds: he says, Take those monies and spread cross families.
My sisters, Hattie and Lou, the nephews, cousins, and TT, Eric, the rest for B, whatever she wants to do, she might start an institute.
Generational wealth.
That's the key.
My parents ain't have S, so that shift started with me.
My mom took her money, she bought me bonds.
That was the sweetest thing of all time.
It's a really good message.
So there's a little capitalism in there.
Did that get a react?
I mean, did that.
It did.
Some people called it a conservative album.
Clearly, compared to his other material, it is.
It's giving an important message about responsibility and wealth and finance.
But then, here comes the chorus of that same song: Legacy, Legacy, Legacy, Black Excellence.
You're going to let him see.
Legacy, Legacy, Legacy.
Black Excellency, baby, let him see.
Later on, from the song Family Feud, he says, Y'all still drinking Perriers UA, ha, but we ain't get through to you yet, huh?
What's better than one billionaire, two, especially if they're from the same hue as you?
Y'all stop me when I stop telling the truth.
There's a black solidarity and a racial grievance that permeates a lot of the album.
From the story of OJ, one of the bigger songs, it has a video on YouTube.
We can't play it because it'll get our own content taken down.
Okay.
They've been very strong on copyright.
He says, You want to know what's more important than throwing away money at a strip club?
Credit.
Good point.
You ever wonder why Jewish people own all the property in America?
This is how they did it.
Financial freedom is my only hope.
F living rich and dying broke.
I can't wait to give this S to my children.
Y'all think it's bougie.
I'm like, it's fine.
All a great message.
Bougie mean bourgeois.
Bourgeois, coming from bourgeois.
But then we get to the chorus.
Light N-word, dark N-word, faux N-word, real N-word, rich N-word, poor N-word, house N-word, field N-word, still N-word, still N-word.
Jay-Z may be many things.
Yeah.
A mediocre lyricist, impressive businessman, but he is no N-word.
That is always.
I mean, if that is N-word, like sign me up.
He's a billionaire.
He's exceeded beyond anyone, even in his own industry.
But certainly he's made over a billion dollars of wealth, and he's one of the most prominent artists of our time, which says quite a lot about art and our time.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
All right.
Well, thank you very much for doing that.
So I didn't have to.
When does your show start?
You pushed it a week, right?
We had to push it a week because I'm still recovering from listening to Jay-Z.
So Thank you for that.
But we'll be beginning very soon.
Very soon.
Sooner even than you think.
And I would like to say, before we go, I would like to thank Jay, you know, just from my heart for apologizing to Cousin Day.
You're a big man.
We're doing it.
Hopefully the music's a little better next time.
It's nice to know the Knowles stick together.
We stick together, that's right.
Thanks a lot.
I'll see you later.
All right.
Well, I couldn't contribute to that because I just don't cannot listen to that music.
I will say this, though, about a black guy, a prominent black guy, saying that even if he's doing it through victimology, saying that success is the best revenge, because I think that that is what has motivated a lot of people from the Irish and the Italians and the Jews to, you know, like, yeah, you can pick on me now, but I'm going to build up my wealth.
I'm going to do the job.
I'm going to work hard.
I'm going to get to college.
I'm going to build a business and make it.
And that really has been the way forward.
And I have to say, there's one thing I have never understood as a man.
You know, I'm not a big, I kind of believe race is a superstition.
I mean, I believe in culture, but race, to me, I doubt there's enough genetic difference between a black person and a white person and a yellow person to make any real difference.
They couldn't be dispelled by culture within a generation.
I think there are two kinds of people, men and women.
I think those are the two kinds of people.
Those are the two people who are different.
Those are the two kinds of people that are different from one another.
I think a black man and a white man have so much more in common than any man and any woman, basically.
And what I've never been able to understand is the Democrats sell black men this helplessness and this poor little you, you're all so picked on.
You can't do it without the government, but we'll help you.
Two Kinds of People 00:07:01
You know, I know you can't even run a bank.
Remember, was it Maxine Waters who said that he can't even open a bank account?
Oh, the government has to help you.
Anybody said that to me, I would stick my fist so far down his throat he would be sitting on it.
I mean, I do not understand why they buy that message.
Whereas the message from a guy, it's white people who attack a guy like Jay-Z when he says, make a lot of money.
They say, oh, no, no, no, you don't want to do that.
You want to be helpless and victim.
You know, you can't succeed until people stop hating you.
People will never stop hating you.
There'll always be someone who hates you.
There'll always be a grievance.
You'll always be a victim of something.
But if you get ahead and become a billionaire, it's a lot more fun to be hated and a victim.
I just have never understood why black males buy into that.
That you need to be taken care of by the government.
That would just go right up my spine.
I would hate it.
All right.
Stuff I like.
You know, I'm going to review Dunkirk.
I know a lot of people love this film, Christopher Nolan's new film.
I mean, this was one of the, you know, when I lived in England, they used to joke about this all the time because they used to say, you know, they would never win in athletics.
They would never win at Wimbledon.
They would never win at soccer, you know, which they call football.
They would never win at rugby or anything.
And they would say, well, it's the Dunkirk spirit.
We lose, but we lose beautifully.
And Dunkirk is one of the great losses.
You know, it was a military disaster.
The British forces and the French forces were pushed to the sea by the Germans.
The Germans held off wiping.
They could have just moved in and wiped them out, but they didn't.
And in an absolute military miracle, I mean, this is just history.
I hope I'm not giving you away.
If this for you is a spoiler, turn me off now, because I will tell you what happened in history.
But in one of the great military miracles of history, like every British guy with a boat, which was everybody on the coast, got in their boats, sailed across with the RAF protecting them in the air, and brought back hundreds of thousands of soldiers and saved the war, basically, saved the war.
So it is an amazing, amazing story.
People love this film, and I thought it was a good movie.
It was, first of all, it's under two hours, which I think every movie that's under two hours is better than every other movie that is longer.
It's immersive.
The action.
Did you see it, Austin?
No, but I've heard a lot of your answers.
I mean, it people people loved it, and it's just it's immersive, it's beautifully shot, it's wonderfully acted, it is very much like it's exciting, and it gets you in the battle.
There's not one human relationship in the entire movie, not one.
I mean, there's one, there's two kids who kind of have a relationship.
There is no mourning, there is no memory, there is nothing that relates anything to anybody but just trying to survive in this battle, which isn't actually realistic.
I mean, even when you're trying to survive, you are thinking about human relations.
And there is something about Christopher Nolan, who is so talented and so brilliant, and has made a couple of films that I really liked.
I loved the one about the guy who loses his memory.
What's that?
Who's Memento?
And I love the Dark Knight film and all that.
And I love the fact that he's obviously a conservative.
One of the things I liked about Dunkirk is that it is an openly patriotic film, although they never mention it starts out with a thing that says the enemy has pushed the troops to the sea.
And you think the enemy, it would be the Germans.
The enemy had a name, but he doesn't do any of that.
But it is an openly patriotic and openly pro-Western film, and I like that.
So it's a good movie.
It's a good movie.
But it is kept from being a great movie by a problem Nolan has with his sterile approach to humanity.
I mean, he does not, he has not yet learned to tell a story about the way people feel about each other.
And that's what stories are about.
I mean, stories are not just about this guy did this.
You know what this was?
It was like a dramatized documentary.
It was a dramatized documentary, so well dramatized.
So anyway, if you want to see, well, since we're talking about stuff I like, I think I've recommended this once before, but it's worth saying again.
If you want to see a really fine film about war, take a look at the Dawn Patrol, 1938.
This is Basil Rathbone, David Niven, and Errol Flynn.
Errol Flynn is the big star of this.
It was written by a guy who was an American writer, John Saunders, who said to the fact that he couldn't get into combat as a flyer with the U.S. Air Force, so he wrote about this.
And what I've always loved about this film is it's almost a comedy about the fact this is World War I, people flying in World War I, and the flyers in World War I would just get shot out of the sky constantly and they were just constantly being killed.
And they sing a song in this movie, Hurrah for the next man who dies.
And everything is a joke.
They just turn everything into a joke.
And it works in kind of a reflective way that because these guys are always drinking and always kidding around, you start to realize they're going to die.
They're on death's edge all the time.
And here's a scene where David Niven as a flyer has been shot down and somehow he makes his way back from behind enemy lines.
He makes his way back to the tavern where Errol Flynn greets him and they're all drinking and getting drunk.
But what he doesn't realize is the guy who shot him down, the German who shot him down, is being held prisoner in this tavern and has been allowed to get completely smashed.
They love him.
They're being friendly.
They don't care.
You know, it's not about, it's not personal.
And it's just a great depiction of men in war living for the moment.
And it really is intense.
a brief scene of that tavern scene and the stretcher bear are pouring some rum down my thought you should have some of that rum you didn't have it you didn't just a couple of drops but i stopped for some refreshment on the way back and i brought these come on open them up what's that Well, that's the man that brought you down.
Who?
Introducer Monifabes, this is the Herr, whom you brought here.
The Herr brought here?
Yes.
Yes.
Oh, oh, oh, oh.
That would be a very big thing.
That would be me very.
You are my friend.
You are my friend.
What do I say?
I don't know, right?
He just wants him to have a drink.
Oh, drink!
Drink!
Bach drinks!
Don't waste it, so that's it.
It's just the drinking and the fight, and it's all like so much fun, except it's all about death.
The whole movie's about death.
It's really good and great flying footage, some of the best flying footage ever.
Dawn Patrol.
Tomorrow, we have Carrie Lucas on, who you may not have heard of, but she is a woman who runs the Independent Woman's Voice, which is trying to fight back against take care of me feminism by teaching women about the value of liberty and free markets.
So that should be an interesting conversation.
I will be here as well, so that'll be a little less interesting.
But I'll do my best.
I'm Andrew Clavin.
This is the Andrew Clavin Show.
We'll see you then.
Export Selection