All Episodes
Jan. 20, 2022 - The Joe Rogan Experience
03:12:06
Joe Rogan Experience #1767 - James Lindsay
Participants
Main voices
j
james lindsay
02:00:32
j
joe rogan
01:04:39
Appearances
j
jamie vernon
02:00
k
klaus schwab
01:24
| Copy link to current segment

Speaker Time Text
unidentified
Joe Rogan Podcast, check it out!
The Joe Rogan Experience.
Train by day, Joe Rogan Podcast by night, all day!
Hello, Joe.
james lindsay
Hello, Joe.
unidentified
Good to see you.
joe rogan
You heterodox individual, you.
james lindsay
I am very heterodox.
joe rogan
I like to use that word because I never use that word.
james lindsay
Well, you used it properly.
joe rogan
I just did.
I think it's the first time I've ever used it on the podcast.
james lindsay
Yeah, definitely not orthodox.
unidentified
Yeah.
joe rogan
So tell me what you were just telling me about a conference.
We were having a conversation where I was saying, I wonder how many undercover feds have either gotten on the podcast or tried to get on the podcast.
james lindsay
Yeah, it's like I've had a couple places.
One, I had this guy come up to me and we were like just in the crowd, right?
It wasn't like I just got off stage or anything like that.
And he comes up to me and he's like, you know, if we had to narrow it down to, like, you know, the top 10, 12 individuals pulling all this crazy stuff that's going on in the world, could you name who they are?
Like, who are they?
And the question is, you know, what are we going to do about them?
You know, are we going to have to take them out?
You know, are we going to have to go off?
When do we get to go off?
It was, like, the statement.
When do we get to go off on them?
Like, that violence is...
joe rogan
Are we going to have to take them out?
james lindsay
Going to have to take them out.
Like, I'm looking at this guy thinking you're not taking anybody out, but...
joe rogan
But what are you doing?
Like, what is this?
james lindsay
Yeah, like, why are you asking me this question?
I had another guy.
I did a talk.
And this was a totally awesome event.
Like, there's a mechanical bull in the venue.
Like, it was nuts.
And I'm doing this, like, professional talk and everything.
It was nuts.
And this guy's drunk afterwards.
I don't know.
Probably he's just drunk.
Maybe he's not.
And he's like, I wanted to ask you one question, man.
And I was like, what is it after I talked?
And he was like...
When do we get to start shooting them?
And I was like, holy shit, dude, no.
You know, we don't.
Like, that's the trap, if anything.
Like, you don't.
joe rogan
Do you think that guy was just crazy?
Or do you think that guy was a fed?
And how do you know the difference?
james lindsay
That's the question.
I don't know.
I actually suspect that guy was just drunk and shooting off at the mouth and frustrated.
But I don't know.
And then the weirdo guy that was like, if we could narrow it down to who are the...
Because that guy wouldn't leave me alone.
The guy I told you about first, like, he wouldn't leave me alone.
It's like he just kept asking questions and like trying to talk to me and I was like, huh.
joe rogan
That Epps guy that everyone has decided was an agent provocateur that was at the January 6th thing, they still haven't found that guy.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
Or excuse me, they still haven't charged that guy.
james lindsay
Haven't charged that guy.
unidentified
Yeah.
james lindsay
Very suspicious circumstances around that.
joe rogan
The weirdest, right?
james lindsay
Right.
unidentified
Right.
james lindsay
Like, let's just, you know, we'll have him on the list of people we're interested in.
And then people are going to say, you know, we're all screaming.
He's a Fed.
He's a Fed.
And then there's all this video of him doing weird stuff and people saying Fed, Fed, Fed.
And then all of a sudden they're like off the list.
He's not on the wanted list anymore.
joe rogan
Yeah.
Not wanted, not being charged.
It's so odd.
james lindsay
While other people are rotting in jail.
joe rogan
Yeah.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
Well, then when Ted Cruz grills the FBI lady and she's like, I can't answer that.
I can't answer that.
james lindsay
The answer to those questions is very simple.
No, no, no.
And she's like, I can't answer that question.
joe rogan
Did the FBI or any agents incite violence?
I can't answer that.
What?
james lindsay
I mean, I understand the Fifth Amendment.
Nobody can be compelled to incriminate themselves.
But...
joe rogan
Does the Fifth Amendment even apply when you're a representative of an organization?
Because it's a different scenario.
She's a representative of the FBI. It's not like she's incriminating herself.
james lindsay
Right, yeah.
I don't even know in that case, but that looked bad.
joe rogan
It looks strange.
It's like, what are you doing?
Like, all those questions, did they incite violence?
Like, you should never be inciting violence.
You're the FBI. You're the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
You shouldn't be inciting violence ever.
That should be, we didn't never do that.
james lindsay
Yeah, that's the opposite of what we do, right?
That's literally the opposite of what we exist to do.
joe rogan
We're completely not interested in that.
james lindsay
Yeah, but no, that's not the answer.
I'm sorry, I can't answer that question.
I can't answer that question either.
I'm just going to give that answer to all of your hard questions.
joe rogan
I can't answer that.
I have been trying really hard not to go down a Klaus Schwab rabbit hole.
james lindsay
Oh buddy, we're probably going to do that.
joe rogan
Oh my god, someone sent me a video of Klaus Schwab introducing Xi Jinping the other day.
Have you seen that?
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
Jamie, pull that up because Klaus Schwab, now I do not know, I know very little about Klaus Schwab.
james lindsay
I've read his book.
joe rogan
But he seems like a bad guy in a Batman movie.
james lindsay
He came straight out of Central Casting or something.
It's not even James Bond, though.
It's like a spoof.
joe rogan
It's so over the top.
james lindsay
And he's wearing a space suit when he's not wearing his business suit or whatever.
It's like, what is this guy?
joe rogan
He wears a space suit?
james lindsay
Have you not seen the space suit?
joe rogan
No.
james lindsay
Oh, man.
It's like this leather thing with like a triangle.
Oh, it's really...
Yeah, it's freaky.
joe rogan
Now, what does he do?
james lindsay
He is the, I guess, chairman, CEO of this thing called the World Economic Forum, which is like a billionaire's club where fancy pants people like, you know, titans of industry, government officials, NGO people, all the big philanthropists can show up and like rub elbows at Davos and chill out.
And basically it's like...
It's like a big country club for, like, the biggest players in government.
unidentified
What?
james lindsay
Space suit.
joe rogan
What the fuck?
What is that?
james lindsay
He's so weird.
joe rogan
He wears that all the time?
james lindsay
Well, I mean, he's got a suit and tie at other times.
I don't know how often he wears it.
I don't know the guy, but look at that.
unidentified
What?
joe rogan
What is that?
james lindsay
Like, I wouldn't even wear that on Halloween.
joe rogan
What does the caption say there?
jamie vernon
It's just someone's tweet.
joe rogan
See if you can find the video of him introducing Xi Jinping, because he gives this bizarrely glowing introduction to the leader of the Chinese Communist Party.
Listen to this.
james lindsay
Look at it.
It's a Bond villain.
joe rogan
Yeah.
klaus schwab
Human destiny.
joe rogan
Give it to me from the beginning.
I want to hear the whole thing.
klaus schwab
Human destiny.
joe rogan
Oh, okay.
klaus schwab
In the last five years, the world has become more interconnected than ever.
But in many ways, it's becoming even more fragmented and polarized.
unidentified
Polarized!
klaus schwab
China has made significant economic and social achievements under your leadership.
In the first three quarters of 2021, China's economy grew by over 9%.
You have achieved a historic goal to become a moderately prosperous society in all respects.
Mr. President, I strongly echo your remarks in 2017 that mankind has made progress by surmounting difficulties.
And when encountering difficulties, we should join hands and rise to the challenge.
I believe this is the best time for leaders to come together and work jointly For the world to become more inclusive, more sustainable, and more prosperous.
We now welcome His Excellency Xi Jinping, President of the People's Republic of China.
unidentified
Professor Klaus Schwab.
Ladies and gentlemen, friends.
james lindsay
Is that not...
joe rogan
So weird.
james lindsay
And you know who spoke like right after that, right?
joe rogan
Who?
james lindsay
Fauci.
joe rogan
No.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
Really?
Yeah.
Whoa.
james lindsay
And if you listen, actually, I don't think we should try to deal with listening to all of what Xi says, but he's like, you know, he goes into this whole thing.
It's like a paraphrase of Lenin.
He's all like, you know, there's an old Chinese saying.
That everything contains its contradictions.
That's actually an old Marxist saying is that everything contains its contradictions.
The Taoists don't – I mean they have that with the yin-yang thing but they don't really have everything contains its own contradiction.
They say things contain their opposites which is different.
And so Marx was like everything contains its own contradiction which capitalism makes a lot of wealth but then it makes a lot of poor people so it's got its own contradiction.
And he says we got to lean into the – she said – to paraphrase him, we got to lean into the contradictions.
What Lenin said when people were starving, like he's like literally starving people and killing people.
He's like accelerate the contradictions because if you make them see how terrible life is by showing them the contradictions, oh, we're supposed to have this great society and look, you're suffering, you're starving.
Then they'll want to have a revolution.
And so it's like that's the thing that Schwab there just introduced was his speech about that.
He also says we can't think of ourselves anymore as like 190 little boats like the different countries of the world to solve problems like climate change or I guess COVID. That went real well.
And we got to think of ourselves as one big boat, like one world government or something.
And then – She is the guy that's the model for this.
And then we see Mr. Spacesuit there saying, I strongly echo your comments.
Prosperous.
unidentified
Prosperous.
james lindsay
The guy's weird.
I read his book.
He's got a book called COVID-19, The Great Reset.
He's got a few books, actually.
I've read some of his other ones, but I read all of that one.
And it's just corporate gobbledygook.
But what he says is that COVID-19 is the ideal window of opportunity, a very narrow window of opportunity to reset the whole world's economy.
And he wants to create this whole new world economy he calls stakeholder capitalism through what he calls a public-private partnership where he gets these government guys to sign up with his corporate dudes at Davos and make a partnership.
The UN is actually usually the public thing.
And then he's the corporate guy bringing them together in a world economic form to make public-private partnership.
But if we go back to Mussolini, what was his definition of fascism?
It's corporatism.
It is a fusion of the state and corporation.
and you're like, huh, what's going on here?
joe rogan
Well, this Great Reset thing is the big tinfoil hat conspiracy theory conversation, that we're experiencing the Great Reset, and that they crashed the economy on purpose.
I don't think that's true in terms of what they did to Los Angeles.
I think it's incompetence, and I think there's a bunch of people that wanted to do something That showed that they were trying to enact measures to protect people.
And in doing that, they crippled a lot of these restaurants and bars and small businesses.
And they did it because it didn't affect them at all financially.
Like, if it had any effect on them financially.
james lindsay
But it did in a lot of cases.
Like, look at how the billionaires are all way richer now.
unidentified
Right.
joe rogan
Right, but that's what I'm saying.
I'm saying the politicians.
If it had affected the politicians financially, then they would have never enacted those measures.
Like, if the politicians got paid based on how well the economy did in their city.
Like, say, if you're a mayor, and if your economy crashes, you lose all your money.
You would never see lockdowns.
You would never see, like, I have a friend, she lives in Mexico, and she was telling me that in Mexico, nothing's shutting down because the cartels won't allow it.
james lindsay
Right, right.
joe rogan
Because the cartels make a percentage of the money that these businesses get, so they get paid.
So if the businesses go under, the cartels don't make any money.
Jamie, you have COVID. Do you got the cough?
james lindsay
You got the breathe?
Everything's cough.
unidentified
Can't be coughing?
joe rogan
Can't be coughing in front of you?
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
It's dangerous times to just be out and out coughing.
james lindsay
It's almost attempted murder.
joe rogan
She was telling me that when they are in Mexico that nothing's shut down.
Everything's wide open.
All the restaurants, all the bars, nothing ever shut down.
And the reason why she said we're free is because of the cartel.
She was like LOL-ing when she said this.
james lindsay
Right.
Well, I mean what that tells you then is that there's either absolute disconnect with politicians or that they're being taken care of some other way.
That's the conspiratorial side, that there's money coming in some other way.
So their paycheck is not dependent upon the economy locally, but it's dependent on some other factor.
joe rogan
Well, in local government, it's depending upon taxes.
Like my friend, his brother works for the whatever COVID response thing in California.
And there was a conversation when they were shutting down outdoor dining at one point in time.
And he protested and he said, there is no evidence that there's any spread that's because of outdoor dining or any outdoor activities.
And she said, it's about optics.
james lindsay
Oh yeah, well.
joe rogan
So this was a conversation he had with a real public official who's in charge of making these decisions.
So this idea that it's all motivated by some conspiracy to reset the economy, I don't think that's the case.
I think what's going on is that there's a lot of incompetence and a lot of really dumb people, a lot of foolish people that are running some aspects of government.
Then you have people that are taking advantage of that.
And the billionaires are most certainly getting richer.
By definition, if you close mom-and-pop stores, where are people going to buy their stuff?
Well, they're going to have to go to Target.
They're going to have to go to the big places.
unidentified
Yeah.
james lindsay
And then if you can loot targets and you can shoplift at Walgreens or whatever, where are they going to go online?
Amazon.
And you can kind of see how all of these really crooked business practices can kind of multiply.
In this kind of an environment.
joe rogan
So do you think that places like San Francisco and areas of California where they've enacted these really fucking stupid laws where you can steal up to 900 and something dollars worth of stuff and they don't arrest you at all?
So people just grab stuff, they throw it in a bag and they walk right out the door and no one does anything to stop it.
Do you think that those laws are enacted knowing that they're going to kill these businesses?
Knowing that this is going to prop up Online businesses like Amazon and larger places that have the ability to do that.
james lindsay
Well, you know, I'm in my 40s, which means that I never underestimate any longer the depths of human stupidity.
So it is possible that they're just stupid and don't realize the extraordinarily obvious thing that literally everybody yells at them.
No, I actually – I'm inclined to believe that they know to some degree what they're doing and I wouldn't even be surprised to find out that there's some kind of weird backroom deals.
And that's what this new economy is supposed to be.
It's like we go back to Schwab.
His thing is he calls it stakeholder capitalism.
You don't care about the shareholder anymore because profit is too dangerous of a motive.
You care about these people that are called stakeholders.
They're going to tell you they're experts in environmental policy.
They're experts in health policy.
They're experts in – Trust the experts.
And social policy, you know how I feel about that.
These critical theories or whatever.
They're experts in best practices and governance.
And they've created these whole investment metrics called ESG metrics, environmental social governance.
I think we're good to go.
I think we're good to go.
We're not going to give you the favors anymore.
And so there's this perverse scoring system that's worked its way in, and the goal is to shift out of that.
Now, what are the politicians doing?
Well, I mean, we see obviously there's corruption somewhere.
We got insider trading happening in Washington.
That's like coming out all over the place.
joe rogan
No, no, no, that's fine.
unidentified
That should be allowed, the participating in the economy.
james lindsay
Yeah, it's like we should start letting the MMA guys, the UFC guys, bet on their own fights.
Why not?
joe rogan
You know, they used to have pool was something that you could bet on at casinos.
They did it once.
And when they did it, the guy who was the lowest seed won the tournament.
And it was embarrassing.
Like guys were like missing balls dead in the hole.
They were doing it on purpose because they bet against themselves.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
And they bet on this one guy.
unidentified
Right.
joe rogan
And they all chopped up the money.
james lindsay
How about that?
joe rogan
How crazy.
james lindsay
How wild that they might game a bad incentive structure.
joe rogan
Who's 15 to 1?
Interesting.
unidentified
Hmm.
joe rogan
Mm-hmm.
What do you think would happen if he won?
So they stopped.
Because pool players are kind of notoriously shady folks.
A little bit.
So they stopped doing that.
But yeah, that would definitely happen if fighters were allowed to bet on themselves.
But fighters do bet on themselves.
Because there's more money for them if they win in the long term of their career.
james lindsay
Correct, correct.
But there's not a whole lot of incentive.
Like you don't have some bookie over here who's going to make it up to you if you get your face messed up kind of on purpose.
joe rogan
People are worried about that though.
There is concern.
Like I'm sure the FBI has investigated boxing matches and stuff along those lines.
I guarantee they have.
james lindsay
They investigate a lot of things.
The Department of Justice is investigating moms and dads for showing up to school boards.
They're also investigating maybe some real crime, but not the guy that came here to Texas from Britain who shouldn't have been able to even get in.
joe rogan
What's that?
james lindsay
That guy that took the hostages at the synagogue.
joe rogan
Right.
Yeah.
I forgot about that because there's so many of these goddamn things happening.
james lindsay
Yeah.
This is really recent, right?
A million things.
It was like last week.
unidentified
Yeah.
joe rogan
Yeah.
james lindsay
Just like the other day.
joe rogan
So where did he come from?
james lindsay
He's British, but he's got a name that would indicate that he's Islamic.
But he's got a British accent as well.
And he came in from the UK and he was like eyeballs on him from MI5 or something like this.
You know, they knew he was a problem.
And he comes over to the U.S. Somehow he manages to get a firearm.
Next thing you know, he's at a synagogue taking hostages, doing whatever they do.
They deal with the situation and the FBI and the president come out and they're like, well, we don't know the motive.
The guy's screaming his motive while he's doing it.
And we have no idea why this happened.
And we have to do an investigation.
It's just the weirdest farcical thing.
And then meanwhile, the big joke that was going on the internet with it was, well, they didn't have time to catch this guy coming into the country because they were too busy investigating parents at school board meetings who were showing up because of that letter, right?
joe rogan
Trevor Burrus Which letter?
james lindsay
Trevor Burrus So somewhere in the – it's now been shown.
Like actual journalists – Azrin Amani, for example, I think it was leading on this – dug up proof that somebody in the Biden administration, maybe the Department of Education, maybe it was Cardona himself, gets this letter, this memo, and it goes to the National School Board Association, NSBA. And so they actually just send it back to the Biden administration and say – Parents are showing up at school boards.
There's all this violence and danger.
But it came from inside the house.
Sent it to the School Board Association, which most of its members didn't even know that this was happening, and a lot of them have disavowed it.
And then they send it back to the DOJ, and then Merrick Garland comes out and says that they're going to start watching parents at school board meetings like they're domestic terrorists.
And they have.
joe rogan
Now, I did hear about that, but is it because they're worried that there's going to come a time where a parent crosses a line and shows up armed and does something insane?
james lindsay
I mean, that's the perpetual justification for that kind of thing.
But at the same time, they literally sent out a memo to treat parents showing up at school board meetings as though they are domestic.
joe rogan
Not all parents.
Obviously, they want some parents to show up at school board meetings because they want to be active in...
james lindsay
I'm not sure that's the case anymore.
joe rogan
You don't think they want any parents showing up at school board meetings?
james lindsay
You think they think that it's all negative and that I mean, they is too big to say, you know, everybody everywhere.
But you actually saw that attitude, you know, in the governor's race in Virginia last year when, you know, Yunkin beat McAuliffe.
And did he beat McAuliffe?
I forget how it works out.
Terry McAuliffe, yeah.
And so – because Northam is the previous governor because Virginia has this weird rule where you can't be governor twice in a row.
joe rogan
Oh, really?
james lindsay
Yeah.
So they have to have two people each time.
And so anyway, McAuliffe came out and he said that they don't want – that parents shouldn't have a role in shaping curriculum and that they don't want that going on amid these huge scandals.
You know, they have this – exactly what people said would happen a number of years ago.
This kid claiming to be – it's clearly disturbed, claiming to be non-binary, wearing a skirt, goes in and rapes a ninth-grade girl in the bathroom.
Exactly what people said.
You remember back in like 2015, people were like, if you do the trans bathroom thing that way, we're going to see sexual assaults.
Well, that's exactly what happened.
And then the school's – like the school district covers it up.
joe rogan
They tried to tell the parents to keep their mouth shut about it.
james lindsay
Yeah, and they – All these activists showed up when the dad of the girl comes to this meeting or whatever and they provoke him and he like flipped out.
I don't remember if he hit somebody or if he just started screaming at me.
He might have hit somebody.
And then he becomes like, you know, the worst thing ever.
And then...
I mean there's a lot of stuff right now going on where they don't actually want parents involved.
They want to control the kids.
They think that the school is the professionals, the experts, and that they know the best policies for masks.
They know the best policies for curriculum.
That's where they're getting all this social-emotional learning and critical race theory and the queer theory, gender theory stuff rammed into the schools.
And they're like, no, parents, if you don't like this, you're not the experts.
You don't understand.
And you're seeing school boards where they're not taking public comments or they're limiting those rather significantly now because I don't think they do want parents speaking up.
I don't think they want parents involved at this point.
joe rogan
The thing about it is if you look at it reasonably, like if there was any other time in history, in the history of my life, And you thought of parents coming in to tell teachers how the kids should be taught.
You're like, well, what do the parents know?
But then when you see some of the ridiculous shit that kids are getting taught in school today, and then if you follow, like, libs of TikTok...
james lindsay
No kidding.
joe rogan
And you see some of these crazy groomer teachers.
james lindsay
Groomer teachers, yeah.
joe rogan
It's so bizarre.
It's so bizarre to see these people making these videos because they're doing it like out in the open.
They're like, we are going to teach your kids the right things.
We are going to teach your kids to respect us.
We are going to teach your kids whatever theories that they want.
And they're doing it in this weird, arrogant assertion that they're going to indoctrinate these children into their ideology, and they're literally mocking or taunting the parents that we're going to do this to your kids.
And I don't understand the motivation.
I don't understand why they would make those videos.
I don't understand why anybody would hire those people to be teachers and why they wouldn't fire them immediately upon seeing those videos.
I know they did fire that one teacher.
I think it was a professor who was talking about people who are attracted to underage people that we shouldn't call them pedophiles.
james lindsay
Yeah, that was a professor.
That's right.
joe rogan
Right.
james lindsay
Yeah, I'd forgotten about that.
joe rogan
She said we shouldn't call them pedophiles.
We should call them minor attracted.
james lindsay
Minor attracted persons, which the MAP, but the P in MAP should just stand for pedophile because that's what minor attracted means.
joe rogan
Well, this idea that you can be a pedophile but not act on it.
Which I guess is true.
I guess, for some reason, you could be attracted to children and not act on it.
The question is like, how does that happen?
Like, what is it about a human that would have that sick inclination to want to have a sexual interaction with a child?
Like, what is that?
james lindsay
Yeah, I have no idea.
It's got to be like some cycle of abuse.
Like, abuse generates abuse generates abuse.
joe rogan
Right.
james lindsay
Like, that's not a healthy thing.
Like, that's not good.
joe rogan
I wonder if there's, like, in the literature, if there's ever any instances of that happening without abuse.
james lindsay
Yeah, I don't know.
I do know how it got into schools.
That I've researched.
joe rogan
Please tell me how.
james lindsay
Well, I mean, a lot of people don't know that the radicals of the 60s...
There's this book.
It's called The Critical Turn in Education.
I've been doing a podcast series on this book.
It's written by a guy named Isaac Gottsman.
He's a Marxist education theorist from Iowa State.
And at the very beginning, it's like literally the first sentence of the book.
He says, well, where did all the radicals from the 60s go?
Well, they didn't go to yuppiedom.
They didn't go to – I forget what.
He lists a couple of things.
He says, no, they went to the classroom.
And so a lot of those radicals, those violent radicals, 68, 69, early 70s, we could name Angela Davis, for example, as a key figure, literally went to K-12 activism.
And through the 70s, they kind of prepared the ground.
By about 1985, though, what this so-called critical turn in education, which means critical theory, or as this Gotsman says, he says, we shouldn't call it critical theory.
We should call it what it is.
We call it critical Marxism.
By about 85, These guys have basically become dominant in terms of setting teacher college training.
So if you're going to go to teacher college somewhere, Marxists are teaching you how.
And they bring in this guy from Brazil.
His name is Paulo Freire, a straight-up Marxist educator.
I've read his books.
He quotes Marx.
He quotes Lenin.
He's like, this is how it should be.
He's got this total weird idea like – Teachers and students, kids, adults and children shouldn't have like a differential in power.
They should be like equals with one another, which is a terrible idea because kids need structure and boundaries and especially in a learning environment.
joe rogan
Why would anybody – what's the motivation behind that?
james lindsay
The goal is to train them in what he calls conscientization.
I didn't say that right.
It's a hard word to say and here we are.
But to raise in them what's called a critical consciousness, which is a Marxist consciousness of oppression in society.
Basically, he's looking around and he says people are going to realize that they're dependent based on the society that they live in.
And rather than saying, OK, maybe you are, you know, maybe you're working a shit job, maybe you're stuck.
Let's teach you responsibility how to take control of your own life and, you know, raise yourself up and work hard and put your head down or whatever.
He says, no, we're going to go the collective route instead of the individual route.
We're going to try to have a revolution.
Freire famously says in this book from 85, which brought him into the U.S., a book called The Politics of Education, he says that the revolution, meaning The communist revolution has to be perpetual.
He says if a revolution ceases to be a revolutionary, it becomes a status quo.
And so he says as you awaken to this critical consciousness, this conscientization, which I still can't say – well, I've even got it stuck in Portuguese in my head.
I don't read Portuguese but it's usually not translated and I can say that worse.
Like that's way bad if I try that one, consciência tchau or something like that.
Anyway, it means to awaken to consciousness.
And so their goal by the mid-'80s in education was to start turning education more and more and more along this erase all power differentials, awaken a consciousness, and this queer theory stuff fits right within that.
So you're doing that at the identity level by breaking down the barriers between gay and straight, male and female, etc.
So it latches right into that.
In fact, the communists have been using He's like, let's sexualize the kids.
This has been a thing that they've done throughout – It's a lot of communist attempts whether in the 20s and 30s and then again in the 60s with Herbert Marcuse leading like the sexual liberation kind of side of Marxism through the 60s and they're doing it again.
And so these people are Marxists.
They started to take over education schools and they're not going to say no to this stuff when it comes knocking on the door.
So this book again Critical turn in education says it went in three stages.
First, there was Marxist critiques in education.
Then by the mid-80s and early 90s, the post-structuralist feminists took over the critique of education, and that's where they brought the queer stuff in.
And I mean queer with like official queer theory.
I'm not doing the – just to be clear for the people who hate us.
unidentified
Look at the queer stuff.
james lindsay
Yeah, the queer stuff.
Which, by the way, the definition of that is an identity without an essence.
I did this podcast about this paper by Hannah Dyer.
She wrote a paper in 2016 about queer futurity in education, something, early childhood education.
And she says in there explicitly that the point of queer theory is not to create a stable LGBTQ identity.
It's in fact to not have stable identities at all because those become the status quo.
And that would be the problem.
So you have to be constantly overturning that.
I don't know if you know who Dan Savage is.
It gets better, that guy.
The whole last third of the paper is criticizing it gets better, saying, well, that means he's just admitting that it's bad for kids.
It's this message of hope that was super effective at curbing kids.
joe rogan
And it gets better means reaching out to young gay kids to tell them that there's going to come a point in time where it's going to feel okay.
james lindsay
It's going to be better.
joe rogan
You'll find your community.
There's a lot of us out there.
james lindsay
It's awkward now.
Life's weird.
It's hard.
Maybe it's harder for you because of some stuff you didn't sign up for.
And it gets better, man.
Don't give up.
It gets better.
And he even has this messaging in there like it's going to make you stronger.
You know, it's super positive, actually.
And so she just takes him to task for this.
So this is the post-structural feminists turned into the queer theorists.
They got eaten up by Judith Butler coming along and saying, well, if gender is a social construct, well, maybe sex is a social construct, too.
joe rogan
Have you heard Douglas Murray talk about this?
james lindsay
A little bit, yeah.
joe rogan
Well, he talks about the end of civilizations.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
Yeah, and when civilizations start to crumble, they become obsessed with gender.
james lindsay
Yeah, androgyny and, yeah, the whole thing.
And homonormativity over heteronormativity, he's got a whole thing about that.
Like, they're trying to normalize that which is abnormal.
And that's really the definition of queer theory.
joe rogan
What's funny, it's fascinating that...
See, Douglas has a free pass because he's gay, and he's brilliant.
So when he talks about these things, they don't know what to do.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
Like when he starts talking about these considerable issues when it comes to trying to figure out what's what, he can kind of get away with stuff.
And when he explains that at the end of all these civilizations with the Roman...
Civilization, the Greek Empire, they all started falling into this thing where they wanted to redefine gender.
unidentified
They do, yeah.
james lindsay
You can actually see it in like the statues and stuff.
joe rogan
Yeah.
It's really interesting.
james lindsay
They go from being like these super buff dudes and like sexy babes and then, you know, all of a sudden they all look like, you know, an anime character or something.
I don't know.
They look like NPCs eventually is what they look like.
joe rogan
It's such a weird time because everything has happened so rapidly.
And it really is from the onset of social media.
If you go back to pre-social media to what the world was like to today, the change has been so radical.
james lindsay
Oh yeah, it's crazy how fast it is.
I mean, think about it.
We're totally connected to one another.
We can form our alliances now worldwide.
Based on what we think, what we agree with, what we think is funny, what we don't, rather than, oh yeah, we all happen to be in Texas, so we've got to get along.
joe rogan
Also, the amount of people that are interacting on social media is not like, you know, I did a bit about it last night.
It's not the large percentage of the population.
It's a small percentage of the population that's shaping the The way the culture thinks about things because they're the ones that are talking the most.
james lindsay
Right.
joe rogan
And so these are people that are obsessed people.
james lindsay
Obsessed.
joe rogan
Obsessive.
james lindsay
Obsessives.
joe rogan
Yeah.
james lindsay
And socially awkward ones, too.
joe rogan
Yeah, a lot of them.
Yeah.
james lindsay
You know, we don't...
I know I'm going to sound like Jordan Peterson with the whole, you know, we don't know the effects that this will bring...
But really, we don't.
We suddenly went from, with the advent of social media, we went from an era where extroverts, by kind of definition, kind of ruled the public sphere.
Introverts did a lot of important work.
We're not to discount that.
But once you get them online...
Now introverts have this hugely expanded voice while extroverts are out doing cool stuff and they're not on the internet.
And then you add in people with social anxiety issues.
Well, they're not out hanging out and going to the bar because they have social anxiety.
What are they doing?
They're on the internet yelling at people.
joe rogan
Yeah.
james lindsay
And then you get certain ones of these people who are absolute obsessives.
And I'll tell you about this fanatic thing, this obsessives.
So the military, it turns out Eisenhower after World War II was like, all right, these black soldiers fought like hell for us.
We're going to desegregate the military.
This is way before the schools or any other thing.
We're going to do this.
And so they're like, how do we integrate the units, right?
How do we do this?
And so they started this thing with these different approaches to diversity training, what we would recognize as so-called diversity training now.
And the first program they had, they called it putting them on the hot seat.
And what they would do is they would basically do what diversity training in workplaces does now.
Some guy down there and make him confess all of his different racist ideas and then have like a lesson about it and like everybody would have to confess their racist stuff and they put the black people there and like, oh, I've always thought this bad stuff about you.
And what they found out was that for a small percentage of the group, it worked.
It made them more aware of these attitudes and biases and what a jerk they're being, and it worked.
And then for most of the people, they actually had way less of a problem with race than anybody was assuming, and it didn't really do anything.
Plus, it's all just kind of a waste of time and nobody likes administrative BS anyway.
They just want to do the stuff.
But then for another small segment, maybe about – I don't know what percentage, so I don't want to make some number up, but some small percentage, they literally became fanatics.
That's the word in the report.
They became fanatics who wouldn't do anything except go around and call everybody racist all the time for everything.
unidentified
Stop it.
james lindsay
Twitter!
Yeah, it was so bad that they had to cancel the program.
And that's right.
That's exactly right.
It's Twitter.
And so, you know, these obsessives...
I just mentioned, you know, post-structural feminism working into the critical turn in education or whatever.
Critical race theory, by the way, is the third step, Gotsman says, is the turn to education.
But...
I just mentioned that, but they were the bloggers, man.
Back in, like, 08, 09, it was like every blog in the universe was some feminist woman bitching about something.
And, like, bitching about somebody and bitching about, you know, why can't we grow out our armpit hair?
Why can't we stink?
Why can't we wear, you know, whatever clothes we want?
Why can't we do this?
Why can't we do that?
And it's patriarchy, patriarchy.
These people, there's your obsessives, right?
joe rogan
Yeah.
james lindsay
And they totally dominated that blog sphere when before, like, there was like pre-social media or barely social media time.
And that's where everybody was, like, sharing these ideas.
And so these obsessives gained an extraordinarily outsized voice.
Now, have you heard of renormalization?
joe rogan
No.
james lindsay
Okay, this is a big idea because it's the idea that a very small...
That group of extremely intolerant people can change a very large number of normal people.
So 3% or 4% being just absolutely intolerant can move the entire needle.
And the way it works – the example – I saw this video on YouTube, so I'm stealing this.
The way it works though is like you can imagine like a family of four and you got like, you know, the daughter or whatever decides she's vegan.
The teenage daughter, she's like, I'm vegan now.
And so like whoever's cooking, the parents are like, well, I can cook two meals or I can, you know, get in a fight every night at dinner or I can just cook some vegan stuff.
Right?
And all of your options are basically, unless you're going to go kind of like hard-nosed, all of your options are kind of bad except just keep the peace and that's it.
Be soft.
Be nice.
Keep the peace.
No struggle.
Don't offend anybody, right?
And So now your whole family's cooking vegan meals.
So now the neighborhood has a barbecue.
You got one girl who's actually vegan.
Whole family's eating vegan and they're like, well, we need vegan options.
And so now the barbecue of the neighborhood's like, well, we got to do something for the Johnsons down the street.
You know, they're vegans now.
And so what can happen is like the whole neighborhood now has to accommodate vegans, but there's one vegan, right?
And you can just see how this expands out.
This process is called renormalization.
So when you have this small contingent of obsessives, Which these people who are in these Marxist ideologies – woke Marxism is what I – I don't even call it woke anymore.
I call it woke Marxism.
Woke Marxists are completely obsessives, and they're completely intolerant.
Anything but their way is sexist, racist – Probably capitalist, patriarchal, and you are the worst kind of person and the dumbest person and probably crazy for not going along with them.
And they can renormalize an entire, say, social media platform, at which point they have this massive amount of dominance over the national discourse.
joe rogan
Well, especially if that kind of ideology gets into the administration of that social media platform, which it has on basically all of them.
My friend Giannis Papas just got a strike against his account on YouTube.
And I'm going to read you the transcript of what they struck, because this is wild shit.
Because it's gotten to the point where it doesn't have to have anything to do with It has nothing to do with bullying, nothing to do with hate.
He's just joking around about stuff.
And he makes a point, or he makes a joke that is essentially...
You know, I mean, he's just being silly about the gay pride parade.
And he said, I support gay rights, but can we move the gay parade tonight so I can explain gay rights to my daughter without having to see your asshole before noon?
That's a joke.
It's just a joke.
They gave him a strike on his account for that.
I mean, this is wild shit.
And then there was another one that he had that was about...
There was another one that he had about...
I think it was about Justin Bieber or something like that.
Which was even more...
Yeah, here it is.
Bieber's old N-word.
jamie vernon
Yeah, this is what he posted.
joe rogan
Yeah, that's it.
But look, go down below.
Look here.
Yeah, that's it.
It's the top one.
Jared, I like to hum myself.
I like melodies.
I like to sing.
That's my thing, son.
But I don't discriminate against any music.
You know, play Hootie, play Leonard Skinner, play whatever.
I'm down for it.
What the fuck is that?
How is that in any way?
How is that the thing that they highlighted as something that YouTube is going to ban?
That doesn't even make any sense.
james lindsay
That's nuts.
joe rogan
Play Hootie, play Leonard Skinner, play whatever, I'm down for it.
What the fuck is that?
How could anybody think that that is offensive?
That makes no sense.
james lindsay
That makes no sense.
I thought my example was like crazy.
I got dinged for saying that onion rings cure COVID. That should be so obviously parody.
joe rogan
But Giannis, the thing is, is he's a male...
Comedian.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
And, you know, he jokes around about shit.
He's a very open-minded guy.
He's very progressive.
He's very intelligent.
And they're somehow or another lumping him in with, like, a bad person or with alt-right or whatever.
james lindsay
That's the game, man.
joe rogan
That is the game.
I mean, it happens with fucking smart people.
james lindsay
Right.
joe rogan
Smart people use that pejorative.
Oh, these alt-right people.
I'm like, stop.
You're talking about people that aren't even remotely alt-right.
Like, don't do that.
james lindsay
Yeah, yeah, exactly.
I mean, that was a whole thing.
Like, you know, we had just the other day here on the show, you had the, you know, Tim Pool's alt-right or whatever it was.
joe rogan
Josh Zeps, yeah.
james lindsay
It wasn't quite that.
joe rogan
He said that to try to diminish what Josh Zeps has been saying about Australia because he works for Australian media and he's trying to be nice-nice over there.
james lindsay
No, I hear you.
Australia's scaring the shit out of me, though, I'll tell you that.
joe rogan
It should.
You know, and it didn't, Josh, and he lives there, and I think, you know, sometimes people, when they work for an organization that is going along with the government's rules and guidelines, and they think everything's good and fine, and you don't live in Australia, so you don't know.
We're all vaccinated, so we're free, and you're wrong, and this is right.
Like, you're not convincing me by telling me that people like Majid Nawaz are alt-right.
That is fucking nonsense.
james lindsay
Right, totally.
joe rogan
That's so dumb.
It's so crazy to call him alt-right.
And to call Tim Poole alt-right as well.
Tim is, if anything, he's a centrist.
He's just a guy who...
He was like a boots-on-the-ground journalist for Vice.
james lindsay
Yeah, he was all up in Occupy.
joe rogan
He was an Occupy Wall Street guy.
Yeah.
james lindsay
He was like right there.
joe rogan
I know Tim very well.
He's not alt-right at all, but he'll entertain a conversation with anybody.
james lindsay
He will.
joe rogan
Like he had, okay, he had O'Keefe from Project Veritas on the other day.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
And that's like, that guy's the boogeyman to the left.
You can't, like even if what he's saying is a fucking threat, he's exposing threats to democracy.
unidentified
Yeah.
joe rogan
He's exposing real live corruption.
He's exposing real live conspiracies.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
And they're like, oh, no, but it's Veritas.
james lindsay
But it's Veritas, yeah.
joe rogan
They've somehow or another decided that an individual can be, like, you could, it's almost like a cure to the reality of whatever he's exposing.
Like, you could say, oh, it doesn't matter because it's James O'Keefe.
And you can put that on top of the thing and it all goes away.
james lindsay
Yeah, exactly.
joe rogan
It's wild!
james lindsay
It's extremely wild.
I mean, that's the, I mean, that's, again, your show, Blue Open Mass Formation Psychosis.
joe rogan
Well, that's not a thing.
Don't you know that's not even a thing?
james lindsay
Well, yeah, I saw that.
joe rogan
It's not even a real thing.
james lindsay
I mean, there's books like back to the 1800s about it, but it's not a thing.
But it's not real.
joe rogan
It's not real.
james lindsay
It's not real.
unidentified
It's fake.
joe rogan
Well, there's a certain psychologist that went to a college, and he told me it's not a thing.
So there's that.
james lindsay
Yeah.
You know...
joe rogan
It's for sure, whatever you want to call it.
james lindsay
Like something's going on where people get to feel morally superior, whether they're execs at Instagram or interns or whoever knocks down that account.
And they get to be morally superior.
Or, you know, look at this drop Veritas just did.
Like, I don't know if that thing that they just did with the COVID is...
Like, panned out or not.
But if it did, that's...
Like, somebody should probably be looking into that, you know?
joe rogan
What's fascinating is how it is completely 100% ignored by the left-wing media.
james lindsay
It's like it doesn't exist.
joe rogan
Fox is the only people covering it.
And how much...
Is Fox covering it quite a bit?
james lindsay
I don't watch TV, so I don't know.
Tucker's talked about it.
joe rogan
Tucker's talked about it.
But if you look on left-wing media, Rachel Maddow and...
james lindsay
Oh, it doesn't exist.
joe rogan
It doesn't exist.
It's not...
Even if you think it's a lie, you have to cover it.
It's a significant issue.
We need to get to the bottom of it.
Are these documents true?
Are they correct?
james lindsay
Yeah, exactly.
Is it true that this leaked, according to the document, that this leaked COVID-19?
It leaked actually not in November, December, whatever it was.
But in August, is it true that it was created in these patents?
Is it true that they knew that hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin and the other things you're not allowed to say anywhere could work as curatives?
Because that's in – I don't know all the facts.
I don't even claim to.
But I know that's in the document.
I read the document.
joe rogan
Not only that, this concerted effort by a group of these people, Francis Collins and Fauci and all these people, to try to demonize these distinguished intellectuals.
james lindsay
The Great Barrington?
Yeah.
joe rogan
Oxford, Harvard.
james lindsay
Lots of lunatic extremists there, right?
joe rogan
Guys who are experts in their field.
james lindsay
Total fringe guys, Oxford.
Who's ever heard of that crap hole?
joe rogan
It's so strange.
And meanwhile, left-wing media ignores.
Ignore, ignore.
Didn't happen.
Didn't happen.
Absolutely didn't happen.
The only people that you can trust that are left-wing are the independent people.
And that's why it's so strange.
It's the strangest time ever.
james lindsay
It really is.
joe rogan
It's wonderful for independent people.
Because for people like Crystal and Sagar from Breaking Points, it's opening the door.
For people like The Hill, like Kim Iverson, it's opening the door for people to expose these things.
So you get a chance to see these independent people rise.
And then more people go, hey, you've got to listen to this lady talk about this.
She explains it in very rational, factual terms.
And now people will pay attention to Kim Iverson.
Now people will pay attention to Crystal and Sagar.
james lindsay
I watched Kim this morning.
As a matter of fact, she did a thing.
I don't know when she did it because it's on the internet.
So who the hell knows when the actual video was.
A YouTube video got sent to me.
And it's Kim Iverson.
And they were like, what's on your mind, Kim?
She has a little segment on her show.
And she was like, The Great Reset.
And she's like, here's some key things to know about it.
And it has bullet points on the screen.
And it's like, number one, it's real.
It's like...
Okay.
Just to kind of tie that knot a little bit tighter, though, we're talking about CNN. The media won't talk about these things.
It just vanishes.
So do you know Klaus Schwab has a new book after COVID-19, The Great Reset?
You know what it's called?
joe rogan
What?
james lindsay
I shit you not.
It's called The Great Narrative.
Yeah, right?
I haven't read that yet.
joe rogan
Where's his background?
I never heard of him until like a month ago.
james lindsay
It's very hard to find out about his background, actually.
If you look him up, it's all shadowy.
joe rogan
I was born in a cave.
james lindsay
Yeah, something like that.
I've heard stories about his parentage that probably shouldn't be repeated on air because we don't know what they are.
unidentified
Somewhere in the middle of the earth is a secret laboratory where I was born.
james lindsay
Yeah, but he's been doing this since the 70s.
It wasn't called the World Economic Forum in 71, but that's when he wrote his first thing to try to come up with this stakeholder capitalism scam that he's worked out and tried to foist on the world.
And so The Great Reset, obviously people are like, wait, what is this bullshit?
It's like it's not going well for them.
So now he comes out with a book, The Great Narrative.
And then you look at what CNN's doing, you look at all the left-wing media, MSNBC, you're like...
And that's been the hot word of a year, right?
The narrative, the narrative.
What is it?
January 6th has a narrative.
Everything has a narrative.
joe rogan
What do you think the people that are on the talking heads that are on these networks, how do you think that works?
Do you think they get informed as to what the narrative is, what they're allowed to and not allowed to discuss?
james lindsay
I know they're getting lists of things they're not allowed to discuss.
joe rogan
How do you know this?
james lindsay
Because I know somebody who went on TV and got yelled at for it.
I can't verify it.
The guy told me in person.
joe rogan
What did he say he got yelled at for?
james lindsay
I'll even tell you who the guy is.
We're going to name one of those names you're not allowed to name.
Mike Lindell.
The MyPillow guy?
joe rogan
Oh.
james lindsay
I met him at Mar-a-Lago last year.
joe rogan
He's a little silly.
james lindsay
He is.
But he said that what got him, he is, in fact.
joe rogan
He's quite a bit silly.
james lindsay
Yeah.
Apparently, if you get the pillows, you have to put them in the dryer to activate them.
I don't know what that's about.
unidentified
Activate them?
james lindsay
I don't know what this is about.
joe rogan
Wait a minute.
What are you saying?
james lindsay
I've heard that the pillows, I'm not supposed to like, I don't want to like piss on the guy's business, but I heard the pillows suck.
And then if you put them in the dryer, they're really good.
joe rogan
What are you talking about?
It's just a pillow.
james lindsay
No, it's just a pillow.
joe rogan
How could it change when you put it in a dryer?
james lindsay
Who knows?
It probably gets hot and, like, I don't know.
I don't have one.
joe rogan
Like, a hot pillow?
james lindsay
Like, all these other people I know have these, like, coupon codes to, like, go get your MyPillow.
joe rogan
Hold.
What is this?
The patented fill will lock into place when laying on your back, bunch MyPillow registered, Under the curve of your neck to get the right amount of support for you as an individual.
What does that mean?
As opposed to what, you as a group?
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
Before first use, place in a dryer for 10 to 15 minutes with a damp washcloth to activate the patented interlocking fill.
james lindsay
I have no idea how it works.
joe rogan
What is in there?
james lindsay
All I know is that he got, I saw him at Mar-a-Lago.
joe rogan
Let me see a picture of one of these fucking things.
What is the deal?
Is it just a foam pillow?
james lindsay
Holy shit, it's like in a little bag.
joe rogan
It comes in a bag?
james lindsay
It's like all the air sucked out of it.
joe rogan
Look at this!
Place pillow in a dryer for 15 minutes before first use.
It says it in the bag?
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
Have you ever seen one of these, Jamie?
jamie vernon
I have not purchased a MyPillow.
I have gone another route.
james lindsay
He has the slippers.
unidentified
What kind?
joe rogan
What do you got?
jamie vernon
Other pillows?
I don't fucking know.
joe rogan
I got one of these groovy foam ones.
It's like a hole for your head, and your head sits in there when it locks it in place.
james lindsay
Mine's like memory foam alongside and soft shit on top.
Oh, I love it.
joe rogan
Yeah, mine's some kind of memory foam too, but it's memory foam, but it's contoured to your head.
james lindsay
Yeah, it's got to be contoured or it'll ruin your life.
joe rogan
I fucked my neck up.
I got a really stiff, thick pillow, and I was sleeping on it for like a couple of weeks, but I was sleeping with my head kind of bent because it's so thick.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
And I got a kink on the left side of my neck, and I've been fucking rubbing it out every day.
james lindsay
I'll work that out for you later.
joe rogan
What are you, a massage therapist?
james lindsay
I was for 10 years, yeah.
unidentified
Wait, really?
james lindsay
I just retired my license this year, yeah.
joe rogan
No shit!
unidentified
Or last year.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
Okay.
Because what I've been doing is I use, like, we have this company that was a sponsor, Hyperice, and they have this ball.
It's called the Hypersphere.
It's the shit.
You press a button, it goes...
And then press another button, press it again, it goes...
And another button goes...
Like, same button, just keep pressing over and over again.
james lindsay
That was exactly that Spaceballs thing, by the way, that scene with the radar.
joe rogan
Oh, really?
james lindsay
Yeah, you did.
Sounds good.
joe rogan
Thank you.
So anyway, I get this vibrating ball, and I put it under my neck, and then I bridge on it.
So I get on there and really dig into it.
Yeah.
james lindsay
Is it working?
joe rogan
I'm an intense kind of guy.
Yeah, it does work.
james lindsay
You can be.
joe rogan
Yes.
james lindsay
You're pretty chill, too, though.
joe rogan
Most of the time.
I have a Switch.
I like to keep it under wraps.
james lindsay
I think most people do.
joe rogan
Yes, most people do, too.
james lindsay
So speaking of the switch, though.
joe rogan
So MyPillow guy.
james lindsay
MyPillow guy was flipping out.
I tried to just go up.
I thought, okay, let's go meet the guy.
Say hi.
Trump's over there.
Let's talk.
And, like, he's just mad.
And he's, like, ranting about his experience on the media.
And I don't know if it's on, like, Hannity or one of these guys.
He went on one of these Fox guys.
And they literally, on their desk, had a list of stuff that if the guest goes there, take it away.
And he went, like, just...
This was about the election fraud stuff that he got all...
unidentified
Oh, yeah.
james lindsay
And he went, like, balls to the wall into it.
And they, like, took his microphone from him and everything.
So there's a list of stuff they're not supposed to talk about.
joe rogan
Yeah, but that actually kind of makes sense because if you're running around saying the election was a fraud, that Donald Trump is the true president, they can get in trouble for that.
That's a real problem because you're promoting propaganda.
If you have that person on your network and you're putting it out on the airwaves, There's a faction of our country that really does believe that the true president is Donald Trump and that JFK Jr. is alive and he's gonna meet Donald Trump in the middle of fucking Dealey Plaza.
It's a bit thick there.
Yeah, but you know what I mean?
A lot of those QAnon dorks, they believe that stuff.
james lindsay
Right.
joe rogan
So if you go and start spouting out that kind of shit on TV, on Fox, that's bad for business.
Because people have this thing about Fox already.
james lindsay
Right, of course.
joe rogan
It's the home for less educated, loony people that are more inclined to believe in Pizzagate, right?
james lindsay
Yeah, like Texans.
unidentified
Yeah.
joe rogan
What?
james lindsay
No, I'm just kidding.
joe rogan
Hey!
Son of a bitch.
james lindsay
That'll teach you to move.
joe rogan
So when a guy like Mike Lindell, is that his name?
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
So when he goes on a network and he says a lot of wacky shit, he's said some wacky shit before, right?
james lindsay
Right.
He has, but, so has, I said last night, our friend, but I haven't met him yet, Alex Jones has said a lot of wacky shit.
joe rogan
You haven't met Alex yet?
james lindsay
No.
joe rogan
Oh, you need to meet Alex.
james lindsay
Yeah, we gotta get together.
joe rogan
Yeah, we need to make that happen.
james lindsay
Yeah, it'll be fun.
So anyway, I think that we – I actually believe that we should be having – and this is what the internet is causing is a lot of open dialogue about things, some of which is going to be wacky.
I actually no longer worry about misinformation.
I actually don't worry about it anymore.
I worry about propaganda, but I don't worry about misinformation.
And the reason I don't worry about misinformation is because if the ideas are out there and people are discussing them, one thing you find out is that stupid stuff gets shot down fast.
How do you know?
Look at the official narratives that got spun around COVID and look how fast internet sleuths were like, nope.
joe rogan
Like what?
james lindsay
Well, like hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin being things that you can take that might help.
Like people were figuring that out in like March of 2020 before it was even like a thing.
joe rogan
Right.
But there are a lot of people that don't believe in it, including doctors.
There's a lot of doctors.
Look, my doctor prescribed it.
I have several friends who have doctors that prescribe it.
But now they're having a really hard time finding it.
Even though it's an incredibly common medication, they're trying to actively stop people from taking it.
And there's certain doctors that they won't prescribe it for you.
You ask for it, they'll say, would he pay attention to Joe Rogan or something?
Like, they literally get upset about it.
james lindsay
Yeah, he's a Texan.
joe rogan
But there's...
Like, there's a long history of use of that stuff.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
But there's a large chunk of our country that believes that it's horse medication and that it's dangerous.
Yeah, I know.
And that there was a line of people waiting to get into an emergency room in Oklahoma for gunshot wounds because there were so many people there that were overdosing on ivermectin.
Rolling Stone said it.
Rachel Maddow said it.
It's 100% full of shit.
It never happened.
By the way, how many people are getting shot in Oklahoma?
What is this, the Wild West?
You got a line of people with gunshot wounds in their hands?
What the fuck are you talking about?
It doesn't even make sense.
james lindsay
I've been to Oklahoma City.
It's nice.
It's a great place.
No, but that's what I'm saying, though.
It's like so they've got the official narratives that they can put out.
And then I think that I'm not worried about misinformation.
In fact, I think that more information is generally better.
But then we have this ability for these ideas to compete and for ones not necessarily that are better, but often ones that are better, but also ones that are, you know, the danger is the ones that are more sticky or salient or interesting or that they get people's emotions going or whatever.
There are processes, though, there are selection processes to let ideas rise up to the top.
joe rogan
If they're not censored.
james lindsay
That's what I'm saying, right?
So that's what I'm saying is I don't think that we should be censoring these things.
Like if Mike Lindell, for example, is doing this gigantic...
Maybe it's all complete horseshit, but he's got the statistics and he's done all this thing and the voting machines and the Dominion and he's got all this shit.
He's put millions...
This maybe is a newsworthy thing, if for no other reason, so that it gets more eyeballs on it so people can say, this is where it's bullshit, this is where that falls apart.
It's where this stuff gets caught up in these little corners where it can fester that I worry more about bad info.
I want to see it as open as possible.
I'm not saying that Fox has to do whatever with its programming.
But I'm saying that it's better that we're having kind of a free information economy, if you will, than one that's – we've got the official gatekeepers of that, whether they're stupid – I almost said the F word – professors.
I'm really mad at professors, by the way.
joe rogan
These fucking professors.
james lindsay
Yeah, the other day I gave this talk.
joe rogan
I said it for you.
james lindsay
For these like very nice people and, you know, some of them were quite religious and they were like, just don't say the F word during your talk.
And I was like, okay, but what if it's like fucking commies?
And they're like, well, you can say fucking communist, but no other way.
What?
Yeah, if you say these fucking communists.
joe rogan
You can't say fuck you, you can say fucking communists?
james lindsay
Well, I mean, I could have said it.
It's like free speech, but they- They asked you not to swear.
Don't swear, but if communist is the next word.
So I'm like that with professors right now in many regards, but also these media heads.
Like I don't need an aristocracy telling me how ideas – which ideas are going to be true and false.
Now, as you know, we talked about postmodernism last time I was here with you.
I'm not exactly a postmodernist, but I listened.
I read that shit, right?
And I didn't just read it to like, oh, this is why these guys are wrong.
I read it, right?
I read Michel Foucault, for example, and he talks about how power works.
And he's got a lot of crazy shit in there because he's ultimately at the bottom of Marxist and so capitalism has to be the problem of everything.
But he's got a lot of stuff that we should be listening to right now.
What he's saying is if you have the official power – he's saying it's always this but I don't think that's true.
But if you have the official power of like the state and the media or whatever and they get to decide what's true, they impose like – A narrative of truth.
Like, there's these aristocrats, professors, media personalities, etc.
They get to decide what's true for everybody, and that's what we all have to nod our heads and go along with.
Uh-uh.
I don't like that.
I think that the aristocracy that we had in the 19th century was not a great thing.
In 17th century, 18th century, I don't think that was a great thing.
The serfs, you know, getting abused and whatever else.
I think we've got the exact same scenario going on in the information world right now.
And the Internet's breaking it free.
So guys like Alex Jones, breaking it free, and what do they do?
Turns out he was right about 93.5% of everything he said, except for maybe the Satan stuff, I don't know.
Interdimensional child molesters.
But he was right about an uncanny amount of stuff.
joe rogan
An uncanny amount of stuff.
james lindsay
And what did they do?
He was the first guy.
They sliced him off everything.
They shut him down off of all of the social media.
joe rogan
That was the beginning of this.
He was the beginning of this, and that was a guy that they felt they could justify because of Sandy Hook.
james lindsay
Yeah, exactly.
joe rogan
And so they used that, and then they used that to silence him, and then they moved forward from there and just started silencing all kinds of different people.
james lindsay
Right.
And so I look at that, and I think, no, I want the opposite of that.
So I'd rather have, you know, occasionally you end up with Mike Lindell on Fox News talking, like if Hannity wants, or whoever it was, I don't know, wants to have him on the show, like, let it freewheel.
Let his idea get out there.
And then, like, let's say it's 100% bullshit.
Let all these geniuses on the internet, because they're everywhere, and they don't have anything else to do, start crunching the numbers and be like, here's where he made his mistake.
joe rogan
The problem is that it dismisses the credibility of Fox News.
It diminishes the credibility of Fox News.
james lindsay
I don't think that they have any...
joe rogan
They do to people that like Fox News.
james lindsay
I I know, but that's the problem.
joe rogan
You don't think the Tucker Carlson show has credibility?
james lindsay
No, it does, actually.
But what I'm saying is, in general, I don't like this.
He's got a huge platform.
You also have a huge platform.
I'm getting a platform.
joe rogan
You're platformed right now.
james lindsay
I am.
Thank you for platforming me.
I feel so platformed.
No, but it's like I feel like we don't want to have a very relatively small number of characters that head these things up getting to determine what is going to be credible, true.
joe rogan
I agree with you.
When you're a person who's looking at this from the outside, you say this guy is on TV in front of millions of people and he's saying things that are absolutely not true that are in fact dangerous to democracy because he's saying that our elections are – they're invalid.
They're rigged.
They're fake.
Donald Trump should be the president.
And that allows all these other people that are doing, whether it's the people that are censoring folks on YouTube, the people that are censoring folks on Twitter, they look at this and go, see, this is why we have to do this.
james lindsay
No, I get that.
joe rogan
Because this kind of shit can get out and we have to stop this shit from getting out.
So if Hannity or whatever these guys – they can stop the most egregiously silly ideas or the provably untrue ideas.
Yeah, but – If they can stop that.
james lindsay
But we don't want like Rachel Maddow deciding that you can't take Horst to Wormer or that Joe Rogan's gray on CNN and – No, I'm not saying we do.
joe rogan
But I'm saying that the reason why they feel like they have to do this – No, you're right.
It's because of the fact that it's so easy to dismiss them right now.
Also, if you look at it from a perspective like strategy, there's one versus many.
They're kind of surrounded.
If you looked at Fox News, and I'm not saying, it's not a value judgment, like one's wrong or one's...
I'm just saying if you looked at the way their perspective on the right is represented in the news, there's fucking no one left.
OAN, that Wacky News Network, they just got kicked off of DirecTV.
james lindsay
Yeah, they just got kicked off TV. Yeah.
joe rogan
Well, they're still on Verizon and a few other of those cable, but DirecTV is huge.
james lindsay
Right.
Well, speaking of kicking people off, Mike Lindell just got his ability to bank shut down.
joe rogan
Tell me what you were saying earlier because you glossed over it but then you stopped.
You said he spent millions of dollars on this shit.
james lindsay
He's utterly convinced.
This is actually important about the democracy point you raised.
He's utterly convinced that there was...
You know, misfeasance with regard to...
joe rogan
Malfeasance?
Is that what it is?
james lindsay
Well, it's probably mal actually instead of mis.
Both are words, but...
joe rogan
I've never heard mis.
james lindsay
It's less bad.
So we'll say malfeasance.
It's really bad.
So he thinks that they used the Dominion machines that had shady programming, etc.
And I don't know the details of his hypothesis, but that they were changing the numbers in a particular way to move votes from one guy from Trump to Biden, etc.
And so he spent millions of dollars on some kind of a statistical analysis to dig into this.
Right.
Really?
unidentified
Yeah.
james lindsay
And so that's like he had his whole conference like in South Dakota or something about it over like the summer last year.
Like this is a whole thing.
And so he's trying to make this point.
And what there are, like it or not, millions upon millions of Americans who are looking at the 2020 election and they're kind of squinting one eye.
And they're like, OK, maybe something like I mean, like maybe as many as 50 or 80 million Americans are like, I think something shady went on there.
And so he's got this hypothesis, right?
So the distrust in the democratic process in the country is already shaken.
So my view is when somebody's bringing up a point like this, the only way – like if something happens where people are suspicious enough or there's a guy that's going to devote millions of dollars to something like that, you've really – of course, you could just have a crazy guy with a lot of money.
That's always possible.
The way that you recover what's dangerous to democracy is not tying off those loose ends, right?
So if you leave that open, like, the trust is already shattered.
And so what you want is this—so he comes up with this hypothesis.
OK. And he spent all his money and he presents his evidence and then people, you know, as ideally transparently as possible, analyze the evidence that he presents and says, this is, oh, my God, this is an emergency or there might be something here or, you know, this is total bullshit.
You're a crazy person and we're never going to hear from you again in any significant way.
Go go home that.
What's missing is that transparency.
So what's dangerous for me to democracy is the idea that there are going to be people, whether it's Sean Hannity on Fox, whether it's Rachel Maddow on MSNBC, whether it's Don Lemon on CNN, whether it's Anthony Fauci, whatever the hell he is, whether it's Joe Biden, you know, Back in 1989 because he doesn't know where he is.
Whatever it happens to be, I don't think it's good for anything if those people get to delimit what we're going to see as officially true and that's what we have to go with because that's the mess that we're in with why you got attacked for taking horse medicine even though you took the human version obviously and you took a Nobel Prize winning medicine with decades of – You know,
human use and science and success behind it.
And that was a decision made between yourself to take it and your doctor as the consultant who recommended and was able to get you the prescription to get it.
Anthony Fauci didn't need to intervene in that decision.
Discussion.
You could have taken these pills, which have a long time of human use, and it could have done nothing.
It could have just given you diarrhea or, you know, it could have made you sick or whatever, and then your doctor could have reacted accordingly to try to create a treatment protocol for you tailored to what's actually going on in your individual body as you dealt with the COOF. You don't need a bureaucrat, I think, deciding, no, no, no, these are the official things that we're going to say work and don't work because that's where you get yourself in these really dangerous positions.
joe rogan
I agree with everything you said.
Have you ever listened to what Mike Lindell says and did you ever look at his evidence?
james lindsay
Oh, I think he's a bit nutty.
joe rogan
But did you ever look at his evidence about the stolen election?
james lindsay
I did not.
I did not.
joe rogan
What do you think he's nutty about?
I think he's nutty too, but I don't have – like if you cornered me and go, why is he nutty?
I'm like, ah, I saw him in an interview once.
He looked wacky.
james lindsay
Well, I mean, yeah, there's that.
joe rogan
It's probably people have that opinion in me.
james lindsay
I mean, when I met him, he actually, what did he say?
He said something really funny because he used to be on crack, right?
joe rogan
Really?
james lindsay
Yeah, he used to be like a crackhead.
joe rogan
For real?
james lindsay
I'm not making that up.
Yeah, totally.
And so he made some joke about how, you know, he said something and he was like, I didn't even have to smoke crack to say that or whatever, you know, some kind of a joke like that.
And it's like...
joe rogan
Okay.
james lindsay
Anyway, I don't have the skill, in fact, to parse his evidence.
But such people do.
Or certain people do.
joe rogan
Look at this.
How this entrepreneur went from a crack addict to self-made millionaire.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
So this is before he was nutty.
This is 2017. He was like just a self-made millionaire.
It's like he wasn't a nut back then.
In 2017, he was allowed to be nutty.
james lindsay
So I don't...
joe rogan
And clean and sober for over eight years.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
Oh, so 2011, smoking that rock.
jamie vernon
You got a really good idea.
joe rogan
Yeah, really good idea where he's cracked out.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
When did he start the company?
Let's find out when the company got started.
About 2012. I mean, are these fucking pillows worth buying?
I'm very curious.
james lindsay
I don't have one.
joe rogan
I feel like I'm very curious.
james lindsay
I mean...
joe rogan
2004. 2004. So, he started the company, cracked out.
james lindsay
Cracked out, yeah.
joe rogan
Cracked out, making pillows.
Yeah.
james lindsay
Did better than the kid from Harvard that was trying to make pillows to compete with him.
That didn't go so good.
joe rogan
Was there a kid from Harvard that made pillows?
james lindsay
Yeah, David Hogg.
joe rogan
Oh, that kid?
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
He made pillows?
james lindsay
Yeah, I think he called them like OurPillow or some communist shit.
joe rogan
Oh, silly.
Oh my god, that's so silly.
Now, does anybody analyze his stuff and say the MyPillow guy's got a point?
james lindsay
I don't know.
No, but people could.
And I would rather it be out there and have that transparency to the maximum degree with people who are weighing in on this and saying, no, actually, he's totally nuts.
joe rogan
I agree.
I think there should be platforms in terms of whether it's like a YouTube or a Twitter and Facebook and all these fall into this thing that are accessible to all Americans.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
Because I think they're a basic human right.
Because the right to express yourself, when we live in this very strange time of misinformation, disinformation, the counter to that should be more communication.
james lindsay
I think so.
Like I said, I think truth is sort of spiritual sounding, but I think of truth like a flame.
Like it burns its way out of boxes of lies that it gets put into.
joe rogan
That sounds like a Bette Midler song.
unidentified
Is it?
joe rogan
Some say hello.
Oh, no.
james lindsay
No, that's something else, Joe.
jamie vernon
According to the headlines, when I Google the evidence he has for voter fraud, from last week, he has evidence that he'll put up to 300 million Americans in jail.
joe rogan
That's us.
We're going to jail.
james lindsay
That's a lot of people.
jamie vernon
For life?
james lindsay
See, so that's wacky.
joe rogan
That's as wacky as he gets.
jamie vernon
These are the headlines.
james lindsay
There are only 330 million.
joe rogan
Well, maybe he was doing a Biden thing.
He's old.
He fucked his brain up on crack.
And you remember when Biden said, like, over one billion Americans have been vaccinated.
unidentified
Get vaccinated.
joe rogan
Remember when he did that?
300 million people belong in jail for voter fraud.
james lindsay
That's unlikely to be true unless he's talking globally, in which case it's still unlikely to be true.
joe rogan
He's an entrepreneur.
You don't know what the fuck you're talking about.
This guy is a genius.
Yeah, that's wacky.
james lindsay
I would love to see that shot down through robust public debate.
joe rogan
I would too, but if you're Hannity and you got a seven-minute segment with this fucking loon, you don't want this guy spouting this kind of crazy shit on your show.
james lindsay
Why do you call him in the first place?
joe rogan
Diminish the accuracy of your show.
I don't know.
Maybe there's something else to talk about.
Maybe there's something else.
james lindsay
He's on a bit of a quest, you know.
joe rogan
To prove that the voter fraud was there.
james lindsay
Yeah.
So, again, maybe Hannity's not the place for it.
I don't know.
But I would rather...
joe rogan
If you're Fox, though, does it make sense to you that you wouldn't want someone saying that on your network?
james lindsay
Possibly.
It depends on its general public salience.
Like, is this a huge discussion point that Fox has been dancing around a little bit here and there, but they won't?
So, in that case, it's like, let's bring this guy in, hear what his evidence is, and then start bringing up counterpoints if you want to bring up counterpoints.
I just don't want any...
I think that where we're trapped the most is that people like whoever it is that Instagram gets to strike down your buddy and my onion ring joke.
And whoever it is, like you were saying, the social media platform should be free for everybody.
I don't think that we want...
People that we don't even necessarily know who they are in a lot of cases getting to make the decisions of what is and is not going to be considered true, especially when they're putting flags on stuff like Lynyrd Skynyrd and Hootie.
joe rogan
They're doing something that is without a doubt suppressing certain views and perspectives.
And imagine a world where Milo Yiannopoulos is never banned from Twitter.
Gavin McGinnis never banned from Twitter.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
Alex Jones never banned from Twitter.
Donald Trump never banned from Twitter.
People go, well, those are terrible people.
Well, guess who's not banned from Twitter?
The head of the fucking Taliban.
Okay, guess who's not banned from Twitter?
Cardinal Ratzinger, a man who is wanted for crimes against humanity, who moved priests who molested children.
The former Pope, the Ratzinger guy, moved priests that molested children to new places where they can molest children, where they molested thousands.
There was at one point in time one priest that he moved that molested 100 deaf kids.
I mean, this is horrible, evil shit.
That guy's on Twitter.
So just explain to me why that makes any fucking sense at all.
Look around at what is actually on Twitter and who's allowed to talk on Twitter.
And you find yourself in a very weird situation where you're trying to justify this.
james lindsay
Yeah.
And so there's a bias with that as well.
The bias has a name.
It's called repressive tolerance.
Repressive tolerance is the name of an essay from a Marxist in the 60s.
Herbert Marcuse was the guy's name.
Most influential guy in the 60s in the Marxist scene probably.
His book from 1964, the year before the essay, was called One Dimensional Man, sold 300,000 copies.
So That's in the 60s, right?
It's pretty big time.
And he writes this essay in 65 called Repressive Tolerance and he says – and I shit you not.
I mean we could pull up the quote.
It says that repressive tolerance means – or actually he calls it liberating tolerance.
Liberating tolerance means – Tom Hanks, Jr.: Tolerating movements from the left and being intolerant against movements from the right.
And so the whole tilted playing field is visible there.
And his justification, he says, is that we could have stopped World War II. We could have stopped Auschwitz if we would have withdrawn democratic tolerance, that's his words, from Hitler when he was making his speeches.
And he says, so this only – this is censorship.
He says this is even pre-censorship.
He's like, this obviously can only make sense.
Under a circumstance, it's like emergency powers, right?
He says under a circumstance where it's clear and present danger.
And then he literally goes on, totally mental, to say, I maintain that our society is in that situation all the time.
Thus, we always have to censor the right, pre-censor the right.
He says we have to stop the idea from ever entering their head.
So this is where this kind of suppression of, say, Mike Lindell's views, maybe totally batshit, or Alex Jones's views, We have to stop the thought from ever entering the head.
Why?
So that we can avoid Auschwitz in a world war.
I don't think it's actually how it works.
We've got this Marxist telling us that we need to tilt the playing field so that the left is always advantaged.
He even says in the essay that you have to tolerate even when they're violent because revolutionary violence is different than reactionary violence.
So violence that serves causes for the left is actually breaking up an oppressive order, whereas even intolerance from the right is maintaining an oppressive order.
So they're not on a moral level.
So we have to – even if there's violence involved, we have to tolerate whatever the left does.
And if there's – even to the point of not allowing the thought to enter the head of people on the right, we have to censor – and he says pre-censor – and repress, repressive tolerance.
We have to repress the right wing.
And that's the game that we all have to live in right now.
Yeah, sure, Ratzinger is not exactly this liberal dude, right?
But there are occasionally these cases where – Something doesn't quite fit that mold, but for the most part, that's what we're seeing.
Everybody else you named is a right-wing dude.
And the suppression is absolutely not...
You and I know right now that if we were going to go on Twitter, we pull out our phones right now, we're going to get on Twitter, and it's like, all right, let's do a contest to see who can get banned from Twitter first.
Like, you know exactly what types of opinions are going to get you banned, and they're not left-wing opinions.
joe rogan
Right.
james lindsay
You could come out and say, like, those videos, you could say the most wacky stuff, like, I'm going to groom children, or whatever, and you're probably going to be okay.
joe rogan
You'll be okay.
james lindsay
As long as you couch it in theory or something first so you sound intelligent and whatever.
joe rogan
Minor attracted persons.
james lindsay
Minor attracted persons.
Yeah, those accounts are all still there.
They're literally groomers.
And they're bringing those books with literal depictions of graphic sex acts into schools.
joe rogan
No, is that real?
Is that something that they're actually bringing into school?
Or is that something?
What is that?
james lindsay
Yes, it's real.
And they're not even just bringing it into schools.
They're doing it in an underhanded way.
Because a lot of people have forgotten this, but the state, turns out, does not have free speech.
Citizens have free speech.
So it's already – this is long government precedent.
It's obvious First Amendment law.
The state, like the teachers, the curriculum can't do – they can't just say anything.
Free speech is not a defense available to them if they're saying something that's like unprofessional out of their job description or whatever or bringing pornography into the – even if it's fairly soft pornography into the classroom.
But the library works differently.
And so they're actually bringing it in through the library.
So these aren't like books like the teacher necessarily is reading through in class.
They're available in the library and they can be – kids will be told the books are in the library.
And they do.
They depict – this one is called Genderqueer.
I mean this is like crazy.
I got in trouble on YouTube for even saying what's in this book.
But I've seen the picture from the book.
Yeah.
It's actually, it shows, you know, appears to be some kind of lesbian-type relationship, or maybe it's non-binary, and there's a strap-on dildo on a minor and another one performing oral sex on the strap-on dildo.
joe rogan
A minor?
james lindsay
They're children.
joe rogan
There's a child with a strap-on and another child performing oral sex.
Okay.
And this is a book that's in the library?
james lindsay
Yeah, there's another one I saw yesterday, and I apologize because I don't know what the title of it is because I only just saw it, where it actually shows people going down on each other like cunnilingus.
You want to make a graphic novel of that and publish it for adults.
joe rogan
Is this available online?
Can I see these images?
james lindsay
Yeah, I bet you can.
joe rogan
Let me take my pants off.
No.
james lindsay
Okay.
joe rogan
Just kidding.
james lindsay
Look it up.
Genderqueer.
joe rogan
Terrible joke.
james lindsay
Genderqueer.
joe rogan
Show me this online.
james lindsay
This is scandalous.
jamie vernon
I don't know what to look up.
If I just type those words in, you end up on the wrong websites.
joe rogan
You end up on a bad list.
james lindsay
Genderqueer schools books.
That's what I would type in.
joe rogan
Think of that.
Or a school's book.
Why don't you go to DuckDuckGo?
Stop using Google.
Keep fucking you.
unidentified
Yeah.
jamie vernon
Alright, for this one I will.
joe rogan
Google gives you bad info.
Have you ever done the side-by-side?
james lindsay
It's nuts sometimes.
joe rogan
It's wild.
james lindsay
It's really wild sometimes.
joe rogan
Mass formation psychosis is a good example of that.
james lindsay
It is.
They did the thing right after your show.
And they were like, we're still updating the quality of our search results or something like that for a day.
And then it's not there.
joe rogan
Well, what was there was mocking Robert Malone and critiques of Robert Malone.
james lindsay
Wasn't there some poor guy's video?
And he got totally bombed or whatever because it prioritized just some random video of some kid saying it doesn't exist or whatever?
joe rogan
I do not know, but I do know that when you looked at Mass Formation Psychosis and DuckDuckGo, you got all the relative information.
james lindsay
All the stuff.
Yeah, it's shocking.
joe rogan
I do that all the time.
Whenever there's any kind of weird, controversial story, I immediately go to DuckDuckGo.
james lindsay
I don't fuck with Google.
I know.
This is, again, just another example I'm talking about.
joe rogan
It's curated.
jamie vernon
Is this it?
james lindsay
That's the right colors.
jamie vernon
This is all cartoon stuff.
james lindsay
It's a graphic novel.
It's not...
joe rogan
Okay, so there's blood all over that kid's legs?
james lindsay
It's a boy who had his period.
joe rogan
Oh, the boy had his period.
james lindsay
And so...
joe rogan
Okay.
So the boy's on a date with a girl and he has this period?
What's happening?
jamie vernon
I was looking for the pictures, like he said, and I didn't see them when I quickly scrolled through.
These are other pictures that are in the book.
joe rogan
Have you ever shaved your pubic hair?
They're holding hands.
Nope.
That's so brave.
james lindsay
Yeah, right there.
joe rogan
Brave?
I thought it was lazy.
james lindsay
That's the picture I'm talking about.
joe rogan
Right there.
Whoa.
Okay.
So that is supposedly a strap-on that looks like a penis.
How do we know that?
Oh, there it goes.
So that...
Okay, that is so insane.
So this, but I can't feel anything.
This was much hotter when it was only my imagination.
james lindsay
Why can't you feel anything?
joe rogan
Because it's a rubber dick.
Let's try something else.
Of course, Hart.
So this is, they're literally showing in a book that's in a library.
A kid sucking on a rubber dick that's strapped onto this.
jamie vernon
And the articles, when I was Googling for it, it said they got pulled from the libraries, though, too.
james lindsay
And there's this huge fight to get it put back in everywhere.
And a lot of schools are standing up saying, no, we're going to keep this because we have to protect LGBT kids, etc.
joe rogan
The thing is, like, if you wanted to make this and sell it to people over 18, that makes sense.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
Like, why not?
james lindsay
Of course.
Like, why not?
joe rogan
But if you want to put this in libraries...
james lindsay
School libraries.
Yeah.
And so...
joe rogan
It seems like you're...
james lindsay
So we wheel back to not just queer theory, but all these critical theories, right?
Critical race theory, whatever.
And they actually openly say, I mentioned that paper by Hannah Dyer earlier, they openly say that one of the targets that they have is childhood innocence.
They say childhood innocence is a narrative that's created by People who have privilege and advantage, like you're a rich white guy or whatever, so your kids can grow up innocent.
But if you're a queer kid or if you're a black kid in the city or whatever, you can't grow up innocent.
You can't grow up racially innocent.
So they literally say that their target is to unmake childhood innocence.
So what do they do?
They expose them to adult sexual themes.
They expose them in pre-K even to like racism themes.
And a lot of parents, of course, are like, I don't think that's appropriate.
joe rogan
And what are they trying to accomplish with the goal of eliminating childhood innocence?
james lindsay
Well, depends on who's doing it.
Those minor attracted persons, of course, they might have their own, if we will, minor attracted pedophiles would have their own agenda, right?
joe rogan
Groomers.
james lindsay
They're groomers.
And if there is no childhood innocence, then the childhood doesn't have innocence and we can even do away with maybe aging consent laws or we can da-da-da.
So there's that whole sick side of it.
But from the Marxist perspective, having studied the history of Marxism through the 20th century, I'm telling you, this guy, George Lukács, in Hungary laid this plan out because if you get these kids, like, you break down their innocence sexually especially, what you can do is then they're going to go home and they're going to tell their parents that they're some, like, lithromantic, you know, demisexual, you know, tree self gender, some, you know, pronouns tree, tree self or something.
And the parents are going to be like, what?
And they're going to be like, mom, you just don't understand.
So you separate the younger generation from the older generation.
So you get them to break away and think that they're old fogies, that they're repressive, you don't want me to be my true self, etc.
The goal is actually to destabilize the kid's identity so that they're groomable.
That's identity without an essence in queer theory.
And then they're groomable.
You groom them into this stuff and then they look at their parents' culture.
They look at their parents' themselves.
They look at their parents' generation.
They look at the parents' religion and they say, that doesn't represent me.
We need something completely different.
So it's to – just like in Mao's Cultural Revolution and I mean that much more literally than you might suspect.
It's to cut the tie between the continuity of culture up to that point, including the family, and to start a whole new culture afterwards.
Pol Pot called it year zero.
I guess Klaus Schwab calls it the Great Reset.
But the goal is to separate the new generation from the traditions and views of the old generation.
For Mao, it was to destroy the so-called four olds.
Old culture, old habits, old customs, and old ways of thinking.
Sojiu in Mandarin.
And these kids would get like hopped up on this crap and became the Red Guard and like would go into temples and like rip down all the statuary and tear things down and destroy all the old – all the old kung fu masters got their asses beat by mobs to get rid of like old Chinese culture because it's embarrassing or whatever.
There's all – Chinese medicine of course.
And you can say, well, that stuff was bullshit.
They probably need it.
But it doesn't matter.
It was like destroy the old culture and they would go home and they eventually got to where they're beating their parents or beating their teachers that were considered revolutionaries – or sorry, reactionaries instead of being in favor of the Chinese Cultural Revolution.
And Mao had a whole program he used in schools.
And I see something so similar to that in our schools now that I'm freaking out.
And what he did was he separated.
Listen to this.
You'll see it immediately.
He created 10 classes of people.
Five of them were black, were labeled black classes.
They're bad.
And five of them because of communism are red and they're good.
And I can't remember them all off the top of my head, but the black classes were like...
Landlord or child of landlord, right?
What else would you have?
Landlords, counter-revolutionaries, bad influences was one of the – so like that's us because we're spreading – we're bad influences.
And so he had these categories, people who had lots of money basically.
unidentified
Right.
james lindsay
People who are capitalists, especially landlords.
And so those people are bad.
And if you're like the son of one of those people or connected to one of those people, they're going to tell you at school you're like the worst kind of person.
Your dad's a landlord.
Your family does this.
You guys are landholders.
Rich Farmer was one of them.
Rich Farmer was one of them.
And then they give you these red identities.
Well, you can be a revolutionary.
Peasant classes, day laborers, that's one or two of the red classes because it's communism.
But then you can become a revolutionary.
You can join the Red Guard.
You can take up these – you can be a good communist.
And now we'll call you – we'll give you like a red jacket or whatever, a red feather, I don't know, something.
And you're like one of the cool kids, whereas we're going to constantly tell you how bad you are over here.
Now, take out those classes like landowner or whatever and switch it out, white, straight, male, thin, fit, attractive, conventionally attractive, whatever, right?
There's your black classes.
So you start telling all these kids, for example, it's critical race theory stuff or like I have this here, race Marxism.
You start showing them, you start telling them that they are part of the racist superstructure of society basically, that they're part of the systemic racism problem.
And so their whole identity generationally – your parents are white.
You didn't do it.
It's not your fault.
But you have all this privilege, blah, blah, blah.
You have these kids who are like, well, how can I have a positive identity?
What do those look like?
Well, you could be black or some other racial minority.
You could be queer.
And all of a sudden you have a pathway, a funnel, into a positive identity.
Not gay, because that's not enough.
You have to actually be queer.
Like, it's not meant to be a stable, like, oh, well, I'm a guy who likes guys.
The end, no.
I was born this way.
No.
Queer theorists don't get on with it.
They didn't support gay marriage.
The queer theorists don't like any of that stuff.
They don't want to normalize anything.
joe rogan
Well, what is queer then?
james lindsay
Queer is an identity without an essence.
It's a constantly fluid identity.
It can be whatever you want as long as it's politically active against anything that's considered normal or normative.
joe rogan
So you can be queer and have a heterosexual relationship?
james lindsay
I mean if you wanted to yell about things the right way.
But mostly you're going to have to adopt something, one of these like made-up genders, sexual orientations.
unidentified
Non-binary.
james lindsay
Yeah.
They even have romantic orientations, like who you're romantically attracted to instead of sexually attracted.
They're obsessives.
We've said that word earlier.
But you give people a pathway.
And where do you see the vast majority of these young people transitioning and seeking non-binary and bisexual and whatever else?
Young girls.
Who are the most social status concerned and white man is probably not going to get anything anyway.
And so these young white girls are all becoming some kind of weird gender thing.
Why?
Because they're getting constantly barraged by critical race theory that says white is bad.
White is complicit in racism.
You're a racist.
You can become an ally.
That's a red identity, ally, racial ally.
these pathways to where you get social status and it's not enough that you're going to say, oh, I'm bi or I'm pansexual or I'm demisexual or I'm whatever.
It's not enough to do that.
You now have to politically be active in that regard or you're not authentically that.
That's where we heard so many people, Ayanna Pressley most famously, I put on Twitter the other day, Ayanna Pressley, and I couldn't remember where she's from, So I put, you know, it's always like D and then like the state, like DMI if it's from like Michigan or whatever, or D Michigan.
I put D hell because I don't remember where she's from.
But Ayanna Pressley came out and had this speech during the St. Floyd riots.
And she was like, we don't need any more black faces who don't want to be black voices.
We don't need any more brown faces who don't want to be brown voices.
What does that mean?
It means you have to be politically active.
Nicole Hannah-Jones from the New York Times, the 1619 Project said the same thing.
There's a difference between being racially black and politically black.
So then in your former home state of California – or not home state, I guess, but resident state of California, Larry Elder runs for governor, was the LA Times run.
Blackface of white supremacy.
unidentified
Yeah.
james lindsay
Because he's not politically black.
So you have to be politically active.
You have to be a revolutionary in that ideology.
joe rogan
But it wasn't even about politically black.
He wasn't politically left.
james lindsay
Well, that's what it really means.
joe rogan
Right.
He's from Compton.
james lindsay
He wasn't – he's not a Marxist.
joe rogan
Right.
james lindsay
You only count if you're acting out one of these identity-based Marxist – Political views.
Whether that's, you can't just be a black kid, you have to be a politically black kid.
You have to spout critical race theory, or they say that black voices thing.
One of the pillars of critical race theory is called a unique voice of color.
They actually believe that you are morally determined, structurally determined, they call it, but it means morally determined.
If you happen to be black and you live in a white supremacist society as they define it, then your character is shaped.
So we listen to Martin Luther King, you know, that's this week.
His birthday was just the other day.
We listen to Martin Luther King when we say, you know, contents of character, not color of skin.
But according to the critical race theory view, your content of your character is determined by the color of your skin.
So that doesn't work.
And you have to take on the politics that is being a critical race theory advocate or whatever for your blackness to count.
joe rogan
Where the fuck does all this go?
This is what's so disturbing about it.
It seems like it's uprooting civil discourse in this country.
And between that and whatever is going on politically between the left and the right in terms of like The people that want to make sure that Trump never gets into office again and make sure that everyone who's right-wing is demonized and discussed as the worst aspects of society.
Leaving one choice.
If you're an intellectual, if you're a person who went to college, if you're a person who is a white-collar person, you're not allowed to be anything other than left-wing.
james lindsay
Yeah, exactly.
joe rogan
If you want to be respected and taken seriously.
Where does this go?
james lindsay
I mean you can look at what happened with the Cultural Revolution because we're playing out the exact same logic.
I mean the Chinese Cultural Revolution, not the American one that we're in the middle of right now.
The logic is the same.
So it goes to a situation in which we don't have a Mao Zedong character.
That's going to, you know, lead this and use the chaos that it creates to seize an iron grip of communist power.
What we have instead are people like this Klaus Schwab introducing Xi Jinping and saying, you know, what does he say?
I echo everything that you just said or that you said in 2017. I don't want to misquote him.
But then you have him, Xi, talking about how we have the many boats and we're all going to be one boat now, right?
unidentified
Right.
james lindsay
So what you actually end up having is – it's not old school communism.
Communism has evolved.
It's like we're not going to have like Stalin like sending people to Siberia with this.
What you're going to have is this new thing where the corporate – Those ESG scores are going to come down ultimately to control people at the level of social credit for themselves.
Like if you want to be able to bank, if you want to be able to go to the grocery store maybe, if you want to go like in Australia more than five kilometers from your house, you have to have a justified reason.
That was a whole thing in their COVID. Like whatever the state of affairs there is, that's true.
Like during their hard lockdown, you couldn't be a certain distance away from your house.
Well, they can track you on your phone We've got a GPS in it if they needed to and especially if we go all the way into like these digital ID apps or whatever.
And so the goal is to install something that they have total social control run by the goons who think that this is a good idea so that we can become this one – it's not communism.
It's a mixture of communism and fascism into one thing.
joe rogan
What was the one thing that they were recently talking about, about labeling people that are dissenting against government opinions, people that are rabble-rousers?
unidentified
DVEs.
joe rogan
Yeah.
james lindsay
Domestic violent extremists.
joe rogan
Yeah.
james lindsay
Yeah.
We can say that in terms of repressive tolerance.
joe rogan
How do they define it?
Because they were defining it in a very weird way.
james lindsay
Yeah, we'd have to pull it up.
It's really vague.
joe rogan
It's weirdly vague.
james lindsay
It's disturbingly vague.
joe rogan
Because the way they were describing it, you could easily say us, like people who are podcasters.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
People who, what was the terms that they used?
They used a term, I was like, wow, that's not very clear.
james lindsay
It's really vague and, you know, concerning.
joe rogan
Yeah.
james lindsay
Very concerning.
joe rogan
What did they say?
They didn't say misinformation.
They said like someone who...
It was against the government.
james lindsay
It was like government authority or something like that.
unidentified
Yeah.
joe rogan
Someone who has...
james lindsay
Questioning the government authority.
joe rogan
Questioning government authority.
james lindsay
Maybe not an exact quote.
joe rogan
Something along those lines.
But it's close to it.
Who released this?
Where was this from?
james lindsay
It was from like the DOJ. That's crazy.
joe rogan
See, the problem with this kind of shit, folks, is they don't even give it back to you.
james lindsay
No.
joe rogan
This is like when COVID's over and it's endemic and it becomes like the seasonal flu.
You don't get those rights back.
james lindsay
No, you're going to have to, and I don't mean this by violence, because it's from the FBI's paper I downloaded.
joe rogan
Okay, the FBI and the DHS are both charged with preventing terrorist attacks in the United States, including those conducted by domestic violent extremists.
jamie vernon
And that three is right here.
joe rogan
The goal drives the FBI's mission to proactively lead Law enforcement and domestic intelligence efforts to defeat terrorist attacks against U.S. citizens and U.S. interests through an integrated strategy to detect, penetrate.
And then how are they describing it?
jamie vernon
This thing here.
joe rogan
Okay, here it is.
The FBI and DHS define a domestic violent extremist as an individual based and operating primarily within the United States or its territories without direction or inspiration from a foreign terrorist group or other foreign power Who seeks to further political or social goals wholly or in part through unlawful acts of force or violence.
The mere advocacy of political or social positions, political activism, use of strong rhetoric.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
Or generalized philosophic embrace of violent tactics may constitute extremism.
james lindsay
May not constitute.
joe rogan
May not, excuse me, my microphone's in the window.
And may be constitutionally protected.
What does that mean, though?
james lindsay
So, that last part is not as bad as it sounds.
joe rogan
No, it doesn't sound bad at all.
james lindsay
I mean, I saw this graphic thing that had very vague words on it, but...
This last part is very clear that they're saying, you know, you may have constitutionally protected free speech and so mere advocacy of these things may not be sufficient to qualify you as an extremist.
The scary part is the word may, of course, because that's a squishy word.
joe rogan
Right.
May not constitute extremism doesn't make me feel very happy.
Keep going.
Scroll down.
What does it say?
Disrupt and dismantle criminal DT plots in the FBI and DHS mission to provide strategic analysis of the DVE landscape.
I hate when they use those little acronyms.
james lindsay
Oh, I know.
It makes it hard to keep up with.
joe rogan
DT, it's not an acronym, right?
It's an acronym if you say it.
unidentified
Like a dv.
james lindsay
I assume that, yeah, dv.
joe rogan
What's the difference?
An acronym is one where you...
james lindsay
No, it's an acronym.
joe rogan
What's the one when you say the...
jamie vernon
Makes it a word.
james lindsay
Like NASA. Right.
joe rogan
It's a different word.
I fucking hate that.
james lindsay
We'll have to look that up too.
joe rogan
Okay.
The DT for the FBI's purpose is referenced in the U.S. Code, blah, blah, blah, blah, as defined as activities involving acts dangerous to human life that are a violation of the criminal laws of the United States or any other state, or any state, appearing to be intended to intimidate or coerce civilian population.
Here's one.
Influence the policy of government by intimidation, coercion, or affect conduct of government by mass destruction, assassination, or kidnapping, and occurring primarily within the territorial jurisdiction of the United States.
Well, all that makes sense.
james lindsay
Yeah, that all makes sense, except that's like, isn't that what they did with the governor?
joe rogan
Michigan?
james lindsay
They kidnapped?
joe rogan
Well, that's the thing.
I was going to bring that up to you about January 6th.
What do you think they were trying to do?
And why were they trying to do that?
james lindsay
Who are the they that you're referring to?
joe rogan
So if the FBI is involved, or the feds, if they are involved, and that's why that woman was not able to answer those questions to Ted Cruz and said, I can't answer that, I can't answer that.
And things that you should be able to answer, like were you involved in citing violence?
Were you involved in violent activities?
So what do you think they were trying to do and why were they trying to do that?
Do you think it's because it's no secret that Donald Trump had a terrible relationship with the intelligence community?
james lindsay
Right.
joe rogan
He disparaged them, dismissed them, called them incompetent, fired Comey, the whole deal, right?
And they were out to get him, supposedly, right?
Do you think that what they were trying to do by inciting that Epps guy saying, we need to go in there.
unidentified
I might get arrested for saying this, but we need to go into the Capitol.
joe rogan
And everybody's like, who's this fucking Fed?
jamie vernon
After you guys noticed that, I saw this news came out that he is going to be doing an interview with the FBI to transcribe what he was I don't know what he was doing there that day, I guess.
joe rogan
Informally.
He met informally, Jamie.
jamie vernon
No, he did already.
He's going to meet formally now.
joe rogan
Look at this.
Figure at the center of pro-Trump January 6th theories to speak with select committee on Friday.
Ray Epps met informally with the panel in November and told them he had no relationship with the FBI. No, he's with the NSA. We don't know who the fuck he's with.
He's with somebody.
Or he's a nut.
It could be he's a nut.
But if he was a nut, they would have arrested him.
jamie vernon
Don't you think?
james lindsay
Yeah, I think so.
Because they arrested normal people.
joe rogan
Well, he didn't go in, though.
Did he go in?
james lindsay
I don't think so.
joe rogan
No.
I think they're trying to arrest people that didn't go in, too.
I think they got it out for Alex Jones.
Yeah.
And Alex Jones is telling people, don't go inside.
Don't go in there.
Don't let him talk into it.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
Like Mr. False Flag, right?
On a bullhorn, telling people don't go inside there.
jamie vernon
Yeah, of course.
joe rogan
But then when the cops opened up the gates and let people in, what do you think they were trying to accomplish?
This is my point.
james lindsay
So they tell you.
Of course, they turn it into like a holiday or something weird, right?
So it's really important to them that this was a very significant event.
joe rogan
Right.
james lindsay
And what are they doing with it?
Well, they immediately, literally like the next day, which is oddly fast, you know, had legislation that they wanted to put to control domestic extremists.
Then they have this extremism stand down that they do throughout the military all year last year where they're there.
And, you know, they're talking to him about white supremacy and they're talking about all this.
joe rogan
They put up a green zone around the Capitol.
james lindsay
Yeah.
Yeah, they did.
And so then and I don't know if you saw this.
The New York Times on January 1st – so first of all, there's all this kind of like Patriot Act 2.0 looking shit coming out of this to label people who are – we'll say at least further to the right as potential domestic terror threats or whatever to our democracy, which is its own thing.
But on January 1st, the New York Times published an article.
titled, Every Day is January 6th Now.
Is that not like the stupidest thing you've ever heard?
But I just told you about the essay from 1965 called Repressive Tolerance.
So what does this mean?
If every day is January 6th, we always have to be aware that there's this one side that supported Trump.
Obviously, one of the things they wanted out of it, though, speaking of Trump, they wanted to make sure that Trump would never be able to hold office again.
How do we know that?
Because they kick that political football every chance they get.
They try to use something to justify that he can never hold office again.
So only their dudes can hold office.
We got you.
And then this article, though, is the idea of repressive tolerance.
It is every day is January 6th.
And what did Marcuse say?
The clear and present danger is the constant state of our societies.
It's the normal state of affairs.
What does that justify?
Repression of movements from the right, intolerance of movements from the left.
It's exactly what they were—if the FBI constructed— The bulk of the bad stuff that went down on J6. They were trying to construct their excuse to have a political biasing of the playing field that represses rightward and opens the gate leftward even further.
And so – and to add like Department of Justice, FBI, et cetera, teeth to this otherwise kind of cultural movement.
So it's the kind of – again, having studied the Chinese Cultural Revolution, it's the kind of thing that I start to get really nervous about.
The idea that if you read Mao, he's always talking about counter-revolutionaries.
He's always talking about conservatives and rightists.
And that those people have to be suppressed.
They have to be stopped.
They're a constant threat to the people's movement or to the revolution or whatever it is, however we phrase it, is often the people's movement is how he phrases it.
And you see this again, same kind of Maoist and Marxist maneuver to It's consolidate and lock up power in the – I don't even want to say the Democrats to be honest with you.
It's not the Democrats.
It's bigger than the Democrats.
It's in the – what often got referred to either as the deep state or the swamp or whatever, this kind of political class that wants to hold itself up above everybody else and make no mistake, there are lots of Republicans involved as well.
The Democrats are virtually completely beholden to this ideology at this point.
But there's a lot of Republicans who are in on the show as well that say the right things sometimes that are mostly ineffectual.
And so there's this thing that some people call it – I call it on Twitter the regime with a capital R that wants to create conditions under which it can persecute or at least intimidate its political enemies including with this Department of Justice letter.
It's not connected to January 6th for parents.
Showing up to school boards, pissed off that there's books in the school library, which we already saw what's in those books in the school library.
They want to create the ability to repress those people so they can create the conditions of repressive tolerance, which is a – it's basically like taking the whole political football field and tilting it to the left.
So everything naturally runs that way and it's really hard to go rightward on anything.
So that's – I mean I seriously think that that's what the point was.
That's why you have guys like Epps, whatever he's doing, like telling guys, make this worse than it is and we're going to use it.
I remember on January 6, 2021, I guess, I was tweeting.
I was like, you do not know what's happening at the Capitol.
And I wasn't doing some false flag conspiracy thing.
I was like, you just don't have enough information.
Stop jumping to conclusions.
Hold up.
Wait.
And it's just media spin.
I wasn't doing some Alex Jones false flag thing.
I was like tweeting that and I'm watching how people are reacting.
And then if you follow the thread where I have that, I even say, you know, this is like the biggest gift in the world to the potential regime that wants to clamp down on its enemies, that wants to censor people who might be encouraging insurrection in the future, who might be giving people information that makes them, you know, doubt the authority of the CDC or the government or, you know, whatever it happens to be, or the school board or the Department of Education or whoever.
And it just makes it that much easier for whatever agendas that they might have, which clearly they have some.
unidentified
Yeah.
james lindsay
Build Back Better is the name of one of the agendas that they're pushing.
It makes it that much easier for them to try to slide that stuff through if you can't criticize it to whatever reason they have.
Like, OK, so with COVID, we had a lot of different paths.
So this thing gets out in the world.
Let's take the most dumbass naive view.
Like, oh, it just escaped.
No bad actors.
It was a natural thing.
They were totally stupid and naive.
It comes out.
It's in the world at some point, say, beginning of 2020. We have a million different paths we can follow.
We can start sending everybody vitamin D and ivermectin like Mexico just did.
unidentified
Right?
james lindsay
Like they're sending people packets.
If you get sick, this is what you do.
There are lots of different paths we could have taken.
We could have done a lot of different...
Instead, we all locked down.
We all do these other things.
And in fact, we have this book come out in June by Klaus saying that we're doing the Great Reset using COVID-19 as the pretext.
joe rogan
Who did he write that book for?
james lindsay
Probably.
I mean, it's really badly written, so I'm assuming it's for his little Davos club members because it's really— Is it published with a legitimate publisher or is it self-published?
That's a good question.
I don't know.
I read the book, but I didn't look at that page.
That's a good question.
It's kind of a joke of a book.
It's just like a bunch of corporate jargon words.
Even I'm trained to see through jargon, and it's just a bunch of corporate gobbledygook.
joe rogan
So when it comes to false flags and it comes to some orchestrated agent provocateur tactics like when Governor Whitmer, when they were planning to kidnap her, how many different FBI agents were involved in that?
james lindsay
Like six or something, right?
joe rogan
Something crazy.
It was more than half of the people in the kidnap.
That's like that funny Spider-Man meme.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
Where it's like feds pointing at each other.
james lindsay
You remember they had the thing over the summer, they had something to do.
There's supposed to be this conservative thing about the J6, like free the prisoners or something, and nobody showed up.
And then there's that famous picture of the feds all standing there in their sunglasses and whatever.
And it's like you read the story of what happened there, and the only person who got arrested at that event, whatever it was, was a fed by another fed.
And it's like, oh my god.
joe rogan
It's funny.
It's funny, but it's like what are they trying to do and why is it allowed?
This is what Kennedy talked about when he talked about like secret societies.
james lindsay
Yeah.
Well, it's allowed because there's no accountability.
And anybody who calls for accountability can be labeled under – like with a serious call for it, can be labeled under somebody who's a threat to democracy.
They can be labeled under somebody who's a potential insurrectionist or instigating an insurrection or inciting.
joe rogan
But the federal officers that are involved in this – What do you think they think they're doing?
james lindsay
I think the majority of them think they're just doing their job.
joe rogan
Right, but do they know what the endgame is?
What do they think their job is?
unidentified
I don't know how you do that.
joe rogan
I mean, if you're pretending to be an insurrectionist and you're plotting some kidnapping of a governor or whatever you're trying to do...
What the fuck?
james lindsay
So there is an answer to that.
And what it is is they think that some dude, say in whatever Michigan, is this lunatic who wants to kidnap the governor.
But he's not going to act until he gets kind of like ginned up, right?
And so they want to just kind of, A, be in the vicinity.
So that if something goes down, they can interact or intervene immediately.
And B, like, give them that little extra push over the edge.
joe rogan
Right.
Make them active.
james lindsay
Yeah.
So, but like, the law enforcement should not be doing that.
No.
joe rogan
Shouldn't be encouraging crime.
james lindsay
Yeah.
And so, why on earth?
I mean, maybe they just think that they're like, hot shit or something.
I don't know.
joe rogan
Is that like a firefighter starting fires thing?
james lindsay
It could be.
I know a dude who did that.
Well, I didn't know him.
He was a guy in my town where I grew up and I was a little kid.
Like, there was literally a crazy guy that did that there.
joe rogan
It's more common than it should be, but it does happen.
And this has happened before in terms of, like, people that were supposedly informants, people that were working with the FBI that wound up doing something.
Like, the Boston Bombers.
Weren't the Boston Bombers some, they were informants?
james lindsay
Yeah, something like that.
Something like that.
And then who's on the scene?
I don't know if you ever saw this.
The one that they interviewed, the medical professional in Boston.
joe rogan
Yes.
james lindsay
Leanna Nguyen.
joe rogan
Yes.
james lindsay
Who's like, I call her Minnie Mouse.
joe rogan
Well, Mouse, yeah.
unidentified
Mouse.
joe rogan
And she was in front of a green screen, wasn't she?
james lindsay
Something like that.
And she said the weird- It looks super fake.
So it's like super fake.
She's like- And then it's like camera turn on and her face turns on and then she says this thing and it's like, oh yeah, there was way less carnage and damage than we were expecting.
It's like, than you were expecting?
Like, what are you talking about?
joe rogan
But also if you do hear a bomb went off, you expect a lot of carnage.
james lindsay
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
There's ambiguity there.
joe rogan
She's an odd duck.
james lindsay
She's weird.
joe rogan
Well, what's weird, too, is that she's the one who's now the message of CNN that masks don't work.
Like, she's now cloth masks are nothing more than facial decorations.
And everyone's like, wait, what?
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
The fuck did she just say?
james lindsay
Well, you know what that means.
joe rogan
They're not going to stop Omicron or Delta.
james lindsay
Yeah.
P.S. If they're facial decorations, you know what they are?
joe rogan
What?
james lindsay
Speech.
Which means the First Amendment, they can't compel you to wear a facial decoration.
joe rogan
Have you ever seen the video where they're discussing this?
This is pre-pandemic.
I'm going to send this to you, Jamie, because it's pretty interesting.
They were discussing the mask thing.
That was going on during the 1918 pandemic, and they were talking about the ineffectiveness of mass.
It's really kind of wild when you watch it, because it's one of those things where you see it and you're like, holy shit, this is kind of...
I mean, it's essentially the same thing that we're dealing with now, but this was, you know, a hundred fucking years ago.
Let me try to find it here.
Somebody sent it to me.
It's going to take a few minutes.
james lindsay
I got, by the way, while you look, I got dinged off of Facebook or something at one point.
All I did was I took a video of Fauci saying don't wear a mask from the very beginning of the pandemic.
And I put it on there and the only words were Fauci and then whatever month it was, like March 2020 or April 2020. That was the only thing I said with it, and they locked me out and put a strike on my account for sharing misinformation.
It was literally just a video of Fauci saying it.
I was just saying this is what the man said at the time.
joe rogan
I had that very same video.
I put it up on Instagram.
james lindsay
Was it from like 60 Minutes or something?
joe rogan
Yeah.
Well, he's like, the facial masks, they're not going to work.
You're going to smudge something.
They're not enough to stop a virus.
james lindsay
Something about nanometers.
joe rogan
Yeah, he's an odd cat.
You know, I'm in the middle of this thing that's talking about his response to the AIDS epidemic and about the way he handled that, which is very similar in the fact that they suppressed...
Alternative treatments and early treatment options in favor of AZT. And they stopped all other studies in favor of AZT. And it turns out that AZT was actually killing people even quicker.
james lindsay
And that's the parallel to remdesivir or whatever it's called.
joe rogan
Yes.
james lindsay
It's like super shady.
joe rogan
Yeah, I'm trying to find this motherfucker.
I get so many goddamn messages.
I'm not going to find it.
unidentified
Yeah.
joe rogan
See if you can find it, Jamie.
See if you can find a video of them discussing masks in 1918. Sorry, this is very boring to everybody, but I think it's kind of important.
jamie vernon
I'm trying to find it.
james lindsay
I can take my pants off.
unidentified
No!
joe rogan
What did you do?
jamie vernon
I searched for it.
I don't know what it looks like.
joe rogan
There's a black and white video.
jamie vernon
Maybe that?
joe rogan
Of them talking about it.
Yeah, let's try that.
Try that.
james lindsay
April 3rd, 2020 is the date on that.
jamie vernon
Yeah, I don't know.
james lindsay
It looks like an article.
jamie vernon
No video.
unidentified
Hmm.
joe rogan
I hate when I don't save things.
james lindsay
Yeah, tell me about it.
joe rogan
I have too many of them.
james lindsay
I have too many.
Dude, it's like...
joe rogan
I'll find it.
I'll find it later.
james lindsay
Yeah.
So, yeah, the thing is, though, is, like, you are right.
This was all kind of played out.
They knew, you know, I've seen the papers before COVID broke out that they knew that...
Masks were, at best, very limited utility.
joe rogan
But is limited utility better than nothing?
I mean, this is my perspective on it.
It's like, if it just stops a little bit of transmission, if it stops a little bit of the viral load, if people get less sick than they would have gotten, if people were just openly breathing and coughing all over each other, is that better?
james lindsay
Maybe.
Because here's the thing.
I'm actually really glad you said this because I actually wanted to bring this up if we got a chance.
The problem we're seeing with so much of this, especially with the masks and kids, is this collapsing of everything to one damn variable.
Transmission.
That's the only variable that counts now.
We don't have to ask questions of like, well, what's it doing to kids' ability to speak and understand language?
What is it doing to their, like, rates of pneumonia from breathing back in or facial, like, acne or, you know, eye infections from breathing their own mouth bacteria back onto their face and being trapped in that?
What's it doing, like, what is it, how many, some absurd number of billions of masks floating in the ocean?
joe rogan
Yes, it's crazy.
james lindsay
There's a million other things going on.
And if we just pay attention to one single variable, does it stop transmission?
Right.
We're missing like it's like it's not even like you miss the forest for the tree.
It's like you're looking at like a frickin bit of moss on the bark and not even knowing what's going on there.
You can't collapse a very, you know, multi-dimensional problem that has lots of trade offs.
There are billions of masks floating in the ocean is a fucking problem.
It is.
And it's funny because, you know, they're getting, if we go back to the ESG thing, they're getting points on their G for good governance by forcing people to wear the masks.
But they should be losing points in the environmental category, right?
But they're not because it's all like stakeholder bullshit.
They want to prioritize COVID is more important, just like all of a sudden COVID didn't matter when Black Lives Matter became more important as the S score goes up.
And you can see that this is, that's where you've got to worry about this small number of people who are largely unaccountable I think we're good to go.
There's a million things going on with kids and childhood development and everything.
Is it worth everybody wearing masks at the cost, the environmental outlay, the side effects of wearing masks?
Everybody's like, oh, I can't breathe in hypoxia.
There is a bit of suck it up buttercup to that.
But there's not suck it up buttercup to you're breathing back in your gross mouth stuff and getting pneumonia if you're, say, six years old.
Right?
And like everybody that's dealt with a six-year-old knows how that works.
They're like little snot machines.
joe rogan
Yeah.
james lindsay
I mean, that's like a running commentary throughout all of comedy, of parents' comedy for all of history is that they generate snot.
And they're breathing that back in.
They're touching their face all the time because they got the mask on and it's uncomfortable.
They're not – apparently all this stuff's coming out.
They're not learning to speak.
There's so many other variables that have to be considered.
And we see that in all of these things.
unidentified
Right.
joe rogan
Okay, I found it.
Sorry.
james lindsay
No, it's cool.
joe rogan
Here, I got a...
I'm going to send it to you, Jamie.
It's on YouTube.
Sorry about that.
james lindsay
No, I filled the space.
joe rogan
You did.
You did it very well.
Here, I'll show you.
james lindsay
I heard I got a radio voice.
joe rogan
You do have a radio voice.
unidentified
That's awesome.
joe rogan
It should be on radio, but then they would suppress you.
I just texted to you, Jamie.
james lindsay
Yeah.
So, you know, that's the question.
Is it worth it?
But if you're only looking at one thing, you don't know if it's worth it.
joe rogan
Right.
james lindsay
You're just like, oh, it reduces this one thing that's bad.
There's like a million things that are bad.
joe rogan
But it did in some ways calm people that everyone around you that has masks on is doing the right thing.
james lindsay
Mask, formation, psychosis.
joe rogan
But maybe, but also like for folks, let's listen to this.
jamie vernon
It's a 50-minute video.
james lindsay
Dude, that's like an hour.
joe rogan
Is it really?
jamie vernon
Yeah.
It's like a whole special on PBS about Spanish flu.
joe rogan
Oh, but I think I sent...
I thought it was...
Wasn't it timestamped?
Hold on a second.
Oh, that's the link to the full documentary.
I'm sorry.
james lindsay
That was not a good flu.
joe rogan
Yeah, I'm sorry, Jamie.
Here, I'll send you a link to the...
Oh, that's what it is, because someone sent me a video.
Saved the camera roll.
Okay, here.
Sorry.
Here's the actual video.
I'll text it to you right now.
Sorry.
So here's...
I sent it to you.
You should get it to me any second now.
james lindsay
Yeah, I legit think that, like, we've spent too much time caring about what makes lots of other people feel better, and we've put ourselves in a bad position as a result.
So I don't personally find...
joe rogan
There's some of that for sure.
I mean, the suck it up buttercup thing, you know, there's some of that.
But, okay, let's play this real quick.
unidentified
The epidemic was now a national crisis.
Something had to be done.
In many places, officials rushed through laws requiring people to wear masks in public.
All of America, it seemed, put on masks.
At last, many thought, they were safe.
We're seeing these images.
They were thin and porous.
No serious restraint to tiny microbes.
It was like trying to keep out dust with chicken wire.
joe rogan
So this was obviously made before...
What happened there?
Something else I sent you?
Oh, it's another text I say.
The video, this documentary was made, obviously, before the pandemic.
Right.
You wouldn't make that video now.
No one would put that in a documentary.
They'd be like, edit that out.
james lindsay
Yeah, it'd be totally considered misinformation.
joe rogan
Right.
Because even though it's factual, I'm sure you've seen that doctor who blows vape smoke.
james lindsay
My favorite one that I've seen, I have seen the smoke one.
My favorite one that I've seen was a dude that put on like five of them and he went out and it was like ass cold with snow everywhere.
And you know, your breath.
And it's just like clouds of it all around his head as he breathes, coming through the mask, going out the sides.
And it's like...
joe rogan
Five of them.
james lindsay
Yeah, like five masks.
He puts on one and breathes and it's everywhere.
He puts on another one and it just like kind of gets worse the more he puts on.
joe rogan
If you can breathe, you breathe out.
If you breathe in, you breathe out.
If you breathe out, air is coming out and then those tiny little...
james lindsay
Aerosol part of this.
joe rogan
Yeah, they're gonna go out with it.
It's just like how much of it is being captured by the mask and is it enough where it justifies it?
james lindsay
The apparent answer is mostly probably not, but...
joe rogan
But there have been studies, supposedly.
james lindsay
Supposedly.
joe rogan
Like they're always talking about, studies have shown that masks and social distancing work.
I think social distancing works if you're like 50 feet apart.
Yeah, I think that works.
But I mean the six-foot thing, really?
Like, you and I right now are about, what is this?
How wide is this?
About five.
Okay, so this is six feet.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
Would you be comfortable with someone that had fucking the plague and they were this close to you breathing?
james lindsay
That's crazy.
In a closed room.
joe rogan
That's crazy.
james lindsay
Absolutely not.
joe rogan
The fact that we were told, like, have you ever seen that guy in Germany that walks around at these protests with a pole?
unidentified
With a pole!
joe rogan
That's a six-foot pole, makes sure that people are apart from each other by six feet.
james lindsay
It's so lame.
It's like I keep wanting to, like, I want to see somebody take it like a bo staff and just, like, go full Jackie Chan on the guy or whatever.
joe rogan
It's just, well, it's one of the things where people are looking for something to comfort them, and the mask, in some ways, comforts people.
I put it on in the beginning of the pandemic, gladly, because whether it works or not, I was like, at least people know you're not an asshole.
james lindsay
Yeah, yeah, yeah, I got that.
I did the same thing.
I kind of looked back at it and kind of wish I didn't now.
I think we needed a little bit more reasonable asshole as opposed to unreasonable asshole.
joe rogan
The thing is, like, there's too many people who are falling in line.
You would just be attacked.
james lindsay
Well, I mean, I was in Tennessee, so not so much.
If I'd been in L.A. hanging out with you, we might have had a different story.
Because, like, Tennessee, by, like...
April, May, we're just like, yeah, screw this.
And then our governor came on TV, he's like, we recommend you wear masks.
And we're like, recommend, huh?
Okay.
You know, we're done.
joe rogan
See, England today dropped everything.
james lindsay
They dropped it, yeah.
But Boris got rid of it all because he knows he's politically screwed.
joe rogan
Yeah.
james lindsay
Well, he got caught partying while he's locking everybody down and 10 Downing and all this stuff.
He's been real weird ever since all that.
joe rogan
Where was he partying?
james lindsay
In 10 Downing Street, like during the height of the lockdown, like last Christmas, not last year, but the year before, like Christmas.
unidentified
So many of them.
james lindsay
I know.
joe rogan
Mayor of San Francisco, she got busted, and then all of a sudden she's hard on crime now.
james lindsay
Yeah, right?
joe rogan
She's like, we gotta do something about this crime.
Like, what?
What are you saying?
james lindsay
All of a sudden.
joe rogan
You locked the fucking city down.
unidentified
All of a sudden.
joe rogan
You were responsible for a lot of that shit, the tolerance of that shit.
james lindsay
See, I worry, though, not only, like, we talk about mass formation, psychosis, or whatever, but I worry...
the idea that they're safe when they're not, if safety is the thing you're appealing to.
joe rogan
Right.
james lindsay
Because, I mean, you know, martial arts, we all have the old thing.
Like, you teach somebody a kata and then they think they know how to fight.
And then they're more confident, so they go and get their ass beat, right?
And it's, you know, it's a joke if it's some dude, you teach him, like, his yellow belt and then he goes and gets beat up.
It's like, ha ha.
But because we're guys and we don't care about guys getting beat up.
And it's funny.
Like, dude, you try to do a jump kick?
Like, really?
When it's like women's self-defense.
joe rogan
Right.
james lindsay
And you teach her just enough to get confident enough to get her ass beat.
Like, that's not good.
And so it's literally part of the Dunning-Kruger effect where you get overconfident in how good you are and then you make bad decisions or whatever.
joe rogan
That's – I used to teach martial arts and I went to one of those women's self-defense courses where they would – They put someone in a giant foam outfit.
james lindsay
Yeah, a red man suit.
joe rogan
Yeah, and then the guy would try to attack a woman, and then the woman would say, no!
And she'd punch him in the face, and no!
And kick him in the nuts, and no!
And everyone's like, yeah, yeah, yeah!
And I'm sitting there going, man, you're setting these people up to get really fucking hurt.
Because a woman, especially a tiny woman, I mean, some women would fuck you up that can punch really hard.
james lindsay
True story.
joe rogan
It's real.
Some women can knock you the fuck out, but a lot of them can't.
james lindsay
Right.
joe rogan
And there's nothing you're going to be able to do.
They have, like, these little tiny hands.
There's not a damn thing you're going to be able to do.
unidentified
Wait.
james lindsay
Hold up, Joe.
Are you one of those extremists that believes that men and women are not the same?
joe rogan
That's what I do.
unidentified
Yes.
james lindsay
Man, woman, boy, girl, we're all the same.
You know where I saw that?
joe rogan
Where?
james lindsay
On a mural in Chinese in Beijing.
unidentified
Ooh.
Jesus.
joe rogan
Well, not in a fight.
james lindsay
Not in a fight.
Turns out those bell curves of upper body strength don't overlap very much.
joe rogan
There's a hilarious article that was in, might have been like Pink News or one of those things, about Michael Phelps.
And Michael Phelps unironically saying that it's not fair if this Penn State transgender woman competes against that Michael Phelps ironically says it's not an even playing field.
Like, unironically, rather.
Unironically.
Because it's not even playing field because he's gifted.
Like, that's the idea.
It's like they're making a parallel between Michael Phelps being physically gifted, because he is physically gifted.
james lindsay
He's a bit of a, yeah, anomaly.
joe rogan
Kind of a physical freak.
unidentified
Yeah.
joe rogan
But, you know, so it was...
LeBron James.
james lindsay
Yeah, exactly.
So basically in any sport at this point, all the hyper...
unidentified
The elite of the elite.
joe rogan
Yeah, hyper athletes.
But you can't compare that to a transgender woman competing against females that's beating people by 38 seconds.
james lindsay
Yeah, it's like the entire length of the pool or something.
It's so crazy.
Something so absurd.
joe rogan
It's so absurd.
Did you see that she got beat by another transgender woman?
james lindsay
I did.
I laughed in my heart.
joe rogan
It's like, what is happening?
james lindsay
What is this?
It's like that, you know, you laugh and then you cry.
joe rogan
Well, women should be crying.
james lindsay
Exactly.
joe rogan
Women's sports are getting destroyed by transgender women in that regard.
james lindsay
Because social constructivism doesn't have any breaks is the problem.
It turns out all that gender construct shit, it doesn't have any breaks.
joe rogan
Here it says, none of Thomas' teammates have spoken on the record about their opinion on the matter.
Of course, they don't want to get attacked.
Though some have chosen to do so anonymously to voice their concern.
She compares herself to Jackie Robinson.
She said this is like the Jackie Robinson of Transports.
One of Thomas' teammates told the Washington Examiner last week.
She laughs about it and mocks the situation.
Instead of caring or showing that she cares about what she's doing, Or what she's doing to her teammates.
She's not sympathetic or empathetic at all because she's acting like a guy.
james lindsay
Yeah, and a narcissistic guy at that.
Can you imagine comparing yourself to Jackie Robinson?
joe rogan
Scroll up, though, so you can see the headline, because it's kind of crazy.
Michael Phelps.
No, that's great that he said that, because it does need to be a level playing field.
Biological females should be competing against biological females, and you are going to have outliers.
When you have biological females, you're going to have super athletes that are going to dominate.
The Michael Jordans of female athletes.
That is not what I was talking about.
What I was talking about was...
I'll find it here.
What they were saying is that he's silly for saying that.
james lindsay
Yeah, of course they are.
He doesn't understand anything or whatever.
joe rogan
Yeah, it's in pink news.
It says...
Here, I'll send you this, Jamie.
You can see it.
You got it?
Here, I just sent you the image of it.
It's just like...
There's a difference, kids.
james lindsay
There's a difference.
joe rogan
There's a big difference between an outlier who's also biologically male and a person who is in a completely different category.
There's a reason why we separate male sports versus female sports.
james lindsay
Even just within each.
Then we separate by weight and we separate by, in some sports, not like the top top, but by years of experience.
We used to sport fight some.
Brown belt class, black belt class.
joe rogan
And certainly weight classes.
james lindsay
Yeah, and certainly weight classes.
Because it turns out, it matters.
joe rogan
Fuck, man, it matters a lot.
james lindsay
It matters a lot.
joe rogan
Yeah, when everybody says, no, technique matters.
Okay, well, how about you get a Gordon Ryan who's also giant and with great technique?
james lindsay
Yeah, exactly.
joe rogan
You're fucked.
james lindsay
Here, here it is.
jamie vernon
I can't make it look better.
joe rogan
Oh, sorry.
Michael Forbes, like...
Without a hint of irony, Michael Phelps says sports should be even playing field.
Without a hint of irony.
james lindsay
So they're making fun of him.
joe rogan
He's so silly.
james lindsay
He's so silly.
joe rogan
He's so dumb.
He's so dumb.
Embrace the future.
And then probably everyone's a fed.
james lindsay
Yeah, right.
They're all feds, transgender feds.
joe rogan
It's like these guys that are the ones that are showing up at that rally and then there was only feds showing up wearing glasses.
Like, do they think like, what did I sign up for?
Or do they just do their job?
james lindsay
You know, the ones that I wondered about were the ones who were like the fake Tiki Torch guys outside of Yunkin's bus in Virginia.
I was like, what's that parody though?
joe rogan
Wasn't that a joke?
james lindsay
I don't think so.
I don't know.
I think not.
I thought they were like seriously trying to, you know, stage some some shit.
joe rogan
Oh, I thought that that was a parody.
james lindsay
It was like people on the other guy's campaign were tied to it.
This is, again, what I was talking about earlier with the internet, sleuthing out within 15 minutes.
It's like, oh, here's this chick's Facebook page.
Here's who she is.
Oh, she works for this blah, blah, blah, Democrat, this and that.
And it's like, holy crap.
joe rogan
Right.
james lindsay
Could you imagine standing there dressed with the button-down white shirt and a Trump hat and holding a tiki torch, just a putz, knowing you're a putz?
joe rogan
Lincoln Project says it's behind the group with Tiki Torches by Young and Campaign Buster.
james lindsay
Oh yeah, Lincoln Project threw themselves under the bus, probably to protect the campaign, in my opinion.
Because their name's already mud.
Like, they got all that pedophile stuff going on with them.
joe rogan
What?
james lindsay
Oh yeah, the Lincoln Project has all kinds of, like, they have their own, like, pedo scandal around them.
joe rogan
And what are you talking about?
james lindsay
99% sure.
joe rogan
I didn't know that.
james lindsay
Yeah, it's...
joe rogan
I've not heard that at all.
james lindsay
Yeah, it's not good.
We'd have to look it up.
But they got in a hell of a lot of trouble for it.
joe rogan
So there was someone on the campaign or the Lincoln Project that was involved in this?
james lindsay
With the Tiki Torch thing?
No, the pedophile stuff that you're talking about.
Yeah, I think it's one of the guys that was near the top, was doing some weird crap.
We'd have to look it up.
I don't want to get the details wrong, but I have a pretty decent memory.
joe rogan
Here it goes.
Lincoln Project founders try to deny they knew co-founder who sexually harassed boys.
Oh, great.
james lindsay
Oh, great.
How about that?
How about that?
There's a lot of that going on in the swamp.
joe rogan
How many fucking creeps there are out there?
james lindsay
Dude, I know.
joe rogan
You know?
james lindsay
Yeah.
It's friggin' crazy.
joe rogan
What are you...
I mean, how many are there?
Like, that's the thing that leads people to think that, like, Pizzagate is real.
james lindsay
Exactly.
That's exactly right.
Right?
Because there's so many of these, like, breadcrumbs.
joe rogan
Right.
james lindsay
And it's so easy to, like, follow, follow, follow, and then the next thing you know, you're in some ditch.
joe rogan
Right.
james lindsay
Right?
Like, you're showing up to a pizza place with a rifle.
joe rogan
Right.
unidentified
Right.
james lindsay
To save the kids who aren't there.
And it's like...
I mean, so many of the things we talked about today all come back to that.
It's like, this is why...
Why don't you guys do this really crazy thing called Come Clean?
Just start telling us some truth instead and get your credibility back.
Who would do that?
joe rogan
You mean journalists?
Is that what you're saying?
james lindsay
Well, I mean...
Yeah, journalists, they're even doing it.
Like CNN and the CDC both are all of a sudden like, you know, well, there were a lot of deaths with COVID that weren't deaths of COVID. Isn't that wild when you hear that?
joe rogan
Like, what are you saying?
james lindsay
Yeah, right?
joe rogan
Like when Fauci's talking about children, there's a lot of children who are in the hospital with COVID. Yeah.
Not because of COVID. All of a sudden, yeah.
james lindsay
Well, I mean, if we're going to stick in Fedland, we're going to talk about this concept called a limited hangout.
Do you know what a limited hangout is?
joe rogan
You explained to me last night.
james lindsay
Yeah, it's Watergate.
Watergate.
So a limited hangout is like instead of letting it all hang out, you're going to do a limited amount of hanging it out.
So you're going to tell some of the truth to regain your credibility.
But then you're going to retain the key bad stuff and not give those details away.
And so all of a sudden, basically their narrative has – what we're watching right now is a very exciting time, weird time, but an exciting time to be alive.
We're watching the narrative collapse.
joe rogan
Right.
james lindsay
And so they're trying to regain their credibility because CNN's viewership is in the toilet.
joe rogan
They've lost 90 percent.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
Yeah, it's bad.
90% of their viewers.
Do you know how insane that is?
james lindsay
And they, like, own the airports and stuff.
joe rogan
Not anymore.
james lindsay
No, it's Fox or something now.
joe rogan
No, I don't know if they're even doing news at the airport.
james lindsay
Actually, I have no idea.
Yeah, right.
joe rogan
Everybody should be happy.
CNN is so doom and gloom.
That's the last thing you want to see before you get on a fucking metal tube that flies through the air.
james lindsay
That was the other thing we talked about last night, was the guy who came up with the word microaggression.
joe rogan
Yes.
james lindsay
So I looked this dude up.
Chester Pierce is his name.
Okay, so Chester Pierce came up with microaggressions in 1970. And what I told you was that he was somehow involved with MKUltra.
joe rogan
Yes.
james lindsay
Which is exciting, right?
Turns out he also was one of the chief consultants, I looked him up and read about him this morning, for Sesame Street when it started.
unidentified
Oh!
james lindsay
So do you know the story where – what's his name?
Jolly.
joe rogan
Yeah, Jolly West.
james lindsay
Yeah, Jolly West.
With the elephant?
With the LSD and the elephant?
joe rogan
Yes.
james lindsay
So Chester Pierce was part of the elephant thing.
joe rogan
Explain the story.
james lindsay
Okay.
So they have this elephant, Tusca or something like that.
It was an elephant's name.
Literally, I read this this morning.
And they were trying to figure out something about how LSD does things and controllability and all this.
And for some reason they're really interested in elephants and don't know what it is.
They have no idea what dose LSD to give an elephant.
So they shoot it with a dart that has like, you know, just the human dose like scaled up.
Some, you know, LSD people will get it like some number of milligrams, like maybe hundreds of milligrams.
Of LSD into the elephant's ass and it goes nuts.
It's like rampaging around and laying on his side and his tongue turns blue and it's like seizures.
And they try to give it like antipsychotics and the elephant dies, right?
Not that long later.
And then they find out, turns out the elephants are super, super, super sensitive to LSD. And so they killed this elephant like screwing around with it.
And this part of like...
So Jolly West was like the MK Ultra guy doing all the mind control.
Well, Charles Pierce was like this guy and he was kind of in charge of...
I don't know what his deal with elephants was.
But he was in charge of this thing that was a like coalition of black psychiatrists.
And he was a Harvard psychiatry guy, but he was tied up with West, Jolly West.
And he talked about how, you know, the black man like really loves Jolly West because all this.
He had all these things with Jolly West.
He did the elephant thing with Jolly West.
I don't know how involved in MKUltra he was, but he was very interested in the way that TV in particular brainwashes black kids to feel inferior.
That was like a huge thing for him.
And so he wanted to try to combat that.
And as far as I can tell, the Sesame Street stuff is not all that nefarious, but it's a little weird that Snuffleupagus is on there now that they killed an elephant and then he makes Sesame Street with a woolly mammoth or whatever as one of the characters.
But a little weird.
But this guy who was literally like...
A black radical in the 60s who was also a Harvard psychiatrist and was tied up with all this like police and FBI and like CIA garbage with LSD and all the experiments he was doing and he was a longtime friend and collaborated with West, Jolly West.
This guy...
Is also the guy who names microaggressions, which is this weird little idea that if I say, like, hey, where are you from?
And you happen to be from, like, Mexico or something, that you have to be insulted now.
Yesterday, it turns out, was Tuesday.
And we're in Austin, so I got tacos on Taco Tuesday.
That's a microaggression, right?
Can you believe I did that?
joe rogan
Tacos on Taco Tuesday is a microaggression?
james lindsay
Yeah, because that's, like, stealing Mexican culture of tacos.
joe rogan
What if you buy them from Mexicans?
james lindsay
Well, that might be okay.
I don't know.
No, it's probably—no, I have no idea.
It's all made up.
So this concept, though, comes from this guy who also is like a consultant for Sesame Street and wants to use like psychological techniques to like do diversity on TV to—well, it looks like good reasons.
Like I'm not even going to crap on Sesame Street.
I'm not going to say that— Sesame Street was a CIA plot to like tear America apart.
It's nothing like that.
But this guy is an interesting character.
But he's the guy who comes up with microaggressions and he worked on MKUltra.
So it's like...
joe rogan
How did he define microaggressions?
james lindsay
So small slights that over time build up.
Like if you hear like a little thing about, you know, or kind of racially tinged comment or whatever...
It doesn't really bug you.
You can brush it off.
But if you hear them again and again and again and again and again.
joe rogan
So is a microaggression, like if you told an Asian, like, you sure are good at math, that's a microaggression.
james lindsay
Yes, that would be one.
That would definitely be one.
joe rogan
Because you're playing on a stereotype.
james lindsay
Stereotype, yeah.
Yeah.
Or even saying long time no see, because it's a direct transition.
joe rogan
What about if a black guy has a big dick?
james lindsay
Well, you know, he's probably not going to complain.
joe rogan
Everybody's happy to have a big dick.
That's like one of those stereotypes of people like, yeah, we like that one.
james lindsay
Yeah.
All the positive stereotypes.
Right.
Maybe the ones with the small dicks, they're going to be mad.
Like, why do you always assume?
Right.
Like, and those guys have got like some little man syndrome going on, like probably extra.
joe rogan
Right.
Imagine the expectations, right?
james lindsay
Yeah, that's disappointing.
joe rogan
The patriarchy or something.
james lindsay
Yeah, it's definitely something patriarchal.
joe rogan
Something cisgender or something.
james lindsay
Something bad.
Some ism is going on here.
joe rogan
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
There's a lot of wrongs.
james lindsay
A lot of wrongs.
A lot of wrongs.
Domestic violent extremists.
joe rogan
Let me ask you this because this is – I mean, I know you think about this probably more than anybody.
Your understanding of critical theory and your analysis of what's happening.
Where does this all go?
Like, do you think we can pull out of this?
Yeah, actually.
You do?
james lindsay
I do.
I do.
But we actually have to kind of culturally wake the fuck up.
We have to realize that it's not just guaranteed here, right?
It's not just, you know, the old saying is, you know, people think it couldn't happen here.
No, it could.
And it turns out that the critical theories, as it happens, are stupid.
They're, like, transparently dumb.
Everybody reads about, you know, critical race theory.
Like, it's so complicated.
I can't understand it.
I'm telling you.
It's as broad as a Great Lake, but, like, an inch deep.
Actually, I put this as the first thing.
This book isn't real, by the way.
The book is, but this copy's not.
But I do have...
joe rogan
What do you mean it's not real?
james lindsay
Well, I don't have it typeset fully yet.
joe rogan
So what's going on in that book?
james lindsay
The first chapter over and over and over again.
joe rogan
Come on.
james lindsay
No, really, because I haven't finished the typesetting yet.
It's in stages.
It comes out like on the 15th of February.
joe rogan
But that's like a mock book?
james lindsay
It's a mock book so that I could show that I have a book.
But I'm painfully honest, so I can't pretend.
joe rogan
That's good.
james lindsay
That's a good quality.
This really is the first chapter, though.
And the first thing I have is defining critical race theory, chapter one.
And I say critical race theory, noun.
Calling everything one wants to control racist until you control it.
That's all it comes down to.
Calling everything racist, sexist, or whatever until you control it.
joe rogan
But let me be the opposite of this.
Because the thing that people argue against is that what people are trying to do by denying critical race theory, they're denying the conversation about the wrongs of the past.
And they want to pretend that nothing happened.
They want to pretend that red line laws didn't happen, Jim Crow didn't happen, slavery didn't happen.
Or if it did, it's not worth discussing today.
Because what's going on today, we're on an even playing field.
We had a black president and everything's fine.
And they're saying, no, that's not the case.
What critical race theory is to them is discussing the wrongs of the past.
james lindsay
That's what they want you to believe.
But what it is, is it's discussing the wrongs of the past in a particular way.
joe rogan
Trevor Burrus And what is wrong with the way that they're discussing it?
james lindsay
Aaron Ross Powell Their assumption fundamentally is that – discussing it in a Marxist way is what's the problem.
In the Marxist view, there's a system that – the entire society operates under a system that dictates how the society operates.
It's in fact that you have the base for Marx.
Let me just do a little Marxism for you.
You have the base, the productive workers, the proletariat.
They make all the stuff.
And so they're the rightful inheritors to society because they make all the stuff.
Trevor Burrus And not be overthrown.
Like, no, people need religion, so they need somebody who understands God, so we need a minister, so I should have a job as a priest and you should come to church and tithe to me and pay me.
Or people need – the law needs to be worked out, so we need lawyers who are going to be able to help people settle disputes and keep it within the realm of the law, and we need law in the first place.
So now we need lawyers.
So there's these claims about why those jobs should exist and then why people like them should have them.
Well, I went to law school and worked really hard, so my merit got me there.
I worked so hard.
And what the Marxists say is it's all fake.
It's all a mythology created by the people in power to keep their power.
Okay?
And the belief is that until that is completely overthrown in revolution and the people on the bottom seize power through a period of dictatorship, literally he called it the dictatorship of the proletariat, that the system doesn't change.
So all these – in critical race theory, the ideology is white supremacy.
And the country was founded in white supremacy.
So it doesn't matter that Thomas Jefferson wrote, all men are created equals.
He held slaves and therefore he didn't believe it.
Even if you – but if, of course, you read Thomas Jefferson, you see him struggling with this.
Like he doesn't know what to do about it and he laments kicking it down the generations to some later time that landed on Lincoln.
But no, he created a system rooted in white supremacy that's for white benefit, etc.
And, of course, that is in the 18th century.
Right?
And for the Marxist, that never changes.
All the thing on top, that ideology, the whiteness that you have access to, all the white supremacists ever do is figure out how to hide the fact that they're justifying their illegitimate position better.
So you need a critical theory that can see – it's critical so it can see through those lies.
It understands that there's a structural nature to society that's produced by the interaction of the lower and the upper.
Matthew Feeney Except that the people who benefit from white supremacy have figured out ways to hide it better by,
say, letting some racial minorities succeed or by desegregating schools.
That was Derrick Bell, first critical race theorist, formally speaking.
His big thing was that desegregating schools was actually white people trying to … protect American interests against communists at the expense of black people who are now going to have to go to integrated schools where they're going to suffer racism and so on.
It's very pessimistic and cynical analysis.
But nothing – not abolition of slavery through the Civil War and all that blood and everything, which was in a sense a revolution, not the civil rights movement.
None of that actually changed racism except in how it manifests.
The ideology from the white supremacists just took a different form.
And in fact, there's a book – I can't remember the title of the book, Race, Class and Nation, Race, Nation, Class, something like this.
It's a French Marxist book I was reading a couple of weeks ago.
They actually say that – they say explicitly that racism has gotten worse as it's gone out of the biological and out of the institutional and into the culture where it's super diffuse and you can't find it.
It's all hidden.
joe rogan
Like it's gotten worse because it's gotten better?
james lindsay
Yes.
unidentified
Yes.
james lindsay
Exactly.
They say it hasn't gotten better.
It's exactly the same, but it's more intense and it's invisible, except to people like them who have the special goggles that can see it.
So it's not whether or not we want to have conversations about the past.
It's how those conversations are going to proceed.
And as we have dealt with, some certain very intolerant people are going to say that every other possible way to discuss the past and the present of this country is racist.
Only critical race theory is anti-racist.
Everything else is racist.
That's literally their model.
Right?
And so it's not about whether we're going to discuss.
Yeah, there are some assholes who don't want to talk about it, who don't want to look at it.
I very rarely hear from messages like that.
I always hear, we're going to talk about our history warts and all.
I think there's a lot to learn from all that so we don't do that shit again.
Right?
And so no, it's a question of how we're going to do it.
And we have this intolerant ideology that sees only one way to do it.
But what was the definition I just read to you that I give as the first thing in my new book is that critical race theory is calling everything you want to control racist until you control it.
So now you want to have a conversation about race?
Every version except theirs is racist because they want to control the conversation about race.
And that's the problem.
It's not whether or not we're going to have these conversations.
It's not that there were issues and that there are probably things – there are definitely things that still hang over from those issues, redlining, et cetera.
The wealth gap is significant.
What happened following the civil rights with the Great Society and the decimation of the black family, that's freaking real.
It has serious consequences today in terms of all the things we're talking about.
It's all real.
Right?
But it's how that conversation has to proceed.
And if they're going to say every single way but our way is racist, all they're trying to do is use that label racist to control the conversation, put it on their terms.
But their terms are this crackpot Marxist thing that it keeps getting worse until when?
Until they're totally in power.
joe rogan
I feel like there's also an aspect to it where social media has illuminated these pathways for people to take, where they can become famous and prominent by addressing these concerns that people have about racism.
And calling everyone racist and looking at things in the most uncharitable light because they then get attention from that and then these arguments and these discussions and they make YouTube videos or they're on television shows or whatever they're doing.
And then it becomes their avenue to success by calling everything racist.
james lindsay
Yeah, that's right.
And so it creates really bad incentives, right?
Those incentives are totally perverse.
And what you'll notice, by the way, what you just pointed out is, yeah, these people who are actually like Marxist types can manipulate that.
No, grifter city.
Do you know how easy it is to become a race grifter in those conditions?
All you have to do is say you have these feelings and nobody can question your feelings and you call like the idea that master bedrooms sounds like slave quarters versus master.
It turns out that's not it.
joe rogan
That was from Sears in like 1929. How funny was it when that one dude said that so many white people are pretending that they're people of color in order to get into university?
james lindsay
Ibram Kendi.
Yeah, he torpedoed himself a bit there, didn't he?
joe rogan
Explain that.
james lindsay
Yeah, so Ibram Kendi is like one of the patron saints of this stuff.
He wrote two really kind of influential books.
One is stamped from the beginning, which is what I was just saying.
America was stamped from the beginning in racism.
So it doesn't get out until they have all the power.
And I'll come back to Kendi on the power and the proletariat and the dictatorship thing.
That's super important.
But then he's going over all his colleges and there's this problem and he wants to like crap on white people.
He's got his other book, sorry, it's How to Be an Antiracist.
I forgot to say that.
And that's where he says the only – page 19, the only remedy to past discrimination is present discrimination and the only remedy to present discrimination is future discrimination.
So he's advocating for discrimination.
So then he looks at the colleges and you have this problem going on.
There are a lot of white kids that are pretending all of a sudden to be people of color, right?
They're pretending to be some other race and they've got their sad story or whatever.
And he's like wanting to say, well, this is just white people trying to cash in on...
They're trying to exploit the situations of people of color to their own advantage yet again.
That's like his analysis of everything.
He's called everything racist until you control it.
And it kind of blew up on him because what he's actually pointing out is there is a strong incentive structure to pretend that you're not white because the advantage lies somewhere else now under this ideology.
And so he ends up torpedoing his own thing.
Now, people screw up on Twitter all the time.
Believe you me, I'm all about screwing up on Twitter.
I know about this.
However, there are certain things you don't do when you screw up on Twitter.
The first thing you don't do is just freaking delete that shit.
Because then everybody's like, oh, he knew he was wrong.
So Kendi deletes it.
And then he comes back the next day and decides to do these tweet threads and just blow everybody up.
And so this guy, Jack Posobiec, He calls him out on all of this and then he starts going after Jack and that's a mistake.
Jack is really good at Twitter.
You don't go after people who are really good at Twitter and have like 1.3 million followers.
And so he ends up just torpedoing himself and he actually like vanished from the limelight for a little while until they brought him back out for Martin Luther King, you know, Critical Race Theory Day.
And he did his thing there where it's like we're going to interpret Martin Luther King in a particular way and white people shouldn't be invoking him, especially his, you know, most famous I Have a Dream speech.
But he vanished for a while because he torpedoed himself because he admitted that under the regime that they've created, that the advantage doesn't flow automatically to white people.
White privilege is no longer material in the systems they've created.
joe rogan
Because white people pretending to be a person of color, they get in college is easier.
james lindsay
Yeah.
Why else would you do it unless there was some incentive?
joe rogan
Right.
james lindsay
If your race literally didn't matter.
joe rogan
So by saying that, What he's done, where the fuck up is.
james lindsay
He's undercut his own theory.
joe rogan
Right.
james lindsay
Yeah.
He's like, no, white people have permanent privilege.
And then he's describing how white people have to pretend to be people of color to gain access to privileged locations in society.
It's like, whoops.
And poor guy.
He's not the brightest, Dr. Kendi.
But I want to talk about him for a second because I mentioned his books.
But in 2019, he got asked by Politico.
They have this series, how to, how to do whatever, right?
And so how do you fix inequality?
I kid you not.
It's one paragraph.
And he says the way we fix inequality is by instituting an anti-racist constitutional amendment.
And what will it do?
He says it's going to be based on two principles, that all the races are equal, and inequity, so differences in outcome on average by racial group, over a certain threshold will be By definition, racist.
Be chalked up to racism.
Racism was the cause of any outcomes that are different by group on average.
And so then he says, what's this constitutional amendment that enshrines those principles?
Which, by the way, he misspelled the word principles.
I could even show you.
He literally misspelled principles in his little one paragraph write-up.
He says, what's it going to do?
It's going to establish this thing called the Department of Anti-Racism, DOA. I'm not making that up either.
Come on, dude.
DOA. Dead on arrival, I... All right.
What's that going to do?
It's going to be able to – it's going to be first of all composed of formally trained experts on racism and no political appointees, he tells us.
And if we ended up pulling this thing up, I'm telling you, I'm like quoting this thing from memory of Reddit so many times, like to public audiences.
And it's no – yeah, right here, look.
The amendment would make unconstitutional racial equity over a certain threshold as well as racist ideas by public officials.
It would establish and permanently fund the Department of Anti-Racism, comprised of formally trained experts on racism and no political appointees.
Like, seriously, I'm like doing it word for word almost from memory.
The DOA would be responsible for pre-clearing all local, state, and federal public policies.
That's a fucking dictatorship.
joe rogan
Pre-clearing?
What does that even mean?
Pre-clearing all local, state, and federal public policies to ensure that they won't yield racial inequity.
Pre-clearing.
james lindsay
Yeah.
So if you want to have a local law in your, you know, Austin City Council or whatever, or Texas State...
I think we're going to put them into action if they get cleared, pre-cleared, I guess.
Monitor those policies.
Investigate private racist policies when racial inequity surfaces.
So now you're Google.
It's not even public policy.
And now your corporate policy is going to be subjected to this as well.
And to monitor public officials for expressions of racist ideas.
The DOA would be empowered with disciplinary tools to wield over and against policymakers and public officials who do not voluntarily change their racist policy and ideas.
That's a dictatorship.
… led by the anti-racist as he calls them who are formally trained experts on racism, which means critical race theorists.
That's Marxism 101, that you're going to have the proletariat, no political appointees because those would be the bourgeois people, and they're going to seize the means of production, establish a dictatorship of the proletariat that's now going to be in charge of clearing all policies on all levels to make sure that it yields economic equity.
joe rogan
But see, you got to unpack this because if you looked at it on the surface, who the hell would be against stopping racism?
james lindsay
Because that's what it's not about, right?
Like he even says in his book that it directly says that the remedy is discrimination.
So it depends on how you want to define racism, which means we're playing this weird game.
And the way that they want to define racism is this weird structural thing that the white people set up society for their own benefit.
It excludes everybody else.
And because they've done that, Their benefit is basically perpetual.
They never actually investigate it.
They need a critical theorist to tell them where they're actually being racist.
And so of course people don't want there to be racism.
But what they mean by racism is actually how society works because they believe it was created in white supremacy and therefore the entire – like I said before, Marxist structure of society – Marxist theory structure of society, the organizing principle of society is actually racism.
So racism is the – this is quoting from another book, which is Critical Race Theory, an introduction in case we wonder if it's about critical race theory.
Racism is the ordinary state of affairs in society, not an aberration from them.
It's so-called normal science.
That's from Richard Delgado from 2001. He wrote that book.
Same book where he actually says that critical race theorists find another liberal mainstay.
This is page 23. They call into question another liberal mainstay or highly suspicious.
Sorry, I want to get the wording right.
Critical race theorists are highly suspicious of another liberal mainstay, namely rights.
So they're highly suspicious of rights.
joe rogan
Highly suspicious of rights.
What does that mean?
james lindsay
Well, they say rights are said to be alienating because I could say a racial slur to you and then you could say, hey, you can't say that hate speech.
And I say free speech.
joe rogan
But what about rights like the right to bear arms?
Same thing.
Second Amendment is racist?
james lindsay
They would say definitely so, because more white people than black people own guns.
And if black people go to own guns, you say, oh, no, angry black person with a gun, he's probably a criminal, blah, blah, blah.
So, yeah, definitely.
Everything for them, the entire structure of society has racism baked into it.
If I put it in their terms, what critical race theory says is that racism was baked into the law from the beginning, stamped from the beginning, being the title of Kendi's other book.
And it doesn't come out without a revolution that installs this kind of guy in power.
joe rogan
That's the only solution.
Therefore, they are the only solution.
james lindsay
They are the only people who have what's called a critical consciousness of race who therefore understand race to actually work this way.
joe rogan
Have you debated anybody on this?
james lindsay
Kind of.
It's hard to debate them.
They don't like to debate.
I did a small debate in Fort Worth at the beginning of November.
With who?
Some YouTube guy.
I'm almost embarrassed to say his name.
His real name is Justin.
He goes by Jangles.
joe rogan
Jangles?
Like Mr. Bojangles?
james lindsay
Without the Bo part, just Jangles.
It's really strange.
joe rogan
That's his YouTube handle?
james lindsay
Yeah.
I had very short patience with this guy, so it's fun to watch.
I was pretty mad.
So I encourage people to watch it.
I went on Dr. Phil, and we kind of had a debate.
They had a professor.
Sean Harper from USC. He's a critical race theory guy.
I looked up his CV. He's got all this, like, he's not just, like, got some of the credentials for the academic stuff, but he's got, like, he lists all of the grants that he's worked under, and it's like, you know, critical race and education, this, blah, blah, blah, Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, $750,000.
He's got millions from the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation and others to push this critical race theory.
And so this guy's, like, I guess he's kind of somehow in connection with Dr. Phil too.
He's like – they know each other.
He's been on the show before or something because at the beginning of the show, he's like, oh, it's good to see you again or whatever.
He's like, oh, it's good to be here.
So they know each other somehow.
But they brought him out first and then he dumps on a bunch of parents.
Like this is a story, man.
I'm still kind of pissed about this.
And I'm a pretty even-keeled guy.
So I got told I was going to go on Dr. Phil, have a debate, and there's going to be this professor.
And so he's their domain expert.
I'm the opposing side's anti-CRT domain expert.
So they bring the CRT guy out, and he, like, is by himself.
This is no debate.
He's just framing the whole thing.
And then they start bringing out dad.
They bring out this dad, Derek Wilburn.
He's just this guy from Colorado, three kids, whatever, conservative black dad.
And he's like, no, this is critical race theory, and he's saying all this stuff.
And then the professor just starts making fun of him.
Like, you don't know what you're talking about.
It's not even in schools.
That's not critical race theory.
Like, just belittling it, everything he says.
And I'm sitting in the back watching this because I'm not allowed out there yet.
Like, he's lying.
Oh, my God.
Or he doesn't know one or the other.
This is shameful.
And then they bring out some moms.
They bring out another expert on the CRT side first and then...
They double up on poor Derek.
And then they start bringing out some moms and it's like professors and professionals versus regular moms and dads.
And it's obviously stacked.
And they brought me out in like the last two minutes, like literally.
And I was so pissed off.
Dr. Phil asked me some question, and I was like, I didn't even answer it.
I just started saying, like, you guys are lying, you know, I just kind of went nuts.
It was super fun.
So I sort of, I mean, that kind of is a debate, but they didn't let me actually debate the guy.
joe rogan
Well, two minutes is certainly not a debate.
Did they respond to what you said?
james lindsay
No.
joe rogan
They didn't?
james lindsay
No.
joe rogan
So you said they were liars?
james lindsay
One person said, well, it's not taught in schools, like right at the very end.
Actually, that's not how it ended.
That's how they edited it to end.
The way it really ended was I had gone off about this one specific thing that the professor had laughed at Derek for.
So Derek had said, blah, blah, blah, started in 1989. And the professor was like...
1989, haha, how silly.
It's books from the 1970s.
And he was referring to Derrick Bell's Race, Racism and American Law from 1970. But it turns out the founding conference of critical race theory was in Madison, Wisconsin, in a convent off the campus of University of Wisconsin at Madison.
In 1989. And that's where Kimberly Crenshaw, who's one of the chief critical racers, named it critical race theory because it's critical theory using race and racial justice that employs critical theory.
That's what she said.
joe rogan
So is it semantics?
Like why is he defining it as a previous book?
james lindsay
You could say that it actually – the first real book of critical race theory was in the 1970s.
But he brings up 89. This guy has to be aware of the relevance of 1989. But he like – it's one thing to say, you know, actually it goes back a little further than that.
But yeah, that's a significant date.
But no, he made fun of the guy.
So anyway, the way the show – the recording really ended was I had went off and I was like, you know it was 1989. You know about the conference.
And I just did kind of the whole thing.
And I even added that Richard Delgado, who wrote the Critical Race here introduction, was at that meeting.
And he had this interview in like 97 or something and he describes it.
And he says, you know, we're in a convent.
He says there's an austere room with crucifixes here and there on the wall.
And then he puts in – he dashes off.
He adds a kind of parenthetical comment.
He says there's an odd setting for a bunch of Marxists.
And like that's the founding conference.
That's one of the guys at the founding conference of critical race theory describing the founding conference of critical race theory.
So I go through this whole thing.
joe rogan
Hold up.
But did you ask why they only brought you out in the last two minutes and why they Wasted all this time.
james lindsay
That was definitely the opportunity to ask such a question maybe of the producer afterwards could have come up.
But he seemed really happy.
joe rogan
He was happy in what way?
james lindsay
He was like, I kept getting told by the people who work there.
I probably end up getting half of them fired now.
I got told by a bunch of people later, I'm so glad you got to come out and actually say something about this.
We love what you have to say about it.
And the producer was all like, yeah, so great.
What you did was so great.
joe rogan
It's going to be great TV. So they liked that you did that or did they like that there was an argument?
james lindsay
I don't know.
joe rogan
They were happy.
The problem is when they have those television shows, what they really like is conflict.
james lindsay
Yeah, of course.
joe rogan
They don't necessarily like that you had a poignant...
james lindsay
Well, they came back into my dressing room kind of one by one and told me, you know, secretly I listen to your podcast and agree with most of what you say.
So I think there's a little bit of both.
joe rogan
Secretly is not good.
james lindsay
What?
Los Angeles.
joe rogan
I know, but it's fucking dumb.
I'm sick of it.
But why do they have these kind of conversations where they have a bunch of people who are professionals at discussing these topics gang up on someone who's a parent?
james lindsay
Well, you know why?
Because it...
It sets the narrative control.
They get to frame the narrative in a certain way.
joe rogan
Why would Dr. Phil want to do that?
It doesn't even make sense.
james lindsay
I mean, I don't know why Dr. Phil...
I don't know his motivations.
I didn't even speak with the guy.
joe rogan
It's probably his producers.
james lindsay
Yeah.
Or, I mean, he's under the Oprah umbrella.
So, you know, and Oprah's promoted stuff like Critical race theory ideas for the last little while.
joe rogan
And when she's done that, why do you think she's doing that?
She's probably thinking that this is a good thing because we're addressing racism.
james lindsay
Yeah, because a lot of people have been totally plausible that she just thinks this is a good thing and got swept up.
And I don't know that Oprah Winfrey is a Marxist or anything like that.
I'm not saying anything like that.
I don't know, but the framing was clear.
Just to finish the story, the last word, though, I bust this guy from 1989, and Derek, actually being a funny dude, turns to Dr. Phil and he points and he's like, I told you it was 1989. You know, it's a ha-ha, everybody laughs.
But they edited it to where the last word apparently came from one of them, saying, but that's not even taught in schools, which is false.
They're not teaching...
joe rogan
Why would they do that?
Why would they edit it that way?
james lindsay
I don't know.
Probably to try to make me look crazy.
joe rogan
I like Dr. Phil.
He's a great guy.
He's been on my podcast before.
james lindsay
He squeezed my shoulder.
He's all right.
Because he stuck me in the audience.
joe rogan
He squeezed your shoulders?
james lindsay
So as he walked by, he put his hand on my shoulder and squeezed it or whatever.
joe rogan
That makes him alright?
james lindsay
Well, he's nice enough for the circumstance.
I don't know.
He might not be alright.
joe rogan
He's a good guy.
He was a guest on the show and very good friends with his son.
james lindsay
So there you go.
I'm right off of yours.
joe rogan
I think shows like that are terrible.
james lindsay
I do too.
joe rogan
Not that they're terrible always, but they're terrible for discussing any complex issue that you need to have people say.
It needs to be a volley, like a tennis game.
james lindsay
Like a formal debate even.
joe rogan
Well, at least a conversation.
james lindsay
Yeah.
So it would have been cool.
joe rogan
The time constraints of those formats, they don't lend themselves to discussing complex issues.
james lindsay
Correct.
Correct.
If they would have brought me and him out, like him first, fine, whatever, and then me afterwards to kind of discuss and respond and then start bringing parents out, it would have been a very different structure to the show, a very different mood for me.
joe rogan
But I can see why they did it the way they did it because it incites conflict.
unidentified
Yeah.
joe rogan
And that's what gets ratings.
james lindsay
Well, I got them some ratings.
joe rogan
To have parents there and...
Well, I mean, if you were at the last two minutes, you probably didn't, honestly.
james lindsay
Well, I don't know.
joe rogan
Because most people don't make it to the last two minutes.
james lindsay
That's true.
joe rogan
Those kind of shows, they're very top-heavy, just like podcasts are.
james lindsay
That's because if you watch them, it's like...
joe rogan
Well, any shows.
Most people aren't there to the very end.
Like, if you watch any show, whether it's The Tonight Show or fucking Jimmy Kimmel, the vast majority of people are watching in the beginning, and they tail off.
james lindsay
They tail off, yeah.
joe rogan
People get bored.
We have developed an entire culture that has a short attention span.
james lindsay
Yeah, tell me about it.
joe rogan
So you have a complex issue like discussing curriculums in schools that do or don't promote certain theories.
james lindsay
Right.
joe rogan
You need people to fucking sit down and discuss it.
james lindsay
Yeah, long form.
joe rogan
Yeah, long form.
And if you got one of those guys on your podcast, then it would be interesting.
james lindsay
That would be interesting, yeah.
joe rogan
Have you reached out to any of those people?
james lindsay
I don't interview people of mine, so I haven't reached out to anybody.
I'd be willing to.
joe rogan
Yeah, you certainly should.
james lindsay
Yeah, I've seen lots of people try to get these things set up.
I had some friends who concocted this scheme where people would give money and then like it'd build up a pot and get donated either to the person participating or to charity, whatever.
If they participated to kind of like leverage debates.
Does that work?
For normal people, but when they've tried to get like Robin DiAngelo white White fragility lady.
Or Ibram Kendi or whatever.
No, they just won't come.
Even if you exceed the amount that their normal fee is.
joe rogan
Well, it seems like they've got a thing going on and they don't want to fuck up this thing that they've got going on.
james lindsay
I think that's correct.
joe rogan
They've got it completely locked in where they're generating a lot of income by speaking.
unidentified
Right.
james lindsay
And they have a justification in-house inside their theory that says that, you know, if they sat down to talk to you, you're already on, like, the bad list, right?
joe rogan
I'm on the bad list?
james lindsay
Well, you're on some bad lists, right?
You're a right-wing extremist now, according to everybody.
joe rogan
Never voted right-wing in my life.
james lindsay
I know, right?
I didn't until the last election.
joe rogan
Did you vote for Trump?
james lindsay
Yeah.
I said I was going to, and I had to go on TV in multiple countries to explain myself.
joe rogan
And why did you decide to vote for Trump?
james lindsay
A variety of reasons.
One was, I don't perceive Biden as being a radical.
I perceive Biden as being corrupt.
And so I figured he was going to get pushed around by his radical party and other forces, like possibly weird stuff with China, weird stuff with Ukraine or Russia or whoever might be involved, but China, certainly.
joe rogan
And what makes you think that Biden is corrupt?
james lindsay
That he's always been corrupt?
joe rogan
That's crazy.
Don't people change?
james lindsay
Well, he's changed a little in the last few years.
joe rogan
Well, he's lost his ability to count.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
He doesn't speak very well anymore.
james lindsay
Yeah.
Actually, when I got picked up from the airport on my way to the hotel when you flew me in here, the guy that drove me, the driver, was like, yeah, I drove Joe Biden around here a few years ago.
We got talking about that somehow.
And he's like, he kept asking me.
Come on, man!
He's like, what city are we in?
What city are we in?
And that was like four or five years ago.
unidentified
Whoa.
james lindsay
Yeah.
And it's like, Austin, Texas.
Yeah, it could not be true.
joe rogan
That guy could be just a fucking crazy Trump supporter.
james lindsay
You never know.
joe rogan
They're all nuts, you know?
james lindsay
So I figured he was corrupt.
I figured the media, which was holding Trump to account for everything he did and millions of things he didn't even do or say, was not going to treat Biden similarly.
I figured they were going to run cover for him.
And I fundamentally believe that it's crucial to a democracy that the – or a republic really – that the press is holding power to account.
The press shouldn't be the megaphone of the administration.
The press should be asking them tough questions.
And I just perceived that's not going to happen.
And then they were writing articles which have not come true yet, but it told me what direction they were thinking that said things like we should – if we don't get our way with the Supreme Court, we should start ignoring the Supreme Court.
Maybe we shouldn't actually have a Supreme Court.
Maybe we should pack the Supreme Court.
Maybe we don't need a constitution anymore.
These were in New Republic-level leftist magazines.
This isn't like Joe Biden came out and said that.
But I watched Kamala support bailing out the Black Lives Matter rioters.
Yeah.
how critical race theory works to the degree that I do is like I can't support people who are openly supporting critical race theory and its initiatives.
Like that's too scary.
So I was like, I'm going to have to bite the bullet.
And Trump's like the last kind of like rock on the train track that might derail this thing before it goes over.
joe rogan
Well, people hated Trump so badly that they pretended that Biden was a good candidate.
james lindsay
Yeah, right.
joe rogan
Intelligent people, they developed this cognitive dissonance where they were allowed to pretend openly and publicly that Biden was a good candidate.
And now that you're seeing who he is and how compromised he is, not just compromised mentally, but compromised in terms of like his ties to businesses and the way they're running things.
james lindsay
Whatever's going on with his son.
I mean, that was another ingredient too, right?
The Biden laptop, Hunter Biden laptop disappearing, like the media deciding this is something we're not going to talk about.
I was like, oh shit, the media is not going to play this right if he's president.
joe rogan
No, they didn't play it at all.
It was really creepy because it's a real issue.
And they had decided that the game had gone far enough where you couldn't have an additional Democratic candidate.
That was the only one.
And so because of that, they were willing to ignore truth.
james lindsay
Yeah, exactly.
joe rogan
That's scary.
It's scary because that's how – I mean, once you get people to accept that, now we're in a cult.
james lindsay
Right.
And so that's why I voted for Trump.
I was like, no, I'm not going along with that.
And if I have to bite the bullet to vote for Trump, now I kind of think the guy's hilarious.
So I'm like, eh, all right.
I think he's pretty funny.
joe rogan
Did you hang out with him?
james lindsay
I have not hung out with him.
joe rogan
Did you go somewhere where he was?
james lindsay
I was at Mar-a-Lago.
It was like 35-40 feet away.
No, it was a fundraiser.
joe rogan
What's he like to be?
Oh, I met him.
What am I saying?
I met him at the UFC. I was actually working.
I was sitting there and he came over and shook my hand.
By the way, regular size hands.
james lindsay
Regular sized hands.
joe rogan
And I have big hands, so it's nuts.
It's one of those weird things where they're just like trying to pretend.
james lindsay
Yeah, of course.
joe rogan
That he's got like these little T-Rex arms and little tiny hands.
james lindsay
No, normal hands.
joe rogan
But I think he just wears a big suit because he's overweight.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
And when you look at his hands and they're like this.
james lindsay
Well, he's trimming down now.
joe rogan
Is he?
james lindsay
Yeah, he's apparently trimmed down quite a bit.
joe rogan
Let me see some video.
james lindsay
Like there's some picture.
I don't know.
joe rogan
Is this probably you, a Trump supporter?
What's going on?
Is this propaganda?
Yeah, MAGA. You went to Mar-a-Lago.
james lindsay
I did go to Mar-a-Lago.
joe rogan
Yeah, you were hanging out with them.
james lindsay
I get it.
And you know, my deep old-school left sensibilities, right?
This is the only place on earth I've ever walked into and looked around, and the first thing I thought was, this place shouldn't exist.
joe rogan
Really?
james lindsay
It's so opulent.
It's gorgeous.
If there's five stars, five star, it's like seven stars.
Is it?
It's crazy, crazy nice.
joe rogan
Can anybody go there?
What is Mar-a-Lago?
I don't even know what it is.
james lindsay
It's like his house, but it's also an event.
Yeah, a club event place.
It's his house?
I mean, he has quarters there, yeah.
joe rogan
Quarters.
Right, but isn't it like a country club or something?
What is it?
james lindsay
I don't know.
unidentified
I don't know.
joe rogan
It's like a thing that I've never questioned.
james lindsay
I went there once.
joe rogan
It's like Mar-a-Lago, Trump's place.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
But then I'm like, well, why are so many people there?
Like, what is that?
james lindsay
It's the Winter White House, he said, remember?
joe rogan
Right.
And so you went to the Winter White House.
james lindsay
Yeah, it was fun.
joe rogan
So he's got his own little spot.
james lindsay
Yeah.
It was a fundraiser for Ken Paxton.
joe rogan
Who's that?
james lindsay
Near Texas.
He is your Attorney General.
joe rogan
Texas Attorney General?
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
Here we go.
Trump's viral pic showing remarkable weight loss slammed as fake as hell.
So that's the pic on the right?
Is it fake?
james lindsay
Who knows?
Who knows?
joe rogan
Maybe he lost some weight.
james lindsay
I mean, he was a good 30-40 feet away from me.
joe rogan
What are you reading this from?
jamie vernon
I'm looking at why they're saying it's fake.
joe rogan
No, I know, but what is the website?
jamie vernon
I just typed in weight loss.
There were some pictures.
This is an older story from September.
15 pounds is what maybe it was.
james lindsay
He's really orange there.
joe rogan
Both of them, he's orange.
Yeah, but the one on the left is ridiculous.
james lindsay
He's a little ridiculously orange.
joe rogan
Is that makeup?
What is that?
james lindsay
I don't know.
I don't know him that well.
joe rogan
So is the idea that they do that just to make him look healthier?
Because if he was super pale and looked like that, he would look like shit?
james lindsay
Maybe.
I have no idea.
joe rogan
The one on the right, if that is real, boy, not only does he look like he lost weight, like his skin's developed elasticity that it didn't possess.
james lindsay
Yeah, maybe a little fake then.
joe rogan
It looks fake as fuck because...
james lindsay
I saw some other pictures, like body shots.
He looked like he lost some weight, like in his golf clothes or whatever.
joe rogan
Let me see this.
But this is, like, many months ago.
jamie vernon
Yeah, I just typed in Trump losing weight and wasn't getting a ton of recent, like, October 11th.
james lindsay
That's because he got banned from Twitter, so he doesn't sit on his phone all damn day.
jamie vernon
Yeah, it's about the guy who was, like, making money being an impersonator, lost 45 pounds after he stopped doing it.
unidentified
Oh, wow.
joe rogan
Okay.
So, M-E-A-www.com.
What is that?
It's just some weird way.
jamie vernon
Sure.
joe rogan
So let's go over images.
Trump losing weight.
james lindsay
This is going to be wild.
joe rogan
But you saw him at Mar-a-Lago.
Did he look thin?
james lindsay
How long ago was this?
It was beginning of December.
joe rogan
But there was a video of him talking just like a couple of days ago.
Where he was talking about Biden and making fun of Biden, he looked like exactly the same.
james lindsay
Maybe he's not losing weight.
joe rogan
Trump recent speech.
Just Google that.
Trump recent speech.
Because I looked at him, he looked exactly the same.
When I met him, he was not thin.
james lindsay
No.
He certainly wasn't.
joe rogan
That was quite a few months ago.
james lindsay
He was not thin when he was in office, by any means.
joe rogan
No, but I mean, when I saw him, again, that was quite a few months ago.
He came over, said hello, you do a tremendous job, you both do a tremendous, tremendous job.
Daniel Cormier, former UFC light heavyweight and heavyweight champion, he's like, I would not want to fight this man.
james lindsay
That's not looking thin.
joe rogan
That is not thin at all.
That was recently.
jamie vernon
Three days ago it said.
joe rogan
Three days ago.
james lindsay
He's got to do some jumping jacks.
That's not working.
joe rogan
That's fat.
So that photo was fake.
It was hilarious that he put all those blacks for Trump behind him with white shirts.
That is hilarious.
james lindsay
Fat is a new thing.
joe rogan
Come on.
Is that set up or was that set up?
I mean, this is wild shit, man.
james lindsay
You saw that picture that was going around the other day, right, with the fat woman and it's supposed to be like the new face of fitness or something?
joe rogan
Yes, I did.
james lindsay
That kills me.
I hate that.
Fat studies, body positivity.
joe rogan
Oh, my God.
It's so dumb.
It's so bad for people.
james lindsay
And in the middle of COVID where we know.
joe rogan
Yes.
james lindsay
Like it does something with your fat cells and makes you die or whatever.
Right.
It's one of the comorbidities.
It's like, come on.
joe rogan
It's one of the biggest comorbidities.
james lindsay
Yeah, seriously.
joe rogan
It's so strange that people are just accepting that.
james lindsay
But no, I didn't meet Trump yet, so it might be coming.
joe rogan
I got another one.
I got another image that's hilarious.
It's another one of those fat things where someone was saying that in order to dismantle fat phobia, we have to destroy Western civilization.
Right.
james lindsay
That's what I'm telling you, dude.
Same thing.
Call everything fatphobic that you want to control until you control it.
joe rogan
It's the same thing.
james lindsay
And the only remedy is to destroy the existing civilization.
And then you've got Klaus Schwab over here saying, yes, destroy it, and we're going to move in our new freaking reset system.
I'm telling you, that's what's going on.
joe rogan
I'll just send it to you, Jamie.
So do you think that this is – but here's my thing.
I'm always hesitant to believe that there's some sort of a grand plan because the government is so incompetent and so inept.
Look at this.
To end fatphobia, we need to dismantle Western civilization, says Philadelphia therapist.
james lindsay
No.
unidentified
What?
james lindsay
She's just wrong.
joe rogan
Well, she's just sad.
james lindsay
Remember that fake paper we wrote about fat bodybuilding?
joe rogan
Yes.
james lindsay
Yes.
joe rogan
Well, for folks that don't know, you with Helen Pluckrose and Peter Boghossian had written a bunch of these fake grievance papers.
james lindsay
Yeah, fake papers and grievance studies, fat studies, gender studies.
joe rogan
And these studies were, unfortunately, accepted, lauded, and praised, and you guys even won awards for these parody studies.
james lindsay
Yeah.
Seven of them were accepted.
One got an award for excellence.
That was about dog sex.
joe rogan
Please explain that one because that's my favorite one.
james lindsay
What's it called again?
Human Reactions to Queer Performativity and something else in urban dog parks in Portland, Oregon.
Rape culture.
Queer performativity and rape culture in urban dog parks in Portland, Oregon.
So we claim that we spend a thousand hours as one person, feminist, watching dogs hump each other and fight each other in dog parks.
joe rogan
A thousand hours is so long.
james lindsay
In a year.
It's like five hours a day.
And then across like a work week or whatever.
joe rogan
So they didn't even investigate that.
Wait a minute.
james lindsay
And we said never in the heavy rain, which in Portland, right?
It's like, come on.
joe rogan
That's not even possible then.
james lindsay
Yeah.
And then we said there were over 10,000 dogs that we interacted with, which is so many.
There's only like 20, 30 dogs that go to any given park probably.
It's just like the neighborhood park.
And we inspected their genitals, and then we would see how their owners reacted.
You know, in particular, did they praise, like, male-on-female dog rape while being upset about male-on-male dog rape?
And so the gay dog rape, if they were bothered by that, and we claimed that that's what they did.
joe rogan
And this won an award?
james lindsay
Yeah, this won an award for excellence in scholarship.
And we said that dog parks are canine rape culture.
They're petri dishes of canine rape culture, actually.
And they are rape-condoning spaces, just like nightclubs.
joe rogan
Here's the problem with, like, it's so hard.
People are so nuts right now.
It's hard to tell parody.
Jamie, pull up this article that I posted on my Instagram from the San Francisco Chronicle.
james lindsay
Oh, yeah.
I don't even know for sure if that one's parody or not.
joe rogan
I don't think it can be.
jamie vernon
I read people saying it was parody.
joe rogan
Is it parody?
james lindsay
Because it starts with a modest proposal or whatever.
Like, the state should own all of your children or whatever.
joe rogan
But isn't it in a newspaper?
jamie vernon
It's fine.
james lindsay
Yeah, you can do satire in a newspaper.
unidentified
That's okay.
joe rogan
That's so confusing.
But what I said is, like, in A World Gone Mad, it's...
james lindsay
Yeah, force parents to give away their children.
Yeah.
I think it starts with a modest proposal, blah, blah, blah, which means it would be satire.
joe rogan
I looked at it.
I was like, what is this?
So I said, the world got mad.
It's harder and harder to spot parity.
james lindsay
That's the thing.
joe rogan
Yeah.
That's why when I looked at this.
But this is the San Francisco Chronicle.
It says, opinion.
Want true equity?
California should force parents to give away their children.
Like, is that...
Okay, if that's clear parody, and it seems like it is to me, when I read that, I was like, okay, this is, what's crazy is that the world is so nuts, it's hard to spot parody.
james lindsay
Exactly.
Exactly.
And it's so hard.
I'll tell you, this is an update to the Grievance Studies papers, that fat bodybuilding I just brought up.
joe rogan
Yes.
james lindsay
There was a neuroscientist.
In fact, you remember that thing with, like, the, getting, like, the phobia of holes in things?
joe rogan
Yes.
james lindsay
The trypophobia, or whatever they called it.
Like, something that looks like a honeycomb, and you're like, uh, you know, something.
The guy, Jeff Cole is his name, the neuroscientist who identified that phobia, wrote a paper saying that there's nowhere that you could stand to say that fat bodybuilding is actually ridiculous.
I'm not kidding.
He was like, there's no ability to have genuine consensus about what's ridiculous and what's not ridiculous.
And I was like, what?
joe rogan
What the fuck does that mean?
That's opinion.
People can think your suit is ridiculous.
james lindsay
Anything goes.
joe rogan
Yeah.
james lindsay
Anything goes, right?
joe rogan
But there's no grounds to stand on.
We would say fat bodybuilding is ridiculous.
james lindsay
Yeah.
And this is a neuroscientist.
This isn't some, like, fat feminist that wants to justify being allowed to be fat and not have her feelings hurt.
So, like, yeah, dude.
It's like, you can't tell...
It's clown world.
It's, like, literally, like, satire and reality.
Look how many times a Babylon Bee has been, like, fact-checked or...
You know, they got fact-checked.
This is my favorite one to bring up.
They got fact-checked for saying that CNN buys giant washing machines so they can spin the news before they air it.
And they got fact-checked on that.
They did not actually buy washing machines.
Can you imagine how stupid you are being the straight man on that?
joe rogan
Are they fact-checked by AI? What are they fact-checked by?
james lindsay
They're fact-checked by millennials, probably.
joe rogan
Do you think so?
james lindsay
I don't know.
joe rogan
How could they be fact-checked for something that dumb?
Giant washing machines?
That's almost like, I'm wondering if this is farmed out to AI. I mean, it might be.
james lindsay
They've been fact-checked a number of times, though, on things that are very obviously fake.
joe rogan
You know, one of the things that I've read that gave me hope, and I don't know why I should have any hope, is that they said that CNN was going to switch their format to an objective news format, and they were going to get rid of all their opinion-based editorial staff, like Don LeLon, like those knuckleheads, that they were going to get rid of them.
james lindsay
You know, that would be, if it's genuine, a positive step.
joe rogan
Well, they have to know that they've destroyed their business.
james lindsay
They have no credibility left.
joe rogan
And they have to think that, you know, like, the thing about the 90% drop in their ratings last year, they want to say that it's because of scandals.
That's like what it, you know, Cuomo, and they don't help.
The two guys, again, two more people that got busted being pedophiles, right?
That were on their staff, which is fucking wild.
Producers.
james lindsay
Totally nuts.
unidentified
Right.
joe rogan
Producer for Jake Tapper, and there's a producer for who else was the other producer?
Was it Cuomo?
james lindsay
Yes, I think so.
Yeah, maybe.
joe rogan
I don't know.
james lindsay
I can't remember.
Two high-level producers, though.
joe rogan
Most people don't know that, though.
Most people aren't even aware of that because they never even covered it.
james lindsay
Right, it's that their programming sucks.
joe rogan
It's not just that it sucks, but it's preposterous.
james lindsay
Preposterous, yes.
joe rogan
Yeah, it's preposterous.
james lindsay
Solzhenitsyn says, you know, we know they're lying.
They know they're lying.
We know they know, you know, the whole thing.
joe rogan
It's also the smugness in which they disseminate propaganda.
People know that they're full of shit, and they're doing it with a smugness, and it turns people off.
james lindsay
It turns them way off.
joe rogan
It would turn people off even if they were accurate.
james lindsay
Yeah.
Yeah, that attitude sucks.
joe rogan
It sucks.
james lindsay
It's like I remember when I was a kid, like my mom being like, you know, what you're saying might be right, but your attitude sucks or whatever, you know, if I smarten off.
joe rogan
It's also an extreme lack of understanding of human nature.
The way they discuss things, like one of the things they were talking about, shaming people.
Like whether or not we should start shaming people for not following the public health guidelines that have changed over and over again and have been proven over and over again to be wrong.
Like what are you fucking saying?
You're on the news and you're talking about shaming people?
james lindsay
Shaming people, yeah.
This is what I'm telling you, dude.
This is why...
I actually am hopeful.
I am cautiously optimistic.
It's not going to fix itself.
joe rogan
But because of the drop-off of their...
james lindsay
Well, not specifically the drop-off.
It's that they are so arrogant that they think they can just get away with anything.
And what that causes is people to see through it.
joe rogan
Yeah.
james lindsay
And when enough people see through it, I mean, their ratings are going to drop 90%, and then other forces are going to come into play, or protests are going to start coming up, or whatever else.
joe rogan
And One of my favorite ones was when Brian Stelter was talking about what a shame it was that there were programs on YouTube that get more ratings than CNN in prime time.
And I remember thinking, do you think you guys, that people owe you ratings?
Do you think you deserve ratings?
james lindsay
They're so arrogant.
joe rogan
What do you think ratings are coming from?
This concept that CNN is a respectable news source, like, bro, this is 2022 or 2021 when that was happening.
This is not 2005. That ship has sailed, kid.
james lindsay
You don't know that?
That entitlement.
I'm cautiously optimistic because I think they're just going to keep making mistakes.
joe rogan
But it's so wild that that's the big one.
You know, like, that's the one controversial, like, CNN used to be rock-fucking-solid.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
That used to be the place that I would go for everything.
james lindsay
Yeah, of course.
joe rogan
I would go to CNN.com, like, first thing in the morning, see what's happening in the world.
Now I look at them like, what kind of spin are they putting on this?
james lindsay
Yeah, what nonsense is this going to be?
joe rogan
How little have you investigated into this story to spread it this way?
james lindsay
Right, yeah.
How is this racism, or racism is a public health threat now, or whatever else it is?
jamie vernon
There's a little spin on this story, too.
joe rogan
Yeah?
jamie vernon
It's 90% down from where it was from this week last year, which was the week that the riots happened, which would have been everyone fucking watching the news.
james lindsay
Oh, sure.
joe rogan
That's a spin.
james lindsay
That's a little dodgy.
jamie vernon
I went back to 2019 when they were going up, and they were getting just over a million viewers a day-ish.
joe rogan
At the best.
That was before the elections.
The Trump thing, for sure, they lost 50% because that was like an objective analysis of all of their ratings and they were talking about across the board.
That's a giant number, man.
james lindsay
That's a lot of people.
joe rogan
Because that means you're dependent upon conflict.
So that sets up what you're doing, that you have to find some outrage.
james lindsay
And that's the other thing.
People get outrage fatigue.
No one wants to listen to that crap all the time.
Like, people just want some normal life, man.
joe rogan
Also, you can't force outrage.
james lindsay
Nope.
joe rogan
Like, when it's not really that outrageous...
james lindsay
Like J6. Yeah.
Like, we have to be all really mad about this thing a year later, and they polled a bunch of Democrats, and they were like, eh, it's not really on my list of concerns.
joe rogan
My favorite is when they ask Kamala Harris questions.
And then she gives, like, a kid in seventh grade essay, like, when they're trying to fill the 150 words that you have to use, or whatever the fuck it is.
It is crazy to hear her talk about it when she was talking about Pearl Harbor, and she was talking, what were the other- Pearl Harbor, Civil War, and then 9-11.
james lindsay
Yeah.
joe rogan
Pearl Harbor, Civil War, 9-11.
And then January 6th.
james lindsay
January 6th.
joe rogan
Where, you know, a bunch of fucking morons- Went to the Capitol and probably were instigated by the feds to do so.
james lindsay
Right, and what did Norm MacDonald say about it?
He said how great it was that they respected the velvet ropes in Statuary Hall.
God, what a genius.
joe rogan
Oh, I miss him.
james lindsay
Oh, man.
joe rogan
Well, listen, man, let's wrap this up.
Let's bring it home.
There's no happy ending to this show, folks.
We're in a weird time.
I guess the happy ending is what you're saying, that people are kind of aware.
james lindsay
Yeah.
No, I think there is a happy ending.
I think we're going through a bumpy time, but man, are they stupid.
And it's like they can't understand why people don't like them, and that's always a good sign that they're probably not going to win.
joe rogan
Well, it's also they really hate independents, like independent media that's successful.
Yeah.
And they want to demonize independent media also that's bipartisan or that is least objective and is willing to talk to people on all sides.
And they want to regain control, but they want to do it through the old methods, and that's not going to work in this day and age.
james lindsay
That's right.
That's right.
So this is what I'm saying.
I think we're going through – we talked about the Enlightenment.
I think we're going through the second Enlightenment.
I think we're – I talked earlier about like an aristocracy of ideas and the media figureheads and the professors and the experts get to decide what is and isn't true for people.
I think the internet is allowing people to do their own research as it were and is burning that down.
And we're going to have a real marketplace of ideas and we're going to have more freedom if we don't let them – I think they're like – they see their freedom slipping away and they're like grasping for it.
And their power, I should say, is slipping away and they're grasping for it.
And I think for a while, I wasn't sure, but I'm pretty confident now, like, we're going to get through this and we're going to have a more free, smarter society on the other side.
It's not to say it's going to be smooth for the next little while.
And it's not to say that we can go to sleep and it'll just work itself out.
joe rogan
How much time do you think we got before that works itself out?
james lindsay
10, 15 years with the working out.
But for the...
joe rogan
Bro, basically you'd be dead by then.
james lindsay
Well, I mean...
joe rogan
The fuck, man?
15 years.
james lindsay
In 15 years, it'll be like 70. How long will it be before we can get back to some semblance of normal life, though?
joe rogan
Right.
james lindsay
Like, that literally could be this year.
joe rogan
You think so?
james lindsay
I mean, I'm not...
joe rogan
I don't think it will be, but it could be.
Do you think they will follow England when they're having this, you know, completely dropping all of their COVID mandates?
james lindsay
You know, I think we're going to have to.
I think everywhere...
I think the COVID narrative has fallen apart, and it just looks like heavy-handed government and authority abusing power to keep trying to voice this crap on people.
joe rogan
They've kind of hid information, though.
Like, one of the things they're doing now is they're hiding the death count now because it's so low with Omicron.
james lindsay
But the fact that we know that is...
Proof that that information is getting out, and it's going to keep getting out.
These alternative sources that they don't want you listening to, that CNN thinks they should be getting the ratings instead, this is escaping their grasp.
And if people actually stand up and say, no, we're not going to do this, well, it's going to have to happen, though.
If you want the positive path, it doesn't really matter too much if it's Republican or Democrat, but you're going to have more space on the Republican side of the aisle.
The place where America is going to be put to the political test is going to be in the primaries this year because they're going to try to run a bunch of establishment stooges because they now know the Democrats have no prospects.
So they're going to try to run a bunch of establishment stooges in the Republican people to kind of just keep the pot on simmer.
We have to fix the schools, though, because the schools are their next best hope.
If they can screw up the kids, then they're going to be able to just try again in a few years and throw another cultural bomb in wherever.
joe rogan
As more people become 18 years old, their pool of talent grows larger.
james lindsay
Exactly.
And so if we're willing to do everything in our power to rescue the schools and to avoid going into this kind of like digital passport mentality, Then we can throw off their plans.
And I think what's going to happen, I think what they're reaching for so desperately, so many of these people are being exposed as either frauds or maybe even criminals.
And they don't want that to happen because they're going to lose all their power and maybe go to jail.
And so they're trying to like clamp down and make sure you can't listen to different voices that might call them criminals.
Rightfully those things.
They don't want to hear people like Dr. Malone come on here and say a bunch of stuff about COVID that makes them look like a bunch of either incompetent people or assholes or criminals.
And so they've got to try it.
But they can't put the cork back in the bottle.
There's too many holes or whatever.
It's a bad metaphor, but it's a broken bottle, I guess.
joe rogan
I hope you're right.
james lindsay
You know, you asked me last time I came on here if I was optimistic, and I said, well, I have to be because I have no use for pessimism.
I'm actually optimistic now.
It's cautious, but I'm genuinely optimistic.
But we all have to be willing.
This is the most important thing.
We have to be willing to stand up, and we have to be willing to speak up.
We have to be willing to say, no, we're going to put people in office who are going to start safeguarding our freedom from big tech, safeguarding our freedom from these stupid medical tyranny attempts.
We're not going to go down frickin climate change passports next, guys.
Like we're just not – you're not going to – we need to put in safeguards for people like at the Bill of Rights level that you can't take people out of society based on these stupid things.
Whether it's big tech squeezing people out, whether it's out of the space to speak or whether it's this medical apartheid or whatever they're doing.
If we can put those – if we can get the right people and get enough momentum behind it and get those people to say these things, to start figuring out the legalities of these things to protect citizens again, we can actually get out of this.
joe rogan
I hope you're right.
James Lindsay, thank you very much.
Appreciate you.
Conceptual James, follow him on Twitter.
It's an awesome follow.
You tweet all day long.
You got a real problem with that.
james lindsay
I do.
joe rogan
Wake up.
Stop doing that.
unidentified
Go outside.
All right.
james lindsay
Touch grass.
joe rogan
Love you guys.
Export Selection