All Episodes
Previous Next
Oct. 17, 2024 - Judging Freedom - Judge Andrew Napolitano
28:53
Matt Hoh : How to Stop the Slaughter
| Copy link to current segment

Time Text
Hi, everyone.
Judge Andrew Napolitano here for Judging Freedom.
Today is Thursday, October 17th, 2024.
Matt Ho joins us now.
Matt, a pleasure, my dear friend.
Thank you for accommodating all the schedule changes that visit both of us and for joining us today.
I want to start where I was going to end this conversation, and that is who or what will stop Unfortunately, Judge, I don't have an answer for you.
I don't think anything will.
I don't see it occurring without some type of cataclysmic ex-Makina type event.
Extraordinary that we can't foresee or expect.
I see there's nothing within the Israeli side that will lead them to stop.
This is what they want.
This is the opportunity.
Naftali Bennett said it so well two weeks ago now.
This is a once-in-a-50-year opportunity what we have.
the ethnic cleansing of Gaza, the potential to annex the West Bank or in East Jerusalem or Judea and Samaria, as they call it, to push into Lebanon to get the war with Iran alongside the United States we've always wanted.
So I just don't see a way this ends until the...
The only hope that there was was that there would have been some type of political pressure on the White House and the Biden-Harris campaign to reel them in, just as we saw American administrations reel in the Israelis in the 50s, in the 60s, in the 70s, in the 80s, the 90s.
Even under Barack Obama, he reeled them in.
And it just doesn't work that way anymore.
So I am heartbroken and infuriated, but I see nothing but more suffering for the Palestinians until the Israelis have reached what they want until they've satisfied themselves.
Well, you certainly, I think, don't let me put words in your mouth, agree with McGregor and Ritter.
That Netanyahu may grossly overreach and be visited with a fusillade that he can't resist.
From Iran.
From Iran.
Certainly.
Certainly, Judge.
But that doesn't help the Palestinians.
The Palestinians suffer no matter what happens.
Even if the best case for the Palestinians, there is elections early in 2025 for the Israeli Knesset.
Which doesn't look like that's going to happen.
Looks like that's going to be in October maybe of next year.
So another year until elections and Netanyahu loses, which according to polls right now, he's not going to.
He's going to remain in power.
And then you get what?
You get some of the air, Lapid, Benny Gantz, who just basically reset the clock back for the Palestinians back to October 6th with all of the death, destruction, suffering of Gaza still present.
What do we know?
Today about the relationship between the Kremlin and Tehran.
Oh, it's something that would make many historians, many Ford affairs experts, statespeople of the last two or three centuries spin in their grave if they knew there was this type of alliance between Moscow and Tehran.
We have done seemingly the impossible.
By putting these two historic rivals together.
And what we've seen is we're seeing something very formal.
Not just, hey, we're going to sell you some weapons, we're going to exchange some advisors, No, but they're looking at if it's forming into an actual military alliance.
And there is a defense pact that is in the midst of being signed, I believe, between Russia and Iran.
Iran, interestingly, also, Judge, about a week or two ago, pushed forward this proposal to formalize the axis of resistance into something that essentially looks like NATO.
I mean, so you're continuing to have.
And this is the countering of the American empire.
That has long been expected being made concrete in front of us.
Well, you know, the two questions are combined.
who or what can stop the Israelis and what is the relationship between Iran and Russia.
At some point, if Netanyahu thinks he's losing, he's going to have to No?
No.
I think that that is just calling on the United States for more.
That is the understanding in Israel that the United States will always be there, that the control of the American political system
that they will be the West Sparta, if you will.
They will be Thermopylae, if people remember the 300.
This is how people like to stylize it.
This is how they like to think of it.
This has also, too, been formed for decades now, this narrative, this understanding of the world, this clash of civilizations.
So certainly I think what the understanding in Israel is, is that the United States will be here and they will hook up a hose from the treasury of the United States to Israel to keep us afloat.
To get back to this idea about the Palestinians, say it gets so bad in Israel, as many of us have been talking about, that it descends into civil war.
They're basically going through a collapse.
Even in that state, I see that the punishment that gets meted out onto the Palestinians becomes even harder.
In a clash between the Israelis themselves, the Palestinians will still suffer.
They will be made examples of.
They will be victimized in order to try and achieve some type of internal Israeli political goals.
So, I mean, it's heartbreaking and it's infuriating.
I don't know what else to say, Judge, but for the Palestinians, I simply see no hope.
And I hate saying that.
What do you think President Putin will do?
Tehran, he's not going to sit back and do nothing, is he?
No, I think what he will do is provide continued support to the Iranians, like we've seen, more support, more missiles, more electronic warfare systems, more visors, that type of thing.
But also, too, he will have a check or a hedge in Syria because that's where his air force is, that's where his spetsnats are, his special operations, that's where the Wagner forces are to serve as a warning or as a hedge to Israel and the U.S. that this will lead into a major power conflict, this will lead into a world war, as well as, too, you possibly will see, and they've warned of this before, the Russians actually...
So you'll see that as well, the arming of groups allied with Iran by Russia.
And then you will see this continual building out of military, diplomatic, economic infrastructure, this new world order, if you will, a newer world order.
So I think what the Russians want is, of course, the Russians want to see the U.S. further sucked into the Middle East, because that pulls their attention, that pulls their ability to do anything with regards to Europe that diminishes that.
But then also, too, the Russians have a desire to see a long-term building.
This would be a neocon dream come true.
If Iran versus Israel were to be a proxy for Russia versus the United States, at the same time, Ukraine is a proxy.
For the United States to, it's failing terribly, but the neocons don't acknowledge that publicly, for battering Russia.
This would make Lindsey Graham and Josh Hawley and Tom Cotton and Victoria Nuland and John Boland ecstatic, no matter who's the president of the United States.
That's correct.
We've seen this already.
They tried to do this with Afghanistan.
If you go back about five, six years, as the Trump administration was making gestures towards getting out of Afghanistan, it became all about Russia and the Taliban bounties to kill American soldiers.
But it was all this attempt to try and tie Russia into a war where American soldiers were dying, not even in that many numbers at that point, but just to try and make sure that we're always keeping our eye on the true villain, on the true man in the black hat, right?
And because that's essentially what we need as a narrative, as an empire, is we have to have something as an opposite.
It has to be Manichaean.
It has to be good versus evil.
Very much like our political system here.
So if people are confused about when people talk about how domestic or foreign policy is rooted in domestic politics, you can see just in the structure, the format, that there can't be anything other than zero-sum.
There can't be a multipolar world.
There can only be, at best, bipolar.
Or, you know, hopefully unipolar.
But yeah, you're exactly right, Judge.
The fever dream of linking us all together, and you see that, and you see that even in Volodymyr Zelensky's most recent statements, as he's trying to play this, as he's trying to use this to his advantage, saying that there's this alliance between Russia, Iran, and North Korea.
And this is why you have to continue us, because we're doing our part.
I want to ask you about North Korea, but I have one or two more questions on Israel.
Where is the EU?
Where is NATO?
Where are the various individual nations of the EU and NATO on the Israeli slaughter, particularly in light of the Israeli attack on UNIFIL, which brought outrage from the Irish, the French, Right, right.
First of all, I just want to say, God bless the soldiers of Unifil.
They are absolutely outstanding in their professionalism.
They are neither yielding to the business So they're refusing to cede their ground to the Israelis, and at the same time they're not falling into the Israeli trap of shooting back, which would allow the Israelis to drop 2,000-pound bombs on them.
You're seeing these cracks within the EU, and these have been present throughout the most of the year, particularly led by, say, the Irish and the Spanish.
My grandparents came from both those places.
So I also have a grandparent from Germany.
I'm not so happy about that heritage right now.
But certainly with the Irish and the Spanish of my ancestry, I'm very proud.
Matthew, you cannot control your heritage.
You can pick your friends, but you can't pick your relatives.
Go ahead.
So I'm very, you know, my Spanish grandparents, my Irish grandmother, you know, I think they'd be very proud, too, of what their countries are doing in terms of leading this effort to Basically, align with the EU's stated values, the EU's stated purposes and their missions and their charter.
So the Irish and the Spanish this past week have put forward a proposal to kick Israel out of the free trade agreement with the European Union because Israel does not align with the European Union's own rules.
So you're seeing this, and particularly what the French said, what Macron said this past week, I don't think he's going to do anything about it, but the fact that he's willing to.
And this is a big difference, right, from what we've seen in the past year where they have been much more mealy-mouthed.
So you're starting to see these cracks within the EU.
Certainly those cracks are further exploited by things like Ukraine or by the fact that, you know, you mentioned China, that the United States and parts of Europe want this war on China.
NATO, this is I think we will see a big.
He wants to make war with China a NATO mission.
And the EU is looking at this and saying, that's our biggest trading partner.
Are you nuts?
So you're seeing these schisms develop not because of internal tensions.
And there certainly are those in Europe.
Don't get me wrong, but not because of those internal tensions, but because of these foreign wars that the European countries have gone along with being loyal vassals of the American empire.
And then, Chris, please post the full screen of what he said, not in front of the camera.
So cut number three.
It is totally unacceptable for UNIFIL troops to be deliberately targeted by Israeli-armed forces.
We condemn it.
We do not and will not tolerate it happening again.
Now, here's what he said, but not in front of a microphone or a camera.
Mr. Netanyahu must not forget that his country was created by a decision of the UN.
Therefore, this is not the time to disregard the decisions of the UN.
Matt?
Right.
And it'd be wonderful if he puts the French military behind his words.
The French have the capability to put fighter aircraft off of their aircraft carrier as well as within the region in the skies over Lebanon.
They have that ability to create a no-fly zone.
It would be amazing to see that happen.
We won't see that happen, but could you imagine what's happening And so you have the Germans, and that warship is a part of the UNIFIL mission, supposedly.
So you have a German warship off the coast of Lebanon shooting down Hezbollah drones, but making no action to do anything to protect either the UNIFIL peacekeepers or the Lebanese civilians.
And unfortunately, I think that's what you'll see more of, is you'll see these words, which are important because, like I said, it's different than what we heard months ago.
But what we're really seeing, though, is the continued actions of states like Germany, the United Kingdom, and the United States that are the only reason, the sole reason, that Israel is able to conduct these wars, these atrocities, these crimes.
Take a listen to a Chinese military commander who is apparently the commander of the 400 or so Chinese soldiers that are there.
At present, the conflict between Lebanon and Israel is intermittently escalating.
Due to the ongoing combat, several camps of the United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon have suffered damage.
Additionally, a portion of our peacekeeping comrades have been injured.
We continue to make every effort to maintain peace and stability in the region.
Did you know that the Chinese troops were there on the ground?
No, no, I had no idea the Chinese were there.
I didn't either, because Chris found this.
Makes you wonder.
I also had no idea, according to that video, the Chinese designate their units in their military as batches.
The 22nd batch.
I didn't know that either.
I won't ask producer Chris where he found the translation.
But anyway, regardless of that, the fact that they have 400 there, not 40 or 4, but 400.
I mean, in military terms, that's an Italian minus, basically.
I was not aware of that, but it shows a Chinese presence there.
And this takes it one step forward then for the Chinese in terms of not, I don't think, what they would do immediately.
Because I don't think the Chinese are going to sail their one aircraft carrier over to the Mediterranean and do anything if the Chinese peacekeepers are hurt or killed.
What I do think it means is it tells the Chinese, we have to be more aggressive.
We have to lead much more forward in our deployments, in our role in the world.
We have to be able to project power to protect our own people overseas.
And so I think there's, you know, a lot of times as we look at the short term, And I think something like this, where the Chinese have 400 of their kids, 400 of their boys, in Lebanon on a peacekeeping mission, and here's Israel threatening them, potentially killing them.
The United States is backing them.
What are you going to do about it?
And this just tells the Chinese, we need to do something about this in the future, or at least be able to do something about this in the future.
This gets back to what we've said before.
We talked about Turkey, say.
Why wouldn't the Turks get a nuclear weapon now?
Looking at everything that's happening, why wouldn't they?
Because that's the one thing that Israel is allowed to run rush rod over those countries with.
That's the big stick they have is that, hey, Turkey, you want to get involved in Lebanon or anywhere else?
Well, we'll bomb Ankara.
So they can balance that out.
And so you're seeing this, both those two things dovetail with both potential nuclear proliferation as well as a greater presence getting back to what you asked before, Judge.
About Russia and Iran, a greater presence of other powers within the region, as well as a formalizing of relationships that leads to real structures that can really effectively counter the American empire going forward.
And it's not talking about 20 years from now, we're talking 5 or 10 years from now, the very real possibility of a strong counter to the American empire, not just in the Middle East, but throughout the world.
As if things couldn't get any crazier.
Now I'm transitioning to Ukraine, but I'm going to read what Newsweek reported about 9 o 'clock this morning Eastern, so about two hours ago.
Some 18 North Korean soldiers are believed to have deserted the Russian front line with Kremlin fighters reportedly searching for them.
You can't make this stuff up.
It's true.
The troops were deployed in Russia's Kursk and Bryansk oblasts about four miles from the border with Ukraine when they deserted, the public broadcasting company of Ukraine reported.
Intelligence officials cited by the broadcaster said the Russian military is searching for the North Korean soldiers while commanders are trying to conceal the desertion.
First of all, are North Korean soldiers present in Russia?
Second, does Putin need more soldiers from a foreign country?
Third, is this credible?
I mean, I don't know if it's credible or not.
I mean, there's all types of things that have been stated by both sides.
You know, a year ago, Judge, before October 7th, we had a show, you and I, where we talked about the Ukraine-Russia wars being the most propagandized war of all time.
Yes.
You just really can't believe anything you hear from anyone on either side, I feel.
You know, in terms of what does Putin need?
No, he doesn't need forces from outside his country.
But then other things, too, that, you know, you start talking about integrating your militaries.
That's very difficult, particularly in this day and age with the nature of communications, the nature of technology, the requirements for things to be done very quickly.
And not to have trained together before to be fully integrated is a really difficult thing.
So I can't imagine the Russians wanting to have Korean forces, North Korean forces alongside their forces in active combat.
And again, they don't need it.
They seem manpower wise.
They seem to be fine.
But this seems pretty far-fetched, and this plays into Zelensky's You know, alarm over the last couple weeks about the Koreans.
This is just too timely.
Could be true.
I mean, you know, the North Koreans, who knows why they would have been sent there, what they would have been told.
They found themselves there.
And, you know, they're out looking for a McDonald's or something like that.
You know, I mean, I don't know.
I don't know whether to believe it or not.
But it's just the timing of it goes very congruently with Zelensky's increasingly desperate.
Cries for help.
He just released his five-point peace plan, which is just more of the same.
But this tying of Russia into this evil axis of Iran and North Korea, now, of course, there's Korean soldiers there.
Yeah, it's all just too perfect, it seems to me.
Okay.
I'm going to go back.
ask your forgiveness for going back and forth.
We're going to go back to Europe and its reaction to Israeli slaughter because we now have a tape of a Spanish member of parliament ripping, ripping into the prime minister of Spain for failing to impose an arms and trading
How does this differ from Nazi gas chambers?
I address you all, ladies and gentlemen, including the president, no difference.
As a nation, we are complicit in perpetrating this genocide.
You travel globally discussing an arms embargo that your government cannot enforce.
Your government has been selling arms since after October 7th.
It has bought 1 billion euro worth of weapons.
One billion euros, ladies and gentlemen, during this year of genocide have allowed weapons to be transported through from our ports throughout this year.
If you truly support the arms embargo, Mr. Sanchez, cease to seat and enact it immediately.
Can we expect more of that from European parliamentarians?
I would hope so.
I think so.
I think you're having more and more galvanizing.
It's been a year, but we're continuing to be galvanized or continue to be horrified by the images, the video, the spectacle that is coming out of Gaza, as well as just, you know, as you take the geopolitical dangers of all this, but just the moral horror.
This picture of that young man who was burned alive in the hospital where he was a patient at is becoming, I've heard this said a number of times now.
It's becoming similar to the photo out of Vietnam of the young girl who had been burned with napalm.
It is becoming a rallying type or iconic, and that may push.
More nations, or at least their parliamentarians, to do things that their executives are against.
So I think maybe you possibly see a movement within a parliament like Spain's or of Ireland to do something independent of the EU.
And I mean, this is how these things happen, Judge.
It all takes time.
One nation has to lead, another start to follow.
Things will occur.
The International Court of Justice will eventually find Israel guilty of genocide.
I'm not so confident of that.
Will the International Crime Report ever issue arrest warrants for Benjamin Netanyahu and Yoav Gallant?
I don't know.
I'm not so confident of that because they're more susceptible to pressure from the Americans than the ICJ is.
But these things happen in time and they happen step by step.
And whatever we can do to support people like that.
efforts.
And I think the way you look at this is you look at this in the sense of the collapse of the South African regime in the 1980s and how that began decades before.
The pressure on South Africa lasts for decades, and it's a slow, gradual rolling process.
And even when most of the world was sanctioning and blockading South Africa, the Americans stood with South Africa for years.
For years, we stood with South Africa.
And I think that will be the example that we can look to.
We don't want to misuse history, right?
But certainly, I think that's the example we look to as the I want to go back to what I said before about Israel and the Palestinians.
My comments are really geared next one, two, three years.
But long term, certainly I agree with everyone else that this is untenable for Israel.
But I think they've got 10 or 15 years of American support behind them, at least.
Matt Ho, thank you very much, my dear friend.
Great analysis on both Ukraine and Israel.
We'll look forward to seeing you again next week.
All the best.
Thanks, Judge.
Of course.
Coming up later today, 1 o 'clock this afternoon, Colonel Lawrence Wilkerson.
At 3 o 'clock this afternoon, Professor John Mearsheimer.
At 4 o 'clock this afternoon, Aaron Maté.
And at 5.30 this evening from midnight in Moscow, Pepe Escobar.
▲
Export Selection