Neil deGrasse Tyson faces sharp criticism for conflating astronomy with gender ideology, specifically mocking his subway experiment where he identified sex via superficial traits like eyeliner and makeup rather than biology. The host ridicules Tyson's claim that chromosomes are insufficient, arguing that surgeries like genital removal do not alter biological reality and that gender is synonymous with sex. Ultimately, the segment asserts that societal distinctions regarding men and women stem from competition, rejecting the concept of gender as a spectrum separate from physical characteristics. [Automatically generated summary]
Transcriber: nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v2, sat-12l-sm, and large-v3-turbo
|
Time
Text
The Planet Watcher00:01:59
Yeah, I got a new show for y'all.
We got a damn good show.
Neil deGrasse Tyson.
He's a scientist and astrophysicist.
He studies planets and stars and it's a lot more than that.
No, that's not what he do.
He's a planet watcher.
Well, I'm sure.
What else he do?
Look at black holes?
That's it.
He's not an astronaut.
He's got his telescope at home and he looks at shit.
That's what he does.
Well, we need to do some research on it, but he's an astrophysicist.
I always thought when somebody's a physicist.
Glorified Star Watcher.
Well, he's a physicist, so he's got a...
Well, what has he accomplished?
He did anything?
I don't know.
I haven't followed him that time.
Oh, man.
Y'all giving this man too much credit.
But anyway, this astrophysicist, he starts talking about gender.
Once you stick to planets and stars and finding black holes and stuff.
Why are you talking about gender?
You should already know what gender is if you've studied planets and stars.
Yeah.
You still, wait a minute, you an expert in astronomy, but you haven't figured out what a male and female is?
He has figured it out.
Oh, he figured out for everybody, huh?
Yeah, he's explaining it to everybody.
Earth is got, he's a genius, right?
I guess so.
He's an astrophysicist.
You got to be smart to be an astrophysicist.
Maybe he, maybe, but you know, in this time, this day and age, he's black, right?
So probably gave him a couple points.
They just gone throw him in now.
Yeah, gon' throw him any black.
He's one of them.
Give him about 15 points.
Yeah, go ahead.
We got a.
It's all about inclusivity.
It's all about equity.
Not equality.
Equity.
Equity actually inhibits equality.
Yeah.
Equity inhibits equality.
But anyway, check out this video.
Gender Identity Experiments00:09:32
I did this experiment.
I was in the New York City subway.
It was in the winter.
Everyone has a he did him an experiment.
On the subway.
Everybody, the scientist did an experiment on the subway.
Well, you can have experiments where.
Man, any experiment you do in the subway ain't about shit.
But he's a scientist.
I'd go on the subway and do an experiment.
Anybody can do that.
Yeah, yeah.
I guess he's doing, well, well, just go to the video.
All right.
I was in the New York City subway.
It was in the winter.
Everyone has a big coat on.
And so I'm just looking at heads sticking out of the winter coats.
And I said, why do I know who's male and who's female?
As I go down the line.
This is just a simple question I ask myself.
And I say, well, these six people are female.
Those four are male.
Why do I, why am I sure of that?
I was sure of it because what I was cueing on were features that are secondary and tertiarily added to a person's appearance.
Tertiarily.
So all the girls compared to the boys, I looked at all.
What are the girls doing?
They have, on average, longer earrings.
They have two earrings.
They have, on average, longer hair.
They have eyeliner.
They have tweezed eyebrows.
Longer nails on average.
Painted nails.
They have makeup, a blush.
Okay?
And if there was any hair on their upper lip, that got removed.
Any hair between the eyebrows?
Removed.
Okay, Paul.
If it's all trimmed there.
All I look at is hips, chest.
That camel toe between their legs.
Yeah.
You talk about all this superficial stuff.
Of course, different.
I mean, those are just hallmarks.
It's superficial characteristics of what women wear and what men wear.
See, because of men like you, a man thinks he can put on a dress and he's a woman now.
Yeah, he ain't got.
He ain't got.
They trying to say that your body parts.
What he's trying to insinuate he's, he's making implications that your body parts.
He said tertiality.
What the hell does that mean?
I never heard tertiality.
What is that?
Some kind of astronomy word?
I don't know.
He gives that a disease.
That's.
Nobody's using that word.
You know what I know about smart people.
They use words nobody's ever heard of to make them look smart and most people like man this dude's smart.
Tertiality what the hell's that He's trying to make?
He's insinuating that what makes a woman and a man is is what they wear.
That's what he was saying.
Yeah, how they make up.
But if that was the case, why you got people, if that's the case, if you're clothes and your hallmarks and superficial things make you a man or woman, why is people chopping cocks off?
Yeah, we chopping healthy cocks off the human body.
Cocks, nuts.
Well, they suggest also that your sexual organs doesn't determine your gender.
But if that's the case, why are you chopping them off?
I just said that.
I cleaned it up for you.
No, well, you got to replicate it, man.
I already said it.
Mine was better.
Let's keep rolling.
Man.
Those are the girls.
What are they wearing?
They're wearing girls' clothes.
Well, how do I know they're girls' clothes?
Just go to the store.
They know how to sell you girls' clothes.
There's a whole section for just girls and women, okay?
I'm just saying girls and boys.
How about the boys?
Oh, the boys.
If there's anyone who is a little thin and flabby, they went to the gym.
So they walked, they sitting down and they got some muscles.
I could tell a girl if she's wearing boy clothes.
These transgenders out here that went from girl to boy, I'm like, something's off here.
Oh, you wanted them with a girl dressed up like a guy?
You can't hide that boot in them hips.
Yeah.
You could grow that beard up, but you walk around still got them big old hips.
Like childbirth hips.
I still can see, you still got a nice booty, man.
Yeah, like when you see a dude go to a woman.
Yeah, you look at that Adam's app on his throat.
I mean, you just, they just got this present-like hard face.
That face looks hard.
That face hard as hell.
They got a washboard face.
Yeah, that damn face is chiseled out of stone.
This is an experiment.
Yeah.
Looking at people's looking at superficial things.
Stereotypical things.
Yeah, I call this an observation.
I wouldn't call it.
You a scientist?
Really?
Yeah.
Kids, I mean, man, that's not even an experiment.
That's just a walk in daily life.
Let's keep going.
There's some more of this.
Yeah.
And they've got, yeah.
And they might grow a beard and a mustache because that's a manly thing to do.
Wow.
And they're wearing boy clothes because they went to the boy section of the store to get it.
And if the women's chest is not as large as she wants it, she goes and gets surgery to make it bigger as 300,000 American women do every year.
I know several.
You're right.
Okay, so my point is, apparently, the XXXY chromosomes are insufficient.
Oh, because when we wake up in the morning, we exaggerate whatever feature we want to portray the gender of our choice.
You don't choose gender.
Either the one you're assigned, the one you choose to be.
Whatever.
Stephen A. Smith, and he's actually entertaining.
There's no backlash.
There's no pushback or anything.
You know what he's doing?
You have gender and sex.
Gender and sex has always been synonymous.
Now this new thing is gender identity.
He's conflating gender identity with actual gender, which is synonymous with sex.
Yeah.
And this is a scientist, astrophysicist, they call him.
This dude throws out science, the X, Y, the chromosome, he just throws that out.
That's meaningless.
Yeah, you're not a biologist, you astrophysicist.
I don't think you qualified to talk about these subjects.
I don't think you, actually, I don't even think you qualify to be an astrophysicist.
If you're this damn stupid on something people have learned by the time they went to preschool, you know what?
Four-year-olds, four-year-olds know the difference between a man and a woman.
He's an astrophysicist and don't know that.
There's some more to this.
Two progressive clowns.
Stephen A.
I think Stephen A.
No, I wouldn't say he's progressive.
He's probably liberal.
No, liberal's dead.
Yeah, but he's that part has been hijacked by progressives.
Well, he's got to be progressive.
He's entertaining this nonsense with no pool.
Yeah, he's definitely progressive.
There's no such thing as a modern liberal anymore.
Liberals and conservatives is like this.
They're like that.
Progressives, they're batshit crazy.
All right, let's keep going.
And so now, here, so now just to tie a bow on this, I say to you, somewhere I read, somewhere, I think I read that the United States was a land where we have the pursuit of happiness.
Suppose no matter my chromosomes, today I feel 80% female, 20% male.
I'm going to put on makeup.
I'm going to do this.
Tomorrow I might feel 80% male.
I'll remove the makeup and I'll wear a muscle shirt.
Why do you care?
Same reason why.
What business is it of yours to require that I fulfill your inability to think of gender on a spectrum?
Oh, it's my inability.
Oh, it's our inability.
Why do we care?
Because we got to participate in your nonsense.
You got men competing against females.
You got men taking positions away from women.
That's why we care.
Hey, Kevin, you hear that condescending, patronizing tone?
Yeah, like you better.
You require to undertake follow me with this.
I know you're slow.
Why do you care?
There's a pursuit of happiness.
Okay, of course.
Well, you care so much.
Yeah.
But that's not the argument.
Nobody's saying they can't do what they're doing.
What we're saying is you could be dressed like a woman, but you're still a man.
Yeah.
You can dress like a man and if you want, if you're a woman, you still a woman.
It doesn't change anything.
Yeah.
Yeah, you're lying to people.
That's why we care.
For the whole, man, since the beginning of time, when you look at a bathroom, it has the, you know, the pictures on it, man, woman.
Yeah.
There's no been, never been a time where you looked at a picture, seen a dress, and it's like, okay, if I wear a dress, I can go on there.
Yeah, who does that?
I'll tell you who.
People that are nuts.
Okay, this room right here, when I go to the bathroom, if I'm wearing a dress, I can use this one.
If I'm wearing a pair of pants, I can use this one.
Gender is not a spectrum.
Gender identity is, but you're conflating gender identity with gender.
And gender and sex are synonymous.
They've always been.
Yeah, suck it up, Buttercup.
Burning hell.
Damn, good shit.
Suck.
Hey, we got a new giveaway going.
Just hell.
A Ram 2500 diesel with the Cummins in there.
And you know what make a good truck, man?
It's all that coming side of it.
Go to officialheartstwins.com.
Anything you buy from the site gets you automatically winning the cruck.