All Episodes
Previous Next
Oct. 3, 2025 - Sargon of Akkad - Carl Benjamin
15:17
It's Time to Admit the Multicultural Project has Failed

On its own terms.

| Copy link to current segment

Time Text
It's been a tense couple of days here recently.
A lot's going on.
And actually, I think a lot of the narratives about what Britain is, ought to be in the current state of it are resolving themselves.
The contradictions within them are coming to a resolution.
And this is imposing a series of conclusions on public discourse that people just really aren't ready to deal with.
They're not actually prepared to genuinely engage with what we're being shown here.
So, you, of course, will remember the Labour conference where Keir Starmer said, if you even imply any of the immigrants who come here aren't English, we're coming for you with everything we've got.
And then a Muslim man decided to murder some Jews outside of a synagogue on their holy day.
Why would he do that?
If everyone in the country is just English, what would be the reason for that?
Why is it significant that that day is a day at all?
Other than a normal day ending in why, if they're all just English?
And the answer is, of course, they're not.
The Jewish people aren't just English, they're Jewish.
They have their own culture, customs, history, and calendar of holy days.
And they have ethnic enemies.
And we brought millions of them into the country.
And for some reason, we allowed them to just live cheap bar jowl in Manchester.
If you actually look at where the attack took place, you'll notice that one side of the road is Jewish, and the other side, mostly Jewish, and the other side is mostly Muslim.
And they're different.
They actually are kind of just enemies.
And things that are happening around the world make them enemies.
As if the rivalry and objection to one another doesn't go back longer than that anyway.
And there aren't deeply embedded issues between them in at least one of their holy books.
And yet we're supposed to say, well, this is all just part and parcel of being English in Keir Starmer's renewed Britain, restored Britain, whatever he calls it.
The Greater Britain against Little England.
And it's okay, well, I don't know whether you've noticed, but tensions couldn't really be higher.
And I don't really see these communities getting on.
And nobody has any answers for any of these issues.
So, I mean, Shabana Mahmoud, the English home secretary, said, as a Muslim, this is how I feel.
And she appealed to calm and for solidarity and compassion.
I saw like a bunch of the mainstream shitlibs like Emily Maitlis and on the news agents and the BBC implying that, in fact, straight up saying, oh, the right will use this to divide us.
The BBC was like, this could be neo-Nazis.
So we need solidarity and unity against who?
It looks like the division already exists.
It looks like the division is plain as day.
And because of what's happening in the Middle East between Israel and Palestine, that is taking place on our streets because we've recreated the issue in miniature in this country.
And so, well, the right will use this to divide us.
Well, I'm sorry, but I mean, I don't think the right needs to be involved in this in any way, shape, or form.
But again, calls for solidarity and unity against who?
And the answer is against us, isn't it?
The answer is that you were using these two communities as some sort of cudgel against the native English.
Weren't you, Emily?
Weren't you BBC?
Weren't you Kiestama?
Weren't you Shabana Mahmood and David Lamy?
You were using all of these against the native British, which is why you fear Gamanzilla so much.
Because even now you realize that Gamanzilla, if he chooses, has the power to just exercise his democratic will against all of you if he wanted to.
And that's the thing, the looming horror that you see in Nigel Farage, isn't it?
You see in Nigel Farage not the avatar, but the political instrument of Gamanzilla.
That he could say, you know, I've had enough of all of you.
And Nigel Farage says, yeah, you're right.
Millions of them need to go home.
This is what indefinitely to remain needs to be removed for.
So millions of them will go home.
But that creates a problem for those people who are against the native British population.
But I can't help but notice that these groups just won't play nice with one another.
All day, today, all day, I was watching LBC, Times Radio, you know, various other things that were crossing my timeline.
And it's nothing but Jews ringing up these places saying, well, okay, well, we don't feel safe in England anymore.
It feels like actually the Muslim community might start turning on us.
I hear that this is called an intifada that they have been angrily protesting about in the streets for a couple of years now.
And so we're not feeling very safe.
And we think we might leave.
Well, it must be nice to have somewhere to go.
Because the English haven't felt very safe in England for a long time.
And nobody cares.
And we don't have anywhere to go.
So at least you have that.
Wouldn't it be nice to have a state that actually prioritizes your concerns?
And the thing is, it's not like the British state and the intelligentsia of this country haven't done everything they can to try and keep the coalition against the native population intact.
They've done everything they can.
Say, no, no, our Jewish friends are welcome.
Our Jewish friends are welcome.
And personally, I haven't got a problem with them.
I haven't got a problem with any Jewish people, actually, now that I think about it.
This is such a small community of Jewish people and they don't ever blow anything up.
So I've never really thought about them.
They don't interfere with my life.
I don't feel persecuted by them.
I don't feel put in danger by them.
But there is a community in this country that does feel put in danger by them, right?
Because they see Jewish people as an extension of Israel.
And they also see the Palestinians as an extension of the Ummah.
And so they feel like the Jewish people in Israel killing Palestinians is not separate to Jewish people in this country.
Now, you can complain that that doesn't seem fair to you.
True, it's not fair.
You can complain that these things are actually completely different.
Not all Jewish people feel represented by Israel.
And maybe they don't.
But this is a question of perceptions.
This is not a question of what is actually true or necessarily even just.
It's what certain communities believe.
And if they believe that they are represented in the Palestinians, that they are constantly going on about Israel murdering to the tune of hundreds, if not thousands of them, then you can see why Jewish communities in this country don't feel safe.
Because they will look and go, well, You are right here, and I'm supposed to pretend, from their point of view, that this isn't political outside of the context of the Middle East.
But I mean, I don't know whether you've noticed, it's obviously incredibly political to these people outside of the context of the Middle East, whether they're here or not.
And I was listening to LBC earlier, and the Muslim caller called up and said, I don't feel safe here either.
Oh, great.
So no one feels safe in modern multicultural Britain.
In Kirstama's renewed Britain, this glorious multicultural, progressive, woke paradise, no one feels safe.
Incredible.
And on the very day of the attack, there was a very rowdy, riotous protest in Parliament Square.
Like 40 people were arrested.
There's only a thousand, two thousand of them.
It really wasn't very big, but it was meaningful.
Now, you'll remember for the Tommy Robinson Unite the Kingdom rally, there were only 26 arrests, and there were a million people there.
There were 40 arrests with a couple of thousand.
So you can see proportionally which group is more likely to cause trouble.
And this is something that has been clearly felt by Starma's government.
That whatever's happening at the moment, the tension in the Starma bunker must be dripping off the walls.
David Lamy went out to give a speech in solidarity and he got heckled by the Jewish attendees there because as far as they were concerned, he's an anti-Semite.
But then, of course, by the other side, he's also anti-Palestine.
So what can he do?
He can appeal to unity and say, look, guys, we need to stay together for whatever reason.
And so the government, Shaban Mahmood, Kierstama, and the rest have decided to beg the Muslim community for solidarity, for charity, consideration towards the Jewish community.
Yes, they have their Palestine marches all the time, but we've just had a Muslim jihadi called Jihad al-Shami, which means jihadi from Syria, holy warrior from Syria, murder a couple of Jews outside of a synagogue on the holy day.
So could we have some consideration from you?
And the answer is no.
The goodwill is not forthcoming from the Muslim community to the Jewish community because the Muslim community views the Jewish community as an undertaking a genocide.
Whether you agree with that or not, the goodwill is not forthcoming on their part.
In fact, the unspoken words, we got one of yours, are kind of hanging in the air at the moment.
And so they are going to continue protesting.
They are going to continue doing what they're doing.
And they're not going to find themselves being very sympathetic to your Jewish position on whether they feel safe or not.
The talking heads, the progressive thought leaders of both sides, are both saying the same thing, but you can tell the activists aren't feeling it.
These groups hate each other and they kind of want to have the fight.
They think they are having the fight back in the old country.
And now they're here.
They're continuing it on.
And they have been for some time.
And the problems are so deep.
The problems genuinely run so to you.
Have you ever looked into some of the things they teach in the mosques?
Have you ever looked in some of the things that they actually say about the people of this country, not just the Jewish community either?
I don't think there's the political will to fix this problem.
And so it will come down to one or the other.
Kiostama keeps basically pledging fealty to each community, depending on which day something has happened.
He'll say, oh no, I'm with the Muslim Qutir, I'm with the Jewish community, I'm with this, I'm with that.
It's like, okay, but you can't actually placate all of these contradictory communities.
When these communities have problems with one another, I'm afraid you kind of have to make a choice.
It seems like the end of the multicultural project is coming about.
They have significantly sidelined the native population.
We don't see native concerns represented in our politics.
We don't see native concerns represented in our media.
And the closest we get is them saying you're not allowed to care about immigration because that's racist.
That is the closest we get.
And we can get a million people out in the streets.
And they say, no, you're all racist.
It's a racist march.
If Nigel Farage comes out and says, look, I think we're going to end indefinitely to remain because actually nobody asked for it and it's not really appropriate.
That's a racist policy.
The government denounces him.
The media denounces him.
And so all we're told is when the nativist position is raised in mainstream politics, you're bad people, be quiet.
Okay, well, the space is available to you.
What are you going to do with it?
Desperately try and keep your coalition against the majority together in the face of two groups, probably more or less behind, who hate one another and who don't feel safe in one another's presence and for whom ideologues probably on either side, let's be fair, are quite happy to use hard power against one another when and where they can, whether it's here or elsewhere.
And so what is to be done?
What are the options that we actually have?
We have to make a choice.
It turns out that, in fact, the dream of the multicultural project that everyone could just leave side by side and everyone would just be completely happy and none of the problems that occur when these groups are smushed together will manifest themselves here.
Well, that's just not true.
And it looks like the government is just losing control at this point.
It doesn't have control of the nativists.
It doesn't have control of its own client groups.
And it doesn't have the proper sympathy that it would expect from those groups it's desperately trying to protect.
This is not going to go on forever, is it?
Or it's going to descend into something that's much more unpleasant.
And I would rather it if it didn't descend into something that's much more unpleasant.
I'd actually rather it if we could just be honest about what the problem is and the actual way that it has to be resolved.
We have to make a choice.
Which one of the Middle Eastern communities are we actually committed to?
It's this one or this one?
Because I don't think they're going to live harmoniously side by side.
▲
Export Selection